Neo-Modernism

Neo-modernism is the return, after 1946, of the modernist errors condemned by Saint Pius X: keeping the words of the faith while changing their meaning. Theses, responses of the popes, and the rule of homogeneous development.

Ignispedia

Neo-modernism refers to the return, from the 1940s and especially after the Second Vatican Council, of the principles that Saint Pius X had condemned in 1907 under the name of modernism: the idea that dogmas would be merely provisional expressions of religious experience, to be rewritten according to the philosophy of each age[1]. Its distinctive mark is no longer to reject the formulas of the faith openly, but to keep the words while changing their meaning: one continues to say "resurrection", "real presence" or "original sin", while giving them a content different from that which the Church "has understood and still understands"[2].

The term comes from the critics of the phenomenon rather than from official texts, but the thing itself is described with precision by the magisterium. Pius XII warns as early as 1946 against a "new theology" which, evolving with all things, would be "always on the move, never arriving"; then the encyclical Humani generis (12 August 1950) sets out its errors; after the Council, the letter of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith of 24 July 1966, the Credo of Paul VI (30 June 1968) and the declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae (1973) respond to the same theses[3]. In 1966, the philosopher Jacques Maritain speaks of a "neo-modernist fever" beside which the modernism of the time of Pius X was "but a modest hay fever"[4].

The Church does not oppose to this error immobility, but homogeneous development: doctrine grows "in the same sense and in the same thought", according to the rule of Saint Vincent of Lérins taken up by Vatican I and then by John XXIII at the opening of the Council[5]. Neo-modernism must therefore not be confused either with the return to the patristic sources that the Church has welcomed, or with the Second Vatican Council itself, which Benedict XVI asked to be read according to a "hermeneutic of reform", in continuity, and not according to a "hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture"[6].

This article treats neo-modernism as a doctrinal error: its origins, its theses, the responses of the magisterium and the objections it raises. The crisis of 1907 is covered by the articles Modernism and The Modernist Crisis (1893-1914); relativism as a system, by the article Doctrinal Relativism; the history of the Council, by the article The Second Vatican Council (1962-1965): the reader is referred to them rather than repeating the material[7].

What is neo-modernism?

The term and the thing

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The prefix says the essential: neo-modernism is not an unprecedented heresy, but the return of a system already judged. In 1907, the encyclical Pascendi had described modernism as a religion built on two principles — agnosticism, which confines reason "within the circle of phenomena", and "vital immanence", which makes faith arise from an interior need — from which followed one consequence: dogma not only can, but must "evolve and change"[8]. Condemned, then held in check by the oath imposed on the clergy in 1910, the system goes dormant; it reappears a generation later in new garments, those of existentialism and historicism named by Humani generis[9].

The term itself comes from the critics of the phenomenon, not from its supporters, exactly as modernism was the name given by the judge of 1907[10]. Maritain uses it in 1966 to designate a tendency rather than a school, which in his view expresses itself first among the most advanced Protestant thinkers, but also acts among Catholic thinkers who are no less so; he notes in passing that the word modernism has aged, but that he knows of no better one[11]. The magisterium, for its part, describes the thing without giving it this name: in 1998, John Paul II writes that historicism "tends to present itself" in theology "in the form of 'modernism'", a form which, "by confusing what is current with what is true", cannot satisfy the demands of theology[12].

"The problems of the past return, but in new forms. It is no longer only questions that concern particular persons or groups, but convictions spread throughout the surrounding environment, to the point of becoming in some way a common mentality." — Saint John Paul II, encyclical Fides et ratio, 14 September 1998, § 55[13]

The error in one phrase: keep the words, change the meaning

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Pascendi had already observed this: for the modernist, dogmatic formulas are merely "inadequate signs of its object, commonly called symbols", which the believer employs "so far as they are useful to him", subject to "the social reverence due to them"[14]. Neo-modernism pushes this procedure to the end: instead of rejecting the old formula, it keeps it and rereads it. The difference is decisive for the ordinary reader, who hears the familiar words of the Creed and does not suspect that their content has changed. The First Vatican Council had already provided for the case in 1870: it anathematizes anyone who maintains that to the dogmas proposed by the Church it would be possible, "by reason of the progress of science", to give "a meaning different from that which the Church has understood and still understands"[15]. The rule concerns the meaning, not the vocabulary: one may change words in order to say the same thing better, but never keep the words in order to say something else.

This is exactly the criterion that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith will apply when it declares, on 15 December 1979, that several essential points of the faith — the consubstantiality of Christ with the Father, the doctrine on the Blessed Virgin Mary — were being given in the writings of the Swiss theologian Hans Küng (1928-2021) "a meaning different from that which the Church has understood and understands"[16]. An image helps to grasp the procedure: a map on which all the city names have been kept while the cities themselves have been moved. Nothing appears to have changed, and yet no path leads any longer where it once led.

"Wherefore, the sense of the sacred dogmas which must be preserved perpetually is that which our Holy Mother the Church has declared once for all, and it is never lawful to depart from it under the pretext or on the basis of a deeper understanding." — First Vatican Council, constitution Dei Filius, 24 April 1870, chapter 4 (DH 3020)[17]

What neo-modernism is not

Because the term is often used as a weapon in post-conciliar quarrels, five confusions must be set aside from the outset[18] :

  • Returning to the sources is not neo-modernism. The 1950 encyclical itself recalls that theologians "must always go back to the sources of divine revelation" and that the sacred sciences "always find a new youth in the study of the sacred sources"[19]. The patristic renewal of Henri de Lubac or Jean Daniélou was welcomed by the Church, which made them cardinals.
  • The development of dogma is not an evolution of dogma. The definitions of the Immaculate Conception (1854) or the Assumption (1950) make explicit what the Church already believed; neo-modernism, by contrast, changes what she believed[20].
  • Adapting the language is not changing the doctrine. In 1946, Pius XII asked the Jesuits to adapt their manner of speaking wisely "to the genius and inclinations of their century", right before recalling that "what is immutable", no one may shake[21].
  • Going through a crisis of faith is not professing an error. The instruction Donum veritatis (1990) carefully distinguishes the theologian's "situation of personal difficulty" from "the public attitude of opposition to the magisterium", called "dissent"[22].
  • The Second Vatican Council is not neo-modernism. The 1966 Roman letter that lists the errors of the post-conciliar period begins by praising the council's "most wise documents", and targets "abuses in the interpretation of its doctrine"[23]. We will return to this below.

Where does neo-modernism come from?

A system condemned, then put to sleep (1910–1940)

Saint Pius X in 1907. Czaich Á. Gilbert and Fráter Aladár, public domain.

The anti-Modernist oath prescribed by Saint Pius X on 1 September 1910 gives the measure of what was at stake at the time. Every priest, every seminary professor had to swear that he received "the doctrine of the faith handed down from the apostles up to us, always in the same sense and the same interpretation", and to reject "the heretical invention of the evolution of dogmas, passing from one meaning to another, different from that which the Church first professed"[24]. The same text condemned the idea that a learned Christian might don "a double personality, that of the believer and that of the historian", as if the historian could hold for true what the believer holds for false[25].

Benedict XV renewed the condemnation in his very first encyclical, Ad beatissimi Apostolorum (1 November 1914). He wanted not only that Catholics "detest the errors of the Modernists", but "that they avoid their tendencies and their spirit": the spirit of the one who "rejects with disgust whatever smells of antiquity" and "greedily and everywhere seeks novelty, in the manner of speaking of divine things, in the celebration of sacred worship, in Catholic institutions and even in the exercise of private piety"[26]. In the same encyclical, he asked Catholics to renounce the recent appellations that served "to distinguish Catholics from Catholics": "There is no need of qualifiers to signify the profession of Catholicism; it is enough for each one to say: Christianus mihi nomen, catholicus cognomen" — Christian is my name, Catholic my surname[27]. Firmness on doctrine and refusal of partisan labels: both demands are laid down together, in the same text.

Between the two wars, the Modernist networks dispersed: the journals died out, the leaders submitted or left the Church, like Alfred Loisy, excommunicated in 1908[28]. But the questions remained — the history of dogmas, biblical criticism, the place of experience in faith — and new philosophies came to reformulate them. Humani generis would name three of these currents in 1950, come "from outside the fold of Christ": evolutionism applied to "the origin of all things", existentialism, which "is concerned only with the existence of each one" while neglecting essences, and "a false historicism" which "overthrows the foundations of all truth and of all absolute law"[29].

1946: a theology "always on the move, never arriving"

Pius XII around 1951; cropped photograph, levels adjusted on Commons. Michael Pitcairn; cropping and levels: Donrdg54 — Public domain, PD-Italy per Commons. Source Wikimedia Commons.

On 17 September 1946, receiving the delegates of the Society of Jesus gathered to elect their superior general, the pope asked them to follow the doctrine of Saint Thomas, to remain attached to the magisterium, but also to adapt their language to their times; then he added a sentence that would make its mark[30]:

"But what is immutable, let no one trouble or shake it. Much has been said, without sufficiently thorough examination, about the 'new theology' which, evolving with all things always in motion, would always be on the move without ever arriving. If such an opinion were to be embraced, what would become of the Catholic dogmas, which must never change; what would become of the unity and stability of the faith?" — Pius XII, address to the electors of the XXIXth General Congregation of the Society of Jesus, 17 September 1946[31]

The pope names no one and speaks in the conditional; he is not condemning an author, he is drawing a line. In the same address, he summarized the attitude he expects from those who grapple with new questions: to distinguish the certain from the conjectural, to be wary of what sounds "entirely new" in theology, and to hold out a friendly hand to those who have gone astray "without conceding anything to the errors of their opinions"[32]. Five days later, before the general chapter of the Dominicans, he spelled out the issue: it concerns, he said, "the very foundations of perennial philosophy and theology", and whether the intellect can penetrate the truths revealed by God "by means of certain notions"[33].

That same year, the Dominican Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange gave this concern its sharpest expression. In an article in the Angelicum entitled "Where Is the New Theology Leading?", he concluded[34]:

"Where is the new theology leading? It is leading back to Modernism." — Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, "Where Is the New Theology Leading?", Angelicum 23 (1946), p. 143[35]

In his view, the decisive point is the very definition of truth: in place of the traditional definition — the conformity of judgment with extramental reality and its immutable laws — the philosophy of action substitutes a conformity of judgment "with the demands of action or of human life, which is always evolving"[36]. The tone is severe, and history has partly contradicted him as regards the persons: the theologians targeted were never condemned for heresy (see below). But as for the peril itself, Humani generis would vindicate the diagnosis four years later.

1950: the diagnosis of "false opinions"

On 12 August 1950, the encyclical Humani generis, "on certain false opinions threatening to undermine the foundations of Catholic doctrine", gave the fullest description of the phenomenon. The pope is not targeting unbelievers, but Catholics who, "for fear of being thought ignorant" of the progress of the age, give way to novelties and risk "gradually drifting away from divinely revealed truth"[37]. He also identifies a danger "all the more grave as it is the more hidden beneath the cloak of virtue": an "irenism" which, in order to draw separated Christians closer, would go so far as to envisage "a reconciliation of contraries, even in dogmas"[38].

The heart of the diagnosis concerns the very status of dogmas. Some, the pope writes, want to "weaken the meaning of dogmas as much as possible" and express them by means of "immanentism, idealism, existentialism, or any other system to come," on the grounds that the mysteries of the faith could only be signified by "approximate and ever-changing notions"[39]. The consequence is named without detour:

"So much effort not only leads to what is called dogmatic "relativism," but already in fact involves it. [...] To neglect, reject, or deprive of their value so many precious goods [...] and to substitute for them conjectural notions and the shifting and vague expressions of a new philosophy destined to an ephemeral existence, like the flower of the field, is not merely to sin by grave imprudence, but to make of dogma itself something like a reed shaken by the wind." — Pius XII, encyclical Humani generis, 12 August 1950, § 16-17[40]

The encyclical then enumerates the "poisoned fruits" of these novelties in almost every part of theology: the gratuity of the supernatural order corrupted, the notion of original sin "perverted," transubstantiation that one would wish to correct in order to reduce the real presence "to a certain symbolism," the inerrancy of Scripture restricted to religious questions alone[41]. It contains, finally, a sentence that the post-conciliar period will verify: what some teach "in a veiled manner, with precautions and distinctions," others will propose "tomorrow with greater boldness, in broad daylight and without any restraint"[42].

