Saul (c. 1080–1010 BC)

Saul, first king of Israel: anointed by Samuel for his stature, rejected for preferring his own will to obedience, persecutor of David as far as Gilboa.

Ignispedia

Saul is, according to the Scripture received by the Church, the first king of Israel: the handsome Benjaminite who set out to seek lost donkeys and returned anointed by Samuel, the deliverer of Jabesh acclaimed at Gilgal, then the disobedient king of Gilgal and Amalek, the persecutor of David, and finally the fallen man of Mount Gilboa over whose body his successor would sing an immortal lament. His life occupies more than half of the First Book of Samuel, from chapter 8 to chapter 31, in the mid-eleventh century before Jesus Christ.

His name runs through the whole Bible: the Chronicles devote a genealogy to him and the solemn judgment of his death, a psalm title recalls the night when he had the house of David watched, Paul cites him at Antioch of Pisidia as the king of the forty years, and the apostle of the nations will bear his name, Saul of Tarsus, a Benjaminite like him. The article first presents the narrative as the Church receives it, its place in the canon and its ancient witnesses, then its theology, its fulfilment in Christ, its presence in the liturgy and the arts, and finally the debate with modern historical-critical exegesis.

Saul in the canon of the Scriptures

The dossier of the First Book of Samuel, chapters 8 to 31

The life of Saul occupies chapters 8 to 31 of the First Book of Samuel, from the request for a king "like the nations" to the death of the king on Gilboa and the exposure of his body on the walls of Beth-shan[1]. He reappears one last time in chapter one of the Second Book, in the lament that David composes on hearing of the disaster, a piece that closes his dossier like a eulogy pronounced by the man he had persecuted[2]. Everything that follows, the reign of David at Hebron and then at Jerusalem, takes place after him, upon the ruins of his house.

In Hebrew, the book is called Shemouel and forms a single scroll with what our Bibles call the Second Book of Samuel; the division into two books comes from the Greek Septuagint, which titles the whole the books of Reigns, and then from the Latin Vulgate[3]. For the detailed history of these two books, their structure, their text and their overall theology, see the article devoted to the books of Samuel: the present article deals with the man, not with the literary dossier[4].

The other mentions of Saul in the Bible

Saul is not confined to his own book: about ten passages, from the Chronicles to the Acts by way of the Psalms and Hosea, name him or presuppose his reign, which rules out treating his story as a late piece tacked on. The table below gathers the main mentions outside the First Book of Samuel.

Biblical bookPassageWhat the text contributes about Saul
1 Chronicles1 Chr 8, 33 and 9, 39The genealogy: Kish, Saul, Jonathan, then the descent through Merib-baal
1 Chronicles1 Chr 10, 1-14The second account of the death at Gilboa, concluded by the judgment: infidelity and the medium
PsalmsTitle of Ps 59"When Saul sent men to watch the house in order to kill him": the night of 1 Sam 19
HoseaHos 13, 10-11"I give you a king in my anger": commonly read of the first king
ActsActs 13, 21-22"Saul, son of Kish, a man of the tribe of Benjamin, for forty years"
PhilippiansPhil 3, 5Paul, "of the tribe of Benjamin": the same blood as the first king
ActsActs 13, 9"Saul, also called Paul": the apostle first bears the name of the king

Two features stand out in this sweep. First, the later books speak of Saul with the precision of the archive: his genealogy is kept over three generations (Chronicles), a psalm is dated by one of his policing orders (Ps 59), the years of his reign are counted (Acts)[5]. Second, the New Testament makes him the luminous foil for David: Paul opposes in a single sentence the rejected king and "the man according to my heart", as if the whole history of the monarchy were contained in that contrast[6].

The biblical account, step by step

  1. Around the mid-11th century BC
    Qish's donkeys

    Saul, son of Qish, a Benjaminite, searches for the lost animals and meets the seer in the town.

  2. Shortly after
    The anointing and the acclamation

    Secret anointing, the lot at Mizpah, victory over the Ammonites of Jabesh, coronation at Gilgal.

  3. Early years of the reign
    Wars of liberation

    Michmash and Jonathan's victory, pursuit of the Philistines, campaigns against Amalek and the neighbours.

  4. Middle of the reign
    The two acts of disobedience

    The usurped sacrifice at Gilgal, the spoil spared from Amalek: the kingdom is torn away from Saul.

  5. Long years
    The persecution of David

    The evil spirit, the jealousy sparked by the women's song, the spears, Nob, the caves of En-gedi.

  6. Around 1010 BC
    Endor and Gilboa

    The necromancer, the shade of Samuel, the lost battle, the death of the king and of Jonathan.

The Benjaminite with the lost donkeys

It all begins in the smallest of the tribes: "There was a man of Benjamin whose name was Kish", a man of substance, and "he had a son whose name was Saul, who was young and handsome", the account tells us[7]. Saul himself will remind Samuel of this: Benjamin is the smallest tribe of Israel, and his clan the least of the tribe, which makes the chosen man one without support, picked from above rather than carried by a party[8].

"He had a son whose name was Saul, who was young and handsome. There was not a man among the people of Israel more handsome than he; from his shoulders upward he was taller than any of the people."

  • First Book of Samuel 9:2, liturgical translation[9]

Qish's donkeys having strayed, Saul sets out with a servant through the hill country of Ephraim, Shalisha, Shaalim and the land of Benjamin, as far as the land of Zuph, where he wants to turn back for fear of worrying his father: the obedient and thoughtful son is already taking shape, before the king who will stop listening[10]. The servant suggests consulting the man of God in the town with a quarter of a shekel of silver, in an economy still without coined money where the seer is paid in kind[11]. And the narrator's gloss, "he who is today called a prophet, was then called a seer", betrays the antiquity of the transmitted account: a late forger would modernise the vocabulary rather than explain its archaism[12].

The secret anointing, Mizpah, Jabesh and Gilgal

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The Lord had warned Samuel the day before: "Tomorrow about this time I will send to you a man from the land of Benjamin. You shall anoint him to be prince over my people Israel"[13]. The anointing takes place in secret, with the vial of oil poured over his head and the ritual kiss; then Samuel summons Israel to Mizpah, has the tribes advance one by one, the clans one by one, and the lot singles out Saul, who is found hiding among the baggage, so timid is the tall young man[14]. The contrast is deliberate: the giant hides, and it is precisely this trembling that makes him fit to receive power without being intoxicated by it.

"Samuel said to all the people, 'Do you see him whom the Lord has chosen? There is none like him among all the people.' And all the people shouted, and said, 'Long live the king!'"

  • First Book of Samuel 10:24, liturgical translation[15]

Proof by arms was still needed: the Ammonites besiege Jabesh in Gilead and offer the besieged an infamous pact, putting out the right eye of each; Saul, coming in from the fields behind his oxen, raises in a single night an army from all Israel, cuts the besiegers to pieces "until the heat of the day", and it is in the joy of deliverance that the whole people proclaims the kingship at Gilgal[16]. The shepherd turned war leader has won his crown: Samuel then delivers his farewell as judge and promises to go on praying for the people, "far be it from me to sin against the Lord by ceasing to pray for you"[17].

