Our Lady of Naju and Julia Kim (South Korea, 1985-)

Since 30 June 1985, Julia Kim claims to see a statue of the Virgin weep and bleed in Naju (South Korea), with eucharistic miracles reported before bishops. The Church has judged these phenomena non-supernatural: sacraments celebrated on site incur automatic excommunication, and pilgrimages are forbidden by the local authority.

Ignispedia

Our Lady of Naju refers to a series of mystical phenomena reported since 30 June 1985 by Julia Kim (born Hong-Sun Youn, 22 January 1947), a converted Catholic woman residing in San Sebastián de Naju, in the Archdiocese of Gwangju (South Korea). The reported manifestations include ordinary and then bloody tears from a statue of the Virgin Mary over two periods of 700 days each, according to the shrine (tears from 30 June 1985 to 14 January 1992; perfumed oil from 24 November 1992 to 23 October 1994), twelve reported Eucharistic miracles between May 1988 and October 1996, descents of hosts between 1994 and 2002, stigmata, and the appearance of a spring on the hill known as the "Mountain of the Virgin"[1][2].

Several high-ranking ecclesiastics are among the direct witnesses: Bishop Roman Danylak, Apostolic Administrator of the Eparchy of Toronto for Ukrainian Catholics, published a written sworn testimony regarding the Eucharistic miracle of 22 September 1995; Bishop Dominic Su Haw-Chiu of Sibu (Malaysia) testified to a similar phenomenon; Bishop Giovanni Bulaitis, then Apostolic Nuncio to Korea, witnessed several descents of hosts according to accounts published by the shrine's defenders. The defenders further invoke a morning Mass celebrated by Pope Saint John Paul II in his private chapel on 31 October 1995, during which, according to their indirect testimony alone, a further Eucharistic miracle allegedly took place — an episode never confirmed by John Paul II and unsupported by any official document from the Holy See[3].

The diocesan authority of Gwangju nevertheless followed a trajectory of growing rejection. An investigating commission is established on 20 December 1994[4]; on 1 January 1998, Bishop Victorinus Youn Kong-hi declares that the phenomena "have provided no proof of divine origin"[5]. On 21 January 2008, his successor Bishop Andreas Choi Chang-mou promulgates a decree of automatic excommunication (latae sententiae) striking anyone who celebrates or participates in the sacraments at Naju[6]. In April 2008, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith upholds the 1998 judgment as the official position of the Church (letter Prot. N. 112/1993-27066)[7]. Catholic press outlets subsequently report a Roman reaffirmation in 2011, and then a reply from the Dicastery in October 2023 extending its scope to pilgrims from around the world — primary acts as yet unverified, pending verification[8][9]. Several Asian bishops' conferences echo these positions in a coordinated manner in 2025–2026[10][11].

The present article sets out the facts, the testimonies and the ecclesiastical trajectory without claiming to settle the nature of the phenomena. The canonical status in force — supernatural character not established, accompanied by severe disciplinary sanctions — is binding on every Catholic: it is not permitted to promote the phenomena publicly as supernatural, nor to take part in sacramental celebrations at Naju. Personal discernment must be exercised within the bounds of this ecclesiastical obedience; the reader will find the classic criteria in the article The Discernment of Supernatural Phenomena.

The Setting — Naju and Julia Kim

San Sebastián de Naju

Naju (羅州市, Naju-si) is a city in South Jeolla Province, in the south-west of South Korea, about 30 km south-west of Gwangju, the provincial capital. The city had a population of around 100,000 in 1985. The parish of San Sebastián de Naju, in the neighbourhood where Julia Kim lives, falls under the Archdiocese of Gwangju, one of the three metropolitan sees of South Korea alongside Seoul and Daegu. Catholics make up roughly 11 % of the Korean population in 2020 — a fervent but well-organised minority, generally conservative and careful to maintain its unity with Rome.

Biography of Julia Kim

According to the biographical account published by the shrine — the only source available for these details, in the “Who is Julia Kim?” section of her presentation page[12] — Hong-Sun Youn was born on 22 January 1947 in Naju. Her father was a schoolteacher and a scholar of Chinese (a specialist in classical Chinese literature); her mother stayed at home. The Korean War (1950-1953) hit the family hard: in 1950, her grandfather and father were killed by communist soldiers. Her younger sister died of illness shortly afterwards. Their mother raised the remaining children alone in great poverty; Julia left school before finishing middle school in order to work.

Again according to this same account from the shrine, in 1972 she married Julio Kim (Kim Man-bok), an employee of the agricultural department of Naju City Hall. The couple had four children (two sons and two daughters). Julia ran a small beauty salon adjoining their house, working as a hairdresser.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: key biographical milestones of Julia Kim before the statue's first tears.

In the early 1980s, Julia was diagnosed with terminal cancer. According to the account published by the shrine (same presentation page, with no independent corroboration), after several unsuccessful operations her husband took her to see a Catholic priest who prayed for her; Julia testified that she then felt “a warmth passing through her body” and found herself completely healed[13]. This healing led her, again according to the shrine's account, to receive Catholic baptism — Julia becoming her baptismal name — after a Protestant upbringing.

Again according to the shrine's account, in July 1982 (a dating given only by the shrine), she is said to have had a vision of the Christ covered in wounds, the Sacred Heart bleeding “because of the sins of mankind”. Following this vision, she says she consecrated herself as a “victim soul” and began to display episodic stigmata on her hands, feet and forehead[14].

The Timeline of the Phenomena (1985-2002)

30 June 1985 — the statue's first tears

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: chronology of the alleged phenomena of Naju, from 1985 to 2002, with their witnesses and documentary limitations.

On Sunday 30 June 1985 around midnight, Julia Kim claims to have seen her home statue of the Virgin Mary (a plaster statuette about 60 cm tall, bought in a religious shop) shed tears. The news spread quickly through the neighbourhood and the house began to receive its first visitors[15]. According to the counts carried out by the site's custodians, the statue wept intermittently for a total of 700 days, from 30 June 1985 to 14 January 1992[16].

18 July 1985 — the first message

On 18 July 1985, two and a half weeks after the first tears, Julia reports having received her first interior message attributed to the Virgin Mary[17]. The messages would continue for several years, dealing with classic themes of Catholic spirituality: conversion, penance, the Rosary, Eucharistic devotion, support for priests, and reparation for sins.