Ressourcement or neo-modernism: the distinction history confirmed

Should all the theologians suspected around 1950 be classed under the name of neo-modernism? History answers no. Henri de Lubac was removed from his teaching duties by his superiors as early as June 1950, Yves Congar was placed under surveillance from 1947 to 1956; but Humani generis names no one, and neither of them, nor their friend Jean Daniélou, would ever be condemned for heresy. All three would become experts at the council, then cardinals: Daniélou in 1969, de Lubac in 1983, Congar in 1994[43]. Their program was a ressourcement: rereading Scripture, the Fathers, and the liturgy to nourish theology, not to dissolve it.

The rest of their lives confirms this. Henri de Lubac founded the international journal Communio in 1972 with Hans Urs von Balthasar and Joseph Ratzinger, to promote "the renewal of theology in continuity with the living Christian tradition"[44]. Yves Congar had published as early as 1950 True and False Reform in the Church, whose entire purpose is to distinguish the reform that remains within communion from the one that breaks it[45]. The judgment of 1950 targeted tendencies, and the Church subsequently learned to distinguish persons from tendencies: the danger the encyclical described was real, but not all those who had been suspected embodied it. The articles devoted to Henri de Lubac and Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange trace the two sides of this quarrel.

The theses of neo-modernism, one by one

Neo-modernism has neither founder nor manifesto: it is a cluster of converging theses, which Roman documents noted one by one. The two most complete lists are that of Humani generis in 1950 and that of the letter addressed on 24 July 1966 by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to the presidents of the episcopal conferences, which numbers ten[46]. The seven theses that follow take up the essentials; each is first set out in its strongest form, as its proponents defend it, then confronted with the teaching of the Church.

Dogma, provisional formula of an experience

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The thesis. Every human word is situated within a culture. The councils expressed the faith with the notions of Greek philosophy — substance, nature, person — which the man of today no longer understands; divine truth would therefore surpass all formulas, which would give only successive approximations, to be replaced when culture changes. The thesis is seductive in its apparent modesty before mystery and in its missionary concern[47].

The Church's response. The Church accepts part of the observation: the declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae (1973) acknowledges that the meaning of statements of faith "depends in part on the semantic scope of the language used," and that a dogmatic truth can be "first expressed in an incomplete manner — not false, however" — before being signified "more fully"[48]. But she refuses the conclusion, and names it:

"As for the meaning of dogmatic formulas, it remains always true and identical in the Church, even when it is further explained and more fully understood. The faithful must therefore be very careful to guard against the opinion [...] according to which dogmatic formulas [...] would signify nothing but changing approximations [...]. Those who would adopt this opinion would not escape dogmatic relativism, and they would corrupt the concept of the Church's infallibility." — Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae, 24 June 1973, § 5[49]

Paul VI had given the underlying reason as early as 1965: the formulas by which the Church enunciates dogmas "express concepts which are not bound to a certain form of culture, nor to a particular phase of scientific progress, nor to this or that theological school"; they take up "what the human mind borrows from reality through universal and necessary experience." They can be explained more clearly, "but it will always be in the same sense," so that "the immutable truth of the faith will remain intact while the understanding of the faith progresses"[50]. The word substance, for example, presupposes no Greek physics: it designates what a thing is, as distinct from what it appears to be.

History, judge of the faith

Second edition of L'Évangile et l'Église by Alfred Loisy (1903). Bibliothèque nationale de France, public domain.

The thesis. Dogmas are products of their time; the historian must study them like any other document, suspending his faith, and what was true for the Fathers or for Trent may no longer be true for us. The thesis presents itself as a demand of scientific honesty[51].

The Church's response. As early as 1910, the anti-modernist oath rejected the idea that the learned Christian puts on "a double personality, that of the believer and that of the historian," as if it were permitted to the historian "to hold what contradicts the faith of the believer"[52]. John Paul II described the same error under its philosophical name: for historicism, "what was true in one age may no longer be so in another," and thus one denies "at least implicitly the perennial validity of the true"; yet, he adds, even if a formulation is bound to an age, "the truth or error" it expresses can always be recognized as such[53]. Paul VI had inscribed the rule of interpretation at the very threshold of his Credo:

"It is of the utmost importance to recall that beyond what is seen and what we perceive through the sciences, the intelligence God has given us can attain what is, and not merely the subjective meaning of so-called structures, or of the evolution of human consciousness. It must also be recalled that it belongs to interpretation — to hermeneutics — to seek to understand and to elicit, while respecting the word pronounced, the meaning a text bears, and not to invent some new meaning according to arbitrary conjectures." — Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, 30 June 1968, § 5[54]

A Scripture without inerrancy, a Christ of faith without the Jesus of history

The thesis. The Bible would be without error only in what concerns salvation; the Gospels would be proclamations of faith more than testimonies, and their narratives — virginal conception, miracles, empty tomb — figurative ways of expressing an experience. The resurrection would thus become the disciples' faith in the living Jesus, and not the return of a body to life. It is, transposed into Catholic theology, the program of “demythologization” proposed in 1941 by the Lutheran exegete Rudolf Bultmann, whose method marked exegesis far beyond Protestantism[55].

The Church's response. The 1966 Roman letter described exactly this shift: a “christological humanism” which reduces Christ “to the condition of a mere man”, and for whom his virginal conception, his miracles and his resurrection “are conceded in words, but reduced in reality to the purely natural order”[56]. The Council had yet affirmed that the books of Scripture teach “firmly, faithfully and without error the truth which God wanted to have consigned in the Sacred Letters for our salvation” (Dei Verbum 11); the phrase “for our salvation” says why God had this truth consigned, not what inerrancy would cover, since Pius XII had set aside in 1950 “the theory which admits the inerrancy of the sacred letters only where they teach God, morals and religion”[57]. The 1992 Catechism decides the point for the resurrection: it is “a real event that had manifestations historically verified”[58].

Two Roman examinations show how the rule applies. In 1979, the Congregation noted in the book by the French Dominican Jacques Pohier (1926-2007), Quand je dis Dieu, the denial of “the bodily resurrection of Christ” and of “survival, resurrection, eternal life with God as man's vocation”, and specified that it is impossible to consider them “as opinions left to the free discussion of theologians”[59]. In the examination of the christological books of the Belgian Dominican Edward Schillebeeckx (1914-2009), conducted by a clarification colloquium and not by a trial, the latter concedes that the theologian “must take as the supreme rule of his thought not his own conception of the Jesus of history, but the Church's thought on Jesus”[60]. The whole debate lies in that sentence.

The consecrated bread reduced to a sign

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The thesis. The notion of substance would be an outdated philosophical category; what changes at the consecration would not be the being of the bread, but its meaning (“transsignification”) and its purpose (“transfinalization”): a bread become a sign of Christ's presence, as a letter becomes the sign of a friendship. The thesis appeals by its personalist language and by the insistence, legitimate, on the meal[61].

The Church's response. Humani generis had already aimed at those who want to correct transubstantiation, “wholly founded on an outdated philosophical notion”, in order to reduce the real presence “to a certain symbolism”[62]. On 3 September 1965, in the midst of the Council, Paul VI published the encyclical Mysterium fidei: it is not permitted, he wrote, to treat the mystery “without allusion to the wonderful conversion of the whole substance of the bread into the body of Christ”, so as “simply to remain with what is called “transsignification” and “transfinalization””[63]. The 1968 Credo gives the rule to which every explanation must conform:

“Every theological explanation which seeks to understand something of this mystery must, to be in accord with the Catholic faith, maintain that, in reality itself, independently of our mind, the bread and wine have ceased to exist after the consecration, so that it is the adorable Body and Blood of the Lord Jesus which are henceforth really before us under the sacramental species of bread and wine.” — Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, 30 June 1968, § 25[64]

The commission of cardinals charged with examining the Dutch catechism formulated in 1968 the correct articulation: after the consecration, the appearances of bread and wine do acquire “a new meaning and a new end”, but they take them on “because transubstantiation has taken place”[65]. The new meaning is the consequence of the real change, not its replacement. The articles What is transubstantiation? and The Real Eucharistic Presence develop this doctrine.

Original sin without Adam

The thesis. “Original sin” would designate the sinful situation into which every man is born, by reason of the collective history of humanity, and not the personal fault of a first man transmitted by generation; Adam would be a name for the whole of humanity. The thesis seeks to make the doctrine compatible with evolutionary reconstructions of human origins[66].

The Church's response. Humani generis had judged in 1950 that one does not see “at all how such an affirmation” — that Adam designates “the whole multitude of innumerable first fathers” — could be reconciled with the teaching on a sin “really committed by one single person, Adam”[67]. The 1966 Roman letter noted those who “minimize” the doctrine of Trent to the point that “Adam's original fault and the very transmission of sin” are “at the very least obscured”; and the cardinals of 1968 asked that expressions be avoided which would suggest that original sin is contracted only by the influence of a community in which sin reigns[68]. The Credo of Paul VI holds the whole doctrine:

“We believe that in Adam all have sinned. [...] We hold therefore, with the Council of Trent, that original sin is transmitted with human nature, “by propagation and not by imitation”, and that it is “proper to each one”. ” — Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, 30 June 1968, § 16[69]

The 1992 Catechism repeats it: Adam and Eve “commit a personal sin, but this sin affects the human nature which they will transmit in a fallen state”[70]. The historical reality of Adam and Eve, which Ignispedia holds with Tradition, is set out in the article Did the Garden of Eden and original sin really exist?.

The Magisterium relegated to the rank of opinion

The palace of the Holy Office, photographed in October 2013. Geobia — CC BY-SA 4.0. Source Wikimedia Commons.

The thesis. Only infallible definitions would bind; the ordinary teaching of the popes and bishops would be only one theology among others, which the scholar may publicly contest in the name of his conscience, the consensus of specialists or the opinion of the faithful. The Church should function as a democracy of ideas[71].

The Church's response. The 1966 letter already denounced an ordinary magisterium “sometimes neglected and disparaged to the point of being almost relegated to the domain of free opinions”[72]. Humani generis had recalled that encyclicals, which belong to the ordinary magisterium, demand assent, for it is to this magisterium too that the word applies: “Whoever listens to you listens to me”[73]. In 1990, the instruction Donum veritatis describes with precision the birth of “a kind of “parallel magisterium” of theologians”, “in opposition to the authentic magisterium and in competition with it”[74], and gives its diagnosis:

“To ask majority opinion what should be thought and done, to resort against the Magisterium to pressures exerted by public opinion, to invoke a “consensus” of theologians, to claim that the theologian is the prophetic spokesman of a “base” or autonomous community which would thus be the sole source of truth, all this denotes a grave loss of the sense of truth and the sense of the Church.” — Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, instruction Donum veritatis, 24 May 1990, § 39[75]

The same instruction nevertheless protects the good-faith researcher: it distinguishes public and organized opposition from personal difficulty, which the theologian must raise with the authority rather than with the media[76]. The case of Hans Küng illustrates this: in 1979, at the end of a procedure opened in 1975, the Congregation declared that he could no longer teach "as" a Catholic theologian, for having reduced infallibility to "a certain fundamental indefectibility of the Church in truth"; the declaration pronounced no excommunication; it withdrew the mandate to teach in the Church's name[77]. In 1998, John Paul II enshrined in canon law the duty of assent to truths set forth "in a definitive way," "to defend the Catholic faith against errors put forward by certain of the faithful, especially those engaged in the theological disciplines"[78].

