Samuel is, according to the Scripture received by the Church, the last judge of Israel and the first prophet of its monarchy: the child given to Shiloh who hears God call him in the night, the seer who anoints first Saul and then David, and the man whom the New Testament makes the first link in the prophetic chain leading to Christ. His life spans the first twenty-five chapters of the book that bears his name, at the turn of the 11th century before Jesus Christ, between the waning age of the judges and the dawning age of the kings.
His name runs throughout the Bible: the Chronicles cite the books of Samuel the seer, the Psalms and Jeremiah rank him with Moses among the great intercessors, Ben Sira devotes to him one of the finest praises in his pantheon, and the Epistle to the Hebrews names him between David and the prophets. The article first presents the narrative as the Church receives it, its place in the canon, its traditional author and its ancient witnesses, then its theology, its fulfilment in Christ, its presence in the liturgy, and finally the debate with modern historical-critical exegesis.
Samuel in the canon of Scripture
The First Book of Samuel, his own book
The life of Samuel occupies chapters 1 to 25 of the first book of Samuel, from the prayer of Hannah his mother to his death and burial at Ramah[1]. He reappears one last time in chapter 28, in the episode of the medium of En-Dor, which presupposes his death as already narrated and symbolically closes his file[2]. Everything that follows in the book—the end of Saul's reign and then the rise of David—takes place after him, like the afternoon of a day of which he was the morning[3].
In Hebrew, this book is called Shemouel, after the prophet, and forms a single scroll with what our Bibles call the second book of Samuel[4]. The division into two books comes from the Greek Septuagint, which titles them the books of Kingdoms (first and second), and then from the Latin Vulgate, which calls them the first and second books of Samuel: our Christian Bibles have kept this division[5]. For the detailed history of these two books, their structure, their text and their overall theology, see the article devoted to the books of Samuel: the present article treats of the man, not of the literary dossier[6].
The other mentions of Samuel in the Bible
Samuel is not confined to his book: about a dozen passages, from Chronicles to Revelation by way of the prophets and the Psalms, name him or presuppose his work, which rules out treating his story as a late addition. The table below gathers the main mentions outside the first book of Samuel.
| Biblical book | Passage | What the text contributes about Samuel |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Chronicles | 1 Chr 29:29 | The "books" (words) of Samuel the seer, with Nathan and Gad, sources of the history of David |
| 2 Chronicles | 2 Chr 35:18 | A Passover "such as had not been celebrated since the days of Samuel" under Josiah |
| Psalms | Ps 99:6 | "Samuel [...] among those who called upon his name": ranked with Moses and Aaron |
| Jeremiah | Jer 15:1 | "Even if Moses and Samuel stood before me": the intercessor par excellence |
| Ben Sira | Sir 46:13-20 | The great praise: royalty established, anointings, thunder of Mizpah, integrity, prophecy after death |
| Acts | Acts 3:24 | "All the prophets from Samuel" have announced the days of Christ |
| Acts | Acts 13:20-21 | The judges "until the prophet Samuel", then King Saul for forty years |
| Hebrews | Heb 11:32 | "Gideon, Barak, Samson, Jephthah, David, Samuel and the prophets" in faith |
Two features stand out in this survey. First, the later historical books speak of Samuel as a dated, archival reference: his writings are preserved (Chronicles), feasts are dated by his time (Josiah), he is cited as a model of prayer (Psalms, Jeremiah)[7]. Second, the New Testament makes him the threshold of messianic prophecy: Peter opens with him the list of the prophets who announced Christ, and Paul places him precisely at the hinge between the judges and the kings[8].
The biblical narrative, step by step
- Around the mid-11th century BCBirth at Ramah
Barren Hannah obtains a son through her prayer at Shiloh and consecrates him to the Lord.
- Childhood at ShilohEli's little attendant
Samuel grows up at the sanctuary beside the old priest Eli, between the ark and the lampstand.
- One night at ShilohThe calling
The Lord calls the child by name; Eli discerns and passes on the answer: listen.
- Around 1050 BCAphek, the ark in captivity, then Mizpah
Defeat at Aphek and death of Eli, captivity and then return of the ark, victory at Mizpah: Samuel judges.
- Samuel's old ageThe king requested
Israel demands a king "like the nations"; Samuel anoints Saul after warning him.
- Saul's reignThe rejection and the secret anointing
Saul disobeys at Gilgal and then against Amalek; Samuel anoints David at Bethlehem.
- End of the 11th century BCDeath at Ramah, apparition at Endor
All Israel mourns Samuel; shortly afterwards, his shade announces to Saul his imminent end.
The child asked for and given: Hannah, Eli, and Shiloh
Everything begins at Shiloh, the sanctuary where the ark dwells before Jerusalem, served by the old priest Eli and his two sons Hophni and Phinehas[9]. A man of Ramah, Elkanah, goes up each year to sacrifice there with his two wives: Peninnah, who has children and taunts her rival, and Hannah, barren and humiliated, whom her husband loves yet cannot console[10]. Hannah's barrenness is no sentimental detail: throughout the Old Testament, from Sarah to Elizabeth, it signals that the child to be born will belong to God's design and not to the mere course of nature[11].
Hannah's prayer, lips moving and voice inaudible, is so interior that Eli takes her for drunk; she corrects him and makes a solemn vow: if God gives her a son, she will consecrate him to Him for all the days of his life, as a nazirite whose head the razor shall not touch[12]. Granted her request, she names the child Shemouel, a name the account itself ties to the verb "to ask": the child is the one asked for, and his name will tell the whole story of his life of listening and response[13]. As soon as he is weaned, she brings him to Shiloh with an offering and entrusts him to Eli: the child "ministered before the Lord" while, each year, his mother brought him a little robe she had sewn with her own hands[14].
"My heart exults in the Lord; my horn is exalted through my God! My mouth derides my enemies, because I rejoice in your victory!"
- Canticle of Hannah, First Book of Samuel 2:1, liturgical translation[15]
The canticle Hannah then sings, opening the book as Mary's will open the infancy Gospel, already overturns all the powerful: the well-fed toil for bread, the barren woman bears seven children, the Lord "makes poor and makes rich, he humbles and he exalts," and the poem ends on an unheard-of flourish for its time, the announcement of a king and a messiah to whom God "will give strength"[16]. The Church reads in this song the matrix of the Magnificat, and neither liturgy nor exegesis has ever separated the two mothers who were answered[17].
The night of the calling: learning to listen
The child grows up between a corrupt sanctuary and an old priest blind in spirit as in body: Eli's sons extort the sacrifices and dishonour the holy place, and "the word of the Lord was rare in those days; visions were not widespread"[18]. It is in this night without prophecy that everything changes, in three calls. Lying near the ark, Samuel hears a voice calling him by name; he runs to Eli, who did not call him and sends him back to sleep; the third time, the old man understands and gives the child the words that will make him a prophet: say, when the voice returns, that you are listening[19].
"Speak, Lord, your servant is listening."
