The Virgin Mary in the New Testament

The Virgin Mary in the New Testament: survey of the passages, traditional authors and dating, Annunciation, Nativity, Cana, the Cross, Revelation, Marian theology in its embryonic form, the Fathers, liturgy, objections and the historical-critical debate.

Ignispedia

The Virgin Mary is, in the New Testament, the Mother of Jesus: the angel Gabriel greets her at Nazareth as full of grace, she conceives by the Holy Spirit without knowing man, she gives birth in Bethlehem, she ponders the events in her heart, she intercedes at Cana, she stands at the foot of the cross where Jesus entrusts her to the beloved disciple, she prays with the apostles before Pentecost, and the Apocalypse shows her as the Woman clothed with the sun. No other woman in Scripture occupies so many pages: some twenty direct passages, spread across the four Gospels, Acts, the letters of Paul and the Apocalypse, from the first chapter of Matthew to the twelfth chapter of Revelation[1].

Her scriptural dossier already contains, in seed, the whole of Marian doctrine: Elizabeth calls her the Mother of my Lord, a title from which the Church will draw the Mother of God at Ephesus in 431; she calls herself the servant who believes, from which the Fathers will draw the new Eve; the angel calls her full of grace, from which the Church will read her immaculate holiness; she asks how she is to bear a child without knowing man, from which the Church will profess her perpetual virginity; heaven shows her crowned, from which the Church will contemplate her Assumption[2].

The article first presents Mary as the Church receives Scripture: the inventory of passages, the sacred authors and their traditional dating, the ancient witnesses of the text, then the complete journey of the scenes, from the Annunciation to the Apocalypse, the theology that the New Testament already teaches, the reception among the Fathers and in the liturgy, the common objections with their answers, and finally the debate with modern historical-critical exegesis. The life of the Holy Family in Nazareth and the role of Joseph belong to the dossier Saint Joseph in the New Testament; the developed dogmas belong to the Immaculate Conception, the Assumption and Mary Mother of God.

Mary in the canon: the inventory of passages

Around twenty scenes, from the first to the last book

Mary appears in five of the seven groupings of the New Testament: the three synoptic Gospels, the fourth Gospel, the Acts of the Apostles, the Pauline letters and the Apocalypse. Only the Catholic letters and the Epistle to the Hebrews do not name her. The table below gives the complete inventory of direct passages, in the order of the canon[3].

BookPassageScene
MatthewMt 1:16-25Genealogy, Joseph's dream, virginal conception
MatthewMt 2:11-23Magi, flight into Egypt, return to Nazareth
MatthewMt 12:46-50His mother and brothers outside, the true kinship
MatthewMt 13:55-56"Is not his mother called Mary?"
MarkMk 3:31-35Mother and brothers, whoever does the will of God
MarkMk 6:1-6At Nazareth, "the son of Mary"
LukeLk 1:26-56Annunciation, Visitation, Magnificat
LukeLk 2:1-52Nativity, shepherds, Presentation, Temple
LukeLk 8:19-21Mother and brothers, hearing the word
LukeLk 11:27-28"Blessed is the womb that bore you"
JohnJn 2:1-11Cana, "Woman", the first sign
JohnJn 19:25-27At the foot of the cross, "behold your mother"
ActsActs 1:14At prayer with the apostles before Pentecost
PaulGal 4:4"Born of a woman", the earliest mention
PaulRom 1:3"Descended from David according to the flesh"
ApocalypseRev 12:1-17The Woman clothed with the sun

Two infancy narratives, two complementary perspectives

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Matthew and Luke are the only ones to recount the childhood of Jesus, and they do not recount the same episodes: Matthew follows Joseph, the just man to whom the angel speaks in a dream, while Luke follows Mary, visited by Gabriel, welcomed by Elizabeth, kneeling at the manger and then standing in the Temple. Far from contradicting each other, the two accounts fit together: the virginal conception, Bethlehem, Nazareth and the Davidic descent are affirmed on both sides, each with its own witnesses, the Magi on one side, the shepherds on the other[4].

The silence of Mark and Paul, and what it means

Mark recounts neither the Annunciation nor the Nativity, and Paul mentions the mother of Jesus only once. This silence has an explanation in terms of literary genre, not dogmatic scope: Mark begins his preaching at the baptism of John, exactly as the apostolic preaching summarized in Acts starts "from the baptism of John"[5], and Paul writes occasional letters, not lives of Jesus, while delivering in his earliest formulas the motherhood and the Davidic descent[6]. When Mark must name Jesus at Nazareth, he calls him "the son of Mary", and when Paul must summarize the Gospel, he writes "born of a woman".

The Received Authors and Dating of the Marian Narratives

Matthew, the apostle tax collector, witness of the Judean childhood

The most ancient tradition makes the infancy gospel according to Matthew the work of the apostle Matthew, the tax collector turned disciple, written first for the Jewish Christians. As early as the first half of the 2nd century, Papias of Hierapolis attests that "Matthew composed the words of the Lord in the Hebrew dialect"[7], a testimony preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea in his Ecclesiastical History[8]. Clement of Alexandria confirms that the genealogical gospels, Matthew and Luke, were written first[9]. The Church thus receives this narrative as that of a witness: Joseph's dreams, the visit of the Magi, the flight into Egypt, and the return to Nazareth are told by an apostle before the ruin of Jerusalem, in the years 40 to 60 according to the traditional dating[10].

Luke, the companion of Paul, and his orderly investigation

Luke opens his gospel with a historian's dedication: he has "investigated everything carefully from the origins" from "those who were from the beginning eyewitnesses" in order to write "an orderly account" to Theophilus[11]. The unanimous tradition, from Irenaeus of Lyons to the Muratorian Canon, sees in him the physician of Antioch, companion of Paul, who records the Gospel preached by the Apostle[12][13]. Now Paul knows Mary, the house of Jerusalem, and James "the brother of the Lord"[14]: Luke had access, through Paul and through the Churches of Judea, to the direct witnesses of the events of Nazareth and Bethlehem. The Acts ending with Paul's Roman captivity, around 62-63, without mentioning his death or the ruin of Jerusalem, the Church dates the gospel of Luke to the years 60 to 63, and Acts to 62-63[15].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"Since many have undertaken to compose an account of the events fulfilled among us, as those who were from the beginning eyewitnesses and ministers of the Word have handed them down to us, I too have decided, after investigating everything carefully from the origins, to write you an orderly account, most excellent Theophilus." — Saint Luke, Lk 1:1-3[16]

Mark, the interpreter of Peter: an eloquent discretion

Mark develops no Marian narrative, and it is the same tradition that explains it: Mark is the interpreter of Peter in Rome, who sets down in writing the preaching of the Apostle after his departure, that is, after his martyrdom under Nero[17]. Peter's preaching, as Acts summarizes it, begins with the baptism of John and runs toward the Passion: the childhood does not appear there, but the Mother appears twice, at Capernaum and at Nazareth, named with her sons in the very incomprehension of her village. The Church dates this gospel to the years 60, before 67, while the Roman memory of Peter was still alive[18].

