Pius IX (Pius IX), born Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti at Senigallia, in the Marche, on 13 May 1792, and deceased in the Vatican Apostolic Palace on 7 February 1878, is the pope whose reign lasted longer than any other in the history of the Church: nearly thirty-two years, from 16 June 1846 until his death.[1][2] The Holy See lists him as the 255th successor of Saint Peter, elected after the death of Gregory XVI and followed by Leo XIII.[3]
His pontificate is one of the most dramatic of the modern age. Acclaimed in 1846 as a "liberal pope" who granted amnesty to political prisoners and opened the Papal States to reform, Mastai-Ferretti was overtaken as early as 1848 by the revolutionary wave: the assassination of his minister Pellegrino Rossi, the Roman uprising, his disguised flight to Gaeta, and the proclamation of a Roman Republic shattered the illusion of a throne reconciled with revolution.[4][5] Restored to Rome in 1850 by French bayonets, he henceforth governed as an intransigent pope, determined to defend the freedom of the Church against states that claimed to absorb it.[6]
This long reign was also a doctrinal summit. Pius IX proclaimed the dogma of the Immaculate Conception on 8 December 1854, condemned modern errors in the encyclical Quanta cura with the Syllabus in 1864, and convoked the First Vatican Council, which defined papal infallibility on 18 July 1870.[7][8][9] Two months later, the Italian army entered Rome: Pius IX lost the thousand-year temporal power of the popes and declared himself a "prisoner of the Vatican".[10][11]
The liberal opinion that had exalted him in 1846 and then reviled him after 1848 — the European liberal press, historians of the Risorgimento — saw in him a pope overtaken and defeated by his century.[12][13] Catholic memory retained something else: a man of ardent Marian piety, of famous humor even in captivity, who transformed political defeat into spiritual witness. Beatified by John Paul II on 3 September 2000, on the same day as John XXIII, he is now honored as Blessed.[14][15]
Why Does Pius IX Matter?
The Longest Pontificate in History
Pius IX reigned for thirty-one years, seven months, and twenty-two days, from 16 June 1846 to 7 February 1878[16]: this is, in verified terms, the longest pontificate in the history of the papacy, the only one to exceed the twenty-five jubilee years that Roman tradition had attributed to Saint Peter alone - hence the saying, "the years of Peter shall not be seen again."[17][18] Pius IX was the first to pass them, celebrating his papal jubilee in 1871 and then his thirtieth anniversary in 1876.[19]
That exceptional duration gave him time to imprint his mark on the entire Church: he created 123 cardinals in twenty-three consistories[20], canonized fifty-two saints[21], beatified two hundred and twenty-two servants of God[22], proclaimed three new Doctors of the Church[23], and published thirty-eight encyclicals[24]. No pope had governed so long; none had watched his world give way so completely beneath his feet.
From "Liberal Pope" to "Intransigent Pope"
The figure of Pius IX sums up the nineteenth-century divorce between the Church and liberal revolution. Elected in the hope of a Catholicism reconciled with modern liberties, he embodied for two years the dream of a "neo-Guelph" Catholic liberalism — the idea, carried by thinkers such as Vincenzo Gioberti, of an Italy unified under the moral presidency of the pope.[25] Then the revolution of 1848 showed him that the forces he had encouraged were aiming, beyond reforms, at the end of papal sovereignty itself and Italian unity under Turin.
Out of this trauma emerged the Pius IX remembered by history: the pope who, in the Syllabus of 1864, rejected the idea that "the Roman Pontiff can and should reconcile and adapt himself to progress, liberalism and modern civilization."[26] This refusal was not political nostalgia: it was the assertion that the Church cannot be absorbed by the State or submit revealed truth to the spirit of the age. The whole second half of his reign unfolds this line, up to the First Vatican Council.
The Pope Who Lost Temporal Power
Finally, Pius IX is the pope under whom the temporal power of the popes, more than eleven centuries old, collapsed. When the army of the Kingdom of Italy broke through at the Porta Pia on 20 September 1870, the Papal States disappeared and Rome became the capital of unified Italy.[27] Pius IX rejected the Law of Guarantees offered by the new regime, enclosed himself in the Vatican, and bequeathed to his successors the Roman Question - resolved only in 1929 by the Lateran Accords.[28]
This defeat, experienced as a martyrdom, paradoxically transformed the papacy. Stripped of its legions, the pope gained in moral and spiritual authority what he lost in territory. The "prisoner of the Vatican" became a universal figure of conscience, and the council that defined his infallibility sealed, at the very moment he lost Rome, the full recognition of his spiritual primacy.[29]
Principal Sources
Ecclesial and Biographical Notices
The official list of the Holy See places Mastai-Ferretti among the sovereign pontiffs under the name Pius IX, with a pontificate from 16 June 1846 to 7 February 1878.[30] The standard English-language synthesis remains Michael Ott's article in the 1911 Catholic Encyclopedia, which retraces his career, election, the 1848 revolution, the restoration, and the struggle against Italian unity.[31] The Encyclopaedia Britannica confirms the chronology and emphasizes the shift from the "liberal pope" to doctrinal firmness.[32]
Modern historiography is dominated by Giacomo Martina's major biography, Pio IX (Gregorian University, three volumes, 1974-1990), long regarded as the most complete scientific study, and by Frank J. Coppa's English synthesis, Pope Pius IX: Crusader in a Secular Age (1979).[33][34] For the person of the pope and his spirituality, the positio for the beatification cause, assembled throughout the twentieth century, gathers testimonies and archival documents.[35]
Sources for the Roman Question and Beatification
The doctrinal acts are preserved and accessible: the bull Ineffabilis Deus (8 December 1854), the encyclical Quanta cura and the Syllabus (8 December 1864), the dogmatic constitution Pastor aeternus (18 July 1870), and the encyclical Etsi multa against the Kulturkampf (21 November 1873).[36][37][38][39] For the fall of temporal power, the Italian Law of Guarantees of 13 May 1871 and its rejection by the pope are documented in the diplomatic correspondence of the period.[40]
Finally, the beatification homily delivered by John Paul II on 3 September 2000 is the magisterial source that fixes the spiritual meaning of the pontificate, presenting Pius IX as "an example of unconditional adherence to the immutable deposit of revealed truths."[41]
From Giovanni Mastai-Ferretti to the Election of 1846
A Noble Birth in Senigallia
Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti was born at Senigallia, an Adriatic port in the papal Marche, on 13 May 1792, the ninth child of Count Girolamo Mastai-Ferretti and Countess Caterina Solazzi.[42][43] The family belonged to the small provincial nobility, deeply attached to the Apostolic See. At baptism he received a long series of names - Giovanni Maria Battista Pietro Pellegrino Isidoro - according to the usage of Italian noble families.[44]
Educated by the Piarists at the College of Saint Michael in Volterra, the young Mastai received there a Marian devotion that would never leave him and that would one day shine forth in the proclamation of the Immaculate Conception.[45]
Epilepsy and a Thwarted Vocation
Mastai-Ferretti's vocation almost broke against illness. As an adolescent, he suffered from epileptic seizures that initially barred him from an ecclesiastical career: Pius VII, when petitioned, refused to admit him to the papal noble guard because of these attacks.[46][47] The young man turned to prayer and believed he obtained lasting improvement during a pilgrimage to Loreto.
