Our Lady of Silence

Mary who keeps and ponders in her heart, the mute apparition of Knock in 1879 and the icon with a finger on her lips placed by Pope Francis in the Apostolic Palace: what the title Our Lady of Silence names exactly, and what it does not name.

Ignispedia

Our Lady of Silence designates the Virgin Mary invoked and contemplated in her silence. The title does not refer to a distinct apparition bearing this name alone. It covers three linked realities, which this article carefully distinguishes: the silence of Mary in the Gospel, who keeps and ponders the events of salvation in her heart; the apparition of Knock, in Ireland, on 21 August 1879, where the Virgin showed herself without uttering a single word, to the point of often being called in English Our Lady of Silence; and the contemporary devotion to an icon of the Virgin of Silence, her finger laid upon her lips, spread from Italy by the Capuchin Emiliano Antenucci and placed by Pope Francis at the entrance to his apartments in the Apostolic Palace[1][2].

The two homes of this devotion are Knock in Ireland, where the Virgin showed herself without uttering a word, and, for the icon, Penne and then Avezzano in Italy[3]. Few Marian titles touch so closely on a question that runs through the whole Gospel, namely what God makes heard by those who know how to be silent and listen.

One title, three realities not to be confused

What the title names exactly

“Our Lady of Silence” names first of all a way of being of Mary: she listens, she keeps, she ponders, she speaks little and only at the right moment. The Gospels record only a few words of hers: her “yes” at the Annunciation, the Magnificat, her question to Jesus found again in the Temple, and her two sentences at the wedding at Cana[4]. The rest of her Gospel life unfolds in an attentive presence, up to the foot of the Cross, where John records no word of hers, but her presence: “Standing by the cross of Jesus were his mother” (Jn 19:25)[5].

What the title does not name

The title does not name an autonomous apparition comparable to Lourdes or Fatima, with its own place, seer and message that would be called “Our Lady of Silence”. When the name appears linked to an event, it is as a nickname for Knock, because of the very silence of the apparition[6]. When it appears linked to a present-day place of worship, it is the Madonna del Silenzio shrine in Avezzano, born of an icon and a school of prayer, not of an apparition[7]. Keeping these three planes separate avoids two opposite errors: lending the title an apparition that is not its own, or reducing a true path of prayer to a mere nickname.

RealityPlace and dateWhat happens thereStatus
Mary's silence in the GospelNazareth, Bethlehem, Jerusalem, the life of JesusMary keeps and ponders the events in her heart (Lk 2:19; 2:51)Scripture, faith of the Church
Apparition of KnockKnock, Ireland, 21 August 1879The Virgin, Saint Joseph, Saint John and the Lamb show themselves without a single wordTestimonies judged worthy of belief in 1879, confirmed in 1935-1936
Icon of the Virgin of SilenceIcon written at San Giulio, Orta, arrived in Penne on 13 June 2011; Avezzano afterwardsAn icon and courses of silence teach listening and guarding one's tonguePrivate devotion, encouraged by Pope Francis

Mary's silence in the Gospel

“She kept all these things”

Saint Luke says the same thing twice about Mary, and the repetition is no accident of the pen. After the shepherds' visit to Bethlehem:

“But Mary kept all these things, pondering them in her heart.” : Gospel according to Saint Luke 2:19[8]

After Jesus was found again in the Temple, when she and Joseph “did not understand” the child's saying, Luke repeats:

“And his mother kept all these things in her heart.” : Gospel according to Saint Luke 2:51[9]

The verb matters. Mary does not understand everything at once. She keeps: she preserves the facts, the words, the faces, and she ponders them, that is, she brings them together in prayer until their meaning is revealed. Her silence is therefore neither a void nor an absence of thought. It is an interior, patient work that lasts a whole lifetime.

Benedict XVI's commentary

Pope Benedict XVI commented on this trait of Mary in his general audience of 28 December 2011, devoted to the prayer of the Holy Family of Nazareth. There he stresses that Luke presents Mary as the model of the believer who keeps the word and compares it with life:

“Saint Luke says: ‘Mary kept all these things, pondering them in her heart’ (2:19), and he thus describes Mary's attitude before the mystery of the Incarnation, an attitude that would continue throughout her life: keeping these things, pondering them in her heart.” : Benedict XVI, general audience of 28 December 2011[10]

In the same catechesis, Benedict XVI notes that the memories of Jesus, “imprinted in her mind and in her heart, marked every instant of Mary's existence”, and that Luke makes known in her faith, hope, obedience and above all “her interiority and her prayer”[11]. On 14 March 2012, in a catechesis on Mary's praying presence, he takes up the same reading: the stages of Mary's journey, from Nazareth to Jerusalem and as far as the Cross, “are marked by her capacity to maintain a persevering atmosphere of recollection, in order to meditate on each event in the silence of her heart before God”[12]. Mary's silence thus carries teaching authority: it is not merely a character trait the Church admires, it is a school of prayer that a pope proposes to the faithful.

