Saint John the Evangelist (Bethsaida - Ephesus, c. 100)

The disciple whom Jesus loved, author of five books of the New Testament: his life from Galilee to Ephesus, his writings received by the Church, and the reasons for upholding their traditional attribution.

Ignispedia

Saint John, son of Zebedee and brother of James, is the apostle whom Jesus loved: the only one of the Twelve to remain at the foot of the Cross, the first to believe before the empty tomb, the one to whom Christ entrusted his Mother. Setting out from Galilee as a simple fisherman, he ended his life at Ephesus as the patriarch of the Churches of Asia, dying around the year 100 after having seen the whole of the first Christian century pass before him[1].

He is also, with Paul, the greatest author of the New Testament: a Gospel, three epistles, and Revelation bear his name, that is, five books out of twenty-seven. The Church has received them from him from the very beginning, and the Pontifical Biblical Commission confirmed in 1907 that it is historically certain that Saint John wrote the fourth Gospel, a historical document of the real events and discourses of the life of the Lord[2].

This article presents him as a figure of the Bible received by the Church: his life in the Gospels and Acts, the traditional attribution and dating of his five books, the ancient witnesses that guarantee them, their structure and theology, their use in the liturgy, and then, at the end of the journey, the common objections and the debate with modern exegesis. The detailed dossier on the fourth Gospel can be found in The Gospel according to Saint John, and the one on Revelation in The Revelation of Saint John: they are not repeated here, we simply refer to them.

John's Place in the New Testament

The Disciple Whom Jesus Loved, and the Most Named after Peter

In the four lists of the Twelve, John is always named right after James his brother, except in a few passages where he precedes him: second in Acts 1:13, third in Mark 3:17, fourth in Matthew 10:3 and Luke 6:14[3]. From the fact that James is placed first, it is concluded that John was the younger of the two sons of Zebedee[4]. Yet this younger brother holds a unique place: with Peter and James, he forms the trio who alone witnessed the raising of Jairus' daughter, the Transfiguration, and the agony in Gethsemane[5].

The fourth Evangelist never gives his own name: he identifies himself by the title that says everything about his relationship with the Master, the disciple whom Jesus loved[6]. This expression returns at the four decisive moments: the Last Supper, the Cross, the empty tomb, and the Sea of Tiberias[7][8][9][10]. Far from being an author's affectation, this anonymity is a signature: the witness withdraws so that the reader may take his place, he too leaning against the breast of the Lord.

Five Books out of Twenty-Seven: The Written Work of John

No other apostle, apart from Paul, wrote as much in the canon. The following table shows the exact extent of the Johannine legacy in the twenty-seven books received by the Church.

BookPlace in the canonReceived attributionTraditional dating
Gospel according to Saint John4th and last GospelJohn, son of ZebedeeEphesus, around 90 to 100
First Epistle of John23rd book, 1st of the Johannine lettersJohn the elder, the apostleEphesus, around 90 to 100
Second Epistle of John24th bookJohn the elderEphesus, end of the 1st century
Third Epistle of John25th bookJohn the elderEphesus, end of the 1st century
Revelation27th and last bookJohn, on PatmosPatmos, around 95, under Domitian
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The councils of Hippo in 393, then of Carthage in 397 and 419, fixed the list of the twenty-seven books with these five Johannine writings in their present place[11]. Since then, neither the East nor the West has ever removed a single one of these books from the canon: the reception is universal and uninterrupted.

The Son of Zebedee, Fisherman of the Sea of Galilee

A family of fishermen, a father who stays, a mother who follows

John is the son of Zebedee and Salome, and the brother of James the Greater[12]. The family fishes the Sea of Galilee with boats, nets, and hired hands: this is not poverty, but the comfortable trade of a master fisherman[13]. When Jesus calls the two brothers, they at once leave their father Zebedee in the boat with the hired hands and follow him: the father stays, the sons go[14].

Salome, their mother, is among the women who accompany Jesus and serve him with their substance; she stands at the foot of the cross and is among the first at the tomb[15]. It is she who one day asks for her two sons the first places in the Kingdom, drawing from the Lord his answer about the cup to be drunk[16]. The whole family has thus entered the adventure: the father who lets them go, the mother who follows to the end, the two sons surnamed by Jesus himself.

Boanerges: the sons of thunder

To the two brothers, Jesus gives a surname in Aramaic: Boanerges, that is, sons of thunder[17]. The nickname is not decorative: it speaks of temperament. When a Samaritan village refuses to welcome Jesus, James and John propose calling down fire from heaven; Jesus rebukes them[18]. When they ambition the first places, the other ten are indignant and Jesus must remind them that the first shall be the servant[19].

This ardent character, the Lord does not break it: he converts it. The son of thunder will become the apostle of charity, the one who will repeat at the end of his life: little children, love one another[20]. The fire of Galilee, passed through the fire of Pentecost and of age, will yield the gentleness of Ephesus.

First a disciple of the Baptist, then called at the lake

According to the most probable explanation, John and his brother were first for a time disciples of John the Baptist, and it was from the circle of the Precursor that Christ called them, along with Peter and Andrew, to become his disciples[21]. The fourth gospel recounts this first encounter in detail: two disciples of the Baptist follow Jesus after the testimony of the Lamb of God; one is Andrew, the other remains anonymous, and all of tradition sees in him John himself[22].

After a first time spent with Jesus in Judea and Galilee, John and his companions had returned to their fishing: it is there, by the lake, that Christ calls them to definitive discipleship, and they leave everything to follow him[23][24]. This two-stage beginning illuminates all that follows: John has known Jesus since the Jordan, he chose him before being chosen, and his attachment does not date from a thunderbolt but from a proven fidelity.

