Athanasius Schneider, born Anton Schneider on 7 April 1961 in Tokmok, in then-Soviet Kyrgyzstan, is a Catholic auxiliary bishop in Kazakhstan.[1] A member of the Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra, ordained priest on 25 March 1990, he served as auxiliary bishop of Karaganda from 2006 to 2011, and has since 2011 been auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Saint Mary of Astana.[2] His titular see is Celerina.[3]
He is the author of books published since 2008 on the reception of Holy Communion, the liturgy, and the Catholic faith, including Dominus Est (2008), Christus Vincit (2019, interviews with Diane Montagna), and Credo: Compendium of the Catholic Faith (2023).[4] He has co-signed several dated public statements, notably the Profession of the Immutable Truths about Sacramental Marriage of 31 December 2017 with two other bishops of Kazakhstan, the forty-point Declaration of the Truths of 10 June 2019 with four other prelates, and the statement of the Archdiocese of Astana of 19 December 2023 on Fiducia supplicans.[5][6][7]
This page sets out his exact career with its dates, his books with their publishers and years, and his public statements reported in context, with the date and signatories of each one. For each issue, the relevant Church document is quoted alongside, in its own terms, so that the reader can distinguish what belongs to a magisterial text, what belongs to the Catechism or to a disciplinary norm, and what belongs to the word of a particular bishop. A statement by a bishop, even when published and widely circulated, does not by itself carry the authority of a text by the pope, a dicastery, or the Catechism.
At a Glance
- 7 April 1961Born in TokmokSoviet Kyrgyzstan
Anton Schneider is born into a Catholic family of Black Sea German origin, deported to Central Asia after the Second World War.[8]
- 1973Departure for West GermanyRottweil
After receiving his First Communion in secret, he leaves the Soviet Union with his family and settles in Rottweil, West Germany.[9]
- 1982Entry into the Canons Regular of the Holy CrossAustria
He enters the Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra, in Austria, and takes the religious name of Athanasius.[10]
- 25 March 1990Priestly ordinationby Bishop Manuel Pestana Filho
He is ordained priest by Bishop Manuel Pestana Filho, Bishop of Anápolis (Brazil), and then carries out several years of ministry in Brazil.[11]
- 1997 and 1999Thesis defended, then published, and teaching in KaragandaRome and Kazakhstan
- 2 June 2006Episcopal ordination at St. Peter'sby Cardinal Sodano
Appointed auxiliary bishop of Karaganda and titular bishop of Celerina, he is ordained bishop at the Altar of the Chair of Saint Peter by Cardinal Angelo Sodano.[14]
- 2008Dominus Est appears in ItalianLibreria Editrice Vaticana
His book on the reception of Holy Communion is first published in Italian, with a preface by Bishop Malcolm Ranjith, then Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship.[15]
- 5 February 2011Auxiliary Bishop of AstanaKazakhstan
He is transferred as auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Saint Mary of Astana, whose archbishop is Bishop Tomash Peta.[16]
- 31 December 2017Profession of the Immutable Truths about Sacramental Marriagewith Bishop Peta and Bishop Lenga
- 10 June 2019Forty-point Declaration of the Truthsfive signatories
With Cardinals Raymond Burke and Jānis Pujats, Bishop Tomash Peta, and Bishop Jan Paweł Lenga, he publishes a forty-point declaration on faith, the law of God, and the sacraments.[18]
- 19 December 2023Statement of the Archdiocese of Astana on Fiducia supplicanswith Bishop Tomash Peta
In the wake of the declaration by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Archbishop of Astana and his auxiliary publish a statement addressed to the priests and faithful of the archdiocese.[19]
From Tokmok to Rottweil: a childhood in the underground Church
A German family deported to Central Asia
Anton Schneider was born on 7 April 1961 in Tokmok, in the north of present-day Kyrgyzstan.[20] His parents belong to the Black Sea Germans, German-speaking populations settled since the 18th century on the northern coast of the Black Sea, then part of the Russian Empire.[21] At the end of the Second World War, the family was evacuated to Berlin, then deported to a labour camp in Krasnokamsk, in the Urals.[22] After their release, they settled in the Kirghiz Soviet Socialist Republic.[23]
