Walter Kasper (1933-)

Walter Kasper, German cardinal born in 1933, theologian at Tübingen and later Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart, presided over the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity from 2001 to 2010. His book on mercy marked the beginning of Pope Francis's pontificate.

Ignispedia

Walter Kasper, born on 5 March 1933 in Heidenheim an der Brenz, is a German cardinal, a theologian of the Tübingen school, Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart from 1989 to 1999, and then President of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity from 2001 to 2010.[1][2] His name remains associated with three areas: ecumenical dialogue with Lutherans, Orthodox, and Anglicans; an academic Christology translated throughout the world; and a theology of mercy that Pope Francis publicly praised from the very first Angelus of his pontificate, on 17 March 2013.[3]

Walter Kasper is not the founder of a religious order, nor a mystic, nor a spiritual writer in the usual sense. He is a theologian who became a bishop, and then a man of Church government entrusted, for eleven years, with the cause of Christian unity in Rome.[4] Reading him therefore requires distinguishing three levels that this article will never confuse: the dated facts of his career, the theses of his books with their publishers and years, and the pastoral proposals he defended in 1993 and then in 2014, which have been debated and which do not, by themselves, constitute the teaching of the Church.

From the professorate to the episcopate, and then to the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity. Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

This distinction matters all the more because his name has often been reduced, in the press, to a single controversy: that of the divorced and civilly remarried. His work is broader. It begins with a thesis on Schelling, continues with a 1974 Jesus the Christ that became a staple of university faculties, leads to the signing of the Joint Declaration on Justification in 1999, and culminates in a book on mercy in 2012 that Francis said did him a great deal of good.[5][6][7][8]

From Heidenheim to Tübingen: the making of a theologian

Birth in 1933 and ordination in 1957

Walter Kasper was born on 5 March 1933 in Heidenheim an der Brenz, in Baden-Württemberg, in southern Germany.[9] From 1952 to 1956, he studied philosophy and theology in Tübingen.[10] He was ordained priest on 6 April 1957 for the Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart.[11] He first carried out parish ministry in Stuttgart, as a curate, in 1957 and 1958, before returning to his studies.[12]

This starting point is simple, but it explains what follows: Kasper is a German diocesan priest who became a professor, not a religious formed in a school of his order. His first field is the German public university, where Catholic theology is carried out in permanent dialogue with philosophy, history, and the neighbouring Protestant faculties. Tübingen, where Catholics and Protestants have worked side by side since the nineteenth century, left a lasting mark on his manner: to argue, to make distinctions, to seek a common language without erasing differences.

Doctorate, Scheffczyk, Küng, and the habilitation on Schelling

After his time as a curate, Kasper earned a doctorate in dogmatic theology at the Faculty of Theology of Tübingen.[13] He taught in Tübingen from 1958 to 1961 and spent three years as assistant to two professors who were apparently opposed in every way: Leo Scheffczyk, a dogmatician of great classical rigour, and Hans Küng, then a young theologian rapidly on the rise.[14] This double apprenticeship matters for understanding Kasper: from Scheffczyk he learned a concern for doctrinal precision, and from Küng a taste for the great questions put to the Church of his time. Yet he would become the disciple of neither, and his own work would take a middle path, at once academic and ecclesial.

His habilitation — the qualification that in Germany opens the way to a professorship — dealt with the philosophy and theology of history in the late philosophy of Friedrich Schelling.[15] It was published in 1965 under the title Das Absolute in der Geschichte, the Absolute in history.[16] The choice of subject is not insignificant: how can God be thought of within history, without being reduced to history? This question runs through his two great books, Jesus the Christ and The God of Jesus Christ. The hurried reader may take away this much: before being a man of pastoral debates, Kasper is a metaphysician by training, formed in the German school of fundamental theology.

Professor of dogmatic theology at Münster and then Tübingen

Kasper taught dogmatic theology at the University of Münster from 1964 to 1970, and became dean of the Faculty of Theology in 1969.[17] He then served as dean in Tübingen in 1970, where he continued teaching dogmatic theology.[18] In 1983, he taught as a visiting professor at the Catholic University of America in Washington.[19] He also took part in the direction of the Lexikon für Theologie und Kirche, the great reference dictionary of German-language Catholic theology.[20]

During these university years, he published the books that made his reputation. Glaube und Geschichte, faith and history, appeared in 1970, followed by Einführung in den Glauben, introduction to the faith, in 1972.[21] These are professors' books, written for students and priests, which seek to express the Christian faith in a culture marked by historical criticism and by the modern philosophy of history. Their language is technical, their aim pedagogical: to give ordered reasons for belief, without dodging the objections of the age.

