The Limits of Evolutionary Theory

Twelve scientific, historical, and theological arguments (fossils, Cambrian explosion, irreducible complexity, mathematics) that call Darwinian macroevolution into question, and an examination of its difficult compatibility with the Catholic faith. It is not up to God to save a theory that does not work.

Ignispedia

Why are living things alike, yet so different? The theory of evolution offers an answer. This article first explains it fairly, then presents the main difficulties it faces. It distinguishes between what we observe directly, what we reconstruct about the past, and questions that biology cannot answer on its own. Finally, it shows what the Catholic faith teaches about human origins.

1. What the theory of evolution proposes

The theory of evolution states that living things share a common history. According to its supporters, ancient populations are thought to have slowly changed, then split into different branches. Living things today would therefore descend from common ancestors. This history would resemble an enormous family tree.

This does not mean that a chimpanzee living today became a human being. Instead, the model proposes that humans and chimpanzees shared a common ancestor. Their lineages would then have followed different paths. We need to start with this accurate account to discuss the theory without misrepresenting it.

Charles Darwin presented this theory in On the Origin of Species, published in 1859. He explained these changes through small variations passed on to offspring. Some would help living things survive or reproduce in a particular environment. They would then become more common over the generations.

This is called natural selection. Living things with an advantageous trait survive or reproduce more, and pass it on. This sorting process involves no conscious decision by nature. An advantage also depends on the environment in which the living thing lives.

To understand the current version of the theory, we need a few terms. A cell is a very small living unit that living things are made of. Some living things have just one. Others are made of a huge number of cells working together.

An animal cell contains different parts that work together. The numbers identify these parts: you do not need to remember them to follow the article. Diagram from Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

DNA is a substance found in cells. It carries many of the instructions needed for living things to function. A gene is a section of DNA that a cell uses to make or control something. A mutation is a change in DNA that can be passed on to offspring.

The modern version of the theory mainly combines mutations and natural selection. Mutations produce variations. Selection sorts their effects. Saying that a mutation is random means that it does not occur in response to a living thing's needs.

According to this model, the build-up of small changes would explain all the diversity of life over vast periods of time. Dates in millions or billions of years belong to this reconstruction. Ignispedia, for its part, accepts the short biblical chronology: a world about six thousand years old. A dogma is a truth that the Church has defined as something all Catholics must believe. This chronology is not a dogma, but a traditional reading, presented below with those who have supported it.

The debate is mainly about how much the proposed mechanism can explain. Does it explain only small adaptations, or also the appearance of bodies organised in new ways? Even researchers who support evolution are calling for the model to be revised. The Austrian biologist Gerd B. Müller wrote in 2017:

“A growing number of publications call for a major revision or even a replacement of the standard theory of evolution.”[1]

Müller does not argue for creation. He proposes adding other mechanisms to mutations and selection. His comment shows that this pair, often presented as the driving force behind everything, is debated within biology itself.

2. Observed variations: what do they prove?

Dog breeds do not all have the same size or appearance. Yet they all belong to the same species. Biologists classify living things into groups called species, bringing together living things that are very similar despite their differences. Variations within a species are observed every day. No one disputes them in this debate.

These variations passed on within a species are called microevolution. The much larger changes proposed to explain the appearance of major groups of living things, such as fish or birds, are called macroevolution. Supporters of the theory think the second is simply the first added up over vast periods of time. Its critics reply that this step has not been demonstrated.

Bacteria are living things made of a single cell. Antibiotics are medicines used against certain bacteria. A population of bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic. This is a real, measurable, and sometimes very important change.

But becoming resistant does not mean building a new machine inside the cell. The biochemist Michael Behe, a specialist in the chemistry of living things, points out that many adaptations studied alter, damage, or switch off existing functions.

Since 1988, the biologist Richard Lenski has been growing populations of bacteria in a laboratory. His experiment had passed 75,000 generations by 2022. It allows adaptations to be observed directly across a very long line of descendants. It therefore holds an important place in the debate about the limits of Lenski's experiment.

Its most famous result concerns citrate. This is a substance that these bacteria cannot normally use as food when oxygen is present. Around generation 31,500, one lineage acquired this ability. The press saw it as direct proof of evolution.