A morality without absolute norms

The thesis. No act would be bad in itself; everything would depend on the situation, the intention and personal conscience, which the magisterium could only enlighten by "proposing values." The thesis presents itself as a morality for the free adult, opposed to a morality of rules[79].

The Church's response. The 1966 letter had already noted the rejection of "the objective rule of morality," of natural law, and the assertion of a "situation ethics"[80]. In 1993, John Paul II observes that the crisis has changed in scale: "It is no longer a matter of limited and occasional dissent, but of an overall and systematic calling into question of the moral patrimony," in which the magisterium is held to be able to intervene only to "exhort consciences" and "propose values"[81]. Moral relativism as a system is dealt with in the article Doctrinal relativism; it suffices here to note that it applies to morality the same principle that neo-modernism applies to dogma.

The seven theses and the Church's response in a table

The following table summarizes, for each thesis, what it maintains, what the Church upholds, and the Roman text that states this most clearly.

Neo-modernist thesisWhat it maintainsWhat the Church upholdsReference text
Provisional dogmaThe formulas give only shifting approximationsThe meaning of the formulas remains true and the same, even if better understoodMysterium Ecclesiae 5 (1973)
History judges the faithWhat was true yesterday may no longer be soThe truth expressed can always be recognized as suchFides et ratio 87 (1998)
Scripture and the Christ of faithAccounts of faith, resurrection-experienceInerrant Scripture, resurrection as a real eventDei Verbum 11; CCC 639
Eucharist-as-signTranssignification instead of transubstantiationChange of substance, new meaning flowing from itMysterium fidei 11 (1965)
Original sin without AdamA mere collective situation of sinAdam's fault transmitted by propagationPaul VI's Credo 16 (1968)
Magisterium-as-opinionOnly what is infallible binds; the theologian judgesThe ordinary magisterium binds; no parallel magisteriumDonum veritatis 34 and 39 (1990)
Situation ethicsNo act bad in itselfUniversal and permanent moral normsVeritatis splendor 4 (1993)

The seven theses have one thing in common: each keeps the Christian vocabulary while shifting its content toward the subject — from truth to experience, from fact to meaning, from the Church to opinion.

The post-conciliar period: the "fever" and the responses (1965–1990)

1966: the warning of the letter of 24 July

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Seven months after the close of the council, on 24 July 1966, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, headed by Cardinal Alfredo Ottaviani (1890–1979), sent to the presidents of the episcopal conferences a letter that at first remained confidential. It opens by commending the "very wise documents" promulgated by Vatican II and recalls that it is for the bishops to ensure that they receive "a correct interpretation," in keeping with "their proper force and intention"; it then notes that from various regions "not very encouraging" news has arrived of growing abuses in the interpretation of conciliar doctrine, and of "strange and bold" opinions that trouble many of the faithful[82].

The Congregation specifies that it commends research carried out to deepen the truth, on condition of distinguishing "what is to be believed and what is matter of opinion"; but it notes theses which, going beyond the limits of a mere hypothesis, "seem in some way to reach dogma itself and the foundations of the faith"[83]. The letter was to remain secret; newspapers having published distorted extracts of it, Rome had it published in full in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis[84]. It asked the bishops to discuss it and reply before Christmas. The ten errors it enumerates "by way of example" draw the complete map of post-conciliar neo-modernism:

  1. recourse to Scripture while deliberately setting aside Tradition, with restricted inspiration and inerrance and a poorly assessed historical value of the texts;
  2. dogmatic formulas subjected to historical evolution to such a point that "their very objective meaning" would change;
  3. an ordinary magisterium, especially that of the Roman pontiff, "relegated almost to the realm of opinions";
  4. objective truth almost unrecognized, all truth being supposed to follow "the rhythm of the evolution of conscience and of history";
  5. a "Christological humanism" that reduces Christ to a mere man who gradually became aware of his divine sonship;
  6. a real presence diluted into an "exaggerated symbolism," and the Mass seen as a meal rather than as a sacrifice;
  7. penance reduced to reconciliation with the Church, without personal confession of sins;
  8. original sin minimized;
  9. a morality without objective rule or natural law, in favor of a "situation ethics";
  10. ecumenism pushed to a dangerous "irenism" and "indifferentism," "quite foreign to the mind of the council."

Paul VI, the pope of doctrinal firmness

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

On doctrine, the acts of Saint Paul VI (pope from 1963 to 1978) are of great clarity. On 3 September 1965, even before the end of the council, he published Mysterium fidei against the reduction of the Eucharist to a sign[85]. On 29 September 1967, opening the first assembly of the Synod of Bishops — which would debate, until 29 October, the "crisis of the faith" — he described the danger with a precision that serves as a definition[86]:

"These dangers are full of snares, since they arise within the Church herself, through the work of certain teachers and writers who, while striving to express Catholic doctrine by new ways and new methods, often seek rather to adapt the dogmas of the faith to profane modes of thinking and speaking than to obey the norms of the ecclesiastical magisterium. [...] Faith is not merely searching: it is above all certainty; rather than the fruit of our investigation, it is a mysterious gift." — Saint Paul VI, opening homily of the Synod of Bishops, St. Peter's Basilica, 29 September 1967[87]

The "Year of Faith", announced in February 1967 for the nineteenth centenary of the martyrdom of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, closes on 30 June 1968 with the solemn proclamation of a Creed in Saint Peter's Square[88]. Paul VI explains why he pronounces it: he is aware of the anxiety troubling certain circles concerning the faith, and "we even see some Catholics allowing themselves to be seized by a kind of passion for change and novelty"; research is a duty, but care must be taken that the truths of Christian doctrine are not thereby shaken, for otherwise it brings "trouble and doubt into the soul of many faithful"[89]. According to the historian Philippe Chenaux, this Creed took up "in its essentials" the draft of a "complete and detailed" profession of faith that Jacques Maritain had had transmitted to the pope by Cardinal Charles Journet[90].

On 29 June 1972, for the feast of Saints Peter and Paul, Paul VI confides in a homily, according to the official account, that he has the sense that "through some crack, the smoke of Satan has entered the temple of God"; the same account summarises his thought: doubt has entered consciences, and it was believed that after the council would come a day of sunshine, whereas there came a day of clouds, storm and uncertainty[91]. The phrase does not call the council into question: it notes the doubt that has settled even within the Church. The articles Pope Saint Paul VI and Saint Paul VI trace the whole of the pontificate.

The Dutch Catechism: a case study (1966–1968)

The best-documented case of the post-conciliar period is that of the New Catechism (De Nieuwe Katechismus) published in the Netherlands in 1966. The book, whose "uncommon qualities" the Roman commission would later acknowledge, was quickly translated; but, by the same commission's own admission, its "new opinions" troubled many of the faithful from the very beginning[92]. Rome proceeded by stages. Paul VI first had three theologians designated by the Holy See and three designated by the Dutch bishops brought together from 8 to 10 April 1967; he had himself cited, by way of example, the virginal conception of Christ, the existence of angels, and the character of satisfaction and sacrifice of Christ's death. The colloquium achieved almost nothing[93].

The pope then entrusted the examination to a commission of six cardinals — Frings, Joseph Lefebvre (Archbishop of Bourges, not to be confused with Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre), Jaeger, Florit, Browne and Journet — which met in June and then in December 1967 with theologians from seven countries; meanwhile, English, German and French translations appeared without the requested corrections[94]. The final declaration, dated 15 October 1968, asks in ten points for the restoration, among other things, of the immediate creation of souls, original sin transmitted through nature, the fact of the virginal conception, transubstantiation and infallibility, which guarantees the Church not merely a "perpetual search" but the truth, to be explained "always in the same sense"[95]. It nonetheless ends with praise: these remarks, "neither few nor slight", leave intact "the greater part" of the catechism, whose "pastoral, liturgical and biblical" character deserves to be commended[96]. Firmness on doctrine, fairness towards the work: the method is exemplary.

Examine before judging: the Roman way

The doctrinal examinations of the post-conciliar period follow a procedure published by the Congregation on 15 January 1971, which provides that an author whose positions give rise to difficulties first submits a written reply, and may then explain himself orally in a colloquium with several theologians[97]. During the colloquium of December 1979 with Edward Schillebeeckx, the Congregation stresses that its representatives "by no means constitute a tribunal" and that the exchange aims "exclusively at arriving at a clarification"[98]. In the declaration on Hans Küng, it recalls that the canonical mission of a professor is "the witness of a mutual trust", and that it intervenes only after having exhausted "all the means suggested by charity"[99].

This patience has a theological reason, given in the same declaration: the faithful "also have the sacred right to receive the word of God without alteration"[100]. Neo-modernism is not primarily a matter of professors: it is ordinary faithful who pay the price, they who have neither the time nor the means to verify whether the words they hear have kept their meaning.

The guardians of renewal against rupture

Council Fathers in Saint Peter's Square on 11 October 1962. Peter Geymayer, public domain.

Among the most vigorous critics of neo-modernism are men who had prepared or welcomed the council. In November 1966, Jacques Maritain, Thomist philosopher and friend of Paul VI since the 1920s, publishes The Peasant of the Garonne: in it he gives thanks for the gains of the council, then describes the "neo-modernist fever", highly contagious in so-called intellectual circles, as a "kind of 'immanent' apostasy" — an apostasy which, he specifies, intends to remain Christian at all costs, and which is falsely attributed to "the spirit of the council", or even to "the spirit of John XXIII"[101]. He draws up the list: original sin, the infancy Gospel, the resurrection of the flesh and creation held to be myths, transubstantiation as a scholastic invention, hell simply forgotten, the Cross and Redemption reduced to symbols; and he specifies in a note that he is not describing there the views of honest scholars, but those of extremists[102]. Yet he refuses to judge persons: it is, he writes, sincerely, and sometimes in the fever and anguish of a deeply religious soul, that the leaders of neo-modernism declare themselves Christians; they are victims of a philosophy accepted in advance, according to which the intellect can no longer attain anything that exists independently of the mind[103].

Other voices follow. Hans Urs von Balthasar opposes as early as 1966, in Cordula or the Decisive Trial, the figure of the martyr to the notion of the "anonymous Christian" proposed by Karl Rahner[104]. Dietrich von Hildebrand publishes in 1967 The Trojan Horse in the City of God, in which he defends the council's documents against the "post-conciliar spirit" that claims to derive from them[105]. Louis Bouyer, an architect of the liturgical reform, publishes in 1968 The Decomposition of Catholicism[106]. Cornelio Fabro devotes in 1974 an entire book to the "anthropological turn" of Karl Rahner[107]. Henri de Lubac, Balthasar and Joseph Ratzinger found in 1972 the journal Communio[108].

Henri de Lubac himself, although suspected in 1950, describes in 1969 the crisis in words that match the diagnosis. In a lecture given at Saint Louis University (Missouri) and published by the Nouvelle revue théologique, he denounces "a bitter and vindictive disposition, resolved beforehand to spare nothing; a will to disparagement, a kind of aggressiveness exercised both against the Church's past and against her present existence"[109]. And he warns against an "openness" that would become "a forgetting of salvation, a drawing away from the Gospel, a march towards secularism, a slackening of faith and morals, in short, a dissolution into the world"[110].

On the Roman side, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger names in 1985 the "anti-spirit" that claims the council as its own:

"[Already] during the sessions, and then more and more in the period that followed, a so-called 'spirit of the Council' set itself up in opposition, one which in reality is a veritable 'anti-spirit'." — Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, The Ratzinger Report (Entretien sur la foi, with Vittorio Messori), Paris, Fayard, 1985, p. 36[111]

Three years later, before the bishops of Chile, he adds that many treat the council "as if it were almost a superdogma which robs everything else of importance"[112].

The 1985 Synod and the Catechism: rereading the council as a whole

John Paul II on 17 July 1985, a few months before the extraordinary synod. James G. Howes, reused with attribution.