His mother Maria is mentioned, in the biographical accounts of this period, among the women who sheltered Blessed Oleksiy Zaryckyy, a Ukrainian priest who died in 1963 at the Karlag camp in Kazakhstan after his underground ministry.[24] This fact is reported by the biographies devoted to Bishop Schneider and by the account he himself gives of it in his interviews; it belongs to the family history as transmitted by these sources.[25]
Underground Masses and a secret First Communion
The child grew up in a clandestine Catholic practice, under a regime that forbade the public exercise of worship.[26] The biographical accounts tell how the family, after a stay in Soviet Estonia, would travel roughly once a month from Valga to Tartu to attend Mass, taking the first train in the morning and the last train in the evening, the scarcity of priests and the surveillance of the authorities making the journey exceptional.[27]
He made his First Communion in secret, shortly before the family's departure.[28] In 1973, the family left the Soviet Union for Rottweil, in West Germany.[29] Bishop Schneider speaks German, Russian, Portuguese, Spanish, English, French and Italian, and reads Latin and Ancient Greek, according to the notice listing his languages.[30]
Formation, religious life and priesthood
The Canons Regular of the Holy Cross, from 1982
In 1982, in Austria, Anton Schneider entered the Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra (abbreviated O.R.C.), an order of canons regular linked to the Opus Sanctorum Angelorum, and took the religious name of Athanasius, in French Athanase.[31] He was ordained priest on 25 March 1990 by Bishop Manuel Pestana Filho, Bishop of Anápolis, in Brazil.[32] He then carried out several years of priestly ministry in Brazil, before returning to Central Asia.[33]
The doctorate in patristics: the Shepherd of Hermas, defended in 1997
His Roman training culminated in a thesis in patristics defended in May 1997 at the Augustinianum Patristic Institute in Rome, on the Shepherd of Hermas, a 2nd-century Christian text. The thesis was published in German in 1999 under the title « Propter sanctam ecclesiam suam » : die Kirche als Geschöpf, Frau und Bau im Bussunterricht des Pastor Hermae (the Church as creature, woman and building in the penitential teaching of the Shepherd of Hermas), by the Augustinianum's publisher, with ISBN 88-7961-030-9.[34]
From 1999 onwards, he taught patristics at the Mary Mother of the Church seminary in Karaganda, Kazakhstan.[35] Karaganda was then one of the country's Catholic sees, in a region marked by the history of Soviet deportations and the Karlag camp.[36]
Auxiliary Bishop in Kazakhstan
Karaganda, 2006 to 2011
On 2 June 2006, he was ordained bishop at the Altar of the Chair in St Peter's Basilica, in the Vatican, by Cardinal Angelo Sodano, Secretary of State.[37] He was appointed auxiliary bishop of the Diocese of Karaganda and received the titular see of Celerina, a former episcopal see in Mauretania, in present-day Algeria, whose Latin name serves as the title of auxiliary bishops without a diocese of their own.[38]
Astana, since 2011
On 5 February 2011, he was transferred as auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Saint Mary of Astana, the capital of Kazakhstan, whose metropolitan archbishop is Bishop Tomash Peta.[39] The notices of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Kazakhstan also present him as secretary general of that conference.[40] The Catholic Church in Kazakhstan is a small minority in a predominantly Muslim country, with a significant Orthodox presence; the Archdiocese of Astana is one of the country's four Latin dioceses.[41]
It is from Astana that he co-signs, together with the local archbishop, the declarations of 2017 and of 2023 cited below: in both cases, the document is an act of the bishops of this archdiocese for their territory, before being circulated and commented on abroad.[42][43]
His Books: Publishers, Dates, and Content
The table below gives the main bibliography, in chronological order of first publication. The dates and publishers are those of the cited editions; several works were later translated, and the translation dates vary by country.
