The Collège des Bernardins is a former 13th-century Cistercian college, located at 20 rue de Poissy in the 5th arrondissement of Paris, reopened in September 2008 as a place of dialogue between the Christian faith and culture. Debates, training, research, exhibitions and concerts echo one another within one of the finest examples of Cistercian architecture in Paris.[1][2]
Its history consists of two lives. The first begins around 1253, when the Cistercian monks sent to study theology at the University of Paris settle in the clos du Chardonnet, at the initiative of Étienne de Lexington, abbot of Clairvaux. The second begins in 2008, when the Diocese of Paris, having purchased the building in 2001 and carried out a complete renovation, reopens the site as a Parisian venue for dialogue between Christian wisdom and the cultural, intellectual and artistic currents of society.[3][4]
It is in the restored great nave that Benedict XVI delivers, on 12 September 2008, his address to the world of culture, one of the major texts of his pontificate on the monastic roots of European culture. This address gives the reopened venue its intellectual charter: seeking God, in the Latin formula quaerere Deum, gives rise to a culture of the word, of books and of reason.[5]
A Cistercian college at the heart of the University of Paris
Why monk-students in Paris?
In the 13th century, Paris is the intellectual capital of Christian Europe. Its university draws students from across the continent to study theology, and the new religious orders establish colleges there to train their young members. The Dominicans and Franciscans settle there first. The Cistercians, a monastic order founded at Cîteaux and illustrious through Saint Bernard of Clairvaux, decide in turn to give their student monks a permanent house in Paris.[6]
The order's general chapter approves the project, and Pope Innocent IV strongly encourages the Cistercians, in a bull of 1245, to come and study theology in Paris in order to pass on their teaching to their brethren afterwards. The Parisian college is granted preeminence over the order's other colleges: it is there that the Cistercian intellectual elite is to be formed.[7]
Étienne de Lexington buys marshy land
The organizer of the foundation is Étienne de Lexington, abbot of Clairvaux, from a powerful English family. The monks' first dwelling quickly becomes too small. Étienne then buys, in the clos du Chardonnet, plots of land reputed unhealthy because regularly flooded by the Bièvre, the river that then flows through the south of Paris before joining the Seine.[8]
The main body of the college is completed around 1253. It comprises several buildings on four levels, with classrooms, refectories and dormitories. To prevent the building from sinking into this marshy soil, the Cistercians rest the foundations on oak piles. The stability problem thus posed in the 13th century would determine, seven and a half centuries later, one of the most delicate underpinning projects of the renovation of the 2000s.[9][10]
Alphonse of Poitiers, brother of King Louis IX, becomes the protector of the college and provides an endowment to support twenty to thirty religious students. In 1320, the abbot and monks of Clairvaux cede the institution to the whole Cistercian order.[11]
Jacques Fournier, the student who became Pope Benedict XII
The vitality of the college can be measured by its alumni. Between the 13th and 15th centuries, several thousand young Cistercian monks study there, coming from northern France, Flanders, Germany, Central Europe and the Iberian Peninsula. The registers of the Paris faculty of theology bear witness to this European reach.[12]
The most illustrious of them is Jacques Fournier, received as a doctor of theology in 1314, who became pope in Avignon from 1334 to 1342 under the name of Benedict XII. A former Cistercian monk himself, from 1338 he encourages the construction of a sacristy and a church for the college. The church will remain unfinished, but the building project says much about the bond between the Parisian college and the summit of the Church of its time.[13]
- 1245Innocent IV's encouragement
Pope Innocent IV encourages the Cistercians to study theology in Paris. The order's general chapter grants the Parisian college preeminence over its other colleges.
- Around 1253The main building is completed
Étienne de Lexington, abbot of Clairvaux, has the college built in the clos du Chardonnet, on oak piles driven into the marshy soil of the Bièvre.
- 1338Benedict XII's building project
Pope Benedict XII, a former student of the college who became a doctor of theology in 1314, encourages the construction of a sacristy and a church, which will remain unfinished.
- 1790Revolutionary confiscation
The college is confiscated as national property and the last monks are driven out. It becomes a prison, then serves secular purposes for two centuries.
- 2001The purchase by the Diocese of Paris
The Diocese of Paris purchases the building, with the unanimous approval of the Conseil de Paris, to make it a Catholic spiritual and cultural centre.
