Saint Joseph in the New Testament

Saint Joseph in the New Testament: dreams, flight into Egypt, Nazareth, traditional authors and dating, Davidic paternity, virginal marriage, Fathers, liturgy, objections and historical-critical debate.

Ignispedia

Saint Joseph is, in the New Testament, the husband of Mary and the legal father of Jesus: a descendant of David, a craftsman from Nazareth, who receives in a dream the command to take Mary into his home, who gives the child the name of Jesus, who saves him from Herod by the flight into Egypt, who brings him back to Nazareth, who presents him in the Temple with Mary, who searches for him for three days in Jerusalem, and who then disappears from the narrative before the public life, without a single one of his words being recorded. No other man in the Gospel holds such a role in such a silence: about a dozen direct passages, concentrated in the infancy narratives of Matthew and Luke, extended by two mentions in John, and framed by an eloquent absence everywhere else[1].

His scriptural dossier already contains, in seed, the whole of the Church's doctrine about him: the angel calls him son of David, a title from which the Church will draw the transmission of the Davidic rights to Jesus through his legal father; he is called just, from which the Fathers will draw the model of the righteous; he takes Mary without knowing her, from which the Church, with Augustine, will confess the true virginal marriage; he says nothing, from which tradition will contemplate silence and the interior life; he guards the child and his mother, from which Pius IX will draw the patron of the universal Church[2].

The article first presents Joseph as the Church receives Scripture: the inventory of passages, the sacred authors and their traditional dating, the ancient witnesses of the text, then the complete course of the scenes, from the betrothal to the four dreams, from Bethlehem to Nazareth, from the carpenter's workshop to the silent death before the public life, the theology that the New Testament already teaches, the reception among the Fathers, the popes and in the liturgy, the common objections with their answers, and finally the debate with modern historical-critical exegesis. Mary's dossier, the other side of the same scenes, falls under the article on the Virgin Mary in the New Testament; the feasts and the developed cult fall under Saint Joseph on March 19.

Joseph in the canon: the inventory of passages

About a dozen scenes, between Matthew, Luke and John

Joseph appears in three of the seven groupings of the New Testament: the Gospel according to Matthew, the Gospel according to Luke and the Gospel according to John. Mark, Paul, Acts, the Catholic letters and Revelation do not name him. The table below gives the complete inventory of direct passages, in the order of the canon[3].

BookPassageScene
MatthewMt 1:16-25Genealogy, Joseph the just, first dream, name of Jesus
MatthewMt 2:13-15Second dream, flight into Egypt
MatthewMt 2:19-23Third and fourth dreams, return, Nazareth
MatthewMt 13:55In Nazareth, "the carpenter's son"
LukeLk 1:27Mary "betrothed to a man named Joseph, of the house of David"
LukeLk 2:4-7Journey up to Bethlehem, the Nativity
LukeLk 2:21-24Circumcision, Presentation, offering of the poor
LukeLk 2:33"His father and his mother" in wonder
LukeLk 2:41-51Jesus lost and found, "your father and I", a life of obedience
LukeLk 3:23"Son, so it was thought, of Joseph, son of Heli"
JohnJn 1:45"Jesus, son of Joseph, of Nazareth"
JohnJn 6:42"Whose father and mother we know"

Two features leap to the eye before any reading. First, Joseph never speaks: the angel speaks, Mary speaks, the shepherds speak, Simeon speaks, but of Joseph the text records no word, only acts of immediate obedience. Next, Joseph disappears: present on every page of the infancy, he is absent from Cana, absent from the ministry, absent from the cross where Jesus entrusts his mother to the beloved disciple, absent from the upper room. Tradition reads into this his death between the twelfth year of Jesus and the beginning of the public life, assisted by Jesus and Mary, whence his title of patron of a happy death[4].

Two infancy narratives, Joseph's side and Mary's side

Matthew and Luke tell the same childhood through two different doors. Matthew tells it from Joseph's side: it is he who doubts, he who receives the angel in a dream, he who names the child, he who flees, he who returns. The dreams structure the whole narrative, like those of the patriarch Joseph, his namesake the son of Jacob, and at every stage Matthew quotes the oracle fulfilled, Isaiah, Hosea, Jeremiah[5]. Luke tells it from Mary's side: the Annunciation, the Visitation, the Magnificat, the shepherds, Simeon, then the Temple regained, where Joseph appears as the father who goes up, who offers, who searches, who marvels[6]. The two narratives agree on the essentials, betrothal to Mary, house of David, virginal conception, Bethlehem and then Nazareth, without copying one another: Matthew omits the manger and the shepherds, Luke omits the Magi and Egypt, and the two converge precisely where two independent inventions would diverge.

The silence of the rest of the New Testament, and what it means

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Mark does not name Joseph, but he knows "the carpenter, the son of Mary" of Nazareth, with his brothers James, Joses, Jude and Simon[7]. Paul does not name Joseph, but he attests before everyone the Davidic descent "according to the flesh", which passes legally through the legal father[8]. Acts does not name him, and for good reason: its narrative begins at the Ascension, long after his received death. Far from being a suspicious void, this silence draws the portrait: a man of the previous generation, dead before the preaching, whose role ends when the child reaches manhood, and whom the texts of the ministry meet only through the formula of the Nazarenes, "the son of Joseph".

The Received Authors and Dating of the Accounts of Joseph

Matthew, the Apostle, and the Joseph Side of the Story

Codex Sinaiticus, Matthew 1:1 to 2:5, fourth century. Public domain: Wikimedia Commons, file Codex Sinaiticus Matthew 1,1-2,5.JPG.

The most Josephine account in the New Testament is attributed by the earliest tradition to the apostle Matthew, the tax collector turned disciple, writing first for Jewish Christians. As early as the first half of the second century, Papias of Hierapolis attests that "Matthew compiled the words of the Lord in the Hebrew dialect"[9], a testimony preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea[10]. Clement of Alexandria confirms that the genealogical Gospels, Matthew and Luke, were written first[11]. Now Matthew is precisely the Gospel of the two fulfilled genealogies, that of Jesus through Joseph at the opening, and of dreams in the manner of the patriarchs: an account of the son of David for readers who know what son of David means. The Church therefore receives the four dreams as the testimony of an apostle, gathered before the destruction of Jerusalem, in the years 40 to 60 according to the traditional dating[12].