John, the beloved disciple: the Mother entrusted

The fourth gospel tells neither the Annunciation nor the Nativity, but it gives Mary the two most theological scenes of the New Testament: Cana, where the signs begin, and the cross, where the gift reaches its completion. The tradition, carried by Irenaeus who claims the authority of Polycarp, a disciple of John himself, attributes this gospel to the apostle John, son of Zebedee, at Ephesus, at the end of the 1st century[19]. It is to this same John that Jesus entrusts his mother from the height of the cross, and it is in this same city of Ephesus that tradition places Mary's dwelling with him[20]. The Church thus receives the words "Woman" and "behold your mother" as the testimony of the one who heard them and who took the Mother "to his own"[21].

Paul and Acts: the earliest mentions

Even before the written gospels, Paul already names the mother of Jesus: "God sent his Son, born of a woman," he writes to the Galatians, and to the Romans he specifies "descended from David according to the flesh"[22]. These letters date from the years 48 to 58: the motherhood of Mary and the Davidic descent of Jesus are thus attested in the earliest Christian texts there are, some twenty years after the cross. Acts, by the same Luke, then shows Mary in prayer with the apostles, the women, and the brothers of Jesus as they await the Spirit[23].

"But when the fullness of time had come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under the Law, to redeem those who were under the Law, so that we might receive adoption as sons." — Saint Paul, Gal 4:4-5[24]

The ancient witnesses of the Marian text

WitnessReceived dateWhat it attests
Papias of HierapolisFirst half of the 2nd centuryMatthew in the Hebrew dialect, Mark interpreter of Peter
Saint Justin, ApologiesAround 155-160The "memoirs of the apostles" read every Sunday with the prophets
Muratorian CanonAround 170-200, RomeLuke companion of Paul, John the fourth gospel
Tatian, DiatessaronAround 170Harmony of the four gospels, Marian narratives included
Saint Irenaeus, Against HeresiesAround 180The four gospels, neither more nor less, and their authors
Papyrus P52Around 125Fragment of John already circulating in Egypt
A material witness to the gospels. Codex Alexandrinus, 5th century, open at the end of Luke and the beginning of John, British Library. Photograph by Daderot, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0.

As early as the middle of the 2nd century, Justin attests that the communities read every Sunday "the memoirs composed by the apostles, or by those who followed them", on the same level as the prophets[25]. Around 170, Tatian merges the four gospels into a single continuous narrative, proof that they circulate together and complete, childhood of Jesus included[26]. Irenaeus, who knew Polycarp, disciple of John, fixes the doctrine of the four: neither more, nor less[27]. And papyrus P52, a fragment of the Gospel of John copied in Egypt around 125, proves materially the early circulation of the fourth gospel, a few decades after its composition[28].

The Annunciation and the Visitation (Lk 1)

"Hail, full of grace" (Lk 1:26-38)

The Annunciation. Fra Angelico, fresco at the San Marco convent, Florence, 15th century. Photograph by Gleb Simonov, Wikimedia Commons, public domain work.

In the sixth month of Elizabeth's pregnancy, the angel Gabriel, the same one who explained the visions to Daniel[29], is sent to Nazareth, a village of Galilee so obscure that it would later be said: can anything good come from Nazareth[30]. He enters the house of a virgin betrothed to Joseph, of the house of David, and greets her with an unheard-of title: rejoice, full of grace, the Lord is with you[31]. The Greek word, kécharitôménè, is a perfect participle: a grace received that abides, a stable state and not a moment. And the formula "the Lord is with you" echoes the calling of Gideon, the valiant warrior visited before battle[32].

"Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with you." — The angel Gabriel to Mary, Lk 1:28[33]

Mary is troubled, and the angel announces: she will conceive a son named Jesus, God saves, who will be great, Son of the Most High, to whom God will give the throne of David his father for an everlasting reign[34]. Then comes the question that grounds perpetual virginity: "How shall this be, since I do not know man?" The verb is in the present tense: betrothed and promised in marriage, Mary speaks of a present intention, which Saint Augustine reads as a vow of virginity already formed[35]. The angel answers with the shadow of the Most High, the same cloud that covered the Tent of meeting[36], and with the precedent of Sarah: "nothing is impossible for God", word for word the promise made to Sarah for Isaac[37]. And Mary consents: "I am the handmaid of the Lord, let it be done to me according to your word"[38].

"Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be done to me according to your word." — The Virgin Mary, Lk 1:38[39]

The Visitation and the Magnificat (Lk 1:39-56)

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Mary sets out "in haste" towards the hill country of Judah, to a town that tradition identifies as Ain Karem, near Jerusalem[40]. As soon as Elizabeth hears her greeting, the child leaps within her and she cries out, inspired: "Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb!" The formula echoes the blessings of Jael and Judith, the two liberators of Israel[41], and Elizabeth adds the first Marian title in history: "the mother of my Lord", where Lord translates in the Greek Bible the very Name of God[42]. Then: "Blessed is she who believed", a beatitude of faith that precedes all the beatitudes of the Kingdom[43].

Then Mary sings the Magnificat, woven from the canticle of Hannah, the barren mother of Samuel who was answered[44]: "My soul magnifies the Lord... for the Almighty has done great things for me", and already "all generations will call me blessed"[45]. The canticle overturns the order of the world, the powerful and the rich, and ends with fidelity to Abraham: the child promised to Mary is the fulfilment of the oath made to the offspring[46]. Mary remains three months with Elizabeth, until the birth of John the Baptist, handmaid before being the Mother of the Servant. The leaping of Elizabeth's child is already the Forerunner's first encounter with his Lord: all the passages concerning him are gathered in Saint John the Baptist in the New Testament.

