Pope John XIII (Ioannes XIII) governed the Church of Rome from 1 October 965 to 6 September 972. The Holy See counts him as the 133rd pope of the Catholic Church, born in Rome, successor to Leo VIII and predecessor of Benedict VI.[1] His pontificate belongs to the first Ottonian papacy: after the violence of John XII, Leo VIII and Benedict V, Rome had to be stabilised under the watchful eye of Emperor Otto I.
John XIII was chosen in the presence of the imperial legates Liudprand of Cremona and Otgar of Speyer. Yet he was no mere German functionary placed over Rome: he was bishop of Narni, trained at the Lateran, a former Roman librarian, and a member of a powerful aristocratic milieu related to the families that had dominated Rome since Theodora, Marozia and Alberic II.[2][3] His person thus embodied the compromise of 965: a pope acceptable to the Empire, but Roman enough not to repeat the brutal failure of Leo VIII.
His pontificate was brief but eventful. It saw an almost immediate Roman revolt: on 16 December 965 the pope was manhandled, shut up in Castel Sant'Angelo, and then held in a fortified place in the Roman Campagna (the Campagna of Latium, not to be confused with the Campania of Naples). After taking refuge with Pandulf of Capua, he returned to Rome on 14 November 966; with the support of this prince and the approach of Otto, he then presided over a series of lasting acts: the synods of Rome and Ravenna, the elevation of Magdeburg for the mission to the Slavs, the consolidation of Capua and Benevento, the imperial coronation of the young Otto II on Christmas Day 967, and then the marriage of Otto II to the Byzantine princess Theophano on 14 April 972.[4][5][6]
John XIII therefore deserves more than a catalogue notice. He is the pope who turned Ottonian tutelage into a more stable system: Rome remained dependent on the emperor, but the Roman Church resumed genuine international activity, from England and France to Bohemia, Poland[7], eastern Germany and southern Italy.[8][9] His pontificate shows a papacy humiliated politically, yet still able to decide, to arbitrate, to consecrate and to organise the mission.
« En présence des envoyés impériaux Liudprand, évêque de Crémone, et Otgar, évêque de Spire, […] Jean, évêque de Narni, fut élu pape. » — Johann Peter Kirsch, Catholic Encyclopedia (traduction maison de l'anglais)[10]
Why does John XIII matter?
The first pope after the storm of 963–965
John XIII arrived after three years of almost uninterrupted crisis. John XII, a legitimate but gravely scandalous pope, was deposed by an imperial synod in December 963; Leo VIII was elected under pressure from Otto while John XII was still alive; Benedict V was elected by the Romans after the death of John XII, then deposed and sent to Hamburg; Leo VIII died in March 965.[11][12][13][14]
The choice of John XIII therefore cannot be read as an ordinary election. The vacancy lasted several months. The Romans first asked Otto for the return of Benedict V, but he died in Hamburg on 4 July 965. The emperor then sent Liudprand of Cremona and Otgar of Speyer to Rome to oversee the election of a new pope.[15][16]
The result was a compromise more astute than the imposition of Leo VIII. John XIII had imperial support, but he also belonged to the Roman world. Treccani insists on this point: the experience of Leo VIII had doubtless shown that Rome was better governed in collaboration with its ruling group than by treating it as an enemy.[17]
A Roman pope, but not a prisoner of Rome
The paradox of John XIII is plain. He was born into the Roman aristocracy, trained at the Lateran, had climbed the ranks of the Roman clergy, and had been librarian and bishop of Narni. But his election depended on the imperial presence, and his return after exile depended on Otto's intervention.[18]
This blend explains both his strength and his fragility. His strength: he knew Rome, its families, its offices, its networks and the ecclesiastical dossiers. His fragility: part of the nobility judged him too closely tied to the Empire, too authoritarian, too favourable to his own family. The revolt of December 965 arose precisely out of this tension.[19][20]
A pontificate of organisation rather than doctrine
John XIII left no great body of doctrine nor any dogmatic act comparable to the ancient councils. His importance is institutional. He organised sees, confirmed synods, granted privileges, dealt with questions of canon law and inserted the papacy into the Ottonian reconstruction of Christian Europe.[21][22]
Not all popes are doctors, saints or martyrs. John XIII ranks among the popes of organisation: after the crisis of 963–965, he inscribed the reassertion of control into lasting structures — dated synods, metropolitan sees erected, privileges confirmed.
