Karl Keating (1950-)

Karl Keating (1950-), a San Diego lawyer turned apologist, founder of Catholic Answers in 1979 and author of Catholicism and Fundamentalism (1988).

Ignispedia

Karl Keating, born in 1950, is an American Catholic apologist, trained as a lawyer, founder in 1979 of Catholic Answers, the San Diego lay apostolate that became one of the leading English-language outlets for explaining and defending the Catholic faith.[1][2] His name remains attached to one book, Catholicism and Fundamentalism, published by Ignatius Press in 1988, which gave a generation of American Catholics a model for documented responses to the objections of fundamentalist Protestants.[3]

Keating is neither a priest, nor a bishop, nor an academic theologian. A lifelong Catholic rather than a convert, he practised law for twelve years before closing his firm in 1988 to devote himself full-time to apologetics.[4][5] His authority is therefore that of an author, a debater, and the founder of a lay apostolate recognised in his diocese. It is not the authority of the magisterium, a distinction this article maintains throughout: when Keating quotes a council, the Catechism, or a pope, it is the quoted text that carries authority, not the apologist quoting it.

His contribution comes down to three repeated gestures over nearly forty years. First, to respond in writing, tract by tract, to a specific objection. Second, to train ordinary Catholics able to respond in turn, through books, a magazine, and public debates. Third, to hand on the reins: the presidency of Catholic Answers was passed to Christopher Check, a succession announced in February 2015 and placed in 2016 by the organisation's own timeline, after which Keating retired from the apostolate on 30 June 2017.[6][7]

Key dates

  1. 1950
    Birth

    Karl Keating is born in 1950 in the United States.

  2. 1972
    Applied mathematics

    Degree in applied mathematics from the University of California, San Diego, followed by studies in law and theology at the University of San Diego.

  3. 1979
    The windshield tract

    Leaving Mass in San Diego, he finds a fundamentalist tract against the Eucharist on his windshield, writes a reply, signs it "Catholic Answers," and opens a post office box under that name.

  4. 1982
    Founding of the apostolate

    Keating himself dates the formal establishment of Catholic Answers to 1982, between the first tract of 1979 and the full-time work of 1988.

  5. August 1986
    The monthly letter

    First issue of the Catholic Answers newsletter, to spread the word about apologetics and track the growing activity.

  6. 1988
    Law left behind, book published

    He closes his law practice, moves into apologetics full-time, and publishes Catholicism and Fundamentalism with Ignatius Press.

  7. January 1990
    This Rock

    The newsletter becomes the magazine This Rock, which Keating edits for nine years. Publication continues today online as Catholic Answers Magazine.

  8. 2015-2016
    The handover

    Christopher Check is announced in February 2015 to succeed him as president. Catholic Answers' timeline places the succession in 2016, with Keating then remaining a senior fellow.

  9. 30 June 2017
    Retirement

    Keating's last day at Catholic Answers. He writes that from the following day he will be fully retired from the apostolate, while continuing apologetics as a guest and author.

A Catholic Lawyer in San Diego

Mathematics, Law, and Theology

Keating's educational path does not look like that of a seminarian turned apologist. He first earned, in 1972, a degree in applied mathematics from the University of California, San Diego, then a law degree and training in theology from the University of San Diego.[8] This dual background, scientific and then legal, shapes his way of writing: define the terms, pose the exact question, cite the source, and then conclude only what the evidence allows one to conclude.

San Diego in 1985, the city where Karl Keating practiced law and developed Catholic Answers. Photograph by Edward Gohlich, Historic American Buildings Survey, Wikimedia Commons, public domain. No cropping.

He then practiced civil law in San Diego for twelve years, until 1988.[9] In parallel, he wrote early: the San Diego Reader, a local weekly, recalls that he wrote for that paper from 1973 to 1987, before and during his years as a lawyer in downtown San Diego.[10] Apologetics therefore does not arrive to find a man without a pen. It arrives to find a lawyer who already publishes, and who is going to put this habit of written argument in the service of one specific religious controversy.

Catholic Since Childhood, Not a Convert

Many American apologists of his generation tell of a conversion, like Jimmy Akin, received into the Church in 1992, or Trent Horn, who entered the Church at 17 after personal study.[11][12] Keating's path is the opposite. He has been Catholic since childhood and did not have to pass through another confession to arrive at the faith he defends.[13]

This difference explains a trait of his work. Where a convert often bears witness to a journey, Keating answers an attack. His starting point is not "how I became Catholic," but "why what you are being told about Catholicism is false, piece by piece." His apologetics is therefore less autobiographical and more documentary: Scripture, the Church Fathers, history, and Church teaching, summoned objection by objection.