Luke, the Investigator, and the Father Who Goes Up to the Temple

Luke names Joseph from the Annunciation onward, "betrothed to a man named Joseph, of the house of David," and does not leave him again until the twelve-year-old Jesus[13]. The unanimous tradition, from Irenaeus of Lyon to the Muratorian Canon, sees in Luke the physician of Antioch, companion of Paul, who writes "after having investigated everything carefully from the origins" with the eyewitnesses[14][15][16]. Now Paul knows the house of Jerusalem and James "the brother of the Lord"[17]: through Paul and the Churches of Judea, Luke had access to the memories of the family itself, including those that Mary "kept and pondered in her heart." With the Acts of the Apostles ending on Paul's Roman captivity, around 62–63, without mentioning either his death or the destruction of Jerusalem, the Church dates the Gospel of Luke to the years 60 to 63[18].

"Since many have undertaken to compose a narrative of the events that have been fulfilled among us, just as they were handed down to us by those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and servants of the Word, I too have decided, after investigating everything carefully from the origins, to write you an orderly account, most excellent Theophilus." — Saint Luke, Lk 1:1–3[19]

John: Two Mentions That Presuppose Everything Else

The fourth Gospel does not tell the story of the childhood, but it names Joseph twice, and these two mentions presuppose the whole dossier to be known. Philip announces to Nathanael: "The one about whom Moses wrote in the Law, and the prophets, we have found: Jesus, son of Joseph, of Nazareth"[20]. At Capernaum, the crowd murmurs: "Is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know?"[21]. The tradition, carried by Irenaeus, who claims the authority of Polycarp, a disciple of John himself, attributes this Gospel to the apostle John, son of Zebedee, at Ephesus, at the end of the first century[22]. It is to this same John that Jesus will entrust his mother from the height of the cross: if Joseph were still alive, the mother would not be entrusted to the disciple. John's two mentions thus frame, by what is left unsaid, the death of Joseph before the ministry.

The Silence of Mark and Paul, and What It Means

Mark, the interpreter of Peter at Rome, sets down in writing the preaching of the Apostle, which begins with the baptism of John and runs toward the Passion: the childhood does not appear there, but the house of Nazareth does, with the carpenter and his brothers[23][24]. Paul, in the earliest letters of Christianity, years 48 to 58, attests the Davidic descent "according to the flesh," which is legally that of the legal father[25]. Neither of them had to tell of the dreams: their genres ruled that out. But both confirm, each in his own way, the two pillars of the dossier of Joseph, the trade of Nazareth and the house of David.

The Ancient Witnesses to the Text of Joseph

WitnessReceived DateWhat It Attests
Papias of HierapolisFirst half of the second centuryMatthew in the Hebrew dialect, Mark as Peter's interpreter
Hegesippus, MemoirsAround 160–180Clopas, brother of Joseph, and his descendants at Jerusalem
Saint Justin, ApologiesAround 155–160The "memoirs of the apostles" read every Sunday with the prophets
Muratorian CanonAround 170–200, RomeLuke as Paul's companion, John as the fourth Gospel
Tatian, DiatessaronAround 170Harmony of the four Gospels, childhood and dreams included
Saint Irenaeus, Against HeresiesAround 180The four Gospels, no more and no less, and their authors
Papyrus P52Around 125Fragment of John already circulating in Egypt

Hegesippus deserves special mention here: this second-century Jewish Christian chronicler, preserved by Eusebius, specifies that Clopas was the brother of Joseph, and that Simeon, son of Clopas, became the second bishop of Jerusalem after James[26]. The kindred of Joseph is thus known, named, and traced by the Church of Jerusalem itself, as early as the century of the apostles. Justin, around 155, attests the Sunday reading of the apostolic memoirs[27]; Tatian weaves them into a single narrative around 170[28]; Irenaeus fixes their four authors around 180[29]; and papyrus P52 circulates John in Egypt around 125[30].

The Four Dreams and the Obedience of the Righteous Man

"Joseph, son of David": the first dream (Mt 1)

Mary is with child "before they had come to live together", and Joseph, a "righteous man", decides to dismiss her quietly so as not to expose her to shame[31]. The Greek word, dikaios, says it all: an observer of the Law, yet possessing a righteousness already of the Gospel, which refuses both public suspicion and private deceit. While he is pondering this, the angel of the Lord appears to him in a dream and addresses him by the title no one else receives anywhere in the New Testament: "Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife, for what is conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit"[32]. Son of David: the messianic title is placed upon the legal father before it is placed upon the child. The child will bear the name of Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins, and Joseph, by naming him, will perform the first act of legal fatherhood — the one that inscribes the son into the lineage[33]. "When Joseph awoke, he did as the angel of the Lord had commanded him": not a word, but an act[34].

One cannot understand Joseph's dilemma without knowing what Jewish betrothal entailed: erusin already constituted a real marriage, and a wife unfaithful before cohabitation fell under the law of adultery[35]. Joseph can neither keep Mary without lying, nor denounce her without losing her: his righteousness seeks the third way, the quiet dismissal, and it is in this impasse of a righteous man that the angel speaks.

"Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife, for what is conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit. She will bear a son, and you are to name him Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins." — The angel of the Lord to Joseph, Mt 1:20-21[36]

"Get up": the flight into Egypt (Mt 2, 13-18)

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Once the magi had departed, the angel appears a second time: "Get up, take the child and his mother, and flee to Egypt"[37]. Joseph rises by night, without delay, without any described belongings, and the child escapes the massacre ordered by Herod, who has the children of Bethlehem killed — a small village of a few hundred souls, where Matthew hears Rachel weeping for her sons[38]. Egypt is no coincidence: it is the land of the first Joseph, sold and then raised up, who there fed his family in the time of famine, and Matthew hears in it the oracle, "Out of Egypt I have called my son"[39]. The second Joseph, like the first, goes down to Egypt with his own and there keeps them alive. The apocryphal tradition of the History of Joseph the Carpenter will embellish the sojourn, but the canonical text says only the essential: nocturnal obedience and protection[40].

The return and Nazareth: the third and fourth dreams (Mt 2, 19-23)

Herod being dead — in 4 BC, according to Flavius Josephus — the angel speaks a third time, always in a dream, always in Egypt: "Get up, take the child and his mother, and go back to the land of Israel"[41][42]. Joseph returns, but Archelaus is ruling over Judaea with a cruelty already notorious, and Joseph, "warned in a dream" — the fourth and final mention — withdraws to Galilee and settles in Nazareth, fulfilling the oracle that he would be called a Nazarene[43]. Four dreams, four risings, four acts of obedience: Matthew's narrative is built like a litany of listening. Between the first dream and the settling in Nazareth, Jesus was born between 6 and 4 BCE, the monk Dionysius Exiguus having been off by a few years in his sixth-century calculation[44].