19 October 1986 — the first tears of blood

On 19 October 1986, for the first time, the clear tears turned into bloody red tears on the statue's face[18]. The site's custodians sent samples to a medical laboratory. According to the documentation published by najumary.kr, analyses carried out notably at Seoul National University allegedly concluded that it was human blood, with the blood type invariably identified as AB, and with DNA matching between samples taken on different dates[19]. These analyses, as presented by the shrine, were never published in verifiable form in a peer-reviewed scientific journal, and were not reproduced by independent laboratories commissioned by the diocesan authority.

5 June 1988 — the first Eucharistic miracle

On 5 June 1988, the Feast of Corpus Christi, Julia reports that the host received at Communion in the parish church of Naju allegedly visibly turned into bleeding flesh in her mouth[20]. This is the first of a series said to comprise twelve occurrences between May 1988 and October 1996.

24 November 1992 — the perfumed oil

On 24 November 1992, the statue began to exude a fragrant oil resembling balm. The phenomenon, intermittent but daily, lasted, according to the shrine, 700 consecutive days until 23 October 1994[21]. Witnesses speak of a “roses” perfume sometimes perceived at a distance. The phenomenon is said to have resumed sporadically from March 2001.

1992 — the water spring of “Mary's Mountain”

In 1992, on a hill acquired by the faithful near Naju, named “Mary's Mountain” (Mary's Mountain) and where a calvary would later be erected, a water spring appeared spontaneously where none had naturally existed, according to the custodians. Pilgrims began to drink this water, and several healings were attributed to it[22].

22 September 1995 — Eucharistic miracle in the presence of Bishop Roman Danylak

On Friday 22 September 1995 at 5 p.m., during an open-air Divine Liturgy celebrated in a valley near Naju, Bishop Roman Danylak, then Apostolic Administrator of the Eparchy of Toronto for the Ukrainians and Titular Bishop of Nyssa, was one of the principal concelebrants alongside Revv. Aloysius Chang (parish priest of the Archdiocese of Gwangju) and Joseph Peter Finn (retired priest of the Diocese of London, Canada)[23]. Bishop Danylak subsequently wrote a written sworn testimony stating that he had seen, at the Communion given to Julia Kim, the host “transform into a little heart of living flesh” about 5 mm thick, “with visible veins and tissue”[24]. This testimony is among the most frequently cited pieces of evidence by the defenders of the phenomena; it has been published in several Catholic periodicals and remains accessible online. Bishop Danylak died in 2012.

31 October 1995 — the Mass in the papal chapel

On 31 October 1995, Julia Kim, on pilgrimage to Rome, was invited to the morning Mass in the private chapel of Pope John Paul II. According to several indirect testimonies reported by the shrine's custodians, the host received by Julia allegedly transformed once again at the Communion given by the Pope himself[25]. John Paul II never publicly confirmed any such miracle. The defenders of Naju invoke a reported remark, “I too have seen the Eucharistic miracle”, said to have been spoken the same day at the Angelus, whose precise context and attribution remain disputed. To the knowledge of historians of the pontificate, there is no official document from the Holy See, nor any record from the Papal Household, attesting such an event.

1994-2002 — descents of hosts

Between 24 November 1994 and 6 January 2002, the shrine reports seven descents of consecrated hosts from the sky during open-air prayer meetings on the Mountain of the Virgin or in the chapel. The first, on 24 November 1994, was witnessed by Archbishop Giovanni Bulaitis, then Apostolic Nuncio to Korea (1990–1997), as was the second, on 1 July 1995, when seven hosts are said to have appeared simultaneously in the air and fallen before the altar[26]. With the cautious approval of the local bishop at the time, these hosts were consumed by two priests and five laypeople (including Julia Kim); during Julia's communion, the host is said to have bled again. Archbishop Bulaitis died in 2002.

9 November 2001 — blood and flesh on the Way of the Cross

On 9 November 2001, during a Way of the Cross on the Mountain of the Virgin in the presence of a small group, Julia reports an intense vision of the bleeding crucified Jesus. The group then discovers on the stones and leaves hundreds of drops of fresh blood and small tissue fragments[27]. Samples are sent to the forensic laboratory of Seoul National University; the shrine reports the conclusion “human blood of group AB” — without any reproducible independent scientific publication. An analogous phenomenon recurs on 11 June 2002.

The successive ecclesial positions

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: trajectory of the ecclesial decisions on Naju, from the 1994 diocesan commission to the coordinated warnings of 2025-2026.

The trajectory of the decisions of ecclesial authority forms the best-documented aspect of the case. It is marked by growing firmness over thirty years, independent of changes in archbishops.

20 December 1994 — diocesan investigating commission

According to the Catholic press (The Catholic Herald, March 2026 — primary diocesan act unverified to this day), the Archdiocese of Gwangju, under Archbishop Victorinus Youn Kong-hi, is said to have established on 20 December 1994 a diocesan investigating commission tasked with examining the reported phenomena. This commission is said to have gathered testimonies, observed certain prayer meetings and collected analyses. Several priests and foreign theologians travel to the site privately: the French theologian René Laurentin, a world-renowned specialist in Marian apparitions, meets Julia Kim in 1991 and expresses cautious interest; his observations will not lead to any magisterial endorsement[28].

1 January 1998 — first negative decree

On 1 January 1998, after more than three years of investigation, Archbishop Victorinus Youn Kong-hi issues a formal decree declaring that “the alleged miracles attributed to the Blessed Virgin Mary in Naju have provided no proof of divine origin” and that “to regard these events as supernatural is an act that breaks the unity of the Church's faith”[29]. The decree orders the priests of the diocese no longer to travel to Naju, the parishes not to organize pilgrimages, and the faithful not to regard the phenomena as certain.

Julia Kim then chooses to obey: she withdraws from public life for seven years (1998–2005) and stops meeting pilgrims. In 2001, the new archbishop, Archbishop Andreas Choi Chang-mou (in office since 2000), is said, according to the shrine's defenders, to have issued an ultimatum conveyed through an intermediary priest: Julia Kim was to sign a public statement acknowledging that all the phenomena were a hoax, failing which she would be barred from communion[30]. Julia refuses. She is barred from receiving communion in her parish.

From 2005 onwards, under growing pressure from foreign pilgrims and with the support of a few “sympathizing” priests, Julia Kim resumes her public activities, and sacraments are celebrated on the margins in Naju, in direct disobedience to the 1998 decree.