| Year | Work | Cited Publisher | Nature of the Work |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 | « Propter sanctam ecclesiam suam » (thesis on the Shepherd of Hermas) | Patristic Institute Augustinianum, Rome | Doctoral thesis in patristics, in German[44] |
| 2008 | Dominus Est : It Is the Lord | First in Italian (Libreria Editrice Vaticana), then Newman House Press in English (2009) | Essay on the reception of Holy Communion[45] |
| 2013 | Corpus Christi : Holy Communion and the Renewal of the Church | Italian edition in 2013, English edition at Gracewing (ISBN 9781782802013) | Sequel to Dominus Est on Holy Communion[46] |
| 2015 | Option préférentielle pour la famille (with Bishop Aldo di Cillo Pagotto and Bishop Robert Vasa) | Edizioni Supplica Filiale, 2015 | One hundred questions and answers on the Synod on the Family[47] |
| 2019 | Christus Vincit : Christ's Triumph Over the Darkness of the Age | Angelico Press, 2019 (ISBN 9781621384908) | Book of interviews with the journalist Diane Montagna[48] |
| 2021 | The Catholic Mass : Steps to Restore the Centrality of God in the Liturgy (with Aurelio Porfiri) | Sophia Institute Press, 2021 (ISBN 9781644135402) | Essay on the liturgy of the Mass, translated by Diane Montagna[49] |
| 2021 | The Springtime That Never Came | Sophia Institute Press, 2021 (ISBN 9781644135136) | Book of interviews with Paweł Lisicki[50] |
| 2023 | Credo : Compendium of the Catholic Faith | Sophia Institute Press, 2023 (ISBN 9781644139400) | Compendium of the Catholic faith in catechism form[51] |
| 2024 | Flee from Heresy : A Catholic Guide to Ancient and Modern Errors | Sophia Institute Press, 2024 (ISBN 9798889113188) | Guide to ancient and modern heresies[52] |
Dominus Est (2008): Communion on the Tongue and Kneeling
Dominus Est, whose title takes up the words of the Gospel of John, "It is the Lord" (Jn 21:7), first appears in Italian in early 2008.[53] The English edition is published by Newman House Press in 2009, translated by Nicholas L. Gregoris (ISBN 9780977884612).[54] The book carries a preface by Bishop Malcolm Ranjith, then Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, who later became Cardinal Archbishop of Colombo.[55]
The thesis of the book, as its author formulates it, is that the way the Body of the Lord is distributed and received manifests the Church's awareness of the Eucharistic mystery. He writes in 2009, in the text picked up by the Catholic press at the time of publication:
« The awareness of the greatness of the Eucharistic mystery manifests itself in a particular way in the manner in which the Body of the Lord is distributed and received. »[56]
French translation by the editorial staff; original English text published in 2009. In the book, Bishop Schneider argues that receiving Communion on the tongue became the Church's usual practice around the fifth century, and he cites Pope Gregory the Great rebuking priests who refused this practice.[57] He proposes a return to receiving on the tongue and kneeling as the usual norm.[58]
What Church discipline says on this precise point is as follows. Communion on the tongue always remains lawful for any faithful who requests it. Communion in the hand exists only where the bishops' conference has requested it and the Holy See has granted it by indult, beginning with the instruction Memoriale Domini of 29 May 1969, which maintained Communion on the tongue as the usage to be preserved while opening up this possibility.[59] The instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum of 25 March 2004 recalls at no. 91 that every faithful person always has the right to receive Communion on the tongue by choice.[60] Bishop Schneider's proposal therefore goes beyond the discipline in force: it asks for a change in the usual norm; it does not describe the current norm.
Corpus Christi (2013) and the Interview Books (2019 to 2021)
Corpus Christi extends Dominus Est on Holy Communion and the renewal of the Church; the Italian edition appears in 2013, and the English edition from Gracewing carries ISBN 9781782802013.[61]
Christus Vincit (Angelico Press, 2019) is a book of interviews with the journalist Diane Montagna, in which Bishop Schneider recounts, among other things, his childhood, his family and his path, and sets out his views on the liturgy, Holy Communion, and the life of the Church.[62] The Springtime That Never Came (Sophia Institute Press, 2021) is a second book of interviews, with the Polish journalist Paweł Lisicki.[63] The Catholic Mass (Sophia Institute Press, 2021), written with Aurelio Porfiri and translated into English by Diane Montagna, deals with the place of God in the liturgy of the Mass.[64]
Credo (2023): A Compendium of the Faith
Credo : Compendium of the Catholic Faith is published by Sophia Institute Press on 30 October 2023 (ISBN 9781644139400, 402 pages in the English hardcover edition).[65] The work received the imprimatur of Bishop Peter Anthony Libasci, Bishop of Manchester (New Hampshire, United States).[66] An imprimatur is the permission to print granted by the competent ordinary after the nihil obstat of a censor: it attests that the text contains nothing contrary to faith and morals, without constituting an approval of each of the author's opinions nor a text of the universal magisterium.[67]
In the presentation he gives of his intention, in October 2023, Bishop Schneider says he wants to help dispel what he calls a widespread doctrinal and liturgical confusion, so that Catholics may distinguish, in his words, the wheat from the tares.[68] The book was praised by Cardinal Robert Sarah and recommended by the theologian Scott Hahn, according to the presentations of the publisher and the Catholic press in 2023; it also received critical readings in the Catholic press, notably regarding its proposed clarifications of certain passages of the Second Vatican Council and the Catechism.[69] These assessments, favourable or critical, are the judgements of readers and commentators: they do not change the status of the book, which remains the work of a particular bishop.
His public statements, reported with their dates
This part reports the best-documented public interventions, in chronological order. For each one, the date is given, the signatories, the text to which it responds where there is one, and the exact tenor of this text of the Church. The strong quoted formulations are those of Bishop Schneider or of documents co-signed by him; the unquoted summaries are paraphrases identified as such.