1979: A Tract on a Windshield

The Sunday It All Begins

The story of Catholic Answers begins on a Sunday in 1979, after Mass in San Diego. A local fundamentalist church had placed on every car in the parish parking lot a tract attacking the Eucharist and repeating the classic accusations against the Catholic Church.[14] Keating finds the tract on his windshield. The apostolate's official account puts it this way, in English:

"Catholic Answers began in 1979 when our founder, Karl Keating, a lawyer in San Diego, came out of Mass and found on his windshield a tract attacking the Eucharist." Official founding account of Catholic Answers.[15]

The next gesture is tiny, and it is the one that matters. Keating goes home with a modest goal, according to the same account: to write a response presenting the basic Catholic beliefs and rebutting the tract's charges.[16] He signs his response with the name "Catholic Answers," opens a post office box under that name, then places his text on the windshields of the cars at the church that had distributed the tract.[17]

More Tracts, Then a Newsletter

The responses he receives convince him that a real need exists. On the one hand, many non-Catholics know Catholicism only through caricatures. On the other, many Catholics do not know how to answer when questioned about purgatory, the primacy of the pope, prayer to the saints, or the Real Presence. In the following years, Keating writes more tracts, in response to the questions received.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In August 1986, he launched a monthly newsletter, initially called Catholic Answers, to follow up on this work and spread apologetics.[18] In January 1990, this newsletter was replaced by This Rock, an apologetics and evangelization magazine published ten times a year, which Keating edited for nine years.[19][20] The rest of this story — radio, website, and video — is told in the article Catholic Answers. This present article keeps to the man: a lawyer who, for nearly ten years, ran this work part time, alongside his practice, before making it his profession.

1982 or 1979: Two Dates That Do Not Contradict Each Other

Keating himself distinguishes three possible beginnings, and the distinction avoids false precision. In his 2017 farewell text, he asks from when to count his years of work, and he lists the three answers without settling on any one:

"Should I count from my entry into full-time apologetics work, the first day of 1988? From the incorporation of Catholic Answers in 1982? Or from my first public act of apologetics, when I began using the name Catholic Answers in 1979?" Karl Keating, farewell text to Catholic Answers, June 30, 2017.[21]

The date of 1979 is thus that of the first act and the name. That of 1982 is that of the formal incorporation that Keating himself cites. That of 1988 is that of the move to full time. An article that kept only one of these dates would tell the story accurately, but incompletely.

1988: Leaving the Law, Publishing the Book

Going Full Time

The year 1988 is the biographical turning point. Keating closes his law practice and makes Catholic Answers a full-time apostolate, with a first office and paid staff.[22] He had practiced law for twelve years by then.[23] The choice is clear-cut: leaving an established profession for a work that, nine years earlier, amounted to a post office box and pamphlets left on windshields.

That same year sees the publication of the book that will carry his name far beyond San Diego. This is no accident of timing. The book and the move to full time reinforce each other: the book gives the apostolate a written foundation, and the apostolate gives the book an organized readership, first through the newsletter, then through the magazine from 1990.

Catholicism and Fundamentalism, the 1988 Book

Catholicism and Fundamentalism: The Attack on « Romanism » by « Bible Christians » is published by Ignatius Press in 1988.[24] The subtitle names the adversary and its vocabulary: "Romanism," the polemical term by which some fundamentalists designated Catholicism, and "Bible Christians," the name these same movements gave themselves. The book draws on a series of apologetics articles published over thirty weeks in the Catholic press, notably in The Wanderer.[25]

Thirty years later, Keating himself gives the most sober definition:

"My book Catholicism and Fundamentalism, published in 1988, was the first sustained response to the inroads of modern fundamentalism. It sought to stem the flow of Catholics to the so-called Bible churches, and it appears to have succeeded in part." Karl Keating, "Present at the Creation", Catholic Answers Magazine, July 1, 2017.[26]