21 January 2008 — decree of latae sententiae excommunication

On 21 January 2008, Archbishop Andreas Choi Chang-mou issues a decree of exceptional gravity:

“I, Andreas Choi Chang-mou, Archbishop of Kwangju, exercising this episcopal office according to the solicitude and mandate of the Roman Pontiff, successor of Peter, and giving thanks to God for his mercy and his grace, promulgate, after mature reflection, the following decree for the unity and communion of the ecclesial community. […] I declare that clerics, religious or lay faithful who preside at or assist at the celebration of sacraments or sacramentals, against my prohibition, in any so-called 'oratory' or 'hill of Our Lady of Naju' incur a latae sententiae excommunication.”[31]

The decree explicitly names Julia Youn Hong-sun, her husband Julio Kim Man-bok and Father Aloysius Chang Hong-bin (who was celebrating Mass there without authorization). Father Chang is reduced to the lay state immediately[32]. The decree is read from the pulpit in every parish of the archdiocese.

This measure — excommunication being the most serious penalty in canon law — makes a great deal of noise. The archbishop imposes it by virtue of his authority as Ordinary, describing stubborn disobedience to a legitimate order as a break in ecclesial communion; the penalty applies automatically (latae sententiae) to anyone who performs the forbidden act, without any individual judgment being necessary.

24 April 2008 — confirmation by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

Three months later, by letter of 24 April 2008 (Prot. N. 112/1993-27066), the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (then presided over by Cardinal William Levada) states that it upholds the decision of Archbishop Victorinus Youn Kong-hi as the official position of the Church on the case[33]. In other words, Rome confirms the 1998 judgment of non constat — not a new universal penal sentence: the exact scope of this letter with regard to the diocesan decree of excommunication remains debated among canonists, and the reading that sees it as raising the penalty to the level of the universal Church is merely an opinion, not a formal act.

March 2011 — reaffirmation by the CDF

In March 2011, under the pontificate of Benedict XVI and the prefecture of Cardinal William Levada, the CDF is said to have reaffirmed its position in a note addressed to the Archdiocese of Gwangju — information reported by the Catholic press, whose primary act has not been verified to this day[34]. The pronounced canonical status remains unchanged: non constat de supernaturalitate, coupled with the excommunication provided for by the diocesan decree for participants in the sacraments celebrated there. This period corresponds to the time when the shrine begins to disseminate its messages massively in English through the multilingual portal Mary's Touch International, based in the United States, and when certain American and Filipino priests publicly amplify the phenomena — amplifications that this article analyses, as an opinion and not as a judgment, as contrary to the requirement of canon 753 of the Code of Canon Law, which asks every faithful to “adhere religiously” to the authentic magisterium of the bishops[35].

October 2023 — extension by Cardinal Fernández

According to the Catholic press (Catholic News Singapore, 26 November 2025), the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith — prefect: Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, in office since 1 July 2023 — is said to have replied in October 2023 by reusing the formula of the 2008 decree (automatic excommunication latae sententiae for anyone who celebrates the sacraments or takes part in them despite the prohibition), read by the press as extending the scope of the warning to pilgrims from around the world[36]. No primary act dated October 2023 has been verified to date: this point remains pending verification. If this reply is genuine, it would follow the logic of the new Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena published in May 2024, which maintain the possibility of a Roman intervention when international diffusion makes the issue a global one — which is precisely the case of Naju[37]. The growing international diffusion of the shrine (YouTube channels in six languages, translations of the messages into more than fifteen languages, pilgrimages organised from Southeast Asia, the United States, Western Europe and Latin America) and the multiplication of sacraments celebrated there without authorisation form its context, according to the bishops.

2025-2026 — Global Episcopal Coordination

As the 40th anniversary of the phenomena (June 2025) approaches, and above all with the Seoul World Youth Days scheduled for August 2027, Naju's international spread intensifies on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok and Facebook — with, according to the bishops, “content wrongly presenting papal endorsement”[38]. The prospect of an influx of young Catholics from around the world into Seoul, only 320 km from the shrine of Naju, leads the Korean bishops to fear unregulated parallel pilgrimages. Several Asian bishops' conferences issue coordinated warnings:

  • 3 October 2025 — Chancery notice of the Archdiocese of Singapore (ref. CHN/CN/2025/026) recalling the excommunication latae sententiae — verifiable act on the archdiocese's website (catholic.sg)[39][40]
  • 31 October 2025 — Singapore reiterates the warning (ref. CHN/CN/2025/030) and invites Catholics who have already visited Naju to receive the sacrament of Reconciliation[41]
  • 4 November 2025 — Archbishop Simon Poh, Archbishop of Kuching (Malaysia), in the diocesan newspaper Today's Catholic: “Catholics are not allowed to participate in the activities or pilgrimages to Naju, which incur automatic excommunication” — a pastoral formulation relayed by the press; the penal sanction of the 2008 decree, for its part, concerns the celebration of and participation in the sacraments[42]
  • 8 November 2025 — The Diocese of Sibu (Malaysia), former see of Bishop Dominic Su Haw-Chiu, is said to have urged its faithful to stay away from religious activities in Naju — information reported by the Catholic press alone, primary act unverified to date[43]
  • 12 January 2026 — Circular letter from the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Korea (Catholic Bishops' Conference of Korea), signed by its secretary general Fr. Lee Cheol-su, addressed to the bishops of the whole world under the title “Church's Teachings on the Issues Related to Julia Yoon of Naju” — existence confirmed by the Catholic press (UCA News), full text unverified to date[44][45]
  • 10 February 2026 — Resolution attributed to the Permanent Council of the Korean conference, requesting the formal cooperation of the Asian bishops' conferences — according to the Catholic press alone, pending verification
  • 12 March 2026 — Coordinated statement according to which Archbishop Simon Ok Hyun-jin, current Archbishop of Gwangju (since 30 November 2022), is said to be in communication with the DDF and preparing a new decree “intended not only for the local Church but for Catholics throughout the world” — according to the Catholic press alone, pending verification[46]

The Korean bishops described their intervention as a “request for attention regarding the situation worsening around Julia Youn of Naju” — a formulation that marks the unity of the episcopal discourse and the firmness of the canonical position. Fr. Lee Cheol-su's letter expressed explicit concern about the alleged participation of foreign clerics in Naju's prayer meetings, including, according to reports, bishops from Southeast Asia: “What is even more worrying is that many clerics, including bishops from Southeast Asia, take part in the prayer meetings”[47]. This internationalisation of the disorder is precisely what precipitated the episcopal coordination of 2025-2026.

Replica of the statue of Our Lady of Naju displayed in a church in the Philippines — an illustration of the Asian spread of the unauthorised cult that triggered the episcopal coordination of 2025-2026.

The following table summarises this thirty-year trajectory: each row indicates the acting authority, the act taken and its canonical scope. It reveals the most striking feature of the case — a firmness that grows and widens geographically without ever contradicting itself, under three successive archbishops and two Roman confirmations.