With his health restored, he was ordained priest on 10 April 1819, with the dispensation that he celebrate Mass in the presence of another priest as a precaution - a measure soon abandoned in practice.[48] This first trial marked the future pope: beneath the appearances of his office, he retained the sense of a fragile man carried by Providence.
From Spoleto to Imola: the Pastoral Bishop
The young priest first distinguished himself by charity. From 1823 to 1825, he accompanied as auditor the apostolic mission to Chile and Peru, his first experience of a world beyond Europe.[49] Back in Rome, he directed the San Michele hospice, a large charitable institution for children and the elderly.
Appointed Archbishop of Spoleto in 1827, he showed moderation during the revolutionary disturbances of 1831, obtaining clemency for insurgents and organizing relief after an earthquake.[50] Transferred to the see of Imola in 1832, in the turbulent Legations, he spent fourteen years in intense pastoral work - visits, catechesis, charity - which earned him a reputation as an open and benevolent bishop. Gregory XVI created him cardinal in pectore — in secret, without public announcement of the name — on 23 December 1839, published on 14 December 1840.[51][52]
The Conclave of 1846
After the death of Gregory XVI on 1 June 1846, a brief but decisive conclave opened. Two lines faced one another: the intransigent zelante line, embodied by Cardinal Luigi Lambruschini, secretary of state of the deceased pope, and a moderate opening to the reforms demanded by Italian opinion. Cardinal Mastai-Ferretti, reputed to be kindly and liberal in temperament, appeared as the man of conciliation.[53]
He was elected on 16 June 1846, on the fourth ballot, and took the name Pius IX in memory of Pius VII, whom he venerated. The rumor of an Austrian veto against Lambruschini, arriving too late, circulated for a long time without decisive proof.[54] Crowned on 21 June 1846, the new pope, aged fifty-four, was greeted by an unprecedented wave of enthusiasm: all Italy thought it saw in him the pope of the future.
The "Liberal Pope" of the First Years
The Amnesty of July 1846
Pius IX's first gesture electrified the peninsula. On 16 July 1846, less than a month after his election, he proclaimed a general amnesty for political prisoners and exiles in the Papal States - more than a thousand people were pardoned.[55][56] The effect was immediate and immense: cities were illuminated, hymns to Pio Nono were sung, and the pope became, in the words of historians, "the most popular man in the Italian peninsula."[57]
The Catholic Encyclopedia, however, notes the naivety of the gesture: it did not occur to the pope "that many of the pardoned political offenders would use their liberty to further their revolutionary ideas."[58] The amnesty that made him an idol unknowingly prepared the revolution that would drive him out.
Reforms and National Enthusiasm
The reforms followed one another: creation of an advisory Council of State, a civic guard, relaxation of censorship and relative freedom of the press, a municipal council for Rome, and the development of railways and the telegraph, held back under Gregory XVI — the phrase attributed to him, "roads to hell," being a legend without documentary attestation (see the dossier Gregory XVI).[59][60] For Italian patriots, the reforming pope seemed capable of leading the national movement against Austria.
"Blessed be the great God, whose right hand has drawn from the treasury of his gifts a Pius to give to our age." — patriotic verses sung in honor of Pio Nono in 1847[61]
This enthusiasm rested on a misunderstanding. Pius IX wanted to reform the administration of his States and improve the condition of his subjects; liberals and nationalists expected him to bless war against Catholic Austria and Italian unity under a constitutional monarchy. The two projects were opposed at their root.
The Fundamental Statute of 1848
Pressure rose with the revolutionary wave that set Europe ablaze in the spring of 1848. On 14 March 1848, Pius IX granted the Papal States a Fundamental Statute, a genuine constitution with two chambers and a lay government, while reserving to the Sacred College a right of veto in spiritual matters.[62] For a theocratic state, the concession was considerable.
But it could not satisfy revolutionaries who wanted national war and the end of clerical government. The trap closed: having become the head of a constitutional state, the pope was summoned to march with revolutionary Italy against the Catholic Habsburg Empire.
1848: Revolution, Rossi's Assassination, and the Flight to Gaeta
The Allocution of 29 April 1848
The breaking point was the war against Austria. When the Milan uprising and the Piedmontese war drew part of the papal troops northward, Pius IX understood that they wanted to make the head of Christendom a belligerent in a fratricidal war between Catholic nations. On 29 April 1848, in a famous consistorial allocution, he solemnly declared that, as common father of all the faithful, he could not declare war on Catholic Austria.[63][64]
That allocution dispelled at once the mirage of the national pope. In the eyes of the patriots, Pius IX had betrayed the Italian cause; his popularity collapsed as quickly as it had risen. Revolutionary Rome slid into agitation.