Main Sources and Their Limits
Holy See, Encyclopedias, and Papal Acts
The official Holy See record provides the minimal reference points: 133th pope, pontificate beginning 1 October 965, ending 6 September 972, born in Rome.[23] The Catholic Encyclopedia by Johann Peter Kirsch provides the classic account: election under imperial legates, family origins, the Roman revolt, captivity in the Roman Campagna (the Campagna), refuge at Capua, return in November 966, synods, Magdeburg, Otto II and Theophano.[24]
The New Catholic Encyclopedia summarizes the same dossier, emphasizing the aristocratic opposition to the imperial election, the captivity, the return with Otto's support, the Cluniac reform, Ravenna, Magdeburg, and the burial at Saint Paul Outside the Walls.[25] Treccani, especially in the Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, is more precise about John's Roman career before the election, his ambiguities under John XII and Leo VIII, the sociology of the Roman revolt, the synods of 967, and the Byzantine negotiations.[26]
| Source | Nature | Main Contribution | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Holy See | Official list | Rank, dates, Roman origin | Very minimal notice |
| Catholic Encyclopedia | Older Catholic synthesis | Clear account of the pontificate and classic bibliography | Relies on Mann/Kirsch, without all the recent nuances |
| New Catholic Encyclopedia | Modern synthesis | Arrest, reform, Ravenna, Magdeburg, Theophano | Very short |
| Treccani DBI | Italian scholarly synthesis | Lateran career, Roman clans, synods, diplomacy | Requires a critical reading of political terms |
| Jaffé / papal regesta | Chronological repertories (each act summarized, with a reference to the full text) | Instrument cited by Mann for the letters of each pope: Regesta Pontificum Romanorum, 2nd ed., Leipzig, 1885 | Not sifted through act by act for this article: no original act is quoted directly from them |
| Liudprand | Ottonian witness | Imperial context and Byzantine diplomacy | A committed source in Otto's service |
| Liber Pontificalis | Medieval pontifical chronicle | Biographical framework for the popes of the 10th century, cited by Kirsch in his reference edition | Composite text, to be cross-checked with the acts and the Ottonian chronicles |
Kirsch's classic bibliography refers first to the Liber Pontificalis in the edition by Louis Duchesne (vol. II, pages 252-254), then to the Regesta Pontificum Romanorum by Philipp Jaffé (2nd edition, vol. I, from page 470).[27] These two instruments do not remove the need to read the acts themselves, but they establish the documentary foundation from which modern syntheses work.
Liudprand of Cremona: A Useful but Not Neutral Witness
Liudprand is omnipresent in the dossier. He had been a witness and interpreter of the events of 963–964; he is sent to Rome for the election of John XIII; he then carries the Ottonian word to Constantinople in 968. His notice in the Catholic Encyclopedia recalls that after the death of Leo VIII, Liudprand returned to Rome with Otgar of Speyer to conduct the election of the new pope, the occasion on which John XIII was chosen.[28]
But Liudprand is not a neutral chronicler. The neighboring articles on John XII, Leo VIII, and Benedict V already show that he writes to defend Otto's intervention. He must therefore be used as a first-hand witness of the imperial milieu, not as the final arbiter of Roman legitimacy.[29]
What We Do Not Know
The date of John XIII's birth is unknown. Modern notices state that he was born in Rome, without giving a date: no dating can therefore be written, not even an approximate one.[30][31] Nor do we possess any intimate spiritual portrait comparable to that of a saintly abbot or a Doctor of the Church.
Genealogy also calls for caution. Kirsch links John to the family of the elder Theodora, through the marriage of the younger Theodora with the consul John; Pauler, more precise, distinguishes two successive ties: the pope's brother, Benedict, had married Stephanie of Palestrina, niece of Senator Theophylact — hence the kinship with the Theophylactian milieu —, while the alliance with the Crescenzi came only from the marriage of the pope's nephew, Benedict, with Theodoranda, daughter of Crescenzio di Caballo Marmoreo, in May 967.[32][33] We must therefore retain the solid fact — high Roman aristocracy, Theophylactian kinship followed by a Crescentian alliance — without merging the two kinships into a single origin.
Origins and Career Before the Election
A Cleric Trained at the Lateran
Treccani gives the most valuable information about John's formation: he receives his religious education at the Lateran, he is highly cultivated, and he climbs in Rome all the degrees of priestly dignity, from the order of ostiarius (the doorkeeper, the first of the minor orders) to the diaconate, before becoming bishop of Narni.[34] This progression matters: unlike Leo VIII, promoted in a few days during the crisis of 963, John XIII is not a layman abruptly installed on the See of Rome.
His profile is that of a man of the ecclesiastical apparatus: trained in Roman institutions, accustomed to acts, archives, synods, and the balances between families. In 961, he is documented as bishop of Narni, and John XII entrusts him with the office of Roman librarian.[35]
Bishop of Narni and Roman Librarian
Narni is not a distant see cut off from Rome. The town lies in Umbria, in an area directly linked to the routes between Rome and central Italy. Being bishop of Narni gives John real episcopal experience without taking him away from Roman affairs.