  1. 5 March 1933
    Birth in Heidenheim

    Walter Kasper is born in Heidenheim an der Brenz, in Baden-Württemberg.

  2. 6 April 1957
    Priestly ordination

    He is ordained priest for the Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart.

  3. 1965
    Habilitation on Schelling

    Das Absolute in der Geschichte is published, on the late philosophy of Schelling.

  4. 1974
    Jesus the Christ

    Jesus der Christus is published by Matthias-Grünewald and becomes his most widely translated book.

  5. 17 April 1989
    Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart

    John Paul II appoints him bishop; episcopal consecration follows on 17 June 1989.

  6. 1 June 1999
    Secretary for Christian Unity

    He leaves his German diocese for the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, in Rome.

  7. 21 February 2001
    Cardinal

    Saint John Paul II creates him cardinal, with the title of Ognissanti in Via Appia Nuova.

  8. 3 March 2001
    President of the Council for Unity

    He succeeds to the presidency of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity.

  9. 1 July 2010
    President Emeritus

    The end of his presidency of the Council for Promoting Christian Unity; Kurt Koch succeeds him in the post.

  10. 20 February 2014
    Address to the consistory on the family

    His address on the Gospel of the family opens the debate that will lead to the synods of 2014 and 2015.

Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart from 1989 to 1999

Appointment in 1989 and consecration on 17 June

Saint Martin's Cathedral of Rottenburg. Photo by Alphacentauri, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

On 17 April 1989, Saint John Paul II appointed Walter Kasper bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart, one of Germany's great Catholic dioceses.[22] He received episcopal consecration on 17 June 1989, at the hands of Archbishop Oskar Saier of Freiburg im Breisgau, with Bishops Karl Lehmann and Franz Kühnle as co-consecrators.[23] The professor became a pastor of a diocese: he remained there for ten years, until 31 May 1999, when he left for Rome.[24]

This move from the lecture chair to the episcopal see changed his writing. Bishop Kasper spoke more of pastoral care, of passing on the faith in reunified Germany, of the place of the laity, and of dialogue with Protestants, very much present in Baden-Württemberg. In 1991 the German Bishops' Conference entrusted to him the chairmanship of its committee for foreign affairs and the vice-chairmanship of its committee for the doctrine of the faith.[25] In 1994, he became co-president of the International Lutheran-Catholic Dialogue Commission.[26] The future Roman president for Christian unity was thus formed first on German ground, where Catholics and Lutherans live in the same cities and sometimes in the same families.

The 1993 pastoral letter on the divorced and remarried

In 1993, Kasper signed, together with other German bishops, a pastoral letter proposing that, case by case, divorced and civilly remarried Catholics be examined for a return to the sacraments.[27] The proposal was then disapproved by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and by Saint John Paul II.[28] This fact must be reported exactly, without amplifying it or erasing it: as early as 1993, Kasper defended a pastoral path of individual examination for certain irregular marital situations, and Rome, at that date, did not adopt it.

This 1993 file sheds light on the one of 2014, twenty-one years later. It is not the improvisation of a media-hungry old man, but a long-standing conviction of his, formed in German pastoral practice, debated, set aside a first time, and then presented in a new form before the consistory of 2014. The reader may approve of or dispute this persistence; he cannot understand it if he does not know its true date of birth: Rottenburg, 1993.

In Rome for Christian unity, from 1999 to 2010

Secretary in 1999, president in 2001, cardinal the same year

On 1 June 1999, Kasper was appointed secretary of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, the Roman dicastery responsible for relations with other Christians and, through its Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, for dialogue with the Jewish people.[29] In that capacity, he also served as president of that Commission for relations with the Jews.[30] He then resigned from his see of Rottenburg-Stuttgart.[31]

Saint John Paul II created him cardinal at the consistory of 21 February 2001, with the title of Ognissanti in Via Appia Nuova, All Saints of the Via Appia Nuova, first as a diaconia, then raised pro hac vice to the rank of titular church on 21 February 2011.[32] A few days later, on 3 March 2001, he became president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, succeeding Cardinal Edward Cassidy.[33] The Holy See has since listed him as president emeritus from 1 July 2010, the date on which the Swiss bishop Kurt Koch succeeded him.[34]

Kasper took part in the April 2005 conclave that elected Benedict XVI, who confirmed him in his office on 21 April 2005, and then in the March 2013 conclave that elected Francis.[35] At that point he was the oldest of the cardinal electors still of voting age, since he turned 80 on 5 March 2013, a few days after Benedict XVI's resignation on 28 February 2013.[36] These dates are not protocol anecdotes: they tell us that one and the same man served Christian unity under John Paul II, under Benedict XVI, and that he was then heard by Francis on mercy and on the family.