DateAuthorityActCanonical scope
20 Dec. 1994Archdiocese of Gwangju (Youn)Diocesan inquiry commission (according to the press, unverified act)Formal examination of the phenomena
1 Jan. 1998Archbishop V. Youn Kong-hiNegative decree: “no evidence of divine origin”Pastoral ban on diocesan pilgrimages
21 Jan. 2008Archbishop A. Choi Chang-mouExcommunication latae sententiae for sacraments celebrated on site; Fr. Chang reduced to the lay stateDiocesan penal sanction (sacraments)
24 Apr. 2008CDF (Card. Levada), letter Prot. 112/1993-27066Upholds the 1998 judgment as the official positionConfirmation of the non constat; penal scope debated
March 2011CDF (note reported by the press, unverified)Alleged reaffirmation of the positionPronounced status maintained
Oct. 2023DDF (reply reported by the press, unverified)2008 formula reused, read as an extensionAlleged universal scope, pending verification
2025-2026Bishops' conferences (Korea, Singapore, Malaysia)Coordinated warnings; new decree announced by the pressRelay of the pastoral ban (Singapore verified; other acts pending)

Testimonies of foreign clergy

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: main clergy cited by the defenders of Naju, distinguishing private testimony from official recognition.

Several foreign clergy members — often ill-informed about the Korean context and the position of the local Ordinary — have offered testimonies favourable to the phenomena of Naju, notably in the 1990s. These testimonies, extensively cited by the shrine's defenders, must be read in their context.

Bishop Roman Danylak (1995)

Bishop Roman Danylak (1930–2012), apostolic administrator of the Eparchy of Toronto for Ukrainian Catholics (1992–1998) and Titular Bishop of Nyssa, is the most detailed foreign ecclesiastical witness. His written sworn testimony on the Eucharistic miracle of 22 September 1995 describes the transformation observed in detail and concludes as to its authenticity[48] :

“The Holy Host received by Julia Kim was changed into living flesh and blood. The Host had turned dark red, and living blood was flowing from it.” — Bishop Roman Danylak, Testimony on the Eucharistic miracle of 22 September 1995[49]

Fr. Joseph Peter Finn, the concelebrant, for his part stated that he had seen “the white edge of the host disappear and change into the substance of living flesh”[50]. These declarations are precise and made under oath; even so, they remain private testimonies uncorroborated by a source independent of the shrine, with no value as established fact. Bishop Danylak was removed from his duties as apostolic administrator in 1998 (in a separate context, related to the administration of the eparchy) and lived in retirement until his death. His testimony binds him alone; no ecclesiastical authority drew from it any canonical consequence favourable to Naju — an individual testimony, even a bishop's, does not take the place of the judgment of the competent Ordinary.

Bishop Dominic Su Haw-Chiu (Sibu, Malaysia)

Bishop Dominic Su Haw-Chiu, then Bishop of the Diocese of Sibu (Malaysia), is said to have witnessed a similar Eucharistic phenomenon during a later visit by Julia Kim to Malaysia. His testimony is mentioned only in the documentation published by najumary.kr and has been the subject of no official publication under diocesan seal[51]: it is an uncorroborated private testimony, with no value as established fact.

Archbishop Giovanni Bulaitis (apostolic nuncio)

Archbishop Giovanni Bulaitis (1933–2002), titular archbishop and apostolic nuncio to Korea from 1990 to 1997, is said to have been present, according to the shrine's account alone, at several descents of hosts (notably on 24 November 1994 and 1 July 1995). A favourable statement is attributed to him by the shrine's defenders alone — “Naju is a place of repentance and salvation for the 4 billion inhabitants of Asia” — with no official document published by either the nunciature or the Holy See confirming it. As nuncio, Archbishop Bulaitis had no authority to pronounce a doctrinal judgment; his personal position, even supposing it was as favourable as reported, does not bind the Holy See. The whole matter falls under uncorroborated private testimony, with no value as established fact.

Bishop Paul Kim Ok-kyun (Cheongju, 1997)

Bishop Paul Kim Ok-kyun, then Bishop of Cheongju (South Korea), is said to have witnessed a descent of a host on 12 June 1997. His testimony is reported by the shrine alone, with no official publication under diocesan seal: uncorroborated private testimony, with no value as established fact. Bishop Kim, as a Korean bishop, is today party to the consensus of the bishops' conference that supports the position of Gwangju.

Fr. René Laurentin (1991)

Fr. René Laurentin (1917–2017), French priest, theologian and historian of worldwide renown as a specialist in Marian apparitions (Lourdes, Medjugorje), met Julia Kim in 1991 in a private capacity. Known for his positive prudence towards mystical phenomena, he spoke favourably of the need for a serious examination but never gave any doctrinal endorsement. As a private theologian, he had no authority to pronounce a judgment on the supernatural character of the events: his interest falls under uncorroborated private testimony, with no value as established fact.

The “miracle” before John Paul II — a critical examination

The episode of the Mass of 31 October 1995 in the private chapel of John Paul II is invoked as the supreme testimony in favour of Naju. Several reservations must be raised:

  1. No public papal confirmation: John Paul II never mentioned Naju in any official document, homily, public audience, or known private letter.
  2. No mention in the Papal Household: the internal documentation of the Papal Household (Pio Vincenzo Ronchi, Stanisław Dziwisz, Gianfranco Ghirlanda) does not mention the event.
  3. The phrase attributed to the Angelus: “I too have seen the Eucharistic miracle” is attributed by the shrine's defenders but does not appear in the official texts of John Paul II's Angelus addresses available on vatican.va.
  4. The canonisation of John Paul II in 2014 made no mention of any element related to Naju, even though the process would have been the occasion for a rigorous examination of the events of his pontificate.

The absence of any official trace, in a case where a papal endorsement would radically change the picture, is in itself a significant negative element.

Difficulties and Objections

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: matrix of the evidentiary record, between alleged signs, private testimonies and limits of verification.

Several elements of the Naju case have fuelled the scepticism of ecclesiastical authorities and of many observers. These deserve to be presented without evasion.

The question of obedience as the primary criterion

This is by far the central difficulty. An authentic visionary is traditionally distinguished by their heroic obedience to the Church, even when she puts them to the test. Saint Bernadette Soubirous submitted without reserve to the Bishop of Tarbes; Lucia of Fátima obeyed Bishop da Silva absolutely; Luisa Piccarreta, according to her biographers, withdrew her books as soon as they were placed on the Index in 1938. Julia Kim obeyed for 7 years (1998–2005), but broke that obedience in 2005 — summarising it herself as a disciplinary fault in the spirit of canon law. The archdiocese saw in this no longer a mere imprudence but an obstinate rupture of communion, justifying the excommunication of 2008.