Twenty years after the close of the Council, John Paul II convenes an extraordinary synod (24 November–8 December 1985) to take stock of it. Its final report lists among the internal causes of the difficulties "a partial and selective reading of the Council, as well as a superficial interpretation of its doctrine in one direction or the other", and a lack of discernment of spirits, which failed to distinguish "a legitimate opening of the Council to the world" from the adoption of the mindset of a secularized world[113]. It lays down the rule of interpretation: "it is not legitimate to separate the spirit and the letter of the Council", which "must be understood in continuity with the great Tradition of the Church"; for "the Church is one and the same through all the councils"[114].

The same synod requests the drafting of a catechism or compendium of the whole of Catholic doctrine, on faith as on morals[115]. The Catechism of the Catholic Church appears seven years later; John Paul II presents it on 11 October 1992, the thirtieth anniversary of the opening of the Council, as "a sure norm for the teaching of the faith"[116]. It is the most comprehensive response to neo-modernism: a single text in which every word of the Creed recovers its meaning, reference by reference.

Chronology of neo-modernism and the Church's responses

The dates below run from the condemnation of modernism to Benedict XVI's address on the hermeneutic of the Council; they retain only dated and published acts.

  1. 1 September 1910
    The anti-Modernist oath

    Pius X requires the clergy to swear that the faith is transmitted "in the same sense" and rejects "the evolution of dogma".

  2. 17 September 1946
    Pius XII and the "new theology"

    Before the Jesuits, Pius XII warns against a theology "always on the move, without ever arriving".

  3. 12 August 1950
    Humani generis

    The encyclical describes "dogmatic relativism" and its fruits in theology.

  4. 30 June 1962
    Monitum on Teilhard de Chardin

    The Holy Office judges that his works contain "ambiguities, and even serious errors".

  5. 11 October 1962
    Opening of the Council

    John XXIII distinguishes the deposit of faith from its formulation, "while preserving for them the same meaning and the same tenor".

  6. 3 September 1965
    Mysterium fidei

    Paul VI defends transubstantiation against "transignification".

  7. 24 July 1966
    The letter to the episcopal conferences

    The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith points out ten errors born of abuses in the interpretation of the Council.

  8. November 1966
    The Peasant of the Garonne

    Jacques Maritain denounces the "neo-modernist fever".

  9. 1967
    A profession of faith replaces the oath

    It requires assent to everything the Church teaches, whether defined or proposed by the ordinary magisterium.

  10. 29 September 1967
    First Synod of Bishops

    Paul VI: "faith is not merely a search: it is above all a certainty".

  11. 30 June 1968
    Credo of the People of God

    Paul VI closes the Year of Faith with a solemn profession of faith.

  12. 15 October 1968
    Declaration on the Dutch Catechism

    Six cardinals request ten sets of doctrinal corrections.

  13. 24 June 1973
    Mysterium Ecclesiae

    The Congregation rejects "dogmatic relativism".

  14. 21 November 1974
    Declaration of Archbishop Lefebvre

    The founder of the Society of St. Pius X sets "eternal Rome" against a Rome he calls "neo-modernist".

  15. 1979
    Pohier, Küng, Schillebeeckx

    Three doctrinal examinations, from 3 April to 15 December 1979.

  16. November–December 1985
    Extraordinary synod

    Taking stock of the Council's twenty years and requesting a universal catechism.

  17. 24 May 1990
    Donum veritatis

    The instruction distinguishes personal difficulty from public dissent.

  18. 11 October 1992
    The Catechism of the Catholic Church

    Presented as "a sure norm for the teaching of the faith".

  19. 1993–1998
    Veritatis splendor, Ad tuendam fidem, Fides et ratio

    Morals, canon law, philosophy: three responses from John Paul II.

  20. 22 December 2005
    The two hermeneutics

    Benedict XVI sets the "hermeneutic of rupture" against "reform" within continuity.

Developing Without Changing: the answer of substance

Growing "in the same sense": Vincent of Lérins' rule

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The Church opposes to neo-modernism not immobility, but a more demanding idea: doctrine grows without changing its nature, just as a child becomes a man without becoming someone else. The rule was formulated in the fifth century by a monk from the island of Lérins, Saint Vincent, in a short treatise against heresies, the Commonitorium (434).

His first rule defines what is Catholic: one must hold to "what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all"[117]. But Vincent immediately anticipates the objection that will be raised against him — and that in the twentieth century will be raised against every defence of dogma: is religion, then, susceptible of no progress?

"Of course there must be progress, and considerable! Who could be so hostile to mankind, so opposed to God, as to try to prevent it? But on the condition that this progress is truly a progress of faith and not an alteration: for progress means that each thing grows while remaining itself, whereas alteration means that one thing is transformed into another. [...] Let understanding, knowledge, wisdom grow and advance greatly [...] — but on condition that it be precisely according to their particular nature, that is, in the same dogma, in the same sense, in the same thought." — Saint Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium, 434, chap. 23, 1-3, trans. Pierre de Labriolle[118]

Vincent compares this progress to the growth of a body: the child and the old man are one and the same man, and "nothing new appears in the aged man that was not already hidden in the child"; if, on the contrary, the human form were to take on an appearance foreign to its species, the body "would perish or become monstrous". From this he draws the law of Christian dogma: "let the years confirm it, let time develop it, let age make it more venerable: but let it remain nonetheless incorrupt and unimpaired"[119]. The whole difference between development and neo-modernism lies in this image: the one makes a body grow, the other grafts a foreign limb onto it.

This rule became that of the magisterium. The First Vatican Council quotes it in 1870 to define the legitimate progress of theology: let understanding, knowledge and wisdom grow, "but exclusively within their own order, in the same belief, in the same sense and in the same thought"[120]. The anti-modernist oath of 1910 turns it into a personal commitment[121]. John XXIII takes up its Latin terms, eodem sensu eademque sententia, in the address that opens Vatican II on 11 October 1962[122]. The council reputed to have changed everything thus opened with the very formula that forbids changing the meaning of dogmas.

Newman: seven signs of a true development

In the nineteenth century, the English theologian John Henry Newman — received into the Catholic Church in 1845, canonised in 2019 and proclaimed Doctor of the Church by Leo XIV on 1 November 2025 — gave this rule a highly elaborate form in his Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine (1845, revised edition 1878)[123]. A living idea, he explains, passes through history and encounters new questions there; it develops in order to answer them without ceasing to be itself. His most famous sentence is often quoted to justify any change whatsoever:

"In a higher world it is otherwise, but here below to live is to change, and to be perfect is to have changed often." — Saint John Henry Newman, Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, chap. I, trans. Jules Gondon, 1848[124]

In its context, however, it says the opposite of what is made to say: the sentence preceding it affirms that the idea changes with circumstances "in order to remain the same"[125]. To distinguish a true development from a corruption, Newman proposes seven "notes", whose common purpose is to establish, in his own words, "the unity and identity of the idea with itself through all the stages of its development"[126]. The following table gives them in the order of the 1878 edition, with what each verifies and what neo-modernism sets against it.

Newman's noteWhat it verifiesWhat neo-modernism sets against it
Preservation of typeThe idea keeps its essential form, as the adult keeps that of the childA new form under an old name
Continuity of principlesThe principles of the starting point remain those of the end pointPrinciples borrowed from the philosophy of the moment
Power of assimilationThe idea integrates what is foreign to it without dissolving into itThe idea dissolves into what it absorbs
Logical sequenceEach development follows from those before itA rupture presented as a sequence
Anticipation of the futureThe development was in germ from the originA novelty with no root in Tradition
Conservative action upon the pastThe development protects what preceded itThe present rereads and corrects the past
Chronic vigourThe idea passes through the centuries without exhausting itselfA fashion that passes with its generation

What can change, what does not change

John Henry Newman, 1890 portrait held at the Rijksmuseum. Anonymous / Rijksmuseum, RP-F-2001-7-67-26 — CC0 1.0. Source Wikimedia Commons.

The twentieth-century magisterium specified what the rule allows. Words can change: Pius XII himself acknowledged in 1950 that the terms used in the schools and by the magisterium "can always be improved and refined", and that the Church "has not always made use of the same terms"[127]. A truth may first be expressed "in an incomplete way — though not falsely", and then "more fully", notes Mysterium Ecclesiae; some ancient formulas have even given way to new expressions that set forth "the same meaning more clearly or more completely"[128]. What cannot change is the meaning: it "remains always true and identical to itself in the Church"[129]. Pope Francis took up the same distinction made by John XXIII between "the substance" and "the way it is expressed", warning of the opposite risk: being "faithful to a formulation" without transmitting "the substance"[130].

Benedict XVI applied the same distinction to the Church's decisions on matters of circumstance. Some nineteenth-century decisions concerned "contingent facts", such as "certain concrete forms of liberalism or liberal interpretation of the Bible"; they were therefore themselves contingent, whereas "only principles express the lasting aspect". Hence his formula: true reform consists "in this combination of continuity and discontinuity at different levels", in which the continuity of principles is never abandoned[131]. Neo-modernism does the opposite: it presents a change of principle as a mere adaptation of circumstance.

"Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away." — Jesus, Gospel according to Saint Matthew 24, 35

Why neo-modernism is a grave error

An error about truth

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Neo-modernism presents itself as humility: no one would possess the truth; each person would approach it through formulas that are always open to revision. True humility, however, is the opposite: it receives a truth it did not produce. The Credo of Paul VI states as a principle that the intelligence God has given us « can attain to what is », and not merely the idea a given consciousness forms of it at a given time[132]. If dogmas were nothing but approximations, faith would never know what it believes, and the Church's prayer would be addressed only to hypotheses. The Catechism says the opposite, and says it in terms of spiritual life:

« There is an organic link between our spiritual life and the dogmas. Dogmas are lights along the path of our faith; they illuminate it and make it secure. Conversely, if our life is upright, our intellect and heart will be open to welcome the light of the dogmas of the faith. » — Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 89[133]

Growth does exist, but it goes from truth to truth better understood, not from a truth to its opposite: this is the work of the Spirit whom Christ promised, « the Spirit of truth », who leads « into all truth » (Jn 16:13). John Paul II named the fault of method that ruins this growth: confusing « currency with truth », by having recourse « only to the most recent assertions and philosophical language »[134].

An error about the Church

The Christian faith is not an endless search, but a deposit received and handed on. The Apostle Jude urges Christians « to contend for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints » (Jude 3); Saint Paul writes to his disciple: « Timothy, guard what has been entrusted to you » (1 Tim 6:20), and again: « Guard the truth that has been entrusted to you by the Holy Spirit who dwells within us » (2 Tim 1:14). The 1992 Catechism opens with the same idea: « Guarding the deposit of faith is the mission which the Lord entrusted to his Church, and which she carries out in every age »[135].

This deposit belongs no more to the pope than to theologians. The Second Vatican Council said so forcefully: the living Magisterium alone has the charge of authentically interpreting the Word of God, « though not above the Word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been transmitted »[136]. Neo-modernism reverses this order: it is the culture of the moment, or the consensus of specialists, that becomes the judge of the Word. The Church loses her continuity thereby — what the 1985 synod expressed in a single phrase: she « is one and the same through all the councils »[137].

An error that wounds the faith of the simple

The most serious consequence of neo-modernism is not intellectual. Those who suffer from it first are ordinary believers, who recite the Credo on Sunday without knowing that its meaning has been changed. Pius XII had pointed out as early as 1950 the « scandal » caused to many, « especially among the younger clergy »[138]; Paul VI spoke in 1968 of the « trouble » and the doubt sown in the souls of many believers[139]; the Congregation recalled in 1979 that they have « the sacred right to receive the word of God without alteration »[140]. Saint Paul had already described the temptation no longer to endure « sound doctrine », and to seek out teachers to suit one's own likings, « to suit their own desires » (2 Tim 4:3).