The office of Roman librarian is even more revealing. In tenth-century Rome, the archives, privileges, and chancery formulas are an instrument of government. A pope who has been librarian knows the titles, rights, donations, imperial documents, and ecclesiastical files. This explains his later activity: confirmations of privileges, decisions of synods, organization of metropolitan sees, letters to foreign Churches.[36][37]
An Ambiguous Role Under John XII
The future John XIII appears in the dossier of 963 before his election. Treccani reports that in the spring of 963, he is part of a legation of John XII to Otto, with the mission, according to Liudprand, of deceiving the emperor about the pope's political intentions. Then, at the imperial synod of November 963, he appears as a witness for the prosecution against John XII.[38]
The fact is delicate. It shows that John is not a simple opponent of the Empire, but it also shows that he survived John XII's return without major sanction. Treccani draws a sociological conclusion from it: he belonged to an aristocratic milieu powerful enough to protect him despite his hostile attitude toward John XII.[39]
For the Catholic historian, this prevents writing an easy hagiography. John XIII is not a pure reformer rising up against the factions. He is a man of aristocratic Rome, shrewd enough to survive the reversals, and then competent enough to become the candidate of stabilization after Leo VIII.
The election of 1 October 965
A long and politically charged vacancy
Leo VIII dies in March 965. The Romans then ask Otto for the return of Benedict V, exiled to Hamburg since his deposition in 964. But Benedict dies on 4 July 965. The possibility of the exiled pope's return disappears, and the vacancy drags on.[40][41]
This vacancy of more than six months shows the scale of the problem. Rome cannot choose freely without taking the emperor into account; the emperor cannot simply impose a man hated by Rome without risking a fresh explosion. The election of John XIII is therefore an act of political repair as much as an ecclesial one.
Otto's legates: Liudprand and Otgar
Otto sends two representatives: Liudprand, Bishop of Cremona, and Otgar, Bishop of Speyer. The Catholic Encyclopedia explicitly names them as present at the election.[42] Their presence means that the emperor does not leave Rome to decide alone. But it also means that the election is carried out by bishops, not by a purely military occupation.
"The emperor's candidate, John, Bishop of Narni, was elected pope and crowned on 1 October 965 under the name of John XIII." — Johann Peter Kirsch, Catholic Encyclopedia (own translation from the English)[43]
Treccani strongly nuances the idea of a purely imperial appointment: John XIII was not chosen exclusively by the will of the emperor, even though the imperial legates made their influence felt. This is the key formula of the pontificate: real imperial influence, but necessary Roman reception.[44]
Why John, and not someone else?
John has four advantages. He is Roman; he belongs to local high society; he is not morally discredited like John XII; he is not canonically problematic like Leo VIII during the first phase of his pontifical career. Moreover, his bishopric at Narni and his post as librarian give him genuine ecclesial competence.[45][46]
This choice therefore answers the question of 965: how to give Otto a reliable pope without humiliating Rome a second time? The answer is John XIII. The fact that the revolt breaks out anyway three months later shows that the compromise was fragile, but not absurd.
The Roman revolt of December 965
Arrest at Castel Sant'Angelo
On 16 December 965, barely three months after his election, John XIII is attacked by a Roman coalition. Treccani names several actors: Peter, the city prefect appointed by the emperor; Stephen, the vestiarius (the vestararius, administrator of the treasury and the papal wardrobe); Roffred, Count of the Roman Campagna (the comes Campaniae, that is, of the territory of Latium around Rome, not of Neapolitan Campania); the consuls and the decarchoi, that is, leaders of the Roman people.[47] The revolt is therefore not simply a mob movement; it involves urban and aristocratic functions.
The Catholic Encyclopedia reports that the nobles hostile to the pope, because he was the imperial candidate and because he sought to curb their encroachments, seized his person in December 965, shut him up in Castel Sant'Angelo, then transferred him to a fortified stronghold in the Roman Campagna (the Campagna of Latium).[48]
"They shut him up in Castel Sant'Angelo, then carried him off to a fortified place in the Campagna [the Roman Campagna]." — Johann Peter Kirsch, Catholic Encyclopedia (own translation from the English)[49]
The grievances: arrogance, family, Roman power
Treccani specifies that the documented grievances bear mainly on arrogance towards the Curia and the favour shown to his own relatives.[50] This precision matters. The opponents do not first contest his doctrine, nor even the transfer from Narni to Rome. They contest his style of government and his redistribution of power.
The pontificate of John XIII thus stands at the crossroads of three conflicts: Rome against the Empire, Roman families against one another, and pope against the local curia. It is a very concrete theatre, far from an abstract vision of the papacy. Sacred institutions function amid families, offices, honours, grudges and calculations.
A paradoxical sign of legitimacy
Treccani points out an important detail: during the eleven months of exile, no attempt to elect another pope took place in Rome, even though John's transfer from Narni to Rome could have provided a canonical pretext.[51] The fact is crucial for reception.
The Romans revolt against John, but they do not replace him. They humiliate him, neutralise him, move him; they do not set up a rival succession. This distinguishes his case from those of Leo VIII and Benedict V. In 965–966 there is violence against the pope, but no complete pontifical schism.