The wars of the reign: Michmash, the ban and the frontiers

Saul's reign is above all a long war of liberation against the Philistines, who then held the land through a monopoly of iron: "there was no blacksmith to be found in all the land of Israel", so much so that the Hebrews go down to the enemy to have their ploughshares and mattocks sharpened[18]. At Michmash, it is Jonathan, the king's son, who forces the decision with only his armour-bearer, climbing the rock barehanded: "nothing can hinder the Lord from saving by many or by few", and panic spreads through the Philistine camp[19]. Saul, for his part, spoils the pursuit with a solemn ban, forbidding the troops to eat before evening on pain of a curse: Jonathan, unaware of the vow, tastes a little honey, and the king, prisoner of his own word, wants to put him to death; the people intervene and ransom the prince[20].

The book then sums up the campaigns in a single sentence of military chronicle: relentless war against the Philistines all the days of his life, blows against Moab, Ammon, Edom, Zobah and Amalek, with Ner's son Abner as commander of the army[21]. The portrait of power is completed: a travelling court with no built capital, a king holding court under the tamarisk at Gibeah, spear in hand, surrounded by his Benjaminite servants[22]. No palace and no administration: Saul's kingship remains a chieftainship of holy war, which explains its fragility as soon as holy war demands obedience rather than courage.

Two acts of disobedience, and the kingdom torn away

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

But Saul, twice, forces God's hand. At Gilgal, before an army that is scattering and a Samuel who is late on the appointed day, he himself offers the burnt offering reserved for the prophet: he has scarcely finished when Samuel arrives and declares that his kingship "shall not continue", for the Lord "has sought out a man after his own heart"[23]. Against Amalek, entrusted with the total ban, the herem that vows men and beasts to the Lord without share, he spares King Agag and the best of the spoil "under pretext of sacrifice": Samuel, after a night of lament before the Lord, announces to him the definitive rejection[24].

"Has the Lord as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the Lord? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams."

  • Samuel to Saul, First Book of Samuel 15:22, liturgical translation[25]

Samuel's cloak, seized and torn in the quarrel, becomes the parable of the kingdom torn away, and the prophet himself executes Agag at Gilgal before withdrawing to Ramah: "Samuel did not see Saul again until the day of his death", while mourning him[26]. Between the two faults, the difference is of degree but not of nature: at Gilgal, Saul invokes military necessity; against Amalek, the piety of sacrifice. In both cases he prefers his own reading of the situation to the order received, and it is this preference, not the material scale of the gestures, that the book calls rebellion[27].

The evil spirit and the young lyre player

"The Spirit of the Lord had departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the Lord tormented him": the sentence, which shocks hasty readers, says in the language of the time that God hands the rejected king over to the sadness of his abandonment[28]. The servants propose a remedy from court: a lyre player whose music will soothe the attacks. The youngest son of Jesse is brought in, David, a shepherd from Bethlehem, "skilful in playing, a man of valour, a man of war, prudent in speech, and a man of good presence"; Saul "loved him greatly", made him his armour-bearer, and "whenever the evil spirit came upon Saul, David would take the lyre and Saul was relieved"[29].

The scene, which painters would return to again and again, already contains the whole drama: the comforter is the secret elect who will replace the one comforted, and the king loves in David the remedy without seeing the successor[30]. The anointing at Bethlehem, received by David "in the midst of his brothers" while the spirit of the Lord "rushed upon him", belongs to the file of David and Samuel: it is not repeated here; we retain only that the two kings now coexist, one keeping the throne without the spirit, the other bearing the spirit without the throne[31].

Jealousy and the long persecution

Everything changes on the return from victory over the Philistines, when the women, dancing out to meet the troops, exchange a refrain: the king counts his thousands there, and the young commander his tens of thousands[32].

"Saul has slain his thousands, and David his tens of thousands."

  • The refrain of the women of Israel, First Book of Samuel 18:7, liturgical translation[33]

"Saul was very angry, for the refrain displeased him": the very next day, the evil spirit seized him in a full delirium in the middle of the house, and twice he hurled his spear at David as he played, "I will pin him to the wall", and twice David dodged aside[34]. Then comes the machinery of the persecution: poisoned marriage promises with Merab and then Michal, exacted at the price of a hundred Philistine foreskins, a public command to kill David, and the nighttime escape through the window, Michal covering the retreat with the teraphim in the bed[35]. The beloved son-in-law has become the man to be brought down, and the king's house is divided: Michal saves David, Jonathan warns him, and Saul kills the priests of Nob who had fed him, eighty-five men wearing the ephod, slaughtered by Doeg the Edomite together with their families and their town[36].

Twice, however, David spares the persecutor delivered into his hands, and twice Saul weeps and confesses: in the cave of En-Gedi, David cuts off only the corner of the royal cloak, then brandishes it as proof; on the hill of Hachilah, he carries off the spear and the water jar planted near the sleeping head[37]. The pursuer's response is the book's lesson on the anointed of the Lord, even if rejected:

"Do not kill him! Who could go unpunished after laying a hand on the one who has received the anointing of the Lord?"

  • David to Abishai, First Book of Samuel 26:9, liturgical translation[38]

And David adds, in the night of Hachilah, the golden rule of judgment upon kingship: "The Lord will repay each man according to his justice and his faithfulness", confessing that the Lord had delivered Saul into his hands and that he refused to "lay a hand on the Lord's anointed"[39]. The word is out: Saul, even rejected, remains the messiah, the anointed, and it is on this account that David will later forbid striking the Amalekite who boasts of having finished him off[40].

Jonathan, the friend who steps aside

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

At the heart of the persecution shines the most famous friendship of the Old Testament: "Jonathan became attached to David with all his soul, and he loved him as himself"[41]. The crown prince strips off his insignia for the elect one, "his cloak, his garments, his sword, his bow and his belt", abdicating in advance the succession his father fights so fiercely to defend[42]. Twice Jonathan intercedes and obtains reconciliation; twice Saul, calmed one day, resumes the hunt the next, even hurling his own spear at his son who defends David at the new-moon table[43].

"As soon as David had finished speaking to Saul, Jonathan became attached to David with all his soul, and he loved him as himself."

  • First Book of Samuel 18:1, liturgical translation[44]

The last meeting of the two friends, in the wood of Horesh, is a farewell: Jonathan strengthens David in God and makes him swear an alliance "before the Lord", himself prophesying the outcome: "you will reign over Israel, and I will be your second"[45]. The legitimate heir acknowledges the divine elect and steps aside: in Jonathan, the house of Saul yields its finest fruit, and it is this fruit that David will mourn along with the father.