John in the Gospels: the disciple whom Jesus loved

From the three privileged to the front rank of witnesses

Peter, James, and John are the only witnesses of three scenes that the other apostles will never see: the raising of Jairus's daughter, the Transfiguration on the mountain, the agony in Gethsemane[25]. At the Transfiguration, John hears with the other two the voice of the Father designate the beloved Son[26]. In Gethsemane, he is one of the three whom Jesus takes aside to keep watch for an hour, and who fall asleep[27].

With Peter, he is also sent alone into the city to prepare the Passover and the Last Supper[28]. This pair, Peter and John, runs through the whole New Testament: they run together to the tomb, they fish together at the lake, they appear together before the Sanhedrin, they visit Samaria together. Two opposite temperaments, one mission: the ardor of Peter and the depth of John together bear the newborn Church. On the figure of the first, see Saint Peter the Apostle.

Leaning on the breast of Jesus

At the Supper, John's place is beside Christ, and he leans on his breast to ask him in a low voice who will betray him[29][30]. The Fathers have meditated endlessly on this gesture: leaning on the heart of the incarnate Word, John drew from it the theology that will spring forth in his Prologue. It is from this breast, tradition will say, that the living waters of his gospel flowed.

After the arrest, when all flee, John follows with Peter as far as the courtyard of the high priest: according to the common interpretation, he is that other disciple known to the high priest who brings Peter in[31]. The son of thunder is not a contemplative far from danger: he is there, in the night of the trial, when the others have scattered.

Alone at the foot of the cross: Woman, behold your son

At Calvary, John alone remains near his Master, with the Mother of Jesus and the holy women, and he receives as Christ's last legacy the grieving Mother[32]. The text has a moving sobriety:

"Now there stood by the cross of Jesus his mother, and his mother's sister, Mary, the wife of Cleophas, and Mary Magdalene. Jesus therefore, seeing his mother, and the disciple standing by whom he loved, said to his mother: Woman, behold your son."[33]

  • Gospel according to Saint John, ch. 19, trans. AELF[34]

Then to the disciple: behold your mother, and from that hour the disciple took her to his home[35]. By entrusting Mary to John, Jesus entrusts John to Mary: the beloved disciple becomes the son of the Mother, and with him the whole Church. This is the scriptural foundation of Mary's universal motherhood, developed in The Virgin Mary in the New Testament.

Where did John take Mary to his home? An ancient tradition has her come with him to Ephesus: the house known as Meryemana, on Mount Bülbül near the city, rediscovered in 1891 according to the visions of the mystic Catherine Emmerich, is kept as a pilgrimage site, with the visits of Paul VI in 1967, John Paul II in 1979, and Benedict XVI in 2006[36]. The Church does not define the place of the Dormition of the Mother, and Jerusalem keeps its own tradition of the tomb: but that she lived under the disciple's roof, at Ephesus or elsewhere, belongs to the very word of Christ on the cross.

The first to believe before the empty tomb

On Easter morning, it is Mary Magdalene who alerts Peter and John; the two run to the tomb, John arrives first but lets Peter enter, then he enters in turn: he saw, and he believed[37][38]. First to arrive, first to believe: tradition sees in this the pure gaze of the virgin disciple, who understands before touching.

At the Sea of Tiberias, after a night of fruitless fishing, it is again John who first recognizes the Risen One on the shore and tells Peter: it is the Lord[39]. Then comes the dialogue that seals his destiny: Peter, just restored as pastor, asks what will become of John, and Jesus answers: if I will that he remain until I come, what is it to you, follow me[40]. From this word arose in the early community the rumor that this disciple would not die; the evangelist himself clarifies that Jesus had not said he would not die, but: if I will that he remain[41]. John's exceptional longevity, dying around the year 100 after seeing three generations pass, gave this rumor an appearance of reason.

The gospel closes on the signature of the witness:

"This is the disciple who testifies to these things and has written them, and we know that his testimony is true."[42]

  • Gospel according to Saint John, ch. 21, trans. AELF[43]
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

An eyewitness who writes, a community that guarantees: the entire Johannine dossier holds in these two sentences.

John in the Early Church

With Peter, at the Temple, in prison, in Samaria

After the Ascension and Pentecost, John takes a leading role with Peter in the founding of the Church[44]. We see him at Peter's side at the healing of the lame man at the Beautiful Gate of the Temple, then thrown into prison with him for proclaiming the resurrection[45][46]. Before the Sanhedrin, which forbids them to speak, the two answer with one voice that one cannot be silent about what one has seen and heard[47].

When Samaria receives the word, it is once again the pair that comes down from Jerusalem to lay hands on the new converts and pray that they may receive the Spirit[48]. John, who once wished to call down fire upon a Samaritan village, now lays hands so that the fire of the Spirit may descend: the conversion of the son of thunder can be read in his gestures as an apostle.

Pillar of the Church at the Council of Jerusalem

Around 51, John is back in Jerusalem for the assembly that settles the question of converted Gentiles. Saint Paul, defending his gospel freed from the Law against his adversaries from Galatia, explicitly names John along with Peter and James as a pillar of the Church, and attests that these three most eminent men of the old mother Church have acknowledged his preaching[49][50]. This is John's last certain appearance in Palestine: when Paul returns to Jerusalem after his second and third journeys, he seems no longer to meet him there, and some place his departure for Asia between 52 and 55[51].

Nothing is known for certain about the exact duration of his activity in Palestine, but he seems, like the other apostles, to have remained some twelve years in this first field, until the persecution of Herod Agrippa I scattered the apostles throughout the provinces of the Empire[52]. A first visit to Asia Minor at this time is not improbable: a Christian community already existed in Ephesus before Paul's first labours there, and the Spirit had forbidden the Apostle to proclaim the Gospel in Asia, in Mysia and in Bithynia during his second journey[53][54]. But such a stay, if it took place, was neither long nor uninterrupted.