- Eli to Samuel, First Book of Samuel 3:9, liturgical translation[20]
"Speak, your servant is listening."
- Samuel to the Lord, First Book of Samuel 3:10, liturgical translation[21]
The divine answer is terrible: the announcement of the fall of the house of Eli, whose sons will die on the same day. In the morning, Eli demands the whole truth, and Samuel, after hesitation, hides nothing from him: the old priest bows, and "Samuel grew up, the Lord was with him, and he let none of his words fall to the ground"[22]. The formula says everything about the figure to come: a man none of whose words fall, because each one comes from a listening. And "all Israel knew that Samuel was accredited as a prophet of the Lord"[23].
The ark in captivity and the God who defends himself alone
Scarcely is the calling recounted when the narrative plunges Israel into its worst humiliation: marching against the Philistines at Aphek, the army seizes the ark like a talisman, Eli's two sons accompany it, and everything collapses—thirty thousand dead, the ark captured, Hophni and Phinehas killed on the same day as foretold, Eli struck dead on his chair at the news, and his daughter-in-law expiring in childbirth while naming the child Ichabod, "no glory," for "the glory has departed from Israel"[24]. The sanctuary of Shiloh will never recover, and both archaeology and text agree in dating the ruin of the place to this generation[25].
But the book at once turns the defeat into a demonstration: the captive ark itself humiliates its captors, toppling the idol of Dagon face to the ground and then shattering it, striking the Philistine cities with tumours, so that after seven months the princes send it back on a new cart drawn by two cows, with golden reparation offerings[26]. The God of Israel needs no army to defend himself: he acts alone, in enemy territory, by his presence alone. The ark then rests twenty years at Kiriath-jearim, and "all the house of Israel lamented after the Lord"[27].
Judge at Mizpah: the stone of help
It is then that Samuel gathers Israel at Mizpah for fasting and confession: they pour out water before the Lord, put away the Baals, and Samuel offers a lamb as a burnt offering while the Philistines come up to attack[28]. The Lord answers with a great thunder that throws the enemy into panic, and Israel, which had done nothing but pray and watch, pursues the fugitives: Samuel sets up between Mizpah and Shen a stone that he calls Eben-Ezer, the stone of help, "for," he says, "until now the Lord has helped us"[29]. Ben Sira, two centuries before our era, will still sing of this day when "the Lord thundered from heaven and, with a great crash, made his voice heard," linking the lamb offered and the Philistine princes destroyed[30].
"Samuel was beloved by his Lord. As a prophet of the Lord, he established the kingdom and anointed the chiefs of his people. He judged the assembly according to the law of the Most High."
Having become judge, Samuel travels each year the same circuit—Bethel, Gilgal, Mizpah—then returns to Ramah where his house and his altar stand: a tour of sedentary justice, the polar opposite of the expeditions of the judges before him, and the text insists that "the hand of the Lord was heavy against the Philistines all the days of Samuel"[32]. The last of the judges is already a different regime: no longer the occasional saviour raised up for a battle, but the permanent shepherd who teaches, judges, and intercedes[33].
The king requested, like the nations
Old, Samuel had appointed as judges over Israel his two sons, Joel and Abijah, who sit at Beersheba but "turn aside after gain, accept bribes, and pervert justice"[34]. The elders use this as a pretext to demand what they have long wanted: "Give us a king to judge us, like all the nations." The request displeases Samuel, who prays; and the Lord answers him with a sentence the rest of the book will go on verifying without end: "It is not you they reject, it is me they reject, from reigning over them"[35]. The rejection of the corrupt judge served as a mask for the rejection of the true King.
Samuel dutifully carries out the order and paints in advance, at God's command, the "king's right": sons conscripted, daughters requisitioned, fields confiscated, a tithe levied, and finally "you yourselves will become his slaves," with the Lord not answering on the day when you cry out[36]. The people insist, the Lord orders them to heed his voice, and Samuel dismisses the assembly while promising the anointing: the monarchy of Israel will be born in this way, willed by the people, permitted by God, framed by the prophet[37].
The anointing of Saul, then his rejection
The first to be anointed is a handsome young man from the tribe of Benjamin, Saul, who had set out to look for lost donkeys with his servant: it is in consulting the "seer" about a trifling loss that he finds a crown, for the Lord had forewarned Samuel the day before[38]. The anointing takes place in secret, with the ritual kiss; then Samuel summons Mizpah, casts lots for the tribe, the clan, the family, and Saul, hiding among the baggage, so tall and fearful is he, is proclaimed amid acclamation[39]. He will still need the victory over the Ammonites of Jabesh for all Israel to acknowledge him at Gilgal[40].
At Gilgal, Samuel then delivers his solemn farewell: he challenges them to testify against him if he has taken anyone's ox or donkey, if he has exerted pressure or accepted a bribe, and the people with one voice attest to his integrity[41]. Ben Sira will later take up the scene almost word for word: "I never took anyone's property, not even a pair of sandals, and no one accused me"[42]. Then come the thunder of the harvest, a sign that asking for a king was a fault, and the promise of the old judge: "Far be it from me to sin against the Lord by ceasing to pray for you," with the pledge to go on teaching "the good and right way"[43].
But Saul twice forces God's hand: at Gilgal he offers the burnt offering himself without waiting for Samuel, and is told that his kingship will not endure; against Amalek he spares King Agag and the best of the spoil under pretext of sacrifice, and Samuel, after a night of lamentation before the Lord, pronounces the sentence that will make him forever the doctor of obedience[44].
"Does the Lord delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as much as in obedience to his word? Yes, obedience is better than sacrifice, and submission is better than the fat of rams."
- Samuel to Saul, First Book of Samuel 15:22, liturgical translation[45]
The cloak torn in the quarrel becomes a parable of the kingdom torn away; Agag is executed, and "Samuel never saw Saul again until the day of his death," yet he mourned him: the prophet who anointed the king is also the one who deposed him, and the tension between the two gestures speaks to the status of the king in Israel—anointed and thus sacred, but judged and thus subordinate[46].
The secret anointing of David at Bethlehem
At the Lord's command, who reproaches him for still mourning Saul, Samuel goes to Bethlehem with a heifer for sacrifice to cover his mission, to the house of Jesse: seven sons file past, handsome and tall, and each time the discernment falls short, until the youngest, ruddy, who keeps the sheep and had not even been summoned[47]. The lesson, given to the prophet himself who had first been mistaken about the eldest, is one of the most quoted in the Old Testament: God does not look at appearance, he looks at the heart[48]. David is anointed "in the midst of his brothers," the spirit of the Lord rushes upon him, and Samuel returns to Ramah: the two kings will now coexist, the rejected one who keeps the throne, the chosen one who waits amid persecution[49].
Once more Samuel protects the chosen one: pursued by Saul, David takes refuge with him at Naioth, and three times the king's messengers, then Saul himself, are seized by the prophetic spirit in the company of the prophets in ecstasy, so much so that Saul strips off his garments and the proverb is reborn: "Is Saul also among the prophets?"[50]. The persecutor disarmed by the Spirit, without a sword being drawn: all the theology of the book in a single scene.