  1. Betrothal
    Joseph, son of David, betrothed to Mary

    Two descendants of David, in Nazareth, an obscure village of Galilee. Mary is with child before cohabitation, and Joseph, a righteous man, ponders dismissing her quietly.

  2. First dream
    Take Mary as your wife

    The angel orders in a dream that Joseph take Mary and name the child Jesus. Joseph obeys upon waking and exercises the legal fatherhood that inscribes Jesus into the Davidic lineage.

  3. Bethlehem
    The Nativity in the city of David

    The journey up for the census, the birth of the firstborn, shepherds and then magi, the Circumcision and the Presentation in the Temple with the offering of the poor.

  4. Egypt
    The nocturnal flight and the sojourn

    The second dream, departure by night, the child snatched from Herod's massacre. A sojourn in Egypt until the death of the tyrant, in 4 BC.

  5. Nazareth
    The return and the hidden life

    The third and fourth dreams, settling in Nazareth. Thirty years of work and silence, until the twelve-year-old Jesus in the Temple, the last scene in which Joseph appears.

Bethlehem, the Temple, and Nazareth: the father who ascends, offers, and seeks

The ascent to Bethlehem, the city of David (Lk 2:1–7)

Luke anchors the birth in imperial history: an edict of Augustus, a census, Quirinius in Syria, and the ascent of Joseph and Mary "from Nazareth to Bethlehem, because he was of the house and lineage of David"[45]. It is Joseph's Davidic descent that leads the family: without it, there is no Bethlehem, and without Bethlehem, no fulfilment of Micah's oracle, "from you shall come forth one who is to rule Israel"[46]. The census of Quirinius raises a famous difficulty, since Josephus places Quirinius's governorship in AD 6, after Herod's death: the proposed answers converge around an earlier initial registration, an extraordinary mission of Quirinius, or the meaning of prōtē as the census "before that of Quirinius", without the text losing its imperial anchoring[47]. Mary "wrapped her firstborn", the legal title of the consecrated son according to Exodus[48], and Joseph is there, present and silent, in every line of the account that the Virgin Mary in the New Testament tells from the Mother's side.

The Presentation: the offering of the poor (Lk 2:21–38)

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Eight days after the birth, Joseph has the child circumcised and gives him the name received in a dream, Jesus, carrying out to the letter the angel's command: the promised name becomes the name borne[49]. Forty days later, according to the Law, Mary and Joseph go up to Jerusalem to present the child and to offer the sacrifice of the poor, two turtledoves, in place of the lamb[50]. The detail matters: the family descended from David offers as poor people. Simeon takes the child in his arms, sings the Now, and then prophesies the sword to Mary, while Luke notes that "his father and his mother marvelled at what was said of him": Joseph is named father, without qualification, in the text itself[51][52]. The prophetess Anne appears in turn: the entire Temple scene has Joseph as its silent witness.

"Your father and I": Jesus found in the Temple (Lk 2:41–51)

Every year, the family goes up to Jerusalem for Passover, and at twelve years old, on the eve of religious adulthood, Jesus remains in the Temple without his parents' knowledge[53]. Three days of anguish, then the discovery: seated among the doctors, questioning them and astonishing them. It is Mary who speaks, but she speaks for two: "Behold, your father and I have been looking for you, anxious."[54]. Never does the New Testament give Joseph a higher title: father, from Mary's own lips. Jesus's reply, "did you not know that I must be in my Father's house?", does not repudiate this fatherhood; it situates it: Joseph is father in truth, but the Father is in heaven[55]. And Luke concludes: "He went down with them to Nazareth, and he was subject to them", to Mary and to Joseph, the Word obeying the carpenter[56].

"He went down with them to Nazareth, and he was subject to them. His mother kept all these things faithfully in her heart." — Saint Luke, Lk 2:51[57]

The carpenter, the hidden house, and the silent death

Tekton: the craftsman of Nazareth

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In Nazareth, Jesus is known as "the carpenter's son", and Mark even specifies "the carpenter" himself, the son learning the trade from his father[58][59]. The Greek word, tektōn, refers more broadly to the craftsman who works wood, stone, and the framing of houses: Saint Justin, as early as the mid-second century, states that Jesus made under Joseph "yokes and ploughs", the tools of Galilean peasants[60]. Thirty years of shavings, measurements, and customers: it is in this workshop, and not in a school in Jerusalem, that the Son of God learns a man's trade, from Joseph's hand. The Catechism sees in it the summit of the hidden life, which "enables every man to be united to Jesus through the most ordinary paths of everyday life"[61].

"Is this not the son of Joseph?": the scandal of familiarity

In Capernaum, after the Bread of Life discourse, the crowd murmurs: "Is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? How does he now say, I have come down from heaven?"[62]. The objection turns into testimony: the Galileans know the family, the father, the mother, the house, and no one disputes Joseph's fatherhood. It is the same scandal as in Nazareth, "where did this man get this wisdom and these mighty works?", and the same answer from the Lord, "a prophet is not despised except in his own country"[63]. Joseph guarded the child so well that the neighbours see in Jesus nothing but the artisan's son: the incognito of Nazareth is Joseph's work as much as God's.

Absent from Cana, absent from the cross: death before the ministry

After Jesus's twelfth year, Joseph never reappears. At Cana, "the mother of Jesus was there", without Joseph[64]. During the ministry, "his mother and his brothers" come to see him, without Joseph[65]. At the foot of the cross, Jesus entrusts his mother to the beloved disciple, which would be unthinkable if her husband were still alive[66]. Before Easter, Mary is at prayer with the apostles, a widow beside the disciple[67]. Tradition, unanimously, therefore places the death of Joseph between Jesus's twelfth year and the beginning of his public life, surrounded by Jesus and Mary: no one has ever had such assistance at the hour of death, whence his title of patron of a happy death, invoked to obtain a peaceful end[68]. The Church does not define the date, but she prays as though it were yesterday: the litanies sing of Joseph, "comfort of the wretched, hope of the sick, patron of the dying"[69].