The Joint Declaration on Justification, signed at Augsburg in 1999

Stages of the Lutheran-Catholic dialogue recounted in the 1999 Joint Declaration. Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

On 31 October 1999, at Augsburg, representatives of the Catholic Church and of the Lutheran World Federation signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification.[37] Augsburg is not a neutral place: it is the city of the Augsburg Confession of 1530, the founding text of Lutheranism. The Declaration affirms a consensus on fundamental truths of justification by grace, and it specifies that the condemnations of the sixteenth century do not apply to the positions thus presented in common.[38]

Kasper was then secretary of the Council for Unity since June 1999, and since 1994 co-president of the International Lutheran-Catholic Dialogue Commission.[39][40] He is not the sole author of the text, which is the fruit of decades of shared work, from the 1972 Malta report to the national and German dialogues. But his dual role, in Rome and in the commission, makes him one of the institutional craftsmen of its reception. For Ignispedia, the right measure is this: a document signed by two parties, prepared by commissions, and brought to Rome by the dicastery of which Kasper had just taken up the office of secretary.

The scope of the text must also be stated without exaggeration. The Declaration abolishes neither the Catholic Mass, nor the Catholic doctrine of the sacraments, nor the differences regarding ordained ministry and the Eucharist. It says that a central cause of separation in the sixteenth century — the way of understanding the justification of the sinner by faith and by grace — can now be confessed together in a differentiated form. It is a real doctrinal step, and a limited one: exactly the kind of step Kasper would subsequently seek to describe as a differentiated consensus, in which agreement on the centre does not erase the proper accents of each tradition.

Spiritual ecumenism, Orthodox and Anglicans

Presence, prayer and conversion of heart

Three interlocutors of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity during the Kasper years. Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

During his eleven Roman years, Kasper several times led the Holy See's annual delegation to the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople for the feast of Saint Andrew, and in August 2007 he led the Catholic delegation at the funeral of Patriarch Teoctist of Romania.[41] These gestures matter in his method: unity is not negotiated only in documents; it is practised through presence, common prayer where that is possible, and public recognition of the other's mourning and feasting.

He readily calls this dimension spiritual ecumenism: conversion of heart, prayer for unity and a change of outlook take precedence over mere institutional engineering.

Doctrinal frankness about the obstacles

When addressing Anglican bishops on 5 June 2006, he argued at the same time that the ordination of women to the episcopate would call into question the special place recognised to the Anglican Communion by the Second Vatican Council in Unitatis redintegratio, no. 13, and would make the restoration of full communion unrealistic as things stand.[42] The two statements belong to the same man: a broad spiritual welcome, and doctrinal frankness about the obstacles. To reduce Kasper to an ecumenist who would dissolve doctrine is as inaccurate as reducing him to a closed gatekeeper: his Roman texts hold together esteem for other Christians and a precise list of what continues to divide.

Relations with Judaism and Dominus Iesus

As president of the Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, Kasper acknowledges that the declaration Dominus Iesus of the year 2000 hurt many Jewish interlocutors in its presentation, while affirming the validity of its doctrinal content.[43] His reported formula is that such a text is not the end of dialogue, but a challenge to an even more intense dialogue.[44] In 2003, he wrote for the European Day of Jewish Culture a text entitled in English Anti-semitism: A wound to be healed, antisemitism, a wound to be healed.[45] On 10 July 2004, in Buenos Aires, the International Raoul Wallenberg Foundation presented him with an award for his commitment to understanding between Jews and Catholics.[46]

Here again, the method is visible: not to withdraw the content of a Roman document, and at the same time to acknowledge that a formulation can wound and must then be taken up again in dialogue. A reader may consider this position too cautious or too conciliatory; he must first receive it as it has been held, with its two facets, doctrinal and relational.

The theological work: from Christ to the God of mercy

The following table lists the major books with their publisher where established and their year, so that each reference can be verified in a library catalogue.