Christ, for his part, blessed the Father for having hidden his secrets from the wise:

« Father, Lord of heaven and earth, I praise you: what you have hidden from the wise and the learned you have revealed to the little ones. » — Jesus, Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11:25

The faith of the simple is not a second-rate faith that the learned should correct: it is the faith of the Church, which the learned have the mission to serve. It has the right not to be, in Saint Paul's words, « tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of doctrine » (Eph 4:14). Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger commented on this verse on 18 April 2005, at the Mass preceding the conclave from which he would emerge as pope:

« The little boat of the thought of many Christians has often been tossed about by these waves — flung from one extreme to another [...]. Possessing a clear faith, according to the Creed of the Church, is often defined as fundamentalism. [...] A dictatorship of relativism is being established that recognizes nothing as definitive and whose ultimate measure is only the self and its own desires. » — Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, homily at the Mass for the election of the Roman Pontiff, 18 April 2005[141]

Was Vatican II neo-modernist? Objections and answers

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Two opposed readings of the Council agree on one point: both see it as a rupture. For some progressives, Vatican II ushered in a new Church, whose "spirit" would go beyond its texts; for some traditionalists, it would have brought about the triumph of the neo-modernism condemned by Pius X and Pius XII. In 2005 Benedict XVI named the reading they have in common, the "hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture": it has, he wrote, "often been able to count on the sympathy of the mass media, and also of a part of modern theology," and it claims that "one should not follow the texts of the Council, but its spirit" — which "opens the door to all the fantasies"[142]. The four objections that follow are presented in their strongest form.

Objection 1 — "The suspect theologians of 1950 became the experts of the Council"

The objection. The names targeted by Humani generis — or at least by its commentators — turn up among the experts of Vatican II; their ideas made their way into its texts; the Council would thus be the revenge of the "new theology" upon the 1950 encyclical. This is the thesis that Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre (1905–1991) brought to its highest pitch in his Declaration of 21 November 1974:

Here are his own words, opening the Declaration[143]:

"We adhere with all our heart, with all our soul to Catholic Rome, guardian of the Catholic faith and of the traditions necessary to preserve that faith, to eternal Rome, mistress of wisdom and truth." — Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, Declaration of 21 November 1974[144]

"On the other hand we refuse, and have always refused, to follow the Rome of neo-modernist and neo-Protestant tendency which clearly showed itself in the Second Vatican Council and, after the Council, in all the reforms that issued from it." — Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, Declaration of 21 November 1974[145]

The answer. Humani generis names no one, and neither Henri de Lubac, nor Yves Congar, nor Jean Daniélou were condemned for heresy: to suspect a tendency is not to condemn an author[146]. Above all, the texts of the Council say the opposite of the neo-modernist theses. Dei Verbum teaches that Scripture teaches the truth "without error" and that the magisterium teaches "only what has been handed on"[147]; Lumen gentium calls for "a religious assent of the will and of the intelligence" towards the pope's teaching, "even when he does not speak ex cathedra"[148] — the exact opposite of a magisterium reduced to opinion. And the programme set by John XXIII at the opening was to hand on doctrine "certain and unchanging," while preserving for it "the same meaning and the same tenor"[149]: this is the formula of Vincent of Lérins, that is, the very rule that neo-modernism rejects. Finally, several men who had served or praised the Council — Joseph Ratzinger and Henri de Lubac, who were its experts, Jacques Maritain, who commended its achievements — were among the first to criticize neo-modernism. The articles the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X and Sedevacantism and the Catholic answers examine in detail the consequences of the opposite thesis.

Objection 2 — "The 1910 oath was abolished in 1967"

The objection. For fifty-seven years, every priest swore to reject the evolution of dogmas; Rome abolished this oath two years after the Council, at the very moment when the errors it targeted were reappearing. The Church would thus have disarmed itself.

The answer. The oath was not abolished without a replacement: in 1967 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith set a new formula, to be pronounced "in place of the Tridentine formula and the anti-modernist oath," by which one embraces and holds "everything that, in matters of faith and morals, has been defined by the Church by a solemn judgment or affirmed and declared by the ordinary magisterium, as she proposes it"[150]. In 1989, a new profession of faith and an oath of fidelity were imposed on those who hold an office in the name of the Church[151]; in 1998, Ad tuendam fidem gave the force of canon law to the obligation to assent to the truths proposed "in a definitive way"[152]. The instrument has changed; the requirement remains, and it is even broader, since it extends to the whole teaching of the Church and not to a dated list of errors.

Objection 3 — "The crisis followed the Council: therefore the Council caused it"

Benedict XVI at an audience on 20 January 2006. Giuseppe Ruggirello — CC BY-SA 3.0. Source Wikimedia Commons.

The objection. Seminaries empty out, catechisms are diluted, theologians challenge the Creed: all of this begins after 1965. The coincidence would be too strong to be accidental.

The answer. That two facts follow one another does not prove that the first causes the second. The diagnosis of Humani generis dates from 1950, fifteen years before the end of the Council, and it already announced that what was being taught "in a veiled manner" would soon be put forward "in broad daylight"[153]. The Roman letter of July 1966, written seven months after the close, attributes the errors not to the Council, whose documents it praises, but to the "abuses" in its interpretation[154]. That same year, Maritain judged false the attribution of this "immanent apostasy" to "the spirit of the Council"[155]. The 1985 Synod named external causes — an ideology marked by the pride of technical progress and by "a certain immanentism" that leads to the idolatry of material goods — and internal causes, chief among them "a partial and selective reading" of the Council[156]. Benedict XVI finally recalled that where the Council was received according to the hermeneutic of reform, "a new life has developed and new fruits have ripened"[157].

Objection 4 — "To denounce neo-modernism is to play into the hands of integrism"

The objection. The label of "modernist" was used, in the early twentieth century, to cast suspicion on loyal Catholics, up to the organization of a network of surveillance and denunciation, the "Sapinière," studied by the historian Émile Poulat[158]; that of "neo-modernist" serves today to disqualify every theologian who thinks for himself, and sometimes the popes themselves. It would be better to abandon so loaded a word.

The answer. The objection touches a real danger, which the Church herself fought: as early as 1914, Benedict XV renewed the condemnation of modernism in the very encyclical where he asked for an end to the appellations used "to distinguish Catholics from Catholics"[159].

Pius XII asked in 1946 that "a friendly hand" be held out to the erring, without conceding anything to errors[160]; Donum veritatis distinguishes sincere difficulty from organized dissent[161]; and the criterion the Church applies is not belonging to a camp, but the meaning of the dogmas, which anyone can verify in the Catechism. The word remains useful for naming a method — keeping the formulas while changing their meaning — on condition that it is never applied to a person without proof. The popes who fought this method most firmly, from the 1946 address to the 2005 speech, are also those who refused immobility: Tradition is alive, and it is precisely because it is alive that it does not change its nature.

Pope Francis recalled this in 2017, when presenting the new draft of the Catechism on the death penalty: quoting in turn the law of growth formulated by Vincent of Lérins, he specified that it "does not signify in any way a change of doctrine"[162].

Discerning Neo-Modernism Today

Five questions to recognize the method

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Neo-modernism cannot be recognized by its vocabulary, since its very principle is to keep the vocabulary. It is recognized by a method, which can be applied to any book, course, or homily. The five questions that follow are not meant to judge persons — an author's intention remains the secret of God — but to verify that a word transmits the faith of the Church and not another. They restate the criteria of the texts cited above and require no specialist expertise: the 1992 Catechism, presented by John Paul II as a sure norm, is in most cases sufficient to settle the question[163].

  1. Do words keep the meaning the Church has always given them? The First Vatican Council laid down the rule: no advance of knowledge permits giving a dogma "a meaning different from that which the Church has understood and still understands"[164].
  2. Do the facts of salvation history remain facts? The resurrection is "a real event"; Scripture teaches the truth "without error"[165].
  3. Is the Magisterium listened to as a teacher or commented on as an opinion? Assent is owed to the pope "even when he does not speak ex cathedra"[166].
  4. Does the novelty come from Tradition or from the spirit of the age? A theology that has recourse "only to the most recent assertions and philosophical language" confuses, John Paul II says, "the current with the truth"[167].
  5. Is the fruit a strengthened faith or a troubled faith? "You will know them by their fruits" (Mt 7:16); Paul VI judged theological research by what it produces in "the souls of many faithful"[168].

These questions also protect against the opposite excess. A new formula is not suspect because it is new, nor a reform because it reforms: John XXIII wanted the doctrine "certain and immutable" to be "deepened and presented in a way that meets the demands of our time"[169]. Pius XII, in the very address in which he warned against the "new theology," traced the line of conduct fitting for each person:

"Let whatever in theology sounds utterly new be weighed with attentive vigilance; let the certain and the firm be distinguished from what belongs to conjecture [...] ; let a friendly hand be extended to those who have gone astray, but let nothing be granted to the errors of opinions." — Pius XII, address to the Jesuits, September 17, 1946[170]

The true novelty: holiness

Neo-modernism promises a Church renewed by doctrine updated to current tastes. The Christian centuries show another path: its great reforms came first of all from saints. The 1985 synod said so in terms one can meditate on just as they are:

"The saints and holy women have always been, in the most difficult circumstances of the Church's history, the source and origin of renewal. Today we have an immense need of saints, whom we must implore from God with assiduity." — Extraordinary Synod of Bishops, final report, December 1985, II, A, 4[171]

The novelty the Church awaits is therefore not another doctrine, but a higher holiness lived in the same faith. In a 1997 message to the congregation founded by Saint Annibale Maria di Francia, John Paul II spoke of that "new and divine" holiness with which, he wrote, "the Holy Spirit wishes to enrich Christians at the dawn of the third millennium"[172]. Saint Annibale was, from 1910 to 1927, the extraordinary confessor and then the ecclesiastical censor of the Servant of God Luisa Piccarreta[173]; the hope attached to this holiness is set out in the article The Divine Will.

That novelty does not change the faith: it brings it to life. It answers the anxiety from which neo-modernism was born — how to speak of God to a world that no longer hears Him? — with the only answer that does not wear out: lives wholly given. Benedict XVI could thus conclude his assessment of the Council on hope: forty years on, "the positive aspect is greater and more alive than what could appear in the turmoil of the years following 1968," and "the good seed, even if it develops slowly, nevertheless grows"[174].

"Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today, and forever. Do not be led away by diverse and strange doctrines." — Letter to the Hebrews 13:8-9

Neo-modernism and its neighbours

Neo-modernism belongs to a family of modern errors that the Church has judged one by one, and which it is useful to distinguish so as not to confuse them. Some pull the faith towards the culture of the day: Catholic liberalism on the political front, Americanism in the spiritual life, Sillonism on the social question, and then modernism and neo-modernism on dogma itself. Others err through the opposite excess, distrusting reason or the Church's living authority: fideism, the philosophical traditionalism of the nineteenth century, or the refusal of the post-conciliar magisterium.

These errors share a common trait: each separates what the Church unites — faith and reason, Tradition and the living magisterium, fidelity and renewal. The table below gives, for each one, the reference date and the article in which it is treated.

ErrorReference dateWhat it distortsIgnispedia article
Catholic liberalismMirari vos (1832), Syllabus (1864)The Church's relation to modern libertiesCatholic liberalism condemned
AmericanismTestem benevolentiae (1899)Adaptation of doctrine and spiritual life to the ageAmericanism
ModernismLamentabili and Pascendi (1907)Revelation, dogma, Scripture: a complete systemModernism
SillonismNotre charge apostolique (1910)Authority, equality, fraternity without charitySillonism
Neo-modernismHumani generis (1950), Mysterium Ecclesiae (1973)The meaning of dogmas, kept in appearanceThis article
Doctrinal relativismDominus Iesus (2000), no. 4Truth itself, reduced to opinionDoctrinal relativism
FideismThe Bautain affair (1840–1844); Vatican I, Dei Filius (1870)Reason, judged incapable of knowing GodFideism
Philosophical traditionalismMirari vos (1832), Singulari nos (1834), Vatican I (1870)Reason, suspended from a primitive revelation transmitted by societyPhilosophical traditionalism
SedevacantismAfter 1965The authority of the post-conciliar popesSedevacantism and the Catholic replies

Neo-modernism and sedevacantism answer one another like two symmetrical errors: one keeps the words while changing the faith, the other keeps the faith of yesterday while rejecting the Church of today. The Catholic faith holds both together: the same faith, in the same Church.