Two clarifications are in order about this statement. "First sustained response" is Keating's own characterization of his book, in a retrospective text from 2017: it is an author's judgment on his own work, not a judgment of the Magisterium. The book's circulation and longevity, on the other hand, are attested by its publisher: Ignatius Press keeps it in its catalogue, in both print and digital editions, and presents its author as a bestselling author, this book included.[27] The subject's online entry likewise describes it as a lasting bestseller for its publisher.[28]

What the Book Answers, Point by Point

The book answers the fundamentalist objections of its day, and its table of contents still forms a map of Catholic and Protestant controversies. Scripture alone as the rule of faith, justification by faith alone, purgatory, the primacy of the pope, the veneration of Mary and the saints, the Real Presence in the Eucharist: each chapter takes up the objection as the adversary formulates it, then answers with Scripture read in context, with the witnesses of the early centuries, and with the teaching of the Church.[29]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The heart of the method is the question of authority. If the Bible alone is the rule of faith, one must still say who fixed the list of its books, and by what authority a reader today settles between two contrary interpretations of the same verse. Keating thus turns the objection back on itself: the debate is not primarily about some isolated verse, but about the body that can say, with stability, what the text teaches. It is this shift, from the isolated citation to the question of authority, that gave the book its pedagogical power among Catholic readers caught off guard in real-life conversations.

Why This Book Mattered

Its importance is historical as much as doctrinal. Before the internet, an American Catholic challenged in a parking lot, at work, or within the family had few short, biblical, and documented answers written in non-academic language. The 1988 book, followed by the pamphlets and the magazine, provided that first layer of response. Trent Horn, an apologist of the next generation at Catholic Answers, works today on other questions — atheism, abortion, difficult passages of the Bible. But the function remains that of 1988: to give an answer that can be spoken in a real conversation, backed behind the scenes by verifiable sources.

The Keating method

Answering the objection in its strong form

Keating's practical rule can be read in the very construction of his books. An objection is never refuted in a weakened form its author would not recognise. It is first set out in the words and arguments of those who advance it — fundamentalists of yesterday, atheists or Protestants of today in the course of the apostolate — and only then examined against the sources. Without this first step, the refutation is worthless, and the reader senses it.

This demand applies to tone as well. Public debate, for Keating, is not aimed at humiliating an interlocutor before a sympathetic audience. It is aimed at making the Catholic position intelligible to someone who can answer back. This is why his preferred formats are written and verifiable: the tract one can reread, the book one can annotate, the magazine article one can cite, and then, in the apostolate he founded, the live call-in show where no question is screened for being easy.

The tract, the book, the debate

Three formats carry this method, at three different depths. The tract answers in a few pages a single question — purgatory, for instance, or prayer to the saints — with verses, ancient witnesses and Church teaching. The book deals with an entire front, such as fundamentalism in 1988. The public debate puts the answer to the test of a real opponent, within a set time.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Keating practised this third format against named Protestant opponents. Dave Hunt, a widely read anti-Catholic author in fundamentalist circles, debated him on the historical question of whether the early Church was Catholic. One witness to this debate, the apologist Dave Armstrong, reports that Hunt argued there that only biblical texts could settle the matter, without citing a single Church Father all evening.[30] This account comes from a witness committed to the Catholic side. It is cited here for what it attests about the format and subject of the debate, not as a verdict on its quality.

Public debates between Keating and other Catholic apologists against Dave Hunt were also released in audio box sets, a sign that this format genuinely belonged to the ordinary work of American apologetics in those years.[31] James White, a Reformed apologist and director of Alpha and Omega Ministries, is another regular opponent of this generation. His own archives discuss Keating's arguments, notably on the doctrines of grace.[32] This article settles none of these debates. It retains the fact, attested on both sides: public controversy, argument against argument, was a claimed place of work, not an accident of the journey.

Training Catholics who answer in turn

A large part of Keating's work addresses not the Church's opponents first and foremost, but Catholics themselves. The intended reader is the ordinary Catholic who wants to be able to explain the faith without aggressiveness, at work, in the family or in a parish. Hence the short, transmissible forms: tracts to distribute, 52 short chapters of answers in What Catholics Really Believe, quizzes, essays and lectures.

The passing of the torch extends this intention. When Jimmy Akin joins Catholic Answers in 1993, followed by Trent Horn in 2012, the apostolate ceases to be the work of one man and becomes a school of respondents.[33][34] The method outlives its founder because it has been institutionalised: same sources, same demand for a precise answer, new channels.