Captivity in the Roman Campagna, Refuge in Capua, and the Return of 14 November 966
Flight to Pandulf of Capua
After his captivity in the Roman Campagna, where he had been placed under the guard of Count Roffred, John XIII eventually escaped. The Catholic Encyclopedia states that he found welcome and protection with Prince Pandulf of Capua, in southern Campania — a different territory from the place of his detention.[52] Treccani specifies that after Roffred's murder by John of Crescenzio de Caballo Marmoreo, the pope was able to take refuge with Pandulf in early summer 966.[53]
This refuge had an institutional consequence: in gratitude for the protection he had received, John raised Capua to the rank of ecclesiastical metropolis and appointed Pandulf's brother, also named John, as archbishop.[54][55] The decision can be read as a political reward, but also as a real organisation of the southern Church.
The Role of the Imperial Approach
John does not return merely because he has escaped. He returns because the emperor is approaching. When Otto undertakes a new Italian expedition in 966, the Romans take fright and allow the pope to return to the city on 14 November 966.[56]
Treccani describes a solemn return: John celebrates Mass at St. Peter's, takes possession of the Lateran, and blesses the rejoicing people, who implore his pardon, while banquets are held.[57] The scene is almost liturgical: the city that had expelled the pope receives him again as shepherd. But the background remains political: without Otto, the return would probably have been impossible.
Otto's Vengeance and the Pope's Severity
The repression is harsh. Kirsch reports that the emperor arrives in December and metes out stern justice: several conspirators are hanged, others banished.[58] Treccani gives more brutal details: consuls sent into exile beyond the Alps, twelve decarchs hanged, Prefect Peter handed over to the pope, publicly humiliated, suspended by his hair from the equestrian statue of Constantine, paraded naked backwards on a donkey, and then imprisoned before being exiled to Germany.[59]
This must be written without complacency. John XIII is not merely a pious victim. He takes part in a harsh political culture in which bodily and public humiliation is a language of power. Catholicism has nothing to gain by artificially softening the 10th century. It is enough to make the distinction: the pontifical office remains sacred; certain political behaviours of the popes are not exemplary.
The Synods of Rome and Ravenna
Rome, January 967: A Synod Whose Details Elude Us
The Catholic Encyclopedia mentions a synod held at St. Peter's on 11 January 967, but adds that its results are unknown.[60] Treccani links this gathering to a document of Otto's for the Abbey of Subiaco, issued at Rome on 11 January 967 (shelfmark given by Pauler: Die Urkunden, n. 336), in the presence of the emperor, the pope, the archbishop of Ravenna, Italian and transalpine bishops, Pandulf, and ecclesiastical and lay dignitaries.[61]
The certain point, then, is the existence of a great ecclesiastical and political gathering around the pope and the emperor. Several questions appear to have been referred to Ravenna, because the Roman synod could not deal with everything.[62]
Ravenna, April 967: Canon Law and Imperial Policy
John XIII accompanies Otto to Ravenna, where a synod opens around mid-April in the church of the monastery of San Severo in Classe (the church of Saint Severus in Classe, near Ravenna). Treccani indicates that it lasted at least until 25 April 967 and dealt both with questions of canon law and with the great political and ecclesial projects of the Empire.[63]
The Catholic Encyclopedia summarises its effects: confirmation of the elevation of Magdeburg to a metropolis, settlement of disputes, privileges granted to churches and monasteries, and the restitution of Ravenna and its territory to the pope as part of the Papal States.[64]
Arold of Salzburg and Discipline
The synod of Ravenna dealt in particular with Arold, archbishop of Salzburg, excommunicated and blinded, who despite the interdict continued to celebrate Mass and to wear the pallium (the band of white wool, the insignia of metropolitan archbishops). Treccani reports that on 25 April the council condemned him, along with those who supported him (Pauler refers to the acts: Zimmermann, Papsturkunden, 1988, n. 351).[65]
This detail shows that the pontificate is not reducible to the Rome–Otto axis. John XIII also deals with episcopal discipline: an archbishop deprived of communion cannot go on acting as if nothing were amiss. The ecclesiastical order, even in a politically violent age, retains its norms.
Ravenna and the Papal States
The synod of Ravenna also has a territorial dimension. In exchange for papal collaboration, Otto restores to the Roman Church territories of the Exarchate which, despite the Privilegium Ottonianum of 962, had not actually come into the pope's possession. Treccani mentions in particular the urban territory of Ravenna, the region of Comacchio, and the county of Ferrara; but the emperor in practice retains a form of administration through Empress Adelaide.[66]
The gesture is typical of the Ottonian balance: the emperor gives back to the pope, but he frames what he gives back. The papacy recovers rights; the Empire keeps its hand in. John XIII advances, but in a watched space.