The Assassination of Pellegrino Rossi
To govern in the storm, Pius IX called to the head of the ministry a statesman of the first rank, Pellegrino Rossi, a jurist and economist rallied to Catholicism, who favored ordered modernization. His firmness earned him the hatred of extremist factions. On 15 November 1848, as he was going to the opening of the chambers at the Palace of the Chancellery, Rossi was assassinated by a knife thrust to the throat, before a crowd that made no move to defend him.[65][66]
The murder unleashed the riot. The next day, 16 November, insurgents besieged the Quirinal Palace, the pope's residence, killed one of his prelates, and turned their rifles toward the papal windows. Pius IX was now a prisoner in his own palace.
The Disguised Flight to Gaeta
On 24 November 1848, with the help of the French and Bavarian ambassadors, Pius IX escaped from the Quirinal disguised as an ordinary priest and, in a nocturnal flight, reached Neapolitan territory.[67][68] He took refuge at Gaeta, in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, where part of the cardinals joined him. The capital of Christendom was in the hands of revolution.
"In human affairs, one must be content to do the best one can, and for the rest abandon oneself to Providence." — Pius IX, cited by John Paul II in the beatification homily of 3 September 2000[69]
This saying, later taken up by John Paul II, sums up the interior attitude of the exiled pope: politically powerless, he abandoned himself to God. It was at Gaeta, in trial, that his decision matured to consult the worldwide episcopate on the definition of the Immaculate Conception.[70]
The Roman Republic
In Rome, the revolutionary assembly abolished temporal power and proclaimed, on 9 February 1849, the Roman Republic, soon governed by a triumvirate dominated by Giuseppe Mazzini, with the military support of Garibaldi.[71][72] From Gaeta, Pius IX excommunicated the usurpers and appealed to the Catholic powers for the restoration of his sovereignty.
The Roman Republic, which secularized Church property and overturned the old order, lasted only a few months. Its existence was enough to convince Pius IX that revolutionary liberalism aimed, under cover of reform, at the annihilation of the Church within the State.
The Return and the Great Turning Point
French Troops and General Oudinot
Four Catholic powers - France, Austria, Spain, and Naples - answered the pope's appeal. In the end, it was the French expeditionary corps of General Oudinot, sent by the Second Republic of Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte, that decided the matter. After a difficult siege against Garibaldi's defenders, Rome fell on 3 July 1849 and the Roman Republic collapsed.[73][74]
A paradox thus inaugurated the second part of the reign: it was a republic, France, that restored the pope's temporal power, and a French garrison that would protect Rome until 1870. The fate of the papacy now depended on the policy of Napoleon III.
The Return to Rome in 1850
Pius IX did not return immediately. He waited until order was fully restored and came back to Rome only on 12 April 1850, after sixteen months of exile.[75][76] The man who returned was no longer the reforming pope of 1846: according to the phrase of the Catholic Encyclopedia, he returned "no longer a political liberal."[77]
Marking the rupture symbolically, he left the Quirinal Palace, scene of the 1848 uprising, and henceforth fixed his residence in the Vatican.[78] The great lesson he drew from the ordeal was doctrinal as much as political: the Church cannot make a pact with the principles that armed the revolution against her.
Cardinal Antonelli and the Government of the States
Temporal government was entrusted to Cardinal Giacomo Antonelli, secretary of state from 1848 until his death in 1876, a skillful diplomat and resolute conservative.[79] Antonelli concentrated civil authority and pursued a rigid policy of defending papal sovereignty, at the cost of an administration often judged immobile and of postponed reforms.
This conservative restoration fed the hostility of European liberals, who made the Papal States the symbol of political backwardness. The contrast was striking between the doctrinal firmness of the reign and the growing fragility of its temporal base.
The Mortara Affair (1858)
No episode damaged the image of Pius IX in Europe more than the Mortara affair. On 23 June 1858, the papal police removed from Bologna Edgardo Mortara, a six-year-old Jewish child, on the grounds that a Christian servant had secretly baptized him while he was gravely ill.[80][81] According to canon law and the law of the Papal States, a baptized person could not be raised in Judaism: the child was taken from his parents and entrusted to the Church.
The affair provoked international indignation, from liberals and Jews alike, and gave opponents of temporal power a powerful propaganda argument.[82] Pius IX, attached to the child whom he had raised under his protection, never yielded; Edgardo Mortara became a priest and defended the pope's decision all his life. The episode remains a stumbling block in the beatification dossier: it illustrates the frontal collision between the confessional law of a dying theocratic state and modern sensitivity to the rights of the family and of conscience. But the dossier does not end with the indignation of 1858: Edgardo himself, grown to adulthood, freely chose to remain Catholic, was ordained priest, and declared himself grateful and happy with his life in the Church.[83] Conducted in full knowledge of this episode — the cause was long slowed by this controversy — the beatification succeeded under John Paul II on 3 September 2000: that is the fact.[84] To see in it the act of a pope bound by the canon law of his time, according to which a baptized child had to receive a Catholic education, and not a personal cruelty, is the interpretation of the author of the present article: neither the Church nor the homily of John Paul II formulates any thesis on the Mortara affair.
The Great Doctrinal Acts of the Pontificate
The pontificate of Pius IX is marked by three major doctrinal acts, each of which has its own specialized Ignispedia article. Their meaning for the reign is recalled here without reopening the detailed treatment given elsewhere.
The Immaculate Conception (1854)
On 8 December 1854, by the bull Ineffabilis Deus, Pius IX defined as a dogma of faith that the Virgin Mary had been, "from the first instant of her conception, preserved immune from all stain of original sin."[85] It was the first dogma defined by a pope on his own authority, after consultation of the whole episcopate - a foreshadowing of the definition of infallibility sixteen years later. Four years afterward, at Lourdes, the apparition would present herself to Bernadette as "the Immaculate Conception", confirming the Roman definition in Catholic eyes.