"My soul magnifies the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God my Saviour, because he has looked upon the lowliness of his handmaid. Behold, from now on all generations will call me blessed, for the Almighty has done great things for me." — The Virgin Mary, Lk 1:46-49[47]

From Bethlehem to Nazareth: the childhood in Matthew and Luke

Joseph's dream and the name of Jesus (Mt 1)

Matthew tells the other side: Joseph, a "just man", discovers his betrothed's pregnancy and decides to send her away quietly so as not to defame her[48]. The angel of the Lord appears to him in a dream: "Joseph, son of David, do not fear to take Mary your wife into your home, for that which is begotten in her is of the Holy Spirit." The child will bear the name of Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins, fulfilling the oracle of Isaiah: "Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and they shall call him Emmanuel"[49]. Joseph takes Mary into his home, and "he did not know her until she had borne a son": the word until, in Greek as in Hebrew, says nothing about afterwards, exactly as the daughter of Saul "had no children until the day of her death"[50].

The Nativity, the shepherds and the Magi (Lk 2; Mt 2)

Luke anchors the birth in imperial history: an edict of Augustus, a census, Quirinius in Syria, and the ascent of Joseph and Mary from Nazareth to Bethlehem, the city of David[51]. The connection to Quirinius raises a debated question: Flavius Josephus dates the census of Quirinius to the year 6 AD, after the deposition of Archelaus, hence after the death of Herod[52]. The proposed readings range from a translation of prôtè as a first census prior to that of Quirinius, to an extraordinary commission of Quirinius in the East before his governorship, attested by the military role Tacitus gives him[53]. Mary "wrapped her firstborn and laid him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the katalyma": the word katalyma designates the guest room of a house, not the traveller's inn of the Good Samaritan, and prôtotokos, firstborn, is the legal title of the son consecrated to God, whether or not he has younger siblings[54]. The first to be warned are shepherds at night, a despised and suspect class, to whom the angel announces "a Saviour, who is Christ the Lord", and the heavenly host sings of glory and peace[55]. "Mary kept all these things, pondering them in her heart"[56].

"Mary kept all these things, pondering them in her heart." — Saint Luke, Lk 2:19[57]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Matthew completes the picture from the East: Magi follow the star, the star of Balaam announced over Jacob[58], to the house at Bethlehem, where they kneel and offer the gold of the king, the incense of the God, the myrrh of the mortal[59]. Warned in a dream, they depart by another road; Joseph, warned in a dream, flees to Egypt with the child and his mother, fulfilling "out of Egypt I called my son"[60]. Herod has the children of Bethlehem killed, a small village of a few hundred souls, and Matthew hears in it Rachel weeping for her sons[61]. Upon the death of Herod, which occurred in 4 BC according to Flavius Josephus, the family returns and settles in Nazareth: Jesus was therefore born between 6 and 4 BC, the monk Dionysius Exiguus having been off by a few years in his 6th-century calculation[62].

The Presentation and the sword of Simeon (Lk 2:22-38)

Forty days after the birth, according to the Law, Mary and Joseph go up to Jerusalem to present the child and offer the sacrifice of the poor, two turtledoves, instead of the lamb[63]. The aged Simeon takes the child in his arms and sings the Now: "my eyes have seen your salvation, a light for the revelation to the nations", echoing the Servant announced by Isaiah[64]. Then, to Mary, the prophecy of the sword: "this child is destined for the fall and rise of many, and a sword will pierce your own soul"[65]. The prophetess Anna, eighty-four years old, of the tribe of Asher, in turn comes forward and speaks of the child to all those who were awaiting the redemption of Jerusalem[66].

Jesus found in the Temple (Lk 2:41-51)

Each year, the family goes up to Jerusalem for Passover, and at twelve years old, on the eve of religious adulthood, Jesus remains in the Temple without his parents knowing[67]. Three days of anguish, then the discovery: seated among the teachers, questioning them and astonishing them. To Mary's complaint, "your father and I have been looking for you," the answer comes: "Did you not know that I must be in my Father's house?"[68]. They did not understand, Luke notes with a honesty that guarantees the account: witnesses do not invent what they admit they do not understand. Jesus goes back down to Nazareth, submissive to Mary and Joseph, and "his mother kept all these things faithfully in her heart"[69].

Public life: Cana, Capernaum, and Calvary

Cana: "Woman, what would you have me do?" (Jn 2, 1-11)

"On the third day," a wedding takes place at Cana in Galilee, and the mother of Jesus is there, apparently of the household, since she is the first to notice that the wine has run out[70]. Her intervention is one sentence long: "They have no wine." And Jesus replies with the solemn address: "Woman, what would you have me do? My hour has not yet come." The word Woman, in Greek gunai, is by no means harsh: it is the title of honour Jesus will also give to the Samaritan woman, the woman caught in adultery, and Mary Magdalene, and above all the word of Genesis, "the woman" facing the serpent[71]. Mary does not argue: "Do whatever he tells you", the same instruction Pharaoh gave concerning Joseph to the starving Egyptians[72]. Six stone jars, each holding two to three measures, that is, more than five hundred litres, become the good wine served last, and John concludes: this was the first of the signs, and his disciples believed in him[73].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"His mother said to the servants: Do whatever he tells you." — Saint John, Jn 2, 5[74]

The true family of Jesus (Mk 3; Mt 12; Lk 8 and 11)

One day, when the crowd is pressing in so much that they cannot eat, "his mother and his brothers" arrive and send word to call him outside[75]. Jesus answers by looking at those around him: "Here are my mother and my brothers. Whoever does the will of God, he is my brother, my sister and my mother." Far from repudiating Mary, he places her at the head of the new kinship, she who did the will of God before all. Luke reports the same scene and adds the episode of the woman who cries out in the crowd: "Blessed is the womb that bore you!" Jesus replies: "Blessed rather those who hear the word of God and keep it", which does not repudiate his mother but beatifies her on a higher title: Mary is blessed above all because she believed, as Elizabeth had sung[76]. Just before this scene, Mark notes that "his own", the wider circle, wanted to seize Jesus, "for they said: he is out of his mind"[77]. The account at once distinguishes Mary, named among those who come to see him, and Jesus' reply repudiates no one: it orders the kinships, flesh after hearing, and Mary passes first there, she who listened before all.

The "brothers of Jesus": what does the text really say?

In Nazareth, four "brothers" are named: James, Joses, Jude and Simon, along with sisters whose names are not given[78]. Three readings have clashed since antiquity. Helvidius, around 380, saw in them children of Mary born after Jesus; Saint Jerome answered him at once, around 383, with the solution of cousins: in Hebrew as in Aramaic, 'ah, brother, denotes any close relative, Abraham calls Lot his brother, Laban calls Jacob his brother[79], and Mary the wife of Clopas, present at Calvary and called the "sister" of the Virgin[80], is the mother of the James and Joses named in Nazareth[81]. Epiphanius of Salamis proposed another solution, the sons of Joseph from a first marriage, according to the Protevangelium of James[82]. Hegesippus, a second-century chronicler, states that Clopas was the brother of Joseph, which makes the said "brothers" Joseph's nephews in both Catholic hypotheses[83].