Few words, words that count

The contrast is striking. Mary speaks rarely in the Gospel, but each of her words carries far. At the Annunciation, she asks a brief question and then consents: “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word” (Lk 1:38)[13]. At the Visitation, her word becomes praise in the Magnificat (Lk 1:46-55)[14]. At Cana, she tells Jesus of the lack she has noticed, “They have no wine” (Jn 2:3), then she addresses to the servants the last word the Gospel records of hers, one that holds for all disciples:

“Do whatever he tells you.” : Mary to the servants, Gospel according to Saint John 2:5[15]

After that, the Gospel lends her no more speeches. She is there, at the foot of the Cross (Jn 19:25-27), then in the Upper Room with the apostles in prayer before Pentecost (Acts 1:14)[16]. Her last biblical posture is therefore not a word, but a silent and common prayer, in the midst of the nascent Church. That is exactly the destination the devotion to Our Lady of Silence proposes to imitate.

Knock, the apparition that says nothing

The evening of 21 August 1879

Church of Saint John the Baptist and Apparition Chapel at Knock. Photo: FredSeiller, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0, unmodified.

The complete Knock dossier is the subject of the detailed article Our Lady of Knock. It suffices here to recall the facts that ground the nickname Our Lady of Silence. On the evening of Thursday 21 August 1879, in the rain, some fifteen inhabitants of the village of Knock, in County Mayo, Ireland, saw against the south gable of their parish church a luminous tableau: the crowned Virgin, her eyes raised to heaven, Saint Joseph at her right, Saint John the Evangelist in bishop's vestments holding a book, and an altar bearing a Lamb, with a cross and angels according to several witnesses[17]. The apparition lasted about two hours. The witnesses prayed the rosary. And above all: no one heard a single word[18].

A message shown, not spoken

Where Lourdes and Fatima deliver words, Knock delivers an image to contemplate. The centre of the tableau is moreover not Mary herself, but the altar and the Lamb, that is, Christ offered and the Eucharist. There Mary holds the place she holds throughout the Gospel: she is present, in prayer, and she points to something other than herself. Presentations of the shrine and of the devotion stress this trait by calling Knock, in English, Our Lady of Silence, because the Virgin spoke there at no moment, unlike her other great apparitions[19][20]. This nickname does not erase the place's proper name: the Church and the shrine speak of Our Lady of Knock, Queen of Ireland. But it tells the truth about the unique form of the event.

The Church's position on Knock

A first commission of inquiry, set up in 1879 by the Archbishop of Tuam, judged the testimonies of the fifteen witnesses trustworthy and satisfactory. A second commission, in 1935-1936, questioned the last witnesses still living in Ireland again and confirmed that judgment[21]. Worship and pilgrimage there are fully authorised, and Pope Francis raised the shrine, on 19 March 2021, to the rank of international Eucharistic and Marian shrine[22]. The status is therefore that of testimonies judged credible by the diocesan authority and of a worship encouraged at the highest level. For the detail of the witnesses, the objections and the history of the shrine, the reader is referred to the article Our Lady of Knock.

The icon of the Virgin of Silence

A gesture come from afar

Saint Anne of Faras, 8th century, National Museum in Warsaw. Reproduction: Google Arts and Culture, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The contemporary icon of the Virgin of Silence shows Mary at half length, a finger laid upon her lips, in the gesture that invites silence, and the other hand in a gesture of blessing. The shrine's official site explains how this motif was chosen. There is, it says, no ancient Byzantine model of a Mother of God “Virgin of Silence”. On the other hand, the same gesture is found in Saint Anne, on an 8th-century Coptic fresco preserved at the National Museum in Warsaw and coming from Faras, and in Saint John the Evangelist, whom Byzantine tradition calls the Theologian, as an invitation to enter into the mystery and listen to the Word[23]. A painter, Gianmario Carozzi, had already depicted Mary full length with this gesture, under the name Santa Maria del Silenzio, starting from this fresco of Saint Anne. It was one of these images that reached Brother Emiliano Antenucci[24].

The theological question was posed seriously by the iconographer nuns: could the gesture of her mother Anne be attributed to the Mother of God? Their answer, reported by the shrine, comes down to one sentence: who, more than Mary, has the right to bear this sober gesture, she who “bears within her the Mystery, the eternal Word made flesh among us for our salvation”[25]. Another difficulty was treated in the same way: tradition represents Mary with her Son. The choice was not to add any figure above her, in order to concentrate the gaze on the Trinity that dwells in Mary and that she keeps in silence[26].