What the New Testament Already Teaches about Joseph

Son of David: the transmission of messianic rights

Matthew opens his gospel with "the book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, son of David, son of Abraham," then unfolds three sets of fourteen generations, from Abraham to David, from David to the exile, from the exile to Christ, passing through Jacob, who "begat Joseph, the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus, who is called Christ"[70]. The break in the chain is deliberate: everywhere else the verb is begat; here it stops at the husband, and the child comes from Mary. Yet it is indeed through Joseph that Jesus is son of David: legal filiation transmits the rights, and Joseph, by taking Mary and naming the child, inscribes Jesus into the house of David[71]. Luke confirms it from the other end: at the close of his ascending genealogy, "son, so it was thought, of Joseph, son of Heli," up to Adam, up to God[72]. The Catechism summarizes: Jesus is "son of David according to the flesh," promised to Israel[73]. And the title placed on Joseph by the angel is not confined to the infancy narratives: it returns to Jesus on the lips of the crowds, in the blind man of Jericho, in the Canaanite woman, in the two blind men of Galilee, right up to the cries of Palm Sunday[74]. This whole procession of sons of David rests on the legal fatherhood of the carpenter of Nazareth.

True husband in a virginal marriage

Joseph "took to him his wife" and "knew her not until she had brought forth a son"[75]. Saint Augustine draws from this the doctrine of true marriage without carnal union: in it all the good of marriage is accomplished — the child, fidelity, the sacrament — for consent makes marriage, not consummation[76]. Saint Jerome, against Helvidius who wanted to give Mary other children, defends perpetual virginity and, with it, the honor of Joseph, whose continence safeguards the mystery[77]. Saint Thomas brings the argument to completion: it was fitting that the Mother of God be married, to protect the child and his mother, to veil the mystery from the demons, and to give the Christ, in Joseph, a father to nourish him, protect him, and present him to the Temple[78]. John Paul II names the thing in a word: Joseph is the virginal father of Jesus, a true husband in a union that the Spirit alone has made fruitful[79].

"All the good of marriage was accomplished in these parents of Christ: the child, fidelity, the sacrament." — Saint Augustine, On Marriage and Concupiscence, I, 11[80]

The just and silent one: obedience without a word

Dikaios, just, from the very first mention; obedient, at each dream, without arguing, without delay, in the night; silent, to the very end, without a single word recorded. Saint John Chrysostom admires this faith that asks for no sign: Joseph believes the unbelievable, the virginal conception, on the sole word of a dream, and "he did as the angel of the Lord had commanded him," questioning neither the messenger nor the mystery[81]. John Paul II sees in this obedience "the expression of the primacy of the inner life": Joseph, a man of silence, accomplishes in the shadows the most decisive work, keeping the Redeemer[82]. Pope Francis, four centuries of devotion later, says no differently: Joseph loved "with a father's heart," in the shadows, through work, through welcome, through the courage of nocturnal flights[83].

"With a father's heart: that is how Joseph loved Jesus, who is called in the four Gospels the son of Joseph." — Pope Francis, Patris corde, introduction[84]

The second Joseph: the typology of the patriarch

Matthew did not choose the dreams and Egypt at random: Joseph, son of Jacob according to the genealogy[85], reenacts the Joseph, son of Jacob of Genesis, and the Judeo-Christian reader recognizes it at once. The table of correspondences, noted by the Fathers, structures the entire narrative.

First Joseph (Gen 37 to 50)Second Joseph (Mt 1 to 2)
Son of Jacob, his father's favoriteSon of Jacob, the husband chosen for Mary
Dreams announce his greatnessFour dreams guide his every step
Sold and then raised up in EgyptFleeing and then returning from Egypt
Chaste before Potiphar's wifeChaste in his virginal marriage
Provider for his family through the wheatProvider of the Living Bread through his work
"Do whatever he tells you" (Pharaoh)"Do whatever he tells you" (Mary at Cana)
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The last line, which the Virgin Mary in the New Testament notes at Cana, completes the portrait: Pharaoh's word about the first Joseph becomes Mary's word about the Son of the second. The New Testament never cites the typology explicitly, but Matthew writes it in deeds, and the Church sings it: Joseph keeps the new wheat even as the old kept the granaries[86].

Reception in the Church: Fathers, Popes, and Liturgy

The Fathers of the early centuries

Joseph is not a late discovery of modern piety: the earliest Fathers already hold to him from Scripture. Justin, around 155, knows the workshop at Nazareth and the carpenter's ploughs[87]. Irenaeus, around 180, sees in the virginal conception the proof that Christ is not the son of Joseph according to the flesh, but truly his son according to the Law[88]. Origen, in the third century, defends Mary's honour against Celsus and, with it, Joseph's righteousness, as he refuses to slander her[89]. Hegesippus names his family line as far as the bishopric of Jerusalem[90]. In the fourth century, the two great readings of the "brethren" are established: Jerome sees them as cousins, the children of Clopas, Joseph's brother[91]; Epiphanius, as the sons of a first marriage[92], following the Protevangelium of James, an apocryphal text from the middle of the second century that the Church never received into the canon but whose existence she knows[93]. Chrysostom preaches the dreams at Antioch, Augustine the virginal marriage at Hippo, and the doctrine is fixed for a millennium[94][95].

As a paraphrase of the Homilies on Matthew of Saint John Chrysostom, and not as a literal quotation, Joseph is the righteous man whose faith asks for no further sign: he welcomes Mary, keeps the child and at once carries out what the angel has prescribed to him[96].

The Popes and Doctors: from guardian to patron

The Middle Ages makes Joseph the model of contemplatives; Bernard and the Franciscans preach his fatherhood, Teresa of Avila entrusts her foundations to him, and Gerson pleads his cause at the Council of Constance[97]. But it is the nineteenth century that settles the matter: on 8 December 1870, Pius IX, by the decree Quemadmodum Deus, declares Saint Joseph Patron of the Universal Church, entrusting to him who guarded the Christ Child the guardianship of the mystical body[98]. Leo XIII, by the encyclical Quamquam pluries of 15 August 1889, orders his patronage to be joined to that of Mary and devotes the month of October, together with the Rosary, to seeking his aid[99]. Saint Pius X approves the litany of Saint Joseph in 1909[100]. Pius XII institutes the feast of Saint Joseph the Worker on 1 May 1955, set against the workers' 1 May[101]. John Paul II crowns the edifice on 15 August 1989 with the exhortation Redemptoris Custos, the guardian of the Redeemer, "the shadow of the Father" over the Holy Family[102]. And Francis, for the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the patronage, offers the Year of Saint Joseph, from 8 December 2020 to 8 December 2021, with the letter Patris corde[103].