En-Dor and Mount Gilboa

On the eve of the decisive battle, God no answers "neither by dreams, nor by the Urim, nor by the prophets", and Saul, who had himself banished the mediums from the land, disguises himself to consult at En-Dor a woman who raises the dead[46]. What rises, Samuel recognizable by his cloak, announces to the king his death and that of his sons for the morrow, and the defeat of Israel: the judge's last prophecy is posthumous, and Ben Sira retained it as his seal: "Even after falling asleep, he prophesied again"[47]. The Fathers debated the identity of the apparition, Augustine wondering whether it was really the soul of Samuel or a spirit that had taken on his likeness, proof that the Church has never read the passage with her eyes closed; but the text itself does not doubt: it is Samuel who speaks and who prophesies[48].

The next day, on Gilboa, Jonathan, Abinadab and Malkishua fall, the archers grievously wound Saul, who asks his armour-bearer to finish him off rather than fall alive into the hands of the uncircumcised; before the horrified refusal, "Saul took his sword and fell upon it", and the armour-bearer did the same[49]. The Philistines expose the bodies on the walls of Beth-Shan, but the men of Jabesh, remembering the deliverance of old, march all night, take down the bodies, burn them and bury the bones under the tamarisk of Jabesh, fasting seven days[50]. Years later, David will have these bones transferred, together with those of Jonathan, to the tomb of Kish at Zela, in Benjamin, reconciling in the fathers' land the fallen house and the reigning house[51].

And David composed the lament of the bow, taught to the sons of Judah, whose verses open the Second Book of Samuel and have not fallen silent for three thousand years:

"Your pride, O Israel, lies slain upon your heights! How the mighty have fallen! Saul and Jonathan, beloved, full of charm, in life and in death they were not divided, swifter than eagles, stronger than lions. Daughters of Israel, weep for Saul: he clothed you in luxurious purple and adorned your garments with golden jewels."

  • Lament of David, Second Book of Samuel 1:19-24, liturgical translation[52]

The received chronology: forty years in the eleventh century

Paul's figure: Saul king for forty years

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The New Testament settles a question that the Hebrew leaves open: at Antioch in Pisidia, Paul sums up "Saul, son of Qish, a man of the tribe of Benjamin, for forty years," then the election of David after his rejection[53]. This figure of forty years, the length of a generation, sets the reign within the rhythm of salvation history: forty years in the desert with Moses, forty years of David, forty years of Solomon, as though every foundation required the same span of time[54].

Biblical milestonePassageChronological scope
Exodus from Egypt and the founding of the Temple1 Kgs 6, 1480 years between the Exodus (c. 1446) and Solomon (c. 966)
Period of the judgesActs 13, 20About 450 years of judges up to the prophet Samuel
Reign of SaulActs 13, 21Saul king for forty years, c. 1050–1010 BC
Accession of David2 Sam 5, 4David king at thirty, seven years in Hebron then thirty-three in Jerusalem
Life of Saul1 Sam 9 to 31Anointed as a young man, died in battle: c. 1080–1010 BC

This framework places the anointing of Saul around 1050, at the close of the period of the judges embodied by Samuel, and his death at Gilboa around 1010, at the opening of the tenth century and the reign of David[55]. The dates remain approximate, as with Gideon or Samson, and the article gives them as such: "c. 1080–1010," without the false precision of invented years[56].

The damaged verse: 1 Sam 13, 1 and the lost numbers

The Masoretic Hebrew opens chapter 13 with a manifestly mutilated sentence: "Saul was ... years old when he became king, and he reigned ... and two years over Israel," with two numbers dropped in the copying[57]. The Greek Septuagint, for its part, simply omits the sentence — a sign that its Alexandrian translators were already working from an embarrassed text[58]. Far from undermining the chronology, the accident confirms it by ricochet: it is because the figure from Acts, forty years, was already circulating as the received figure that the scribes left the blank rather than invent one, and that the Church kept the lesson of the apostles[59]. The detail of the textual dossier is taken up in the debate section at the end of the article.

The ancient witnesses of the account

The Hebrew text, the Septuagint, and the Qumran manuscripts

The dossier of Saul benefits from the same three great witnesses as the whole book: the Hebrew Masoretic text, the Greek Septuagint translated at Alexandria in the third and second centuries BC, and the Dead Sea Scrolls[60]. The caves of Qumran yielded three scrolls of Samuel, one of them, dated to the third century BC, ranking among the oldest biblical manuscripts preserved: the episodes of Saul were therefore already circulating, substantially fixed, centuries before our era[61].

WitnessApproximate dateContribution for Saul
Masoretic textFixed by the Masoretes, 1st millennium ADReceived Hebrew text, with its blank in 1 Sam 13, 1
Septuagint (Reigns I)Alexandria, 3rd–2nd c. BCGreek translation of a sometimes older Hebrew
4QSam (Qumran)3rd–1st c. BCHebrew fragments five centuries older than the Masoretes
Vulgate (1 Samuel)Bethlehem, late 4th c. ADLatin translation by Jerome from the Hebrew

Comparing the witnesses illuminates the dossier instead of dissolving it: where the Masoretic text gives Goliath six cubits, the Septuagint and Qumran read four, but the confrontation itself is attested by all without exception, and the duel belongs to the history of David as much as to the reign of Saul[62]. In other words, textual criticism debates the measurements, never the existence of the dossier.

Josephus, the Chronicles, and the New Testament

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In the first century AD, Flavius Josephus paraphrases the history of Saul at length in Book VI of his Jewish Antiquities, in the received order and treating it as nothing other than national history: the donkeys, Mizpah, Jabesh, Amalek, the medium, and Gilboa — everything is there[63]. The Chronicler, three centuries earlier in the received chronology, had already re-read the king's death as a theologian: "Thus Saul died for his infidelity to the LORD: he had not kept the word of the LORD, he had even consulted the necromancer and consulted her. He had not consulted the LORD, who put him to death and transferred the kingship to David, son of Jesse"[64].

"Thus Saul died for his infidelity to the LORD: he had not kept the word of the LORD, he had even consulted the necromancer and consulted her."

  • First book of Chronicles 10, 13, liturgical translation[65]

The New Testament, as we have seen, makes Saul a chronological marker (Acts 13, 21) and the foil of David (Acts 13, 22)[66]. It is concerning the books of Samuel and Kings that Jerome, around 391–392, places his famous so-called "helmeted" preface, the Prologus Galeatus, in which he enumerates the twenty-two books of the Hebrew Bible; the Council of Trent, in 1546, will confirm the Catholic canon of forty-six books of the Old Testament, including the two books of Samuel in the received form[67]. The chain is thus unbroken: Qumran, Septuagint, Chronicles, New Testament, Josephus, Jerome, liturgy, magisterium — no link suspects a late fabrication[68].

Archaeology: Gibeah, Beth-Shan, and honest silences

Tell el-Ful in 1931. Matson Collection, Library of Congress / Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The text places Saul's court at Gibeah of Benjamin, the hill where the king sits beneath the tamarisk, and the proposed identification with Tell el-Ful, a few kilometres north of Jerusalem, remains the most serious: the American William Albright excavated there in 1922 and 1923, then Paul Lapp in 1964, and recognised a fortress of about 1000 BC, compatible with a chieftain of Saul's time[69]. The identification is debated, as is all biblical topography, but it is not a begging of the question: a power without a palace, seated on a fortified height in the heart of Benjamin, leaves exactly the kind of modest traces found there[70].