Five Books Received as Scripture

One Author, Three Genres, One Voice

The New Testament says nothing more about the person of John after the council: it is through his writings that he is now known. Yet all these writings presuppose an author who counts himself among the eyewitnesses of Christ's life, who lived for a long time in Asia Minor, who knows its communities intimately, and who exercises an authority recognised by all the Churches of the region[55]. The first epistle states as much in its opening lines:

"What was from the beginning, what we have heard, what we have seen with our eyes, what we looked upon and touched with our hands concerning the Word of life — we proclaim it to you."[56]

  • First Epistle of Saint John, ch. 1, trans. AELF[57]

Heard, seen, looked upon, touched: four verbs of the senses to say that the Johannine faith is not an idea but an encounter. And Revelation specifies the place of the exile: the island of Patmos, on account of the word of God and the testimony of Jesus[58].

The Received Attribution: John, the Disciple, the Elder

The tradition has never wavered: the gospel, the three epistles and Revelation are all by the same John, the son of Zebedee, the apostle. The three epistles present themselves as the work of the elder (in Greek ho presbyteros), a title of authority suited to the aged apostle who became the father of the Churches of Asia[59]. Revelation simply names itself John, known to all the communities to which it is addressed, without needing to introduce himself further[60].

The only cloud on the horizon, and an old one at that: Papias, bishop of Hierapolis, speaks in one passage of a presbyter John alongside Aristion, after having named the apostles. Eusebius of Caesarea was the first to draw from this the distinction between two Johns in Asia, and Jerome spread it in the West on his authority[61]. But this distinction has no historical foundation: Eusebius contradicts himself, since in his Chronicle he expressly calls the apostle John the teacher of Papias, as does Jerome himself in his letter to Theodora; above all, Irenaeus positively identifies the apostle and evangelist John as the teacher of Papias, and no writer before Eusebius had ever conceived of a second John in Asia[62]. In Papias, the word presbyteroi designates the apostles themselves, and if John appears twice, it is because he was Papias's eminent teacher: known indirectly through others for certain accounts, and directly, while still living, for his teaching[63]. Influenced by his own doctrinal positions against the apostolic origin of Revelation, Eusebius built upon a single word a hypothesis that closer witnesses refute.

The Received Dating: Ephesus and Patmos, End of the First Century

The traditional chronology rests on three landmarks: Revelation written on Patmos around 95, under the emperor Domitian, who reigned from 81 to 96; the gospel and the epistles composed in Ephesus after the return from exile, around 90 to 100, John being the last of the evangelists to write[64]. Irenaeus affirms it: John published his gospel at Ephesus and lived there until the reign of Trajan[65]. With Eusebius, one is compelled to place the banishment to Patmos under Domitian[66].

The Church has solemnly confirmed this attribution. On 29 May 1907, the Pontifical Biblical Commission replied that it is historically certain that Saint John wrote the fourth gospel, and that this gospel is a historical document recounting the real facts and discourses of the life of the Lord[67]. The contrary views, which deny the Johannine authenticity and the historicity of the narrative, would be condemned a few weeks later in the decree Lamentabili of 3 July 1907[68]. Granted, a 1955 note from the Commission's secretariat would subsequently grant exegetes broad freedom with regard to the decrees of the early century, except where they touch on faith and morals: but this freedom is a permission, never a refutation, and a Catholic remains perfectly free to hold the traditional position[69].

The Gospel according to Saint John: the last one, at Ephesus

Why a fourth Gospel

Clement of Alexandria, quoted by Eusebius, reports the saying that explains everything: John, seeing that the external facts had been set forth in the Gospels, urged by his friends and inspired by the Spirit, composed a spiritual Gospel[70]. Last to come after the three Synoptics, he does not repeat: he contemplates. Where the first three tell mostly of Galilee, John unfolds Judea and Jerusalem; where they recount parables and miracles in crowds, he retains seven signs and seven I am sayings, and digs into each one down to the mystery.

« John, the last of all, seeing that the external facts had been set forth in the Gospel, urged by his friends and inspired by the Spirit, composed a spiritual Gospel. »[71]

  • Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposeis, quoted by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14[72]
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The Muratorian Fragment, the earliest Latin catalogue of the canon from around 170 to 200, tells the story of its origins: the fourth Gospel was composed at the request of the brothers and the bishops, John fasting with them before dictating the revelation he had received[73]. The Gospel is thus born of a Church that asks and an apostle who contemplates: a twofold guarantee, both communal and apostolic.

The plan: Prologue, Signs, Glory, epilogue

The book comprises twenty-one chapters in two great movements, opened by the Prologue and closed by the Galilean epilogue: the details of this architecture, sign by sign, can be read in The Gospel according to Saint John. Here we keep only the skeleton, to measure what the Church receives from John.

PartChaptersContent
Prologue1, 1-18The Word was God, and the Word became flesh
Book of Signs2 to 12Seven miracles revealing glory, from Cana to Lazarus
Book of Glory13 to 20The Last Supper, the Passion, the Resurrection: when the Hour has come
Epilogue21The catch of fish at the lake, Peter restored, the testimony sealed

The Prologue, which opens the book, is the highest text in the whole New Testament on the divinity of Christ:

« In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. And the Word became flesh, he dwelt among us, and we have seen his glory, the glory he has from the Father as only Son, full of grace and truth. »[74]

  • Gospel according to Saint John, Prologue, trans. AELF[75]

Three Passovers run through the narrative, the first at the beginning of the ministry (Jn 2, 13), the second at the time of the bread of life (Jn 6, 4), the last at the Hour of the Passion (Jn 11, 55)[76], which gives the public ministry a duration of about three years, against the single year that the Synoptics read alone would seem to suggest[77]. And chapter 21, sometimes presented as a late addition, is an authentic epilogue: same language, same hand, same theology, sealed by the signature of the witness[78].

