Saint John the Baptist is, in the New Testament, the Forerunner: the child announced to Zechariah by the angel Gabriel, the voice crying out in the wilderness, the preacher of a baptism of conversion in the Jordan, the witness who points to Jesus as the Lamb of God, the friend of the Bridegroom who steps aside with joy, and the martyr beheaded at Machaerus on the orders of Herod Antipas. No figure in the Gospels, apart from Christ and his Mother, receives such prominence: some thirty direct passages, spread across the four Gospels and the Acts of the Apostles, from the infancy in Luke to the memory of the early communities of Ephesus[1].
His scriptural record is unique for a second reason: it is confirmed from outside. The Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, who is not a Christian, devotes to him around 93-94 an entire passage of his Jewish Antiquities: a preacher called the Baptist, a baptism linked to virtue, an execution ordered by Herod, who feared his influence[2]. For the historian, John the Baptist is among the best-attested figures of the whole Gospel.
The article first presents the Baptist as the Church receives Scripture: the inventory of passages, the sacred authors and their traditional dating, the ancient witnesses to the text, then the complete journey of the scenes, from the annunciation to Zechariah to the memory in Acts, the theology that the New Testament already teaches about the Forerunner, the reception among the Fathers and in the liturgy, the common objections with their answers, and finally the debate with modern historical-critical exegesis. The life of the saint, his spirituality of humility and his cult belong to the article devoted to Saint John the Baptist, the Forerunner; the great feast of his birth, to the article on the Nativity of Saint John the Baptist (24 June); the scenes in which his relative, the Virgin, appears, to the dossier on The Virgin Mary in the New Testament, and the childhood seen from the side of the foster father, to the dossier on Saint Joseph in the New Testament.
John the Baptist in the canon: the inventory of passages
A dossier vaster than any other after Jesus and his Mother
John the Baptist appears in four of the seven sections of the New Testament: the three Synoptic Gospels, the fourth Gospel, and the Acts of the Apostles. Only the apostolic letters and the Apocalypse do not name him directly, and this silence has an explanation of genre, as we shall see. The table below gives the complete inventory of direct passages, in the order of the canon[3].
| Book | Passage | Scene |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew | Mt 3:1-12 | Preaching in the wilderness, baptism of conversion |
| Matthew | Mt 3:13-17 | The baptism of Jesus, the voice of the Father |
| Matthew | Mt 11:2-19 | The question in prison, the praise of Christ |
| Matthew | Mt 14:1-12 | Herod, Herodias, the martyrdom |
| Matthew | Mt 16:14 | The crowd takes Jesus for the risen John |
| Matthew | Mt 17:10-13 | Elijah has already come: the disciples understand |
| Matthew | Mt 21:23-32 | Did John's baptism come from heaven? |
| Mark | Mk 1:1-8 | The beginning of the Gospel, the voice |
| Mark | Mk 1:9-11 | The baptism of Jesus, the heavens torn open |
| Mark | Mk 2:18 | The disciples of John fast |
| Mark | Mk 6:14-29 | Herod's banquet, the head on a platter |
| Mark | Mk 8:28 | Some say John the Baptist, others Elijah |
| Mark | Mk 9:11-13 | Elijah has come, and they did to him whatever they pleased |
| Mark | Mk 11:27-33 | The chief priests dare not judge John's baptism |
| Luke | Lk 1:5-80 | Annunciation to Zechariah, birth, Benedictus |
| Luke | Lk 3:1-22 | The fifteenth year of Tiberius, preaching, the baptism of Jesus |
| Luke | Lk 7:18-35 | The question in prison, the praise, the children in the marketplace |
| Luke | Lk 9:7-9 | Herod perplexed: John, I beheaded him |
| Luke | Lk 11:1 | Teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples |
| Luke | Lk 16:16 | The Law and the Prophets until John |
| Luke | Lk 20:1-8 | From heaven or from men, the baptism of John? |
| John | Jn 1:6-8 | He was not the Light, but the witness |
| John | Jn 1:15 | He who comes after me has passed before me |
| John | Jn 1:19-34 | The interrogation, the Lamb of God, the dove |
| John | Jn 3:22-30 | The final testimony: he must increase |
| John | Jn 4:1 | Jesus baptizes more than John (through his disciples) |
| John | Jn 5:33-35 | The lamp that burns and shines |
| John | Jn 10:40-42 | Beyond the Jordan, where John was baptizing |
| Acts | Acts 1:5.21-22 | The baptism of water, the criterion since John |
| Acts | Acts 10:37 | The preaching after the baptism proclaimed by John |
| Acts | Acts 13:24-25 | John preaching before the coming, unworthy of the sandals |
| Acts | Acts 18:25 | Apollos knowing only the baptism of John |
| Acts | Acts 19:1-7 | The twelve of Ephesus rebaptized in the name of Jesus |
Two childhoods told, two complementary perspectives
Matthew and Luke are the only ones to recount the origin of the Baptist, and they do not do so in the same way: Matthew says nothing of his birth and makes him emerge as an adult in the wilderness, clothed in camel's hair, whereas Luke devotes his entire first chapter to him, the annunciation to Zechariah, the Visitation, the birth, and the canticle of the father[4]. Far from contradicting each other, the two perspectives fit together: Matthew writes for Jewish Christians who already know John's kinship with Jesus and goes straight to the preaching, while Luke the investigator traces back to the family origins, with priestly details, the division of Abijah, the descent of Aaron, which betray a source close to the Temple[5].
The silence of Paul and the letters, and what it means
Paul never names John the Baptist, and neither does the Apocalypse. This silence has an explanation of literary genre, not a dogmatic import: Paul writes occasional letters to the Churches, not lives of Jesus, and the Apocalypse is a prophecy of the conquering Christ, not an account of the ministry[6]. When Luke, Paul's companion, recounts the history of Christian origins in Acts, John figures there five times: the criterion for the apostolic witness, the starting point of the preaching, the forerunner preached by Paul himself at Pisidian Antioch, and the living memory of the communities of Ephesus[7]. The silence of the letters is therefore not an absence from the dossier, but the mark of his place: John belongs to the narrative of the beginnings, which the letters presuppose and the Gospels recount.
The Received Authors and Dating of the Baptist Dossier
Matthew the Apostle: the Sober Baptist of the Beginnings
The earliest tradition makes the first Gospel the work of the apostle Matthew, the tax collector turned disciple, written first for the Jewish Christians. As early as the first half of the second century, Papias of Hierapolis attests that Matthew compiled the Lord's oracles in the Hebrew dialect[8], a testimony preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea in his Ecclesiastical History[9]. Clement of Alexandria confirms that the genealogical Gospels, Matthew and Luke, were written first[10]. Matthew's Baptist is sober and striking: emergence in the wilderness, preaching of the nearby Kingdom, the baptism of Jesus in a few verses, the question in prison, the martyrdom told in one stroke. The Church receives this account as that of a witness, before the ruin of Jerusalem, in the years 40 to 60 according to the traditional dating[11].