Site in the accountProposed identificationState of the dossier
Gibeah of SaulTell el-Ful, north of JerusalemFortress c. 1000 BC (Albright 1922–1923, Lapp 1964)
Beth-ShanTell el-Hosn, at the mouth of the Jezreel ValleyConfirmed Canaanite then Philistine city, possible display walls
Jabesh in GileadPresumed Tell el-Maqlub, east of the JordanTopographical hypothesis, limited excavations
EndorKhirbet Safsafeh, north of GilboaTraditional identification, without decisive proof
Mount GilboaJebel Fuquah, south of the Jezreel ValleyUndisputed geographical setting of the battle

Honesty compels one to add the rest: no extrabiblical inscription known to date names Saul, whereas the Aramaic stele from Tel Dan, from the following century, already names the "house of David"[71]. But the argument from silence carries little weight here: a chieftain-level reign without a chancellery, without stelae, and without stone palaces, in a hill country at the turn of the Iron Age, is not the kind of power that carves its name into the basalt of its neighbours[72]. The debated fortresses of the early tenth century, such as Qeiyafa in the Valley of Elah, illuminate the emerging world of David rather than the waning one of Saul, and the article does not make them say what they do not say[73].

Saul's theology: the anointed one judged

Obedience is better than sacrifice

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The sentence pronounced upon Saul after the Amalek affair has become one of the most quoted verses of the Old Testament, taken up by the prophets, the psalms, and the Fathers: worship without obedience is an empty shell[74]. Saul is not condemned for having lacked religion; he had too much of it in his own way: at Gilgal he sacrifices, against Amalek he keeps the spoil "to sacrifice to the Lord", and it is this managerial piety, which uses God instead of listening to him, that Samuel strikes[75]. Hosea will say "it is love I desire, not sacrifice", and Christ will seal the lesson by applying it: mercy, not rites, is the heart of the Law[76].

"Does the Lord delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as much as in obedience to his word? Yes, obedience is better than sacrifice, docility better than the fat of rams."

  • Samuel to Saul, first book of Samuel 15:22, liturgical translation[77]

The missed repentance: justifying oneself instead of confessing

Everything sets the two fallen kings apart, and comparing them is the very subject of the book: rebuked by the prophet, David will say "I have sinned against the Lord", whereas Saul, rebuked in the same way, will answer "I have sinned" and then immediately add "but honour me before the elders", pleading that it was the people who spared the spoil[78]. The table below sets out the contrast, which grounds the entire theology of kingship in the book.

Rebuked by the prophetSaul (1 Sam 13 and 15)David (2 Sam 12)
First words"I have sinned", followed by justification"I have sinned against the Lord", without reserve
The one held guiltyThe people kept the spoil; necessity pressedHimself, without transferring the blame
What is askedTo be honoured before the eldersNothing, save to undergo the punishment
The outcomeThe kingdom torn awayForgiveness given, the child struck

Saul is therefore not damned for a fault heavier than David's: adultery and murder weigh more than the untimely sacrifice and the spoil kept back. He is rejected for the manner of falling: the king who justifies himself cannot be raised up, for he leaves no room for forgiveness, whereas the king who confesses opens the space in which the dynastic promise can pass[79]. Such is the severity and the mercy of the book: God "sought for himself a man after his own heart", not a sinless man[80].

Fear of men, root of disobedience

The book itself gives the psychological key to the first king, and there is nothing pathological about it: "I feared the people and I listened to them", Saul confesses at Gilgal as at Amalek, and Samuel reminds him that he was "little in his own eyes" when God chose him[81]. The giant hiding among the baggage never stopped trembling: before the army scattering in rout, before the people wanting spoil, before the women's song preferring David, before the next day's battle[82]. The book's political theology is terrifyingly clear: Israel wanted a king "like the nations"; God allowed it with a warning, and the anointed king remains a judged servant, not an absolute sovereign; Saul learns to his cost that one cannot force God's hand, whether by offering the reserved sacrifice oneself or by keeping the forbidden spoil under cover of piety[83].

Fulfillment in Christ

The man after God's heart and the promised kingship

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The verdict that founds the dynasty, "the Lord has sought for himself a man after his own heart," is pronounced by Samuel upon Saul (1 Sam 13:14), and Paul will take it up again at Antioch, applying it to David over against the rejected Saul[84]. The apostle's words make Saul the dark background against which the chosen one shines: "After removing him, God raised up David as king for them, and he bore him this testimony: I have found David, son of Jesse; he is a man after my heart who will do all my will"[85].

"Then they asked for a king, and God gave them Saul, the son of Kish, a man of the tribe of Benjamin, for forty years. After removing him, God raised up David as king for them."

  • Paul at Antioch in Pisidia, Acts of the Apostles 13:21-22, liturgical translation[86]

The covenant subsequently promised to David — a house established and a throne made sure forever — belongs to the dossier of the books of Samuel and to the article David: that dossier is not duplicated here; the essential point is retained: it is from the rejection of Saul that there proceeds, by contrast, the lineage that will lead to Joseph of Nazareth[87]. The first king shows what fleshly kingship cannot do: endure without obeying. The second will show what it can do: fall and rise again.

The spared anointed one, figure of the persecuted Christ

David, hunted down, sparing his persecutor and mourning his death, is read by the Christian tradition as a figure of Christ: innocent and pursued, gentle in the face of violence, refusing to seize power through murder[88]. The rule he imposes on himself in the night of Hachilah — not to raise one's hand against the Lord's anointed — foreshadows the One who will let himself be bound without calling upon the legions, and the lament of Gilboa, where the victor weeps for the vanquished, foreshadows the One who will weep over Jerusalem as it rejects him[89]. In this sense, Saul himself, persecutor turned into an object of tears, belongs to the economy of salvation: he gave the king after God's own heart the occasion to show his heart[90].

Saul of Tarsus, the Benjaminite persecutor become apostle

The most beautiful turn of the name Saul comes in the New Testament: the persecutor of the Church is called Saul, he is "of the tribe of Benjamin," and it is under this name that he arrests and hands over the disciples before the Risen One strikes him down on the road to Damascus[91]. Preachers have often noted the symmetry: two Benjaminites named Shaoul, the "asked for," two persecutors — one who pursues David the anointed, the other who pursues Christ in his members — but where the first sinks deeper into self-justification, the second falls to the ground and asks, "What shall I do, Lord?"[92]. The parallel is not a dogma; it is a meditation of the Church on names: God sometimes takes up the same given names in order to write the opposite of the same stories, and the rejected king becomes, through his namesake, the apostle to the nations.