In 2016, another team studied this change closely. By directly selecting bacteria able to use citrate, it obtained the same type of change in just 12 to 100 generations. The mechanism reuses two pieces of equipment already present in the cell, whose use has changed. In this specific case, no entirely new gene appeared.[2]

The bacteria involved remain members of the same species. However, this study does not prove that no new features exist elsewhere in the entire experiment. Its conclusion applies to the mechanism studied.

It would also be wrong to claim that a mutation can never provide a new function. In 2012, researchers observed a bacterial gene in the laboratory that acquired a second activity while keeping its first. Such cases remain rare. The real question is therefore how extensive these new features are and how they build up.[3]

Another debate concerns body parts once thought to be useless. They were called vestigial organs, meaning useless remains inherited from distant ancestors. In 1893, the naturalist Robert Wiedersheim counted 86 of them in humans. Yet several of these organs have functions.

The appendix helps defend the body and shelters bacteria useful to the intestine. The coccyx, or tailbone, is a small bone at the bottom of the spine where several muscles attach. The tonsils also help defend the body.

Not knowing an organ's function therefore did not prove that it was useless. But we need to be careful: the fact that an organ is useful today does not mean it could not have been inherited. This observation mainly removes the argument's value as a specific piece of evidence.

The same care is needed with sections of DNA once called “junk DNA”. A large part of DNA takes part in activities measured in the cell. But taking part in an activity does not necessarily mean performing an essential function. The disagreement is partly about the meaning of the word function.

3. Fossils: valuable but incomplete evidence

A fossil is a remain or trace of a living thing preserved in rock. It provides information about a body, a shape, or a way of moving. But it does not directly tell us what that living thing descended from. All known fossils together make up the fossil record.

Transitional forms are fossils that combine traits from two different groups. Supporters of evolution see them as evidence of ancient changes. These fossils really do exist. The disagreement concerns what they can prove.

Archaeopteryx combines reptile and bird traits. The fossil exists; placing it in a family history requires interpretation. Photo from Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Archaeopteryx, for example, has reptile and bird traits. Tiktaalik, a fossil fish, has a fin whose structure resembles certain parts of a limb. Other fossils are used to reconstruct the history of whales. A sound critique must acknowledge them honestly.

But a resemblance does not identify an ancestor. In a family photograph, several people may look alike without us knowing who is whose parent. In fact, Tiktaalik's discoverers never presented it as a proven direct ancestor.

A discovery published in 2010 made this clear. In Poland, researchers described footprints left by four-limbed animals. According to the model's dating, these tracks are older than the oldest known body remains of these animals. The proposed history therefore had to be extended. This does not erase Tiktaalik's mixed traits, but it shows how uncertain these reconstructions remain.[4]

The main difficulty remains the rarity of long sequences of small changes. Many forms appear suddenly in rock layers, then remain almost unchanged for a long time. A palaeontologist is a fossil specialist. Stephen Jay Gould was a palaeontologist and a firm supporter of evolution. He wrote in 1977:

“The extreme rarity of transitional forms in the fossil record persists as the trade secret of paleontology.”[5]

Gould proposed an explanation: punctuated equilibria. These are long periods of stability interrupted by fairly rapid changes in small, isolated populations. Rapid does not mean instant: Gould ruled out an animal transforming in a single generation.

Critics reply that this model moves the problem elsewhere. It explains the absence of intermediate forms through evolution too rapid and too local to leave many traces. This may account for some gaps, but it does not provide the missing steps.

The Cambrian explosion refers to the appearance, close together in the fossil record, of almost all the major types of animal bodies. A body plan is the general way the parts of a body are arranged. According to the model's chronology, this appearance spans about 13 to 25 million years, a short time on this scale.[6]

Reconstruction of a Cambrian predator, from the period when almost all the major types of animal bodies appear. Image from Wikimedia Commons.

Entirely new bodies must be produced in a short time, with compound eyes, hard shells, or nervous systems. No simple ancestor appears in older layers to explain this diversity. Some researchers think these lineages began long before their first fossil traces. This shifts the debate towards a less visible history without settling it.

The stability of forms also deserves attention. The coelacanth, a fish alive today, broadly resembles very ancient fossils. This does not mean it is exactly the same species, or that its DNA has not changed.

Olivier Nguyen, author of the Catholic book Stabilité des espèces, published in 2014, points out another limit. A group missing from more recent layers has not necessarily died out: some have later been found alive. But an incomplete record proves neither universal evolution nor universal lack of change. It requires us to separate observations from conclusions.