Magdeburg and the mission to the Slavs
An old project of Otto's
The major decision of the Synod of Ravenna is the approval of the erection of Magdeburg as a missionary archbishopric for the evangelisation of the Slavs. John XII had already approved the project in 962, but the opposition of the Archbishop of Mainz and the Bishop of Halberstadt had delayed its implementation.[67][68]
John XIII approved the project at Ravenna on 20 April, on condition of the consent of the Archbishop of Mainz and the Bishop of Halberstadt. After the death of the two opponents, William of Mainz and Bernard of Halberstadt, in 968, the foundation could be set in motion between February and March 968.[69][70]
Adalbert, first archbishop
In October 968, Adalbert, already a bishop after his mission to Russia, presented himself in Rome with the necessary letters of consent. On 18 October 968, John XIII conferred upon him the archiepiscopal dignity in Rome and granted numerous privileges to his Church.[71] The installation in Magdeburg, for its part, took place at Christmas 968: Adalbert there took possession of his see as first archbishop and subsequently consecrated the first bishops of Merseburg, Meissen and Zeitz.[72][73]
We must therefore distinguish the Roman concession of 18 October 968 and the installation in Magdeburg at Christmas 968, followed by the organisation of the suffragans (the bishops placed under the authority of the new metropolitan): John XIII is the pope who put the foundation of Magdeburg into effect.
A missionary geography
Magdeburg became a bridgehead for the evangelisation of the Western Slavs. The New Catholic Encyclopedia states that Magdeburg and its suffragans became the headquarters of the conversion of the Slavs.[74] One must grasp the scope of this decision: the eastern frontier of Latin Christendom is not only military; it is episcopal, monastic, liturgical and missionary.
| See | Role in the project | Status under John XIII |
|---|---|---|
| Magdeburg | Missionary metropolis desired by Otto | Approved and organised under John XIII |
| Merseburg | Suffragan for the Slavic regions | First organisation linked to Adalbert |
| Meissen | Eastern Saxon see | Mentioned in the creation of the first bishoprics |
| Zeitz | Missionary see | Consecrated in the same group |
Evangelisation must not be confused with pure imperial expansion. It is intertwined with conquest, certainly, but it also brings the episcopate, the sacraments, Latin writing, monastic life and the gradual integration of entire peoples into Christendom. John XIII is one of the popes who gave canonical shape to this transition.
Capua, Benevento and southern Italy
Capua rewarded for receiving the pope
John XIII elevated Capua to the rank of ecclesiastical metropolis at the beginning of his pontificate, in gratitude to Pandulf who had received him during his exile.[75][76] This decision directly linked a political favour to an ecclesiastical structure.
It would be naive to ignore the dimension of reward. But it would also be too superficial to see in it nothing but political nepotism. Southern Italy is a strategic space between Lombards, Byzantines, Saracens, Rome and the Empire. Organising metropolitan sees there carries real pastoral and diplomatic weight.
Benevento, metropolis in 969
At the Roman synod of 969, Benevento in turn received the metropolitan dignity.[77] This elevation completed the Roman support for the southern Lombard principality and strengthened the ecclesiastical organisation of the South.
Capua and Benevento thus form a diptych. Both cities are politically important, close to Pandulf and the Ottonian network, and situated in a region where Rome must come to terms with Byzantine power and Lombard realities.
The balance with Byzantium
Southern Italy is also the place where the Ottonian Empire and the Byzantine Empire confront one another. The negotiations surrounding the marriage of Otto II with a princess of Constantinople cannot be separated from this geography. The Byzantines seek to limit the Ottonian claims over Capua and Benevento; Otto seeks the recognition of his imperial dignity by the East.[78]
John XIII therefore worked in a very tense zone. His southern policy is not merely local; it touches on the great question of the tenth century: how can the Western Empire restored by Otto coexist with the Eastern Roman Empire?
Otto II and Theophano
The coronation of 25 December 967
On Christmas Day 967, the young Otto II, about twelve or thirteen years old, came to Rome and received from John XIII the imperial crown as co-emperor alongside his father.[79][80] The act secured dynastic continuity for the Ottonians. It prevented the Empire from having to reopen a crisis of legitimacy upon the death of Otto I.
This coronation also confirmed the Roman role: even in a dependent papacy, the imperial crown passed through the altar of Peter. The emperor protects Rome; Rome sacralises the emperor. This reciprocity is powerful, but dangerous if either party absorbs the other.
The Byzantine negotiations
John XIII favoured negotiations with Constantinople for a marriage between Otto II and a Byzantine princess. The first target, according to Treccani, was Anna Porphyrogénita, daughter of Romanus II. Tensions with Nikephoros Phokas delayed the agreement; the situation changed after the assassination of Nikephoros and the accession of John I Tzimiskes, who sent his relative Theophano.[81]
Liudprand of Cremona, sent to Constantinople in 968, bears witness to the diplomatic humiliations suffered by the Ottonians. His Relatio de legatione Constantinopolitana is a vehement text against the Byzantins, but it reveals the issue at stake: to have the imperial dignity of the Ottonian West recognised by the East.[82]
The marriage of 14 April 972
On 14 April 972, in Rome, John XIII crowned Theophano empress and blessed her marriage to Otto II.[83][84] The act is one of the diplomatic high points of the pontificate. It dynastically united the Ottonian house with a princess from the imperial East.