December 2010: the proposal for a new Syllabus
In December 2010, at a theological conference in Rome, Bishop Schneider proposed that the papal magisterium publish a new Syllabus, on the model of Pius IX's Syllabus of 1864, in order to correct what he presented as erroneous interpretations of the documents of the Second Vatican Council.[70] This proposal is a bishop's position taken at a conference; it was not followed by any such document from the Holy See.[71]
31 December 2017: the Profession of the immutable truths about sacramental marriage
On 31 December 2017, Archbishop Tomash Peta of Astana, Archbishop Jan Paweł Lenga, emeritus of Karaganda, and Bishop Athanasius Schneider published a Profession of the immutable truths about sacramental marriage, in seven points.[72] The document reacts to the pastoral norms issued by certain bishops' conferences after the apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia of Pope Francis, published on 19 March 2016.[73][74]
The text to which the profession responds is Chapter 8 of Amoris Laetitia (paragraphs 291 to 312), devoted to the accompaniment of people in so-called irregular situations. The exhortation there teaches the indissolubility of marriage and, at paragraph 305 accompanied by footnote 351, opens, within the framework of a pastoral and sacramental discernment, the possibility of help through the sacraments in certain cases after discernment.[75] The three bishops of Kazakhstan state for their part that no bishop or group of bishops may authorize communion for divorced and civilly remarried Catholics who continue to live as husband and wife with a person who is not their sacramental spouse, and they present this position as the immutable truth about sacramental marriage.[76] Bishop Schneider later explained to Catholic News Service, on 4 January 2018 in Rome, that the profession responds to episcopal norms that provide for this possibility.[77]
Other bishops and cardinals subsequently adhered publicly to this profession, and other bishops' conferences issued different readings of Chapter 8.[78] The status of the two texts is not the same: Amoris Laetitia is a post-synodal apostolic exhortation by the pope; the 2017 profession is a declaration by three particular bishops for their dioceses, subsequently joined by other signatories.
10 June 2019: the Declaration of truths in forty points
On 10 June 2019, Cardinals Raymond Burke and Jānis Pujats, Archbishop Tomash Peta, Archbishop Jan Paweł Lenga and Bishop Athanasius Schneider published a Declaration of the truths concerning some of the most common errors in the life of the Church of our time, in forty points divided into four parts: the foundations of the faith (points 1 and 2), the Creed (points 3 to 11), the law of God (points 12 to 29) and the sacraments (points 30 to 40).[79] The signatories write that such a declaration is necessary, in their view, in a time of doctrinal confusion and almost universal disorientation; this assessment of the situation is theirs.[80]
Two points illustrate the method of the document, which responds point by point to precise texts without always naming them.
Point 9 concerns religions. It states:
“The religion born of faith in Jesus Christ, the incarnate Son of God and the sole Savior of humanity, is the only religion positively willed by God.”[81]
French translation by the editorial staff; original English text of the declaration of 10 June 2019. This point is read, by the commentators who published it, as a response to a sentence of the Document on Human Fraternity signed in Abu Dhabi on 4 February 2019 by Pope Francis and the Grand Imam of Al Azhar, Ahmad Al Tayyeb, according to which the pluralism and diversity of religions are a wise divine will.[82] Pope Francis subsequently clarified, at the general audience of 3 April 2019, that this diversity falls under the permissive will of God, in the sense that God allows this reality without positively willing it.[83] The declaration of 10 June 2019 and this papal clarification therefore employ the same distinction between positive will and permissive will, with different pastoral conclusions about how to formulate it.
Another point of the declaration concerns the death penalty. It states that the Church has not erred in teaching that civil authorities may lawfully exercise capital punishment when this is truly necessary to preserve the just order of societies.[84] The text of the Catechism then in force is paragraph 2267 as revised by Pope Francis by rescript of 1 August 2018, which teaches:
“The Church teaches, in the light of the Gospel, that the death penalty is inadmissible because it is an attack on the inviolability and the dignity of the person, and she works with determination for its abolition worldwide.”[85]
Revised paragraph 2267 has been the text of the Catechism of the Catholic Church since 2018. The declaration of 10 June 2019 is, on this point as on the others, a declaration of its five signatories.