YearBookPublisher or cited editionMain subject
1965Das Absolute in der GeschichteHabilitation editionPhilosophy and theology of history in Schelling
1974Jesus der ChristusMatthias-GrünewaldChristology: who Jesus is, what history says, what the Church receives from him
1982Der Gott Jesu ChristiGerman edition of 1982God the Trinity, the freedom of God, suffering and love
1987 and 1999Theologie und Kirche, 2 vols.German editions of 1987 and 1999Theology and Church, questions of method and ecclesiology
2004Sakrament der EinheitGerman edition of 2004Eucharist and Church, sacrament of unity
2011Katholische Kirche: Wesen, Wirklichkeit, SendungHerderNature, reality and mission of the Catholic Church
2012BarmherzigkeitHerderMercy, a fundamental notion of the Gospel and the key to Christian life
2014Das Evangelium von der FamilieHerderThe address to the consistory of 20 February 2014 on the family
2015Papst Franziskus: Revolution der Zärtlichkeit und der LiebeGerman edition of 2015A theological reading of Francis's pontificate
[47][48][49][50][51][52]

Jesus the Christ in 1974: a Christology in three approaches

The three approaches announced in Jesus the Christ (Burns and Oates, 1976, p. 16). Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

Jesus der Christus was published in 1974 by Matthias-Grünewald.[53] Its English translation, Jesus the Christ, appeared in 1976 from Burns and Oates, translated by V. Green.[54] In French, Jésus le Christ was published by Éditions du Cerf.[55] From page 16 of the English edition, Kasper announces a Christology conducted according to three successive approaches: a contemporary approach, which starts from the questions of the person of today; a historical approach, which questions the Jesus of history; and a systematic approach, which unfolds what the Church confesses of Christ.[56] After these three approaches, the book deals with the resurrection, the mystery of Christ and his priesthood.[57]

The decisive point of the book is ecclesial as much as Christological. For Kasper, the Church is part of Christology, because Christ did not only say things: he did things, gathered disciples, instituted a community that continues his work.[58] In other words, one does not understand Jesus as an isolated teacher whose words alone would be preserved; one understands him together with the people he formed. This conviction explains why, in Kasper, theology never remains separated for long from the concrete Church: parishes, bishops, sacraments, dialogue with other Christians.

The God of Jesus Christ in 1982: a God free to love and to suffer

Der Gott Jesu Christi appeared in German in 1982, and its English translation, The God of Jesus Christ, from Crossroad in 1986.[59] On pages 191 and 195 of this edition, Kasper concludes that Jesus gave suffering an eternal scope, the scope of love.[60] There he calls upon Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine, who speak of a God capable of freely choosing compassion, and then Origen, who provides him with his clearest formula.[61]

"First God suffered, then he descended. What is the suffering he accepted for us? The suffering of love." Origen, cited by Walter Kasper, The God of Jesus Christ, Crossroad, 1986, pp. 191 and 195, translated into English[62]

Kasper specifies that, in Origen, it is not only the Son who suffers in this way, but also the Father, and that this is possible only through the freedom of God in love.[63] This sentence must be understood at its right degree: it is not a new dogma, it is a theology of the Trinity that refuses a cold and impassible God in the sense of an indifferent one, without thereby making God a being subject to evil like a creature. God remains God; but his love is not an idea, he is capable of letting himself be touched. The whole Kasperian theology of mercy is already contained in this movement of 1982: from the doctrine of God to the pastoral care of wounded persons.

The Catholic Church in 2011: nature, reality, mission

In 2011, Kasper published with Herder Katholische Kirche: Wesen, Wirklichkeit, Sendung, that is, the Catholic Church in its nature, its reality and its mission.[64] The book appeared in the year following his Roman retirement: it is in some sense the ecclesiological testament of the president for Christian unity. In it he defends a Church understood as communion, rooted in the sacraments, and he treats of ministries, primacy and collegiality without setting them against one another as enemy blocs.

This book helps to situate his later interventions on synodality. Kasper is not a supporter of a Church governed by a permanent parliament; he will return to this point in 2021 and 2022. His 2011 ecclesiology holds together the gift received from above, the sacramental structure of the Church, and the real responsibility of the baptized and of the pastors. The reproach sometimes levelled at Kasper of being a theologian of permanent change does not survive a sustained reading of this volume, which is a book of institutional balance as much as of ecumenical openness.

Mercy at the Centre: the 2012 Book and Francis's Praise

Barmherzigkeit in 2012: mercy as a fundamental notion

Three registers of the book Barmherzigkeit (Herder, 2012). Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

Barmherzigkeit: Grundbegriff des Evangeliums, Schlüssel christlichen Lebens is published by Herder in 2012.[65] The title states the programme: mercy as a fundamental notion of the Gospel and as the key to Christian life. The English translation, Mercy: The Essence of the Gospel and the Key to Christian Life, is published by Paulist Press in 2014, translated by William Madges.[66] In French, the book circulates under the title La miséricorde : notion fondamentale de l'Évangile, clé de la vie chrétienne.[67]

The thesis of the book is doctrinal before it is pastoral. Kasper argues that mercy is not a vague sentiment nor a mere indulgence towards sin, but a central attribute of God, revealed in the history of Israel and then in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus, and that the Church betrays its own message when it speaks of God without making this mercy heard. On this point, the reader can follow on with the article God, justice and mercy, which distinguishes the two attributes without opposing them. There he connects theological reflection with spiritual, pastoral and social considerations.[68] From this foundation of 2012 flow, logically, his questions of 2014 concerning those whose marriage has failed: if mercy is at the centre of the Gospel, how does the Church concretely accompany those who recognise a failure and ask to return?