The three epistles: the elder, truth and charity

The first epistle: abiding in the light

The first epistle, the longest, is a sermon with no address or greeting, written by a father to his little children that they may not sin and may know that they have eternal life[79]. Its plan rests on three concentric circles: God is light, God is just, God is love. Walking in the light, practicing justice, loving the brothers: three tests that distinguish the children of God from the children of the devil[80].

It is here that one reads the two most famous definitions of God in the whole New Testament after the Prologue: God is light, and God is love[81][82]. And it is here that the elder warns against the antichrists already at work: those who deny that Jesus is the Christ come in the flesh, who went out from among the faithful but were not of us[83]. Against the early gnosticisms that empty the Incarnation, John sets up the criterion of touch: what our hands have touched of the Word of life, that is the faith[84].

The two notes: the elect lady, Gaius and Diotrephes

The second and third epistles are two short notes from the elder, one page each, showing the concrete governance of the patriarch of Asia. The second, addressed to the elect lady and her children, that is, to a local Church, repeats the double commandment: to walk in the truth and to love one another, without welcoming into one's home those who do not bring the doctrine of Christ[85].

The third, addressed to Gaius the beloved, praises hospitality toward the missionaries and denounces Diotrephes, who loves to be first, refuses to welcome the elder, and expels from the Church those who receive the brothers[86]. One also encounters Demetrius, to whom all give a good testimony[87]. These proper names, these conflicts of precedence, this discipline of welcome: nothing less resembles a late fiction than the real correspondence of an aged bishop watching over his Churches.

The Apocalypse: Patmos, under Domitian

The Seer of Patmos

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Banished to the island of Patmos because of the word of God and the testimony of Jesus, John receives there, on a Sunday, the Revelation which he addresses to the seven Churches of Asia: Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamum, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia, Laodicea[88][89]. The book presents itself as prophecy, reads like a liturgy, and ends as a prayer: Come, Lord Jesus[90].

Its structure, its seals, its trumpets, its bowls, the Woman and the Dragon, the Lamb and the New Jerusalem: the whole unfolding of this prophecy is set out in The Apocalypse of Saint John. Only its Johannine root is retained here: the same Word, the same Lamb, the same Spirit, the same struggle between light and darkness as in the Gospel and the Epistles, but seen from the side of heaven.

The Dating: The End of Domitian's Reign

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Irenaeus, who has the information from the previous generation, writes that the apocalyptic vision was seen towards the end of the reign of Domitian, which ends in 96[91]. Eusebius accordingly places the banishment to Patmos under this emperor[92]. After the death of Domitian, the apostle returned to Ephesus under the reign of Trajan[93]. This chronology makes the Apocalypse the first writing of the exile, and the Gospel the testament of the return: the order of the books in the canon follows this logic, moreover, the Apocalypse closing the New Testament as the seal of all Revelation.

The Ancient Witnesses of John

A Short Chain: John, Polycarp, Irenaeus

The strength of the Johannine case lies in the brevity of its chain of transmission. Between the apostle who died around 100 and Irenaeus who writes around 180, there is only a single link: Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, who had known John and the others who had seen the Lord[94]. Irenaeus recounts that as a child he would listen to Polycarp tell of his dealings with John, and that he could still say where the old man would sit to speak[95]. From John to us in two leaps: no other apostolic figure is so close to its witnesses.

The following table gathers the witnesses who guarantee the Johannine origin of the five books, from the apostle's own lifetime to the fixing of the canon.

WitnessDateWhat he attests
Justin, Dialogue 81around 150 to 160John, one of the apostles of Christ, lived among us at Ephesus
Tatian, Diatessaronaround 170The four Gospels merged into a single narrative, opened with the Prologue of John
Theophilus of Antioch, To Autolycus II, 22around 180Quotes the Prologue naming its author: one of the inspired men, John
Irenaeus, Against Heresies III, 1, 1around 180John published his Gospel at Ephesus
Polycrates of Ephesus, letter to Pope Victoraround 190John, who rested on the Lord's breast, fell asleep at Ephesus
Irenaeus, Against Heresies II, 22, 5 and V, 30, 3around 180John lived until Trajan; vision seen under Domitian
Muratorian Fragmentaround 170 to 200The 4th Gospel, composed at the request of the brethren
Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposesaround 200John, the last, composed a spiritual Gospel
Tertullian, On the Prescription 36around 200The boiling oil of the Latin Gate, unharmed
Origen and Eusebius3rd and 4th c.Reception of the Johannine writings without dispute
Jerome, On Illustrious Men 9around 393John the last, against the heretics

Justin and Irenaeus: Ephesus and Trajan

Saint Justin, martyr around 165, writes in his Dialogue with Trypho that John, one of the apostles of Christ, lived among us, that is to say at Ephesus[96]. This is the earliest external witness: barely fifty years after the apostle's death, a converted philosopher attests his Asian residence as a fact known to all.

Saint Irenaeus speaks of the apostle John in very many places, states expressly that he wrote his Gospel at Ephesus, and that he lived there until the reign of Trajan[97]. Through Polycarp, he reaches the apostolic generation: he is not a second-hand Christian reconstructing a distant message, he has touched the living chain of Tradition. On the master of his master, see Saint Polycarp of Smyrna.