September 2019: the letter on the Synod for the Amazon
In September 2019, Cardinal Burke and Bishop Schneider published an eight-page letter on the working document (Instrumentum laboris) of the Synod of Bishops for the Pan-Amazon region, whose assembly is held in Rome from 6 to 27 October 2019.[86] They identify in it six theological errors which they attribute to the working document, citing in particular what they describe as an implicit pantheism, and they ask Pope Francis to confirm his brothers in the faith through an unambiguous rejection of these errors.[87] They invite clergy and laity to a crusade of prayer and fasting of forty days, from 17 September to 26 October 2019, to this intention.[88] The final document of the Synod and the post-synodal exhortation Querida Amazonia of 12 February 2020 are the texts of the Synod and of the pope that followed this assembly.[89]
16 July 2021 and the following days: Traditionis custodes
On 16 July 2021, Pope Francis published the motu proprio Traditionis custodes on the use of the liturgical books prior to the 1970 reform.[90] Its first article provides that the liturgical books promulgated by Paul VI and John Paul II, in conformity with the decrees of the Second Vatican Council, are the sole expression of the lex orandi of the Roman Rite, and its article 2 entrusts to the diocesan bishop, as moderator and promoter of the liturgy in his diocese, the charge of authorizing and regulating the use of the 1962 Missal in his territory.[91]
Bishop Schneider reacted in an interview with Diane Montagna published on 23 July 2021.[92] He there describes his first impression through an image of his own:
“A shepherd who, instead of having the smell of his sheep, beats them angrily with a stick.”[93]
French translation by the editorial staff; remarks made in English in the interview of 23 July 2021. In the same interview and in his later interventions, he presents the traditional Latin Mass as a treasure that belongs to all the saints and to the Church of all times.[94] These words are those of Bishop Schneider. The norm in force on this subject is the motu proprio of 16 July 2021, subsequently supplemented by the responses and rescripts of the Dicastery for Divine Worship.
18 and 19 December 2023: Fiducia supplicans and Astana's response
On 18 December 2023, the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith publishes the declaration Fiducia supplicans on the pastoral meaning of blessings, approved by Pope Francis.[95] The Dicastery's official presentation summarises the text as follows: it becomes possible to bless couples in irregular situations and same-sex couples, without any ritualisation or impression of marriage, without officially validating their status, and without changing in any way the Church's perennial teaching on marriage.[96] The declaration distinguishes liturgical and ritualised blessings, which require conformity to doctrine, from spontaneous pastoral blessings requested by people who acknowledge themselves as poor and in need of God's help.[97]
On 19 December 2023, Archbishop Tomash Peta and Bishop Athanasius Schneider publish a declaration addressed to the priests and parishes of the Archdiocese of Astana.[98] In it, they state that the blessings of same-sex couples proposed by Fiducia supplicans are, in their view, directly and seriously contrary to divine Revelation and to the uninterrupted, two-thousand-year doctrine and practice of the Catholic Church, and they ask the priests and faithful of the archdiocese not to accept or perform any form of blessing of same-sex couples.[99] The Dicastery subsequently issues, on 4 January 2024, a press release to assist in receiving the declaration, recalling that the doctrine on marriage does not change and that the pastoral blessings in question are neither liturgical nor ritualised.[100]
On this matter, the positions are therefore dated and attributed: the Dicastery's declaration approved by Pope Francis on 18 December 2023 and its press release of 4 January 2024 on the one hand; the declaration of the two bishops of Astana for their archdiocese on 19 December 2023 on the other. Other episcopal conferences published, in the same weeks, different implementations, some welcoming the possibility opened up by Fiducia supplicans within the limits it sets, others suspending or prohibiting it in their territory.[101]
What the Church says and what Bishop Schneider says: degrees of authority
The table below serves as a reading grid for the whole article. It does not judge people's intentions; it gives the status of each type of text, as the Church defines it herself.
| Type of text | Example on this page | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Scripture and the Church's defined faith | The Creed, the indissolubility of sacramental marriage | Catholic faith, defined and irreformable |
| Catechism of the Catholic Church | Number 2267, revised in 2018, on the death penalty | Magisterial teaching, reference text of the faith |
| Text by the Pope | Amoris Laetitia (2016), Traditionis custodes (2021) | Act of the pontifical magisterium, according to its own genre |
| Declaration of a dicastery approved by the Pope | Fiducia supplicans (18 December 2023) | Act of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, approved by Pope Francis |
| Declaration of particular bishops | Profession of 31 December 2017, Astana declaration of 19 December 2023 | Act of bishops for their dioceses, without universal authority in itself |
| Book or interview by a bishop | Dominus Est, Christus Vincit, Credo | Opinion and teaching of an author, even a bishop, without the value of a universal norm |
This distinction is that of the Church's law and practice: a diocesan bishop legislates and teaches for his diocese, in communion with the universal Church, and the Pope and the dicasteries exercise an authority extending to the whole Latin Church in matters within their competence.[102] Reading a declaration by Bishop Schneider as a text of the universal magisterium would therefore be inaccurate; reading it as though it did not exist would be equally so, since these texts are published, dated, and received by an audience that follows them in several countries.[103]
Reception: distribution, support, and critical readings
Archbishop Schneider's books and statements are distributed well beyond Kazakhstan, by his American publishers (Newman House Press, Angelico Press, Sophia Institute Press), by the Catholic press that reports on his interventions, and by the conferences to which he is invited, in person or by video.[104] The Catholic press reports that in 2018 the Holy See asked him to limit his travels outside his diocese, canon law allowing a bishop to be absent from his diocese for more than a month only for a provided reason; his remote interventions then multiplied.[105] This point is reported here as a dated press fact, without the text of the Holy See's request, which has not been published.