4. Building a system that works

A living thing is not a collection of independent parts. A protein is a substance made by cells that performs a specific task in their functioning. Some proteins work together. Their usefulness then depends on their being properly organised.

Michael Behe draws attention to systems in which several parts are needed at the same time. He calls this dependence between parts fitted to one another irreducible complexity. If an essential part is missing, the system stops working.

Michael J. Behe, a professor of biochemistry, formulated the idea of irreducible complexity in 1996. Photo from Wikimedia Commons.

His favourite example is the bacterial flagellum. This is a long filament that spins like a propeller and allows certain bacteria to move. The whole system has about 40 different proteins and works like a motor. Behe asks how it could have formed through small steps, each useful.

The bacterial flagellum: the long filament spins and propels the bacterium, thanks to the parts at its base. You do not need to learn the labels, which are in English. Diagram by LadyofHats, Wikimedia Commons.

A motor does not work simply because all its parts are there. They must also be placed and connected correctly. This coordination is part of what needs to be explained.

Supporters of evolution respond with co-option. This word means reusing parts that originally served another purpose. Elements that were already useful would gradually have been brought together to work in a new way. According to Behe, this answer remains insufficient in the cases he studies. The discussion must therefore focus on these specific pathways, examined one by one.

We also need to remain accurate. In the mechanism that stops bleeding, the absence of certain parts causes serious disorders. The absence of another does not have this effect. So not all its elements are essential in the same way.

Olivier Nguyen points out another difficulty, drawing on two researchers, Yann Hérault and Denis Duboule. A single gene can affect several parts of the body at once. Changing it can therefore produce several effects together. It is a little like moving a wall that supports several rooms in a house.

This does not disprove the existence of common ancestors. But it corrects an oversimplified picture in which each organ changes on its own, without affecting the rest. The scientist Claude Bernard, founder of experimental medicine, had already made this point:

“One must therefore be well aware that, if one decomposes the living organism by isolating its various parts, it is only for the convenience of experimental analysis, and not in order to conceive of them separately.”[7]

In other words, studying a part separately does not mean that it works alone. Every change must remain compatible with the life of the whole.

5. The first life: a different question

Evolution assumes that living things already exist and can reproduce. It therefore cannot explain the appearance of the first living thing, because selection only sorts what is already alive. Another question arises: how could non-living matter have formed a first cell?

Abiogenesis is the name given to this supposed appearance of life from non-living matter. Several hypotheses try to explain it. But no living cell has ever been produced this way in a laboratory. Ongoing research is not a completed demonstration.

Even the simplest cell needs several things at once. It needs instructions and equipment able to read them. It also needs a membrane. This is the covering that separates it from the outside and controls what goes in and out. Finally, it needs energy.

It is a little like a city whose services all depend on one another. Instructions make nothing without the equipment. And the equipment itself is made using the instructions. We meet the chicken-and-egg problem again.

Amino acids are the small building blocks that proteins are made of. In 1953, a famous experiment produced some of them in conditions intended to imitate the early Earth. But making bricks is not the same as building a house.

First, in water, a chain of building blocks naturally tends to break apart rather than grow longer. Cells form long chains using equipment that consumes energy. Obtaining the building blocks does not yet provide this equipment.

Second, many of these building blocks exist in two forms, like a right hand and a left hand. The experiment produces a mixture of both. Yet proteins made by cells use only one of these forms. No known natural process sorts them this way under these conditions.

Some researchers imagine that a substance able to carry instructions and copy itself could have existed before cells. It would provide a way out of the chicken-and-egg problem. But such a substance has never been observed under conditions considered plausible for the early Earth. The hypothesis is still being studied.

Stephen C. Meyer, who holds a doctorate in the philosophy of science, raises another question. A protein is a chain of building blocks, and Meyer identifies three conditions for it to work. First, the building blocks must follow a precise order: only certain orders allow the chain to take a shape that works. Douglas Axe measured how rare these suitable orders are. Second, each building block must be attached to the next by the right type of bond. Finally, all the building blocks must have the same form, out of the two described above.

For a protein with 150 building blocks, Meyer combines these three conditions. According to him, the chance of meeting them at random is one in a number written as a 1 followed by 164 zeros.