The death at Ramah and the night of Endor
"Samuel died, and all Israel assembled to mourn him, and he was buried in his house at Ramah": a single sentence, a national mourning, and the book turns toward the end of Saul[51]. For the abandoned king, on the eve of the battle of Mount Gilboa, attempts the irreparable: God answering "neither by dreams, nor by the Urim, nor by the prophets," he disguises himself to consult at Endor a woman who conjures up the dead[52]. What rises then, Samuel recognizable by his cloak, announces to the king his death and that of his sons for the next day, and the defeat of Israel: Samuel's last prophecy is posthumous, and Ben Sira held it as his seal: "Even after falling asleep, he prophesied again, to announce to the king his imminent end"[53].
"Even after falling asleep, he prophesied again, to announce to the king his imminent end; from the depths of the earth he raised a prophetic voice, so that the people's fault might be wiped away."
The Author of the Book and the Traditional Dating
What Jewish Tradition Says: Samuel, Gad, and Nathan
Jewish tradition, fixed in the Babylonian Talmud, attributes to Samuel himself the composition of the book that bears his name, along with the book of Judges and that of Ruth, and specifies that Gad the seer and Nathan the prophet completed it after his death[55]. The notice explains itself: Samuel dies in chapter 25, and the narrative continues to the end of the second book; continuators contemporary with the events were needed, and Chronicles names exactly these two among the sources of the history of David[56]. Far from being a late pious legend, the attribution places the writing at the very heart of the events, by the prophets of David's court[57].
The New Testament confirms the antiquity of the dossier without speculating on the author: Paul, at Antioch in Pisidia, summarizes "about four hundred fifty years" of judges "until the prophet Samuel," then "Saul [...] for forty years"[58]. Stephen, before the Sanhedrin, goes through all of sacred history in the same received order[59]. No one in the apostolic Church imagines that Samuel would be a figure of mist or his book a late compilation: he is a chronological landmark, like Moses before him[60].
The Internal Chronology: The Eleventh Century Before Christ
The book gives neither Samuel's age nor the years of his ministry, but it fits into an overall chronology that tradition receives as a coherent whole. The first book of Kings dates the fourth year of Solomon, that of the founding of the Temple, to the four hundred eightieth year after the exodus from Egypt[61]. With a Temple founded around 966, the Exodus falls around 1446; the forty years in the wilderness and then the conquest under Joshua occupy the close of the fourteenth century, and the three centuries of the judges, marked by Jephthah himself counting "three hundred years" of Amorite occupation, lead to the eleventh century, that of Samuel, Saul, and the beginnings of David[62].
| Biblical Landmark | Passage | Chronological Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Exodus and founding of the Temple | 1 Kgs 6:1 | 480 years between the Exodus (c. 1446) and Solomon (c. 966) |
| Amorite occupation | Jgs 11:26 | Jephthah counts 300 years since the conquest |
| Time of the judges | Acts 13:20 | "About 450 years" until the prophet Samuel |
| Reign of Saul | Acts 13:21 | Saul king "for forty years" |
| Ministry of Samuel | 1 Sam 1 to 25 | Between the end of the judges and the anointing of David, eleventh century |
This framework places the birth of Samuel around the middle of the eleventh century, his ministry as judge in the second half of the century, and his death shortly before Saul's fall at Gilboa, at the turn of the tenth century[63]. The dates remain approximate, as with Gideon or Samson, and the article gives them as such: "around the eleventh century," without the false precision of invented years[64].
The Marks of Antiquity in the Text Itself
The narrative bears marks of antiquity that late compositions would neither have invented nor preserved. The most famous is the gloss of chapter 9: when Saul sets out to consult the seer, the narrator interrupts his account to explain that "the one who is today called a prophet was formerly called a seer"[65]. A work forged in the Persian period would have no need to explain a word of its own vocabulary: the gloss proves that the writer is transmitting an account older than his language, and preserves it as it stands rather than modernizing it[66].
Other details smell of the period: the quarter shekel of silver offered to the seer as a fee, in an economy still without coined money; the linen ephod of the young servant; the Philistine chariots and blacksmiths whose monopoly on iron crushes Israel; the standing stone set up in memory, after the manner of the patriarchs[67]. Taken one by one, these traits prove nothing; together, they compose a setting coherent with the end of the Bronze Age and the beginning of the Iron Age in the Levant, and not with Persian or Hellenistic Judah[68].
The ancient witnesses of the account
The Hebrew text, the Septuagint and the Qumran manuscripts
Samuel is one of the best-attested biblical books of antiquity, with three major witnesses that check one another: the Hebrew Masoretic text, the Septuagint translated at Alexandria in the third and second centuries BC, and the Dead Sea Scrolls[69]. The caves of Qumran yielded three scrolls of Samuel, one of them, dating from the third century BC, counting among the oldest surviving biblical manuscripts: the text was therefore already circulating, substantially fixed, centuries before our era[70].
| Witness | Approximate date | Contribution to Samuel |
|---|---|---|
| Masoretic text | Fixed by the Masoretes, 1st millennium AD | Received Hebrew text, basis of our translations |
| Septuagint (* Reigns* I-II) | Alexandria, 3rd–2nd c. BC | Greek translation of a Hebrew sometimes older than the Masoretic |
| 4QSam (Qumran) | 3rd–1st c. BC | Hebrew fragments five centuries earlier than the Masoretes |
| Vulgate (1-2 Samuel) | Bethlehem, late 4th c. AD | Latin translation by Jerome from the Hebrew |
The comparison of the witnesses is instructive in both directions. In 1 Sam 9, the Qumran manuscripts call Samuel "the seer" along with the Septuagint, where the Masoretic text has levelled it to "prophet": the agreement of the two oldest witnesses against the most recent one shows that the gloss on the seer rests on a solid textual tradition[71]. As for Goliath's height, Qumran and the Septuagint read "four cubits and a span" where the Masoretic gives "six cubits": the giant's proportions vary from copy to copy, but the confrontation itself is attested by all the witnesses without exception[72]. In other words, textual criticism argues about the measurements, never about the existence of the dossier[73].
Josephus, Ben Sira and the New Testament
As early as the second century BC, Ben Sira sums up the whole career of Samuel in eight verses that presuppose our book as already known: the monarchy established, the anointings, the thunder at Mizpah, the farewell speech, and even the episode of Endor[74]. In the first century AD, Flavius Josephus gives a lengthy paraphrase of the story of Samuel, Saul and David in Book VI of his Jewish Antiquities, treating it in no other way than as national history: Hannah, Eli, the ark, Mizpah, the anointings, Endor — everything passes through in the received order[75]. In Against Apion, the same Josephus counts the books of the Jews as a closed canon of twenty-two works, including those of the prophets who recount "what took place from Moses to Artaxerxes": Samuel figures among the prophets there, and no contemporary disputes the arrangement[76].