- 2008Reopening and Benedict XVI's address
After four years of works, the college reopens in September 2008. On 12 September, Benedict XVI delivers his address to the world of culture there.
How was study conducted at the Bernardins?
Theology taught from morning to evening
In the medieval college, theology was taught every day, from six in the morning to nine in the evening, and students had to argue in Latin. The student monk's day divided his time between the liturgy of the hours, the reading of Scripture and the Fathers, faculty lectures, and the formal disputations that formed the backbone of Parisian scholasticism.[14]
This intensity reveals the project: the aim was not merely to house monks in Paris, but to train theologians capable of teaching in turn in their abbeys. The college predates the Sorbonne, founded in 1257 by Robert de Sorbon, and it belongs to the same movement that made Paris the European capital of theology.[15]
The headquarters of the Strict Observance
In the seventeenth century, the college took on a new importance: it became the headquarters of the Strict Observance, the Cistercian reform movement encouraged by Cardinal de La Rochefoucauld and confirmed by Richelieu, who became abbot of Cîteaux in 1635. The reform carried forward notably by Armand de Rancé, abbot of La Trappe, found its Parisian address at the Bernardins.[16]
The place was therefore not merely a student dormitory: for several centuries, it was one of the points where the future of the Cistercian order in France was decided.
From the confiscation of 1790 to the barracks: two centuries of secular uses
The Bernardins prison and the September massacres of 1792
In 1790, the college was confiscated by the revolutionaries and became national property, while the few remaining monks were driven out. For a time it became the Bernardins prison and received, in the buildings surrounding the cloister, the galley slaves transferred from the neighbouring Château de la Tournelle, which was slated for demolition.[17]
Most of these prisoners, seventy out of seventy-three, were killed during the September massacres, on 2, 3 and 4 September 1792. The college of study thus became one of the Parisian sites of revolutionary violence, a few streets from the Force and Carmes prisons where priests and religious perished on those same dates.[18]
A demolished church, a refectory turned into a barracks
The site was acquired by the city of Paris. It then covered an area of two hectares extending as far as the Seine. The church, abandoned, became a stone quarry. It was demolished shortly after its sale on 22 June 1797, and its last vestiges disappeared during the cutting of the boulevard Saint-Germain in 1886.[19]
The monks' building survived, but at the price of uses that transformed it: the installation of a fire station on the rue de Poissy, a national police boarding school housing many auxiliary police officers as part of national service. During the Bloody Week of May 1871, the Bernardins' refectory, turned into a barracks, served as a refuge for many Parisians, women and children lying higgledy-piggledy in the monks' hall, according to the account of the Communard Jean Allemane.[20]
"It is exactly ten in the evening when we enter the refectory of the Bernardin monks, transformed into a barracks. Hundreds of women and children are there, lying higgledy-piggledy. Nothing is heard but weeping and heart-rending cries." Account by Jean Allemane on the night spent at the Bernardins during the Bloody Week of May 1871.[21]
The Lustiger project: buying back and reopening a place for culture
April 2001, the diocese of Paris buys back the college
In April 2001, the Collège des Bernardins was bought back by the diocese of Paris. The diocese's acquisition of the Bernardins was approved unanimously by the Conseil de Paris. The building, deemed to be of national interest, was threatening to collapse if no large-scale operation was undertaken, and its opening to the public required major alterations that fell outside the ordinary remit of the Historic Monuments service.[22]
The Archbishop of Paris, Jean-Marie Lustiger, promoted the creation of a Catholic spiritual and cultural centre. An agreement was signed between the City, the State, the Île-de-France region, and the Diocesan Association of Paris, with the assistance of the Ministry of Culture's departments, to finance the work on the 4,500 square metres of the future École cathédrale: classrooms, an auditorium under the roof for concerts, symposia, lectures, and exhibitions.[23]
The project had a precise intention, which Benedict XVI would salute in 2008 by quoting Cardinal Lustiger: to make the restored place a centre for dialogue between Christian wisdom and the cultural, intellectual, and artistic currents of society. It is neither a museum of the Cistercian past nor a mere diocesan facility, but a Parisian address where the Christian faith accepts public conversation with contemporary culture.[24]