Meyer then assumes that a minimal cell needs at least 250 proteins of this type, obtained independently of one another. The chance then becomes incomparably smaller. Both assumptions are disputed. The calculation shows the scale of the difficulty within this model, without measuring every possible origin of life.[8]

Finally, in 1862, Louis Pasteur showed that life did not arise spontaneously in the broths he studied. His experiments do not prove, on their own, that no natural origin of life is possible under any conditions. But the transition from non-living matter to life has never been reproduced. This is the subject of research into the origin of life, distinct from the evolution of living things already present.

6. Do mutations have enough time?

A useful mutation can appear in a single individual without spreading throughout the population. It may even disappear if that individual has no offspring. We therefore need to distinguish between the appearance of a change and its spread. Fixation occurs when the change is present in every member of the population.

The waiting time problem involves calculating how long it takes for specific changes to appear and then become fixed. The difficulty grows when several precise changes must come together to be useful. Just any new feature is no longer enough: a particular combination is needed.

The geneticist J. B. S. Haldane had already raised a related question in 1957. His calculation concerns useful changes that spread throughout a population through selection. In this case, individuals without the change survive or reproduce less. Haldane called this the cost of selection. According to him, this cost limits how quickly such replacements can follow one another.[9]

A study by John Sanford and his colleagues, published in 2015, simulated this problem on a computer. It assumes a population of 10,000 individuals, with one generation every 20 years and very strong selection. Two precise DNA changes, useful only together, must appear and then spread throughout the population. The calculated average waiting time is about 84 million years.[10]

This result should be compared with the roughly 6 million years proposed by the model for the split between the human and chimpanzee lineages. The gap is considerable. But other specialists dispute this simulation's parameters and conclusions. The result applies to these two changes specified in advance, within this model, rather than to every transformation.

We need to be honest about another point. In six million years, the total number of mutations that have appeared far exceeds the number of DNA differences to be explained between humans and chimpanzees. The difficulty therefore does not concern the number of mutations. It concerns certain precise combinations and their spread.

This argument therefore has force if it stays precise. It would lose its value if it became a slogan about “the impossibility of chance”. The question of the waiting time for mutations deserves a discussion based on its actual calculations.

7. DNA similarities: a serious body of evidence

Researchers compare the DNA of different living things to reconstruct their possible relationships. The result often takes the form of a family tree, where nearby branches indicate a supposedly closer relationship. These comparisons must be read carefully.

First, different genes can produce different trees for the same species. Gene A, for example, places species 1 close to species 2. Gene B places species 1 close to species 3. Gene C suggests yet another arrangement.

These disagreements have several possible explanations. A gene's history is not always the same as that of populations: genes can pass from one lineage to another, or lineages can mix. Some researchers therefore replace the single tree with a network, with links between branches. This complicates the reconstruction without, by itself, removing the idea of common ancestors.

There are also very strong similarities. A virus is a tiny agent that uses cells to multiply. Some ancient viruses entered their hosts' DNA, and these fragments were passed on to offspring. They are called endogenous retroviruses.

Humans and chimpanzees share such fragments at the same positions in their DNA. A shared inheritance would offer a simple explanation for these matches. This is one of the strongest arguments for a relationship between their bodies. An honest account must acknowledge its strength.

It is true that viruses are not equally likely to insert themselves anywhere: they favour certain regions. But none of the studies examined here shows independent insertions reproducing all these matches. Saying “it could have happened twice” is therefore not enough. And if some fragments have a function today, that does not rule out their having been inherited.

So what does this argument show? It supports a shared biological history of bodies on one specific point. It does not demonstrate that mutations and selection are enough to build every form of living organisation. It says nothing about the human soul. And, as we will see, the Catholic faith does not require us to deny every relationship between bodies.

We often hear that humans and chimpanzees share 98 to 99% of their DNA. This figure depends on what is being compared. It counts only small differences in sections of DNA that can be aligned directly. When added or missing pieces of DNA are also counted, the 2005 study gives about 96% shared DNA.[11]

The similarity remains strong. But the same Creator can also reuse the same materials for similar needs. Resemblance alone therefore does not settle the question of origins. And no percentage measures reason, freedom, or the ability to love.

8. Human history and errors in reconstruction

Popular drawings often show a line of figures, from a stooping animal to an upright human being. This image gives the impression of a continuous, certain progression. The actual evidence is less secure: incomplete fossils, disputed classifications, and several branches.

Reconstructing a body from incomplete bones requires choices. Placing that body in a family history requires others. A very detailed image can therefore suggest more certainty than the remains themselves provide.