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Saint Pius X, encyclical Pascendi Dominici gregis, 8 September 1907, §§ 6, 7 and 14 (French text, vatican.va); Pius XII, encyclical Humani generis, 12 August 1950, §§ 14-16, Acta Apostolicae Sedis (AAS) 42 (1950), p. 561-578 (French text, vatican.va; paragraph numbering follows the English version of the same site).

    1
  2. First Vatican Council, dogmatic constitution Dei Filius, 24 April 1870, canons of chapter 4, canon 3 (DH 3043), translation of the French Denzinger (Benoît library, DH numbering).

    2
  3. Pius XII, address to the electors of the XXIXth General Congregation of the Society of Jesus, 17 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 381-385, here p. 385; Pius XII, Humani generis, 12 August 1950; Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, letter Cum Oecumenicum Concilium to the presidents of the episcopal conferences, 24 July 1966, AAS 58 (1966), p. 659-661; Paul VI, Sollemnis professio fidei (Credo of the People of God), 30 June 1968, AAS 60 (1968), p. 433-445; Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae, 24 June 1973, § 5, AAS 65 (1973), p. 402-404.

    3
  4. Jacques Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne. Un vieux laïc s'interroge à propos du temps présent, Paris, Desclée de Brouwer, November 1966, ch. 1, quoted by René Mougel, "Le paysan de la Garonne : genèse et lignes de fond", Revue des sciences religieuses, 81/4, 2007, p. 439-460, here p. 440, and by Philippe Chenaux, "Magistère et théologiens dans l'après-concile", Revue des sciences religieuses, 96/1-3, 2022, p. 13-28; English translation: The Peasant of the Garonne, New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1968, p. 5.

    4
  5. Saint Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium, 434, ch. 23, 3, Patrologia Latina 50, col. 668: "in eodem scilicet dogmate, eodem sensu eademque sententia" (trans. P. de Labriolle, Saint Vincent de Lérins, Paris, Bloud, 1906, p. 92-93: "in the same dogma, in the same sense, in the same thought"); First Vatican Council, Dei Filius, ch. 4 (DH 3020); John XXIII, opening speech of the Council Gaudet Mater Ecclesia, 11 October 1962, AAS 54 (1962), p. 792. Original text: "eodem tamen sensu eademque sententia".

    5
  6. Benedict XVI, address to the Roman Curia for the presentation of the Christmas wishes, 22 December 2005 (French text, vatican.va).

    6
  7. Articles Modernism, The modernist crisis (1893-1914), Doctrinal relativism and The Second Vatican Council (1962-1965).

    7
  8. Saint Pius X, Pascendi Dominici gregis, 8 September 1907, § 6 ("Human reason, rigorously confined within the circle of phenomena"), § 7 ("the positive side is constituted by what is called vital immanence") and § 14 ("To evolve and change, not only may dogma do so, it must"); French text, vatican.va.

    8
  9. Saint Pius X, motu proprio Sacrorum antistitum, 1 September 1910, anti-modernist oath (DH 3537-3550); Pius XII, Humani generis, §§ 5-7 (evolutionism, existentialism, "false historicism").

    9
  10. The earliest recorded use of the word dates from March-April 1907, in La Justice sociale of Abbé Naudet (no. 711, 9 March 1907, p. 1: "my thinking is too neo-modernist"; no. 716, 13 April 1907, p. 1: "those who, for our use, invented 'neo-modernism'"), then from September 1907 under the pen of Mgr Delamaire, coadjutor of Cambrai (letter to Pius X in adherence to Pascendi, quoted in the Gazette de Cambrai of 22 September 1907, p. 2-3: "current neo-modernism") — images checked, Gallica. But the expression only designates the return of the modernist theses after 1946 among the critics of the 1960s, notably Maritain. On modernism, the name given by the judge of 1907: article Modernism, section "The word and the thing".

    10
  11. J. Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne, 1966, ch. 1; English translation, 1968, p. 5-6 and note on p. 5. Text of the English translation: "The word modernism has aged, but nevertheless I do not know a better".

    11
  12. Saint John Paul II, encyclical Fides et ratio, 14 September 1998, § 87 (French text, vatican.va).

    12
  13. Saint John Paul II, Fides et ratio, § 55.

    13
  14. Saint Pius X, Pascendi Dominici gregis, § 13 (« elles ne sont que des signes inadéquats de son objet, vulgairement des symboles ») and § 21 (« le croyant doit employer ces formules dans la mesure où elles peuvent lui servir [...] sous réserve toujours du respect social qui leur est dû ») ; French text, vatican.va.

    14
  15. First Vatican Council, Dei Filius, canons of chapter 4, canon 3 (DH 3043).

    15
  16. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration Christi Ecclesia on certain points of the theological doctrine of Professor Hans Küng, 15 December 1979, signed by Cardinal Franjo Šeper, Prefect, and approved by John Paul II (French text, vatican.va).

    16
  17. First Vatican Council, Dei Filius, chapter 4, "Faith and Reason" (DH 3020).

    17
  18. Distinctions drawn on the basis of the documents cited in the following notes; same approach as the section "What Modernism Is Not" of the article Modernism.

    18
  19. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 21.

    19
  20. Pius XII, apostolic constitution Munificentissimus Deus, 1 November 1950 (DH 3900-3904); on the distinction between development and evolution, see below the section "Developing Without Changing".

    20
  21. Pius XII, address to the Jesuits, 17 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 384-385. Original text: "oporteat sui saeculi ingenio et propensioni sapienter orationem suam accommodent. At quod immutabile est, nemo turbet et moveat".

    21
  22. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, instruction Donum veritatis on the ecclesial vocation of the theologian, 24 May 1990, § 32 (French text, vatican.va).

    22
  23. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, letter of 24 July 1966, AAS 58 (1966), p. 659. Original text: "sapientissima documenta promulgaverit"; "de abusibus in doctrina Concilii interpretanda invalescentibus".

    23
  24. Saint Pius X, Sacrorum antistitum, 1 September 1910, antimodernist oath, DH 3541 (translation from the French Denzinger).

    24
  25. Same oath, DH 3545.

    25
  26. Benedict XV, encyclical Ad beatissimi Apostolorum, 1 November 1914, AAS 6 (1914), p. 577-578 (Latin) and authentic French version, p. 611 (French text, vatican.va).

    26
  27. Same encyclical, AAS 6 (1914), p. 577 (Latin) and p. 610-611 (authentic French version). The encyclical names no group. The formula Christianus mihi nomen, catholicus cognomen is taken from Saint Pacian of Barcelona, though the encyclical does not specify this.

    27
  28. Alfred Loisy (1857-1940), excommunicated in 1908: see the table of actors in the article Modernism and the article The Modernist Crisis (1893-1914).

    28
  29. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 5-7.

    29
  30. Pius XII, address Ad Patres Societatis Iesu in XXIX Congregatione generali electores, 17 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 381-385.

    30
  31. Same address, AAS 38 (1946), p. 385; Ignispedia translation. Original text: "At quod immutabile est, nemo turbet et moveat. Plura dicta sunt, at non satis experta ratione, « de nova theologia » quae cum universis semper volventibus rebus, una volvatur, semper itura numquam perventura. Si talis opinio amplectenda esse videatur, quid fiet de numquam immutandis catholicis dogmatibus, quid de fidei unitate et stabilitate ?"

    31
  32. Same address, AAS 38 (1946), p. 385. Original text: "quod in re theologica omnino novum sonat, evigilanti cautione perpendatur ; certum firmumque ab eo, quod coniectura ducitur, [...] secernatur ; errantibus amica praebeatur manus, nihil autem indulgeatur opinionum erroribus".

    32
  33. Pius XII, address to the delegates of the general chapter of the Order of Friars Preachers, 22 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 385-389, here p. 387; Ignispedia translation. Original text: "Nunc vero agitur de ipsis philosophiae perennis et theologiae fundamentis [...] ; agitur de veris a Deo patefactis, an nempe mentis acies ea certis notionibus penetrare atque ex eis ulteriora colligere possit".

    33
  34. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, "La nouvelle théologie où va-t-elle ?", Angelicum 23 (1946), p. 126-145, here p. 143 (text read from the original scan, archive.org). Exact text: "Conclusion. Où va la nouvelle théologie ? Elle revient au modernisme. Parce qu'elle a accepté la proposition qui lui était faite : celle de substituer à la définition traditionnelle de la vérité : adaequatio rei et intellectus, comme si elle était chimérique, la définition subjective : adaequatio realis mentis et vitae."

    34 35
  35. Same article, p. 127: "Et comment enfin maintenir que toutes ces propositions sont immuablement vraies, si la notion même de vérité doit changer, et s'il faut substituer à la définition traditionnelle de la vérité (la conformité du jugement au réel extramental et à ses lois immuables) celle proposée ces dernières années par la philosophie de l'action : la conformité du jugement avec les exigences de l'action ou de la vie humaine qui évolue toujours ?"

    36
  36. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 10.

    37
  37. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 11.

    38
  38. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 14-15.

    39
  39. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 16-17.

    40
  40. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 22-26.

    41
  41. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 13.

    42
  42. Henri de Lubac removed from teaching by his superiors in June 1950; Yves Congar placed under supervision from 1947 to 1956; Jean Daniélou made cardinal by Paul VI on 28 April 1969, Henri de Lubac by John Paul II on 2 February 1983, Yves Congar by John Paul II on 26 November 1994: see the articles Henri de Lubac (1896-1991), Yves Congar (1904-1995) and Jean Daniélou (1905-1974) and their sources; for Daniélou, notice of the Académie française (academie-francaise.fr, "Jean Daniélou").

    43
  43. Review Communio, founded in 1972 by Hans Urs von Balthasar, Henri de Lubac and Joseph Ratzinger: presentation of Communio: International Catholic Review, Project MUSE (muse.jhu.edu/journal/884). Original text: "It stands for the renewal of theology in continuity with the living Christian tradition".

    44
  44. Yves Congar, Vraie et fausse réforme dans l'Église, Paris, Cerf, coll. "Unam Sanctam" 20, 1950; see the article Yves Congar (1904-1995).

    45
  45. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 14-37; Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, letter of 24 July 1966, AAS 58 (1966), p. 660-661, points 1 to 10.

    46
  46. Thesis described by Pius XII, Humani generis, § 15 (notions "approximate and ever-changing"), by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 2, and by Mysterium Ecclesiae, § 5.

    47
  47. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration Mysterium Ecclesiae, 24 June 1973, § 5 (French text, vatican.va; AAS 65, 1973, p. 402-404).

    48
  48. Mysterium Ecclesiae, § 5.

    49
  49. Paul VI, encyclical Mysterium fidei, 3 September 1965, § 24 (French text, vatican.va; numbering of the English version of the same site).

    50
  50. Thesis described by Pius XII, Humani generis, § 7 ("false historicism"), and by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 4. Original text of this point: "veritas quaecumque rythmum evolutionis conscientiae et historiae necessario sequatur".

    51
  51. Antimodernist oath, DH 3545.

    52
  52. Saint John Paul II, Fides et ratio, § 87.