The New Testament, as we have seen, makes Samuel a chronological marker and the threshold of prophecy (Acts 3:24; Acts 13:20; Heb 11:32)[77]. Let us add that Paul, quoting "a man after my heart" about David, reuses the very verdict pronounced by Samuel on Saul (1 Sam 13:14), proof that the apostle knows the book in detail and uses it as Scripture[78].
Jerome, the Vulgate and ecclesial reception
It is in connection with the books of Samuel and Kings that Jerome, around 391–392, sets his famous so-called "helmeted" preface, the Prologus Galeatus, in which he enumerates the twenty-two books of the Hebrew Bible: Samuel and Kings hold their rank among the Prophets there, and the Doctor of Bethlehem then translates the whole into Hebrew for his Vulgate[79]. The Council of Trent, in 1546, will confirm the Catholic canon of forty-six books of the Old Testament, including the two books of Samuel in the received form[80]. The chain is therefore unbroken: the Qumran scrolls, the Septuagint, the New Testament, Josephus, Jerome, the liturgy, the magisterium — no link suspects a late fabrication[81].
The theology of Samuel: listening, obedience, the king under God
Listening before speaking
The whole character comes down to the night at Shiloh: before speaking in God's name, Samuel learned to be silent before him. The vocation gives him neither a message to recite nor a power to wield, but a posture — that of the servant who listens — and it is this posture that then accredits each of his words[82]. The Fathers saw in it the model of all prayer: God calls by name, three times, patiently, and awaits the free response of a child who does not yet understand but makes himself available[83]. The Catechism does not mention Samuel by name in its pages on prayer, but the figure illustrates exactly what it teaches: prayer as listening to the living God before being request or discourse[84].
"By his fidelity he showed himself a true prophet, and through his oracles he was found worthy of trust in his visions."
Obedience is better than sacrifice
The sentence pronounced on Saul after the Amalek affair has become one of the most quoted verses of the Old Testament, taken up by the prophets, the psalms and the Fathers: worship without obedience is an empty shell[86]. Samuel does not despise sacrifice — he who offers the lamb at Mizpah and presides over the feasts: he ranks them in order, and recalls that the offering does not make up for disobedience; it expresses it when it is offered in obedience[87]. Hosea will say "it is love that I desire, not sacrifice", the Psalms "you desired neither sacrifice nor offering", and Christ will seal the lesson by applying it to the Pharisees: mercy, not rites, is the heart of the Law[88].
The king under God, never in God's place
The political theology of the book is of a fearsome clarity: Israel wanted a king "like the nations", God allowed it with a warning, and the anointed king remains a judged servant, not an absolute sovereign[89]. Samuel anoints, advises, rebukes and deposes: Saul learns to his cost that one does not force God's hand, whether by offering the reserved sacrifice oneself, or by keeping the forbidden spoil under cover of piety[90]. The law of the king given as early as Deuteronomy already framed the office: no accumulated horses, no multiplied wives, no hoarded gold, and a copy of the Law to read "all the days of his life"[91]. David, the second anointed, will understand the lesson differently: when Nathan rebukes him after Bathsheba, he will repent where Saul had justified himself, and it is this difference that grounds the dynastic promise[92].
The intercessor whom God himself cites as an example
Psalms and prophets agree in making Samuel, with Moses, the type of the answered intercessor: "Moses and Aaron among his priests, and Samuel among those who called on his name: they called on the Lord, and he answered them"[93]. Jeremiah goes further still: even if Moses and Samuel stood before him, God would not spare the apostate people — which implies that their joint intercession represents the maximum imaginable credit with God[94]. Samuel intercedes for the people at Mizpah, at Gilgal, and even into his old age he makes prayer for Israel a duty whose abandonment would be a sin: "Far be it from me to sin against the Lord by ceasing to pray for you"[95]. The Church recognizes in him the figure of Christ the intercessor, and that of the saints whose prayer, without replacing the Saviour's, truly participates in it[96].
The canticle of Hannah, matrix of the Magnificat
The parallel between the canticle of Hannah (1 Sam 2:1–10) and that of Mary (Luke 1:46–55) is one of the firmest in all of Scripture: the same exultation of a mother who has been heard, the same reversal of the powerful, the same God who exalts the humble[97]. The table below lines up the clearest correspondences.
| Canticle of Hannah (1 Sam 2) | Magnificat (Luke 1) | The shared reversal |
|---|---|---|
| "My heart exults in the Lord" (2:1) | "My soul proclaims the greatness of the Lord" (Luke 1:46) | The joy of the heard mother opens both songs |
| "The bow of the mighty is broken" (2:4) | "He scatters the proud" (Luke 1:51) | The powerful are disarmed |
| "The hungry rest," the barren woman bears (2:5) | "He fills the hungry with good things" (Luke 1:53) | The poor are filled, the rich sent away empty |
| "He raises the poor from the dust" (2:8) | "He has lifted up Israel his servant" (Luke 1:54) | The exaltation of the humble |
| "He will give power to his king" (2:10) | "The kingdom" of the Son to come (Luke 1:32–33) | The royal and messianic horizon |
Mary does not copy Hannah by literary artifice: she prays with the words of Scripture she has received, like any daughter of Israel, and the Church has always read in this continuity the proof that the New Testament fulfils the Old rather than replacing it[98]. The canticle of Hannah already announces, in full letters, "his messiah": ten centuries before Bethlehem, the mother of Samuel names the hope that the mother of Jesus will carry[99].
Fulfilment in Christ
David, the king after God's own heart, and his promised descendants
Samuel did not live to see David's reign, dying before it began, yet his whole ministry prepared for it: by rejecting Saul the fleshly king, by secretly anointing the forgotten boy of Bethlehem, by protecting the fugitive at Naioth[100]. The verdict that founds the dynasty, "the Lord has sought out a man after his own heart" (1 Sam 13:14), is pronounced by Samuel himself, and Paul will take it up at Antioch, applying it to David in contrast to the set-aside Saul[101]. The covenant then promised to David—a house established and a throne made sure for ever—belongs to the dossier of the books of Samuel; the article refers the reader there for the detail, and notes here the essential: it is from Samuel's anointing that proceeds the line leading to Joseph of Nazareth[102].
All the prophets since Samuel
Peter's discourse in the Temple gives Samuel a unique place in the history of salvation: "All the prophets from Samuel onwards, and all those who have spoken, have likewise announced those days," those of the suffering and then glorified Christ[103]. Samuel therefore opens the prophetic procession that leads to Jesus, not as a distant ancestor, but as the first witness of an unbroken chain[104]. The Epistle to the Hebrews confirms this by naming him, the only judge cited, at the heart of the cloud of witnesses of faith, between David and the prophets[105].