Lucy is the name given to a famous fossil skeleton discovered in 1974, about 40% of which is preserved. In 2015, a study showed that one of the fragments associated with this skeleton came from a baboon. It did not establish that the entire skeleton was a misleading assembly. The correction is real, but limited.[12]

Even the earliest fossils placed in the same group as humans raise questions. They differ so much from one another that specialists debate the very definition of this group. This weakens overly confident accounts without making the fossils disappear.

The history of this research also includes a genuine fraud. At Piltdown, in the United Kingdom, fragments of human skulls had been combined with a stained orangutan jaw and teeth. This assembly was presented as the “missing link”, meaning the form that would connect humans to apes. The deception lasted 41 years, from 1912 to 1953.[13]

Painting showing the examination of the Piltdown fragments. The assembly presented as an ancient human fossil was fabricated. Wikimedia Commons.

Other cases are different. Nebraska Man was based on a single tooth, thought to belong to a human ancestor. It was actually the tooth of a peccary, an animal related to the pig. This was an error, corrected by the researchers themselves, rather than a fraud.

Archaeoraptor was a fossil faked by a dealer, then presented too hastily by the press in 1999. This was not fraud by scientists. There is also the case of Haeckel. An embryo is an animal at the very beginning of its development. Haeckel drew embryos of several species, exaggerating their similarities. Although criticised as early as 1874, these drawings remained in textbooks for a long time.

These cases have different causes. They do not, on their own, disprove every theory of evolution. But they show that a desire to confirm the expected story has sometimes led people to accept too quickly pieces that seemed to complete it. A reconstruction must remain open to checking.

The same standard applies to the opposite idea, that species are completely stable. Forms that have remained stable for a long time do not prove that every major change is impossible. What is unknown does not become evidence for either side.

9. A scientific theory is not an article of faith

A scientific theory can be corrected, improved, or even abandoned. That is one of its strengths. The problem begins when it is presented as an unquestionable fact that no one has the right to discuss. It then stops being a working hypothesis and becomes an ideology, meaning a view of the world defended out of conviction.

The burden of proof must also be placed correctly. It is up to the theory to show that it explains the complexity of living things. It is not up to its critics to prove that it fails. Yet the difficulties examined above remain unresolved: fossils, the first cell, coordinated systems, and waiting times.

These doubts do not come only from believers. The French zoologist Pierre-Paul Grassé, president of the Académie des sciences in 1967 and a firm supporter of evolution, wrote:

“However numerous they may be, mutations give rise to no kind of evolutionary change.”[14]

A Catholic therefore asks for three simple things. First, that the theory be presented with its strengths and gaps. Second, that critical researchers be free to present their objections. Finally, that biology recognise its limits: it describes matter, but cannot decide that nothing else exists.

If science were one day to demonstrate this mechanism rigorously, a Catholic would accept it, just as Catholics have accepted that the Earth revolves around the Sun. But that day has not come. Catholics do not have to accept in advance, as an established truth, a theory that is still being developed.

10. What the Catholic faith teaches

The human soul

Biology studies bodies, traces, and mechanisms. Materialism, by contrast, claims that all reality can be reduced to matter. This is no longer a scientific observation, but a philosophical position. It claims to explain thought, freedom, and love as well.

The Catholic faith rejects this reduction. The spiritual soul is the principle of life in the human person, enabling the person to know and to love freely. The Church teaches that every spiritual soul is immediately created by God. It is not produced by the parents.[15]

Reason can also understand this. Human beings think about general ideas, such as justice or beauty. We can see a particular just action, such as sharing fairly. But the idea of justice applies to all cases, everywhere and always. We cannot touch it or weigh it. Saint Thomas Aquinas draws a conclusion from this: matter alone cannot produce this ability to think. A cause cannot give more than it possesses. This reasoning belongs to philosophy, rather than to a laboratory experiment.

No sequence of fossils therefore shows the creation of a soul. No percentage of DNA measures a person's dignity. Human beings can seek truth, recognise what is good, and respond freely to God's love.

What the popes have said

An encyclical is a solemn letter from the pope to the whole Church. In 1950, in the encyclical Humani Generis, Pius XII allowed researchers to study an origin of the human body from matter that was already living. He set two conditions: maintaining the direct creation of the soul, and not treating this opinion as certain.[16]

Pope Pius XII, author of the encyclical Humani Generis of 12 August 1950, which sets the Catholic framework for this debate. Photo from Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Pius XII also rejected any theory in which humanity did not descend from a single first father, Adam. His permission to investigate was never an obligation to adopt the theory.