    53
  53. Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, 30 June 1968, § 5, AAS 60 (1968), p. 435; Ignispedia translation of the official Latin text (the French page of vatican.va does not contain the text). Original text: "summi est momenti animadvertere, praeter id quod aspectabile est, quodque scientiarum ope percipimus, intellegentiam a Deo nobis datam id quod est attingere posse, non vero tantummodo significationem in opinione positam sive structurarum, quas vocant, sive evolutionis humanae conscientiae. Ceterum recolendum est, illud ad interpretationem seu ad hermeneuma pertinere, ut, verbo, quod pronuntiatum est, observato, intellegere et discernere studeamus sensum textui cuidam subiectum, non vero novum quendam sensum fingere, prouti arbitraria coniectura tulerit."

    54
  54. Letter of 24 July 1966, points 1 and 5; on the programme of demythologisation (Frankfurt lecture, 21 April 1941), see the article Rudolf Bultmann (1884-1976).

    55
  55. Letter of 24 July 1966, point 5, AAS 58 (1966), p. 660; Ignispedia translation. Original text: "Serpit quidam humanismus christologicus ob quem Christus ad condicionem simplicis hominis reducitur, qui sensim suae divinae Filiationis conscientiam acquisierit. Eius Virginalis conceptio, miracula, ipsa Resurrectio verbotenus conceduntur sed reapse ad merum ordinem naturalem reducuntur."

    56
  56. Vatican II, dogmatic constitution Dei Verbum, 18 November 1965, § 11 (French text, vatican.va); Pius XII, Humani generis, § 22.

    57
  57. Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 639.

    58
  58. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration on the book of Rev. Jacques Pohier, Quand je dis Dieu, 3 April 1979, § 1-2 (French text, vatican.va).

    59
  59. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, letter to Rev. Edward Schillebeeckx concerning his Christological positions, 20 November 1980, annexed note, § 1 (French text, vatican.va).

    60
  60. Thesis described by Pius XII, Humani generis, § 26, by Paul VI, Mysterium fidei, § 11, and by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 6.

    61
  61. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 26.

    62
  62. Paul VI, Mysterium fidei, 3 September 1965, § 11.

    63
  63. Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, § 25, AAS 60 (1968), p. 443; Ignispedia translation. Original text: "Quaevis porro theologorum interpretatio, quae huiusmodi mysterio aliquatenus intellegendo studet, ut cum catholica fide congruat, id sartum tectum praestare debet, ut in ipsa rerum natura, a nostro scilicet spiritu distincta, panis et vinum, facta consecratione, adesse desierint".

    64
  64. Cardinalatial Commission on the "New Catechism" (De Nieuwe Katechismus), Declaration, 15 October 1968, II, 6, AAS 60 (1968), p. 689; Ignispedia translation. Original text: "consequuntur utique novam significationem novumque finem. Sed ideo novam illam significationem finemque induunt, quia facta est transsubstantiatio".

    65
  65. Thesis described by Pius XII, Humani generis, § 37, by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 8, and by the Declaration of 15 October 1968, II, 2.

    66
  66. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 37.

    67
  67. Letter of 24 July 1966, point 8, AAS 58 (1966), p. 661. Original text: « Nec desunt qui doctrinam Concilii Tridentini de peccato originali vel parvipendunt vel ita commentantur ut originalis culpa Adami et ipsius peccati transmissio saltem obfuscentur »; Declaration of 15 October 1968, II, 2, AAS 60 (1968), p. 687-688.

    68
  68. Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, § 16, AAS 60 (1968), p. 439; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « Credimus in Adam omnes peccavisse [...]. Tenemus igitur, Concilium Tridentinum secuti, peccatum originale, una cum natura humana, transfundi propagatione, non imitatione, idque esse unicuique proprium ».

    69
  69. Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 404.

    70
  70. Thesis described by the instruction Donum veritatis, § 33-35, and by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 3.

    71
  71. Letter of 24 July 1966, point 3, AAS 58 (1966), p. 660; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « Magisterium ordinarium Ecclesiae, praesertim Romani Pontificis ita interdum negligitur et parvipenditur, ut ad regionem rerum opinabilium fere relegetur ».

    72
  72. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 20, citing Lk 10:16.

    73
  73. Donum veritatis, § 34.

    74
  74. Donum veritatis, § 39.

    75
  75. Donum veritatis, § 30 and 32: "the theologian will avoid having recourse to the mass media rather than turning to the responsible authority" (§ 30).

    76
  76. Declaration Christi Ecclesia, 15 December 1979; first declaration of the Congregation on two books by Hans Küng, 15 February 1975, AAS 67 (1975), p. 203-204.

    77
  77. Saint John Paul II, motu proprio Ad tuendam fidem, 18 May 1998, preamble and § 4 A (can. 750 § 2) (French text, vatican.va).

    78
  78. Thesis described by Saint John Paul II, Veritatis splendor, § 4, and by the letter of 24 July 1966, point 9.

    79
  79. Letter of 24 July 1966, point 9, AAS 58 (1966), p. 661. Original text: « non pauci obiectivam rationem moralitatis reicere audent ; alii legem naturalem non accipiunt, asserunt vero legitimitatem moralis situationis quam dicunt ».

    80
  80. Saint John Paul II, encyclical Veritatis splendor, 6 August 1993, § 4 (French text, vatican.va).

    81
  81. Letter of 24 July 1966, AAS 58 (1966), p. 659; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « ut eiusdem Concilii Documenta et Decreta rectam interpretationem accipiant et ad effectum deducantur secundum propriam ipsorum vim et mentem adamussim servatam »; « nuntios non faustos pervenisse de abusibus in doctrina Concilii interpretanda invalescentibus, necnon de peregrinis et audacibus opinionibus hic illic insurgentibus quae plurium fidelium animos non parum perturbant ».

    82
  82. Same letter, p. 659-660. Original text: « probe distinguendo inter id quod est credendum et id quod est opinabile »; « sententiis quae limites simplicis opinionis vel hypotheseos facile praetergredientes ipsum dogma et fidei fundamenta aliquatenus afficere videntur ».

    83
  83. Same letter, note from the editors of the AAS, p. 659 (publication prompted by the appearance of extracts in the press); request for a reply « ante festum Nativitatis » and prescribed secrecy, p. 661.

    84
  84. Paul VI, encyclical Mysterium fidei, 3 September 1965, AAS 57 (1965).

    85
  85. Ph. Chenaux, "Magistère et théologiens dans l'après-concile", Revue des sciences religieuses, 96/1-3, 2022, p. 13-28: first Synod of Bishops, 29 September – 29 October 1967, devoted in particular to the "crisis of faith".

    86
  86. Saint Paul VI, homily for the opening of the first assembly of the Synod of Bishops, St Peter's Basilica, 29 September 1967, AAS 59 (1967), p. 963 ff., here p. 965-966; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « eademque insidiarum plena, utpote quae in ipsius Ecclesiae sinu oriantur nonnullorum magistrorum et scriptorum opera, qui, dum contendunt doctrinam catholicam novis viis ac modis exprimere, saepe tamen magis cupiunt fidei dogmata ad profanas cogitandi loquendique rationes accommodare, quam normis magisterii ecclesiastici obtemperare [...]. Fides non solum est inquisitio, sed imprimis certitudo ; potius quam nostrae pervestigationis fructus, est donum quoddam arcanum ».

    87
  87. Saint Paul VI, apostolic exhortation Petrum et Paulum, 22 February 1967; Credo of the People of God, § 1; Ph. Chenaux, art. cit.

    88
  88. Saint Paul VI, Credo of the People of God, § 4, AAS 60 (1968), p. 434; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « Immo vel nonnullos catholicos homines videmus aut mutandarum, aut novandarum rerum quadam quasi cupiditate capi. [...] Sed simul maximopere cavendum est ne, dum necessarium investigandi officium usurpatur, christianae doctrinae veritates labefactentur. Quod si fiat [...] perturbationem et dubitationem fidelium multorum animis afferat. »

    89
  89. Ph. Chenaux, "Magistère et théologiens dans l'après-concile", Revue des sciences religieuses, 96/1-3, 2022, p. 13-28: in January 1967, Cardinal Journet delivered to Paul VI a letter from Maritain proposing "a complete and detailed profession of faith"; the profession of faith of 30 June 1968 "took up in its essentials the project of the French philosopher".

    90
  90. Saint Paul VI, homily for the solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul, 29 June 1972, official account in Italian (vatican.va). Original text: « da qualche fessura sia entrato il fumo di Satana nel tempio di Dio »; « È entrato il dubbio nelle nostre coscienze »; « Si credeva che dopo il Concilio sarebbe venuta una giornata di sole per la storia della Chiesa. È venuta invece una giornata di nuvole, di tempesta, di buio, di ricerca, di incertezza ». Only the first sentence is given as words of the pope; the rest is a summary in indirect speech.

    91
  91. Declaration of 15 October 1968, I, AAS 60 (1968), p. 685. Original text: « qui ex una parte dotibus haud communibus praestat, ex altera vero parte novis opinionibus suis, ab exordio non paucos christifideles turbavit ».

    92
  92. Same declaration, I, p. 685. Original text: colloquium « a die 8 ad diem 10 aprilis 1967 habito »; examples pointed out by the pope: « ad virginalem Iesu Christi ortum [...] ad sententiam [...] qua angelos esse credimus ; atque ad satisfactionis et sacrificii genus, quae Christus Summo Parenti obtulit »; « Attamen colloquio vix aliquid actum est ».

    93
  93. Same declaration, I, p. 685-686: commission of Cardinals Frings, Lefebvre, Jaeger, Florit, Browne and Journet; meetings of 27-28 June and 12-14 December 1967; theologians « ad septem nationes pertinentium »; English, German and French translations published « absque debita emendatione ». Cardinal Joseph-Charles Lefebvre (1892-1973) was Archbishop of Bourges.

    94
  94. Same declaration, II, points 1-10, p. 687-691. Original text of point 7: « infallibilitatem Ecclesiae non praebere ei tantum cursum non devium perpetuae inquisitionis, sed veritatem in doctrina fidei servanda in eaque eodem semper sensu explicanda ».

    95
  95. Same declaration, conclusion, p. 691. Original text: « Praefatae animadversiones, etsi nec paucae nec leves, intactam relinquunt maiorem prorsus Novi Catechismi partem, cum laudanda eius indole pastorali, liturgica et biblica. »

    96
  96. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Agendi ratio in doctrinarum examine, 15 January 1971, art. 13-15, recalled in the declaration of 13 December 1979 on the colloquium with Rev. Edward Schillebeeckx (vatican.va).

    97
  97. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration on the colloquium of clarification with Rev. Edward Schillebeeckx on certain points of Christological doctrine, 13 December 1979 (French text, vatican.va).

    98
  98. Declaration Christi Ecclesia, 15 December 1979.

    99
  99. Declaration Christi Ecclesia, 15 December 1979.

    100
  100. J. Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne, 1966, ch. 1, cited by R. Mougel, art. cit., p. 440 ("neo-modernist fever"; "a kind of 'immanent' apostasy"). English translation, 1968, p. 6: "a kind of 'immanent' apostasy (that is, which intends to remain Christian at all costs) [...] sometimes falsely ascribed to the 'spirit of the Council,' or even to the 'spirit of John XXIII.'"

    101
  101. J. Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne, ch. 1; English translation, 1968, p. 6 and note 8: "What I have brought together in this picture are not the views of honest seekers, but of extremists".

    102
  102. J. Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne, chap. 1 ; English translation, 1968, p. 8 (paraphrase based on the English translation, the original French being unavailable for consultation): « It is certainly with sincerity, and sometimes in the fever and anguish of a fundamentally religious soul, that the leaders of our neo-modernism declare themselves Christians. »

    103
  103. Hans Urs von Balthasar, Cordula oder der Ernstfall, Einsiedeln, Johannes Verlag, 1966 ; see the article Hans Urs von Balthasar (1905-1988).

    104
  104. Dietrich von Hildebrand, The Trojan Horse in the City of God, Chicago, Franciscan Herald Press, 1967 ; see the article Dietrich von Hildebrand (1889-1977).