17 March 2013: Francis says this book did him a lot of good

On 17 March 2013, four days after his election, Pope Francis devotes his first Sunday Angelus to mercy and recommends, without beating about the bush, Cardinal Kasper's book.[69]

« These days, I was able to read a book by a cardinal, Cardinal Kasper, a skilled theologian, a good theologian, on mercy. This book did me a lot of good. » Pope Francis, Angelus of 17 March 2013, text from the Holy See, translated and quoted from the official version[70]

Francis immediately adds that he does not advertise the books of his cardinals, and he reports Kasper's remark that experiencing mercy changes everything.[71] The fact is public, dated, and verifiable on the Holy See website: on the first Sunday of the pontificate, the new pope places mercy at the centre and names Kasper. This does not turn Kasper's book into a document of the magisterium. It does, however, establish why this eighty-year-old theologian becomes, from 2013 onwards, a listened-to interlocutor of the new pope on the family and on the accompaniment of persons.

Family, penance and communion: the 2014 proposal and its reception

The address to the consistory of 20 February 2014

Four stages of the debate on the family, with distinct degrees of authority. Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

On 20 February 2014, Kasper delivers before a consistory of cardinals an address on the Gospel of the family, Das Evangelium von der Familie, published the same year by Herder.[72] The text then lies at the heart of the preparatory work of the synods on the family of 2014 and 2015, to which Francis appoints him as a participant.[73] His proposal can be summarised, without caricature, in four moves: the Church cannot call into question Jesus's word on the indissolubility of marriage; yet new paths must be explored for the civilly remarried divorced who recognise their failure, convert, and ask, after a time of penance, to be readmitted to the sacraments; no general and easy solution can apply to everyone in the same way.[74]

« The Church cannot call into question the words of Jesus on the indissolubility of marriage. Whoever expects from the consistory and the synod general solutions that are easy and applicable to everyone is mistaken. But, faced with the difficulties families encounter today and the sharp increase in marriages that fail, new paths can be explored to respond to the deep needs of the civilly remarried divorced, who recognise their failure, convert and, after a time of penance, ask to be readmitted to the sacraments. » Walter Kasper, address to the consistory of 20 February 2014, translated into French[75]

Every part of the sentence matters. The first affirms indissolubility. The second refuses an automatic rule for all. The third opens a limited pastoral examination, conditional on the recognition of the failure, conversion and penance. To present Kasper as though he had proposed abolishing indissolubility is therefore inaccurate in the light of his own text. To present his proposal as though it contained nothing new would be equally inaccurate: admitting, even case by case and after penance, persons living in a second civil union to communion, while the first sacramental bond remains, was and remains the precise object of the debate.

The 2014 response: Remaining in the Truth of Christ

The proposal meets with public opposition from several cardinals, including Gerhard Ludwig Müller, Raymond Burke, Walter Brandmüller and Carlo Caffarra, who publish in October 2014, together with other theologians, Remaining in the Truth of Christ, Demeurer dans la vérité du Christ, to defend the discipline then in force.[76] Their central argument is that the Church's discipline regarding the communion of the civilly remarried divorced flows from the doctrine itself concerning the indissolubility of marriage and the Eucharist, and that it therefore cannot be changed by a merely pastoral route. Kasper, for his part, holds that he precisely distinguishes doctrine from the pastoral path of penance.

Ignispedia reports this debate as a real debate between cardinals, with its books and its dates, without turning either side into a caricature. On one side, an address to a consistory published by Herder in 2014; on the other, a collective book published in October 2014 in response. The reader is thus given the pieces: he can read both, compare their uses of Scripture, the Fathers and the recent magisterium, and judge where exactly the disagreement lies. That disagreement is not about whether God is merciful, which both sides confess; it concerns the link between the truth of marriage, public state of life and access to Eucharistic communion.