Joseph in the liturgy: the great dates

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI
  1. 19 March
    Solemnity of Saint Joseph, Spouse of Mary

    A medieval feast of the Franciscans, entered in the Roman calendar and extended to the whole Church in the seventeenth century. The Church honours the spouse of the Mother of God and the legal father of the Saviour, recounted in the article on Saint Joseph on 19 March.

  2. 1870
    Patron of the Universal Church

    Pius IX, in the midst of the storm over the temporal power, entrusts the Church to him who guarded Jesus and Mary. The patronage is celebrated and renewed at every crisis.

  3. 1889
    Leo XIII and the month of October

    The encyclical Quamquam pluries joins Joseph's aid to the prayer of the Rosary: the guardian of the Holy Family becomes the guardian of Christian families.

  4. 1 May
    Saint Joseph the Worker

    Pius XII gives workers a patron who worked with his hands for thirty years at Nazareth. The carpenter's workshop illuminates the factory and the office.

  5. Wednesdays and the month of March
    Ordinary devotion

    Wednesday, the day of the week dedicated to Joseph, and the month of March, which holds his solemnity, mark the rhythm of the faithful's prayer, with the litany approved in 1909.

  6. 2020-2021
    The Year of Saint Joseph

    Francis proclaims a jubilee year for the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the patronage, with the letter Patris corde: Joseph loved, tender, obedient, welcoming, courageous, hardworking, in the shadows.

Common objections and answers

"The two genealogies contradict each other" ?

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Matthew descends Jesus from David through Solomon, Luke through Nathan, and the two lists diverge between David and Joseph. The objection is an old one, and so is the answer: as early as the third century, Julius Africanus, in his Letter to Aristides preserved by Eusebius, explains by levirate marriage that Jacob, Joseph's father according to Matthew, and Heli, Joseph's father according to Luke, were half-brothers, born of the same mother, Estha, by two successive fathers; Heli dying childless, Jacob raised up offspring for him according to the law of levirate marriage, and Joseph thus had a father according to nature, Jacob, and a father according to law, Heli[104]. Augustine takes up the solution in his Sermon 51 on the genealogies[105]. Another reading, widespread, sees in Luke's list the lineage of Mary herself, Heli being her father, Joseph's father-in-law named according to the custom that links the son-in-law to the house[106]. Both readings safeguard the essential: through Joseph, legal father, Jesus is legally the son of David, and neither list claims modern exhaustiveness, as Matthew himself says by structuring his three sets of fourteen generations[107].

"Joseph was an elderly widower" ?

Georges de La Tour, Saint Joseph the Carpenter, c. 1640. Public domain reproduction: Wikimedia Commons, file Georges de La Tour. St. Joseph, the Carpenter.JPG.

The image of old, white-haired Joseph comes from the Protevangelium of James, a second-century apocryphal text, which makes him an elderly widower, father of children from a first marriage, chosen to guard Mary[108]. The Church has never received this text as Scripture, and the picture it imposes contradicts the canonical account: an elderly man would not have gone up to Bethlehem for the census, nor fled by night into Egypt with the child, nor worked thirty years at the workshop, and Mary would not have been betrothed according to custom to a man of a different age[109]. The received reading therefore sees in him a young craftsman, in the strength of his years, capable of the journeys, the flights and the work the text ascribes to him. The earlier widowhood remains a free opinion, never defined, but the canonical text depicts a young, just, and strong man.

"He did not know her until" : so afterwards, then?

This is the objection of Helvidius, refuted by Jerome and taken up in the article on the Virgin Mary in the New Testament: the word until, in Greek as in Hebrew, says nothing about afterwards, exactly like Saul's daughter "had no children until the day of her death"[110]. The text knows only one son of Mary; Jesus is her "firstborn" in the legal sense of the consecrated son, and from the height of the cross Jesus entrusts his mother to the disciple, which no younger brother, and above all no living husband, would have allowed[111]. Joseph, true husband, remains the virginal guardian of the mystery.

"The census of Quirinius is a historical error" ?

Josephus places the census of Quirinius in 6 AD, ten years after the death of Herod, under whom Jesus was born: Luke would thus be mistaken by a decade[112]. The answers, without settling a point the Church has not defined, come down to three converging lines: the Greek prōtē can be read "before that of Quirinius", distinguishing two operations; several epigraphic indices suggest an extraordinary mission of Quirinius in the East before his official governorship; and the censuses of Augustus, attested by the inscription of Ancyra for the whole Empire, made registration in Judea plausible as early as the reign of Herod[113]. The imperial anchoring of the account, Augustus, Syria, the journey up to Bethlehem, remains historically consistent.

The historical-critical debate and its limits

What part of contemporary exegesis proposes

Since the nineteenth century, part of exegesis has proposed dating the gospels later than tradition: Mark around 65-70, Matthew and Luke around 80-90 based on Mark and a sayings source known as Q, never found, John around 90-100 or later[114]. Within this framework, the infancy narratives would be late compositions: Joseph would be a literary figure, modeled on the patriarch of the same name, dreams and Egypt included, to express in narrative the paschal faith of the communities, theologoumena true in their meaning, without direct historical scope[115]. The diverging genealogies would serve as confirmation: two incompatible theological constructions, hence two inventions. And the silence of Mark, Paul, and John about the dreams would prove that the first generation knew nothing of Joseph.

The frailties of the reconstruction

This reconstruction piles up the classic frailties of the science of the past. Document Q has never been found: it is a hypothesis to explain resemblances, promoted to the rank of a lost source, then used as proof of late dating, in a circle[116]. The anti-miraculous presupposition dictates the result: when every verified dream and every virginal conception are classified by default among community inventions, Joseph disappears by method before ever having been examined[117]. Typology does not exclude history: that Matthew writes Joseph in echo of the patriarch proves his art as a narrator, not his fiction, exactly as resemblances between two battles do not prove that the second never took place[118]. The argument from silence carries little weight: Mark and Paul write genres that exclude infancy, and John names Joseph twice while assuming the dossier known. And the answer to the genealogies precedes seventeen centuries of criticism: Julius Africanus was already solving, in the third century, through the levirate marriage attested in the Law, the difficulty that is presented as a modern discovery[119].