Saul in the liturgical life of the Church

The lectionary: Saul at the beginning of Ordinary Time

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Every year, in the first weeks of Ordinary Time, the lectionary of the Mass lets the anointing of Saul, his wars, and then his rejection be heard: January is, for the faithful assiduous at daily Mass, the month of the first king as much as that of the prophet who anointed him[93]. The night at En-dor, however, is never proclaimed at the ambo: the Church lets the lessons of the reign be heard, not the forbidden consultation, and leaves the king's end to private reading[94].

Neither feast nor relics: the sobriety of the Church

Unlike Samuel, celebrated in the East on August 20 and commemorated in the Roman Martyrology, Saul has neither a feast on the calendar nor praise in the Martyrology: the Church honors the saints, not rejected kings, and the sobriety here is itself a teaching[95]. She does not curse him either: David mourned Saul, the Chronicler judged him without insulting him, and the translation of his bones to Jabesh-gilead by David speaks of the piety owed to the dead even amid judgment[96]. The pilgrim therefore venerates no tomb of Saul: he rereads his story at Gibeah, at Gilboa, and at Jabesh — three sites of memory rather than a place of worship[97].

Saul outside the Bible: Judaism, Islam and the arts

Judaism: the faultless king who became a fault

Rabbinic tradition, which makes Samuel the author of his book completed by Gad and Nathan, reads Saul with a severity mingled with tenderness: Rashi, commenting on the damaged verse of chapter 13, understands that Saul ascended the throne "like a one-year-old child", without sin, and that his fault was all the more serious for having started from so high[98]. The Midrash counts his lost qualities, the modesty of his baggage, the restraint shown towards the "sons of Belial" who despise him at Mispah and whom he refuses to punish after Jabesh, and sees in this the proof that greatness received without obedience kept turns against the one who bears it[99]. Every daily office thus bears, without knowing it, the trace of the mother of Samuel and of the king he anointed: the prayer of Hannah and the reign of Saul frame the same lesson, everything comes from God and everything is lost without listening[100].

Islam: Talut, the Saul of the Qur'an

The Qur'an never names Saul, but it tells his story: after Moses, the notables of Israel ask "their prophet" to raise up for them a king to fight in the path of God; the prophet points them to Talut, disputed for his poverty then confirmed by the sign of the ark; Talut tests his army at the stream, and the young Dawud (David) strikes down Jalut (Goliath)[101]. The plot plainly follows chapters 8 to 17 of the first book of Samuel, and the great Muslim commentators, at-Tabari and then Ibn Kathir, explicitly identify Talut with Saul and the anonymous prophet with Samuel[102]. The disagreement concerns the meaning, not the facts: where the Bible makes the requested king a first rejection of God, pardoned and then raised up again in David, the Qur'an reads in it a test of military obedience, and the Muslim tradition ignores the Davidic anointing as a covenant[103].

The arts: Handel, Rembrandt and French tragedy

Rembrandt, Saul and David, c. 1651-1658. Mauritshuis / Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The end of Saul struck the imagination more than any other fall of the book: Handel made an entire oratorio of it, Saul (1739), to a libretto by Charles Jennens drawn from the biblical text, whose Act III culminates with the witch of En-Dor raising the prophet's shade before the condemned king[104]. Painters, for their part, preferred the two scenes of the soul: David playing the lyre before the tormented king, a favourite subject of which the Saul and David of the Mauritshuis in The Hague, attributed to Rembrandt and dated c. 1651-1658, remains the summit, and the jealousy of the throne, Rembrandt, Guercino and their emulators multiplying the Sauls with raised spear[105]. Classical France gave the subject its biblical tragedy: David and Jonathan by Marc-Antoine Charpentier (1688), composed for the Louis-le-Grand college, makes the friendship of the two young men the heart of a school opera turned masterpiece, and twentieth-century biblical cinema has often shown Saul as a tormented silhouette, the sick conscience of power[106].

The historical-critical debate: what modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

The Deuteronomistic hypothesis applied to Saul

Since Martin Noth and his studies on the history of traditions (1943), a large part of contemporary exegesis places the chapters of Saul within a great "Deuteronomistic history" written in the exilic period, which would reread the monarchical past in the light of Deuteronomy so as to explain the catastrophe of 587[107]. Applied to Saul, the thesis identifies two accounts of accession judged incompatible: one favourable to monarchy, the private anointing followed by the victory at Jabesh, the other hostile, Samuel's speech against the requested king, and concludes that there were rival sources stitched together by a late editor[108]. Presented fairly, the reconstruction offers subtle readings of the composition: it identifies the seams, the resumptions, the successive pastoral perspectives[109].

But its status must be stated plainly: these are hypotheses about lost documents, of which no manuscript exists, whose boundaries vary from school to school, and whose datings often rest on the postulate that every precise narrative of the past is a late projection[110]. The present article sets them out without caricaturing them, then shows why the traditional dating and attribution remain defensible: not out of ignorance of criticism, but after having weighed it[111].

A single accession in three stages, not two enemy sources

The most common objection concerns the accession: Saul becomes king by the secret anointing in chapter 10, then by lot at Mispah, then by acclamation at Gilgal after Jabesh, and Samuel seems alternately to install the king and to denounce monarchy[112]. For a part of exegesis, these are rival traditions clumsily stitched together, proof of a late compilation[113].

Alleged sequenceCommon critical readingTraditional reading's reply
Secret anointing then public lot (1 Sam 10)Two rival legitimationsPrivate designation then public proclamation: two stages of a single divine choice
Speech against the king (1 Sam 8 and 12) then anointing (1 Sam 11)Anti-monarchical source against pro-monarchical sourceLoyal warning before the anointing: God permits while warning, Samuel anoints while weeping
Jabesh then Gilgal (1 Sam 11)Duplicate confirmationMilitary victory then popular anointing: proof by arms before public right
Two rejections (1 Sam 13 and 15)Compiler's redundancyTwo distinct faults, warning then definitive sentence

The traditional rule of reading is that of complementarity rather than contradiction: the Bible willingly recounts in several stages what life brings about in several stages, and Chronicles confirms the method by citing three distinct prophetic sources for one and the same reign[114]. Let us add that the so-called duplicates often presuppose what they want to prove: the text is divided into sources according to stylistic criteria, these sources are dated according to a theory of religious development, and then the division is invoked as proof of the theory[115].

The figures: 1 Sam 13, 1 and the forty years

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

There remains the objection of numbers, the most honest in the whole dossier: if Saul reigned forty years according to Paul, why does the Hebrew of 1 Sam 13, 1 give no readable age or duration, when it carefully numbers the reigns of David and Solomon?[116]. The answer has three pieces: the Masoretic verse is visibly damaged, with two numbers dropped; the Septuagint omits the sentence, proof that the embarrassment predates our era by two centuries and is not an apologetic arrangement; and Acts provides the figure received from first-century Jewish tradition, forty years, which Josephus follows in his paraphrase[117]. A localized copy corruption, admitted by the witnesses themselves, does not prove an overall invention: it proves a transmission that prefers a blank to a falsehood, and that is a guarantee rather than a suspicion[118].