Mark, Peter's Interpreter: the Most Tense Account
Mark opens his Gospel with John, and the same tradition explains it: Mark is Peter's interpreter in Rome, who sets down the Apostle's preaching after his departure, that is, after his martyrdom under Nero[12]. Now Peter's preaching, as Acts summarizes it, begins precisely with the baptism of John: Mark therefore begins where the kerygma begins[13]. His account of the martyrdom is the most detailed of the four, with the banquet, the dance, the oath, and the platter, like a closely reported memory. The Church dates this Gospel to the years 60, before 67, during the lifetime of the Roman memory of Peter[14].
Luke the Investigator: the Priestly Infancy and the Imperial Chronology
Luke opens his Gospel with a historian's dedication: he has carefully investigated everything from the origins among those who were eyewitnesses from the beginning, so as to write an orderly account for Theophilus[15]. The unanimous tradition, from Irenaeus of Lyons to the Muratorian Canon, sees in him the physician of Antioch, Paul's companion, who sets down the Gospel preached by the Apostle[16][17]. It is he who gives the Baptist dossier its two most precisely dated pieces: the priestly infancy of the first chapter, with its details of classes, kinships, and canticles, and the imperial synchronism of the third, the fifteenth year of Tiberius, Pontius Pilate, Herod, Philip, Lysanias, Annas and Caiaphas, seven verifiable proper names that anchor the preaching of John in datable history[18]. Since Acts ends with Paul's Roman captivity, around 62–63, without mentioning his death or the ruin of Jerusalem, the Church dates the Gospel of Luke to the years 60 to 63, and Acts to 62–63[19].
"Since many have undertaken to compose an account of the events accomplished among us, as those who were from the beginning eyewitnesses and ministers of the Word have handed them down to us, I too have decided, after carefully investigating everything from the origins, to write it down for you in an orderly account, most excellent Theophilus." — Saint Luke, Lk 1:1–3[20]
John the Witness: the Jordan Seen by the Disciple
The fourth Gospel tells neither the infancy nor the martyrdom of John, but it gives the Baptist the most theological words of the whole dossier: the Lamb of God, the dove, the Bridegroom's friend, the lamp. The tradition, carried by Irenaeus who claims the authority of Polycarp, a disciple of John himself, attributes this Gospel to the apostle John, son of Zebedee, at Ephesus, at the end of the first century[21]. The detail of the testimony betrays a witness of the Jordan: the precise hour, the tenth hour, when two disciples leave the Baptist to follow Jesus, and the next day noted twice, like the marks of a personal memory[22]. The Church therefore receives the words of the Precursor as the testimony of the one who heard them on the bank, before becoming himself a disciple of Christ.
Acts: the Apostolic Memory of the Baptist
Acts, by the same Luke, shows that the Baptist is not merely a figure of the past: he is the official starting point of the apostolic memory. Judas's replacement must have followed Jesus from the baptism of John[23]. Peter summarizes the preaching by starting from the baptism proclaimed by John[24]. Paul, preaching at Antioch in Pisidia, presents John as preaching before the coming of Christ a baptism of repentance to all the people of Israel[25]. And twenty-five years after the cross, disciples met at Ephesus know only the baptism of John, before being baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus[26]. The Baptist dossier thus overflows the Gospels: it structures the preaching of the nascent Church.
Flavius Josephus: the Jewish Witness of 93–94
This is the external jewel of the dossier. Flavius Josephus, a Jewish priest turned historian in Rome, devotes an entire passage of Book XVIII of his Jewish Antiquities to John the Baptist, written around 93–94 AD, a generation after the events[27]:
"Herod had him put to death, although he was a good man, who exhorted the Jews to practice virtue, to be just one toward another and pious toward God, and so to come to baptism." — Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 117[28]
Josephus independently confirms the key points of the Gospels: a preacher surnamed the Baptist, a baptism tied to moral conversion, an immense crowd that attaches itself to him, and an execution ordered by Herod Antipas, who feared his influence and had him chained at Machaerus[29]. Unlike the famous passage about Jesus, whose authenticity is debated, this text on John enjoys consensus among historians: it is cited as early as Origen, around 248, and no serious evidence calls its Josephine origin into question[30]. A non-Christian historian, writing for Rome with the archives of the time, thus attests to the Baptist as a fact.
The Ancient Witnesses to the Text of the Baptist
| Witness | Received Date | What It Attests |
|---|---|---|
| Papias of Hierapolis | First half of the 2nd century | Matthew in Hebrew dialect, Mark as Peter's interpreter |
| Flavius Josephus | Around 93–94 | John the Baptist, his baptism, his death by Herod |
| Saint Justin, Apologies | Around 155–160 | The memoirs of the apostles read every Sunday with the prophets |
| Muratorian Canon | Around 170–200, Rome | Luke as Paul's companion, John as the fourth Gospel |
| Tatian, Diatessaron | Around 170 | Harmony of the four Gospels, Baptist dossier included |
| Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies | Around 180 | The four Gospels, neither more nor less, and their authors |
| Papyrus P52 | Around 125 | Fragment of John already circulating in Egypt |
From the middle of the second century, Justin attests that the communities read every Sunday the memoirs composed by the apostles or by those who followed them, on equal footing with the prophets[31]. Around 170, Tatian blends the four Gospels into a single continuous narrative, proof that they circulate together and complete, Baptist included[32]. Irenaeus, who knew Polycarp, John's disciple, fixes the doctrine of the four: neither more, nor less[33]. And the papyrus P52, a fragment of the Gospel of John copied in Egypt around 125, proves materially the early spread of the fourth Gospel, the one that carries the highest testimony of the Precursor[34]. Add to this chain the Jewish witness of 93–94, and the Baptist dossier appears as one of the best attested in the whole New Testament.
The Child of the Promise: the Annunciation to Zechariah and the Birth
Gabriel in the Temple and the muteness of Zechariah
The Gospel of Luke opens its entire account with John's parents. Zechariah is a priest of the division of Abijah, one of the twenty-four priestly divisions that served in the Temple in turn, and his wife Elizabeth is a descendant of Aaron[35]. Luke describes them as righteous before God, but childless, for Elizabeth was barren and both were advanced in age[36]. This barrenness places John in the line of miraculous births of the Old Testament — Isaac, Samson, Samuel — which always herald an exceptional mission. As Zechariah offers incense in the sanctuary, the angel Gabriel appears to him and announces a son whose mission he already describes:
"Your wife Elizabeth will bear you a son, and you shall name him John. You will have joy and gladness, and many will rejoice at his birth, for he will be great in the sight of the Lord. He will be filled with the Holy Spirit from his mother's womb, and he will turn many of the children of Israel to the Lord their God. He will go before him with the spirit and power of the prophet Elijah." — Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 13-17[37]
Three decisive traits are already established: John will be filled with the Holy Spirit from his mother's womb, he will turn Israel back to God, and he will go before the Lord with the spirit of Elijah. Because he doubts this promise, Zechariah is struck mute until the word is fulfilled, a sign that is both punishment and guarantee[38].