The books: from 1988 to retirement

The first circle: answering fundamentalists

WorkPublisher and yearSubject
Catholicism and FundamentalismIgnatius Press, 1988Sustained answer to fundamentalist objections: authority, Eucharist, Mary, purgatory, pope
What Catholics Really BelieveServant Publications, 1992; reissue Ignatius Press, 199552 short answers to received ideas about the Catholic faith
Nothing but the Truth: Essays in ApologeticsCatholic Answers Press, 2000Essays in apologetics
The Usual Suspects: Answering Anti-Catholic FundamentalistsIgnatius Press, 2000Answers to anti-Catholic polemicists
Controversies: High-Level Catholic ApologeticsIgnatius Press, 2001Advanced-level apologetics

The first book remains the most widely distributed. Its publisher still lists it in its catalogue alongside its author, together with What Catholics Really Believe and Controversies.[35] The second, published by Servant Publications in 1992 under the subtitle "Setting the Record Straight", contains 52 answers to received ideas, and it was reissued by Ignatius Press in 1995.[36] The move from one publisher to another, between 1992 and 1995, indicates the reach achieved: a book of short answers, first published by an Ann Arbor house, taken up by the San Francisco publisher that had launched the author in 1988.

The second circle: essays, debates and new subjects

After 2000, Keating's bibliography widens and changes pace. The 2015 Rasselas House books bring together essays and more occasional subjects, including The New Geocentrists, devoted to Catholics who defend geocentrism, and Debating Catholicism, edited transcripts of public debates with professional anti-Catholics.[37][38] In 2017, the year of his retirement, several more Rasselas House titles appear, including The Bible Battle and Tracking Down the True Church, as well as Booked for Life from Catholic Answers Press.[39]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The profile Catholic Answers devotes to its founder presents him as the author of seven books, including those cited there as the most recent, The New Geocentrists and The Ultimate Catholic Quiz, and it notes that Catholicism and Fundamentalism and What Catholics Really Believe were national bestsellers.[40] This count of seven books is the house's at the date of that profile. It does not cover the entire later bibliography, notably the Rasselas House titles and the hiking books. It should therefore be read as a dated presentation, not as a complete bibliography.

The mountain books, another pen

Keating also wrote, outside apologetics, about mountain hiking, including How to Fail at Hiking Mt. Whitney and How to Fail at Hiking Grand Canyon, both from Rasselas House in 2017.[41] An older author biography already summed up this taste in one sentence: for recreation, he hikes the summits of the Sierra Nevada and the depths of the Grand Canyon.[42] These books are not part of his contribution as an apologist. They round out the portrait of a prolific writer who never stopped writing, even after leaving the presidency and then the apostolate.

PeriodMain books and writingsFunction in the work
1979-1988Tracts, thirty-week series in The WandererAnswering objection by objection
1988-2001Catholicism and Fundamentalism, What Catholics Really Believe, ControversiesGiving Catholics reference books
1990-1999Editing This Rock for nine yearsTraining each month, through the magazine
2015-2017Rasselas House titles, Booked for Life, farewell textsEssays, debates, transmission and assessment

Catholic Answers Action and the voter's guide

One episode must be reported with its dated facts, made neither a trial nor a badge of honour. In 2004, a complaint filed with the US tax administration by the organisation Catholics for a Free Choice led to a tax audit of Catholic Answers, which Keating described as costly and burdensome.[43] Following this audit, he founded a separate organisation, Catholic Answers Action, with its own tax status, which continued to publish his Voter's Guide for Serious Catholics.[44]

The guide urged readers not to vote for candidates favouring the legalisation of five issues presented as non-negotiable: abortion, euthanasia, embryonic stem cell research, human cloning and same-sex marriage.[45] This article reports the contents of the guide as documented by the subject's entry. It does not adopt them as voting instructions, and it does not settle the American debate over the place of such a guide in an election campaign. The fact relevant to this portrait is institutional: Keating legally separated civic action from the teaching apostolate, after an audit he regarded as threatening to the latter.

The handover and retirement

Christopher Check, announced in 2015

In February 2015, Catholic Answers announced that Christopher Check would succeed Karl Keating as president. Check had been director of development since 2012, after a path linked to the Rockford Institute and a past as an officer in the Marine Corps.[46] The apostolate's official timeline places the actual succession in 2016, with Keating then remaining as a senior fellow.[47] The two dates do not contradict each other: the announcement precedes the full taking up of the role, and the house's own sources give both.