Documented support includes that of his publishers, Cardinal Robert Sarah for Credo, and the prelates who co-signed his statements of 2017, 2019, and 2023.[106][107] Critical readings, in the Catholic press that publishes them, concern the scope he attributes to certain passages of Vatican II and the Catechism, his statements regarding recent papal texts, and the question of how far an auxiliary bishop may publicly challenge the application of a text approved by the pope.[108][109] This page does not settle these debates: it provides the dated documents, together with the status of each text, so that the reader may judge on the evidence.
To go further
- Raymond Leo Burke, American cardinal, co-signatory of the declaration of 10 June 2019 and of the letter of September 2019
- Walter Kasper, cardinal theologian, whose proposals on the family in 2014 belong to the debate preceding Amoris Laetitia
- Mgr Dominique Rey, Bishop of Fréjus-Toulon, another contemporary French episcopal figure presented in this series
- The Real Eucharistic Presence, at the heart of Dominus Est and Corpus Christi
- Pope Francis, author of Amoris Laetitia, of Traditionis custodes, and approver of Fiducia supplicans
Notes and References
Birth of Anton Schneider on 7 April 1961 in Tokmok, in the Kirghiz Soviet Socialist Republic (USSR). Reference biographical notices on Archbishop Athanasius Schneider, cross-checked with the notices of his publishers and with the Catholic press.
1 20Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra (O.R.C.); priestly ordination on 25 March 1990; auxiliary bishop of Karaganda from 2006 to 2011; auxiliary bishop of Astana since 5 February 2011; titular see of Celerina. Episcopal directories and biographical notices cited, dates cross-checked.
2 3Main bibliography: Dominus Est (2008), Corpus Christi (2013), Christus Vincit (Angelico Press, 2019), The Catholic Mass (Sophia Institute Press, 2021), Credo (Sophia Institute Press, 2023), Flee from Heresy (Sophia Institute Press, 2024). Details and ISBN in the table of the bibliography section.
4Archbishop Tomash Peta, Archbishop Jan Paweł Lenga and Bishop Athanasius Schneider, Profession of the Immutable Truths concerning Sacramental Marriage, 31 December 2017, seven points. Text published and report by Catholic News Service, January 2018.
5 17 42 72 73 76Cardinals Raymond Burke and Jānis Pujats, Archbishop Tomash Peta, Archbishop Jan Paweł Lenga and Bishop Athanasius Schneider, Declaration of the Truths regarding some of the most common errors in the life of the Church of our time, 10 June 2019, forty points in four parts. Text published by the signatories and press reports of 10 June 2019.
6 18 79 80 84 107Archbishop Tomash Peta and Bishop Athanasius Schneider, statement of the Archdiocese of Saint Mary in Astana on Fiducia supplicans, 19 December 2023, addressed to the priests and parishes of the archdiocese. Text circulated by the archdiocese and reports from the Catholic Herald and the Catholic press of 19 December 2023.
7 19 43 98 99Family of Black Sea Germans, evacuated to Berlin at the end of the Second World War, deported to Krasnokamsk (the Urals), then settled in Soviet Kyrgyzstan; mother Maria among the women who sheltered Blessed Oleksiy Zaryckyy, who died in 1963 in the Karlag. Biographical accounts of Archbishop Schneider and Christus Vincit (2019), family history elements reported by these sources.
8 21 22 23 24First Communion received in secret, then the family's emigration in 1973 to Rottweil, in West Germany. Biographical notices cited.
9 28 29Entry in 1982, in Austria, among the Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra; religious name Athanasius; priestly ordination on 25 March 1990 by Mgr Manuel Pestana Filho, Bishop of Anápolis; ministry in Brazil. Biographical notices cited.
10 11 31 32 33Athanasius Schneider, « Propter sanctam ecclesiam suam » : die Kirche als Geschöpf, Frau und Bau im Bussunterricht des Pastor Hermae, Rome, Institut patristique Augustinianum, 1999, ISBN 88-7961-030-9. Doctoral thesis in patristics on the Shepherd of Hermas, defended in May 1997 according to the bibliographic notice of the Library of Congress, which lists the 1999 edition as the publication of this thesis.
