Catholic Answers: the American apostolate of defending the faith (1979-)

Catholic Answers is an American apologetics apostolate founded in 1979 by Karl Keating. Tracts, radio, catholic.com website: history, figures and method.

Ignispedia

Catholic Answers is an American lay Catholic apostolate specializing in apologetics — that is, the explanation and reasoned defense of the Catholic faith. Founded in 1979 in San Diego by the lawyer Karl Keating, it answers objections against the Catholic Church, first through printed pamphlets, then through books, a magazine, a daily radio show, and the website catholic.com, now one of the largest databases of Catholic questions and answers in the English language.[1]

The name means "Catholic answers" in English. It states the program: to a precise question about the faith, give a precise answer, documented by Scripture, Tradition, and the Magisterium, in language accessible to the general public. Catholic Answers addresses Catholics who want to understand their faith, Protestants who are questioning Catholicism, and non-religious people seeking answers about God, the Church, and morality.

Catholic Answers is neither an organ of the Holy See nor a journalistic newsroom. It is a lay initiative, organized as a nonprofit association, which works in visible communion with the Magisterium and is recognized as an apostolate in the Diocese of San Diego.[2]

What is Catholic Answers?

A lay apostolate for the defense of the faith

Apologetics is the discipline that explains the reasons for belief and answers objections. Catholic Answers practices it in a popular form: short written answers, live radio dialogues, public debates, lectures, and training books. Its original audience was American, shaped by the controversies between Catholics and fundamentalist Protestants. Its current audience is worldwide, through the internet, and its questions also cover atheism, Islam, Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormonism, morality, and bioethics.

The apostolate claims an explicit fidelity to the teaching of the Church. Its official presentation puts it this way, in a sentence the article quotes in French:

« Catholic Answers travaille chaque jour à ce que son contenu soit fidèle au magistère. » (Catholic Answers, page de présentation officielle, catholic.com)[3]

This claimed fidelity is a commitment of the apostolate itself. It does not turn its answers into acts of the Magisterium: a pamphlet or a broadcast by Catholic Answers binds its authors, not the universal Church. The distinction matters for the reader: the apostolate is a service of explanation, recognized locally, not an official teaching authority.

A name born from a signature

The name Catholic Answers was not originally that of an organization. It was the signature placed at the bottom of a first reply, in 1979. Karl Keating signed "Catholic Answers," opened a post office box under that name, then placed his reply on the windshields of the cars at the fundamentalist church that had distributed the anti-Catholic tract.[4] The name stuck when the work became a full-time apostolate, nine years later.

History: from windshield tract to media

1979: a tract against the Eucharist

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The story begins on a Sunday in 1979, as Mass ended in San Diego. A local fundamentalist church had placed on every car in the parish parking lot a tract attacking the Eucharist and repeating classic accusations against the Catholic Church. Karl Keating, a lawyer in San Diego, found the tract on his windshield.[5]

He went home with a modest goal: to write a reply presenting the basic Catholic beliefs and refuting the tract's charges. The apostolate's official account summarizes this starting point as follows:

« Catholic Answers a commencé en 1979, quand notre fondateur, Karl Keating, avocat à San Diego, est sorti d'une messe et a trouvé sur son pare-brise un tract qui attaquait l'Eucharistie. » (Catholic Answers, récit officiel de fondation, catholic.com)[6]

Keating distributed his reply in the parking lot of the church that had issued the tract. The responses he received convinced him that a real need existed: many Catholics did not know how to answer objections, and many non-Catholics knew Catholicism only through caricatures. In the years that followed, he wrote other pamphlets on the main objections raised against the Catholic faith.

1986 to 1990: newsletter, then magazine

In August 1986, Keating launched a monthly newsletter, initially called Catholic Answers, to follow the activity of the nascent apostolate and to make apologetics better known.[7] In January 1990, this newsletter was replaced by This Rock, an apologetics and evangelization magazine published ten times a year, which the apostolate presents as having become the leading publication of its kind in the United States.[8] Patrick Madrid, who joined Catholic Answers in January 1988, was one of its co-founders and served the apostolate for eight years, until January 1996, notably as vice president.[9]

More than thirty years after 1990, the publication still exists under the name Catholic Answers Magazine, published online. It continues the same function: in-depth, signed articles dealing with a question of faith, history, or morality, with references.

1988: the book Catholicism and Fundamentalism

The year 1988 is the turning point. Keating closed his law practice and made Catholic Answers a full-time apostolate, with a first office and salaried staff.[10] That same year, he published with Ignatius Press Catholicism and Fundamentalism, a reworked collection of a series of apologetics articles published over thirty weeks in the Catholic press, notably in The Wanderer.[11]

The book answers point by point the fundamentalist objections of its time: Scripture alone, justification by faith alone, purgatory, the primacy of the pope, the veneration of Mary and the saints, and the real presence in the Eucharist. It became one of the most widely distributed works of Catholic apologetics in the English language and remains in print with its publisher. Its importance is historical as much as doctrinal: it gave a generation of American laypeople a model of calm, biblical, well-documented answers.