Archaeology and the ghost of the "great kingdom"

A great deal of contemporary scholarship proposes to reduce the tenth-century monarchy to a colourless village chieftainship and to relegate the stories of Saul, David and Solomon to the workshops of a much later age[119]. The argument mixes one fact, the meagreness of the tenth-century remains in the hills, with one presupposition, the idea that power without a palace of stone is a power of legend[120]. But the book of Samuel describes no palace of Saul: it describes a king under a tamarisk, an itinerant court, an army of volunteers and a Philistine monopoly on iron — a picture exactly proportioned to what archaeology finds: modest fortresses, fortified villages, tightly controlled metallurgy[121]. To ask Tell el-Ful for the archives of Nineveh is to reproach the text with a splendour it never claims: the critic confuses here the absence of what the narrative does not promise with proof of its falsehood[122].

Why the traditional reading remains defensible

Let us gather the pieces: an ancient and precise attribution (Samuel, Gad and Nathan, Baba Batra, Chronicles), an internal gloss that admits the narrative's antiquity (the seer of chapter 9), manuscripts five centuries older than the Masoretes (Qumran), a Greek translation of the third century presupposing a Hebrew already fixed, witnesses who cite the dossier as Scripture (Chronicles, Paul), a historical paraphrase in the first century (Josephus), and an ecclesial reception without any break in continuity[123]. Faced with this body of evidence, late reconstructions offer literary possibilities, never proofs: no manuscript of their supposed sources, no trace of a fraud, no community that would have accepted as Moses a book fabricated under the Persians[124]. As the Second Vatican Council recalls, Scripture "teaches solidly, faithfully and without error the truth which God wanted put into the sacred writings" for the sake of salvation: faith in inerrancy does not forbid criticism of the copies, it forbids making the text say the opposite of what it affirms[125].

To go further

  • The books of Samuel: the companion article on the two books, their structure, their text and their overall theology
  • Samuel, the prophet who made and unmade Saul's reign, from the anointing to Endor
  • David, the shepherd of Bethlehem secretly anointed, persecuted then mourned by his persecutor
  • Moses, the liberator and mediator of the Covenant, whose obedience Saul should have followed
  • Aaron, brother and spokesman of Moses, first high priest
  • Joshua, who led Israel into Canaan before the time of the judges
  • Gideon, judge raised up against Midian, whose holy war Saul prolongs
  • Samson, the Nazirite whose strength judged the Philistines before the king's armies
  • Elijah, the prophet of Carmel, heir to Samuel's mantle
  • Abraham, the father of believers, whose promise will be fulfilled in the Davidic monarchy

Notes and References

  1. 1 Sam 8:1 (the request for a king) to 1 Sam 31:13 (the bones buried at Jabesh): the entire dossier of the first king lies between these bounds.

    1
  2. 2 Sam 1:17-27: the lament of the bow opens the second book and closes the dossier of Saul through the mouth of his successor.

    2
  3. In Hebrew, Shemouel forms a single book among the Former Prophets; Septuagint: Basileiôn I (Kingdoms); Vulgate: Samuhelis I.

    3
  4. The article books of Samuel deals with the structure of the two books, textual criticism and the Davidic covenant: this dossier is not duplicated here.

    4
  5. 1 Chr 8:33 and 9:39 (genealogy); the title of Ps 59 (the order of 1 Sam 19:11); Acts 13:21 (the forty years): three archival usages, all precise.

    5
  6. Acts 13:21-22: Saul named for his rejection, David named for his heart, in two verses that summarise the whole theology of the book.

    6
  7. 1 Sam 9:1: Kish, son of Abiel, a Benjaminite, "a man of substance"; 1 Sam 9:2: Saul, "young and handsome", taller than all the people.

    7
  8. 1 Sam 9:21: "Am I not a Benjaminite, of the smallest tribe of Israel, and is not my clan the least?" (paraphrase of Saul's protest).

    8
  9. 1 Sam 9:2, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the opening portrait, the beauty and stature of the first king.

    9
  10. 1 Sam 9:3-5: the lost donkeys, the crossing of Ephraim, Shalisha, Shaalim and Benjamin, and the father's concern before the beasts.

    10
  11. 1 Sam 9:7-8: no more bread in the sacks, the servant's quarter-shekel of silver, in an economy still without coined money.

    11
  12. 1 Sam 9:9: "the one who is called a prophet today, was then called a seer" (paraphrase of the narrator's gloss).

    12
  13. 1 Sam 9:15-17, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word for vv. 16-17): the divine warning to Samuel and the designation.

    13
  14. 1 Sam 10:1 (the vial of oil and the kiss); 1 Sam 10:20-24 (the lot and Saul hidden among the baggage).

    14
  15. 1 Sam 10:24, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the election acknowledged and the people's ovation.

    15
  16. 1 Sam 11:1-2 (the right eye demanded); 1 Sam 11:6-11 (the muster and the victory); 1 Sam 11:14-15 (the kingship proclaimed at Gilgal).

    16
  17. 1 Sam 12:23, liturgical translation (AELF, according to the received text): "Far be it from me to sin against the Lord by ceasing to pray for you."

    17
  18. 1 Sam 13:19-22: not a blacksmith in Israel, ploughshares sharpened among the Philistines, and six hundred men without a sword around Saul.

    18
  19. 1 Sam 14:6: "nothing keeps the Lord from giving the victory, whether we are many or few" (paraphrase of Jonathan's word); 1 Sam 14:13-15 (the rout and the panic).

    19
  20. 1 Sam 14:24 (the solemn ban); 1 Sam 14:27 (the honey tasted in ignorance); 1 Sam 14:43-45 (the people ransom Jonathan).

    20
  21. 1 Sam 14:47-48 (Moab, Ammon, Edom, Zobah, Amalek) and 1 Sam 14:50-51 (Abner, son of Ner, commander of the army, and Kish brother of Ner).

    21
  22. 1 Sam 22:6: Saul "was sitting at Gibeah, under the tamarisk", spear in hand, surrounded by his servants.

    22
  23. 1 Sam 13:8-14: the seven days, the army scattering, the burnt offering offered without waiting, and the sentence on the kingship.

    23
  24. 1 Sam 15:1-9 (the order of the ban and the sparing of Agag); 1 Sam 15:10-23 (the night of lament and the sentence).

    24
  25. 1 Sam 15:22, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): obedience and docility against burnt offerings.

    25
  26. 1 Sam 15:27-28 (the torn corner, parable of the kingdom); 1 Sam 15:32-33 (Samuel executes Agag); 1 Sam 15:35 (the prophet's mourning).

    26
  27. 1 Sam 13:11-12 (the necessity invoked); 1 Sam 15:20-21 (the people and the sacrifice invoked): two excuses, a single refusal to listen.

    27
  28. 1 Sam 16:14: the spirit of the Lord withdrawn and the evil spirit "from the Lord"; the language of the time for abandonment to the sorrow of rejection.