Tatian, Theophilus, Polycrates: Three Voices from Asia and Syria

Between Justin and Irenaeus, the case knows no gap. Tatian, Justin's disciple who became a schismatic, merges around 170 the four Gospels into a single continuous narrative, the Diatessaron: he opens it with the Prologue of John, proof that the fourth Gospel already circulates as Scripture even among those who break with the Church[98]. Theophilus of Antioch, around 180, is the first to quote the Prologue naming its author: among the inspired men, he says, one, John, affirms that in the beginning was the Word[99]. And Polycrates of Ephesus, writing around 190 to Pope Victor about the date of Easter, claims the great luminaries of Asia asleep in his province:

"John, who rested on the Lord's breast, fell asleep at Ephesus."[100]

  • Polycrates of Ephesus, letter to Pope Victor, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, III, 31[101]
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

A bishop of Ephesus, a century after the apostle's death, shows his tomb as one shows a title deed: John's Asian residence is not a scholarly hypothesis, it is the memory of a city.

The Life of John in a Few Dates

  1. around 27-28
    The Call by the Lakeshore

    First a disciple of the Baptist, then definitively called with his brother: they leave their father in the boat[102].

  2. around 30
    The Cross and the Entrusted Mother

    The only one of the Twelve at Calvary, he receives Mary as his mother and takes her into his home[103].

  3. around 51
    Pillar at Jerusalem

    Named a pillar of the Church with Peter and James, he acknowledges Paul's mission to the Gentiles[104].

  4. around 95
    Patmos under Domitian

    Exiled to the island because of the word of God, he receives there the Apocalypse addressed to the seven Churches[105].

  5. around 96-100
    Ephesus, the Gospel and the Epistles

    Returned after the death of Domitian, he composes the spiritual Gospel and governs the Churches of Asia until the reign of Trajan[106].

Ephesus and the End of the First Century

The Boiling Oil at the Latin Gate

Before his exile, according to the testimony of Tertullian, John had been plunged in Rome into a cauldron of boiling oil before the Latin Gate, without suffering any harm[107]. The Church has kept the memory of this marvel in a proper feast, on May 6, which commemorates the dedication of the church built near the Latin Gate and already appears in the sacramentary of Pope Adrian I, between 772 and 795[108]. The Son of Thunder therefore drank the cup promised to him: not through bloody martyrdom like his brother James, beheaded as early as 44[109], but through the white martyrdom of exile and of torments endured without dying.

The Patriarch of Asia: Cerinthus, the Brigand, the Little Children

Back in Ephesus, John governed the Churches of Asia as a father. Tradition recounts from his last years features of striking beauty: he refused to stay under the same roof as the heretic Cerinthus[110]. Clement of Alexandria tells of his anguish for a young man who had become a bandit chief, whom he won back by his tears and his prayers[111]. And Jerome reports the words of exhortation that he repeated ceaselessly at the end of his life:

"Little children, love one another."[112]

When he was asked why he kept repeating the same phrase, he answered that it was the Lord's commandment, and that this was enough when one fulfilled it[114]. The whole theology of John is contained in this answer: love is not the summary of his doctrine, it is the whole of it.

Death around 100 and the Tomb at Ephesus

Ruins of the Basilica of Saint John in Selçuk. Photo Dosseman, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

John died at Ephesus around the year 100, at a great age, under the reign of Trajan begun in 98[115]. The Churches of the East mark his dormition on September 26, while Rome celebrates him on December 27, within the octave of Christmas[116]. His tomb, venerated from the earliest centuries on the hill of Ayasuluk, was crowned in the sixth century by the great Basilica of Saint John built by the Emperor Justinian, on the model of the Church of the Holy Apostles in Constantinople[117]. The ruins can still be visited at Selçuk, three kilometres from Ephesus: the stone keeps the memory of the only apostle to die in his bed, after having survived all the others.

The Theology of John: Glory, Abiding, and Charity

In the Beginning Was the Word

All Johannine theology springs from the Prologue: the eternal Word, God Himself, became flesh and dwelt among us[118]. From this flow the most direct assertions of Christ's divinity in the whole New Testament: I and the Father are one[119], before Abraham was, I Am[120], my Lord and my God[121]. No evangelist shows the glory of the only-begotten Son so clearly, and none shows his humanity so fleshly: the Word thirsts, weeps before the tomb of Lazarus, pours out the blood and water from his open side[122].

The vocabulary of faith, in John, comes down to three verbs: to believe, to abide, to know. To believe is to adhere to the Son in order to have life; to abide is to remain grafted onto the vine as the branch; to know is to enter into the intimacy of the Father and the Son[123]. The Hour, the glory, and the lifting up speak of the same mystery: it is on the cross, lifted up from the earth, that the Son draws all to himself and reveals fully who he is[124].

The Promised Paraclete and the Water from the Side

In the farewell discourse, Jesus promises another Advocate, the Spirit of truth, who will remain with the disciples and lead them into the whole truth[125]. This is the scriptural foundation of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit as a divine person, distinct from the Son and sent by him: no text grounds Catholic pneumatology so clearly.

From the open side of the Crucified flow the blood and the water, which tradition reads as the sacraments gushing from Christ asleep on the cross, as Eve was drawn from the side of the sleeping Adam[126]. Baptism and the Eucharist irrigate the whole gospel: the water of Cana turned to wine, the living water promised to the Samaritan woman, the bread of life multiplied and then promised at Capernaum, the water and the Spirit of the conversation with Nicodemus[127]. To read John is to learn to see the sacraments wherever water flows and bread is broken.

God Is Love: The Fulfilment of the Epistles

The epistles bring the theology to its fruit: God is love, and whoever abides in love abides in God[128]. Love there is never a feeling: it is the keeping of the commandments, the welcoming of brothers, the rejection of the world and its lusts, the confession of the Son come in the flesh[129]. The criterion is fearsomely simple: he who does not love the brother he sees cannot love God whom he does not see[130].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

And Mary, entrusted to John at the foot of the cross, passes through the whole corpus as the Woman: at Cana, where she obtains the first sign through her prayer, and at Calvary, where she becomes Mother[131]. The Apocalypse finally contemplates her in heaven, the Woman clothed with the sun, crowned with twelve stars, giving birth to the son who will rule the nations[132]. From the first sign to the last heaven, John is the theologian of the Mother, as he is the theologian of the Word.