Detailed article: The dogma of the Immaculate Conception (1854)
Quanta cura and the Syllabus (1864)
On 8 December 1864, exactly ten years after the Immaculate Conception, Pius IX published the encyclical Quanta cura, accompanied by a Syllabus listing eighty modern errors: pantheism, rationalism, indifferentism, socialism, communism, separation of Church and State, and the claim of the State to monopolize education.[86][87] The last article, which condemned the idea of a reconciliation between the pope and "progress, liberalism, and modern civilization," caused scandal and was often caricatured outside its technical meaning.
Detailed article: The Syllabus of Pius IX (1864)
The First Vatican Council and Infallibility (1869-1870)
Convoked by the bull Aeterni Patris of 29 June 1868, the First Vatican Council opened on 8 December 1869 before some seven hundred Fathers. On 18 July 1870, the constitution Pastor aeternus defined the primacy of jurisdiction of the pope and his infallibility when he teaches ex cathedra on faith and morals.[88] The Franco-Prussian War broke out the next day; the withdrawal of the French garrison sealed Rome's fate, and the council, interrupted, would never be formally closed.
Detailed articles: The First Vatican Council (1869-1870) and Papal infallibility
The Roman Question and the End of Temporal Power
Castelfidardo and the Loss of the Marche
Italian unity was built at the expense of the Papal States. After the annexation of Romagna in 1859-1860, Piedmontese troops invaded the Marche and Umbria. On 18 September 1860, the small papal army gathered by the French general de Lamoriciere - including the Papal Zouaves, Catholic volunteers from all over Europe - was crushed at Castelfidardo.[89][90] The pope retained only Latium around Rome, protected by the French garrison.
Pius IX answered the annexations with solemn protests and the excommunication of the despoilers, without being able to prevent anything. Temporal power was reduced year by year to the city of Rome alone and its immediate surroundings.
The Capture of Rome (20 September 1870)
The final trial came with the fall of Napoleon III. The French defeat at Sedan on 2 September 1870 deprived Rome of its protection: the French garrison withdrew. On 20 September 1870, the army of the Kingdom of Italy opened a breach in the wall near the Porta Pia and entered Rome; Pius IX ordered a purely symbolic resistance to make clear that he yielded to force.[91][92] A plebiscite ratified the annexation, and Rome became the capital of Italy.
Detailed article: The capture of Rome in 1870
Thus ended eleven centuries of temporal power of the popes, opened by the donation of Pepin the Short in the eighth century. For Pius IX, the loss was not merely political: it called into question the very freedom of the Apostolic See, which he believed was guaranteed by its territorial independence.
The Law of Guarantees and the "Non possumus"
The new Italian State tried to organize coexistence. The Law of Guarantees of 13 May 1871 recognized the inviolability of the pope's person, sovereign honors, free use of the Vatican, the Lateran, and Castel Gandolfo, and an annual endowment of more than three million lire.[93][94] But this law was a unilateral act of the Italian State, revocable, not a treaty recognizing true sovereignty.
Pius IX rejected it entirely, refused the endowment, and opposed every negotiation with his famous "non possumus" - "we cannot": the pope cannot renounce rights that do not belong to him personally but to the universal Church.[95] This refusal founded the Roman Question, which would poison relations between Italy and the Holy See until the Lateran Accords of 1929.
The "Prisoner of the Vatican"
From 1870 onward, Pius IX considered himself "a prisoner in the Vatican" and never crossed the threshold of the palace again, refusing to appear in a Rome he regarded as occupied.[96] His successors would maintain this attitude until Pius XI. By the encyclical Respicientes ea omnia of 1 November 1870, the pope excommunicated all those who had ordered or carried out the spoliation of Rome — without naming King Victor Emmanuel II in person[97] — and forbade Italian Catholics, through the formula non expedit ("it is not expedient" to take part), to take part in the political life of the new kingdom.
Far from weakening the papacy, this voluntary captivity increased its aura. Deprived of his States, the pope became a moral witness whose spiritual authority, now detached from any territorial interest, radiated over the whole Catholic world.
The Pope Facing the Modern World
According to the reproduction published by the author himself, Pius IX addressed on 17 May 1877 to Constantin James a brief of encouragement for his work Du darwinisme ou l'homme-singe (1877). In it the pope describes Darwinism as a "tissue of fables" to which "alienation from God and the leaning toward materialism" seek support, and judges that such "fancies," because they "borrow the mask of science," must be "refuted by true science"[98]. In it he congratulates the author for having, by a book judged so opportune, deserved well of religion as of his brethren, and concludes with the apostolic blessing. This brief, an encouragement addressed to an author and not a dogmatic definition on evolution, attests the attitude of Pius IX toward Darwinism[99].
Bismarck's Kulturkampf
In the last years of his reign, Pius IX faced the great anti-Catholic offensive of the unified German Empire. From 1871 onward, Chancellor Otto von Bismarck launched the Kulturkampf ("struggle for civilization"): the May Laws of 1873 subjected clerical formation to the State, expelled the Jesuits, suppressed dioceses, and imprisoned recalcitrant bishops and priests.[100][101]
Pius IX responded with the encyclical Etsi multa of 21 November 1873, denouncing the persecution of the Church in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy.[102] The Kulturkampf would indeed fail under Leo XIII, who negotiated the gradual repeal of the May Laws.
The Restoration of Catholic Hierarchies
While Latin Europe was becoming secularized, Pius IX extended the Church in the English-speaking and missionary world. On 29 September 1850, by the bull Universalis Ecclesiae, he restored the Catholic hierarchy in England, with an archbishopric of Westminster and twelve dioceses - a gesture that provoked a fierce Protestant reaction but marked the renewal of English Catholicism.[103] In 1853, he similarly restored the hierarchy in the Netherlands.