    28
  29. 1 Sam 16:18 (the portrait of the young player); 1 Sam 16:21-23 (Saul's love, the armour-bearer's service, the soothing by the lyre).

    29
  30. The comforter is the secret chosen one: the drama lies in the king's ignorance, who loves the remedy and does not know the successor.

    30
  31. 1 Sam 16:13 (the spirit upon David) against 1 Sam 16:14 (the spirit withdrawn from Saul): two consecutive verses that ground the coexistence.

    31
  32. 1 Sam 18:6-7: the women coming out to meet the troops, dances and tambourines, and the refrain that wounds the king.

    32
  33. 1 Sam 18:7, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): Saul's thousands against David's tens of thousands.

    33
  34. 1 Sam 18:10-11 (the first spear, "I will pin him to the wall"); 1 Sam 19:9-10 (the second, David dodges and flees).

    34
  35. 1 Sam 18:17-27 (Merab, Michal and the hundred foreskins); 1 Sam 19:11-17 (the escape through the window and the teraphim).

    35
  36. 1 Sam 22:9-19: Doeg's denunciation, the eighty-five priests with the ephod, the city struck down with women, children and livestock.

    36
  37. 1 Sam 24:4-8 (the corner of the cloak at En-gedi); 1 Sam 26:7-12 (the spear and the jar at Hachilah).

    37
  38. 1 Sam 26:9, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the prohibition to lay a hand on the Lord's anointed.

    38
  39. 1 Sam 26:23, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word in substance): "I would not lay a hand on the Lord's anointed."

    39
  40. 2 Sam 1, 14-16: David has the messenger executed who boasts of having finished off the Lord's anointed.

    40
  41. 1 Sam 18, 1-3: the covenant, love as oneself, before Samuel and Saul still present.

    41
  42. 1 Sam 18, 4: the cloak, the garments, the sword, the bow, and the belt given to David, abdication by the insignia.

    42
  43. 1 Sam 19, 4-6 and 1 Sam 20 (the two intercessions); 1 Sam 20, 30-34 (the father's spear against his son at the new-moon table).

    43
  44. 1 Sam 18, 1, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the bond of souls, the source of friendship.

    44
  45. 1 Sam 23, 16-18: Jonathan strengthens David at Horesh, "you will reign, I will be your second," a covenant before the Lord.

    45
  46. 1 Sam 28, 3-7: the silence of God (dreams, Urim, prophets), the disguise, and the recourse to the woman of Endor.

    46
  47. Sir 46, 20, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): "Even after falling asleep, he prophesied again."

    47
  48. Augustine, On the Care for the Dead (De cura pro mortuis gerenda), ch. 15-18: doubt as to the identity of the apparition.

    48
  49. 1 Sam 31, 1-6: the death of Jonathan, Abinadab, and Malchi-shua, the archers, the king's sword and that of his armor-bearer.

    49
  50. 1 Sam 31, 11-13: the night march of the valiant men of Jabesh, the bodies taken down from Beth-shan, the seven-day fast.

    50
  51. 2 Sam 21, 12-14: David transfers the bones of Saul and Jonathan to the tomb of Kish, at Zela in Benjamin.

    51
  52. 2 Sam 1, 19-24, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the lament of the bow, taught to the sons of Judah.

    52
  53. Acts 13, 21, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): "Saul, son of Kish, a man of the tribe of Benjamin, for forty years."

    53
  54. Forty years in the desert (Num 14, 33-34), forty years of David (2 Sam 5, 4), forty years of Solomon (1 Kgs 11, 42): the measure of foundations.

    54
  55. Anointed around 1050 as the time of the judges ended, dead around 1010 at the opening of David's reign: an accepted range, without artificial precision.

    55
  56. As with Gideon or Samson, the title reads "c. 1080–1010": the acknowledged approximation is better than false exactitude.

    56
  57. 1 Sam 13, 1 Masoretic: "Saul was ... years old ... and he reigned ... and two years," two numbers lost in copying.

    57
  58. The Septuagint omits the numbered phrase of 1 Sam 13, 1: the textual difficulty predates our era by two centuries.

    58
  59. Scribes who leave the gap rather than invent a figure bear witness to faithful transmission, not to fraud.

    59
  60. Masoretic, Septuagint, and Qumran: three independent lines of transmission that allow the variants to be checked rather than merely endured.

    60
  61. 4QSam^a, 4QSam^b, and 4QSam^c (3rd–1st c. BC): the episodes of Saul were already circulating, substantially fixed, centuries before our era.

    61
  62. 1 Sam 17, 4: six cubits and a span (MT) against four cubits and a span (LXX and 4QSam^a); the duel is unanimously attested.

    62
  63. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, book VI: a continuous paraphrase from the donkeys to Gilboa, treated as national history.

    63
  64. 1 Chr 10, 13-14: the infidelity, the necromancer consulted instead of the Lord, and the kingship transferred to David.

    64
  65. 1 Chr 10, 13, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the Chronicler's theological judgment on the king's death.

    65
  66. Acts 13, 21 (the forty years); Acts 13, 22 (the rejection and the man after his heart): chronology and theology in two verses.

    66
  67. Jerome, Prologus Galeatus (preface to the books of Samuel and Kings, c. 391-392); Council of Trent, Fourth Session, 8 April 1546.

    67
  68. Qumran, Septuagint, Chronicles, New Testament, Josephus, Jerome, liturgy, magisterium: the chain of witnesses knows no rupture.

    68
  69. W. F. Albright, excavations of 1922-1923, then P. W. Lapp in 1964: a fortress of about 1000 BC on the hill identified with Gibeah of Saul.

    69
  70. A power without a palace leaves modest traces: the fortress matches the textual portrait instead of contradicting it.

    70
  71. Aramaic stele of Tel Dan (9th c. BC): the "house of David" named in the following century, Saul absent from the known inscriptions.

    71
  72. A chieftaincy without chancery or stelae, at the turn of the Iron Age, is not the kind of power that carves its name among its neighbours.

    72
  73. Khirbet Qeiyafa in the Elah Valley, a debated fortress of the early 10th century: it illuminates the nascent David, one does not make it speak of Saul.

    73
  74. Hos 6, 6; Ps 40, 7-9; Isa 1, 11-17; Mic 6, 6-8: all prophecy takes up the sentence pronounced upon Saul.

    74
  75. 1 Sam 13, 12 ("I forced myself and offered"); 1 Sam 15, 21 ("the people spared, in order to sacrifice"): piety as an excuse.

    75
  76. Hos 6, 6 ("love, not sacrifices"); Mt 9, 13 and Mt 12, 7 (Christ quoting Hosea against the Pharisees).

    76
  77. The same verse as in the narrative section: the sentence deserves its place in theology as in history, so much does it structure the book.

    77
  78. 1 Sam 15, 24-30 (the "I have sinned" immediately justified and the honour requested) against 2 Sam 12, 13 (the "I have sinned against the Lord" without reservation).

    78
  79. Adultery and murder against an untimely sacrifice and the spared booty: David's fault weighs heavier, his confession lifts him up.