Its significance goes beyond the family. The marriage gave Otto II Byzantine prestige; it eased some of the tensions surrounding southern Italy; it established Rome as the ritual place where the Germanic West and the Byzantine East could meet. John XIII was not the master of this game, but he was its sacramental mediator.
« The marriage took place in Rome and was blessed by the pope himself on 14 April 972. » — Johann Peter Kirsch, Catholic Encyclopedia (in-house translation from the English)[85]
The pope's international activity
England and France
The Catholic Encyclopedia reports that John XIII confirmed decrees of synods held in England and in France.[86] The entry does not detail these synods, but the fact is significant: despite Ottonian domination, the papacy continued to be consulted beyond the imperial sphere.
Along the same lines, the New Catholic Encyclopedia stresses that the pope and the emperor encouraged the spread of the Cluniac reform.[87] John XIII thus belongs to a papacy beginning to recover a role of international validation of ecclesiastical reforms.
Cluny and monastic privileges
John XIII granted privileges to churches and monasteries, especially to Cluny according to Kirsch.[88] The detail extends a line already visible under John XI, Leo VII, Marinus II and Agapet II: in a politically damaged century, the popes protect the monastic centres that would carry the reform.
Cluny is no pious footnote. The Burgundian abbey became in the eleventh century one of the great engines of liturgical, monastic and ecclesial purification. Every pontifical privilege that protects it against local powers helps make the future reform possible.
The project of a see at Prague
Kirsch notes that the plan of the Bohemian duke Boleslav II to found a see at Prague was approved by John XIII, but had to be postponed.[89] This point connects the pontificate to the beginnings of the ecclesiastical organisation of Bohemia.
Here again, the pope acts less as a doctrinal writer than as an architect of structures. He confirms, postpones, organises, authorises. This is the discreet yet decisive share of Roman government: to give canonical form to the growth of the Church among newly Christianised peoples.
Death, burial, and succession
The death of 6 September 972
John XIII dies in Rome on 6 September 972.[90][91] His death occurs a few months after the marriage of Theophano and Otto II. The great diplomatic act of his pontificate is thus almost his last visible act.
The New Catholic Encyclopedia states that he was buried at Saint Paul Outside the Walls.[92] This place suits his pontificate: an apostolic basilica outside the dense city, linked to the Pauline mission, and situated in this Rome where the Church survives internal violence by keeping its sacred places.
Benedict VI and the continuation of the Ottonian papacy
His successor is Benedict VI, elected in late 972 and whose pontificate begins in January 973, with his consecration on 19 January.[93][94] The stability does not last long: the death of Otto I in 973 will open new tensions in Rome, and Benedict VI himself will be seized by the faction of Crescentius and the deacon Boniface, held in the Castel Sant'Angelo, and then strangled in 974 to prevent his release by Sicco, the envoy of Otto II.[95] The detail belongs to the neighbouring article Benedict VI.
The sequence reminds us that John XIII did not definitively pacify Rome. He stabilised a phase, not cured the system. The Ottonian papacy remains vulnerable to the Roman families as soon as the emperor withdraws or dies.
What does John XIII reveal?
A protected papacy, therefore a dependent one
John XIII shows that imperial aid can save a pope without fully freeing the Church. Otto enables him to be elected, to return to Rome, to punish the rebels, and to organise great synods. But this protection has a price: the pope must govern within the imperial orbit, support Magdeburg, crown Otto II, and take part in the Byzantine strategy.
One should not caricature Otto. His actions bring an end to part of the Roman chaos and make an institutional recovery possible. But the Gregorian Reform will show, a century later, that the Church cannot live durably under the political guarantee of a prince, however Christian.
An international papacy despite Rome
The other lesson is positive. Despite exile, revolt, and dependence, John XIII acts on a wide map: Rome, Ravenna, Capua, Benevento, Magdeburg, Meissen, Merseburg, Zeitz, Prague, Cluny, England, France, Constantinople. The pope is not merely a city bishop caught up in its clans; he remains the visible centre of a European communion.
This tension is one of the hallmarks of medieval Catholicism. The Roman See can be politically humiliated at home while remaining sought after abroad as arbiter, source of privileges, and point of communion.
Was John XIII merely the emperor's candidate?