The liturgical use of the Johannine heritage

December 27, at the heart of the Christmas octave

Saint John is celebrated on December 27, on the third day of the Christmas octave, between Stephen the first martyr and the Holy Innocents[133]. The placement is no accident: after the blood of martyrdom and before the blood of the innocents, the Church celebrates the disciple who saw the glory of the Word made flesh and touched him with his hands. In Rome, the feast very early became reserved to John alone, whereas he had originally shared the date with James[134].

On May 6, the feast of Saint John at the Latin Gate keeps the memory of the Roman torture and of the dedication of the church built on its site[135]. In the East, the dormition is celebrated on September 26[136]. Three dates for a single apostle: the evangelist of Christmas, the confessor of Rome, the sleeper of Ephesus.

The Prologue, the last Gospel of the Mass

For centuries, every Mass ended with the words of John: after the blessing and the dismissal, the priest went to the Epistle corner and read the Last Gospel, the first fourteen verses of the Prologue[137]. The faithful knelt at these words: and the Word was made flesh. Thus the most contemplative text of the New Testament became the Church's most everyday prayer: millions of Masses closed upon the glory of the only-begotten Son.

Easter lives on John: on Easter evening and the second Sunday, the unbelief and then the confession of Thomas; the third Sunday, the catch of fish and the primacy restored to Peter; Holy Thursday, the washing of the feet; Good Friday, the whole Passion according to John[138]. And the eagle, which soars at the frontispiece of his book, became his attribute throughout Christian art, along with the chalice that speaks of the Supper, the cup drained to the dregs, and the poison overcome[139].

Common objections and answers

Is the Greek too fine for a Galilean fisherman?

The objection concerns the style: how could a fisherman of the lake have written the artful yet profound Greek of the fourth Gospel? The answer has three parts. First, John lived more than forty years in a Greek-speaking environment, in Ephesus, the capital of Asia: an intelligent man, even one starting from Aramaic, handles a second language with ease after half a century. Next, the Greek of John is in fact simple: restricted vocabulary, short sentences, transparent Semitic turns of phrase, far removed from the rhetoric of Luke or the Hebrews. Finally, the ancients accepted the help of a secretary: just as Peter dictated through Silvan, John may have dictated, reread, and corrected with his disciples at Ephesus, without the work ceasing to be his.

Why does the author hide behind anonymity?

The fourth Gospel never names John, any more than the epistles sign themselves with the name of an apostle. Far from being suspicious, this effacement is the mark of the true witness: one who writes what he has seen has no need to state his identity on every page, and the Church of Ephesus knew perfectly well who was speaking. Revelation, addressed to troubled communities who must verify the authority of the sender, names itself by contrast: I, John, your brother[140]. Anonymity and signature are distributed exactly as prudence and authority require.

Are chapter 21 and the woman caught in adultery additions, making the book composite?

Chapter 21 belongs to the Gospel from the earliest manuscripts onwards: the same vocabulary, the same theology, the same signature of the witness, and the Fathers have always read it as authentic[141]. As for the passage of the woman caught in adultery, absent from certain ancient witnesses and displaced in others, the Church has always held it to be inspired Scripture and proclaims it in her liturgy: the history of its manuscript transmission, however complex, changes nothing of its received canonical authority[142]. A book may have a turbulent textual history and remain entirely the work of its author: copying accidents are not proofs of fraud.

Does Revelation read so differently that it cannot be by the same author?

The Greek of Revelation is rough, strewn with solecisms, whereas that of the Gospel is limpid. But the genres are entirely different: a prophecy dictated in the urgency of exile, saturated with Hebrew and Danielic imagery, does not use the same language as a meditation composed in the peace of Ephesus. Above all, the theology is the same: the Lamb, the Word, the living water, the victory over the serpent, the dwelling of God with men. Dionysius of Alexandria, in the middle of the third century, already noted the difference of style without denying the sanctity of the book, which he held to be inspired even while doubting that it was by the apostle[143]: the question has therefore been posed since antiquity, and the tradition, weighing doctrinal unity more than stylistic uniformity, has always kept both under the name of John.

What if the beloved disciple were Lazarus, or someone else?

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

This has sometimes been proposed: Jesus loved Lazarus, says the Gospel, and Lazarus is the only other man whose love by the Lord is thus highlighted[144]. But the beloved disciple sits among the Twelve at the Supper, follows Jesus even into the high priest's courtyard, receives Mary at Calvary, and designates himself as the witness-author of the whole book[145]: none of these traits fits Lazarus of Bethany, whom the Gospel never places in the apostolic circle. Above all, the witnesses of the first two centuries know only one candidate: neither Papias, nor Justin, nor Irenaeus, nor Polycrates ever heard the name of another. A hypothesis without an ancient witness against five unanimous cities: the evidence leaves no room for hesitation.

What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

The most widespread hypothesis today

Part of contemporary exegesis proposes to dissociate the five books: the gospel would be the work of a Johannine community of Ephesus, written around 90 to 110, or even 110 to 170 for the latest ones; the epistles would come from an elder distinct from the apostle, the presbyter John of Papias as re-read by Eusebius; the Apocalypse from a prophet of the same name exiled under Domitian or even under Nero. The fourth gospel, in this reading, would no longer be the testimony of a witness but the theological meditation of a school, historically fragile, to be read as a reinterpretation rather than as a report.