In 1996, John Paul II gave a positive assessment of the research in a message to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences. He wrote:

“Today, almost half a century after the publication of the encyclical, new knowledge leads to the recognition of the theory of evolution as more than a hypothesis.”[17]

This sentence does belong to his official message. But the same text distinguishes between several theories of evolution according to their philosophy, and rejects those that reduce human beings to matter. It maintains the immediate creation of the soul. It even speaks of an “ontological leap” between animals and human beings, meaning a transition to a reality of a different nature.

Pope Benedict XVI during a private audience on 20 January 2006. Photo Sergey Kozhukhov, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

In 2007, Benedict XVI acknowledged a great deal of scientific evidence in favour of evolution. He immediately added that this doctrine does not answer every question. Above all, it does not answer the great question: where does everything come from?[18]

In 2005, Cardinal Schönborn wrote in an opinion article that common ancestry might be true. But he rejected evolution understood as a process without any intention on God's part. This was a personal position, rather than a definition of faith.[19]

Adam, Eve, and salvation

The Catholic faith accepts Adam and Eve as real people, the first parents of all humanity. They are not merely symbols of an ancient population. Models that remove this real first couple therefore contradict the teaching recalled by Pius XII.

The Creation of Adam, Michelangelo's fresco in the Sistine Chapel, around 1512. God directly gives life to the first man. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Grace is the gift through which God allows human beings to share in his own life. Original sin means the real sin of the first parents, and the resulting state of humanity: deprived of the grace originally received. This state is passed on with human nature itself, rather than as a defect written into DNA.[20]

This connection touches the heart of salvation. Salvation is the deliverance from sin that God offers to human beings through Jesus Christ. In his letter to the Romans, Saint Paul sets two men side by side. Through one man, Adam, sin entered the world. Through the obedience of one, Christ, many are made righteous.

If Adam were only an image of a population, this parallel would lose its meaning. Why would Christ come to restore a humanity that had fallen in one man, if that man had not existed? Saint Augustine already held that all human beings descend from the one first man created by God.

Genesis and chronology

Genesis is the first book of the Bible. It tells of the creation of the world and the beginnings of humanity. It repeats that living things are created “according to their kind”. The phrase occurs ten times in the first chapter. It occurs another seven times in the account of the Flood: three times in Genesis 6:20 and four times in Genesis 7:14. That makes seventeen times in all.[21]

Such repetition is deliberate. It shows that the diversity of living things belongs to God's plan, and that he blesses and preserves it. The Hebrew word used means a species, a sort, or a kind. Saint Basil of Caesarea was one of the Fathers of the Church. This is the name given to the great Christian writers of the early centuries. Basil saw this phrase as expressing a stable law that God had placed in nature.

The short chronology rests on the same trust in the text. Over the centuries, it was held by Theophilus of Antioch, Eusebius, Saint Augustine, Saint Bede, and the Church's liturgy. It places the creation of Adam around 4000 BC. Ignispedia accepts it as a traditional interpretation, defended with those who have supported it, without making it a dogma.

Saint Augustine, painted by Philippe de Champaigne around 1645-1650. He is among the early witnesses to the short biblical chronology and to humanity's descent from one Adam. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

What the Church has defined is even more fundamental. God created all things from nothing at the beginning of time. He did not merely transform matter that had always existed. A council is a large assembly of the Church's bishops. The First Vatican Council defined this truth in 1870. The exact length of the world's history has never received such a definition.

Why prefer direct creation?

Some Catholics consider that God may have guided evolution to prepare the human body, then directly created the soul. This is called providential evolution. This position is permitted if the directly created soul and a real first couple are maintained. Yet Ignispedia prefers direct creation, for three reasons.

First, the mechanism on which it relies has not been demonstrated. Second, evolution guided by God is no longer Darwinian evolution, which claims to be without direction. Materialist evolutionists such as Richard Dawkins themselves reject this guided evolution.[22] Finally, if the scientific theory changes, a religious explanation built on it will need to be revised. Direct creation does not have this problem.

The central point remains: God creates through wisdom and love. The Catechism recalls that the world is not the product of chance or blind fate. A process presented as the complete explanation, without intention or purpose, is therefore incompatible with this faith. And faith does not rest on what researchers do not yet know: it rests on what God has revealed.