    105
  105. Louis Bouyer, La Décomposition du catholicisme, Paris, Aubier-Montaigne, 1968 ; see the article Louis Bouyer (1913-2004).

    106
  106. Cornelio Fabro, La svolta antropologica di Karl Rahner, Milan, Rusconi, 1974 ; see the article Cornelio Fabro (1911-1995).

    107
  107. Project MUSE, presentation of Communio: International Catholic Review (muse.jhu.edu/journal/884).

    108
  108. Henri de Lubac, "L'Église dans la crise actuelle", revised text of a lecture given at Saint Louis University (Missouri) on 29 May 1969, Nouvelle revue théologique 91 (1969), no. 6, p. 580-596, here p. 583 (original PDF); Paris, Cerf, 1969, 99 pp.

    109
  109. Same text, p. 588: "Or n'arrive-t-il pas que, tout à l'inverse, une telle "ouverture" devienne un oubli du salut, un éloignement de l'Évangile, une marche au sécularisme, un laisser-aller de la foi et des mœurs, bref, une dissolution dans le monde, une abdication, une perte d'identité, c'est-à-dire la trahison de notre devoir envers le monde ?"

    110
  110. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Entretien sur la foi (with Vittorio Messori), Paris, Fayard, 1985, p. 36 (page given by Courrier de Rome, La Tradition « excommuniée » ?, note 30).

    111
  111. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, address to the bishops of Chile, Santiago, 13 July 1988, published in Il Sabato, 30 July–5 August 1988, p. 15 (reference given by Piero Cantoni, Renovatio 24, 1989, no. 3, p. 458, note 25); Ignispedia translation. Italian text: "La verità è che lo stesso Concilio non ha definito nessun dogma […] ; certo, molti lo interpretano come se fosse quasi il superdogma che toglie importanza a tutto il resto."

    112
  112. Synod of Bishops, II extraordinary general assembly (24 November – 8 December 1985), final report Ecclesia sub verbo Dei mysteria Christi celebrans pro salute mundi, I, 4 ; Ignispedia translation based on the English translation published by the EWTN Library. English text: « Among the internal causes, there must be noted a partial and selective reading of the Council, as well as a superficial interpretation of its doctrine in one sense or another » ; « the failure to correctly distinguish between a legitimate openness of the Council to the world and the acceptance of a secularized world's mentality and order of values ».

    113
  113. Same report, I, 5. English text: « it is not legitimate to separate the spirit and the letter of the Council. Moreover, the Council must be understood in continuity with the great tradition of the Church [...]. The Church is one and the same throughout all the councils. »

    114
  114. Same report, II, B, a, 4. English text: « Very many have expressed the desire that a catechism or compendium of all Catholic doctrine regarding both faith and morals be composed ».

    115
  115. Saint John Paul II, apostolic constitution Fidei depositum, 11 October 1992, IV, « Doctrinal Value of the Text » (French text, vatican.va).

    116
  116. Saint Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium, chap. 2, 5, Patrologia Latina 50, col. 640 ; trans. P. de Labriolle, Saint Vincent de Lérins, Paris, Bloud, coll. « La Pensée chrétienne », 1906, p. 7-8. Original text: « ut id teneamus quod ubique, quod semper, quod ab omnibus creditum est ».

    117
  117. Saint Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium, chap. 23, 1-3, Patrologia Latina 50, col. 667-668; trans. P. de Labriolle, 1906, p. 92-93. Original text: "Sed ita tamen ut vere profectus sit ille fidei, non permutatio. Siquidem ad profectum pertinet ut in semetipsum unaquaeque res amplificetur; ad permutationem vero, ut aliquid ex alio in aliud transvertatur. Crescat igitur oportet [...] intelligentia, scientia, sapientia, sed in suo duntaxat genere, in eodem scilicet dogmate, eodem sensu, eademque sententia."

    118
  118. Same chapter, 23, 4-9, Patrologia Latina 50, col. 668; trans. P. de Labriolle, 1906, p. 94-95. Original text of the formula: "ut annis scilicet consolidetur, dilatetur tempore, sublimetur aetate, incorruptum tamen illibatumque permaneat".

    119
  119. First Vatican Council, Dei Filius, chap. 4 (DH 3020), quoting Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium, chap. 23.

    120
  120. Antimodernist Oath, 1 September 1910, DH 3541.

    121
  121. John XXIII, opening address to the Council, 11 October 1962, AAS 54 (1962), p. 792: « eodem tamen sensu eademque sententia ».

    122
  122. John Henry Newman, An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, London, 1845; new edition, London, Basil Montagu Pickering, 1878. Canonised by Pope Francis on 13 October 2019; proclaimed Doctor of the Church by Leo XIV on 1 November 2025: commentary by the prefect of the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments on the decree of 9 November 2025 (vatican.va, 3 February 2026).

    123
  123. J. H. Newman, Histoire du développement de la doctrine chrétienne, trans. Jules Gondon, Paris, Sagnier et Bray, 1848, chap. I, sect. I, p. 50. Original text (1878 ed., chap. I, sect. 1, § 7, p. 40): "In a higher world it is otherwise, but here below to live is to change, and to be perfect is to have changed often."

    124
  124. Same passage, 1878 ed., p. 40. Original text: "It changes with them in order to remain the same."

    125
  125. J. H. Newman, An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, 1878 ed., chap. V, sect. I-VII, p. 171-206: "Preservation of Type" (p. 171), "Continuity of Principles" (p. 178), "Power of Assimilation" (p. 185), "Logical Sequence" (p. 189), "Anticipation of its Future" (p. 195), "Conservative Action upon its Past" (p. 199), "Chronic Vigour" (p. 203). Quoted sentence, p. 206: "The point to be ascertained is the unity and identity of the idea with itself through all stages of its development from first to last". Ignispedia translation.

    126
  126. Pius XII, Humani generis, § 16.

    127
  127. Mysterium Ecclesiae, § 5.

    128
  128. Mysterium Ecclesiae, § 5.

    129
  129. Pope Francis, apostolic exhortation Evangelii gaudium, 24 November 2013, § 41 and note 45 (French text, vatican.va), citing John XXIII, AAS 54 (1962), p. 792.

    130
  130. Benedict XVI, address to the Roman Curia, 22 December 2005 (French text, vatican.va).

    131
  131. Credo of the People of God, § 5, AAS 60 (1968), p. 435.

    132
  132. Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 89.

    133
  133. Fides et ratio, § 87.

    134
  134. Fidei depositum, I, « Introduction ».

    135
  135. Dei Verbum, § 10.

    136
  136. Final report of the 1985 Synod, I, 5.

    137
  137. Humani generis, § 13.

    138
  138. Credo of the People of God, § 4.

    139
  139. Declaration Christi Ecclesia, 15 December 1979.

    140
  140. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, dean of the College of Cardinals, homily at the Mass pro eligendo Romano Pontifice, Saint Peter's Basilica, 18 April 2005 (French text, vatican.va).

    141
  141. Benedict XVI, address to the Roman Curia, 22 December 2005 (French text, vatican.va).

    142
  142. Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, Declaration of 21 November 1974, § 1-2 (read to the seminarians on 2 December 1974; three concordant full reproductions: Lou Pescadou no. 248, November 2024; La Sainte Ampoule no. 282; Apostle no. 62).

    143 144 145
  143. See above, the section « Ressourcement or Neo-Modernism ».

    146
  144. Dei Verbum, § 10-11.

    147
  145. Vatican II, dogmatic constitution Lumen gentium, 21 November 1964, § 25 (French text, vatican.va).

    148
  146. John XXIII, opening address to the Council, 11 October 1962, AAS 54 (1962), p. 792, French translation taken up by Benedict XVI in his address of 22 December 2005. Original text: « Est enim aliud ipsum depositum Fidei, seu veritates, quae veneranda doctrina nostra continentur, aliud modus, quo eaedem enuntiantur, eodem tamen sensu eademque sententia ».

    149
  147. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, formula of profession of faith to be used « loco formulae Tridentinae et iuramenti antimodernistici », 1967, AAS 59 (1967), p. 1058 ; Ignispedia translation. Original text: « Firmiter quoque amplector et retineo omnia et singula quae circa doctrinam de fide et moribus ab Ecclesia, sive solemni iudicio definita sive ordinario magisterio adserta ac declarata sunt, prout ab ipsa proponuntur ».

    150
  148. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Professio fidei et iusiurandum fidelitatis in suscipiendo officio nomine Ecclesiae exercendo, 9 January 1989, AAS 81 (1989), p. 104-106 (reference given in Ad tuendam fidem, note 1).

    151
  149. Ad tuendam fidem, § 4 A (can. 750 § 2).

    152
  150. Humani generis, § 13.

    153
  151. Letter of 24 July 1966, AAS 58 (1966), p. 659.

    154
  152. J. Maritain, Le Paysan de la Garonne, 1966, chap. 1 ; English translation, 1968, p. 6.

    155
  153. Final report of the 1985 Synod, I, 4. English text: « an ideology characterized by pride in technical advances and a certain immanentism that leads to the idolatry of material goods (so-called consumerism) ».

    156
  154. Address of 22 December 2005. Original Italian text: « Ma ovunque questa interpretazione è stata l'orientamento che ha guidato la recezione del Concilio, è cresciuta una nuova vita e sono maturati frutti nuovi ».

    157
  155. Émile Poulat, Intégrisme et catholicisme intégral, Paris-Tournai, Casterman, 1969 ; see also the article The Modernist Crisis (1893-1914), section devoted to the Sodalitium Pianum.

    158
  156. Benedict XV, Ad beatissimi Apostolorum, 1 November 1914, AAS 6 (1914), p. 577-578 and 610-611.

    159
  157. Address of 17 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 385.

    160
  158. Donum veritatis, § 32.

    161
  159. Pope Francis, address to the participants in the meeting organised by the Pontifical Council for Promoting the New Evangelisation for the 25th anniversary of Fidei depositum, 11 October 2017 (French text, vatican.va), citing the Commonitorium, 23, 1 and 23, 9 ("annis consolidetur, dilatetur tempore, sublimetur aetate"). Original Italian text: "non significa affatto un cambiamento di dottrina".

    162
  160. Fidei depositum, IV.

    163
  161. DH 3043.

    164
  162. Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 639 ; Dei Verbum, § 11.

    165
  163. Lumen gentium, § 25.

    166
  164. Fides et ratio, § 87.

    167
  165. Credo of the People of God, § 4.

    168
  166. John XXIII, 11 October 1962, AAS 54 (1962), p. 792, French translation taken up by Benedict XVI, 22 December 2005. Original text: « oportet ut haec doctrina certa et immutabilis, cui fidele obsequium est praestandum, ea ratione pervestigetur et exponatur, quam tempora postulant nostra ».

    169
  167. Address of 17 September 1946, AAS 38 (1946), p. 385 ; Ignispedia translation (original text quoted above).

    170
  168. Final report of the 1985 Synod, II, A, 4 ; Ignispedia translation based on the English translation. English text: « Men and women saints have always been founts and origins of renewal in the most difficult circumstances throughout the Church's history. Today we have tremendous need of saints, for whom we must assiduously implore God. »

    171
  169. Saint John Paul II, message to Fr. Pietro Cifuni, superior general of the Rogationists of the Heart of Jesus, for the centenary of the congregation, 16 May 1997, § 6; Ignispedia translation (the French page of vatican.va does not contain the text). Original Italian text: "quella santità "nuova e divina", di cui lo Spirito Santo vuole arricchire i cristiani all'alba del terzo millennio".

    172
  170. See the article Saint Annibale Maria di Francia: extraordinary confessor and then ecclesiastical censor of Luisa Piccarreta from 1910 to 1927.

    173
  171. Address of 22 December 2005 (French text, vatican.va). Original Italian text: « il seme buono, pur sviluppandosi lentamente, tuttavia cresce ».

    174

Can’t find your topic?