The God who looks at the heart
The word addressed to Samuel before the sons of Jesse—God looks at the heart when men look at appearance—runs through the whole New Testament like a common thread: the Beatitudes proclaim the pure of heart blessed, the Lord denounces whitewashed tombs, and the Apostle reminds us that God "tests the hearts"[106]. Samuel, who had himself been mistaken about the eldest before being corrected, is the first beneficiary of the lesson he transmits: discerning appearances is learned, even for a prophet, and it begins with listening[107]. In this sense, the seer blinded for a moment before the towering height of Eliab, then enlightened before the little shepherd, is the figure of every reader of the Gospel called to recognise the King in the guise of the servant[108].
Samuel in the Liturgical Life of the Church
The Lectionary: Samuel at the Beginning of Ordinary Time
Every year, in the first weeks of Ordinary Time, the lectionary of the Mass proclaims the vocation of the child of Silo, the anointing of Saul and then that of David: January is, for the faithful who attend daily Mass, the month of Samuel[109]. The night when the Lord calls the child three times is one of the most beloved readings of this cycle, often chosen for ordinations, religious professions and prayer vigils for vocations, so greatly does it express the readiness required of every one who is called[110]. The canticle of Hannah, for its part, nourishes the Liturgy of the Hours and songs of thanksgiving, standing alongside that of Mary[111].
The Feast of 20 August and the Witness of the Martyrology
The Eastern Churches keep the feast of the holy prophet Samuel on 20 August, a date attested from the ancient Palestinian and Constantinopolitan calendars and still inscribed in the Orthodox and Greek Catholic calendars[112]. The West honours him in the Roman Martyrology, which commemorates in Judea "the holy prophet Samuel," recalling, on the testimony of Saint Jerome, the translation of his holy relics to Constantinople under the Emperor Arcadius[113]. The imperial mention is not decorative: to transfer the remains of a prophet to the capital is to profess that the whole Old Testament is moving towards Christ, and that its saints already belong to the Church[114].
The Pilgrimage of Nebi Samwil, the Ramah of Tradition
Since the Byzantine era, the Christian tradition has identified the village of Nebi Samwil, on the heights north-west of Jerusalem, with Ramah, the homeland and tomb of Samuel: a monastery of Saint Samuel is attested there as early as the fourth century, and in the twelfth century the Crusaders made it a major stop on the pilgrimage, rebuilding the church and fortress whose ruins still dominate the site[115]. The Jewish traveller Benjamin of Tudela, in 1173, recounts that the Crusaders had brought back there the bones of the prophet, found in a burial in the coastal plain[116]. Today, as in the time of the American traveller Edward Robinson in 1838, Jews, Christians and Muslims together venerate the tomb beneath the dome, in a sharing as fragile as it is tenacious[117]. Archaeologists debate the identification, many proposing instead that it be seen as the ancient Mizpah, but the continuity of worship over sixteen centuries makes the place, if not a topographical certainty, a living witness to the memory of Samuel[118].
Samuel Beyond the Bible: Judaism, Islam and the Arts
Judaism: Hannah as a Model of Prayer, Samuel as Author
The rabbinic tradition makes the prayer of Hannah the charter of all Jewish prayer: the Talmud draws from the account of Silo the laws of prayer — to pray from the heart even without a voice, to move the lips, not to raise the voice, not to pray in a state of intoxication, to pour out one's grief before God as Hannah did, "pouring out her soul"[119]. Every daily office thus bears, without knowing it, the trace of Samuel's mother. The same Talmud, as we have seen, makes Samuel the author of his book, of Judges and of Ruth, and both the Midrash and the medieval commentators (Rashi, Radak) read his life as that of the prophet-judge par excellence, greater than the kings he anoints since he judges them[120].
Islam: The Unnamed Prophet of Surah 2
The Quran never names Samuel, but it tells his story: after Moses, the notables of Israel ask "their prophet" to raise up for them a king to fight in the path of God; the prophet designates Talut (Saul) for them, contested on account of his poverty then confirmed by the sign of the ark; Talut tests his army at the stream, and young Dawud (David) slays Jalut (Goliath)[121]. The storyline plainly follows chapters 8 to 17 of the first book of Samuel, and the great Muslim commentators, at-Tabari and then Ibn Kathir, explicitly identify this anonymous prophet as Samuel[122]. The divergence concerns the meaning, not the facts: where the Bible sees the requested king as a first rejection of God, pardoned and then elevated, the Quran reads in it a test of military obedience, and the Muslim tradition knows nothing of the anointing of David as a covenant[123].
The Arts: From Handel to the Painters of the Anointing
The night at Endor has seized the imagination more than any other scene in the book: Handel makes it the terrifying climax of his oratorio Saul (1739), to a libretto by Charles Jennens drawn from the biblical text, when the medium brings up the prophet's shade before the condemned king[124]. Painters, for their part, have preferred the two anointings: Saul seeking his donkeys and being found by Samuel, David the forgotten one called from the pasture — scenes of vocations missed and then fulfilled that offer artists the contrast of ages and attitudes[125]. The biblical cinema of the twentieth century has often melted Samuel into a silhouette, a voice-over for Saul's conscience, so greatly does the character resist the foreground: he is the one who designates, not the one who reigns, and the artists have understood this[126].
The historical-critical debate: what modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
The Deuteronomistic hypothesis and its variants
Since Martin Noth and his studies on the history of traditions (1943), a large part of contemporary exegesis has placed the books of Samuel within a great "deuteronomistic history" written in the exilic period, which would reread the monarchical past in light of Deuteronomy to explain the catastrophe of 587[127]. Frank Moore Cross proposed distinguishing two layers within it, an optimistic Josianic first edition and a darkened exilic reworking, while Leonhard Rost isolated as early as 1926, in the second book, a "succession narrative" favorable to Solomon[128]. Presented honestly, these reconstructions offer fine-grained readings of the literary composition: they detect seams, resumptions, successive pastoral perspectives[129].
But their status must be stated plainly: these are hypotheses about lost documents, of which no manuscript exists, whose boundaries vary from school to school, and whose dating often rests on the postulate that any precise account of the past is a late projection[130]. The present article sets them out without caricaturing them, then shows why the traditional dating and attribution remain defensible: not out of ignorance of criticism, but after having weighed it[131].
Doublets: contradiction or complement?
The most common objection concerns repeated passages: Saul becomes king at Mizpah by lot and then at Gilgal by acclamation; he is rejected in chapter 13 and again in chapter 15; David enters the court as a musician in chapter 16 and then as the victor over Goliath in chapter 17; the proverb "Is Saul also among the prophets?" appears twice[132]. For part of exegesis, these are competing traditions clumsily stitched together, proof of a late compilation[133].
| Alleged doublet | Common critical reading | Response from the traditional reading |
|---|---|---|
| Two accessions of Saul (1 Sam 10 and 11) | Two opposing political sources | Private designation, public proclamation, then military confirmation: three moments of a single accession |
| Two rejections of Saul (1 Sam 13 and 15) | Compiler's redundancy | Two distinct faults (usurped sacrifice, spared spoil), second rejection definitive after the first warning |
| Two entries of David at court (1 Sam 16 and 17) | Two traditions of origin | Occasional musician summoned in times of crisis, then national hero after Goliath: a court soon forgets a lyre player |
| "Saul among the prophets" (1 Sam 10 and 19) | Floating saying reused | The proverb is born of a first event and is reborn, enriched, at the second: this is its proverbial function |
| Goliath's height (6 or 4 cubits) | Legendary exaggeration | Copyist variant among witnesses (MT against LXX and Qumran), the encounter itself being attested by all |
The traditional rule of reading is that of complement rather than contradiction: the Bible willingly tells twice, from two angles, what life causes to happen twice, and Chronicles confirms the method by citing three distinct prophetic sources for one and the same reign[134]. Let us add that the so-called "doublets" often assume what they seek to prove: one divides the text into sources according to stylistic criteria, dates those sources according to a theory of religious evolution, then invokes the division as proof of the theory[135].