A renovation of over 50 million euros
The renovation began in 2004 and was completed in August 2008. It was carried out by Hervé Baptiste, chief architect of historic monuments, for the old part, and by Jean-Michel Wilmotte for the contemporary spaces. The entire project cost a little over 50 million euros.[25]
The worksite first had to save the building. Successive occupants had weakened the upper floors by altering the openings over the course of refittings. The renovation installs 322 steel micropiles, 15 to 25 metres deep, beneath all the outer walls and beneath each of the pillars. These micropiles are fitted with metal collars, and jacks identical to those on the deck of the Millau Viaduct stabilise the vaults.[26]
The roof was rebuilt in its medieval dimensions, with a honeycomb steel frame covered with 110,000 handcrafted flat tiles, specially made for the college in six different shades. The cellar, said to be the largest in Paris with its three naves, was cleared out and given a polished concrete floor evoking the original beaten earth. The earthworks uncovered an old diversion canal of the Bièvre and a tombstone dated 1306, that of a Cistercian monk named Günther, from Thuringia: the presence of this German monk in the college grounds attests, from the very beginning, to the house's European reach. The whole building is heated and cooled by geothermal energy.[27]
On 12 September 2008, Benedict XVI gives the place its charter
A speech to the world of culture, in the monks' nave
The renovated building is inaugurated in early September 2008 by the Archbishop of Paris, André Vingt-Trois. On Friday 12 September 2008, on the first day of his apostolic journey to France for the 150th anniversary of the apparitions of Lourdes, Pope Benedict XVI delivers a speech at the Bernardins before 700 figures from the world of culture.[28]
The pope thanks Cardinal Vingt-Trois and pays tribute to the place itself: a place built by the sons of Saint Bernard of Clairvaux, which Cardinal Jean-Marie Lustiger envisioned as a centre for dialogue between Christian wisdom and the cultural, intellectual and artistic currents of society. The choice of setting is not decorative: Benedict XVI speaks of the monastic birth of European culture in a building erected by student monks.[29]
"We find ourselves in a historic place, a place built by the sons of Saint Bernard of Clairvaux, which your great predecessor, the late Cardinal Jean-Marie Lustiger, envisioned as a centre for dialogue between Christian Wisdom and the cultural, intellectual and artistic currents of your society." Opening of the address by Benedict XVI at the Collège des Bernardins, 12 September 2008.[30]
Quaerere Deum: seeking God gives rise to a culture
The heart of the speech lies in one Latin formula: quaerere Deum, to seek God. In the midst of the confusion of their time, says Benedict XVI, the monks desired the one thing most important: to find what has value and always endures, to find Life itself. Behind the provisional, they sought the definitive.[31]
"In the midst of the confusion of those times, when nothing seemed to endure, the monks desired the one thing most important: to devote themselves to finding what has value and always endures, to find Life itself. They were searching for God." Benedict XVI, address to the world of culture, Collège des Bernardins, 12 September 2008.[32]
From this search, according to the pope, there is born a culture of the word. God has placed his Word in the books of Holy Scripture: to understand it, one must learn to penetrate the secret of the language, in its structure and in its uses. The library and the school thus become integral parts of the monastery, and the secular sciences themselves find their place, because they point the way towards the language. Benedict XVI cites in this regard Dom Jean Leclercq and his book The Love of Letters and the Desire for God: in Western monasticism, eschatology and grammar are inseparable.[33]
"What founded the culture of Europe — the search for God and the readiness to listen to him — remains today the foundation of every true culture." Conclusion of the address by Benedict XVI to the world of culture, Collège des Bernardins, 12 September 2008.[34]
The conclusion of the speech gives the reopened Collège its lasting programme: the search for God and the readiness to listen to him remain the foundation of every true culture. The place that trained thousands of monk-theologians becomes again, seven centuries later, a place where this search continues publicly, before interlocutors who do not necessarily share the faith of the Church.[35]
What can be found at the Bernardins today?