Keating himself describes this period as a semi-retirement of more than two years. In his farewell text, he writes that he has been semi-retired since he left the presidency, and that the transition will therefore not be rough, even if he will find it strange to have one fewer key on his keyring.[48]

30 June 2017, last day

On 30 June 2017, Keating published his farewell text, "Farewell to Catholic Answers". Its first sentence sets the date without detour, in French:

« Aujourd'hui est mon dernier jour à Catholic Answers. À partir de demain, je serai pleinement retraité de l'apostolat. » Karl Keating, "Farewell to Catholic Answers", Catholic Answers Magazine, 30 June 2017.[49]

« J'ai pris plaisir à la controverse, même si je m'y suis parfois livré avec trop d'ardeur. » Karl Keating, "Farewell to Catholic Answers", Catholic Answers Magazine, 30 June 2017.[50]

He immediately specifies that he is not retiring from apologetics itself, which he will continue to practise, but that his visits to the Catholic Answers offices will henceforth be those of a guest, not an employee.[51] He thanks past and present staff, attributes the strength of the apostolate to their dedication rather than to himself, and owns its weaknesses. He sums up the mission to which he devoted nearly four decades with the house's own formula: explaining and defending the faith.[52]

After 2017, the Catholic Answers website retains his author profile and texts dating from after his retirement, including articles from 2018 and 2019.[53] This fact is enough to say that he remained an author published by the house he founded. It is not enough to attribute to him an employee or leadership role after 30 June 2017, the date his own text sets as his last day.

Karl Keating's contribution

Having brought Catholic apologetics to a mass audience

Keating's most visible contribution is institutional. A 1979 tract became, under his direction, a full apostolate: a newsletter in 1986, a move to full-time work in 1988, a magazine in 1990, and then, after him and with him, daily radio from 1998, the catholic.com website, conferences and an online school of apologetics. The article Catholic Answers tells this growth in detail. The present portrait retains the man's share in it: without the first tract, without the 1988 book and without the decision to leave the law, this house does not exist in this form.

The second contribution is literary and pedagogical. Catholicism and Fundamentalism established a template later taken up by hundreds of tracts and short answers: one question, the sources, a pronounceable answer. What Catholics Really Believe carried out the same gesture in 52 brief answers. The series of short booklets and the apostolate's live call-in shows extend this template, with voices other than his own.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The third contribution is a generation. Jimmy Akin, who joined in 1993, Trent Horn, who joined in 2012, Tim Staples and many others have worked in the house founded by Keating, with his method and his sources.[54][55] Saying this does not erase their own contribution. It places the founder's role: he created the place where their work became possible, and the format in which it was first exercised.

What his work is not

This place must be stated with its limits, in order to remain fair. Catholic Answers is a lay apostolate, recognised in the diocese of San Diego, which claims to work in fidelity to the magisterium.[56] It is neither an organ of the Holy See nor an editorial office of the magisterium. Keating's books bind their author and their publishers. When they set out a dogma, it is the dogma defined by the Church that obliges the Catholic, not the apologist's formulation. When they settle a question that the Church leaves open to theologians, their position remains an author's position, to be discussed as such.

His context is also dated, and one must know this to read him usefully. Keating writes first against American fundamentalism of the 1980s, in a country where the controversy between Catholics and evangelical Protestants structures the questions. The European objections — secularism, religious indifference, the secularisation of institutions — take up less space in his early books. A French-speaking reader will find in them answers still usable on authority, the Eucharist, Mary and purgatory. He will have to supplement them, for his own questions, with voices formed in his own context, such as Matthieu Lavagna for contemporary French-speaking apologetics.

Finally, his critics exist and have replied. James White's archives discuss his arguments, the Protestant witnesses in his debates dispute his conclusions, and this article has not settled them.[57] Presenting Keating as a major English-speaking apologist is a fact of distribution, institution and bibliography. It does not exempt any reader from checking, source by source, the answers he gives. Indeed, his own method requires it: one does not take an apologist's word, one follows his references.

Further reading

Start with the article on the house he founded, Catholic Answers, then the portraits of the apologists of the next generation, Jimmy Akin and Trent Horn, and, on the French-speaking side, Matthieu Lavagna. For the controversies that structure his books, see Answers to Protestantism and EWTN, the network that broadcasts the daily program born in his home.