The Visitation: the leaping of the Precursor
Six months later, the Virgin Mary, who has just conceived Christ, goes in haste to Elizabeth's house. At her greeting, the child leaps in his mother's womb, and Elizabeth, filled with the Holy Spirit, cries out: "Blessed are you among women"[39]. Catholic tradition has seen in this leaping the sanctification of John in his mother's womb: at the touch of the still-hidden Christ, the child is purified from original sin even before being born. This is why the Church celebrates his birth as that of a being already holy, a privilege he shares only with the Virgin[40][41]. The scene, the first still intrauterine encounter between the Precursor and his Lord, is told from Mary's side in the file on The Virgin Mary in the New Testament.
The Birth and the Benedictus, the Precursor's charter
At the child's birth, the neighbours wish to name him Zechariah, after his father. Elizabeth objects: he shall be called John. The mute father is then asked, and he writes on a tablet: "John is his name"[42]. At that instant his mouth is opened and he prophesies the great canticle the Church sings every morning at Lauds, the Benedictus:
"And you, little child, shall be called prophet of the Most High: for you will go before the face of the Lord, to prepare his ways, to give his people knowledge of salvation by the forgiveness of their sins." — Canticle of Zechariah, Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 76-77[43]
The Benedictus condenses John's entire vocation: prophet of the Most High, herald of salvation through the forgiveness of sins, the dawn that precedes the rising Sun. Luke concludes soberly: the child grew and his spirit was strengthened, and he remained in the deserts until the day of his manifestation to Israel[44].
The Voice in the Desert: Preaching and the Baptism of Repentance
The fifteenth year of Tiberius: a dated preaching
Luke dates precisely the beginning of John's public mission: the fifteenth year of the reign of the emperor Tiberius, that is, around AD 28–29, under Pontius Pilate, Herod, Philip, Lysanias, Annas and Caiaphas[45]. The word of God then comes to him in the desert, and he travels throughout the region of the Jordan. The four Gospels see in this preaching the fulfilment of a prophecy of Isaiah:
"A voice cries in the desert: Prepare the way of the Lord, make his paths straight. Every valley shall be filled, every mountain and every hill shall be brought low; the crooked places shall become straight, the rough roads smooth, and all flesh shall see the salvation of God." — Isaiah 40, 3-5, cited in Luke 3, 4-6[46]
Asked about his identity by the priests and Levites, John refuses every title: he is not the Christ, nor Elijah in person, nor the Prophet. He defines himself solely as that voice: "I am the voice of one crying in the desert"[47]. His very clothing preaches: clad in camel's hair, with a leather belt, feeding on locusts and wild honey, he deliberately takes up the garment of the prophet Elijah[48][49].
A baptism of repentance, not yet the sacrament
John's central gesture is a baptism: he plunges into the Jordan those who confess their sins, in view of repentance, for the forgiveness of sins[50]. But this baptism remains preparatory: it does not yet confer the grace of the sacrament, it disposes one to it. John himself marks the difference clearly:
"I baptise you with water, in view of repentance. But he who is coming after me is mightier than I, and I am not worthy to carry his sandals. He will baptise you with the Holy Spirit and fire." — Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 11[51]
The Church has always carefully distinguished these two baptisms, on the basis of the Acts of the Apostles and the Catechism[52]:
| Aspect | John's baptism | Christian baptism |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Preparatory rite of penance | Sacrament instituted by Christ |
| Effect | Disposes one to repentance | Takes away sin and gives grace |
| Gift of the Spirit | No, baptism with water | Yes, with the Holy Spirit and fire |
| Scope | Directed toward the coming Messiah | Incorporates into the dead and risen Christ |
This is why, according to Acts, the disciples who had received only John's baptism were afterwards baptised in the name of the Lord Jesus[53]. John's baptism is the dawn; Christ's baptism is the full daylight. For the sacrament itself, see the article on Baptism.
To the crowds, to the tax collectors, to the soldiers: a concrete morality
John's preaching is not a vague exhortation: to each category of his listeners he gives a precise instruction. To the crowds: whoever has two garments, let him share with him who has none. To the tax collectors: demand nothing more than what is fixed for you. To the soldiers: do violence to no one, bring no false accusation, and be content with your wages[54]. This concrete justice matches exactly what Josephus retained of him: a teacher who preached virtue, justice towards one another, and piety towards God[55].
Brood of vipers: the axe at the root
John flatters no one. To the Pharisees and Sadducees who come to him, he delivers a burning warning that already heralds judgment:
"Brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Already the axe lies at the root of the trees: every tree that does not produce good fruit is going to be cut down and thrown into the fire." — Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 7-10[56]
This freedom of speech, which shrinks before no religious or political authority, is the mark of the prophet. Applied to the king himself, it will lead him to martyrdom.
From heaven or from men: the authority of John's baptism
During his final ascent to Jerusalem, Jesus is challenged by the chief priests and elders to say by what authority he acts. He agrees to answer on one condition: that they first tell him whence came John's baptism[57]:
"John's baptism, where did it come from? From heaven or from men?" Gospel according to Saint Matthew 21, 25[58]
The trap closes on those who set it. If they answer from heaven, Jesus will ask them why they did not believe his word. If they answer from men, they fear the crowd, for all hold John to be a prophet[59]. So they dodge with a "we do not know," and Jesus in turn refuses to say by what authority he acts. The maneuver reveals two things: John's authority is so firmly established, even among his adversaries, that it serves as a public standard, and the fate meted out to the Baptist foreshadows that of Christ. Those who rejected the voice will reject the Word. Mark and Luke recount the same exchange, in the Temple, during Holy Week[60].
The Baptism of Jesus: the High Point of the Testimony
Behold the Lamb of God
The high point of John's mission is the moment when the Messiah he announced comes to him. Jesus comes from Galilee to the Jordan to be baptized. John, who knows himself to be infinitely inferior, refuses at first: it is I who need to be baptized by you, and yet you come to me[61]. Jesus calms him: it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness in this way. The next day, seeing Jesus coming toward him, John speaks the words that sum up all of Scripture:
"Behold the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world. It is of him that I said: The man who comes after me has passed before me, for before me, he was." — Gospel according to Saint John 1:29-30[62]
This designation, the Lamb of God, links in a single phrase the paschal lamb of Exodus, the suffering Servant of Isaiah 53, and the sacrifice of the Cross. It is the formula the priest repeats at every Mass before Communion. John is thus the first in all of history to point to Christ as the victim of salvation. The next day again, repeating "Behold the Lamb of God" before two of his disciples, he sees them leave his company to follow Jesus: his first apostolic fruit[63].
The Theophany of the Jordan: the Spirit and the Voice of the Father
At the moment of the baptism occurs the first manifestation of the Trinity in the Gospel. John is its eyewitness:
"I saw the Spirit come down from heaven like a dove, and it remained upon him. The one on whom you see the Spirit come down and remain, he it is who baptizes in the Holy Spirit. Yes, I have seen, and I testify that he is the Son of God." — Gospel according to Saint John 1:32-34[64]
The Son is in the water, the Spirit descends in the form of a dove, and the voice of the Father resounds: this is my beloved Son, in whom I find my joy[65]. John had received the specific mission of recognizing this sign. His entire vocation culminates in this instant: he saw, and he bore witness. The Catechism sees in the baptism of Jesus the acceptance by Christ of his mission as suffering Servant, he the sinless one who allows himself to be counted among sinners to fulfill all righteousness[66].