The text itself supports the traditional reading: "firstborn" is a legal title, the son consecrated according to Exodus whether or not he has younger siblings[84]; "until" says nothing about what comes after, as we have seen with Saul's daughter; Jude calls himself "brother of James" and not son of Joseph[85]; and James "the brother of the Lord", a pillar of Jerusalem[86], is counted among the apostles, which Jerome explains by identifying him with James the son of Alphaeus, Clopas Hellenised[87]. Finally, from the height of the cross, Jesus entrusts his mother to the beloved disciple: unthinkable if he still had sons to take her in[88]. The Church "has always understood these passages as not designating other children of the Virgin Mary"[89]. John notes that before Easter "his own brothers did not believe in him"[90]: the unbelief of the wider circle does not reach Mary, whom the same gospel shows standing at Calvary, and after the Resurrection "his brothers" pray with her and the apostles in the upper room[91].

At the foot of the cross: "Behold your mother" (Jn 19, 25-27)

"Standing by the cross of Jesus were his mother, his mother's sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene"[92]. Jesus sees his mother and, beside her, the disciple whom he loved. He says to his mother: "Woman, behold your son." Then to the disciple: "Behold your mother." And from that hour, the disciple took her into his home, literally "into his own possessions"[93]. At the moment he gives his life, Christ gives his mother: Mary becomes the Mother of the disciple, and through him of all disciples. It is the second "Woman" of the gospel, which answers that of Cana and that of Genesis: the hour having come, the Woman receives her offspring.

"Jesus sees his mother and, beside her, the disciple whom he loved. He says to his mother: Woman, behold your son. Then he says to the disciple: Behold your mother. And from that hour, the disciple took her into his home." — Saint John, Jn 19, 26-27[94]

Mary after Easter: the Acts and Revelation

At prayer with the apostles (Acts 1:14)

After the Ascension, the apostles return to the upper room. Luke names the Eleven, then adds: "All these with one accord were devoting themselves to prayer, together with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and his brothers"[95]. This is the last explicit mention of Mary in the order of the Gospel narrative: she who had received the Spirit at the Annunciation waits with the Church for the Spirit of Pentecost, in the midst of the hundred and twenty brethren gathered together[96]. The New Testament opens with a woman visited by an angel and closes, in history, with a Mother at prayer with her own.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"All these with one accord were devoting themselves to prayer, together with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and his brothers." — Saint Luke, Acts 1:14[97]

The Woman of Revelation (Rev 12:1-17)

"A great sign appeared in heaven: a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars"[98]. With child, she cries out in her pains; the red Dragon stands ready to devour the child; the child, "the one who is to rule all the nations", is caught up to God, and the Woman flees into the wilderness. The twelve stars recall Joseph's dream, with the sun, the moon, and the stars bowing down[99]: the Woman is first Israel, from whom the Messiah is born, then the Church, who gives birth amid persecution, and the Fathers, like the liturgy, also contemplate in her Mary, the Mother of the Messiah caught up to God, whom the feast of 15 August sings of each year[100]. The chapter ends with "the rest of her offspring, those who keep the commandments of God": the children of the Woman, that is, Christians[101]. The "pains" of verse 2, sometimes set against the virginal childbirth, misunderstand the genre: the Woman cries out like Zion in labor in the prophets, an image of the people bringing forth salvation in trial, and Isaiah already sings of Zion who gives birth before even suffering[102].

What the New Testament already teaches about Mary

Mother of the Lord and Mother of God in seed

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Elizabeth, "filled with the Holy Spirit", cries out: "And why is this granted to me that the mother of my Lord should come to me?"[103]. Now Lord, in the Greek Bible that Elizabeth and Luke read, renders the ineffable Name: to call Mary mother of the Kyrios is already to say, in Semitic terms, what Ephesus will proclaim in 431 with the word Theotokos. Paul likewise says that the Son was "born of a woman" and "descended from David according to the flesh": true man through his mother, true God through his Father[104]. The Catechism sums it up: "Called in the Gospels 'the mother of Jesus', Mary is acclaimed, under the prompting of the Spirit, even before the birth of her son, as 'the mother of my Lord'", and the Church confesses that she is truly Mother of God (Theotokos)[105].

The new Eve: from disobedience to obedience

From the second century onward, the Fathers read in the New Testament the parallel of the two virgins: Eve listened to the serpent and brought forth death; Mary listened to Gabriel and brought forth Life. Justin writes this around 155: Eve, a virgin and intact, conceived the word of the serpent, while Mary received faith and joy at the angel's message[106]. Irenaeus makes of it the doctrine of the knot untied: what the virgin Eve had bound by her unbelief, the virgin Mary loosed by her faith[107]. Tertullian tightens the formula: Eve believed the serpent, Mary believed Gabriel[108]. And Irenaeus calls Mary the advocate of Eve, she who pleads and makes reparation[109]. The "Woman" of Cana and of Calvary seals the reading: where the first woman had reached out her hand toward the fruit, the new Woman points the servants toward her Son.

"The knot of Eve's disobedience was untied by Mary's obedience. For what the virgin Eve had bound by her unbelief, the virgin Mary loosed by her faith." — Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies, III, 22, 4[110]

"Full of grace": the holiness of Mary in seed

Gabriel's greeting is not a courtesy but a revelation: kecharitōmenē, graced with abiding grace, even before the Annunciation[111]. The Church has read in it the privilege that will become the dogma of 1854: preserved from original sin "in view of the merits of Jesus Christ", Mary is "redeemed in a more exalted way"[112]. The first Gospel supports the reading: already in Genesis, God sets enmity, not complicity, between the serpent and the woman, between his offspring and hers[113]. And Saint Augustine, questioned on the universality of sin, formally exempts Mary: out of honor for the Lord, he will raise "absolutely no question" about her where sins are concerned[114].

Virgin before, during, and after childbirth: the clues in the text

The New Testament expressly affirms the virginal conception, both in Matthew and in Luke, two independent witnesses[115]. For perpetual virginity, the text gives converging clues: Mary's question in the present tense[116], the "until" that settles nothing[117], the absence of any other son at Calvary[118]. The Church confessed Mary's real and perpetual virginity "even in childbirth": Constantinople II names her ever-virgin as early as 553, and the Synod of the Lateran defines it in 649[119]. The Protoevangelium of James, an apocryphal writing of the mid-second century, had already popularized the idea by recounting the childhood of Mary, daughter of Joachim and Anne: the Church never received this text as Scripture, Saint Jerome rejects it expressly, but she kept the two first names in her liturgy, on 26 July[120].