The objection is serious and must be stated without weakening it: a pope elected in the presence of Otto's legates, driven out by the Romans and then brought back by the imperial advance, would he be merely an official of the Empire installed on the see of Peter? Kirsch himself calls John the "emperor's candidate", and the repression of December 966 shows what this protection cost in dependence.[96][97]
Three facts nevertheless prevent stopping there. First, John is not an outsider imposed on Rome: bishop of Narni, trained at the Lateran and Roman librarian, he belongs to the clergy and aristocracy of the City, and Treccani makes clear that he was not chosen by the imperial will alone.[98] Next, during his eleven months of exile, the Romans who had arrested him elected no other pope, even though his transfer from Narni to Rome could have served as a canonical pretext: they contested his government, not his legitimacy.[99] Finally, his acts go beyond service to Otto: the metropolitan sees of Capua and Benevento, privileges to Cluny, confirmations for England and France, approval of the Prague project and the organisation of Magdeburg outline a Roman government active throughout Latin Christendom.[100]
The right answer therefore holds both ends: John XIII owes his election and his return to Otto, and this debt binds him lastingly to the Empire; but he governs as a Roman pope, with his own competence and network. Reducing him to an imperial candidate makes precisely what his pontificate built disappear.
Reform is also born of these humiliations
John XIII is not yet Gregory VII. He does not claim the full libertas Ecclesiae (the freedom of the Church in the face of secular powers) against the Empire. But his pontificate indirectly prepares the question. By dint of depending on lay protectors to survive the Roman factions, the Church understands that it needs a deeper reform: freedom of elections, the fight against simony, clerical discipline, and the purification of relations with princes.
In this sense, John XIII is a pope of transition. He is not great through a treaty, a canonisation, or a dogmatic definition; he is important because he makes visible the passage from the Roman saeculum obscurum to the Ottonian age, and then, in outline, to the future Gregorian Reform.
Chronology
- March 965Death of Leo VIIIEnd of the pope imposed then accepted after the crisis of 963–964
The death of Leo VIII leaves Rome without a pope, but the memory of Benedict V, exiled to Hamburg, remains alive.
- 4 July 965Death of Benedict V in HamburgThe Roman request for his return becomes impossible
The Romans had asked for his return; his death allows Otto to oversee a new election.
- 1 October 965Election of John XIIIBishop of Narni, a candidate acceptable to the Empire and Rome
The election takes place in the presence of the imperial legates Liudprand of Cremona and Otgar of Speyer.
- 16 December 965Roman revoltThe pope is arrested, confined in the Castel Sant'Angelo, then exiled
The Roman nobles reject his government and his closeness to the Empire.
- 14 November 966Solemn return to RomeJohn XIII retakes St Peter's and the Lateran
The return takes place with the support of Pandulf of Capua and the approach of Otto I.
- April 967Synod of RavennaMagdeburg, Ravenna, ecclesiastical discipline
John XIII and Otto together settle several matters of canon law and missionary organisation.
- 25 December 967Coronation of Otto IIThe young son of Otto I becomes co-emperor
The Ottonian dynastic continuity receives its liturgical sanction in Rome.
- 968Organisation of MagdeburgAdalbert becomes the first archbishop
The new metropolitan see structures the Latin mission to the Western Slavs.
- 14 April 972Marriage of Otto II and TheophanoDynastic alliance with Byzantium
John XIII crowns Theophano empress and blesses her marriage to Otto II.
- 6 September 972Death of John XIIIBurial at Saint Paul Outside the Walls
The pontificate ends a few months after his great eastern diplomatic act.
Further reading
- Pope Agapet II (946-955) — the pope of the Rome of Alberic II before John XII.
- Pope John XII (c. 937-964) — the scandalous pope whose crisis opens the Ottonian age.
- Pope Leo VIII (963-965) — the immediate predecessor, imposed and then received amid the crisis.
- Pope Benedict V (964-965) — the Roman pope deposed by Otto and who died in exile in Hamburg.
- The Gregorian reform — the later response to lay domination of ecclesiastical elections.
Notes and References
Holy See, official profile "John XIII" (accessed 4 October 2026): 133rd pope of the Catholic Church, pontificate beginning 1.X.965, ending 6.IX.972, born in Rome. Counting convention: the Holy See's current list numbers Leo VIII as the 131st pope and Benedict V as the 132nd pope (no antipope interposed in 963-965), hence John XIII as 133rd. URL: https://www.vatican.va/content/vatican/en/holy-father/giovanni-xiii.html.
1 23 30 90Johann Peter Kirsch, "Pope John XIII", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent: election on 1 October 965 in the presence of Liudprand and Otgar; Roman family origin; arrest in December 965; refuge with Pandulf of Capua; return to Rome on 14 November 966; synod of Rome, synod of Ravenna, Magdeburg, coronation of Otto II, marriage to Theophano, privileges to Cluny and approval of the Prague project. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08427a.htm.