Amoris Laetitia in 2016 and Kasper's reading of it

In 2016, Pope Francis publishes the apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia, following the two synods on the family.[77] Kasper welcomes the text and holds that its correct interpretation allows, in certain individual cases and after discernment, the admission of the civilly remarried divorced to the sacraments.[78] In 2018, he extends this reading in Die Botschaft von Amoris Laetitia, the message of Amoris Laetitia, presented as a friendly disputatio on the exhortation.[79]

The degree of authority must here be stated calmly. Amoris Laetitia is an act of the pontifical magisterium of Francis. The interpretation Kasper gives of it is that of a cardinal theologian highly regarded at the beginning of the pontificate, but it remains his interpretation, disputed by other cardinals and theologians. Confusing the two levels — whether by lending Kasper the pope's authority or by reducing the pope's exhortation to Kasper's 2014 proposal alone — likewise distorts both texts. The exact sequence is: 1993 German letter set aside, 2014 consistory address debated, two synods in 2014 and 2015, Francis's exhortation in 2016, divergent readings afterwards.

Recent statements: concern over the German Synodal Way

From mercy to warnings about the German Synodal Way. Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI.

After 2016, Kasper speaks out less often, but his statements about the German Church have drawn attention. In 2021, he says he is very concerned about the German Synodal Way, the discussion process launched by the bishops and organised laity of Germany, and he argues that renewal can only come from an interior growth in faith, hope, and charity, while also pointing to a serious problem with catechesis.[80] In June 2022, he warns that the organisers risk breaking their necks, and he criticises the idea of turning a synodal council into a kind of supreme governing body of the Church, one foreign, in his view, to the tradition of synodal governance of the Church.[81]

These interventions make it impossible to cast Kasper as the convenient standard-bearer of any camp. The same man who in 2014 proposes a penitential path for certain divorced and remarried people warns, eight years later, against a synodality understood as a transfer of governance to a permanent council. His underlying line is older and simpler: the primacy of faith and interior conversion, distrust of merely structural solutions, and a refusal to govern the Church by assembly majorities. One may dispute this or that application he makes of it; one cannot honestly paint him as a theologian who would dissolve the Church into the procedures of his time.

Key takeaways, with their degrees of authority

Walter Kasper is a German cardinal born in 1933, ordained a priest in 1957, professor of dogmatic theology at Münster and Tübingen, Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart from 1989 to 1999, secretary and then president of the Council for Christian Unity from 1999 to 2010, and president emeritus since 1 July 2010.[82][83] His work includes a classic of Christology from 1974, a doctrine of God from 1982 in which the suffering of love holds a central place, an ecclesiology from 2011, and a book on mercy from 2012 praised by Francis as early as 17 March 2013.[84][85][86][87]

For a Catholic reader, the right way to read him is therefore threefold. First, receive his books as the work of a great academic theologian who became a bishop: they inform, they argue, they replace neither Scripture, nor the Catechism, nor the magisterium. Second, situate his Roman actions from 1999 to 2010 in their proper place: they are official acts of the dicastery for Christian unity, carried above all by the Joint Declaration on Justification of 1999. Third, present his pastoral proposals of 1993 and 2014 for what they are: proposals debated among cardinals, whose fate was settled, insofar as it fell to the pope, by Amoris Laetitia in 2016, which Kasper subsequently reads in a sense he claims as his own.

Presented in this way, Kasper ceases to be a slogan for or against a pontificate. He becomes again what he is in the documentary record: a theologian of Tübingen whom three popes employed or listened to, a builder of Christian unity who left his mark on his era at Augsburg in 1999, and an elder of the Church who, from the mercy of God to the penance of individuals, sought until the end how the truth of the Gospel can reach wounded lives without ceasing to be the truth.

For further reading

  • Gerhard Ludwig Müller: German cardinal, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, one of the authors of the 2014 response to the Kasper proposal.
  • Raymond Burke: American cardinal, another critical voice on the 2014 proposal regarding communion for the divorced and remarried.
  • Athanasius Schneider: bishop whose article refers back to Kasper in the debate preceding Amoris Laetitia.
  • God, justice, and mercy: to situate mercy, at the heart of the 2012 book, in relation to divine justice.
  • Marriage and Eucharist and real presence: the two sacramental realities at the centre of the 2014 debate.