Why the traditional reading remains defensible

Against late datings, material facts speak early: the papyrus P52 circulates John in Egypt around 125, Justin reads the apostolic memoirs every Sunday around 155, Tatian weaves them into a single narrative around 170, Irenaeus fixes their four authors around 180[120]. Against the idea of community invention, the chain of witnesses is short: Irenaeus knew Polycarp who had known John, and Hegesippus names the very kinship of Joseph up to the bishopric of Jerusalem[121]. Against the dissolution of the account into theology, Matthew and Luke, independent on the infancy, agree on everything essential about Joseph, betrothal, house of David, virginal conception, Bethlehem then Nazareth, an index recognized even by the exegete Raymond Brown, of a tradition prior to the two accounts[122]. And against the separation of history and faith, the Church has settled the matter by magisterium: the gospels "faithfully transmit what Jesus truly did and taught", declares Vatican II[123], after the Pontifical Biblical Commission had set out in 1964 the three honest stages of the work, without dissolving the life of Jesus into the faith of the communities[124]. Joseph's silence is not a void: it is his way of being a father.

To go further

Joseph is to be read first in the New Testament itself: Mt 1 to 2, Lk 1 to 3, Jn 1 and 6, in the TOB or the Jerusalem Bible, before going on to the Virgin Mary in the New Testament, the Annunciation of the Lord, Mary Mother of God, the Immaculate Conception and its dogma of 1854, the Assumption, Saint Joseph on 19 March and the Virgin Mary and Saint Joseph in the life of prayer. One will then consult the Catechism, 437, 488 to 507 and 527 to 534, the exhortation Redemptoris Custos by John Paul II, the letter Patris corde by Pope Francis and the encyclical Quamquam pluries by Leo XIII. For the patristic rooting: Justin against Trypho, Hegesippus in Eusebius, Jerome against Helvidius, Chrysostome on Matthew, Augustine on marriage and the genealogies.

Notes and References

  1. Inventory of the direct passages in which Joseph appears or is named as legal father of Jesus: Mt 1, 16-25; 2, 13-23; 13, 55; Lk 1, 27; 2, 4-51; 3, 23; Jn 1, 45; 6, 42. Liturgical translation of the AELF.

    1 3
  2. John Paul II, apostolic exhortation Redemptoris Custos, 15 August 1989: Joseph, "guardian of the Redeemer", called to guard Jesus and Mary as the Church is called to guard the deposit of faith.

    2 102
  3. Unanimous tradition of the death of Joseph before the ministry, surrounded by Jesus and Mary: foundation of the patronage of a happy death, sung in the litanies ("patron of the dying") and illustrated by centuries of sacred art.

    4 68
  4. Mt 1, 20; 2, 13; 2, 19; 2, 22: the four dreams, modelled on the dreams of the patriarch Joseph (Gen 37; 40; 41), with at each stage the oracle fulfilled (Is 7, 14; Hos 11, 1; Jer 31, 15).

    5
  5. Lk 1, 27; 2, 4-7.21-24.33.41-51: Joseph betrothed, going up, offering, seeking, marvelling, then subject with Mary to the child found again.

    6
  6. Mk 6, 2-3: at Nazareth, "the carpenter, the son of Mary", and the brothers James, Joses, Jude and Simon; cf. Mt 13, 55-56, "the son of the carpenter".

    7 59
  7. Rom 1, 3-4: the Son "descended from David according to the flesh", in a letter dated to the 50s, before any written gospel.

    8 25
  8. Papias of Hierapolis, Explanations of the Lord's Discourses, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Matthew composed the logia in the Hebrew dialect; Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately what he retained of his preaching.

    9 23
  9. Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39 (Papias) and VI, 14 (Clement of Alexandria on the order of the gospels), written around 324.

    10
  10. Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposes, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14: the gospels containing the genealogies (Matthew, Luke) were written first.

    11
  11. Traditional dating of Matthew: the first gospel, in Hebrew then in Greek, intended for Jewish Christians, before the destruction of Jerusalem (70), placed in the 40s to 60s.

    12
  12. Lk 1, 27: Mary "betrothed to a man named Joseph (mnèsteumenèn andri hô onoma Iôsèph), of the house of David".

    13
  13. Lk 1, 1-4: prologue of the ordered enquiry, dedicated to Theophilus, from the eyewitnesses.

    14 19
  14. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, around 180: Matthew published his gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul were evangelising Rome; after their departure, Mark transmitted Peter's preaching, Luke set down Paul's, and John published his own at Ephesus.

    15 22
  15. Muratorian Canon, Rome, around 170-200: Luke, companion of Paul without having seen the Lord, third gospel; John, fourth, at the request of his fellow disciples.

    16
  16. Gal 1, 19: "James, the brother of the Lord", a pillar of the Church of Jerusalem with Peter and John, cf. Gal 2, 9.

    17
  17. Traditional dating of Luke and Acts: Luke around 60-63, Acts around 62-63, the account ending with Paul's Roman captivity without mentioning his death (around 67) or the destruction of Jerusalem (70).

    18
  18. Jn 1, 45: Philip to Nathanael, "the one of whom Moses wrote in the Law, and also the prophets, we have found: Jesus, son of Joseph, of Nazareth".

    20
  19. Jn 6, 42: at Capernaum, "is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know?"

    21 62
  20. Traditional dating of Mark: in Rome from Peter's preaching, in the 60s, before Peter's martyrdom under Nero (64-67).

    24
  21. Hegesippus, Memoirs, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, III, 11 and IV, 22: Clopas, brother of Joseph, and Simeon his son, second bishop of Jerusalem.

    26 90 121
  22. Saint Justin, First Apology, 66-67, around 155: on Sunday, one reads "the memoirs composed by the apostles, or by those who followed them", together with the writings of the prophets.

    27
  23. Tatian the Syrian, Diatessaron, around 170: harmony of the four gospels into a single continuous narrative, infancy of Jesus included.

    28
  24. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 11, 8: there can be neither more nor fewer than four gospels, like the four zones of the world and the four faces of the cherubim.

    29
  25. Papyrus P52 (Rylands Gr. P. 457), fragment of Jn 18 copied in Egypt and dated to around 125, the oldest material witness to the New Testament.

    30 120
  26. Mt 1, 18-19: Mary pregnant "before they had lived together"; Joseph, a "just man" (dikaios), decides to send her away quietly.