The Witness Who Decreases
He Must Increase, and I Must Decrease
Once the Messiah has been designated, John's mission is in a sense accomplished, and he knows it. When his own disciples express concern at seeing the crowds leave John to follow Jesus, the Precursor replies with the highest word in all the spirituality of self-effacement:
"He who has the bride is the bridegroom; but the friend of the bridegroom, who stands by and hears him, rejoices greatly at the bridegroom's voice. Such is my joy; it is complete. He must increase, and I must decrease." — Gospel according to Saint John 3:29-30[67]
John presents himself as the friend of the Bridegroom: the role, in Jewish weddings, of the one who prepares and leads the bride, then joyfully steps aside when the bridegroom appears. His joy is not diminished by his self-effacement: it is brought to fulfillment by it. This is the heart of the Baptist's holiness, and the model for every disciple: not to show oneself, but to show Christ.
Are You the One Who Is to Come: the Question from Prison
The Gospel does not hide John's trial. Imprisoned by Herod, in the darkness of his dungeon, he sends his disciples to ask Jesus a heartrending question:
"Are you the one who is to come, or are we to expect another?" — Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11:3[68]
Far from being a scandal, this question speaks the human truth of the saint: even the greatest of prophets passes through the night of faith. Jesus does not answer with a title, but with the messianic signs of Isaiah: the blind see, the lame walk, lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor receive the Good News[69]. Then, before the crowds, he pronounces the following praise of John. The Precursor's night thus prepares his greatest glory: to be praised by Christ himself.
The Lamp That Burns and Shines
Elsewhere, Jesus compares John to a lamp:
"John was the lamp that burns and shines, and you were willing, for a while, to rejoice in his light." — Gospel according to Saint John 5:35[70]
The lamp is not the light of day: it shines in the night and goes out when the sun comes. This is exactly the function of the Precursor in the economy of salvation: to illuminate the waiting, then to fade before the Day. Those who had rejoiced for a while in his light should have followed his finger to Christ.
The School of John: Disciples, Fasting, and Prayer
John does not preach alone: he forms disciples who fast, who pray according to a rule received from him, and who remain attached to him after his death. People come to ask Jesus why his own disciples do not fast, whereas those of John and those of the Pharisees do[71]. Jesus answers with the image of the wedding: as long as the Bridegroom is with them, the guests do not fast, but days will come when the Bridegroom is taken away from them, and then they will fast[72]. Later, it is upon seeing Jesus pray that a disciple asks him: Lord, teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples[73]. The Baptist thus left a school of prayer well enough established to serve as a model for the Twelve themselves.
This school outlives its master. John is still baptizing at Aenon, near Salim, where water is abundant, while Jesus too is baptizing in Judea, and his disciples are troubled by it: Rabbi, the one who was with you on the other side of the Jordan, he is now baptizing, and everyone is going to him[74]. It is to this complaint that the last great testimony replies: he must increase. The evangelist notes, moreover, that it was not Jesus himself who was baptizing, but his disciples[75]. And twenty years after the Cross, Apollos preaches in Ephesus with fervor, knowing only the baptism of John, before Aquila and Priscilla set out the Way to him more exactly[76]. To the end of the dossier, even in Acts, the imprint of the school remains: beyond the Jordan, where John had baptized at the beginning, many came to Jesus declaring that everything John had said about him was true, and there, many believed in him[77].
The greatest among the children of women
The praise of Christ, without parallel in the gospel
As soon as John's disciples had gone, Jesus turned to the crowd and delivered a panegyric on the Precursor without parallel anywhere in the gospel:
"What did you go out into the desert to see? A reed swayed by the wind? A prophet? Yes, I tell you, and more than a prophet. Amen, I say to you: among the children of women there has been none greater than John the Baptist; and yet the least in the kingdom of Heaven is greater than he." — Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 7-11[78]
The final sentence contains the whole theology of the threshold: John is the greatest of the Old World, yet the humblest baptized member of the Kingdom receives a new grace that John, who died before the Passover, never knew on earth. He is more than a prophet, because he does not content himself with announcing from afar: he points his finger, he baptizes, he touches the Messiah with his own hands.
The new Elijah
At last Jesus explicitly identifies John with the prophet Elijah, whom Malachi announced before the Day of the Lord: he is the Elijah who is to come[79]. And after the Transfiguration: Elijah has already come, and instead of recognizing him, they did to him whatever they pleased, which the disciples understood to mean John the Baptist[80]. Not that John is Elijah reincarnated — he himself denied this before the priests[81]. But he comes with the spirit and power of Elijah[82], fulfilling the figure of the prophet who prepares the coming of God: the same desert, the same garment of hair, the same courage before kings, the same taking up to God, through martyrdom rather than by the fiery chariot.
The violent, the tax collectors, the prostitutes: the Kingdom contested
In the same discourse in which he praises John, Jesus describes what has been at play since the Baptist: from the days of John, the kingdom of Heaven suffers violence, and men of violence seek to seize it[83]. Luke draws the same boundary more tightly: the Law and the Prophets were until John, and since then the kingdom of God is proclaimed, everyone putting all his strength into it[84]. John is the hinge: with him the time of waiting ends, and the time begins when one must enter with all one's strength — that is, through a conversion that yields nothing.
And here is the reversal Jesus observes: all the people who listened to John, including the tax collectors, by receiving his baptism acknowledged that God was just, while the Pharisees and the doctors of the Law, by refusing his baptism, rejected God's purpose for themselves[85]. To the chief priests who dispute his authority, Jesus applies the lesson without detour:
"Amen, I say to you: the tax collectors and the prostitutes go before you into the kingdom of God. For John the Baptist came to you in the way of righteousness, and you did not believe his word." Gospel according to Saint Matthew 21, 31-32[86]
The statement canonizes neither taxation nor debauchery: it observes that public sinners, by believing John, entered through the door that the religious notables refused. The Baptist is thus the touchstone of the Kingdom: each person is revealed in it according to the welcome or the refusal he gave him.
The martyrdom: Herod, Herodias, and Machaerus
It is not lawful for you to have your brother's wife
John's prophetic courage is his undoing. He had publicly reproached the tetrarch Herod Antipas for having married Herodias, the wife of his half-brother Herod, son of Herod the Great — a union forbidden by Mosaic law[87]:
"It is not lawful for you to have your brother's wife." — Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 18[88]
Herodias, wounded, bore a grudge against John and sought to have him killed. But Herod, ambivalent, feared him: he knew that he was a righteous and holy man, and when he heard him he was greatly perplexed, yet he listened to him with pleasure[89]. John was therefore imprisoned, but at first protected by the king's troubled fascination.
Machaerus: Josephus complements the gospels
It is the historian Flavius Josephus who gives us the place and the political motive of the execution, which the gospels do not specify. Herod feared John's influence over the crowds:
"As many people flocked around him, for they were profoundly stirred by his words, Herod took fright: such power of persuasion could incite some revolt. He was therefore, on Herod's suspicion, sent in chains to Machaerus, the fortress we have mentioned, and there put to death." — Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 118-119[90]
The gospels and Josephus complement each other without contradiction: the religious motive — the reproach of the marriage — and the political motive — the fear of an uprising — coexist in one and the same tyrant. The fortress of Machaerus, rising above the Dead Sea in Perea, has been identified by archaeology, and the remains of the Herodian citadel are still shown there[91].