The Church's teaching on the "disobedient visionary"

Catholic mystical theology holds as a constant criterion that an authentic grace or revelation strengthens obedience to the Church, while whatever leads to disobedience, justifies it, or divides the community is held suspect. Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P., professor of dogmatic and mystical theology at the Angelicum, sets out this principle at length in The Three Ages of the Interior Life (1938), in the line of Saint John of the Cross and Saint Ignatius of Loyola[52]:

"The inspiration of the Holy Spirit, far from destroying the obedience due to superiors, makes its fulfilment easier, and must always be understood on condition that obedience does not command otherwise." — Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P., The Three Ages of the Interior Life, Cerf, 1938[53]

It is precisely this criterion that theologians invoke in the Naju case: spectacular phenomena, however numerous, cannot make up for an obstinate rupture with the legitimate Ordinary, for the same Church that discerns charisms is the one that received from Christ the power to bind and to loose (Mt 16:19).

The unverifiable scientific analyses

The blood analyses presented by najumary.kr (human blood, group AB, DNA match) have not been published in peer-reviewed journals nor reproduced by independent laboratories commissioned by the diocesan authority. The comparative reading with the Shroud of Turin is suggestive but not probative: blood group AB is shared by approximately 5% of the world's population. The numerical breakdowns of ethnic origin sometimes cited by commentators rest on no formal publication and are not reproduced here.

The absence of official papal confirmation

The alleged miracle of 31 October 1995 in the papal chapel, the high point for defenders of the apparitions, is attested by no official document from the Holy See. Had John Paul II actually witnessed a Eucharistic miracle, it is extremely improbable that no trace of it would survive in the internal documentation of the pontificate.

The "one-sided" attitude reproached to the diocesan authority

Defenders of Naju point out that the 1994–1998 commission of inquiry was conducted as a prosecution, setting aside favourable testimonies and never travelling to the site during the phenomena, and that the 2008 sanctions are canonically excessive. This argument has some historical validity: the initial inquiry was imperfect, as in several other discernment cases (Garabandal, Medjugorje in its early days). But the constancy of the position over 30 years, under three successive archbishops (Youn, Choi, Ok), with a Roman confirmation in 2008 (and a Roman reply of 2023 reported by the press, unverified), progressively exhausts the force of this objection.

Specific Doctrinal Objections

Beyond the disciplinary questions (obedience) and evidentiary ones (verifiability of the scientific analyses), the Naju case raises strictly doctrinal objections which weigh heavily in the canonical assessment.

The Eucharistic objection: "hosts falling from the sky" and sacramental theology

This is the gravest theological objection. The phenomena reported at Naju between 1994 and 2002 include seven descents of hosts appearing "from the air" during open-air prayer meetings. These hosts were then consumed as sacramental communion by the faithful present. Yet Catholic theology teaches very clearly the conditions for the validity of the Eucharist:

  1. Matter — wheat bread and grape wine (cf. CCC § 1412, Code of Canon Law can. 924);
  2. Form — the words of consecration: "This is my Body… This is the chalice of my Blood…";
  3. Minister — a bishop or validly ordained priest, in persona Christi (cf. CCC § 1411);
  4. Intention — the intention to do what the Church does[54].

The Council of Trent defines dogmatically that by the words of consecration pronounced by a validly ordained priest, "the bread truly becomes the Body of Christ" — and in no other way[55]. Session XIII of 11 October 1551 formulates the canon in deliberately precise and solemn language:

"If anyone denies that in the most holy sacrament of the Eucharist are contained truly, really and substantially the Body and Blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ […] let him be anathema." — Council of Trent, Session XIII, Decree on the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist, Canon 1 (11 October 1551)[56]

Yet the substance of the Body of Christ, according to the same Tridentine decree, becomes present only "by the power of the words" pronounced by a validly ordained minister at the Eucharistic oblation. A host appearing spontaneously, without previously consecrated bread, without Mass, without a priest pronouncing the words of consecration, cannot be the Eucharist in the dogmatic sense of the term. Whatever the nature of the phenomenon observed (unexplained material appearance, illusion, trickery, or even a preternatural phenomenon), the thing is not sacramentally the Body of Christ — precisely because the conditions of validity recalled above, drawn from the Magisterium (Trent, CCC, canon law), are not fulfilled. Consuming it as such, and a fortiori venerating it as such, would entail — according to the theological opinion defended here, not according to a sentence of the Magisterium — the risk of a material idolatry through mistake, by rendering to an object a worship due only to the Eucharistic Body of the Lord. It is this radical difficulty, more even than the disciplinary rupture of 2005, that concerns theologians.

The same problem holds, according to this same theological opinion, for the tissue fragments and drops of blood that appeared in 2001 and 2002 during the Stations of the Cross on the "Mountain of the Virgin": their veneration as relics of Christ presupposes a certainty that the ecclesiastical authority has not granted and that the theology received of the Passion, according to this reading, does not authorise — the glorious Christ "dieth no more" (Rom 6:9, cited here as an argument from scriptural authority, not as formal proof) and bleeds no more in history.

The case of the Salesian Alexander Kim Dae-sik (expelled in 2022)

Iconographic replica of the statue of Our Lady of Naju — a model circulated by the defenders, around which are organised the illicit sacramental celebrations targeted by the 2008 decree of excommunication.

Fr. Alexander Kim Dae-sik is a Korean Salesian ordained in 1996, a missionary in Malawi, who returned to Korea in 2020. From 2020 onward, he began celebrating sacraments in Naju in direct defiance of the 2008 decree. On 22 October 2022, Fr. Ángel Fernández Artime, then Major Rector of the Salesian Society of St. John Bosco, issued a decree of expulsion from the order against Kim Dae-sik for repeated illegitimate acts[57]. This decree does not mechanically reduce him to the lay state — the priestly dimension remains as long as Rome has not pronounced the dimissio in statu laicali — but it withdraws all authorization for ministry. Yet according to the Archdiocese of Gwangju, Fr. Kim continued to celebrate sacraments illicitly at the Naju site until at least 2024, which led to the diocesan warning note published that same year[58].

The Kim Dae-sik case is not an isolated one: he is the second priest explicitly sanctioned in the Naju dossier, after Fr. Aloysius Chang Hong-bin, reduced to the lay state by the decree of 21 January 2008. This recurrence — two priests in fifteen years, one dimissus, the other expelled from a religious institute — illustrates the dynamic of organized disobedience that the Korean bishops have been denouncing since 2008 as a major negative ecclesial fruit.