Debates, training, research and the arts in one place
The Collège's official presentation describes it as a place of dialogue open to the world, a jewel of Cistercian architecture in the heart of Paris, open to all. Training courses, debates, research seminars and artistic performances answer one another there, promoting an authentic cultural and intellectual dialogue between society and Christian wisdom.[36]
The table below gives a readable map of the current activities, as the Collège presents them to the public.
| Current area | What happens there | For whom |
|---|---|---|
| Lectures and debates | Round tables, encounters and debates on questions of society, culture and faith | General public, registration required depending on the event |
| Training | In-person and online courses in theology, philosophy, history, art and the study of Scripture, including the online Campus des Bernardins | Students, auditors, catechists and any enquirer |
| Research centre | Seminars bringing together scientists, academics and theologians on the question of man and his future | Researchers and academics affiliated with the seminars |
| Exhibitions and concerts | Artistic programming in the restored spaces, temporary exhibitions and concerts | General public |
| Visits and venue hire | Tours of the restored medieval building and hire of some twenty flexible spaces for events | Visitors, companies and institutions |
Since 2009, the Collège has also housed the seat of the Académie catholique de France, a body of Catholic academics and intellectuals founded to foster dialogue between faith and research. This presence prolongs, in a contemporary form, the studious vocation of the place.[37]
The École cathédrale and the formation of the laity
The training offered at the Bernardins belongs to the tradition of the École cathédrale de Paris, the diocese's formation body. The courses cover Sacred Scripture, theology, philosophy, Church history and the arts, in person in the restored rooms and online through the Campus des Bernardins, which extends the courses beyond Paris.[38]
For the Ignispedia reader, this is the concrete point that links this place to many neighbouring articles: when a note cites a course at the Bernardins, a seminar from its research centre or a lecture from its programme, it points to this address on the rue de Poissy, where French-language theological training has a public, open and visible home.
What the Collège des Bernardins Is Not
Neither a monastery, nor a museum
No Cistercian monk lives today on rue de Poissy. The reopened Collège is not a refounded abbey, and it should not be confused with the living Cistercian abbeys of France. It is a cultural and intellectual institution of the Diocese of Paris, housed in a restored medieval monastic building.[39]
Nor is it a museum: it does not merely preserve stones. The lecture rooms, the auditorium, the cellar and the great nave host courses, debates, seminars and concerts every week. The 2008 restoration was precisely about returning the medieval building to demanding contemporary use, public reception included, rather than freezing it in time.[40]
Neither the Institut catholique, nor Saint-Serge
The Collège des Bernardins does not confer canonical university degrees in theology: that function belongs, in Paris, to institutions such as the Institut catholique de Paris and its faculty of theology. The Bernardins train, debate and seek, but in the register of a cultural college open to all, not in that of a pontifical faculty.[41]
Distinguishing it from the Saint-Serge Orthodox Theological Institute, founded in Paris in 1925 and located on rue de Crimée, holds for the same reason of accuracy: Saint-Serge is an autonomous school of Orthodox theology. The Bernardins belong to the Catholic Diocese of Paris. The two addresses belong to the same theological Paris, without being one and the same.
To go further
The Collège's official website, collegedesbernardins.fr, provides the calendar of debates, the catalogue of programmes, the presentation of the research centre and visitor information. The full text of Benedict XVI's address of 12 September 2008 is available on the Holy See's website, vatican.va. In Ignispedia, read also the Institut catholique de Paris for the other great theological address in Paris, and the articles on Saint Bernard of Clairvaux and Benedict XVI for the two figures that frame the history of the place.
Notes and References
Collège des Bernardins, official presentation, collegedesbernardins.fr: a place of dialogue open to the world, a gem of Cistercian architecture in the heart of Paris, training programmes, debates, research seminars and artistic performances in the service of a dialogue between society and Christian wisdom. Public sections: lectures and debates, exhibitions and concerts, in-person and online training, research centre, venue hire and visits.
1 36 38 39 41Inauguration of the renovated Collège des Bernardins in early September 2008 by the Archbishop of Paris André Vingt-Trois, followed by Benedict XVI's address on Friday 12 September 2008 before 700 figures from the cultural world, on the first day of his apostolic journey to France from 12 to 15 September 2008 for the 150th anniversary of the apparitions of Lourdes.
2 28Foundation of the Collège des Bernardins: decision by the Abbot of Clairvaux with the agreement of the Cistercian General Chapter, installation at the clos du Chardonnet, a first dwelling that became too small, purchase by Étienne de Lexington of land flooded by the Bièvre, main building completed around 1253 on four levels with lecture rooms, refectories and dormitories, foundations on oak piles.
3 6 8 9Purchase of the Collège des Bernardins by the Diocese of Paris in April 2001, the acquisition unanimously approved by the Conseil de Paris, the building of national importance threatening to collapse without a major undertaking.