The dance of Salome and the oath of Herod
The occasion of the murder is a birthday banquet. Herodias' daughter, whom Josephus names Salome[92], dances before Herod and his guests. Charmed, the king swears to grant her whatever she asks, up to half his kingdom. Urged on by her mother, the young girl demands:
"I want you to give me at once the head of John the Baptist on a platter." — Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 25[93]
The king was deeply distressed, Mark notes, but because of his oath and his guests he did not wish to refuse her[94]. A guard beheads John in the prison; the head is brought on a platter and given to the young girl, who gives it to her mother. John's disciples came and took his body and laid it in a tomb[95]. Thus dies, victim of the vanity and human respect of a cowardly king, the greatest of the prophets.
Dying for the truth of marriage
The martyrdom of John has a precise doctrinal significance that the tradition has never ceased to emphasize: he dies for the truth of marriage. By refusing to endorse Herod's adulterous union, he bears witness that the moral law holds even for kings, and that the prophet must speak it even unto blood. Precursor in birth, precursor in preaching, John is so also in death, preceding the Savior even into martyrdom[96]. This is what the feast of the Passion of Saint John the Baptist, on 29 August, celebrates.
The timeline of the Precursor: from Tiberius to the block
- Around 7-5 BCThe announcement and the birth
Gabriel speaks to Zechariah in the Temple, the Visitation, the birth six months before Jesus according to tradition, and the Benedictus (Lk 1).
- Around AD 28-29The preaching at the Jordan
In the fifteenth year of Tiberius, John proclaims a baptism of conversion in the region of the Jordan and the crowds flock to him (Lk 3:1-14).
- Around AD 29-30The baptism of Jesus
Jesus comes from Galilee, John points to him as the Lamb of God, the dove descends and the voice of the Father resounds (Mt 3; Jn 1).
- Around AD 30The imprisonment
John rebukes Herod Antipas for his marriage to Herodias and ends up in chains, first heeded, then forgotten (Mk 6:17-20).
- Around AD 30-32The martyrdom at Machaerus
The banquet, the dance, the oath, the dish: John is beheaded and his disciples lay him to rest (Mk 6:21-29; Josephus, XVIII, 118-119).
- Around AD 33-58The apostolic remembrance
The criterion established since John for the witness, the preaching of Peter and Paul, the disciples of Ephesus re-baptized (Acts 1; 10; 13; 19).
These dates follow the traditional chronology: John born shortly before Jesus, under Herod the Great, preaching straddling the years 28-29, martyrdom before the Passion of Christ, since Acts already speaks of the Baptist in the past. The uncertainties concern months, never the overall pattern: a brief, intense ministry, sealed by blood before the cross.
What the New Testament already teaches about John
More than a prophet: the hinge of the two Testaments
The Catechism sums up the threshold position of the Baptist: in John the Precursor, the Holy Spirit completes the preparation of a people well disposed for the Lord, and in him the cycle of prophets begun by Elijah comes to an end[97][98]:
"John is more than a prophet. In him the Holy Spirit brings to completion the speaking through the prophets. John completes the cycle of prophets begun by Elijah. He proclaims the imminence of the Consolation of Israel; he is the voice of the consoler who is coming. As the Spirit of Truth will do, he comes as a witness, to bear witness to the Light." — Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 719[99]
John still belongs to the world of the prophets who awaited the Messiah, yet he has the privilege of pointing him out. He is the last of the prophets of the Old Covenant and, at the same time, the first witness of the New: the living hinge between the two Testaments.
The friend of the Bridegroom: the joy of decreasing
The fourth gospel gives the Baptist his most intimate title: the friend of the Bridegroom, the one who leads the bride to Christ and rejoices at his voice[100]. Saint Augustine famously expressed John's relationship to Christ: John is the voice, but the Lord, in the beginning, was the Word. John, a voice for a time; Christ, the Word in the beginning, eternal[101]:
"Let John decrease, let Christ increase: this is what the voice itself says. The voice that has fulfilled its office passes away; but the Word it made heard remains forever." — after Saint Augustine, Sermon 293[102]
The preparatory baptism and the new birth
Finally, with John the Baptist, the Holy Spirit inaugurates, by prefiguring it, what he will accomplish with and in Christ: restoring to man the divine likeness. John's baptism was for repentance; the one in water and the Spirit will be a new birth[103]. The whole dossier of the Baptist thus tends toward Pentecost: the voice prepares, the water disposes, and the Spirit accomplishes.
The reception in the Church: Fathers, feasts and liturgy
The Fathers: the voice and the Word
From the 2nd century onwards, the Fathers cite the Baptist as proof and as a model. Justin sees in him the fulfilment of Isaiah and Malachi in dialogue with Trypho[104]. Irenaeus makes John the seal of the prophets, the one in whom the Spirit completes his speaking[105]. Origen is the first to set before the pagans the testimony of Josephus about John as external confirmation of the gospel[106]. But it is Augustine, preaching every 24 June at Hippo, who gives the Precursor his definitive theology: the voice that passes, the Word that abides, and the Church that celebrates the birth of John as a sacred thing, as she does for no other saint but the Virgin[107].
The two feasts and the Benedictus at Lauds
The cult of John the Baptist is one of the oldest in the Church, and one of the most singular: for only three persons does the Church celebrate the earthly birth — Christ at Christmas, the Virgin on 8 September, and John on 24 June[108].
| Feast | Date | Object | Antiquity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nativity | 24 June | His birth, six months before Christmas | Solemnity attested since the 4th century |
| Passion | 29 August | His martyrdom by beheading | Memorial attested since the 4th century |
The date of 24 June combines the gospel's indication, Elizabeth in her sixth month when Gabriel speaks to Mary, and the traditional date of Christmas: the birth of John is placed six months before that of Christ[109][110]. The Fathers saw in this a sign: at John's birth the days grow shorter, at Christ's they grow longer, for he must increase and John decrease[111]. Each morning, at Lauds, the Church sings the Benedictus of Zechariah, and each day she rereads the Baptist in expectation of the Lord. For the details of the great summer feast, see the article dedicated to the Nativity of Saint John the Baptist (24 June), and for the life of the saint himself, the article on Saint John the Baptist, the Precursor.
Common Objections and Responses
If Jesus is without sin, why is he baptized with a baptism of conversion?
This is the objection that John himself was the first to raise: it is I who need to be baptized by you[112]. The answer lies in the words of Christ: it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness in this way. Jesus is not baptized for his sins, of which he has none, but to take upon himself the sin of the world as the Suffering Servant, to sanctify the waters of the future sacrament, and to give the Baptist his final office: to point out the Lamb[113]. Far from lowering Christ, the scene reveals him: it is as he comes up out of the water that heaven opens and the Father speaks.
John doubts in prison: is this the behavior of a true prophet?
Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another? The question from the dungeon seems to contradict the testimony of the Jordan[114]. But the gospel does not canonize impassibility; it recounts faith in the night: Elijah himself asked for death under the broom tree, and Christ knew the agony. Above all, Jesus' reply is not a reproach but a demonstration, the signs of Isaiah, followed by the highest praise ever pronounced upon a man[115]. Tradition sees here a question asked for his disciples rather than for himself: John sends his own to see the signs, so that they may leave his side to follow Christ.