The timeline at a glance

  1. 1979
    The first tract

    In San Diego, Karl Keating answers in writing a fundamentalist tract left on the cars of a parish. He signs "Catholic Answers" and opens a post office box under that name.

  2. 1986
    The monthly newsletter

    Keating launches a monthly newsletter to make apologetics better known and to follow the apostolate's work.

  3. 1988
    Going full-time

    Keating closes his law practice, Catholic Answers becomes a full-time apostolate, and the book Catholicism and Fundamentalism is published by Ignatius Press.

  4. 1990
    This Rock

    The newsletter becomes the magazine This Rock, the future Catholic Answers Magazine.

  5. 1998
    Catholic Answers Live

    The daily live call-in show begins in January 1998. It will be carried notably by EWTN's radio network.

  6. 2013
    The annual conference

    The apostolate holds its first annual conference, bringing together its speakers and its audience.

  7. 2014
    The 20 Answers series

    Launch of the 20 Answers booklets, twenty questions and twenty short answers on a single topic.

  8. 2015-2016
    The passing of the torch

    Christopher Check was announced in February 2015 to succeed Karl Keating as president. The apostolate's official timeline places the succession in 2016, with Keating remaining on board as senior fellow.

1998 to today: radio, website and video

In January 1998, Catholic Answers Live began, a daily show in which listeners call in live to put their questions to an apologist.[12] The format is demanding: a Protestant objection, an atheist's question, a Catholic's doubt, a moral difficulty — every call receives an immediate answer, with no prepared script. Hosted notably by Cy Kellett, the show is broadcast on the EWTN radio network and released as a podcast.[13]

The catholic.com website has grown alongside the show: full-text tracts, an encyclopedia, categorised questions and answers, magazine articles, specialist videos and podcasts. The official timeline adds two recent milestones: a first annual conference in 2013 and the launch in 2014 of the 20 Answers booklet series.[14] The apostolate has also developed an online school of apologetics and video studios at its El Cajon headquarters in San Diego County.

The figures of Catholic Answers

Karl Keating, the lawyer founder

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Karl Keating was born in 1950. Trained in applied mathematics at the University of California, San Diego, and then in law at the University of San Diego, he practised as a lawyer for twelve years before closing his firm in 1988.[15] A Catholic since childhood, he is not a convert: his apologetics is born of a trained layman's reaction, refusing to leave accusations unanswered.

His principal written work is Catholicism and Fundamentalism (Ignatius Press, 1988). He led the apostolate from its foundation until his passing of the torch, announced in 2015 in favour of Christopher Check, former director of development who joined in 2012, previously associated with the Rockford Institute and a former officer in the Marine Corps.[16] Keating stayed on at the organisation as senior fellow, turning towards writing and lecturing.

📖 See the detailed article: Karl Keating, the founder of Catholic Answers

Jimmy Akin, the apologist of endless questions

Jimmy Akin was born on 24 August 1965. He joined Catholic Answers in 1993 and is its longest-serving collaborator, holding the title of senior apologist.[17] His path is the reverse of Keating's: raised in a Protestant background, he was received into the Catholic Church in 1992, shortly before joining the apostolate.[18]

Akin answers calls on Catholic Answers Live every week and writes for Catholic Answers Magazine. His books deal with the subjects where misunderstandings are most common: Mass Confusion on the liturgy of the Mass, The Salvation Controversy on salvation, The Fathers Know Best on the Church Fathers (Catholic Answers Press, 2010), Mass Revision on the translation of the Mass, and then The Drama of Salvation.[19] Since 2018 he has also hosted a podcast devoted to strange questions and mysteries — a sign that his method goes beyond mere controversy: start from a real question, even a bizarre one, and treat it with the sources.

📖 See the detailed article: Jimmy Akin, the apologist who answers everything

Trent Horn, the debater of the new generation

Trent Horn, born in 1985, is a salaried apologist at Catholic Answers and one of its most listened-to voices among younger audiences.[20] A convert to Catholicism, he studied history at Arizona State University, then theology at the Franciscan University of Steubenville, before further studies in philosophy.[21]

His books show how the questions have shifted between 1988 and today. Where Keating answered fundamentalists first and foremost, Horn answers atheists and the indifferent first: Answering Atheism on the existence of God, Persuasive Pro-Life on abortion, Hard Sayings on difficult passages of the Bible, The Case for Catholicism on classic and contemporary Protestant objections (Ignatius Press, 2017), and Why We're Catholic, a short, positive presentation of the reasons for the Catholic faith (Catholic Answers Press, 14 May 2017).[22] Since 2019, his podcast The Counsel of Trent has continued the same work in interview and debate format.