He multiplied concordats - Spain (1851), Austria (1855), and various Latin American states - and supported missionary expansion in Asia, Africa, and Oceania. The Church that lost Rome gained the world: under Pius IX the globalization of Catholicism that would characterize the following century began to take shape.
A Doctor and Devotee of the Universal Church
The pope crowned this doctrinal zeal with acts of piety on the scale of the whole Church. On 23 September 1856, he extended the feast of the Sacred Heart to the entire Church; on 8 December 1870, in the midst of upheaval, he proclaimed Saint Joseph patron of the universal Church.[104][105] He proclaimed three new Doctors of the Church: Saint Hilary of Poitiers (1851), Saint Alphonsus Liguori (1871), and Saint Francis de Sales (1877).[106]
These decisions, taken at the very moment when the pope was losing his States, reveal his deep conviction: the true power of the See of Peter is not territorial but spiritual, and it is through doctrine, worship, and holiness that the Church passes through revolutions.
Pius IX the Man: Piety, Charm, and Suffering
Marian Devotion as the Thread of a Life
If one trait unifies Mastai-Ferretti's existence, it is devotion to the Virgin Mary, received at the College of Volterra, unfolded in his preaching as bishop, and sealed in the definition of the Immaculate Conception.[107] The proclamation of 1854 was not the abstract act of a jurist: it was the culmination of a personal piety that made the Mother of God the refuge of the pope in all his trials.
"He was an example of unconditional adherence to the immutable deposit of revealed truths." — Saint John Paul II, beatification homily for Pius IX, 3 September 2000[108]
The Humor of Pio Nono
Pius IX left the memory of a man of quick wit and famous humor, which did not abandon him in defeat or captivity. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes his "charity toward the poor, kindness of heart, and wit," which made him deeply lovable.[109]
This mixture of doctrinal gravity and personal cheerfulness explains the lasting attachment of the faithful to Pio Nono. Behind the intransigent pope of the documents, witnesses knew a warm, accessible man, capable of joking about his own misfortune.
Serenity in Trial
The pontificate of Pius IX was, in John Paul II's words, "truly not easy": the pope "had to suffer much in carrying out his mission."[110] Loved and then hated, praised and then slandered, stripped of his States and mocked by the liberal press, he drew from abandonment to Providence a peace his adversaries did not understand.
"He was deeply loved, but also hated and slandered. Yet precisely in the midst of these contradictions the light of his virtues shone more brightly." — Saint John Paul II, beatification homily, 3 September 2000[111]
It was this supernatural serenity in the heart of defeat that the Church recognized as holiness in beatifying him: not political success, which escaped him, but the fidelity of a shepherd to his mission amid the collapse of his world.
Death and Beatification
The Death of 7 February 1878
Pius IX died in the Vatican Apostolic Palace on 7 February 1878, at nearly eighty-six years of age, carried off by the crisis that ended the longest pontificate in history.[112][113] He died as the "prisoner of the Vatican," without having seen again a Rome he regarded as occupied, but surrounded by the veneration of the Catholic world.
Only a few weeks earlier his great adversary, King Victor Emmanuel II, had died: the closeness of the two deaths seemed to contemporaries to close symbolically an epochal confrontation between the papacy and the new Italy.
The Funeral and Nocturnal Transfer
In accordance with his wishes, Pius IX was to rest not in the Vatican grottoes but in the basilica of Saint Lawrence Outside the Walls, which he loved. The solemn transfer of his body, during the night of 12-13 July 1881, under Leo XIII, turned dramatic: an anticlerical crowd tried to seize the coffin from the procession in order to throw it into the Tiber, and the intervention of the carabinieri was needed to protect the remains of the deceased pope.[114] The incident showed the violence of the passions that the Roman Question had left in the city.
Beatification by John Paul II (2000)
The beatification cause, opened as early as 1907 under Pius X and long slowed by political controversies and by the Mortara affair, reached its conclusion at the threshold of the Jubilee of the year 2000. After the recognition as a miracle of the unexplained healing of a French nun — favorable opinion of the medical board on 15 January 1986, definitive decree in December 1999[115] —, John Paul II beatified Pius IX on 3 September 2000, together with John XXIII - a pairing deliberately chosen for two popes who seemed opposed in everything but who, according to John Paul II, were united by the same holiness.[116] The feast of Blessed Pius IX is fixed on 7 February.