Endor, the spirits, and the anti-supernatural presupposition
The episode of the medium concentrates all the suspicions: an evocation of the dead would be a concession to paganism, and the fulfilled prediction, an after-the-fact reworking[136]. The Fathers themselves debated the identity of the apparition: Augustine wondered whether it was really the soul of Samuel or a spirit that had taken on his likeness, proof that the Church has never read the passage with her eyes closed[137]. But the text itself has no doubt: it is Samuel who speaks, who prophesies, and whose posthumous prophecy Ben Sira confirms[138]. To set the account aside on the grounds that an evocation cannot predict the future is to apply to the text a philosophical presupposition, naturalism, and not a historical argument: the method rules out the supernatural before the inquiry, then concludes from the inquiry that the supernatural is absent[139].
Why the traditional reading remains defensible
Let us gather the pieces: an ancient and precise attribution (Baba Batra, Gad, Nathan, Chronicles), an internal gloss that betrays the antiquity of the narrative (the seer of chapter 9), manuscripts five centuries older than the Masoretes (Qumran), a Greek translation of the 3rd century that presupposes a Hebrew already fixed, witnesses from the 2nd century BC (Ben Sira) and the 1st century AD (Josephus, the apostles) who cite the book as Scripture, and an ecclesial reception without interruption[140]. Against this convergence, the late reconstructions offer literary possibilities, never proofs: no manuscript of their supposed sources, no trace of a forgery, no community that would have accepted as Moses a book fabricated under the Persians[141]. As the Second Vatican Council recalls, Scripture "teaches solidly, faithfully and without error that truth which God put into the sacred writings for the sake of our salvation": faith in inerrancy does not forbid the criticism of copies, but it forbids making the text say the opposite of what it affirms[142].
For further reading
- The Books of Samuel: the twin article on the two books, their structure, their text and their overall theology
- Moses, the liberator and mediator of the Covenant, mentioned with Samuel among the intercessors
- Aaron, brother and spokesman of Moses, first high priest
- Joshua, who brought Israel into Canaan before the time of the judges
- Gideon, judge raised up against Midian in the time of the oppressions
- Samson, the Nazirite whose strength judged the Philistines
- Elijah, the prophet of Carmel, heir to Samuel's mantle
Notes and References
1 Sam 1:1 (Elkanah of Ramah) to 1 Sam 25:1 (death and burial at Ramah): the geographical inclusion opens and closes the prophet's life.
11 Sam 28:3 first recalls the death of Samuel before telling of the consultation of Endor: the narrator assumes chapter 25 to be known.
2Received division: 1 Sam 1-7 (childhood, ark, Mizpah), 1 Sam 8-15 (Saul), 1 Sam 16-31 (David and the end of Saul); see the article Books of Samuel.
3In Hebrew, Shemuel forms a single book, classed among the Former Prophets (with Joshua, Judges and Kings).
4Septuagint: Basileiôn I-II (Reigns); Vulgate: Samuhelis I-II. The division cuts Saul's reign in two, in the middle of 1 Sam 31 and 2 Sam 1.
5The article Books of Samuel deals with the structure of the two books, textual criticism and the Davidic covenant: we do not duplicate that material here.
61 Chr 29:29 (archives); 2 Chr 35:18 (dating); Ps 99:6 and Jer 15:1 (intercession): three distinct uses, all ancient.
7Acts 3:24 (prophetic threshold); Acts 13:20 (chronological hinge); Heb 11:32 (cloud of witnesses).
81 Sam 1:3: Eli and his sons Hophni and Phinehas, priests at Shiloh; 1 Sam 1:9: Eli on his seat by the doorpost of the temple.
91 Sam 1:1-2: Elkanah, Hannah and Peninnah; 1 Sam 1:5-8: Hannah's double portion and the tears that her husband's love does not console.
10Sarah (Gen 18), Rebekah (Gen 25:21), Rachel (Gen 30), the wife of Manoah (Judg 13), the Shunammite (2 Kgs 4), Elizabeth (Luke 1): fruitful sterility is a constant motif of sacred history.
111 Sam 1:10-11: the prayer of the lips without voice and the vow of perpetual Naziriteship for the child to be born.
121 Sam 1:20: Hannah "called him Samuel, for, she said, I have asked him of the Lord"; the name condenses the whole vocation of listening.
131 Sam 1:24-28: the weaning, the offering and Hannah's words to Eli; 1 Sam 2:19: the little robe brought each year.
141 Sam 2:1, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): "My heart exults in the Lord..."
151 Sam 2:4-5 (the strong and the hungry); 1 Sam 2:7-8 (poverty and exaltation); 1 Sam 2:10 (the king and the anointed one), liturgical translation.
16Luke 1:46-55 takes up the vocabulary and structure of Hannah's song; see the section on the Magnificat.
171 Sam 2:12-17 (plundering of the sacrifices); 1 Sam 2:22-25 (disorders and the warning scorned); 1 Sam 3:1 (the word was rare).
181 Sam 3:2-9: the three calls, the misunderstanding and Eli's final discernment.
191 Sam 3:9, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): Eli's instruction to the child.
201 Sam 3:10, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): Samuel's answer to the fourth call.
211 Sam 3:11-18: the oracle against the house of Eli and its complete transmission in the morning.
221 Sam 3:19-21: no word falls to the ground, and "all Israel knew" that Samuel was a prophet.
231 Sam 4:1-11 (Aphek and the capture of the ark); 1 Sam 4:12-22 (the death of Eli, of his sons and of Ichabod).
24The destruction of Shiloh in the 11th century is accepted by archaeology as by the text (Jer 7:12-14; Ps 78:60 recall the abandonment of the sanctuary).
251 Sam 5 (Dagon and the tumours); 1 Sam 6:1 (seven months); 1 Sam 6:7-12 (the cart and the cows of Beth-shemesh).
261 Sam 7:1-2: the ark at Kiriath-jearim for "twenty years", and the sighing of all Israel.
271 Sam 7:3-9: the exhortation, the fasting, the poured-out water and the holocaust of the milk-fed lamb.
281 Sam 7:10-12: the thunder, the pursuit and the stone of help between Mizpah and Shen.
29Sir 46:16-18, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the lamb offered and the thunder that destroys the enemy chiefs.