Horn's self-stated speciality is the manner: teaching Catholics to engage those who disagree with them with calm and persuasion rather than aggression. It is the contemporary version of the 1979 tract: the same function, different channels.

The other well-known faces

Tim Staples, a former Southern Baptist who became a Catholic after a path that took him among other things through the Marines, has served as the apostolate's director of apologetics and evangelisation.[23] Patrick Madrid, already mentioned, worked there from 1988 to 1996 before pursuing a personal career as author and editor. Christopher Check has led the organisation since the passing of the torch of 2015 and 2016.[24] Around them, the apostolate maintains a network of associated speakers, priests and laypeople, specialists in liturgy, history, bioethics, theology, philosophy and canon law.[25]

FigureDated roleMain contribution
Karl Keating (born 1950)Founder in 1979, president until the relay announced in 2015The first tract, Catholicism and Fundamentalism (1988), going full-time
Patrick MadridCollaborator from January 1988 to January 1996Co-founder of This Rock in 1990, vice-president
Jimmy Akin (born 1965)Since 1993, senior apologistRadio answers, Church Fathers, liturgy, difficult questions
Tim StaplesDirector of apologetics and evangelisationAnswers to Protestant objections, conversion testimony
Trent Horn (born 1985)Salaried apologist, podcast since 2019Debates with atheists and Protestants, Why We're Catholic (2017)
Christopher CheckPresident announced in 2015, succession placed in 2016 by the in-house timelineLeading the apostolate after Keating

The Catholic Answers method

The tract: one question, one short answer

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The original format is still alive. A Catholic Answers tract runs to just a few pages: a title that is often the objection itself, for example purgatory, praying to the saints, or calling a priest "father," followed by an answer that strings together Bible verses, testimonies from the early centuries, and the teaching of the Church. The tracts are published in full on catholic.com, sorted by subject: Scripture and Tradition, sacraments, Mary and the saints, salvation, morality, non-Christian religions.[26]

The strength of the format is its deliberate limitation: it replaces neither a theology course nor spiritual direction. It gives a hurried reader, or a Catholic caught off guard in a conversation, the first exact answers and the references to go further.

The listener's question: answering live, without a net

Catholic Answers Live moved the method from paper to voice. Two hours of live calls, one apologist, no question screened for ease. This setup says something about the apostolate's confidence in its material: the Catholic answer must be deliverable aloud, before witnesses, to an interlocutor who can reply. The show's archives, cut up by question, then feed the website and the podcasts.

The debate and the book: tackling the objection in its strongest form

The third layer is public debate and the substantive book. Keating against fundamentalists in 1988, Horn against atheist or Protestant opponents today: in both cases, the objection is first stated as the adversary would recognize it, then examined against the sources. The 20 Answers booklets, launched in 2014, condense this approach into twenty short questions on a single subject, for example Mormonism, Islam, or the Jehovah's Witnesses.[27]

What the method does not do

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Catholic Answers does not speak on behalf of bishops and does not settle questions that the Church herself leaves open to theologians. Its authority is that of its sources: when an answer cites a council, a pope, or the Catechism, it is that text that holds authority, not the apologist quoting it. French-speaking readers should also keep in mind that the apostolate reasons within the American context, where controversy with evangelical Protestantism shapes many of the questions. European or French objections, for example secularism or religious indifference, hold a smaller place there.

Catholic Answers' place

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Catholic Answers occupies a specific place among American Catholic initiatives. It is not a news outlet like Vatican News, nor a general-interest television and radio network like EWTN, which by the way broadcasts its daily show, nor a mainstream spirituality network like Aleteia. It is a tool for answering: you come with a question, you leave with a referenced answer and reading to continue with.

For the French-speaking reader, its interest is twofold. First as a working source: its tracts and questions and answers, cross-checked with the primary sources they cite, help prepare a response to almost every common objection. Then as a model of lay apostolate: an initiative born from a tract on a windshield, which became within a generation a complete media outlet, without ever leaving its single subject, explaining and defending the Catholic faith.

For further reading

The Catholic Answers website can be read at catholic.com: full-text tracts, questions and answers, Catholic Answers Magazine, and the Catholic Answers Live archives. To verify its history, the primary sources are the site's official about page and timeline, Karl Keating's book Catholicism and Fundamentalism (Ignatius Press, 1988), and the announcement of Christopher Check's succession in February 2015. In Ignispedia, read also EWTN, Vatican News, Aleteia, and Matthieu Lavagna for French-speaking apologetics.

Notes and References

  1. Catholic Answers, official "About" page and "Our Story" account, catholic.com: founded in 1979 in San Diego, a fundamentalist tract attacking the Eucharist left on the cars at a parish, a reply signed "Catholic Answers," a post office box opened under that name. Original text: "Catholic Answers started in 1979 when our founder, San Diego attorney Karl Keating, came out of Mass one day and found a flyer on his windshield that attacked the Eucharist".