Written by the Benedictines of San Giulio

The original icon was commissioned by Brother Emiliano Antenucci, a Capuchin. It was “written”, according to the word of the iconographic tradition, after about nine months of work, by the Benedictines of San Giulio island, Orta, in Piedmont[27]. It arrived at the convent of Penne, in Abruzzo, on 13 June 2011[28]. The technique is that of the classical icon: egg tempera, mineral and organic pigments, on wood prepared with cloth and layers of gesso[29]. The Greek inscription accompanying Mary is the abbreviation for Mother of God[30].

The testimony of the iconographer nun, published by the shrine, deserves to be heard, because it says what this image asks of whoever looks at it. There she recounts that, from the sketch on paper, the image of the Virgin of Silence imposed itself as “already there”, simple and profound, and that she worked for a long time “more out of desire to be with Her than because the result was slow in coming”[31]. An icon, in this tradition, is not contemplated like a decorative picture: it is received as a presence that teaches one to pray.

Pope Francis and the Apostolic Palace

Between the two lifts

A copy of the icon was offered to Pope Francis, who placed it between the two lifts, at the main entrance of the Apostolic Palace, in the Saint Damasus courtyard, where all those who come to meet him in his private office pass[32]. Catholic News Service, taken up by the Catholic press in August 2019, describes the same scene: near the lifts that lead to the pope's office and the meeting rooms, Francis hung a copy of the icon of Our Lady of Silence, Mary “her index finger laid gently before her closed lips”[33]. The pope also kept a smaller copy on his desk[34].

Brother Antenucci, questioned by Catholic News Service, stressed the choice this placement reveals:

“Just think of the number of Marian icons he receives as gifts, and he decides to put this one there.” : Emiliano Antenucci, remarks reported by Catholic News Service, August 2019[35]

Three gestures of Pope Francis

The shrine's site gives the precise chronology of Pope Francis's gestures towards this devotion. On 18 May 2015, he blessed the copy placed in the Palace with this intention: “May the Virgin Mary intercede with the Lord, so that all those who enter the Apostolic Palace may always have the right words”[36]. In 2016, after an audience, he blessed the original icon itself and signed it on the back with this inscription, in English in the shrine's account: “Do not gossip about others”[37]. On 24 March 2019, the eve of the Annunciation and of his visit to the shrine of Loreto, he wrote by hand to the provincial minister of the Capuchins of Abruzzo, Father Nicola Galasso: “It would be beautiful to find a place, a church, where public worship could be offered to the Virgin of Silence. Think about it and make a proposal”[38].

These three gestures outline the Church's position on this devotion, and it must be stated exactly. Here there is neither an apparition to judge nor a message to authenticate: there is an image, a prayer and a pedagogy of silence, which a pope blesses, places in the path of his visitors and wishes to see honoured publicly. That is strong pastoral encouragement. It is not a declaration of supernaturality, and this article does not lend it one.

The Avezzano shrine and the courses of silence

From an abandoned church to a shrine

Following the pope's letter, Brother Antenucci and the provincial minister, with the permission of the Order's minister general, looked for a suitable place. They chose the church of San Francesco d'Assise and the Capuchin convent of Avezzano, in Abruzzo, abandoned for ten years and owned by the province of the Capuchin Friars Minor of Abruzzo[39]. The Bishop of Avezzano, Bishop Pietro Santoro, welcomed the new shrine into his diocese, in accordance with Pope Francis's wish[40]. The Madonna del Silenzio shrine gives its address at the church of San Francesco, Via Lago di Scanno 41, in Avezzano[41].

A school of prayer born before the icon

The devotion does not begin with the icon. On 1 November 2008, Brother Antenucci wrote a first small booklet for courses of silence, entitled in the shrine's account “Silence speaks to silence”[42]. The first course of silence was held in Foligno, in Umbria, from 26 to 28 February 2010. The courses continued in Abruzzo, land of Saint Peter Celestine, the hermit who became pope, whom the shrine calls “the hermit pope of silence”[43]. On 17 and 18 March 2012, they began in Guadalajara, in Mexico, with translations into Spanish and then into English for other countries[44].