The contrast with recognized visionaries

The criterion of obedience, central to the tradition, stands out in full relief in the comparison. The apparitions that the Church eventually recognized have in common an obedience maintained even through the trial, whereas Naju has known a public rupture. The table below highlights this contrast.

VisionaryTrial imposed by the ChurchThe visionary's responseCanonical outcome
Bernadette Soubirous (Lourdes, 1858)Rigorous interrogations, initial distrust from the Bishop of TarbesTotal submission, withdrawal to the convent in NeversRecognition in 1862; canonization 1933
Lúcia dos Santos (Fátima, 1917)Strict control by Bishop da Silva, secrecy imposedAbsolute obedience throughout her lifeRecognition 1930; canonization of the shepherd children
Luisa Piccarreta (Corato)Placement of her writings on the Index in 1938Withdrawal of her books (according to her biographers)Beatification cause opened in 1994
Julia Kim (Naju, 1985–)Negative decree of 1998, prohibition from the OrdinaryObedience 1998–2005, then public ruptureNon constat; excommunication of participants

Unlike the first three, Julia Kim resumed her public activities in 2005 against the explicit prohibition of her archbishop. It was this rupture, more even than the debated nature of the phenomena, that led to the sanctions of 2008.

The Eastern counter-example: the "Our Lady of Akita" (Japan, 1973–1981)

Just 1,200 km from Naju, a similar case sheds contrasting light on the canonical fate of Julia Kim. In Japan, in the convent of the Handmaids of the Eucharist in Yuzawadai (Akita Prefecture), a wooden statue of the Virgin began to weep between 4 January 1975 and 15 September 1981; the visionary, Sister Agnes Sasagawa Katsuko, deaf and afflicted with mystical episodes, also reported three messages received in 1973. On 22 April 1984, after more than ten years of investigation, Bishop John Shojiro Ito of Niigata published a pastoral letter declaring the events « worthy of belief » and authorizing public devotion[59]. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, then chaired by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, did not oppose this recognition — which some canonists read as tacit assent: a common doctrinal reading, not a formal act of the Holy See.

Four elements distinguish Akita from Naju:

  1. The constant obedience of Sister Agnes, a cloistered religious subject to her bishop and her superior;
  2. The sober eucharistic focus of the messages — a call to the Rosary, penance, reparative Communion — with no "hosts falling from the sky" and no improvised sacramental miracle;
  3. The scientific examination of the tears entrusted to Professor Kaoru Sagisaka of Akita University (human blood of groups A, B, and AB across three successive samples), published at the time;
  4. The complete absence of canonical sanction over the following thirty years, despite the worldwide spread of the dossier — proof that the Church knows how to recognize Marian tears when the ecclesial context remains sound.

The fate of Akita shows that the severity displayed toward Naju is neither a general skeptical reflex nor a prejudice against Asian phenomena. It targets a precise ecclesial configuration: spectacular phenomena + organized disobedience + unverified claims of papal endorsement + illicit sacraments celebrated on site. It is this combination that the Archdiocese of Gwangju and the DDF refuse.

Applicable criteria of discernment

How should a Catholic approach a case like Naju? The founding principle is laid down by the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which places all private revelation below and at the service of the one Revelation completed in Christ and the Apostles[60]:

« Down the centuries, there have been so-called "private" revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to "improve" or "complete" the definitive Revelation of Christ, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history. […] Christian faith cannot accept "revelations" that claim to surpass or correct the Revelation of which Christ is the fulfilment. » — Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 67[61]

Saint John of the Cross had formulated the same principle with a famous radicality: since God has given us his Son, who is his unique and definitive Word, he has no new revelation to add[62].

« He has told us everything at once and in one single utterance in this single Word; therefore he has nothing more to say to us. » — Saint John of the Cross, The Ascent of Mount Carmel, II, 22, cited in the Catechism, § 65[63]

A credible private revelation can therefore add nothing to the faith: its role is purely pastoral, and its examination belongs to the Church. This is codified by the Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena, published by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on 25 February 1978 and then entirely reworked on 17 May 2024 by Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández[64]. The 2024 reform abandons direct judgment on supernaturalness in favour of six graded conclusions, from the most favourable to the most negative. The table below summarises them and situates the case of Naju — this comparison being, let us recall, an interpretive reading without formal classification by the Dicastery.

ConclusionMeaningPastoral decision of the bishop
Nihil obstatSigns of an action of the Holy Spirit; no serious critical aspectDevotion and pilgrimages encouraged
Prae oculis habeaturPositive signs, but elements of confusion or risksCareful discernment and vigilance
CuraturCritical elements, but wide diffusion and fruits already presentNo prohibition; direct the faithful towards other devotions
Sub mandatoPhenomenon rich in positive elements, but exploited by a person or a groupRome directly oversees its management
Prohibetur et obstruatur (interpretive comparison for Naju, not a formal classification)Critical points and serious risksPublic declaration: adherence is not permitted
Declaratio de non supernaturalitateFacts and evidence establishing non-supernaturalnessFormal declaration that the phenomenon is not supernatural

The Naju case has received no formal classification under the 2024 Norms: the only judgment ever pronounced remains the non constat of 1998, upheld by Rome in 2008. By interpretive reading only — not by an act of the Dicastery — the de facto treatment of the case (public prohibition of worship and of propagation) can be compared to the fifth category, the Prohibetur et obstruatur, which the 2024 Norms define as follows[65]:

« The critical points and the risks seem serious. Therefore, in order to avoid further confusion or even scandals, the Dicastery asks the Diocesan Bishop to declare publicly that adherence to this phenomenon is not permitted. » — Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Norms for the Discernment of Supernatural Phenomena, 17 May 2024[66]

For personal discernment, the classic criteria remain those of the tradition (cf. Saint John of the Cross, The Ascent of Mount Carmel II, 21-22; Saint Ignatius of Loyola, Rules for the Discernment of Spirits; Saint Alphonsus Liguori, Theologia Moralis VI, no. 142):

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: seven criteria of discernment applied to Naju, with the decisive weight of the local Ordinary confirmed by Rome.
  1. Doctrinal orthodoxy of the messages (at Naju: broadly compliant — a favourable point)
  2. Lasting spiritual fruits (conversions, life of prayer, inner peace)
  3. External signs (miracles, medically verified healings)
  4. The holiness of the seer (humility, obedience, charity, hidden life)
  5. Attitude towards the hierarchy (heroic obedience, no division)
  6. Absence of ecclesial division created by the movement
  7. The opinion of the local Ordinary as first canonical judge

At Naju, criteria 1, 2 and 3 received a mixed evaluation; criteria 4, 5, 6 and 7 received an explicit and growing negative evaluation from the legitimate authority. For a Catholic, criterion 7 — the opinion of the local Ordinary, validated by Rome — is canonically decisive.