    79
  80. 1 Sam 13, 14: "a man after his heart," not a sinless man; Acts 13, 22 takes up the verdict for David.

    80
  81. 1 Sam 15, 24: "I feared the people and I listened to them" (paraphrase of the confession); 1 Sam 9, 21 and 10, 22 (the smallness of the beginnings).

    81
  82. 1 Sam 13, 11 (the army scattering); 1 Sam 15, 24 (the people and the spoil); 1 Sam 18, 8 (the women's song): the same trembling at every crisis.

    82
  83. 1 Sam 8, 7 (the rejection of God); 1 Sam 10, 25 (the "right of the kingship" recorded); 1 Sam 15 (the judgment of the king); Deut 17, 14-20 (the law of the king).

    83
  84. Acts 13, 22 takes up 1 Sam 13, 14 ("a man after my heart"): Paul knows the book right down to its verdicts.

    84
  85. Acts 13, 22, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word for the most part): the testimony borne to David after the rejection of Saul.

    85
  86. Acts 13, 21-22, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the forty years of Saul and the election of David in two verses.

    86
  87. 2 Sam 7 (the promise to David) and Mt 1 (the genealogy down to Joseph): from the rejection of Saul to the birth of Christ, the chain passes through contrast.

    87
  88. David innocent and pursued, gentle in the face of violence, refusing power through murder: the constant figurative reading of the Fathers.

    88
  89. 2 Sam 1, 24 (the daughters of Israel weeping for Saul); Lk 19, 41 (Jesus weeping over Jerusalem): the victor weeping over the rejection that rejects him.

    89
  90. Without a persecutor, no test of David's heart: Saul provides the elect with the occasion to show the obedience he himself refused.

    90
  91. Acts 13, 9 ("Saul, also called Paul"); Phil 3, 5 ("of the tribe of Benjamin"): the same name and the same blood as the first king.

    91
  92. Two Shaul persecutors, one sinking deeper into self-justification, the other asking "What shall I do, Lord?" (Acts 22, 10): a meditation, not a dogma.

    92
  93. Roman Lectionary, ferial days of Ordinary Time, first weeks: the first book of Samuel (anointing, wars, rejection) opens the liturgical year in Ordinary Time.

    93
  94. 1 Sam 28 is never proclaimed at the ambo: the Church teaches the king's end through the Chronicler (1 Chr 10), not through the medium.

    94
  95. The Roman Martyrology commemorates Samuel and ignores Saul: the Church honours the saints, not rejected kings.

    95
  96. 2 Sam 1 (the lament), 1 Chr 10 (the judgment without insult), 2 Sam 21, 12-14 (the burial): piety toward the dead even in the judgment.

    96
  97. Gibeah, Gilboa, Jabesh: three places of memory visited, no venerated tomb, no feast celebrated.

    97
  98. Rashi (d. 1105) on 1 Sam 13, 1: Saul ascended the throne "like a one-year-old child," without sin, whence the gravity of his fall.

    98
  99. The modesty of his baggage (1 Sam 10:22), the restraint before the mockers (1 Sam 10:27; 11:12-13): the lost qualities counted by the Midrash.

    99
  100. Hannah answered in prayer (1 Sam 1-2) and Saul rejected (1 Sam 13-15): the same lesson frames the book — everything comes from God, and everything is lost without listening.

    100
  101. Qur'an, surah 2, verses 246-251: the anonymous prophet, Talut, the ark as a sign, the trial of the stream, Dawud against Jalut.

    101
  102. At-Tabari (d. 923) and then Ibn Kathir (d. 1373) in their commentaries: Talut is Saul, and the prophet of surah 2 is Samuel.

    102
  103. The Muslim tradition retains the trial and the victory, not the anointing as covenant nor the rejection as a theology of kingship put on trial.

    103
  104. G. F. Handel, Saul, HWV 53 (1739), libretto by Charles Jennens after the first book of Samuel: an entire oratorio for the king's fall.

    104
  105. Saul and David, Mauritshuis, The Hague, c. 1651-1658 (two campaigns): the tormented king and the boy with the lyre, the high point of the subject in painting.

    105
  106. M.-A. Charpentier, David et Jonathas, H. 490 (1688), biblical tragedy for the Louis-le-Grand college: friendship at the heart of the masterpiece.

    106
  107. M. Noth, Überlieferungsgeschichtliche Studien, vol. I, Halle, Niemeyer, 1943: the Deuteronomistic history, from Deuteronomy to Kings, composed in the exile.

    107
  108. 1 Sam 8 and 12 (against) versus 1 Sam 9-11 (for): for part of exegesis, two incompatible accounts of the accession, stitched together late.

    108
  109. Identifying the seams and the perspectives: the descriptive contribution of literary criticism remains valuable for reading the composition.

    109
  110. Sources posited without manuscripts, shifting boundaries from one school to another, datings dependent on the premise: the status remains hypothetical.

    110
  111. Setting out modern theses honestly and then showing their limits: the article's Catholic method, following the Ignispedia compass.

    111
  112. 1 Sam 10:1 (anointing), 1 Sam 10:20-24 (lot), 1 Sam 11:14-15 (acclamation): three moments that criticism reads as three sources.

    112
  113. For part of exegesis, these resumptions betray competing traditions assembled late.

    113
  114. 1 Chr 29:29 (three sources for one reign): the biblical method itself admits several accounts of a single event without seeing contradiction in them.

    114
  115. Stylistic partition, dating by a theory of religious evolution, then proof from the partition: the circle must be named.

    115
  116. 2 Sam 5:4 and 1 Kings 11:42 number David and Solomon; only Saul's number is missing in 1 Sam 13:1: the asymmetry raises a question.

    116
  117. A faulty Masoretic text, a Septuagint in difficulty already at Alexandria, Acts and Josephus agreeing on forty years: three pieces for an answer.

    117
  118. The blank left rather than an invented number safeguards the transmission: one corrects copies, one does not manufacture kings.

    118
  119. For part of contemporary exegesis, the monarchy of the eleventh century amounts to a village chieftaincy and the narratives to late workshops.

    119
  120. One fact (the modesty of the remains) and one presupposition (without a stone palace, no history): the argument blends the two without saying so.

    120
  121. Tamaris, an itinerant court, volunteers, the iron monopoly: the book's picture is proportionate to the finds rather than contradicting them.

    121
  122. To reproach the text with a splendour it never claims is to confuse the absence of what was never promised with proof of falsehood.

    122
  123. Talmudic attribution, the seer's gloss, Qumran, Septuagint, Chronicles, Paul, Josephus, Jerome: eight links converging towards antiquity.

    123
  124. No manuscript of the posited sources, no trace of fabrication, no community the recipient of a fraud: the late hypothesis remains without body.

    124
  125. Vatican II, Dei Verbum, 18 November 1965, § 11: Scripture teaches firmly, faithfully and without error the truth that is for the sake of salvation.

    125

Can’t find your topic?