Does Josephus not contradict the gospels on the death of John?
One sometimes opposes Josephus' political motive, fear of a revolt, to the religious motive of the gospels, the reproach over the marriage[116]. But both motives coexist in the same tyrant: Herod could at once fear the prophet's influence and wish to avenge his conjugal honor, and Mark himself shows a king who protects John out of fear before handing him over out of vanity[117]. As for the date, Josephus mentions John's death in connection with Herod's defeat by Aretas in 36, in a thematic flashback, not in a continuous chronicle: his account imposes no late date and remains compatible with an execution around 30-32, before the Passion[118].
Is John Elijah reincarnated?
Jesus says: this is the Elijah who is to come, and John says: I am not Elijah[119][120]. The contradiction is only apparent: John comes with the spirit and the power of Elijah, he fulfills his figure and his function, without being the same person returned[121]. The Church confesses the creation of each soul and the resurrection of the body, not transmigration: the Catholic answer is typology, not reincarnation. Elijah in the fiery chariot, John on the block: the same mission, the same courage, two destinies that answer to each other.
Does the baptism received from John not make Jesus his inferior?
In antiquity, one might think that the baptized placed himself under the authority of the baptizer, and certain Johannine circles sustained this reading. The gospels refute it in advance through the mouth of John himself: the one who comes after me has passed ahead of me, I am not worthy to untie his sandals, he must increase[122][123]. Acts confirms the hierarchy: the baptism of John must be completed by baptism in the name of Jesus, never the other way around[124]. The superior lowers himself for a moment beneath the hand of the inferior, just as he will wash his disciples' feet: it is voluntary self-abasement, not subordination.
Did Jesus himself baptize, yes or no?
The fourth gospel seems to contradict itself a few verses apart: Jesus, it says first, made more disciples than John and baptized more, then it immediately clarifies that it was not Jesus in person who baptized, but his disciples[125]. The contradiction is only apparent: the evangelist first attributes the work to the master, according to the usage that imputes to the leader what his envoys do, then he removes all ambiguity so that Jesus is not made a second Baptist in competition with the first. The clarification protects exactly the hierarchy that John himself had proclaimed: Christ baptizes in the Holy Spirit, his servants dip in the water, and John remains the sole Precursor of the threshold.
The Historical-Critical Debate and Its Limits
What Part of Contemporary Exegesis Proposes
Since the nineteenth century, a strand of exegesis has proposed dating the gospels later than the tradition: Mark around 65-70, Matthew and Luke around 80-90 from Mark and a sayings source known as Q, never found, John around 90-100 or later[126]. In this framework, the Baptist's words would be community compositions: the Lamb of God would reflect Paschal theology rather than the preaching of the Jordan, and Luke's infancy narrative a midrash built on the marvelous births of the Old Testament, theologoumena true in their meaning, without direct historical reach[127]. Josephus would then serve as the only fixed point: everything else would be faith recounted.
The Fragilities of the Reconstruction
This reconstruction piles up the classic fragilities of the science of the past. The Q document has never been found: it is a hypothesis to explain resemblances, promoted to the rank of a lost source, then used as proof of late dating, in a circle[128]. The anti-miraculous presupposition dictates the result: when every precise prediction is classified by default among the later touches, the late dating is presupposed by the method, not demonstrated by the manuscripts[129]. The argument from silence carries little weight: Paul writes occasional letters that presuppose the account of the beginnings without narrating it, while transmitting through Luke, his companion, the fullest dossier on John. And above all, the criterion of embarrassment here speaks in favor of historicity: the baptism of Jesus by John visibly troubled the early Church, since she had to explain it as early as Matthew by the Baptist's refusal, and no inventor of legend would have subjected his Lord to the rite of an inferior[130]. This is why even critical historians admit the baptism of Jesus by John among the best-established facts of his life[131].
Why the Traditional Reading Remains Defensible
Against the late datings, the material facts speak early: the papyrus P52 circulates John in Egypt around 125, Justin reads the apostolic memoirs every Sunday around 155, Tatian weaves them into a single narrative around 170, Irenaeus fixes their four authors around 180[132]. Against the idea of a community invention, the chain of witnesses is short: Irenaeus knew Polycarp, who had known John, the disciple who came out of the Baptist's school[133]. And against the separation of history and faith, the Church has ruled by magisterium: the gospels faithfully transmit what Jesus truly did and taught, declares Vatican II[134], after the Pontifical Biblical Commission had set out in 1964 the three honest stages of the work, the life of Jesus, the preaching of the apostles, the writing of the evangelists, without dissolving the first into the other two[135]. Add the Jewish witness of 93-94, whose authenticity even critics acknowledge, and the dossier on the Baptist appears for what it is: one of the best founded in all of the New Testament[136].
To go further
John the Baptist is best read first in the New Testament itself: Lk 1 and 3, Mt 3 and 11, Mk 1 and 6, Jn 1 and 3, Acts 1, 13 and 19, in the TOB or the Jerusalem Bible, before going on to Saint John the Baptist, the Precursor, the Nativity of Saint John the Baptist (24 June), Baptism, The Virgin Mary in the New Testament, Saint Joseph in the New Testament and the Annunciation of the Lord (25 March). Then consult the Catechism, 523, 535 and 717 to 720, the constitution Dei Verbum, 19, and the instruction Sancta Mater Ecclesia of 1964. For the patristic roots: Justin against Trypho, Irenaeus against heresies, Origen against Celsus, Augustine sermons 287 and 293. For the external witness: Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 116-119.
Notes and References
Inventory of the direct passages in which John the Baptist appears or is named: Mt 3, 1-17; 11, 2-19; 14, 1-12; 16, 14; 17, 10-13; 21, 23-32; Mk 1, 1-11; 2, 18; 6, 14-29; 8, 28; 9, 11-13; 11, 27-33; Lk 1, 5-80; 3, 1-22; 7, 18-35; 9, 7-9; 11, 1; 16, 16; 20, 1-8; Jn 1, 6-8.15.19-34; 3, 22-30; 4, 1; 5, 33-35; 10, 40-42; Acts 1, 5.21-22; 10, 37; 13, 24-25; 18, 25; 19, 1-7. Liturgical translation of the AELF.
1 3Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities (Ιουδαϊκὴ ἀρχαιολογία), book XVIII, ch. 5, § 2 (§ 116-119), c. 93-94 AD: John surnamed the Baptist, a good man preaching virtue, righteousness and piety and a baptism; Herod Antipas, fearing his influence over the crowds, has him chained and put to death at the fortress of Machaerus. A passage whose authenticity is agreed upon by historians (cited as early as Origen, Against Celsus I, 47, c. 248). Reference text: Loeb edition (L. H. Feldman); French translation: Josephus, Antiquités juives, vol. III.
2 27 28 29 55 90 116 136Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 80 (AELF): the child grew and his spirit was strengthened, in the deserts until the day of his manifestation to Israel.
4 44Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah, 1977: Matthew and Luke, independent on the infancy narratives, agree on the essentials, an indication of a tradition prior to both accounts.