The four Marian dogmas and their New Testament roots

Dogma (definition)Roots in the New Testament
Divine motherhood (Ephesus, 431)"The mother of my Lord" (Lk 1:43); "born of a woman" (Gal 4:4)
Perpetual virginity (Lateran 649, Constantinople II 553)"I do not know man" (Lk 1:34); virginal conception (Mt 1; Lk 1)
Immaculate Conception (1854)"Full of grace" (Lk 1:28); enmity of the woman (Gn 3:15)
Assumption (1950)"Woman clothed with the sun" (Rev 12:1); "all generations will call me blessed" (Lk 1:48)

Reception in the Church: Fathers, Ephesus, and Liturgy

The Fathers of the Early Centuries

Mary is not a late discovery of medieval piety: the earliest Fathers already hold her from Scripture. Ignatius of Antioch, led to martyrdom around 107–110, writes to the Ephesians that the virginity of Mary, her childbirth, and the death of the Lord are "three resounding mysteries" hidden from the prince of this world and accomplished in the silence of God[121]. Justin, around 155, contrasts the two virgins, Eve and Mary, disobedience and faith[122]. Irenaeus, around 180, unfolds the doctrine of the untied knot and of the advocate[123]. And when the pagan philosopher Celsus accuses Mary of adultery with a soldier, Origen answers him point by point as early as the third century — proof that the Church was already defending the Mother's scriptural honor[124].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"The virginity of Mary was hidden from the prince of this world, as was her childbirth, and likewise the death of the Lord: three resounding mysteries, accomplished in the silence of God." — Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Ephesians, 19, 1[125]

Ephesus (431): Theotokos

Nestorius, Patriarch of Constantinople, refuses to call Mary Mother of God and grants her only Mother of Christ, separating in Jesus the man from the Word. Cyril of Alexandria obtains the summoning of the council at Ephesus, the very city where tradition places Mary's dwelling with John[126]. On 22 June 431, the Fathers proclaim Mary Theotokos, she who has given birth to God, and depose Nestorius: if the Son of Mary is not God, man is not saved[127]. Chalcedon would take up the title again in 451, and Gregory of Nazianzus had already pronounced anathema on whoever would refuse it[128]. On 1 January, since 1969 the Church has celebrated the solemnity of Mary, Mother of God, within the octave of Christmas[129].

Mary in the Liturgy: The Great Dates

  1. 431
    Ephesus: Mother of God

    The council proclaims Mary Theotokos and deposes Nestorius. The city of Ephesus, which keeps the memory of her dwelling with John, receives the Fathers.

  2. 6th century
    Dormition and Assumption on 15 August

    Jerusalem celebrates the Dormition of Mary; Rome receives the feast in the 7th century. 15 August becomes the great Marian feast of the summer, read with Rev 12.

  3. 8 September
    Nativity of Mary

    A feast of Eastern origin celebrating the birth of the daughter of Joachim and Anne, nine months after the Conception of 8 December.

  4. 8 December
    Immaculate Conception

    An English feast as early as the 11th century, extended to the whole Church by Clement XI in 1708, and becoming the dogma of 1854.

  5. 25 March
    Annunciation of the Lord

    Nine months before Christmas, the Church celebrates the virginal conception announced at Nazareth, a feast recounted in the article on the Annunciation.

  6. 31 May
    Visitation

    Mary carrying Christ to Elizabeth: mission before words, celebrated on 31 May since the reform of 1969.

  7. 15 September
    Our Lady of Sorrows

    The day after the Holy Cross, the Church honors the Mother at the foot of the cross and the sword of Simeon.

The Magnificat, the Angelus, and the Rosary Today

The Magnificat is not only read: it is sung every evening at the office of Vespers, throughout the world, since the earliest centuries of the Liturgy of the Hours[130]. The Angelus, born in the Middle Ages around the 13th century, rings out three times a day the very words of the New Testament — Gabriel's Ave and Elizabeth's Blessed — together with the verse "Behold the handmaid of the Lord"[131]. The Rosary, fixed by Saint Pius V in 1569 and enriched with the luminous mysteries by John Paul II in 2002, has the faithful meditate in fifteen and then twenty scenes upon the whole New Testament dossier of Mary, from the Annunciation to the Coronation, and the feast of 7 October recalls the victory of Lepanto in 1571[132]. The Catechism names this devotion hyperdulia, utterly special, essentially distinct from the adoration due to God alone[133]. To go deeper, see How to grow in the Rosary.

"Holy Mother Church has held and holds firmly and consistently that the four Gospels, whose historicity she unhesitatingly affirms, faithfully transmit what Jesus, the Son of God, during his life among men, really did and taught for their eternal salvation, until the day when he was taken up into heaven." — Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum, 19[134]

Common Objections and Answers

"Mary had other children"?

This is the objection of Helvidius, refuted once and for all by Jerome: the "brothers" are cousins, children of Mary of Clopas, or, according to Epiphanius, sons of Joseph from a previous marriage. The text knows only one son of Mary; Jesus is called her "firstborn" in the legal sense; the "until" of Matthew proves nothing; and Jesus entrusts his mother to the disciple, something no younger son would have allowed[135].

"Jesus snubs his mother"?

Neither at Cana, nor at Capernaum, nor in the crowd does Jesus belittle Mary: he places her in her true rank. "Woman" is the title of Genesis and Revelation, not a mark of coldness. "Whoever does the will of God" describes Mary before anyone else, and "blessed are those who hear" beatifies her for her faith — the title Elizabeth had been the first to give her[136]. John Paul II, in Redemptoris Mater, shows in Mary the pilgrimage of faith, from the Annunciation to Calvary, without rupture[137].

"All have sinned, so Mary too" (Rom 3:23)?

Paul writes that "all have sinned and are deprived of the glory of God" in order to establish the universal need for salvation, not to take a census of every individual: taken with blind literalism, the verse would condemn Jesus himself and children below the age of reason. The Church confesses that Mary too was redeemed, but in a more eminent way — by preservation, not by pardon, "in view of the merits of Jesus Christ"[138]. Augustine settles the matter: except for the Virgin, regarding whom the honour of the Lord forbids even raising the question[139].

"The Woman of Revelation is Israel, not Mary"?

The two readings do not exclude each other; they call for one another: the Woman is Israel who gives birth to the Messiah, the Church who gives birth amid persecution, and Mary who gives birth to the Messiah in person. This is Scripture's constant method, the literal sense bearing a fuller sense that the liturgy unfolds: every 15 August, the Church reads Rev 12 for the Assumption of Mary, and Pius XII founded the 1950 dogma on these very texts — the crowned Woman, the full of grace, the blessed of all generations[140].