This reconstruction rests on real observations: the difference in Greek between the Apocalypse and the gospel, the apparent silence of certain Fathers on certain details, the highly developed theology of the Prologue, supposedly impossible at an early date. It is set out here fairly, for it holds a large place in universities: a reader of Ignispedia must know what is taught, and why.

The fragilities of the reconstruction

It rests first on a philosophical presupposition rather than on a discovery: so high a theology cannot be primitive, precise prophecy is impossible, therefore the text is late and its claims are projections. This is not a conclusion of research, it is its premise: texts are dated by a theory of doctrinal evolution, and the theory is then proved by the dates thus obtained. The circular dating here is structural, not accidental[146].

It then confuses literary possibility with historical proof: that a school could have retouched a text does not prove that it did so, and that a style varies according to genre does not prove two authors. The argument from silence, finally, plays an excessive role: because such a Father does not cite such a verse, one concludes that the verse did not exist, as if the Fathers cited everything they received.

Why the traditional position remains defensible

The material facts plead for an early date. Papyrus P52, a fragment of chapter 18 copied in Egypt around 125, makes it impossible that the gospel should not have circulated as far as Egypt from the first quarter of the second century: a composition around 170, still upheld by some, becomes materially untenable[147]. Papyri P66 and P75, from the second and third centuries, confirm an early and careful transmission[148]. Even the scholar John Robinson, hardly suspect of conservatism, placed in the 1970s the whole of the New Testament, John included, before 70[149].

The internal arguments converge. The gospel knows Jerusalem before 70 with a resident's topographical precision: the pool of Bethesda described in the present tense, with its five porticoes, presupposes an author who saw the place standing[150]. The three Passovers structure a three-year ministry incompatible with a late legend, which would have simplified. And the chain of transmission is the shortest in all of Christian antiquity: a single link between John and Irenaeus, against centuries of shadow for most ancient works.

There remains the decisive point, which is not technical but moral: the Johannine tradition is not one hypothesis among others, it is the concordant testimony of those who knew the witnesses. Justin in Ephesus, Polycarp in Smyrna, Irenaeus in Lyon, Clement in Alexandria, the Muratorian canon in Rome: five cities, five voices, a single John. To prefer to this concert a modern reconstruction, one must suppose that all of them were mistaken together about the identity of their own father in the faith, and that scholars two thousand years away see more clearly than they. This is possible in principle; in the present case, the proofs are wanting, and the tradition keeps the presumption for itself[151].

For further reading

The fourth gospel, sign by sign and discourse after discourse: The Gospel according to Saint John. The Revelation of Patmos, seals, trumpets and the new Jerusalem: The Apocalypse of Saint John. The Mother entrusted to the disciple: The Blessed Virgin Mary in the New Testament. The Baptist of whom John was first the disciple: Saint John the Baptist in the New Testament. The inseparable duo of the beloved disciple: Saint Peter the Apostle. The first announcement to the Gentiles with Paul: Saint Paul the Apostle. The master of the master of Lyon: Saint Polycarp of Smyrna. The hearth of the whole corpus: The New Testament.

Notes and References

  1. Léopold Fonck, St. John the Evangelist, The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 8, Robert Appleton Company, New York, 1910 (trad. fr. de l'auteur de l'article ; texte anglais sur newadvent.org/cathen/08492a.htm).

    1 3 4 5 12 21 23 25 28 31 32 37 44 49 51 52 53 55 59 61 62 63 64 65 66 92 93 94 96 97 106 107 108 110 111 115 116 133 134 135 136 139
  2. Commission Biblique Pontificale, decree on the author and historical truth of the fourth gospel, 29 May 1907: historically certain that Saint John wrote it; the gospel is a historical document of the real deeds and words of the Lord. Contrary views condemned by the decree Lamentabili, 3 July 1907.

    2 67 68 151
  3. Jn 13:23, trad. AELF.

    6 7 29
  4. Jn 19:25-26, trad. AELF (text noted in La Bible catholique intégrale, trad. AELF).

    8 33 34
  5. Jn 20:8, trad. AELF.

    9 38
  6. Jn 21:7, trad. AELF.

    10 39
  7. Councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397, 419): fixing of the list of the twenty-seven books, including the five Johannine writings.

    11
  8. Mk 1:16-20, trad. AELF.

    13 14 24 102
  9. Mt 27:55-56, trad. AELF.

    15
  10. Mt 20:20-23, trad. AELF.

    16
  11. Mk 3:17, trad. AELF.

    17
  12. Lk 9:54-56, trad. AELF.

    18
  13. Mk 10:41-45, trad. AELF.

    19
  14. Saint Jerome, Commentary on the Epistle to the Galatians, VI, 10: little children, love one another (reported by the Catholic Encyclopedia, art. St. John the Evangelist).

    20 112 113 114
  15. Jn 1:35-42, trad. AELF.

    22
  16. Mt 17:1-8, trad. AELF.

    26
  17. Mt 26:37-46, trad. AELF.

    27
  18. Jn 21:20, trad. AELF.

    30
  19. Jn 19:27, trad. AELF.

    35 103
  20. House of the Virgin Mary at Ephesus (Meryemana), Mount Bülbül near Selçuk: rediscovered in 1891 based on the visions of Catherine Emmerich, a pilgrimage site visited by Paul VI on 26 July 1967, John Paul II on 30 November 1979, and Benedict XVI on 29 November 2006 (blessing of Leo XIII in 1896, indulgences of John XXIII in 1961).

    36
  21. Jn 21:22, trad. AELF.

    40
  22. Jn 21:23, trad. AELF (paraphrasé dans le corps).

    41
  23. Jn 21:24, trad. AELF.

    42 43 145
  24. Acts 3:1-10, trad. AELF.

    45
  25. Acts 4:3, trad. AELF.