Catholic News Service describes these retreats as three-day weekends that teach one to set aside each day a moment of interior peace and exterior calm, in order better to perceive and welcome God's presence, in a world “busy, noisy and saturated with media”[45]. There Brother Antenucci sums up his conviction in two sentences the press retained:

“Silence is a revolution. Silence is the womb where true words are born.” : Emiliano Antenucci, remarks reported by Catholic News Service, August 2019[46]

A devotional booklet in English, Our Lady of Silence, by the same author, presents the icon as “the devotion of Pope Francis” and gathers prayers for learning to think before speaking and to welcome silence[47]. The whole therefore forms less a cult of an image than a path: looking at Mary keeping silent, then learning to keep silent with her.

What this devotion teaches

Keeping, before understanding

The first lesson is Luke's: one can keep without yet understanding. Mary does not understand Jesus' saying in the Temple, and yet she preserves it (Lk 2:50-51)[48]. Many believers abandon a word, an event or a trial because they do not understand them at the time. Mary teaches the opposite: what comes from God is first kept, then pondered, and is often illumined years later, at the foot of the Cross or on Easter morning. Mary's silence is an inhabited memory.

Rare speech, therefore true

The second lesson concerns the tongue. The icon lays a finger on the lips, and the inscription Pope Francis signed on the back of the original aims directly at gossip[49]. His blessing intention of 2015 goes in the same direction: that those who enter may have “always the right words”[50]. Mary speaks little in the Gospel, but she never utters a useless, false or wounding word. The devotion to Our Lady of Silence therefore does not invite closed muteness. It invites the order Benedict XVI saw in her: first listening, pondering in the heart, then speaking only when the word can serve truth and charity.

Silence is not flight

The third lesson corrects a frequent misunderstanding. Mary's silence is not a retreat outside reality: she is present at the wedding where wine runs out, at the foot of the Cross where everything collapses, and in the Upper Room where the Church awaits the Spirit[51][52]. Her silence is a presence that does not flee. That is why it can be proposed to everyone, and not only to contemplatives: to whoever must remain beside a sick person without knowing what to say, to whoever passes through a trial no sentence resolves, to whoever learns to pray when words fail. On this path, the articles How to grow in interior silence and Why God seems silent prolong the reflection, the one on practice, the other on the trial of God's own silence.

Synthesis: why this title counts

QuestionAnswer of the sources
Is Our Lady of Silence an apparition?No, not as a distinct event; the name serves as a nickname for Knock (1879), an apparition without a single word
Is it a feast of the universal Church?No, no universal feast is celebrated under this title
What does the Church recognise at Knock?Testimonies judged worthy of belief in 1879, confirmed in 1935-1936, worship and pilgrimage encouraged
What does the Church recognise in the icon?A private devotion blessed and encouraged by Pope Francis; no supernaturality to declare, for want of an apparition
What does the devotion ask?Listening to the Word, keeping one's heart, guarding one's tongue, praying in recollection at Mary's school

Our Lady of Silence does not ask the reader to believe in one more event. She proposes to him to look at Mary differently: not only in her words, few in number and decisive, but in all that she kept without saying, from Bethlehem to the Upper Room. Knock shows this silence in an image, without a word. The Avezzano icon shows it in a gesture, a finger on the lips. The Gospel, for its part, recounts it in two sentences of Saint Luke that Benedict XVI never ceased to comment on. That is enough to make this title one of the most sober and most demanding of Marian piety: it promises neither a new revelation nor a prodigy, only a way of living before God, attentive, faithful and poor in useless words.

Going further

Notes and References

  1. Emiliano Antenucci, Our Lady of Silence: The Devotion of Pope Francis, Catholic Truth Society, ISBN 9781784696283: icon commissioned and offered to the Holy Father by the author, a Capuchin; collection of devotions to Our Lady of Silence for learning to guard one's words and welcome silence. Presentation by the publisher and Knock Shrine (knockshrine.ie).

    1 47
  2. Tekton Ministries, “Our Lady of Silence: A Pilgrimage to Knock” (tektonministries.org): at Knock, none of the witnesses heard anything; the apparition is presented there under the English title Our Lady of Silence. Pilgrimage source, used for the nickname and the silent trait, the facts of 1879 being established by the depositions and the shrine.

    2 6 18 19
  3. Santuario Madonna del Silenzio, official site (verginedelsilenzio.org), shrine page: chronology of the icon and the devotion. 1 November 2008, first booklet of the courses of silence; 26 to 28 February 2010, first course at Foligno; original icon commissioned by Brother Emiliano Antenucci and written in about nine months by the Benedictines of San Giulio island, Orta; 13 June 2011, arrival of the Madonna del Silenzio at the Penne convent; 17 and 18 March 2012, start of the courses in Guadalajara; 18 May 2015, blessing of the copy by Pope Francis; 2016, blessing of the original and inscription on the back; 24 March 2019, pope's handwritten letter to Father Nicola Galasso; choice of the San Francesco church and Capuchin convent of Avezzano, welcome by Bishop Pietro Santoro. Page read in full.