The Historical-Critical Debate and Its Limits

What Part of Contemporary Exegesis Proposes

Since the nineteenth century, part of exegesis has proposed dating the Gospels later than tradition: Mark around 65–70, Matthew and Luke around 80–90 on the basis of Mark and a sayings source known as Q, never found, John around 90–100 or later[141]. Within this framework, the infancy narratives would be late compositions, built on the model of the marvellous births of the Old Testament, to express in narrative form the paschal faith of the communities: theologoumena, true in their meaning, but without direct historical scope[142]. The silence of Mark and Paul concerning the Annunciation would serve as confirmation: what the first witnesses did not say, the communities would have invented afterwards.

The Fragilities of the Reconstruction

This reconstruction piles up the classic fragilities of the science of the past. The Q document has never been found: it is a hypothesis proposed to explain similarities, promoted to the rank of a lost source, then used as proof of late dating — in a circle[143]. The anti-miraculous presupposition dictates the result: when every precise prediction is classified by default among the later touch-ups, the late dating is presupposed by the method, not demonstrated by the manuscripts[144]. The argument from silence proves little: Mark and Paul write genres that exclude childhood — preaching beginning at the baptism and occasional letters — while attesting to the mother and the Davidic descent. And the agreement of independent witnesses proves much: Matthew and Luke, who do not copy each other on the infancy narratives, agree precisely on the virginal conception — a feature recognised, even by the exegete Raymond Brown, as a tradition earlier than the two accounts[145].

Why the Traditional Reading Remains Defensible

Against the late datings, the material facts speak early: the papyrus P52 circulates John in Egypt around 125; Justin reads the apostolic memoirs every Sunday around 155; Tatian weaves them into a single narrative around 170; Irenaeus fixes their four authors around 180[146]. Against the idea of a communal invention, the chain of witnesses is short: Irenaeus knew Polycarp, who had known John, to whom Jesus had entrusted his mother[147]. And against the separation of history and faith, the Church has settled the matter by magisterium: the Gospels "faithfully hand on what Jesus truly did and taught", declares Vatican II[148], after the Pontifical Biblical Commission had set out in 1964 the three honest stages of the work — the life of Jesus, the preaching of the apostles, the writing of the evangelists — without dissolving the first into the other two[149]. The Catechism expresses this view in these terms: "The gaze of faith can discover, in connection with the whole of Revelation, the mysterious reasons for which God, in his saving plan, willed that his Son be born of a virgin"[150].

To go further

Mary is first read in the New Testament itself: Lk 1–2, Mt 1–2, Jn 2 and 19, Acts 1, Rev 12, in the TOB or the Jerusalem Bible, before going on to the Annunciation of the Lord, Mary Mother of God, the Immaculate Conception and its dogma of 1854, the Assumption, the rosary and the Blessed Virgin Mary and Saint Joseph in the life of prayer. One will then consult the Catechism, 484 to 511 and 963 to 975, the constitution Lumen Gentium, chapter VIII, and the encyclical Redemptoris Mater by John Paul II. For the patristic roots: Ignatius to the Ephesians, Justin against Trypho, Irenaeus against heresies, Jerome against Helvidius.

Notes and References

  1. Inventory of the direct passages where Mary appears or is named as the mother of Jesus: Mt 1, 16-25; 2, 11-23; 12, 46-50; 13, 55-56; Mk 3, 31-35; 6, 1-6; Lk 1, 26-56; 2, 1-52; 8, 19-21; 11, 27-28; Jn 2, 1-11; 19, 25-27; Acts 1, 14; Gal 4, 4; Rom 1, 3; Rev 12, 1-17. Liturgical translation of the AELF.

    1 3
  2. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 495: "Called in the Gospels 'the mother of Jesus' (Jn 2, 1; 19, 25; cf. Mt 13, 55), Mary is acclaimed, under the prompting of the Spirit, even before the birth of her son, as 'the mother of my Lord' (Lk 1, 43). Indeed, the One whom she conceived as man by the Holy Spirit and who truly became her Son according to the flesh is none other than the eternal Son of the Father, the second Person of the Holy Trinity. The Church confesses that Mary is truly Mother of God (Theotokos)" (texte officiel, vatican.va, archive FRA0013).

    2 105
  3. Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah, 1977: Matthew and Luke, independent on the infancy narratives, agree on the virginal conception, a sign of a tradition prior to both accounts.

    4 115 145
  4. Acts 1, 21-22: the replacement of Judas must have followed Jesus "from the baptism of John"; cf. Acts 10, 36-37, Peter's preaching begins with the baptism.

    5
  5. Gal 4, 4-5: "God sent his Son, born of a woman"; cf. Rom 1, 3: "descended from David according to the flesh". Letters dated from the years 48 to 58.

    6 22 24 104
  6. Papias of Hierapolis, Explanations of the Sayings of the Lord, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Matthew composed the logia in the Hebrew dialect; Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote accurately what he retained of his preaching.

    7 17
  7. Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39 (Papias) and VI, 14 (Clement of Alexandria on the order of the Gospels), written around 324.

    8
  8. Clement of Alexandria, Hypotyposeis, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14: the Gospels containing the genealogies (Matthew, Luke) were written first.

    9
  9. Traditional dating of Matthew: the first Gospel, in Hebrew then in Greek, intended for Jewish Christians, before the destruction of Jerusalem (70), placed in the years 40 to 60.

    10
  10. Lk 1, 1-4: prologue of the orderly investigation, dedicated to Theophilus, drawn from eyewitnesses.

    11 16
  11. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, around 180: Matthew published his Gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul were evangelizing Rome; after their departure, Mark handed on Peter's preaching, Luke set down Paul's, and John published his own at Ephesus.

    12 19 147
  12. Muratorian Canon, Rome, around 170-200: Luke, companion of Paul without having seen the Lord, third Gospel; John, fourth, at the request of his fellow disciples.

    13
  13. Gal 1, 14-19: Paul goes up to Jerusalem, sees Peter and then "James, the brother of the Lord", proof of his contacts with the relatives and the mother Church; James is counted among the pillars of the Church with Peter and John (Gal 2, 9).

    14 86
  14. Traditional dating of Luke and Acts: Luke around 60-63, Acts around 62-63, the account ending with Paul's Roman captivity without mentioning his death (around 67) or the destruction of Jerusalem (70).

    15
  15. Traditional dating of Mark: in Rome from Peter's preaching, in the years 60, before Peter's martyrdom under Nero (64-67).