His body, canonically recognized on the occasion of the beatification, now rests in a glass coffin at Saint Lawrence Outside the Walls, where the faithful come to pray before the pope of the Immaculate Conception and the First Vatican Council.[117]
Timeline
- 13 May 1792Birth in SenigalliaMarche, Papal States
Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti is born into a family of the small papal nobility.[118]
- 10 April 1819Priestly ordinationdespite youthful epilepsy
After a vocation hindered by illness, Mastai-Ferretti is ordained priest.[119]
- 1832Bishop of Imolafourteen years of pastoral government
Transferred from Spoleto to Imola, he earns a reputation as a benevolent and reforming bishop.[120]
- 16 June 1846Election to the pontificatehe takes the name Pius IX
Elected after the death of Gregory XVI, he is crowned on 21 June.[121]
- 16 July 1846General amnestythe 'liberal pope'
The amnesty for political prisoners makes Pius IX the most popular man in Italy.[122]
- 14 March 1848Fundamental Statutea constitution for the Papal States
Pius IX gives his States a constitution, without satisfying the nationalists.[123]
- 15 November 1848Assassination of Pellegrino Rossibeginning of the Roman uprising
The pope's minister is stabbed; Rome slides into revolution.[124]
- 24 November 1848Flight to Gaetathe pope disguised as a priest
Pius IX escapes from the Quirinal and takes refuge in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies.[125]
- 9 February 1849Roman RepublicMazzini and Garibaldi
The revolution abolishes temporal power and proclaims a republic in Rome.[126]
- 12 April 1850Return to Romethe great conservative turning point
Restored by French troops, the pope returns "no longer a political liberal."[127]
- 8 December 1854Dogma of the Immaculate Conceptionbull Ineffabilis Deus
Pius IX defines the first dogma proclaimed by papal authority alone.[128]
- 23 June 1858Mortara affairinternational indignation
The removal of Edgardo Mortara becomes a symbol for opponents of temporal power.[129]
- 18 September 1860Defeat at Castelfidardoloss of the Marche and Umbria
The papal army and the Zouaves are crushed by Piedmont.[130]
- 8 December 1864Quanta cura and Syllabuscondemnation of modern errors
The pope lists eighty errors of the age and refuses to compromise with them.[131]
- 8 December 1869Opening of Vatican Iabout 700 council Fathers
The first ecumenical council since Trent opens at the Vatican.[132]
- 18 July 1870Pastor aeternusdefinition of papal infallibility
The council defines the primacy and infallibility of the pope.[133]
- 20 September 1870Capture of Romeend of temporal power
The Italian army enters through the Porta Pia; the Papal States disappear.[134]
- 13 May 1871Law of Guarantees rejectedthe 'non possumus'
Pius IX refuses the unilateral Italian act and declares himself prisoner of the Vatican.[135]
- 21 November 1873Encyclical Etsi multaagainst the Kulturkampf
The pope denounces the persecution of the Church in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy.[136]
- 7 February 1878Death in the Vaticanthe longest pontificate in history
Pius IX dies after nearly thirty-two years of reign, as prisoner of the Vatican.[137]
- 3 September 2000Beatificationby Saint John Paul II
Pius IX is declared blessed on the same day as John XXIII; feast day on 7 February.[138]
Further Reading
- Pope Gregory XVI — Pius IX's predecessor, the last monk-pope, hostile to railways and modern liberties.
- Pope Leo XIII — Pius IX's successor, who adjusted the line toward the modern world and negotiated the end of the Kulturkampf.
- The dogma of the Immaculate Conception (1854) — defined by Pius IX, the summit of his Marian devotion.
- The Syllabus of Pius IX (1864) — the catalogue of modern errors condemned by Quanta cura.
- The First Vatican Council (1869-1870) — the council of Pius IX, which defined papal infallibility.
- Papal infallibility — the doctrine defined under his pontificate by Pastor aeternus.
- The capture of Rome in 1870 — the end of the temporal power of the popes.
- The Papal States — the thousand-year temporal territory lost under Pius IX.
Notes and Sources
Notes and References
Holy See, Annuario Pontificio, official list of the sovereign pontiffs (printed edition: the Holy See publishes no numbered list online on vatican.va): Pius IX (Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti) appears there as the 255th pope, pontificate from 16 June 1846 to 7 February 1878. Taken up online by EWTN: "the 255th pope". URL: https://ewtn.co.uk/article-the-remarkable-life-and-papacy-of-blessed-pope-pius-ix/. See also the catholic-hierarchy.org entry, "Blessed Pius IX (Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti)". Variant: the Simple English Wikipedia ranks him as the "256th Pope" (URL: https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX). The one-unit gap corresponds to Pope-elect Stephen II, listed as Stephen II until the 1961 edition and then removed from the official list, but counted by some lists.
1 30 51 121Michael Ott, "Pope Pius IX", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 12, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1911; New Advent transcription: birth at Senigallia on 13 May 1792, youthful illness, ordination on 10 April 1819, Archbishop of Spoleto then Bishop of Imola, cardinal in 1839-1840, election of 16 June 1846, amnesty of July 1846, assassination of Rossi on 15 November 1848, flight to Gaeta on 24 November 1848, return to Rome on 12 April 1850 "no longer a political liberal", Cardinal Antonelli secretary of state until 1876, Castelfidardo (18 September 1860), Quanta cura and Syllabus, Vatican I, loss of Rome, Law of Guarantees refused, Kulturkampf, death on 7 February 1878. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12134b.htm.
2 4 18 19 31 47 50 56 58 66 67 72 74 75 77 79 89 104 109 120 124 125 127 130French Wikipedia, article "Pie IX" (consulted June 2026): Giovanni Maria Mastai-Ferretti born on 13 May 1792 at Senigallia, ordination on 10 April 1819, Archbishop of Spoleto (1827) then Bishop of Imola (1832), cardinal on 23 December 1839 (published 14 December 1840), conclave opened on 16 June 1846, coronation on 21 June, amnesty of 16 July 1846, Fundamental Statute of 14 March 1848, allocution of 29 April 1848, assassination of Rossi on 15 November 1848, flight to Gaeta on 24 November, Roman Republic of 9 February 1849, return to Rome on 12 April 1850, Mortara affair (23 June 1858), Quanta cura and Syllabus (8 December 1864), First Vatican Council (8 December 1869 - 18 July 1870), capture of Rome on 20 September 1870, Law of Guarantees of 13 May 1871, death on 7 February 1878, burial at Saint Lawrence Outside the Walls, beatification on 3 September 2000. URL: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_IX.
3 5 15 28 40 42 52 55 59 62 63 65 71 73 76 80 90 93 113 118 122 123 126Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Pius IX": election of 1846, liberal reforms and initial popularity, allocution of 29 April 1848 refusing war against Austria, conservative turn after 1848, Syllabus of 1864, First Vatican Council, loss of temporal power; the pontificate presented as the passage from "liberal pope" to doctrinal firmness. URL: https://www.britannica.com/biography/Pius-IX.
6 12 25 32 53 60 64Pius IX, bull Ineffabilis Deus, 8 December 1854, defining as a dogma of faith that the Blessed Virgin Mary was, from the first instant of her conception, preserved immune from all stain of original sin, by a singular grace in view of the merits of Christ. Standard text of Marian magisterium, taken up in Denzinger. See the detailed dossier: Ignispedia article on the dogma of the Immaculate Conception.