The direct sources for verifying this portrait are the profile and founding account on catholic.com, Karl Keating's farewell text of 30 June 2017, his "Present at the Creation" retrospective of 1 July 2017, the Ignatius Press catalogue for his three main books, and Catholicism and Fundamentalism itself, Ignatius Press, 1988.

Notes and References

  1. Catholic Answers, official profile "Karl Keating", catholic.com/profile/karl-keating : founder and senior fellow of Catholic Answers, author of seven books including The New Geocentrists and The Ultimate Catholic Quiz ; Catholicism and Fundamentalism and What Catholics Really Believe presented as national best-sellers.

    1 40
  2. Catholic Answers, official "About" page and account "Our Story", catholic.com/about : founded in 1979 in San Diego, a fundamentalist tract against the Eucharist left on the cars of a parish, a reply signed "Catholic Answers", a post office box opened under that name, the reply left on the cars of the church that had issued the tract. Original text : "Catholic Answers started in 1979 when our founder, San Diego attorney Karl Keating, came out of Mass one day and found a flyer on his windshield that attacked the Eucharist".

    2 14 15 16 17
  3. Karl Keating, Catholicism and Fundamentalism: The Attack on « Romanism » by « Bible Christians », Ignatius Press, San Francisco, 1988.

    3 24
  4. Biographical notices on Karl Keating reproduced by Catholic Answers and its publishers : born in 1950, degree in applied mathematics from the University of California at San Diego in 1972, law and theology at the University of San Diego, twelve years of practice as a lawyer before 1988.

    4 8 9 23
  5. Catholic Answers, "About" page : in 1988, Keating closes his law practice and makes Catholic Answers a full-time apostolate, with a first office and paid staff.

    5 22
  6. Catholic Answers, press release of 2 February 2015 and National Catholic Register, February 2015 : Christopher Check, director of development since 2012, is appointed to succeed Karl Keating as president, Keating remaining senior fellow.

    6 46
  7. Karl Keating, "Farewell to Catholic Answers", Catholic Answers Magazine, 30 June 2017, catholic.com : last day at Catholic Answers, full retirement from the following day, semi-retirement for more than two years after the presidency, three possible starting dates (1979, incorporation in 1982, full time on 1 January 1988), mission summarized as explaining and defending the faith. Original text : "Today is my last day with Catholic Answers. Starting tomorrow, I will be fully retired from the apostolate".

    7 21 48 49 50 51 52
  8. San Diego Reader, "Karl Keating and the Reader", 8 September 2019 : Keating wrote for the Reader from 1973 to 1987, while working as a lawyer in downtown San Diego, before founding Catholic Answers.

    10
  9. Jimmy Akin, conversion testimony : received into the Catholic Church in 1992, joined Catholic Answers in 1993.

    11
  10. Trent Horn, conversion accounts published by Catholic Answers and Holy Apostles College : entered the Catholic Church at 17, after a personal study begun in high school.

    12
  11. Biographical notices on Karl Keating reproduced by Catholic Answers and its publishers : a Catholic since childhood, he is not a convert ; his apologetics arise from the reaction of a trained layman.

    13
  12. Catholic Answers, "About" page : launch in August 1986 of a monthly Catholic Answers newsletter. Patrick Madrid gives the first issue as August 1986.

    18
  13. Catholic Answers, "About" page : in January 1990, the newsletter is replaced by This Rock, a magazine of apologetics and evangelization published ten times a year, now Catholic Answers Magazine online.

    19
  14. Entry "Karl Keating", English Wikipedia, consulted October 2026 : Keating was editor of This Rock for nine years after its launch in January 1990.

    20
  15. Karl Keating, Catholicism and Fundamentalism, Ignatius Press, 1988 : the book draws on a series of apologetics articles published over thirty weeks, notably in The Wanderer.

    25
  16. Karl Keating, "Present at the Creation", Catholic Answers Magazine, 1 July 2017 : his 1988 book presented by himself as the first sustained response to the inroads of modern fundamentalism, intended to stem the departure of Catholics to the so-called Bible churches. Original text : "My book Catholicism and Fundamentalism, which appeared in 1988, was the first sustained response to the inroads made by modern Fundamentalism".