    31
  27. Mt 1, 20-21: "Joseph, son of David (Iôsèph huios Dauid), do not be afraid to take Mary your wife into your home"; the name of Jesus, "for it is he who will save his people from their sins".

    32 36
  28. Is 7, 14, quoted in Mt 1, 22-23: "Behold, the virgin shall conceive", and the Emmanuel, God with us.

    33
  29. Mt 1, 24-25: "When he awoke, Joseph did as the angel of the Lord had commanded him: he took his wife into his home, and he did not know her until she had borne a son, to whom he gave the name of Jesus."

    34
  30. Deut 22, 23-24: the betrothed young woman who is unfaithful is judged as an adulteress; cf. Mishnah, tractate Ketubot, on betrothal (érusin) as the first degree of marriage, followed about a year later by the taking into the husband's home (nissuin). The sending away spoken of by Matthew presupposes the written act of repudiation (Deut 24, 1).

    35
  31. Mt 2, 13-14: "Get up, take the child and his mother, and flee to Egypt"; Joseph "got up and, by night, took the child and his mother".

    37
  32. Jer 31, 15: "Rachel weeps for her children", quoted in Mt 2, 17-18 for the massacre of the Innocents ordered by Herod.

    38
  33. Hos 11, 1: "out of Egypt I called my son", quoted in Mt 2, 15 for the flight and then the return.

    39
  34. History of Joseph the Carpenter, Coptic and Arabic apocryphon of the 4th-5th centuries: account of the death of Joseph at the age of 111, surrounded by Jesus and Mary; never received into the canon, but a witness to ancient devotion.

    40
  35. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVII: the death of Herod the Great shortly before a lunar eclipse, dated to 4 BC; cf. Jewish War, I, on Archelaus, ethnarch of Judaea from 4 BC to AD 6.

    41
  36. Mt 2, 19-21: third dream, in Egypt after the death of Herod, "get up, take the child and his mother, and go back to the land of Israel".

    42
  37. Mt 2, 22-23: "warned in a dream", Joseph withdraws to Galilee and settles in Nazareth, "so that what was spoken through the prophets might be fulfilled: he shall be called a Nazarene".

    43
  38. The birth of Jesus is placed between 6 and 4 BC, on the basis of the death of Herod (4 BC) and the error in the calculation of Dionysius Exiguus in the 6th century.

    44
  39. Lk 2, 4-5: Joseph goes up "to Judaea, to Bethlehem, the city of David, because he was of the house and lineage of David", with Mary his wife, who was pregnant.

    45
  40. Mic 5, 1: "And you, Bethlehem Ephrathah, from you shall come forth the one who is to rule Israel", oracle quoted by the scribes before Herod in Mt 2, 5-6.

    46
  41. Lk 2, 2: "this first census took place while Quirinius was governor of Syria"; Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, places it in AD 6. Answers proposed: an earlier first registration, an extraordinary mission of Quirinius, or reading prôtè as "before that of Quirinius".

    47 113
  42. Ex 13, 2 and Num 3, 13: the firstborn male consecrated to the Lord, a legal title independent of any siblings.

    48
  43. Lk 2, 21: the circumcision on the eighth day and the name of Jesus, "as the angel had called him before his conception".

    49
  44. Lk 2, 22-24: the purification according to Lev 12, and the offering of the poor, "a pair of turtledoves", according to Lev 12, 8.

    50
  45. Lk 2:28-35: Simeon takes the child, sings the Nunc ("my eyes have seen your salvation, a light for revelation to the nations", cf. Is 42:6 and 49:6), then announces to Mary the sign of contradiction and the sword (romphaia).

    51
  46. Lk 2:33: "his father and his mother (ho patēr autou kai hē mētēr) were amazed at what was said about him"; some ancient witnesses read "Joseph and his mother".

    52
  47. Lk 2:41-42: the annual ascent to Jerusalem for Passover, Jesus aged twelve, on the eve of religious adulthood.

    53
  48. Lk 2:48: "Behold, your father and I (ho patēr sou kagō), have been looking for you, anxious."

    54
  49. Lk 2:49: "Did you not know that I must be in my Father's house (en tois tou Patros mou)?"

    55
  50. Lk 2:51: Jesus went down to Nazareth and "was obedient to them" (ēn hypotassomenos autois), while "his mother kept all these things faithfully (dietērei) in her heart".

    56 57
  51. Mt 13:55: at Nazareth, "is this not the carpenter's son (ho tou tektonos huios)?"; cf. Mt 13:54, "where did this man get this wisdom and these mighty works?"

    58
  52. Saint Justin, Dialogue with Trypho, 88, c. 155-160: Jesus, the carpenter's son, made "yokes and ploughs", thereby teaching the symbols of justice and of the active life.

    60 87
  53. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 531-533: Jesus obedient to Mary and to Joseph at Nazareth, and the hidden life which "enables every man to be united to Christ by the most ordinary things of daily life".

    61
  54. Mt 13:54-57: the scandal of Nazareth, "a prophet is not without honour except in his own country and in his own house".

    63
  55. Jn 2:1-4: the wedding at Cana, "the mother of Jesus was there", with no mention of Joseph, already gone from the narrative.

    64
  56. Mk 3:31-35: the mother and brethren outside, "here are my mother and my brethren", with no mention of Joseph.

    65
  57. Jn 19:26-27: "Woman, behold your son... Behold your mother. And from that hour the disciple took her to his own" (eis ta idia, into his own possessions).

    66
  58. Acts 1:13-14: the Eleven, the women, Mary the mother of Jesus and his brethren, constant in prayer in the upper room.

    67
  59. Litany of Saint Joseph, approved by Saint Pius X in 1909: "consolation of the afflicted, hope of the sick, patron of the dying, terror of demons, protector of the Holy Church, pray for us".

    69 100
  60. Mt 1:1-17: the book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, son of David, son of Abraham, in three sets of fourteen generations, up to "Jacob, who begot Joseph, the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus, who is called Christ".

    70 85
  61. The Matthean genealogy names four women, Tamar, Rahab, Ruth and the wife of Uriah, before Mary, the fifth: the history of salvation passes along irregular paths that the legal paternity of Joseph assumes and redeems.

    71 107
  62. Lk 3:23-38: "Jesus, when he began his ministry, was about thirty years of age, being the son (as was supposed) of Joseph, the son of Heli", a genealogy ascending to Adam, and to God.