Notes and References

  1. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": born 5 March 1933 in Heidenheim/Brenz, ordained 6 April 1957 for Rottenburg-Stuttgart, doctorate in theology at Tübingen. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    1 9 11 13 82
  2. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": secretary of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity on 1 June 1999, president on 3 March 2001, president emeritus on 1 July 2010. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    2 4 33 83
  3. Pope Francis, Angelus of 17 March 2013, Saint Peter's Square: praise of Cardinal Kasper's book on mercy, "a skilful theologian, a good theologian", a book that did him a great deal of good. Official text of the Holy See, vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    3 8 69 70 71 87
  4. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": habilitation with a thesis on the philosophy and theology of history in Schelling's late philosophy. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    5 15
  5. Walter Kasper, Jesus der Christus, Matthias-Grünewald Verlag, 1974. Title, publisher and year established from library catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    6 48 53 84
  6. Catholic Church and Lutheran World Federation, Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, signed at Augsburg on 31 October 1999. Official text, vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    7 37
  7. Biographical profiles of Cardinal Kasper: studies in philosophy and theology at Tübingen from 1952 to 1956. Summary by the Holy See Press Office and matching profiles, consulted in October 2026.

    10
  8. Biographical profiles of Cardinal Kasper: parish vicar in Stuttgart in 1957 and 1958, before returning to doctoral studies. Consulted in October 2026.

    12
  9. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": assistant to Leo Scheffczyk and Hans Küng for three years, teaching at Tübingen from 1958 to 1961. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    14
  10. Walter Kasper, Das Absolute in der Geschichte: Philosophie und Theologie der Geschichte in der Spätphilosophie Schellings, 1965. Title and year established by library catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    16 47
  11. Biographical profiles of Cardinal Kasper: professor of dogmatic theology at Münster from 1964 to 1970, dean of the faculty of theology in 1969, then dean at Tübingen in 1970. Consulted in October 2026.

    17 18
  12. Biographical profiles of Cardinal Kasper: visiting professor at the Catholic University of America in 1983. Catholic University of America and matching profiles, consulted in October 2026.

    19
  13. Biographical profiles of Cardinal Kasper: involvement in the editorial direction of the Lexikon für Theologie und Kirche. Consulted in October 2026.

    20
  14. Walter Kasper, Glaube und Geschichte, 1970; Einführung in den Glauben, 1972. Titles and years established by library catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    21
  15. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": appointed Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart on 17 April 1989, episcopal consecration on 17 June 1989. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    22
  16. Episcopal records of Walter Kasper: consecration on 17 June 1989 by Archbishop Oskar Saier of Freiburg im Breisgau, with Karl Lehmann and Franz Kühnle as co-consecrators. Catholic-Hierarchy and matching records, consulted in October 2026.

    23
  17. Holy See Press Office, profile "KASPER Card. Walter": Bishop of Rottenburg-Stuttgart until his departure for Rome in 1999. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    24 31
  18. Biographical notes on Cardinal Kasper: in 1991, the German Bishops' Conference entrusted him with the chairmanship of its commission for foreign affairs and the vice-chairmanship of its commission for the doctrine of the faith. Consulted in October 2026.

    25
  19. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: co-president of the International Lutheran–Catholic Dialogue Commission in 1994. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    26 39
  20. 1993 pastoral letter by German bishops, including Walter Kasper, proposing a case-by-case examination of readmitting the civilly remarried divorced to the sacraments, then disapproved of by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and by Saint John Paul II. Fact reported consistently by biographical summaries and dossiers on mercy, consulted in October 2026.

    27 28
  21. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: appointed Secretary of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity on 1 June 1999. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    29 40
  22. Notes of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity: its president also chairs the Pontifical Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews. Vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    30
  23. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: created cardinal by Saint John Paul II at the consistory of 21 February 2001, title of Ognissanti in Via Appia Nuova, diaconry elevated pro hac vice to the presbyteral title on 21 February 2011. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    32
  24. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: President Emeritus of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity as of 1 July 2010. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    34
  25. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: participation in the conclaves of April 2005 and March 2013, confirmed by Benedict XVI on 21 April 2005. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    35 36
  26. Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, Augsburg, 31 October 1999: consensus on fundamental truths of justification and non-application of the sixteenth-century condemnations to positions commonly presented. Official text, vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    38
  27. Biographical notes on Cardinal Kasper: annual delegations to the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople for the feast of Saint Andrew, Catholic delegation to the funeral of Patriarch Teoctist of Romania in August 2007. Consulted in October 2026.

    41
  28. Walter Kasper, address to the bishops of the Church of England, 5 June 2006: the ordination of women to the episcopate would call into question the special place of the Anglican Communion recognised by Unitatis redintegratio, n. 13. Reported account and text, consulted in October 2026.

    42
  29. Walter Kasper, reactions to Dominus Iesus in 2000: validity of the content affirmed, presentation deemed hurtful to many Jewish interlocutors, dialogue presented as a challenge to be intensified rather than as finished. Text hosted by the Center for Christian-Jewish Learning at Boston College, consulted in October 2026.