12 34 44Teaching of patristics at the Mary Mother of the Church seminary in Karaganda from 1999. Biographical notices cited.
13 35Episcopal ordination on 2 June 2006 at the Chair altar of St Peter's Basilica, by Cardinal Angelo Sodano. Biographical notices and episcopal directories cited.
14 37Athanasius Schneider, Dominus Est : It Is the Lord. Reflections of a Bishop of Central Asia on Holy Communion, first in Italian in early 2008 (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, according to the author's account), English edition from Newman House Press, Pine Beach (New Jersey), 2009, trans. Nicholas L. Gregoris, ISBN 9780977884612; preface by Mgr Malcolm Ranjith, then secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship.
15 45 53 54 55Transfer as auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Saint Mary of Astana on 5 February 2011. Biographical notices and episcopal directories cited.
16 39Athanasius Schneider, Christus Vincit : Christ's Triumph Over the Darkness of the Age, interviews with Diane Montagna, Angelico Press, Brooklyn (New York), 2019, ISBN 9781621384908.
25 48 62Secret Masses about once a month, journey from Valga to Tartu (Soviet Estonia) on the first and last train of the day. National Catholic Register, biographical portrait of Archbishop Schneider, account cross-checked with the biographical notices.
26 27German, Russian, Portuguese, Spanish, English, French, and Italian spoken; Latin and ancient Greek read. Biographical notice listing his languages, in Christus Vincit and publisher presentations.
30Karaganda, a city in Kazakhstan marked by the Karlag camp, one of the great Gulag camps. General historical context of the episcopal see.
36Celerina, titular see of an ancient diocese of Mauretania (present-day Algeria), assigned as a title to auxiliary bishops. Directories of titular sees.
38General Secretary of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Kazakhstan: position attested in 2018 by Catholic World Report (6 July 2018) and still mentioned in the published structure of the Bishops' Conference of Kazakhstan. Position cited for information only, with no bearing on the statements reported.
40The Latin Catholic Church in Kazakhstan comprises four dioceses, including the Archdiocese of Saint Mary of Astana, in a predominantly Muslim country. General data from diocesan directories.
41Athanasius Schneider, Corpus Christi : Holy Communion and the Renewal of the Church, Italian edition in 2013; English edition from Gracewing, ISBN 9781782802013.
46 61Mgr Aldo di Cillo Pagotto, Mgr Robert F. Vasa and Mgr Athanasius Schneider, Option préférentielle pour la famille : cent questions et réponses autour du Synode, Edizioni Supplica Filiale, 2015, preface by Cardinal Jorge Medina Estévez. Notice of the Internet Archive and of the publisher.
47Athanasius Schneider with Aurelio Porfiri, The Catholic Mass : Steps to Restore the Centrality of God in the Liturgy, trans. Diane Montagna, Sophia Institute Press, Manchester (New Hampshire), 2021, ISBN 9781644135402.
49 64Athanasius Schneider, The Springtime That Never Came, interviews with Paweł Lisicki, Sophia Institute Press, 2021, ISBN 9781644135136.
50 63Athanasius Schneider, Credo : Compendium of the Catholic Faith, Sophia Institute Press, 30 October 2023, ISBN 9781644139400, 402 pp. in the English hardcover edition. Publisher's notice and bibliographic notices.
51 65Athanasius Schneider, Flee from Heresy : A Catholic Guide to Ancient and Modern Errors, Sophia Institute Press, 2024, ISBN 9798889113188. Publisher's notice.
52Sentence published in 2009 upon the English publication of Dominus Est and taken up by the Catholic press: "The awareness of the greatness of the eucharistic mystery is demonstrated in a special way by the manner in which the body of the Lord is distributed and received." French translation by the editorial staff.
56Thesis of Dominus Est: reception on the tongue having become usual practice around the fifth century, reliance on Gregory the Great, proposal of reception on the tongue and kneeling as the usual norm. Summary of the book in the cross-checked publication notices.
57 58Congregation for Divine Worship, instruction Memoriale Domini, 29 May 1969: retention of Communion on the tongue as the traditional usage to be preserved, and the possibility of an indult for Communion in the hand granted by the Holy See to bishops' conferences that request it.
59Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum, 25 March 2004, no. 91: every faithful always has the right to receive Holy Communion on the tongue at his or her choice.
60Imprimatur of Bishop Peter Anthony Libasci, Bishop of Manchester (New Hampshire), for Credo (2023), according to the publication notice and press reports of 2023.