5Paul writes occasional letters to the Churches, not accounts of the life of Jesus: his silence about John is a matter of genre, as is that of the Apocalypse, a prophecy of the conquering Christ.
6Acts 1, 21-22: the replacement of Judas must have followed Jesus from the baptism of John; cf. Acts 10, 36-37, Peter's preaching begins with the baptism.
7 13 23Papias of Hierapolis, Explanations of the Sayings of the Lord, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Matthew composed the logia in the Hebrew dialect; Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately what he retained of his preaching.
8 12Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39 (Papias) and VI, 14 (Clement of Alexandria on the order of the gospels), written c. 324.
9Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposeis, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14: the gospels containing the genealogies (Matthew, Luke) were written first.
10Traditional dating of Matthew: the first gospel, in Hebrew then in Greek, intended for Jewish Christians, before the destruction of Jerusalem (70), placed in the years 40 to 60.
11Traditional dating of Mark: in Rome from Peter's preaching, in the years 60, before Peter's martyrdom under Nero (64-67).
14Lk 1, 1-4: prologue of the ordered enquiry, dedicated to Theophilus, from the eyewitnesses.
15 20Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, c. 180: Matthew published his gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul were evangelising Rome; after their departure, Mark handed down Peter's preaching, Luke set down Paul's, and John published his own in Ephesus.
16 21 133Muratorian Canon, Rome, c. 170-200: Luke, companion of Paul though he had not seen the Lord, third gospel; John, fourth, at the request of his fellow disciples.
17Lk 3, 1-2: the fifteenth year of Tiberius (c. 28-29), Pontius Pilate, Herod tetrarch of Galilee, Philip, Lysanias, Annas and Caiaphas.
18 45Traditional dating of Luke and Acts: Luke c. 60-63, Acts c. 62-63, the narrative ending with Paul's Roman captivity without mentioning his death (c. 67) or the destruction of Jerusalem (70).
19Jn 1, 35-42: two disciples leave John to follow Jesus, among them Andrew; the tenth hour noted as a personal memory.
22Acts 10, 36-37: Peter before Cornelius, the preaching after the baptism proclaimed by John, beginning from Galilee.
24Acts 13, 24-25: Paul at Antioch in Pisidia, John preaching before the coming of Christ a baptism of conversion to the whole people of Israel, unworthy to untie the sandals.
25Acts 19, 1-7: the twelve disciples of Ephesus who knew only the baptism of John, afterwards baptised in the name of the Lord Jesus, with the gift of the Spirit.
26 124Origen, Against Celsus, I, 47, c. 248: cites Josephus' testimony about John the Baptist and notes that Josephus did not recognise Jesus as the Christ. Oldest external attestation of the Josephan passage on John.
30 106Saint Justin, First Apology, 66-67, c. 155: on Sunday, one reads the memoirs composed by the apostles, or by those who followed them, together with the writings of the prophets.
31Tatian the Syrian, Diatessaron, c. 170: a harmony of the four gospels into a single continuous narrative, the Baptist dossier included.
32Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 11, 8: there can be neither more nor fewer than four gospels, like the four zones of the world and the four faces of the cherubim.
33Papyrus P52 (Rylands Gr. P. 457), fragment of Jn 18 copied in Egypt and dated c. 125, the oldest material witness to the New Testament.
34 132Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 5 (AELF): Zechariah, a priest of the group of Abia, and his wife Elizabeth, a descendant of Aaron.
35Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 6-7 (AELF): Zechariah and Elizabeth righteous before God, without child because Elizabeth was barren and both were advanced in years.
36Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 13-17 (AELF): announcement of the angel Gabriel to Zechariah; John great before the Lord, filled with the Holy Spirit from his mother's womb, walking with the spirit and the power of the prophet Elijah.
37Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 20 (AELF): Zechariah struck mute until the day of fulfilment, for not having believed the word.
38Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 41-44 (AELF): at Mary's greeting, the child leaps in Elizabeth, filled with the Holy Spirit.
39Catholic Encyclopedia (1913), article Saint John the Baptist, on newadvent.org: birth, sanctification from the womb, ministry, martyrdom, cult and relics.
40 110Catechism of the Catholic Church, n° 717: John was filled with the Holy Spirit from his mother's womb (Lk 1, 15.41) by Christ himself, whom the Virgin Mary has just conceived of the Holy Spirit; the Visitation has become God's visit to his people.
41Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 63 (AELF): Zechariah writes on a tablet, John is his name, and his mouth is opened.
42Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 76-77 (AELF): the Benedictus, you little child prophet of the Most High, going before to prepare the ways of salvation through the remission of sins.
43Lk 3, 4-6 (AELF): the voice in the wilderness according to Isaiah 40, 3-5, every valley filled, every mountain brought low, and all flesh shall see the salvation of God.
46Jn 1, 23 (AELF): I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness, as the prophet Isaiah said.
47Gospel according to Saint Mark 1, 6 (AELF): John clothed in camel's hair, with a leather belt, locusts and wild honey.
482 Kings 1, 8: Elijah described as a hairy man wearing a leather loincloth, a garment taken up by John as a sign of prophetic succession.
49Gospel according to Saint Mark 1, 4 (AELF): John proclaiming a baptism of conversion for the forgiveness of sins.
50Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 11 (AELF): I baptize you with water, the one who is to come will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire.
51Catechism of the Catholic Church, n° 720: with John, the Spirit inaugurates, by prefiguring it, what he will accomplish with and in Christ; John's baptism was for repentance; the one in water and in the Spirit will be a new birth (cf. Jn 3, 5).
52 53 103Gospel according to Saint Luke 3, 10-14 (AELF): the instructions to the crowds, to the tax collectors and to the soldiers: share, do not demand more, do not use violence.
54Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 7-10 (AELF): brood of vipers, the axe at the root, every tree without good fruit cut down and thrown into the fire.
56Gospel according to Saint Matthew 21, 25-26 (AELF): the baptism of John, from heaven or from men, and the fear of the crowd, for all hold John to be a prophet.
57 58Gospel according to Saint Matthew 21, 26 (AELF): answering "from men" would expose one to the crowd, for all hold John to be a prophet.
59Gospel according to Saint Mark 11, 30 (AELF), echoed in Lk 20, 4: the same question about the baptism of John, asked in the Temple during Holy Week.
60Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 14 (AELF): it is I who need to be baptized by you, John said to Jesus.
61 112Jn 1, 29-30 (AELF): behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world, the one who comes after me has passed before me.
62Jn 1, 35-37 (AELF): the next day, saying again behold the Lamb of God, John sees two disciples follow Jesus.
63Jn 1, 32-34 (AELF): I saw the Spirit descend like a dove and remain, this one is the Son of God.
64Gospel according to Saint Matthew 3, 17 (AELF): the voice of the Father, this is my beloved Son, in whom I find my delight.
65Catechism of the Catholic Church, 535: the baptism of Jesus, acceptance and inauguration of his mission as suffering Servant; Jesus, without sin, allows himself to be counted among sinners (cf. Is 53, 12) to fulfil all righteousness.
66 113Jn 3, 29-30 (AELF): the friend of the Bridegroom rejoicing greatly at the voice of the bridegroom, he must increase and I must decrease.