7 36 85 128Pius IX, encyclical Quanta cura, 8 December 1864, condemning modern errors (naturalism, indifferentism, socialism, communism, the claim of the State to absolute sovereignty); accompanied by the Syllabus complectens praecipuos nostrae aetatis errores, listing eighty erroneous propositions. See the Ignispedia dossier on the Syllabus.
8 37 86 131First Vatican Council, dogmatic constitution Pastor aeternus, 18 July 1870, defining the primacy of jurisdiction of the Roman Pontiff and his infallibility when he teaches ex cathedra on faith and morals; council convoked by the bull Aeterni Patris of 29 June 1868 and opened on 8 December 1869 before about 700 Fathers. See the Ignispedia dossiers on the First Vatican Council and papal infallibility.
9 29 38 88 132 133Capture of Rome, 20 September 1870: after the withdrawal of the French garrison following the defeat at Sedan, the army of the Kingdom of Italy opened a breach near the Porta Pia; Pius IX ordered symbolic resistance before capitulation. Annexation ratified by plebiscite; Rome became capital of Italy. See the Ignispedia dossier on the capture of Rome in 1870.
10 27 91 134English Wikipedia, article "Pope Pius IX": full name Giovanni Maria Battista Pietro Pellegrino Isidoro Mastai-Ferretti, birth on 13 May 1792, refusal of the noble guard by Pius VII because of epilepsy, ordination on 10 April 1819, mission to Chile and Peru (1823-1825), cardinal in 1839-1840, election on 16 June 1846, pontificate of nearly 32 years (the longest verified), 122 cardinals according to the biographical notice — whereas the detailed list "Cardinals created by Pius IX" on the same site counts 123 in 23 consistories, the figure retained here after Miranda, 52 saints canonized, 38 encyclicals, move from the Quirinal to the Vatican, Mortara affair (1858), restoration of the hierarchy in England (29 September 1850) and the Netherlands (1853), Kulturkampf (1872-1878), capture of Rome on 20 September 1870, Law of Guarantees of 13 May 1871 refused, "prisoner of the Vatican", excommunication of Victor Emmanuel II, death on 7 February 1878, transfer of the body to Saint Lawrence Outside the Walls in 1881 and attempt to throw the coffin into the Tiber, beatification on 3 September 2000. URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX.
11 17 43 44 46 48 49 54 57 68 78 81 82 92 94 96 100 103 106 112 114 119 129 137Frank J. Coppa, Pope Pius IX: Crusader in a Secular Age, Twayne Publishers, Boston, 1979: standard English-language synthesis on the pontificate of Pius IX and his confrontation with the liberal century.
13 34Saint John Paul II, homily for the beatification of Pius IX, John XXIII, and three other servants of the Gospel, Saint Peter's Square, 3 September 2000: "Faced with the turbulent events of his time, he was an example of unconditional adherence to the immutable deposit of revealed truths"; "His very long pontificate was truly not easy and he had to suffer much in carrying out his mission"; "He was deeply loved, but also hated and slandered. Yet precisely in the midst of these contradictions the light of his virtues shone more brightly." Full text on vatican.va. URL: https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/fr/homilies/2000/documents/hf_jp-ii_hom_20000903_beatification.html.
14 35 41 69 84 108 110 111 116 138From 16 June 1846 to 7 February 1878: 31 years (→ 16 June 1877), 7 months (→ 16 January 1878), 22 days (→ 7 February), in exclusive calendar difference. Counting both the day of election and that of death gives 23 days: this second mode of counting explains the gap with notices giving 23 days. EWTN retains 22 days: "31 years, seven months, and 22 days (June 16, 1846–Feb. 7, 1878)". URL: https://ewtn.co.uk/article-the-remarkable-life-and-papacy-of-blessed-pope-pius-ix/. The English-language list of popes likewise totals 31 years and 236 days. URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_popes.
16Salvador Miranda, The Cardinals of the Holy Roman Church (Florida International University), "Consistories for the creation of Cardinals — 19th Century (1800-1903)", summary table: "Pius IX (1846-1878) — created 123 cardinals", with the nominal list of the 23 consistories. URL: https://cardinals.fiu.edu/consistories-xix.htm.
20English Wikipedia, article "Pope Pius IX" (consulted October 2026): "Pope Pius IX canonized 52 saints during his pontificate" — including the Martyrs of Japan (8 June 1862), Josaphat Kuntsevych (29 June 1867) and Nicholas Pieck (29 June 1867). URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX. Concordant count (checked de visu in session) in an independent ranking: "Pope Pius IX (1846-1878) - 52 saints", The Scott Smith Blog, "Ranking the Popes" (July 2024). URL: https://www.thescottsmithblog.com/2024/07/ranking-popes-top-25-popes-ranked-by.html.
21English Wikipedia, article "Pope Pius IX" (consulted October 2026): "beatified 222 individuals throughout his papacy" — including Benedict Joseph Labre, Peter Claver and his two predecessors Eugene III and Urban V. URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX. Only secondary source identified in session: no independent corroboration (nor verification against the Acta) was found; the figure is kept as the usual count of the lists, pending better.
22English Wikipedia, article "Pope Pius IX" (consulted October 2026): "named three new Doctors of the Church" — Saint Hilary of Poitiers (1851), Saint Alphonsus Liguori (1871) and Saint Francis de Sales (1877). URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Pius_IX. Only secondary source identified in session: no independent de visu corroboration was found; the trio and its dates are kept as the usual count of the lists, pending better.
23Classic count: 38 encyclicals — historical page of the Leuven Faculty of Theology (KU Leuven): "producing 38 encyclicals during his pontificate" (URL: https://theo.kuleuven.be/apps/christian-ethics/history/pius9.html); Catholic News Service (taken up by the Catholic Herald): Quanta cura, "one of 38 encyclicals issued by Pope Pius IX". Variant: the English-language Wikipedia list announces 41 titles, but its table displays only 39 (numbers 8 and 25 missing — observation of 4 October 2026). URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_encyclicals_of_Pope_Pius_IX.