    3 27 28 32 36 37 38 39 40 42 43 44 49 50
  4. Mary's words recorded by the Gospels: Lk 1:34 and 1:38 (Annunciation); Lk 1:46-55 (Magnificat); Lk 2:48 (Jesus found again in the Temple); Jn 2:3 and 2:5 (Cana). No word of hers is recorded at the foot of the Cross or in the Upper Room.

    4
  5. Gospel according to Saint John 19:25-27: Mary stands near the Cross and Jesus entrusts her to the beloved disciple.

    5
  6. Santuario Madonna del Silenzio, official site (verginedelsilenzio.org): Madonna del Silenzio shrine, San Francesco church in Avezzano, kept by the Capuchins of Abruzzo following Pope Francis's request of 2019.

    7
  7. Gospel according to Saint Luke 2:19: “But Mary kept all these things, pondering them in her heart.” Verse commented on by Benedict XVI, general audience of 28 December 2011 (vatican.va).

    8
  8. Gospel according to Saint Luke 2:50-51: Jesus' parents “did not understand” his saying, and “his mother kept all these things in her heart”. Same source as the previous note.

    9 48
  9. Benedict XVI, general audience of 28 December 2011, “Prayer and the Holy Family of Nazareth” (vatican.va): Mary keeps and ponders the events in her heart (Lk 2:19); her memories of Jesus mark every instant of her existence; Luke presents her interiority and her prayer. Text read on the Holy See's site.

    10 11
  10. Benedict XVI, general audience of 14 March 2012, on Mary's praying presence: the stages of her journey, from Nazareth to Jerusalem and as far as the Cross, are marked by recollection and meditation on each event “in the silence of her heart before God” (cf. Lk 2:19-51). Text of the Holy See, read in its complete diffusion.

    12
  11. Gospel according to Saint Luke 1:38: “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.”

    13
  12. Gospel according to Saint Luke 1:46-55: the Magnificat, Mary's song of praise at the Visitation.

    14
  13. Gospel according to Saint John 2:3 and 2:5: “They have no wine”, then “Do whatever he tells you.”

    15 51
  14. Acts of the Apostles 1:14: the apostles, with Mary, mother of Jesus, are devoted to prayer before Pentecost.

    16 52
  15. Account of the apparition of 21 August 1879 from the official depositions of the fifteen witnesses, published in J. MacPhilpin, The Apparitions and Miracles at Knock, Dublin, M. H. Gill and Son, 1880, and taken up by Knock Shrine (knockshrine.ie). See the detail in the Ignispedia article Our Lady of Knock.

    17
  16. Catholic Tradition, “Our Lady of Knock” (catholictradition.org): Mary is said there to be known as Our Lady of Silence because she uttered no word at Knock, unlike her other famous apparitions.

    20
  17. Diocesan commissions of the Archdiocese of Tuam: first commission set up in 1879, which judges the testimonies trustworthy and satisfactory; second commission in 1935-1936, which questions the last witnesses living in Ireland again and confirms the judgment. Cf. Knock Shrine (knockshrine.ie), “History”; detail and references in the article Our Lady of Knock.

    21
  18. Raising of Knock Shrine to the rank of international Eucharistic and Marian shrine by Pope Francis, on 19 March 2021. Cf. Knock Shrine (knockshrine.ie); CNA, 11 March 2021; detailed references in the article Our Lady of Knock.

    22
  19. Santuario Madonna del Silenzio, official site (verginedelsilenzio.org), shrine page, sections on the icon: 8th-century Coptic fresco of Saint Anne (Faras, National Museum in Warsaw), icon by Gianmario Carozzi, gesture of Saint John the Theologian, choice of the Benedictines of San Giulio, egg tempera technique, Greek inscription “Mother of God”, testimony of the iconographer nun. Page read in full.

    23 24 25 26 29 30 31
  20. Catholic News Service, account taken up by The Evangelist (Diocese of Albany), 1 August 2019, “Hush Hour”: copy of the icon of Our Lady of Silence near the lifts of the Apostolic Palace, smaller copy on the pope's desk, three-day courses of silence of Father Emiliano Antenucci, quotations “silence is a revolution” and “silence is the womb where true words are born”. Article read in full.

    33 34 35 45 46
  21. Santuario Madonna del Silenzio, official site (verginedelsilenzio.org), contacts: “Santuario Madonna del Silenzio, Chiesa di San Francesco, Via Lago di Scanno 41, 67051 Avezzano AQ”.

    41

Can’t find your topic?