67 123Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 2-3 (AELF): John in prison sends his disciples to ask, are you the one who is to come.
68 114Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 4-6 (AELF): the answer through the signs, the blind, the lame, lepers, the deaf, the dead, the poor have the good news preached to them, according to Is 35, 5-6 and 61, 1.
69Jn 5, 35 (AELF): John was the lamp that burns and shines, and for a while you were willing to rejoice in his light.
70Gospel according to Saint Mark 2, 18-20 (AELF): the fasting of John's disciples, the wedding guests with the Bridegroom, and the days when the Bridegroom will be taken away.
71 72Gospel according to Saint Luke 11, 1 (AELF): Lord, teach us to pray, as John taught his disciples.
73Jn 3, 23-26 (AELF): John baptizes at Aenon near Salim where there is much water, then the complaint of his disciples, everyone is going to him.
74Jn 4, 1-2 (AELF): Jesus makes more disciples than John, but it is his disciples who baptize, not Jesus in person.
75 125Acts 18, 24-28: Apollos of Alexandria, well versed in the Scriptures, knowing only the baptism of John, instructed more accurately by Aquila and Priscilla.
76Jn 10, 40-42 (AELF): across the Jordan where John was baptizing at first, everything John said was true, and many believed in Jesus.
77Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 7-11 (AELF): the praise, more than a prophet, among those born of women none greater than John, and the least in the Kingdom greater than he.
78 115Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 14 (AELF): he is the Elijah who is to come, according to Mal 3, 23-24.
79 119Gospel according to Saint Matthew 17, 12-13 (AELF): Elijah has already come and they did to him whatever they pleased, understood of John the Baptist.
80Jn 1, 21 (AELF): are you Elijah, John is asked, and he answers no, nor the Prophet.
81 120Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 17 (AELF): to go before him with the spirit and the power of Elijah, to prepare for the Lord a people well disposed.
82 121Gospel according to Saint Matthew 11, 12 (AELF): from the days of John, the kingdom of Heaven suffers violence, and men of violence seek to seize it.
83Gospel according to Saint Luke 16, 16 (AELF): the Law and the Prophets go up to John, and since then the kingdom of God is proclaimed.
84Gospel according to Saint Luke 7, 29-30 (AELF): the people and the tax collectors acknowledge God's righteousness by receiving the baptism, while the Pharisees and the lawyers reject God's plan.
85Gospel according to Saint Matthew 21, 31-32 (AELF): the tax collectors and the prostitutes go before you into the Kingdom, for John came in the way of righteousness and they believed his word.
86The Gospels name this husband Philip, the brother of Antipas (Mk 6, 17); Josephus calls him Herod, son of Herod the Great and Mariamne II (Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 5, 1 and 4). A prince without territory, not to be confused with his half-brother Philip the Tetrarch (Lk 3, 1), who will later marry Salome herself (Josephus, XVIII, 5, 4).
87Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 18 (AELF): it is not lawful for you to have your brother's wife.
88Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 19-20 (AELF): Herodias had a grudge against John, Herod feared him as a righteous and holy man and listened to him with pleasure.
89 117Herodian fortress of Machaerus (Machaerus, present-day Jordan), in Perea above the Dead Sea: the place of the execution according to Josephus, XVIII, 119; the citadel was uncovered by the Franciscan excavations of the Studium Biblicum (V. Corbo, 1978-1981), then by the Hungarian mission (G. Vörös, since 2009), with a courtyard and throne apse.
91Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 5, 4 (§ 136): Salome, daughter of Herodias and her first husband; the Gospels (Mt 14, 6; Mk 6, 22) name her only as the daughter of Herodias.
92Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 25 (AELF): the request for the head of John the Baptist on a platter.
93Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 26 (AELF): the king was deeply distressed, but bound by his oath and the guests.
94Gospel according to Saint Mark 6, 29 (AELF): his disciples came, took the body and laid it in a tomb.
95Saint Augustine and the liturgy: John forerunner of Christ in birth, preaching and death; feast of his Passion (Beheading) on 29 August.
96Catechism of the Catholic Church, n° 718: John is Elijah who is to come (Mt 17, 10-13); the fire of the Spirit dwells in him and makes him run ahead, as precursor, before the Lord who comes; in him the Spirit brings to completion the preparation of a people well disposed for the Lord (Lk 1, 17).
97Catechism of the Catholic Church, n° 719: John is more than a prophet (Lk 7, 26); in him the Spirit completes what was spoken through the prophets; he brings to an end the cycle begun by Elijah, announces the Consolation of Israel, and comes as a witness to bear witness to the Light (Jn 1, 7).
98 99Jn 3, 29 (AELF): the one who has the bride, that is the bridegroom, but the friend of the bridegroom stands there and listens to him.
100Saint Augustine, Sermon 293, § 3 (PL 38, 1328-1329), for the Nativity of John the Baptist: John is the voice, but the Lord, in the beginning, was the Word; the voice passes, the Word remains.
101 102Saint Justin, Dialogue with Trypho, 49 and 51, c. 155-160: John as the forerunner Elijah announced by Isaiah and Malachi.
104Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 10-11 and IV: John the last of the prophets, the seal of prophecy, in whom the Spirit brings his speaking to completion.
105Saint Augustine, Sermon 293, § 1: the Church observes the birth of John as a sacred thing, just as she celebrates that of Christ, which she does for no other saint.
107 108Solemnity of the Nativity of Saint John the Baptist, 24 June, six months before Christmas according to Lk 1, 26.36; liturgical texts on vatican.va.
109Patristic tradition taken up by Saint Augustine, Sermon 287: at the birth of John the days grow shorter, at the birth of Christ they grow longer.
111Josephus mentions John's death in connection with Herod's disaster against Aretas IV of Nabataea (36 AD), presented as divine punishment: the passage is a thematic flashback, not a dating of the execution, and remains compatible with a martyrdom around 30-32, before the Passion.
118Jn 1, 30 (AELF): the one who comes after me has passed before me because, before me, he was.
122Two-source hypothesis: Markan priority (65-70), Matthew and Luke (80-90) combining Mark and a sayings source Q, never found, John around the turn of the second century.
126Rudolf Bultmann and demythologization: the origin narratives read as narrative expressions of Easter faith (theologoumena), without direct historical import.
127Passages cut up according to stylistic criteria, dated according to a theory of religious development, then invoked as proof of that development: the reasoning is circular.
128When every precise announcement is classified by default among later additions, the late dating is presupposed by the method, not demonstrated by the manuscripts.
129Criterion of embarrassment: Jesus' baptism by John embarrassed the early Church, which had to explain it as early as Matthew; no inventor would have subjected his Lord to the rite of an inferior.
130John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew, vol. 2, Mentor, Message, and Miracles, Doubleday, New York, 1994: the baptism of Jesus by John among the best-established facts, with the Baptist dossier treated at length.
131Second Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church affirms without hesitation the historicity of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus really did and taught.
134Pontifical Biblical Commission, instruction Sancta Mater Ecclesia, 21 April 1964: the three stages — the life of Jesus, the oral preaching of the apostles, the writing of the evangelists — without dissolving history into the faith of the communities.
135