    18
  16. Ephesian tradition: Mary dwelt with John at Ephesus; the house known as Meryem Ana identified in 1891 near Ephesus, visited by Paul VI (1967), John Paul II (1979) and Benedict XVI (2006); the council of 431 was held there in the church known as that of Mary.

    20 126
  17. Jn 19, 26-27: "Woman, behold your son... Behold your mother. And from that hour the disciple took her to his own" (eis ta idia, into his own belongings).

    21 88 93 94 118
  18. Acts 1, 13-14: the Eleven, the women, Mary the mother of Jesus and his brothers, devoted to prayer in the upper room.

    23 91 95 97
  19. Saint Justin, First Apology, 66-67, around 155: on Sunday, one reads "the memoirs composed by the apostles, or by those who followed them", along with the writings of the prophets.

    25
  20. Tatian the Syrian, Diatessaron, around 170: a harmony of the four Gospels into a single continuous narrative, childhood of Jesus included.

    26
  21. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 11, 8: there can be neither more nor fewer than four Gospels, like the four zones of the world and the four faces of the cherubim.

    27
  22. Papyrus P52 (Rylands Gr. P. 457), fragment of Jn 18 copied in Egypt and dated around 125, the oldest material witness of the New Testament.

    28 146
  23. Dan 8, 15-16 and 9, 21: Gabriel explains the visions to Daniel; Lk 1, 19.26: the same Gabriel sent to Zechariah and then to Mary.

    29
  24. Jn 1, 46: "Can anything good come out of Nazareth?", Nathanael says to Philip.

    30
  25. Lk 1, 28: Chaire, kecharitomene, ho Kyrios meta sou. Liturgical translation: "Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with you."

    31 33 111
  26. Judg 6, 12: the angel to Gideon, "The Lord is with you, mighty warrior", same formula of a call to battle.

    32
  27. Lk 1, 31-33: the name of Jesus, Son of the Most High, throne of David his father, everlasting kingdom, according to the promise of 2 Sam 7, 12-16.

    34
  28. Saint Augustine, On Holy Virginity, 4: Mary had vowed her virginity to God, hence her question to the angel despite her betrothal.

    35
  29. Ex 40, 34-35: the cloud covers the Tent of meeting and the glory of the Lord fills it; cf. Lk 1, 35, "the shadow of the Most High".

    36
  30. Gen 18, 14: "Is anything impossible for God?", promised to Sarah for Isaac; cf. Lk 1, 37.

    37
  31. Lk 1, 38: "I am the handmaid of the Lord (doule Kyriou); let it be to me according to your word."

    38 39
  32. Ain Karim, village in the hill country of Judah near Jerusalem, identified by tradition with the town of Elizabeth; church of the Visitation entrusted to the Franciscans.

    40
  33. Judg 5, 24: "Blessed among women be Jael"; cf. Judg 13, 18 for Judith; cf. Lk 1, 42 for Mary, third of the triptych.

    41
  34. Lk 1, 43: "the mother of my Lord" (he meter tou Kyriou mou), where Kyrios transcribes the divine Name in the Septuagint.

    42 103
  35. Lk 1, 45: "Blessed is she who believed", the beatitude of Elizabeth's faith in Mary.

    43
  36. 1 Sam 2, 1-10: the canticle of Hannah, barren mother of Samuel, matrix of the Magnificat (the lowly exalted, the mighty cast down, the anointed king).

    44
  37. Lk 1, 46-55: the Magnificat, "all generations will call me blessed" (v. 48), "he has cast down the mighty from their thrones" (v. 52), "he has remembered his mercy toward Abraham" (v. 54-55).

    45 47
  38. Lk 1, 54-55: the fulfilment of the oath sworn to Abraham and to his posterity.

    46
  39. Mt 1, 18-19: Mary with child "before they came together"; Joseph, "a just man", decides to send her away quietly.

    48
  40. Is 7, 14, quoted in Mt 1, 22-23: "Behold, the virgin shall conceive", and Emmanuel, God with us.

    49
  41. Mt 1, 25: "he knew her not until (heos hou) she had borne a son"; cf. 2 Sam 6, 23, Michal "had no child until the day of her death".

    50 117
  42. Lk 2, 1-5: the decree of Augustus, Quirinius in Syria, the ascent from Nazareth to Bethlehem, the city of David.

    51
  43. Lk 2, 2: "this first census (hauta apgraphe prote) took place while Quirinius was governor of Syria"; Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 1, 1: the census of Quirinius after the deposition of Archelaus, in the year 6; Tacitus, Annals, III, 48: Quirinius' earlier eastern role.

    52 53
  44. Lk 2, 6-7: the firstborn (prototokos, legal title from Ex 13, 2) laid in the manger, for there was no room in the katalyma, the guest room, distinct from the inn (pandocheion) of Lk 10, 34.

    54
  45. Lk 2, 8-14: the shepherds, the angel, "a Saviour, who is Christ the Lord", and the heavenly multitude, glory and peace.

    55
  46. Lk 2, 19: "Mary kept (syneterei) all these things, pondering them in her heart."

    56 57
  47. Num 24, 17: the oracle of Balaam, "a star shall come forth out of Jacob", read by tradition in the star of the Magi.

    58
  48. Mt 2, 9-11: the house at Bethlehem, the prostration, the gold, the frankincense and the myrrh.

    59
  49. Hos 11, 1: "out of Egypt I called my son", quoted in Mt 2, 15 for the flight and then the return.

    60
  50. Jer 31, 15: "Rachel weeping for her children", quoted in Mt 2, 17-18 for the slaughter of the Holy Innocents ordered by Herod.

    61
  51. Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, XVII: the death of Herod the Great shortly before a lunar eclipse, dated to 4 BC; Dionysius Exiguus, in the 6th century, set the common era with a few years' offset.

    62
  52. Lk 2, 22-24: the purification according to Lev 12, and the offering of the poor, "a pair of turtledoves", cf. Lev 12, 8.

    63
  53. Is 42, 6 and 49, 6: the Servant, "light to the nations", taken up in the canticle of Simeon, Lk 2, 30-32.

    64
  54. Lk 2, 34-35: Simeon to Mary, "this child is destined to be a sign of contradiction, and you yourself a sword (romphaia) shall pierce your soul".

    65
  55. Lk 2, 36-38: Anna the prophetess, daughter of Phanuel, of the tribe of Asher, eighty-four years old, in the Temple night and day.

    66
  56. Lk 2, 41-42: the annual journey up to Jerusalem for Passover, Jesus aged twelve, on the eve of religious adulthood.

    67
  57. Lk 2, 49: "Did you not know that I must be in my Father's house (en tois tou Patros mou)?"