What to remember

  • Variations passed on to offspring are observed and are not denied.
  • Extending them to explain the origin of the major forms of life has not been demonstrated.
  • Fossils, the first cell, coordinated systems, and waiting times raise serious difficulties.
  • Critical calculations depend on their assumptions, which must always be stated.
  • Some DNA similarities are real evidence of relationships between bodies and should be examined fairly.
  • No history of bodies proves that everything is matter.
  • The Church teaches the direct creation of every soul and the reality of Adam and Eve.
  • The short chronology is a traditional reading, with those who have supported it, but is not a dogma.

The strength of a critique depends on its accuracy. Denying a real fossil, turning an error into a conspiracy, or presenting a disputed calculation as final would weaken the entire case. The difficulties presented here instead call for precise answers.

What is disputed here is not every possible relationship between bodies. It is the claim that mutations and selection alone explain everything, right up to the human spirit. This mechanism has not been demonstrated, and the difficulties remain unresolved. Catholics therefore have no obligation to adopt it: it is not God's job to rescue a scientific theory that does not work.

Catholics can freely examine the research, without fear and without giving up their faith. Science must explain what it claims. Faith recalls what matters most: our existence is not an accident; it is willed and loved by God.

Notes and references

Notes and References

  1. Gerd B. Müller, Why an extended evolutionary synthesis is necessary, Interface Focus (Royal Society), vol. 7, no. 5, August 2017. Müller was then head of the Department of Theoretical Biology at the University of Vienna; he is now professor emeritus.

    1
  2. Dustin J. Van Hofwegen, Carolyn J. Hovde, Scott A. Minnich, Rapid Evolution of Citrate Utilization by Escherichia coli by Direct Selection Requires citT and dctA, Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 198, no. 7, April 2016, p. 1022-1034, DOI 10.1128/JB.00831-15. Under direct selection, 46 independent mutants able to use citrate were obtained in 12 to 100 generations; the mechanism reuses the CitT and DctA transporters. The conclusion is limited to this mechanism; it does not concern every possible innovation in Lenski's experiment.

    2
  3. Joakim Näsvall, Lei Sun, John R. Roth & Dan I. Andersson, Real-Time Evolution of New Genes by Innovation, Amplification, and Divergence, Science, vol. 338, no. 6108, 19 October 2012, p. 384-387, DOI 10.1126/science.1226521. A bacterial gene acquiring a second activity while retaining the first; a rare case, obtained under directed selection in a laboratory.

    3
  4. G. Niedźwiedzki, P. Szrek, K. Narkiewicz, M. Narkiewicz & P. E. Ahlberg, Tetrapod trackways from the early Middle Devonian period of Poland, Nature, vol. 463, 7 January 2010, p. 43-48, DOI 10.1038/nature08623. According to the model's chronology, the trackways are older than the oldest tetrapod body remains and than Tiktaalik: a revision of the chronology, rather than a disappearance of Tiktaalik's transitional features. On Tiktaalik, never presented by its discoverers as a proven direct ancestor: Daeschler, Shubin & Jenkins, Nature, vol. 440, 6 April 2006.

    4
  5. Stephen Jay Gould, Evolution's Erratic Pace, Natural History, vol. 86, no. 5, May 1977, p. 14, article p. 12-16. Original: “The extreme rarity of transitional forms in the fossil record persists as the trade secret of paleontology.”

    5
  6. A diversification period of about 13 to 25 million years according to the current synthesis, within the chronology of the model under discussion. See also D. H. Erwin et al., The Cambrian conundrum: early divergence and later ecological success in the early history of animals, Science, vol. 334, no. 6059, 2011, p. 1091-1097, DOI 10.1126/science.1206375, which distinguishes fossil appearance from earlier divergence.

    6
  7. Claude Bernard, Introduction à l'étude de la médecine expérimentale, 1865, part II, chapter II, § 1, quoted by Olivier Nguyen, Stabilité des espèces. L'Enquête, Éditions du Jubilé, 2014, p. 148.