📖 Related article: for a systematic presentation of the criteria of discernment and the new DDF nomenclature (May 2024), see The Discernment of Supernatural Phenomena.

The Fate of Julia Kim and Naju

Julia Kim is now 79 years old (in 2026). According to the shrine's public communications, she continues to receive ecstasies and deliver messages. On 30 June 2025, for the 40th anniversary of the first tears, the shrine organized an international commemoration that brought together several thousand pilgrims, including groups from Japan, the Philippines, Singapore, Malaysia, the United States and Western Europe[67]. It is precisely the scale of this mobilization that triggered the worldwide episcopal coordination of October 2025 — March 2026.

The shrine has an international center run by the organization Mary's Touch International (United States) and publishes multilingual bulletins. Hundreds of testimonies of healing or conversion are reported. Defenders invoke against the ecclesial sentence the Gospel word on the tree and its fruits[68]:

"By their fruits you will know them. Do men gather grapes from thorns, or figs from thistles? […] A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit." — Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 7, 16-18[69]

The argument is not, however, decisive. The bishops reply by distinguishing the psychological and religious fruits — consolations, fervor, personal conversions, which can accompany any intense devotion, even outside the Catholic Church — from the authentic ecclesial fruits, which are recognized by communion and obedience. Saint Paul had formulated this unambiguously in distinguishing the signs of the spirits and the fruits of the Spirit: the latter are "charity, joy, peace, patience, helpfulness, goodness, trust in others, gentleness, self-control" (Gal 5, 22) — not the spectacular phenomena, but the structure of communion they generate[70]. Now the most visible fruit of Naju since 2008 is an organized disobedience leading to the excommunication of the faithful — a fruit that tradition holds precisely to be bad.

Saint Thomas Aquinas had codified it in the Summa Theologiae (II-II, q. 178, a. 2): the gratiae gratis datae (extraordinary charisms given for the sake of others) must always yield, in the order of discernment, to the gratia gratum faciens (the sanctifying grace that makes the soul pleasing to God and which is recognized by charity and obedience). An extraordinary sign is never self-validating: it is worth what its fruit is worth, and its true fruit is to strengthen the bond with the Church — not to break it[71].

What Attitude Should a Catholic Adopt?

The position of the Catholic Church on Naju is unambiguous in 2026:

  • The phenomena are not recognized as supernatural: the only judgment issued, the non constat de supernaturalitate of 1998, upheld by Rome in 2008.
  • Pilgrimages are forbidden by the local authority (pastoral warning, echoed by several Asian bishops in 2025-2026) — distinct from the penal sanction.
  • Only the celebration of the sacraments and sacramentals on site, or participation in them despite the prohibition, entails excommunication latae sententiae (diocesan decree of 21 January 2008).
  • Public promotion of the phenomena as supernatural is forbidden.

This position is binding on every Catholic, regardless of his or her personal judgment on the nature of the phenomena. The criterion of ecclesial obedience takes precedence over personal attraction to a mystery that remains scientifically and theologically disputed. Saint Ignatius of Loyola had given the extreme formula, which measures how far the trust owed to the Church's judgment extends[72]:

"To be sure in all things, we must always hold that what I see as white, I believe to be black, if the hierarchical Church so defines it." — Saint Ignatius of Loyola, Spiritual Exercises, no. 365 (thirteenth rule for the true sense in the Church)[73]

This rule does not ask one to deny one's reason or one's senses, but to grant the Church's judgment, in matters belonging to it, a trust superior to one's own impressions. Applied to Naju, it means that however strong the emotion before the reported signs, the faithful defer to the sentence of the legitimate authority.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI: the Catholic's practical attitude toward Naju as long as the unfavorable ecclesial judgment stands.

This in no way prejudges a possible future re-examination. The history of Marian apparitions shows cases initially rejected and then reopened, and vice versa. A Catholic may pray privately for Julia Kim, ask God for light on this case, study the elements of the file in a spirit of honest research. What he or she cannot do is travel to Naju to participate in sacraments or publicly promote the phenomena as supernatural.

The case of Naju illustrates — and this is its major pedagogical value — the complexity of ecclesial discernment in a context where:

  • The spectacular phenomena are numerous and abundantly documented (videos, photographs, testimonies).
  • Several foreign clerics have given favorable testimonies.
  • The scientific analyses presented are impressive but cannot be independently verified.
  • And yet: the legitimate ecclesial authority, after decades of examination, delivers a clear negative judgment and confirms it on several occasions.

This tension is not unusual. It underscores how demanding the discernment of spirits is and how ecclesial prudence often goes beyond mere human impressionability before the marvelous.

To go further

Notes and References

  1. « Julia Kim — Messages and Signs from Naju, Korea », biographical presentation page published by the shrine of Naju (najumary.kr), section « Who is Julia Kim? » (born 1947 in Naju, father a Chinese-language schoolteacher, deaths in 1950, poverty, marriage 1972, four children, cancer, healing, beauty salon, stigmata). This source is that of the defenders of the phenomena and the only one to provide these details; it is cited as the shrine's account, without independent corroboration and without taking a position on the supernatural interpretation.

    1 12 13 14 15 17 19 22 27 30 51
  2. « Our Lady of Naju, Korea, 1985-2002 », Divine Mysteries and Miracles (divinemysteries.info). Chronological compilation of the reported phenomena, aggregating the shrine's primary sources and the public testimonies of foreign clergy.

    2 16 18 20 21 26
  3. « Eucharistic Miracle of Naju, Korea, Vatican, Toronto, ON 1995 », Apostolate of Eucharistic Adoration Inc. (perpetualeucharisticadoration.com). Compilation of testimonies relating to the Eucharistic miracles of September and October 1995, including the detailed account attributed to Bishop Danylak and the reported details of the pontifical Mass of 31 October 1995.

    3 24 25
  4. « Church in South Korea repeats warning over excommunicated visionary », The Catholic Herald, 24 March 2026 (thecatholicherald.com). Overview article on the 2025-2026 episcopal coordination, giving the complete timeline of ecclesiastical decisions since the commission of inquiry of 20 December 1994.