4 22Benedict XVI, address to the world of culture, Collège des Bernardins, Paris, Friday 12 September 2008, full text on vatican.va: thanks to Cardinal Vingt-Trois, greeting to the place built by the sons of Saint Bernard of Clairvaux and desired by Cardinal Jean-Marie Lustiger as a centre of dialogue between Christian wisdom and the cultural, intellectual and artistic currents of society.
5 24 29 30Bull of Pope Innocent IV of 1245 strongly encouraging the Cistercians to pursue their theological studies in Paris in order to pass on their teaching to their brethren. The General Chapter confirms the pre-eminence of the Collège des Bernardins over all the other colleges of the order.
7Consolidation of the Collège des Bernardins during the renovation: 322 steel micropiles 15 to 25 metres deep beneath all the exterior walls and beneath each of the pillars, metal casing of the micropiles and stabilisation of the vaults using jacks identical to those of the deck of the Millau viaduct.
10 26Alphonse of Poitiers, brother of Louis IX, protector of the Collège des Bernardins, gives an endowment to support twenty to thirty religious students. In 1320, the abbot and monks of Clairvaux cede the institution to the Cistercian order.
11Studies at the Collège des Bernardins: several thousand young Cistercian monks trained between the thirteenth and fifteenth centuries, coming from northern France, Flanders, Germany, Central Europe and the Iberian peninsula, according to the registers of the Paris faculty of theology. The college precedes by a few years the Sorbonne college founded in 1257 by Robert de Sorbon.
12 15Jacques Fournier, a former student of the Collège des Bernardins who received his doctorate in theology in 1314, pope in Avignon from 1334 to 1342 under the name Benedict XII, encourages from 1338 the construction of a sacristy and a church for the college, which remained unfinished.
13Daily teaching of theology at the Collège des Bernardins, from six in the morning to nine in the evening, with argumentation in Latin by the students.
14The Collège des Bernardins becomes in the seventeenth century the headquarters of the Cistercian Strict Observance, a reform encouraged by Cardinal de La Rochefoucauld and confirmed by Richelieu, who became abbot of Cîteaux in 1635, in the wake of Armand Jean Le Bouthillier de Rancé.
16Confiscation of the Collège des Bernardins in 1790 as national property, expulsion of the last monks, transformation into the Bernardins prison receiving the galley slaves transferred from the nearby château de la Tournelle, condemned to demolition.
17September massacres of 2, 3 and 4 September 1792: most of the prisoners of the Bernardins, seventy out of seventy-three, are killed.
18Acquisition of the site by the city of Paris, two hectares extending to the Seine, abandoned church turned into a stone quarry, demolished shortly after its sale on 22 June 1797, last vestiges destroyed during the cutting of the boulevard Saint-Germain in 1886.
19Jean Allemane, Memoirs of a Communard: night of the Bloody Week of May 1871 spent in the refectory of the Bernardin monks turned into a fire station on rue de Poissy, serving as a refuge for hundreds of Parisian women and children.
20 21Agreement signed between the City of Paris, the State, the Île-de-France region and the Diocesan Association of Paris, with the support of the Ministry of Culture, to fund the work on the 4,500 square metres of the future École cathédrale: classrooms, auditorium under the roof, concerts, colloquia, lectures and exhibitions.
23Renovation of the Collège des Bernardins from 2004 to August 2008, carried out by Hervé Baptiste, chief architect of historic monuments, for the old part, and Jean-Michel Wilmotte for the contemporary spaces. Total cost a little over 50 million euros.
25 40Renovation of the Collège des Bernardins: restoration of the roof to its medieval dimensions with a honeycomb metal framework and 110,000 hand-made flat tiles in six shades, three-aisled cellar cleared with a polished concrete floor, discovery of a diversion channel of the Bièvre and of a 1306 tombstone of a Cistercian monk named Günther from Thuringia, heating and cooling by geothermal energy.
27Benedict XVI, address to the world of culture, Collège des Bernardins, 12 September 2008, full text on vatican.va: the monks' quaerere Deum, the search for the definitive behind the provisional, the culture of the word born from the reading of Holy Scripture, the library and the school as integral parts of the monastery, quotation from Dom Jean Leclercq, The Love of Letters and the Desire for God, and conclusion on the search for God as the foundation of all true culture.
31 32 33 34 35The Collège des Bernardins has housed the headquarters of the Académie catholique de France since 2009.
37