30Sir 46:13-14, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): beloved of the Lord, established kingdom, anointings, judgeship.
311 Sam 7:15-17: Bethel, Gilgal, Mizpah and the return to Ramah, with the altar built to the Lord.
32Unlike Gideon or Samson, raised up for a deliverance, Samuel exercises a permanent office of judge, prophet and intercessor.
331 Sam 8:1-3: Joel and Abijah, judges at Beer-sheba, turned aside by gain.
341 Sam 8:4-8: the elders' request and the divine answer, "it is not you they reject".
351 Sam 8:10-18: the picture of the "right of the king", requisitions and servitude foretold.
361 Sam 8:19-22: the stubbornness of the people and the divine order to listen to their voice.
371 Sam 9:1-14: Saul and the donkeys, the quarter shekel and the ascent to the seer; 1 Sam 9:15-17: the divine warning to Samuel.
381 Sam 10:1 (secret anointing); 1 Sam 10:20-24 (lot and proclamation at Mizpah).
391 Sam 11 (Jabesh besieged and then delivered); 1 Sam 11:14-15 (renewal of the kingship at Gilgal).
401 Sam 12:1-5: the summons of accusation and the unanimous acquittal of the judge.
41Sir 46:19, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): "not even a pair of sandals, and no one accused him".
421 Sam 12:16-25: the thunder of the harvest, the confessed fault and the promise of intercession.
431 Sam 13:8-14 (Gilgal); 1 Sam 15:1-23 (Amalek): the two acts of disobedience and their sentences.
441 Sam 15:22, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): obedience and docility against holocausts.
451 Sam 15:24-31 (confession and refusal); 1 Sam 15:27-28 (the torn hem, parable of the kingdom); 1 Sam 15:35 (Samuel mourns Saul).
461 Sam 16:1-5 (the mission and the heifer); 1 Sam 16:6-11 (the seven sons refused).
471 Sam 16:7: God does not see as men see, men see the appearance and the Lord sees the heart (paraphrase of the famous verse).
481 Sam 16:12-13: the anointing in the midst of the brothers and the spirit of the Lord rushing upon David.
491 Sam 19:18-24: the three waves of messengers and then Saul himself seized at Naioth, and the proverb renewed.
501 Sam 25:1: the death, the mourning of all Israel and the burial at Ramah.
511 Sam 28:3-7: the silence of God (dreams, Urim, prophets) and the disguised recourse to the woman of Endor.
52Sir 46:20, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): the posthumous prophecy announcing to the king his end.
53Sir 46:20, same verse: "from the womb of the earth he raised a prophetic voice".
54Babylonian Talmud, Baba Batra 14b-15a: Samuel wrote his book, Judges and Ruth; Gad and Nathan completed it.
551 Chr 29:29: the acts of David recorded in the "books" of Samuel the seer, of Nathan and of Gad.
56An editing by the contemporary prophets better explains the precision of the scenes (courts, battles, dialogues) than a distant compilation.
57Acts 13:20-21: about 450 years of judges until Samuel, then forty years of Saul.
58Acts 7:2-53: Stephen follows the received order of sacred history, from Abraham to Solomon.
59Nowhere does the New Testament treat Samuel as a symbol: it counts him, dates him and quotes him as a witness.
601 Kgs 6:1: the 480th year after the exodus from Egypt, 4th year of Solomon, month of Ziv.
61Exodus around 1446, wilderness and conquest at the end of the 14th century, judges from the 13th to the 11th century: see the articles Moses and Joshua for the details of the framework.
62Birth around the middle of the 11th century, ministry in its second half, death at the turn of the 10th: received range, without artificial precision.
63As with Gideon or Samson, the heading reads "around the 11th century BC": the stated approximation is better than false precision.
641 Sam 9:9: "the one who is called a prophet today was formerly called a seer" (paraphrase of the narrator's gloss).
65A late forger modernizes the vocabulary instead of explaining its archaism: the gloss is the signature of a faithful transmitter.
661 Sam 9:8 (quarter of a shekel); 1 Sam 2:18 (linen ephod); 1 Sam 13:19-22 (Philistine monopoly on iron); 1 Sam 7:12 (stone set up).
67Late Bronze Age and early Iron Age in the Levant (Philistines, chariots, forges): the setting suits the end of the 2nd millennium BC, not the Persian period.
68Masoretic, Septuagint and Qumran: three independent lines of transmission that allow the variants to be checked rather than merely endured.
694QSam^a, 4QSam^b and 4QSam^c (3rd–1st c. BC): the second is among the oldest surviving biblical manuscripts.
701 Sam 9:18-19: Qumran and the Septuagint read "the seer" where the Masoretic text has levelled it, confirming the antiquity of the gloss.
711 Sam 17:4: six cubits and a span (MT) against four cubits and a span (LXX and 4QSam^a); the duel itself is unanimously attested.
72Textual criticism arbitrates between measurements, not between existence and legend: no witness knows a Samuel without Goliath.
73Sir 46:13-20: kingship, anointings, Mizpah, farewells, Endor, the whole book is presumed known two centuries BC.
74Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, Book VI: a continuous paraphrase from Hannah to the death of Saul, treated as national history.
75Flavius Josephus, Against Apion, I, 38-40: twenty-two books, including the prophets from Moses to Artaxerxes.
76Acts 3:24; Acts 13:20; Heb 11:32: prophetic threshold, chronological hinge, cloud of witnesses.
77Acts 13:22 reprises 1 Sam 13:14 ("a man according to my heart"): Paul knows the book down to its sayings.
78Jerome, Prologus Galeatus (preface to the books of Samuel and Kings, c. 391-392): enumeration of the twenty-two Hebrew books.
79Council of Trent, Fourth Session, Decree on the Canonical Scriptures, 8 April 1546: forty-six books for the Catholic Old Testament.
80Qumran, Septuagint, Ben Sira, New Testament, Josephus, Jerome, liturgy, magisterium: the chain of witnesses knows no break.
811 Sam 3:9-10: the answer learned from Eli becomes the programme of the prophet's whole life.
82The Fathers read in the three calls God's patience with beginners: God repeats, explains through a teacher, then speaks directly.
83Prayer as listening before asking: Samuel illustrates the common doctrine of prayer, from the Old Testament to the masters of Carmel.
84Sir 46:15, liturgical translation (AELF, checked word for word): proven fidelity and visions worthy of trust.
85Hos 6:6; Ps 40:7-9; Ps 50:8-15; Isa 1:11-17; Mic 6:6-8: all prophecy reprises the saying of Samuel.
86Samuel himself offers sacrifice (Mizpah, Gilgal, Bethlehem): he subordinates sacrifice, he does not abolish it.
87Hos 6:6 ("love, not sacrifices"); Matt 9:13 and Matt 12:7 (Christ quoting Hosea to the Pharisees).
881 Sam 8:7 (the rejection of God); 1 Sam 10:25 (the "right of the kingship" recorded); 1 Sam 15 (the judgment of the king).