2 4 9 13 16 19 21 24 32 36 42 46 48 52 55 56 58 60 64 67 70 72 75 77 79 83 86 88 89 91 100Roland Pauler, "Giovanni XIII, papa", Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 55, Istituto dell'Enciclopedia Italiana, 2001, Treccani: religious training at the Lateran, culture, ecclesiastical degrees, bishop of Narni documented in 961, Roman librarian, ambiguous role in 963, election of 1 October 965 after a long vacancy, revolt of 16 December 965, exile, refuge with Pandulf, return on 14 November 966, repression, synods of 967, Magdeburg, Ravenna, Byzantine negotiations and the marriage of Theophano. URL: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/papa-giovanni-xiii_%28Dizionario-Biografico%29/.
3 6 8 14 15 17 18 20 26 33 34 35 37 38 39 40 44 45 47 50 51 53 54 57 59 61 62 63 65 66 68 69 71 76 78 81 84 97 98 99S. McKenna, "John XIII, Pope", New Catholic Encyclopedia, republished by Encyclopedia.com: pontificate from 1 October 965 to 6 September 972; born in Rome, no date (a simple "b. Rome"); bishop of Narni; opposition of the Roman nobles, captivity in the Campagna, return with Otto's support; Cluniac reform; synod of Ravenna; coronation of Otto II; marriage to Theophano; Magdeburg and burial at Saint Paul Outside the Walls. URL: https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/john-xiii-pope.
5 22 25 31 74 80 87 92Roland Pauler, "Giovanni XIII, papa", Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 55, Treccani (online edition, unpaginated): « dai più vari regni europei, fossero l'Inghilterra, la Francia o la Polonia, giungevano continuamente postulanti che richiedevano consigli e giudizi su questioni ecclesiastiche, o anche privilegi. » The mention of Poland pertains to these requests and privileges; Pauler, however, documents no specific act regarding a status for Jordan of Poznań in 968, which is therefore not alleged here. URL: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/papa-giovanni-xiii_%28Dizionario-Biografico%29/.
7Johann Peter Kirsch, "Pope John XIII", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent. English original: "In presence of the imperial envoys, Liutprand, Bishop of Cremona, and Otgar, Bishop of Speyer, the emperor's candidate, John, Bishop of Narni, was elected pope, and crowned on 1 October, 965, as John XIII." The quotations in the body are our own translation (Liutprand rendered Liudprand following French usage). URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08427a.htm.
10 43 96See the Ignispedia article Pope Leo VIII (963-965), sections on the contested election of December 963, the deposition of Benedict V, the role of Liudprand and the later reception of Leo VIII.
11 29See the Ignispedia article Pope Benedict V (964-965), sections on the election of May 964, the deposition by Otto, the exile in Hamburg and the death of 4 July 965.
12 41Johann Peter Kirsch, "Pope John XIII", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent, final bibliography: "Liber Pontificalis, ed. Duchesne, II, 252-4; Jaffé, Regesta Rom. Pont., I (2nd ed.), 470 sqq." URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08427a.htm.
27S. Vailhé, "Liutprand of Cremona", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 9, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent: Liudprand accompanies Otto's interventions in the affairs of the Holy See, returns to Rome after the death of Leo VIII with Otgar of Speyer to conduct the election of John XIII, then leaves in 968 for Constantinople to negotiate the marriage of Otto II. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09313a.htm.
28 82Johann Peter Kirsch, "Pope John XIII", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent. English original: "They shut him up in the Castle of Sant' Angelo, and subsequently removed him to a fortified place in Campagna." The quotation in the body is our own translation. "Campagna" here means the Roman Campagna (the Latium around Rome, where Pauler places the exile under the surveillance of Count Roffred: « esiliato nella Campagna »), not the Neapolitan Campania where Capua is located. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08427a.htm.
49Diocese of Magdeburg, « Bistum Magdeburg - Geschichte »: Adalbert receives the pallium from the pope in Rome on 18 October 968 and is then installed in Magdeburg at Christmas 968. URL: https://www.bistum-magdeburg.de/bischof-bistum/bistum/geschichte.
73Johann Peter Kirsch, "Pope John XIII", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910, republished by New Advent. English original: "The marriage took place at Rome, and was blessed by the pope himself on 14 April, 972." The quotation in the body is our own translation. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08427a.htm.
85Holy See, official profile "Benedict VI": 134th pope of the Catholic Church, pontificate beginning indicated as December 972 or 19 January 973, ending in July 974, born in Rome. URL: https://www.vatican.va/content/vatican/fr/holy-father/benedetto-vi.html.
93Horace K. Mann, "Pope Benedict VI", The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 2, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1907, republished by New Advent: cardinal-deacon of Saint Theodore, elected after John XIII towards the end of 972, consecrated on 19 January 973 after awaiting imperial consent; Mann also reports the tragic end: seized by the faction of Crescentius, detained in the Castle of Sant' Angelo, then strangled after less than two months to prevent his release by Sicco, Otto II's envoy. URL: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02428c.htm.
94 95