    72
  63. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 437: Jesus, "Son of David according to the flesh", the anointed one awaited by Israel, acknowledged by the blind men and by the Palm Sunday crowd.

    73
  64. Mk 10:47-48 (the blind Bartimaeus at Jericho); Mt 15:22 (the Canaanite woman); Mt 9:27 (the two blind men); Mt 21:9.15 (Palm Sunday, "Hosanna to the Son of David").

    74
  65. Mt 1:25: "he knew her not until (heōs hou) she had borne a son"; cf. 2 Sam 6:23, Michal "had no child until the day of her death".

    75 110
  66. Saint Augustine, On Marriage and Concupiscence, I, 11: "Every blessing of marriage (omne nuptiarum bonum) was accomplished in these parents of Christ: offspring, fidelity, the sacrament."

    76 80 95
  67. Saint Jerome, Against Helvidius, c. 383: the "brethren" are cousins, children of Mary of Clopas; James the brother of the Lord is James the son of Alphaeus, Clopas in its Hellenized form.

    77 91
  68. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, III, q. 29, a. 1-2: it was fitting that Mary be married to Joseph, a true marriage without carnal union, to protect the child and to veil the mystery.

    78
  69. John Paul II, Redemptoris Custos, 7-8: Joseph, "son of David" called by the angel, "virginal father" of Jesus, a true husband in a marriage that the Spirit alone made fruitful.

    79
  70. Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Gospel of Saint Matthew, IV, 10 (on Mt 1:20) and V, 5 (on Mt 1:24): Joseph, full of faith, has no need of a manifest vision (IV, 10); on waking, Chrysostom notes his obedience and his docile soul, which keeps Mary and serves God's design (V, 5). Paraphrase, not a literal quotation.

    81 94 96
  71. John Paul II, Redemptoris Custos, 24-25: the obedience of Joseph as "an expression of the primacy of the inner life", the man of silence accomplishing in the shadows the work of salvation.

    82
  72. Pope Francis, apostolic letter Patris corde, 8 December 2020: "With a father's heart: that is how Joseph loved Jesus"; Joseph beloved, tender, obedient, welcoming, courageous, hardworking, in the shadows; Saint Joseph Year 2020-2021 for the 150th anniversary of the proclamation of his patronage.

    83 84 103
  73. Typology noted by the Fathers: the two Josephs, son of Jacob, the dreams (Gen 37; Mt 1-2), Egypt the nourishing land (Gen 41-47; Mt 2), chastity (Gen 39; Mt 1), and the words "do whatever he tells you" (Gen 41:55; Jn 2:5).

    86 118
  74. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 21-22: the virgin conception proves that Christ was not born of Joseph according to the flesh, while being enrolled in his house according to the Law.

    88
  75. Celsus, True Discourse, c. 178: the accusation of adultery by Mary with a soldier named Panthera; Origen, Against Celsus, I, 28-32, c. 248, refutes it point by point and defends the justice of Joseph.

    89
  76. Epiphanius of Salamis, Panarion, 78, 4th century: the "brethren" would be the sons of Joseph from a first marriage, according to the Protoevangelium of James.

    92
  77. Protoevangelium of James, mid-2nd century: an apocryphal account of the childhood of Mary and of the choice of Joseph, an elderly widower; never received into the canon, set aside by Saint Jerome, but the source of the names Joachim and Anne (26 July) and of Epiphanius' reading of the "brethren".

    93 108
  78. Jean Gerson, chancellor of Paris, pleads at the Council of Constance (1414-1418) for the feast of Saint Joseph and the doctrine of his virginal paternity; Saint Teresa of Avila entrusts her foundations to him in the 16th century.

    97
  79. Pius IX, decree Quemadmodum Deus, 8 December 1870: Saint Joseph declared patron of the universal Church; he who guarded the Christ child will guard the mystical body.

    98
  80. Leo XIII, encyclical Quamquam pluries, 15 August 1889: the patronage of Joseph joined to that of Mary, and the month of October consecrated to the Rosary with his aid.

    99
  81. Pius XII, 1 May 1955: the feast of Saint Joseph the Worker, giving to workers the patron who worked thirty years with his hands at Nazareth.

    101
  82. Julius Africanus, Letter to Aristides, early 3rd century, preserved by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, I, 7: Jacob and Heli, half-brothers through their mother Estha, and the levirate (Deut 25:5-6) explaining the two paternities of Joseph.

    104 119
  83. Saint Augustine, Sermon 51, on the genealogies of the Lord: the solution of the levirate and of double paternity, according to nature and according to law.

    105
  84. A reading widespread since antiquity: Luke's genealogy would give the lineage of Mary herself, Heli being her father and Joseph's father-in-law, named according to the custom that links the son-in-law to the house of his wife.

    106
  85. The canonical account presupposes a young man: the ascent to Bethlehem for the census, the night flight into Egypt, the return with the child, thirty years in the workshop. Early widowhood remains a free opinion, never defined by the Church.

    109
  86. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 500-501: the Church "has always understood these texts as not referring to other children of the Blessed Virgin Mary", and "Jesus is the only son of Mary".

    111
  87. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 1-2: the census of Quirinius, governor of Syria, in 6 AD, ten years after the death of Herod the Great.

    112
  88. The two-source hypothesis: Mark priority (65-70), Matthew and Luke (80-90) combining Mark and a sayings source Q, never found, John around the turn of the 2nd century.

    114
  89. Rudolf Bultmann and demythologization: the infancy narratives read as narrative expressions of Easter faith (theologoumena), with no direct historical bearing.

    115
  90. Passages cut out according to stylistic criteria, dated according to a theory of religious evolution, then invoked as evidence of that evolution: the reasoning goes in circles.

    116
  91. When every verified dream and every virginal conception is automatically classed among communal inventions, the late dating is presupposed by the method, not demonstrated by the manuscripts.

    117
  92. Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah, 1977: Matthew and Luke, independent in their infancy narratives, agree on the virginal conception, an indication of a tradition earlier than both accounts.

    122
  93. Second Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church "affirms without hesitation the historicity" of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus actually did and taught.

    123
  94. Pontifical Biblical Commission, Instruction Sancta Mater Ecclesia, 21 April 1964: the three stages—the life of Jesus, the oral preaching of the apostles, the writing of the evangelists—without dissolving history into the faith of the communities.

    124

Can’t find your topic?