    4 7 8 11 28 33 34 38 45 46 67
  5. « Decree of the Archbishop of Kwangju », Sangguniang Laiko ng Pilipinas, 13 October 2018 (cbcplaiko.org). Full text of the decree of 21 January 2008 by Archbishop Andreas Choi Chang-mou of Gwangju, instituting latae sententiae excommunication for participants in the sacraments at Naju and reducing Fr. Aloysius Chang Hong-bin to the lay state.

    5 6 29 31 32
  6. « Why visiting Naju shrine carries automatic excommunication », Catholic News (Singapore), 26 November 2025 (catholicnews.sg). Summary of the position of Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, on the extension of the excommunication to pilgrims worldwide (October 2023).

    9 36 40
  7. « Catholics warned to avoid controversial South Korean Marian shrine », Aleteia, 11 November 2025 (aleteia.org). Coverage of the statement by Archbishop Simon Poh of Kuching (Malaysia), dated 4 November 2025, and of the Archdiocese of Singapore of 3 and 31 October 2025.

    10 39 41 42 43
  8. Bishop Roman Danylak, Testimony on the Eucharistic Miracle of September 22, 1995, written testimony under oath published and reproduced in particular at sacredheartofjesus.ca and Mary's Touch (marys-touch.com). Bishop Danylak (1930-2012) was apostolic administrator of the Eparchy of Toronto for Ukrainian Catholics (1992-1998) and titular bishop of Nyssa. Original English text: « The Sacred Host received by Julia Kim was changed to living flesh and blood. The Host had changed to dark red, living flesh and blood was flowing from it »; for Fr. Finn: « he saw the white edge of the host disappearing, and changing into the substance of living flesh ».

    23 48 49 50
  9. Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 753: « Bishops in communion with the head and members of the College, whether individually or gathered in conferences of Bishops or in particular councils, although they do not enjoy infallibility in their teaching, are the authentic teachers and masters of the faith of the faithful entrusted to their care; the faithful are obliged to adhere with religious submission of mind to this authentic magisterium of their Bishops. » See also Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium, no. 25 (21 November 1964); Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§ 891-892 on the doctrinal authority of the bishops.

    35
  10. Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena, 17 May 2024, signed by Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, prefect (French text at vatican.va). These norms replace those of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith of 25 February 1978 and substitute six graded conclusions (Nihil obstat, Prae oculis habeatur, Curatur, Sub mandato, Prohibetur et obstruatur, Declaratio de non supernaturalitate) for the former triad.

    37 64 65 66
  11. « Korean bishops reiterate call to avoid Marian shrine », Aleteia, 18 January 2026 (aleteia.org). The article details the circular letter of 12 January 2026 from the Catholic Bishops' Conference of Korea, signed by its secretary general, Fr. Lee Cheol-su, and entitled « Church's Teachings on the Issues Related to Julia Yoon of Naju ». The letter expresses concern over the alleged participation of Southeast Asian bishops in the Naju prayer meetings.

    44 47
  12. Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P., Les Trois Âges de la vie intérieure, prélude de celle du ciel [The Three Ages of the Interior Life, Prelude to That of Heaven], Éditions du Cerf, 1938, vol. II — account of the discernment of private revelations and the role of obedience as a criterion of authenticity.

    52 53
  13. Council of Trent, Session XIII (11 October 1551), Decretum de sanctissimo Eucharistiae sacramento, canons 1-4 — on the matter, form, and minister of the sacrament of the Eucharist; Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§ 1411-1412; Code of Canon Law (1983), can. 924-927. The validity of the sacrament requires the conjunction of the four elements (matter, form, minister, intention); no prodigious phenomenon can supply for their absence.

    54 55
  14. Council of Trent, Session XIII, Decretum de sanctissimo Eucharistiae sacramento, canon 1 (11 October 1551), DH 1651 (Denzinger-Hünermann, 43rd ed., Cerf, 2010). Original Latin text: « Si quis negaverit, in sanctissimae Eucharistiae sacramento contineri vere, realiter et substantialiter corpus et sanguinem una cum anima et divinitate Domini nostri Iesu Christi […] anathema sit. »

    56
  15. « Catholics warned against visiting controversial Marian site in S. Korea », UCA News, 7 November 2025 (ucanews.com). The article specifies in particular the identity of Fr. Alexander Kim Dae-sik, a Salesian ordained in 1996, missionary in Malawi, who returned to Korea in 2020 and was expelled from the Salesian Society by decree of the Rector Major, Fr. Ángel Fernández Artime, on 22 October 2022 for illegitimate celebration of sacraments in Naju.

    57 58
  16. Bishop John Shojiro Ito, Bishop of Niigata, Pastoral Letter on the Events of Akita, 22 April 1984. See also F. Yasuda, Akita: Tears and Message of Mary, F.-X. de Guibert, Paris, 1990; and K. Sagisaka (University of Akita), hematological analysis reports on the tears and blood exuded by the statue of Yuzawadai (1981-1982). The episcopal recognition did not receive an explicit nihil obstat from the Holy See; the absence of opposition from the CDF under Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in 1984-1988 is read by some canonists as tacit assent — a doctrinal reading, not a formal act.

    59
  17. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§ 65 and 67, on Revelation completed in Jesus Christ and the status of private revelations (Mame/Plon edition, 1992; official text at vatican.va).

    60 61
  18. Saint John of the Cross, The Ascent of Mount Carmel, book II, ch. 22, on the fullness and closure of Revelation in the Word; passage cited by the Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 65.

    62 63
  19. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 7:16-18 (translation of the Jerusalem Bible, Cerf). Passage regularly invoked in controversies over apparitions; see the application made of it by the Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 67, which subordinates this discernment to the Magisterium.

    68 69
  20. Saint Paul, Epistle to the Galatians, 5, 22-23 (translation of the Bible de Jérusalem, Cerf, 1998). A key passage for New Testament discernment: the fruits of the Spirit are interior and relational dispositions, not prodigious phenomena. See the patristic commentary of Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on Galatians, hom. V.

    70
  21. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, II-II, q. 171-178 (De gratiis gratis datis), especially q. 178, a. 2 (Utrum donum miraculorum conveniat malis). See also Summa contra Gentiles, book IV, c. 55. For the classic distinction gratia gratum faciens / gratia gratis data, see Fr. Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P., The Three Ages of the Interior Life, vol. II, Part II, ch. XLIV, on gratia gratis data and its discernment.

    71
  22. Saint Ignatius of Loyola, Spiritual Exercises, no. 365 (thirteenth of the Rules for Having the Right Judgment in the Church Militant). Original Spanish text: « debemos siempre tener para en todo acertar, que lo blanco que yo veo, creer que es negro, si la Iglesia jerárquica así lo determina ».

    72 73

Can’t find your topic?