    7
  8. Stephen C. Meyer, Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design, HarperOne, 2009, chapter 9: the probability of a functional protein of 150 amino acids appearing at random is estimated at 1 in 10¹⁶⁴. This estimate combines three factors: the rarity of functional folds measured by Douglas D. Axe, Estimating the Prevalence of Protein Sequences Adopting Functional Enzyme Folds, Journal of Molecular Biology, vol. 341, no. 5, 27 August 2004, p. 1295-1315, DOI 10.1016/j.jmb.2004.06.058, of the order of 1 in 10⁷⁷; the probabilities associated with peptide bonds; and those associated with homochirality. Axe's figure and Meyer's therefore do not measure the same thing. Then, conditionally, at least 250 proteins and independent trials give 1 in 10⁴¹⁰⁰⁰. Strong and disputed assumptions. Exact pages of the edition have not been checked against the printed book.

    8
  9. J. B. S. Haldane, The cost of natural selection, Journal of Genetics, vol. 55, no. 3, 1957, p. 511-524, DOI 10.1007/BF02984069: the selective cost of each substitution places an upper limit on the rate of adaptive substitutions.

    9
  10. John C. Sanford, Wesley H. Brewer, Franzine D. Smith, John Baumgardner, The waiting time problem in a model hominin population, Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling, vol. 12, 17 September 2015, article 18, DOI 10.1186/s12976-015-0016-z. Population of 10,000 individuals, 20-year generation time, 50% selection, simulation run until fixation; about 84 million years on average for two specific codependent nucleotides. The authors' model, whose parameters and conclusions are disputed.

    10
  11. The Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium, Initial sequence of the chimpanzee genome and comparison with the human genome, Nature, vol. 437, 1 September 2005, p. 69-87, DOI 10.1038/nature04072. About 1.23% substitutions in aligned sections; counting insertions and deletions, about 96% shared sequence, according to the NHGRI press release of 31 August 2005 on this study.

    11
  12. M. R. Meyer, S. A. Williams, M. P. Smith & G. J. Sawyer, Lucy's back: Reassessment of fossils associated with the A.L. 288-1 vertebral column, Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 85, August 2015, p. 174-180, DOI 10.1016/j.jhevol.2015.05.007. A single vertebral element reassigned to a gelada baboon; the other elements remain attributed to Lucy.

    12
  13. I. De Groote et al., New genetic and morphological evidence suggests a single hoaxer created 'Piltdown man', Royal Society Open Science, vol. 3, article 160328, 10 August 2016, DOI 10.1098/rsos.160328.

    13
  14. Pierre-Paul Grassé, Evolution of Living Organisms: Evidence for a New Theory of Transformation, Academic Press, New York, 1977, American edition of L'évolution du vivant, Albin Michel, 1973, p. 88 of the English edition: “No matter how numerous they may be, mutations do not produce any kind of evolution.” Quotation translated from English. Grassé, a firm supporter of evolution, was president of the Académie des sciences in 1967.

    14
  15. Catéchisme de l'Église Catholique, § 366: every spiritual soul is immediately created by God; it is not “produced” by the parents.

    15
  16. Pius XII, Humani Generis, encyclical of 12 August 1950, §§ 36-37. French text from the Holy See.

    16
  17. Saint John Paul II, Message à l'Académie pontificale des sciences, 22 October 1996, § 4. French text from the Holy See. The message distinguishes theories according to their philosophy in § 4, maintains the immediate creation of the soul in § 5, and speaks of an “ontological leap” in § 6.

    17
  18. Benedict XVI, meeting with the clergy of the dioceses of Belluno-Feltre and Treviso, Auronzo di Cadore, 24 July 2007. Remarks summarised here, without direct quotation.

    18
  19. Cardinal Christoph Schönborn, Finding Design in Nature, The New York Times, 7 July 2005. A personal opinion article distinguishing common ancestry from a process excluding all design; it does not, on its own, constitute a magisterial definition.

    19
  20. Catéchisme de l'Église Catholique, § 404: the transmission of human nature in a fallen state, deprived of original grace, distinct from the genetic transmission of a defect.

    20
  21. Count based on the Masoretic Hebrew text: Genesis 1, v. 11 ×1, v. 12 ×2, v. 21 ×2, v. 24 ×2, v. 25 ×3; Genesis 6:20 ×3; Genesis 7:14 ×4. Total: seventeen. The Hebrew word min means a species, a sort, or a kind. Saint Basil's reading: Hexaëméron, homilies VIII and IX, paraphrased.

    21
  22. Daniel Dennett, Darwin's Dangerous Idea, 1995; Richard Dawkins, The Blind Watchmaker, 1986; Jerry Coyne, Faith vs. Fact, 2015. All three reject theistic evolution, each in his own way; exact pages have not been cross-checked.

    22

Can’t find your topic?