891 Sam 13:13-14 (Gilgal); 1 Sam 15:22-23 (Amalek): two faults, one lesson, the kingdom torn away.
90Deut 17:14-20: horses, women, gold limited, and the copy of the Law to be read every day.
912 Sam 12:1-14: rebuked by Nathan, David confesses ("I have sinned against the Lord") where Saul had justified himself (1 Sam 15:20-21).
92Ps 99:6: Moses, Aaron and Samuel among those who call, and God who answers.
93Jer 15:1: even Moses and Samuel interceding would obtain nothing more, so great is the credit presumed theirs.
941 Sam 12:23: to cease praying for the people would be to sin against the Lord.
95Christ "intercedes for us" (Rom 8:34) and the saints share in his intercession: Samuel is its Old Testament type along with Moses.
96Structure, vocabulary and theology common to both canticles: exultation, reversal, raising of the lowly, royal horizon.
97Luke 1:46-55 weaves at least a dozen Old Testament allusions: Mary prays as a daughter of the Scriptures, not as an improviser.
981 Sam 2:10: "he will raise the horn of his anointed", the final thrust of the canticle, ten centuries before Bethlehem.
99Rejection of Saul (1 Sam 13 and 15), anointing at Bethlehem (1 Sam 16), protection at Naioth (1 Sam 19): three acts for a single coming.
1001 Sam 13:14: "the Lord has sought for himself a man according to his heart"; Acts 13:22: Paul applies the saying to David.
1012 Sam 7 (the promise to David) and Matt 1 (genealogy as far as Joseph): from the Samuel anointing to the birth of Christ, the chain is continuous.
102Acts 3:24: "all the prophets from Samuel" have announced the days of the Christ suffering and glorified.
103Samuel opens the list, his "successors" continue it: prophecy is a chain, not a series of isolated oracles.
104Heb 11:32: Samuel, the only judge named in the list of witnesses of faith, between David and the prophets.
105Matt 5:8 (pure hearts); Matt 23:27 (whitewashed tombs); 1 Thess 2:4 (God tests hearts): Samuel's discernment runs through the Gospel.
1061 Sam 16:6-7: deceived by Eliab's stature, Samuel receives the lesson before passing it on.
107Like Samuel before the sons of Jesse, the reader of the Gospel must recognize the King under the appearance of the suffering servant.
108Roman Lectionary, weekdays of Ordinary Time, first weeks: the first book of Samuel (vocation, Saul, David) opens the liturgical year of Ordinary Time.
1091 Sam 3:3-10: the classic reading for celebrations of vocations, ordinations and professions.
110The canticle of Hannah (1 Sam 2) appears in the repertoire of canticles for the Liturgy of the Hours and thanksgiving, as a pendant to the Magnificat.
11120 August: Greek Orthodox Church, Slavic and Eastern calendars, and ancient Palestinian calendars (Georgian calendar of Ioane Zosime, 10th century).
112Roman Martyrology, commemoration of the holy prophet Samuel in Judea: relics transferred to Constantinople under the Emperor Arcadius, according to the testimony of Saint Jerome.
113The translation of Old Testament relics to the Christian capital professes the unity of the two Testaments and the holiness of the righteous before Christ.
114Nebi Samwil, north-west of Jerusalem: a Monastery of Saint Samuel from the 4th century, at its height in the Crusader 12th-13th centuries.
115Benjamin of Tudela, travel account (c. 1173): the Crusaders would have brought the prophet's bones to Nebi Samwil.
116Edward Robinson, Biblical Researches (1838): a mosque regarded by Jews, Christians and Muslims as covering the tomb of Samuel.
117Its identification with Ramah remains disputed (many propose Mizpah): the cult tradition, however, has been continuous since the Byzantine period.
118Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 31a: from Hannah's prayer (1 Sam 1:10-13) are drawn the rules of prayer, in a low voice and from the depths of the heart.
119Rashi and David Qimhi (Radak) on 1 Sam: Samuel, prophet-judge superior to the kings, since he anoints and judges them.
120Quran, sura 2, verses 246-251: the unnamed prophet, Talut, the ark as sign, the test of the stream, Dawud against Jalut.
121Al-Tabari (d. 923) and then Ibn Kathir (d. 1373) in their commentaries: the prophet of sura 2 is Samuel.
122The Muslim tradition retains the test and the victory, not the anointing as covenant nor the Davidic dynasty as promise.
123G. F. Handel, Saul, HWV 53 (1739), libretto by Charles Jennens after the first book of Samuel: Act III culminates with the medium of Endor.
124The anointing of Saul and that of David, twin scenes of vocation, are among the favourite Samuel subjects of classical painting.
125A prophet who anoints without ruling, Samuel inspires artists as the conscience of the king rather than as a hero: see the visuals prepared in phase 2.
126M. Noth, Überlieferungsgeschichtliche Studien, vol. I, Halle, Niemeyer, 1943: the Deuteronomistic history, from Deuteronomy to Kings, written in the exile.
127F. M. Cross, Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic, Harvard UP, 1973 (double redaction); L. Rost, Die Überlieferung von der Thronnachfolge Davids, 1926 (succession narrative).
128Spotting the seams and perspectives: the descriptive contribution of literary criticism remains valuable for reading the composition.
129Supposed sources with no manuscript, shifting boundaries depending on the school, datings dependent on the presupposition: the status remains hypothetical.
130Setting out the modern theses honestly and then showing their limits: the Catholic method of the article, following the Ignispedia compass.
1311 Sam 10 and 11 (accession); 1 Sam 13 and 15 (rejection); 1 Sam 16 and 17 (David at court); 1 Sam 10, 11-12 and 19, 24 (proverb); 1 Sam 17, 4 (stature).
132For part of exegesis, these repetitions betray competing traditions assembled at a late date.
1331 Chr 29, 29 (three sources for one reign): the biblical method itself admits several accounts of the same event without seeing contradiction in them.
134Stylistic partition, dating by a theory of religious evolution, then proof drawn from the partition: the circle must be named.
135A consultation condemned by the Law (Deut 18, 10-12) and a prophecy fulfilled: two scandals for the naturalistic reading.
136Augustine, On the Care for the Dead (De cura pro mortuis gerenda), ch. 15-18: doubt about the identity of the apparition, a spirit taking on Samuel's features.
1371 Sam 28, 12-19: the woman sees, Saul recognises, "Samuel" speaks and prophesies; Sir 46, 20 confirms the traditional reading.
138Excluding any intervention from beyond the grave by principle, then concluding that the account is legendary: the verdict is contained in the presupposition.
139Talmudic attribution, gloss of the seer, Qumran, Septuagint, Ben Sira, Josephus, apostles, Jerome: eight converging links pointing to antiquity.
140No manuscript of the supposed sources, no trace of fabrication, no recipient community for a fraud: the late hypothesis remains without substance.
141Vatican II, Dei Verbum, 18 November 1965, § 11: Scripture teaches firmly, faithfully and without error the truth that is for the sake of salvation.
142