66Nihil obstat and imprimatur: Code of Canon Law, canons 822 to 832, on the publication of books dealing with faith and morals. Permission to print attests to the absence of error against faith and morals according to the censor and the ordinary who grants it.
67Bishop Schneider interview on Credo, October 2023: dispelling widespread doctrinal and liturgical confusion, distinguishing wheat from chaff. Catholic Family News, 26 October 2023, interview cited with its reference to Credo, p. xxi.
68Endorsements from Cardinal Robert Sarah and theologian Scott Hahn reported by the publisher and the press in 2023; critical readings in the Catholic press regarding the proposed clarifications of Vatican II and the Catechism. Publication reviews of Credo, October and November 2023, favourable and critical.
69 106 108Proposal for a new Syllabus to correct erroneous interpretations of Vatican II, theological conference in Rome, December 2010. Catholic Culture and Catholic World News, January 2011, cross-checked reports.
70 71Pope Francis, post-synodal apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia, 19 March 2016, Chapter 8, nos. 291 to 312, in particular no. 305 and note 351, on pastoral and sacramental discernment. Official text of the Holy See.
74 75Statements by Bishop Schneider to Catholic News Service, Rome, 4 January 2018: the profession responds to the norms of bishops' conferences providing for the possibility of Communion for some divorced and civilly remarried persons. Catholic News Service, 4 January 2018, taken up by the American Catholic press.
77Subsequent endorsements of the 2017 profession by other bishops, and different episcopal readings of Chapter 8 of Amoris Laetitia in other conferences. Catholic press, January and February 2018.
78Declaration of 10 June 2019, point 9, original English text: “the religion born of faith in Jesus Christ, the Incarnate Son of God and the only Savior of humankind, is the only religion positively willed by God”. French translation by the editorial staff.
81Pope Francis and Grand Imam Ahmad Al Tayyeb, Document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together, Abu Dhabi, 4 February 2019: the plurality and diversity of religions presented as a wise divine will. Official text of the Holy See.
82Pope Francis, general audience of 3 April 2019: the many religions fall under God's permissive will. Official text of the audience, Holy See.
83Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 2267, text revised by Pope Francis, rescript of 1 August 2018. Official French text quoted in the body.
85Cardinal Raymond Burke and Bishop Athanasius Schneider, eight-page letter on the Instrumentum laboris of the Synod for the Pan-Amazonian region, September 2019: six errors identified, request to Pope Francis, crusade of prayer and fasting from 17 September to 26 October 2019. Text published by the authors and press reports of September 2019.
86 87 88Synod for the Pan-Amazonian region, assembly from 6 to 27 October 2019; Pope Francis, post-synodal apostolic exhortation Querida Amazonia, 12 February 2020. Official texts of the Holy See.
89Pope Francis, apostolic letter issued motu proprio Traditionis custodes, 16 July 2021, articles 1 and 2. Official text of the Holy See.
90 91Interview of Diane Montagna with Bishop Athanasius Schneider on Traditionis custodes, published on 23 July 2021. Original English text of the interview, remarks quoted in French translation by the editorial staff.
92 93The traditional Latin Mass presented as a treasure belonging to all the saints and to the Church of all times, in Bishop Schneider's interventions on Traditionis custodes from July 2021. Reports of his interventions, including that of the National Catholic Register of October 2022 on his conference with Cardinal Burke.
94Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, declaration Fiducia supplicans on the pastoral meaning of blessings, approved by Pope Francis, 18 December 2023, and its official presentation. Text and presentation of the Holy See.
95 96Fiducia supplicans, 18 December 2023: distinction between liturgical and ritualized blessings and spontaneous pastoral blessings; marriage defined as the exclusive, stable and indissoluble union between a man and a woman, naturally open to the generation of children. Official text.
97Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, press release to assist in the reception of Fiducia supplicans, 4 January 2024: the doctrine on marriage does not change; the pastoral blessings concerned are neither liturgical nor ritualized. Official text of the Holy See.
100Different applications of Fiducia supplicans by bishops' conferences and dioceses in the weeks following 18 December 2023. Catholic press reports of December 2023 and January 2024.
101 109Authority of the diocesan bishop over his diocese and authority of the pope and the dicasteries for the universal Church: Code of Canon Law, in particular canons 381 and 455, and the Second Vatican Council's constitution Lumen Gentium, nos. 23 and 27.
102Dissemination of Bishop Schneider's books and statements by his publishers, the Catholic press and his in-person and video conferences. Publisher presentations cited and cross-checked press reports.
103 104Request by the Holy See to limit travel outside the diocese, reported by the Catholic press in 2018, together with the reminder of the canonical rule on the bishop's absence from his diocese; video interventions subsequently multiplied. Catholic press, 2018. Text of the request not published.
105