    26
  17. Ignatius Press, author page "Karl Keating", ignatius.com/authors/karl-keating : founder and president of Catholic Answers, best-selling author of Catholicism and Fundamentalism, What Catholics Really Believe and Controversies: High-Level Catholic Apologetics.

    27
  18. Entry "Karl Keating", English Wikipedia : Catholicism and Fundamentalism, drawn from a thirty-week series in The Wanderer, is an enduring best-seller for its publisher Ignatius Press.

    28
  19. Karl Keating, Catholicism and Fundamentalism, Ignatius Press, 1988 : controversies treated, the authority of Scripture and Tradition, justification, purgatory, the primacy of the pope, Mary and the saints, the real presence in the Eucharist.

    29
  20. Dave Armstrong, account of a debate between Dave Hunt and Karl Keating in the Detroit area on the question "was the early Church Catholic?", published on his Patheos blog : Hunt argues that only the Bible can settle the matter, without citing a Church Father. Testimony of a committed Catholic apologist, cited for the format and subject.

    30
  21. "The Catholic Debates" audio box sets : public debates by Dave Hunt with Catholic apologists including Karl Keating, Robert Fastiggi, Keith Fournier, Gerry Matatics and Robert Sungenis.

    31
  22. Alpha and Omega Ministries, James White archives : discussions of Karl Keating's arguments, notably on the doctrines of grace, and a response to Eric Svendsen on the state of Catholic apologetics.

    32 57
  23. Jimmy Akin, Catholic Answers notices : staff member since 1993, longest-serving member of the apostolate, senior apologist.

    33 54
  24. Trent Horn, Catholic Answers notices : salaried apologist who joined in 2012, the year he completed his master's degree in theology at Franciscan University of Steubenville.

    34 55
  25. Ignatius Press, Karl Keating author catalogue : Catholicism and Fundamentalism, What Catholics Really Believe and The Ultimate Catholic Quiz in print and digital editions, consulted October 2026.

    35
  26. Karl Keating, What Catholics Really Believe: Setting the Record Straight, Servant Publications, Ann Arbor, 1992, 155 pages ; reissue Ignatius Press, 1995. Full subtitle : 52 answers to common misconceptions about the Catholic faith.

    36
  27. Karl Keating, Rasselas House titles, 2015 : Jeremiah's Lament ; No Apology ; Anti-Catholic Junk Food ; The New Geocentrists ; Apologetics the English Way. Bibliographic list from the entry "Karl Keating", English Wikipedia.

    37
  28. Karl Keating, Debating Catholicism, Rasselas House, 2017 : edited transcripts of public debates with professional anti-Catholics.

    38
  29. Karl Keating, 2017 titles : How to Fail at Hiking Mt. Whitney, How to Fail at Hiking Grand Canyon, The Bible Battle, High Desert Showdown, Tracking Down the True Church, Face Off with an Ex-Priest and Debating Catholicism at Rasselas House ; Booked for Life at Catholic Answers Press. Bibliographic list from the entry "Karl Keating", English Wikipedia.

    39
  30. Karl Keating, How to Fail at Hiking Mt. Whitney and How to Fail at Hiking Grand Canyon, Rasselas House, 2017.

    41
  31. Author presentation for What Catholics Really Believe : for fun, Keating hikes the peaks of the Sierra Nevada and the depths of the Grand Canyon. Text reproduced in the book-trade notices for the Servant Publications edition, 1992.

    42
  32. "Karl Keating," English Wikipedia, Catholic Answers section: complaint by Catholics for a Free Choice filed with the Internal Revenue Service in 2004, tax investigation described by Keating as costly and burdensome, creation of Catholic Answers Action as a separate 501(c)(4) entity, continued publication of the Voter's Guide for Serious Catholics and its five so-called non-negotiable questions.

    43 44 45
  33. Catholic Answers, official timeline, catholic.com/timeline: Christopher Check's succession as second president dated to 2016, following the February 2015 announcement.

    47
  34. Catholic Answers, "Karl Keating" profile: articles published after his June 30, 2017 retirement, including "The Faith Is Exciting If You Present It Right," February 13, 2018, and "Patriotism Begins at Home," July 3, 2019.

    53
  35. Catholic Answers, "About" page: independent nonprofit organization, listed in the Official Catholic Directory and recognized as a ministry in good standing by the Diocese of San Diego.

    56

Can’t find your topic?