    43 44
  30. Walter Kasper, Anti-semitism: A wound to be healed, text for the European Day of Jewish Culture, 2003. Official text, vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    45
  31. Raoul Wallenberg International Foundation: award presented to Cardinal Kasper in Buenos Aires on 10 July 2004 for his commitment to understanding between Jews and Catholics. Foundation report, consulted in October 2026.

    46
  32. Walter Kasper, Der Gott Jesu Christi, German edition of 1982; The God of Jesus Christ, Crossroad, New York, 1986. Titles and years established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    49 59 85
  33. Walter Kasper, Katholische Kirche: Wesen, Wirklichkeit, Sendung, Herder, Freiburg, 2011. Title, publisher and year established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    50 64 86
  34. Walter Kasper, Barmherzigkeit: Grundbegriff des Evangeliums, Schlüssel christlichen Lebens, Herder, Freiburg, 2012. Title, publisher and year established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    51 65
  35. Walter Kasper, Das Evangelium von der Familie: Die Rede vor dem Konsistorium, Herder, Freiburg, 2014. Title, publisher and year established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    52 72
  36. Walter Kasper, Jesus the Christ, translated by V. Green, Burns and Oates, London and New Jersey, 1976. English edition established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    54
  37. Walter Kasper, Jésus le Christ, Éditions du Cerf, Paris. French edition cited in French-speaking theological literature, notably Cerf, Paris, 1980, p. 125. Consulted in October 2026.

    55
  38. Walter Kasper, Jesus the Christ, Burns and Oates, 1976, p. 16: christology in three approaches, contemporary, historical and systematic, then resurrection, mystery and priesthood; the Church as part of christology. Page cited by the references of the English edition, consulted in October 2026.

    56 57 58
  39. Walter Kasper, The God of Jesus Christ, Crossroad, 1986, pp. 191 and 195: suffering receives from Christ an eternal scope, that of love; Gregory of Nyssa, Augustine and Origen on a God free to show compassion. Origen's original text reported in a footnote: first God suffered, then he descended, the suffering of love accepted for us.

    60 61 62 63
  40. Walter Kasper, Mercy: The Essence of the Gospel and the Key to Christian Life, translated by William Madges, Paulist Press, New York, 2014. English edition established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    66
  41. Walter Kasper, La miséricorde : notion fondamentale de l'Évangile, clé de la vie chrétienne, French edition of the 2012 book. French title established from French-language catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    67
  42. Walter Kasper, Barmherzigkeit, Herder, 2012: theological reflection combined with spiritual, pastoral and social considerations on mercy. Publisher's presentation, consulted in October 2026.

    68
  43. Holy See Press Office, "KASPER Card. Walter" fact sheet: appointed by Francis a participant in the extraordinary assembly of the Synod of Bishops in October 2014 and the ordinary assembly in October 2015 on the family. Official page press.vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    73
  44. Walter Kasper, address to the extraordinary consistory on the family, Rome, 20 February 2014, published in Das Evangelium von der Familie, Herder, 2014. Original English text reported: the Church cannot call into question Jesus' words on indissolubility; new paths after penance for the civilly remarried divorced who acknowledge their failure.

    74 75
  45. Robert Dodaro, ed., with among others Gerhard Ludwig Müller, Raymond Burke, Walter Brandmüller and Carlo Caffarra, Remaining in the Truth of Christ: Marriage and Communion in the Catholic Church, Ignatius Press, English edition of October 2014. Collective book in response to the 2014 proposal, established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    76
  46. Pope Francis, apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia, 19 March 2016, following the synods on the family of 2014 and 2015. Official text, vatican.va, consulted in October 2026.

    77
  47. Reading of Amoris Laetitia by Walter Kasper from 2016: possible admission, on a case-by-case basis and after discernment, of some civilly remarried divorced persons to the sacraments. Interviews and public comments from 2016, consulted in October 2026.

    78
  48. Walter Kasper, Die Botschaft von Amoris Laetitia: Ein freundlicher Disput, 2018. Title and year established from catalogues, consulted in October 2026.

    79
  49. Walter Kasper, June 2021 interview on the German Synodal Way: concern expressed, renewal through the inner growth of faith, hope and charity, serious problem of catechesis. Catholic World Report, 10 June 2021, consulted in October 2026.

    80
  50. Walter Kasper, text on synodality and renewal, June 2022: a warning about the risk of breaking one's neck and the rejection of a synodal council erected as a supreme governing body. English translation released in June 2022 and consistent reports, consulted in October 2026.

    81

Can’t find your topic?