24Pius IX, Syllabus errorum, 8 December 1864, proposition 80: condemnation of the idea that "the Roman Pontiff can and should reconcile and adapt himself to progress, liberalism and modern civilization." The formula, technical in its doctrinal context, was widely caricatured by the liberal press.
26 87Giacomo Martina, Pio IX, 3 vols., Editrice Pontificia Universita Gregoriana, Rome, 1974-1990: standard scholarly biography, based on Vatican archives, covering the whole pontificate (1846-1878), the revolution of 1848, the Roman Question, the First Vatican Council, and the pope's spirituality.
33Pius IX, encyclical Etsi multa (Etsi multa luctuosa), 21 November 1873, denouncing the persecution of the Catholic Church in Italy, Germany (Bismarck's Kulturkampf, May Laws of 1873), and Switzerland; afterward, the Swiss Federal Council broke relations with the Holy See and expelled the nuncio. Text in collections of the pontifical magisterium.
39 102 136Contre-Reforme catholique, "Le bienheureux Pie IX, pape et docteur de l'Immaculee": biographical and spiritual notice on Mastai-Ferretti's Marian devotion formed at the College of Volterra, the amnesty of 1846, the maturation of the definition of the Immaculate Conception, and the proclamation of Saint Joseph as patron of the Church. Apologetic source used as a bibliographic relay; dated facts cross-checked with Ott and Wikipedia. URL: https://crc-resurrection.org/toute-notre-doctrine/renaissance-catholique/histoire-eglise/19e-siecle/bx-pie-ix.html.
45 61 70 105 107Vittorio Messori, Kidnapped by the Vatican? The Unpublished Memoirs of Edgardo Mortara (Ignatius Press, 2017, English translation): unpublished memoirs of Edgardo Mortara (1851-1940), who became a Catholic priest and declares himself grateful to Providence and happy with his life in the Church ("most grateful to Divine Providence [...] living happily"); reviewed by Kathy Schiffer, National Catholic Register, 14 November 2017. URL: https://www.ncregister.com/blog/kidnapped-by-the-vatican.
83"Non possumus" — formula by which Pius IX, after 1870, refused to recognize the Italian Law of Guarantees (13 May 1871) and any renunciation of the rights of the Holy See, judging that he could not alienate what belongs to the universal Church; foundation of the Roman Question, resolved only by the Lateran Accords of 1929. See Wikipedia, article "Non possumus."
95 135New Catholic Encyclopedia, article "Roman Question" (consulted de visu in session): "Pius IX issued the encyclical Respicientes ea omnia, excommunicating all who had ordered or executed the usurpation, but without specifically mentioning Victor Emmanuel II (Nov. 1, 1870)". URL: https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/roman-question.
97Pius IX, brief to Dr Constantin James, Rome, 17 May 1877 (date and text after the author's reproduction): Constantin James, Mes entretiens avec S. M. Don Pedro sur le darwinisme, Paris, Librairie de la Société bibliographique, 1888, pp. 84-85, via Dominique Tassot, L'Évolution en 100 questions-réponses, Le Chesnay, Via Romana, 2021, appendix, pp. 291-292 — pages not consulted de visu in session. Content corroborated in session by the full English translation given by Andrew D. White, a witness hostile to the pontifical position, in New Chapters in the Warfare of Science (1896, chapter "From Creation to Evolution"), with the exact equivalents: "tissue of fables", "alienation from God and the leaning toward materialism", "such fancies", "borrow the mask of science", "refuted by true science", book "so opportune and so perfectly appropriate to the exigencies of our time", apostolic blessing. URL: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/New_Chapters_in_the_Warfare_of_Science:_From_Creation_to_Evolution_IV. The existence of the work (Du darwinisme ou l'homme-singe, Paris, 1877) is attested by the Darwin Correspondence Project (Darwin's letter to James of 5 July 1877).
98 99Aleteia, "Le Kulturkampf ou comment l'Eglise a resiste aux attaques du chancelier Bismarck", 5 February 2018: account of the struggle launched by Bismarck from 1871-1873 (May Laws, expulsion of Jesuits, imprisonment of bishops) and its progressive failure under Leo XIII. Popular source used as a relay; facts to be checked against pontifical acts. URL: https://fr.aleteia.org/2018/02/05/le-kulturkampf-ou-comment-leglise-a-resiste-aux-attaques-du-chancelier-bismarck/.
101Miracle retained for the beatification: unexplained healing of a French nun, favorable opinion of the medical board on 15 January 1986, definitive decree in December 1999 (heroic virtues recognized on 6 July 1985, venerable). catholic.net notice ("Pius IX"), taken up by catholicsaints.info ("Pope Blessed Pius IX"). The nun's name was not found in session: it is not given here. URL: https://catholic.net/op/articles/2123/cat/1205/pius-ix.html and http://catholicsaints.info/pope-blessed-pius-ix/.
115Burial of Pius IX: the exact date of the exhumation with a view to beatification (6 April 2000 according to the old note, taken from Wikipedia) was not corroborated de visu in session and has been removed from the body. The transfer of the body into a glass coffin on the occasion of the beatification of 2000 is reported by The Eponymous Flower ("Pius IX: Strong and Inconvenient Pope", 2014): "the amazing incorrupt body of Pius IX was reburied in a glass coffin". URL: https://www.theeponymousflower.com/2014/12/pius-ix-strong-and-inconvenient-pope-of.html. The keeping of the remains at the basilica of Saint Lawrence Outside the Walls (San Lorenzo al Verano) is confirmed by Italian Traditions ("Pope Pius IX: The Pope of the Risorgimento"). URL: https://italian-traditions.com/pope-pius-ix-pope-risorgimento/.
117