    46
  26. Acts 4:19-20, trad. AELF.

    47
  27. Acts 8:14-17, trad. AELF.

    48
  28. Gal 2:9, trad. AELF.

    50 104
  29. Acts 16:6-7, trad. AELF.

    54
  30. 1 Jn 1:1-2, trad. AELF (text noted in La Bible catholique intégrale, trad. AELF).

    56 57 84
  31. Rev 1:9, trad. AELF.

    58 88 105 140
  32. Rev 1:1-4, trad. AELF.

    60
  33. Position held in this article according to the Ignispedia doctrinal compass and the charter of the line: tradition first as the framework, modern exegesis afterwards as the object of examination, with its presuppositions named. On the 1955 note: semi-official explanation by the secretary of the Commission, A. Miller, in the Benediktinische Monatsschrift (review of the reprint of the Enchiridion), recalling the disciplinary character of the decrees of the early century (documented by Joseph Fitzmyer, appendix to the 1993 instruction on the historical truth of the Gospels).

    69 146
  34. Clément d'Alexandrie, Hypotyposes, quoted by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14, 5-7: John, the last, seeing that the outward facts had been brought to light, urged by his friends and inspired by the Spirit, composed a spiritual gospel (trad. fr. de l'auteur ; texte anglais sur newadvent.org/fathers/250106.htm).

    70 71 72
  35. Fragment de Muratori, lines on the fourth gospel, Latin canon around 170-200: composed at the request of the brothers and the bishops.

    73
  36. Jn 1:1 and 1:14, trad. AELF (text noted in La Bible catholique intégrale, trad. AELF).

    74 75 118
  37. Jn 2:13; 6:4; 11:55, trad. AELF.

    76
  38. Detailed presentation referred to The Gospel according to Saint John (Ignispedia article); three Passovers, authentic epilogue, woman caught in adultery received into the canon.

    77 78 141 142
  39. 1 Jn 2:1 and 5:13, trad. AELF.

    79
  40. 1 Jn 3:7-10, trad. AELF.

    80
  41. 1 Jn 1:5, trad. AELF.

    81
  42. 1 Jn 4:8, trad. AELF.

    82
  43. 1 Jn 2:18-19, trad. AELF.

    83
  44. 2 Jn 4-11, trad. AELF.

    85
  45. 3 Jn 9-10, trad. AELF.

    86
  46. 3 Jn 12, trad. AELF.

    87
  47. Rev 1:11, trad. AELF.

    89
  48. Rev 22:20, trad. AELF.

    90
  49. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, V, 30, 3: the apocalyptic vision seen towards the end of Domitian's reign.

    91
  50. Saint Irenaeus, Letter to Florinus, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, V, 20: childhood memories of Polycarp speaking of John.

    95
  51. Tatian the Syrian, Diatessaron, c. 170: harmony of the four Gospels opening with Jn 1:1 (attested by Dionysius bar-Salibi and Ephrem's commentary; Eng. trans. on newadvent.org/fathers/1001.htm).

    98
  52. Theophilus of Antioch, To Autolycus, II, 22, c. 180: quotes Jn 1:1-3 naming John among the inspired authors (Eng. trans. on newadvent.org/fathers/02052.htm).

    99
  53. Polycrates of Ephesus, letter to Pope Victor, c. 190, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 31, 3 and V, 24: John, who reclined on the Lord's breast, fell asleep at Ephesus (trans. by the author; English text on newadvent.org/fathers/250103.htm and /250105.htm).

    100 101
  54. Acts 12:2, trans. AELF.

    109
  55. Basilica of Saint John at Ephesus, Selçuk (Turkey): built by Justinian in the 6th century over the presumed tomb of the apostle, Ayasuluk hill.

    117
  56. Jn 10:30, trad. AELF.

    119
  57. Jn 8:58, trans. AELF.

    120
  58. Jn 20:28, trans. AELF.

    121
  59. Jn 19:34, trad. AELF.

    122 126
  60. Jn 15:1-10, trad. AELF.

    123
  61. Jn 12:32, trad. AELF.

    124
  62. Jn 16:13, trad. AELF.

    125
  63. Jn 3:3-7, trad. AELF.

    127
  64. 1 Jn 4:16, trad. AELF.

    128
  65. 1 Jn 2:3-6, trad. AELF.

    129
  66. 1 Jn 4:20, trad. AELF.

    130
  67. Jn 2:3-5, trad. AELF.

    131
  68. Rev 12:1-5, trad. AELF.

    132
  69. The Prologue (Jn 1:1-14) read as the Last Gospel at the end of each Mass in the Tridentine rite, with a genuflection at Et Verbum caro factum est.

    137
  70. Paschal readings from John (Thomas, the catch of fish, the washing of the feet on Holy Thursday, the Passion on Good Friday): Roman liturgical usage.

    138
  71. Dionysius of Alexandria, judgment on the Apocalypse reported by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, VII, 25: a holy and inspired book, but in his eyes by an author other than the apostle, because of the style (English text on newadvent.org/fathers/250107.htm).

    143
  72. Jn 11:3.5.36: Jesus loved Martha, her sister and Lazarus; the Jews said: see how he loved him, trad. AELF.

    144
  73. Papyrus P52 (Rylands Gr. P. 457, Jn 18:31-33.37-38): copied in Egypt c. 110-140 (c. 125), held at the John Rylands Library in Manchester.

    147
  74. Papyrus P66 and P75 (2nd-3rd centuries): early and careful witnesses to the Johannine text in Egypt.

    148
  75. John A. T. Robinson, Redating the New Testament, SCM Press, London, 1976: the whole New Testament, John included, before 70.

    149
  76. Jn 5:2, trad. AELF.

    150

Can’t find your topic?