    1 4 5 6
  2. Catholic Answers, "About" page: an independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, listed in the Official Catholic Directory and recognized as a bona fide apostolate by the Diocese of San Diego, where its main office is located.

    2
  3. Catholic Answers, "About" page. Original text: "Catholic Answers works each day to ensure our content is faithful to the Magisterium".

    3
  4. Catholic Answers, "About" page: the launch of a monthly newsletter in 1986, initially to report on the apostolate's work and introduce people to apologetics. Patrick Madrid gives the first issue as August 1986.

    7
  5. Catholic Answers, "About" page: in 1990, the newsletter was replaced by This Rock, an apologetics and evangelization magazine published ten times a year, later succeeded online by Catholic Answers Magazine.

    8
  6. Patrick Madrid, author biographical profiles: active in apologetics since 1987, employed by Catholic Answers for eight years, from January 1988 to January 1996, vice-president and co-founder of This Rock in January 1990.

    9
  7. Catholic Answers, "About" page: in 1988, Keating closed his law practice and made Catholic Answers a full-time apostolate, with its first office and staff.

    10
  8. Karl Keating, Catholicism and Fundamentalism, Ignatius Press, 1988. The book draws on a series of apologetics articles published over thirty weeks, notably in The Wanderer.

    11
  9. Catholic World Report, feature on Catholic Answers Live: producer Darin DeLozier recalls that the daily apologetics and evangelization program began in January 1998.

    12
  10. Catholic Answers, Catholic Answers Live page and broadcast FAQ: a daily live call-in show hosted by Cy Kellett, distributed notably by the EWTN radio network, terrestrial radio, and digital platforms. Catholic Answers stated in 2018 that it continued to provide its program free of charge to EWTN Radio and to independent stations.

    13
  11. Catholic Answers, official timeline, catholic.com/timeline: first annual conference in 2013, launch of the 20 Answers booklet series in 2014, construction of the G. K. Chesterton Studio in 2015, Christopher Check's succession as second president in 2016, and the launch of Catholic Answers Studios.

    14 27
  12. Karl Keating, biographical notice: born in 1950, degree in applied mathematics from the University of California, San Diego in 1972, then law and theology at the University of San Diego, twelve years practicing as a lawyer before 1988.

    15
  13. Catholic Answers, press release of 2 February 2015 distributed by Christian Newswire, and National Catholic Register, February 2015: Christopher Check, director of development since 2012, is appointed to succeed Karl Keating as president, with Keating remaining a senior fellow. The official timeline at catholic.com places the succession taking effect in 2016.

    16 24
  14. Jimmy Akin, Catholic Answers biographical notices: born 24 August 1965, a Catholic Answers contributor since 1993, presented as its longest-serving member, senior apologist, weekly guest on Catholic Answers Live, and contributor to Catholic Answers Magazine.

    17
  15. Jimmy Akin, conversion testimony: received into the Catholic Church in 1992. His account "A Triumph and a Tragedy" is published in the collection Surprised by Truth.

    18
  16. Jimmy Akin, Mass Confusion; The Salvation Controversy; The Fathers Know Best, Catholic Answers Press, 2010; Mass Revision; The Drama of Salvation. List taken from the author's official profiles at Catholic Answers.

    19
  17. Trent Horn, Catholic Answers notices: born in 1985, salaried apologist, a convert to Catholicism, a regular speaker on Catholic Answers Live, and host of the podcast The Counsel of Trent since 2019.

    20
  18. Trent Horn, author profiles: bachelor's degree in history from Arizona State University, theology degree from the Franciscan University of Steubenville, philosophy studies at Holy Apostles College.

    21
  19. Trent Horn, Answering Atheism; Persuasive Pro-Life; Hard Sayings; The Case for Catholicism, Ignatius Press, 2017; Why We're Catholic, Catholic Answers Press, 14 May 2017. Why We're Catholic is presented by the publisher as a presentation of the reasons for Catholic faith, hope, and charity.

    22
  20. Tim Staples, Catholic Answers profiles: raised a Southern Baptist, returned to the Christian faith in his late teens, served in the United States Marine Corps, then became director of apologetics and evangelization at Catholic Answers.

    23
  21. Catholic Answers, "About" page: the salaried apologists work with a broad network of associates, clergy and laity, experts in liturgy, history, bioethics, theology, philosophy, canon law, and other disciplines.

    25
  22. Catholic Answers, the tracts section of catholic.com, consulted in October 2026: themes of Scripture and Tradition, sacraments and worship, morality, Mary, saints and angels, salvation and the Church, non-Christian religions, purgatory, abortion, and end-of-life issues.

    26

Can’t find your topic?