    68
  58. Lk 2, 51: Jesus submissive to Mary and Joseph at Nazareth, and "his mother kept all these things faithfully (dietêrei) in her heart".

    69
  59. Jn 2, 1-4: the wedding at Cana "on the third day", the mother of Jesus present, "they have no wine", "Woman (gunai), what does this have to do with me?"

    70
  60. Gen 3, 15: the enmity between the serpent and the woman, between his offspring and hers, the Protoevangelium read by the whole Marian tradition.

    71 113
  61. Gen 41, 55: Pharaoh to the starving Egyptians, "do whatever he (Joseph) tells you"; cf. Jn 2, 5.

    72
  62. Jn 2, 11: Cana, "the first of the signs", revealing his glory, and his disciples believed in him.

    73
  63. Jn 2, 5-10: "Do whatever he tells you", the six stone jars, the good wine served last, according to the master of the feast (architriklinos).

    74
  64. Mk 3, 31-35: the mother and brethren outside, "here are my mother and my brethren", whoever does the will of God.

    75
  65. Lk 11, 27-28: the woman who blessed the womb and the breasts, and the answer, "blessed rather are those who hear the word of God and keep it".

    76 136
  66. Mk 3, 20-21: "his friends" (hoi par' autou, those close to him) sought to seize him, "for they said, 'He is out of his mind'" (exestè); cf. Mk 3, 31, where Mary is named among those who ask for him.

    77
  67. Mk 6, 2-3: at Nazareth, "the carpenter, the son of Mary", and the brothers James, Joses, Jude and Simon; cf. Mt 13, 55-56.

    78
  68. Gen 13, 8: Abraham to Lot, "we are brothers ('ahim)", although Lot is his nephew; cf. Gen 29, 12-15 for Jacob and Laban, same broad usage.

    79
  69. Jn 19, 25: at Calvary, his mother, his mother's sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary of Magdala.

    80 92
  70. Mk 15, 40: "Mary, the mother of James the Less and of Joses", among the women watching from afar, identified by Jerome as Mary of Clopas.

    81
  71. Epiphanius of Salamis, Panarion, 78, 4th century: the "brothers" would be the sons of Joseph from a first marriage, according to the Protoevangelium of James.

    82
  72. Hegesippus, Memoirs, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, III, 11 and IV, 22: Clopas, brother of Joseph, and Simeon his son, second bishop of Jerusalem.

    83
  73. Ex 13, 2 and Num 3, 13: the firstborn male consecrated to the Lord, a legal title independent of any sibling relationship.

    84
  74. Jude 1: "Jude, servant of Jesus Christ and brother of James", with no mention of Joseph.

    85
  75. Saint Jerome, Against Helvidius, c. 383: the "brothers" are cousins, children of Mary of Clopas, "sister" of the Virgin in the broad sense; James the brother of the Lord is James son of Alphaeus, Clopas hellenised.

    87
  76. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 500-501: the Church "has always understood these passages as not referring to other children of the Virgin Mary", and "Jesus is Mary's only son".

    89 135
  77. Jn 7, 3-5: the brothers urge Jesus to go up to Jerusalem, "for his brothers did not believe in him either".

    90
  78. Acts 1, 15: Peter stands up "in the midst of the brethren", about one hundred and twenty people gathered.

    96
  79. Rev 12, 1-6: the Woman clothed with the sun, the moon under her feet, the crown of twelve stars, the child caught up to God.

    98
  80. Gen 37, 9-10: Joseph's dream, the sun, the moon and eleven stars bowing down; cf. the twelve stars of Rev 12, 1 for the twelve tribes.

    99
  81. Reading of Rev 12 at the Mass of 15 August (Assumption) and scriptural foundation of the 1950 dogma along with Lk 1 and Gen 3, 15, cf. Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus.

    100
  82. Rev 12, 17: "the rest of her offspring, those who keep the commandments of God and bear testimony to Jesus".

    101
  83. Rev 12, 2: "she was with child, and she cried out in her labour and in the pangs of childbirth"; cf. Is 66, 7-8, Zion who gives birth before suffering, and Mic 4, 9-10, the pangs of the daughter of Zion.

    102
  84. Saint Justin, Dialogue with Trypho, 100, c. 155-160: Eve, a virgin and intact, conceived the word of the serpent and gave birth to disobedience and death; Mary received faith and joy at the announcement of Gabriel.

    106 122
  85. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 22, 4: "the knot of Eve's disobedience was untied by Mary's obedience; what the virgin Eve had bound through her unbelief, the virgin Mary loosed through her faith".

    107 110 123
  86. Tertullian, On the Flesh of Christ, 17, c. 210: Eve believed the serpent, Mary believed Gabriel; the fault that entered through a betrothed virgin is repaired by a betrothed virgin.

    108
  87. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, V, 19, 1: Mary "advocate (advocata) of Eve", the obedient virgin repairing the disobedient virgin.

    109
  88. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 492: Mary, "redeemed in a more exalted way, by reason of the merits of her Son", and 503: the "full of grace" of Lk 1, 28.

    112 138
  89. Saint Augustine, On Nature and Grace, 36: concerning sin, "except the holy Virgin Mary, concerning whom, out of honour for the Lord, I wish to raise absolutely no question".

    114 139
  90. Lk 1, 34: "How shall this be, since I know not man?", the verb in the present tense.

    116
  91. Lateran Council, 649, canon 3 (Martin I): Mary holy, ever-virgin, before, during and after the birth; Constantinople II (553) names her ever-virgin (aeiparthenos).

    119
  92. Protoevangelium of James, mid-2nd century: apocryphal account of Mary's childhood, daughter of Joachim and Anne; never received into the canon, set aside by Saint Jerome, but the source of the liturgical names (26 July).

    120
  93. Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Ephesians, 19, 1, c. 107-110, on the road to his martyrdom in Rome: the virginity of Mary, her childbirth and the death of the Lord, three mysteries hidden from the prince of this world.

    121 125
  94. Celsus, True Discourse, c. 178, against the Christians: accusation of adultery by Mary with a soldier named Panthera; Origen, Against Celsus, I, 28-32, c. 248, refutes it point by point.

    124
  95. Council of Ephesus, 431: Mary Theotokos, the deposition of Nestorius; opening session on 22 June 431 under Cyril of Alexandria; confirmed at Chalcedon (451).

    127
  96. Saint Gregory of Nazianzus, Letter 101 to Cledonius: if anyone does not confess that Mary is Mother of God (Theotokos), let him be separated from the divinity.

    128
  97. Solemnity of Mary, the Holy Mother of God, on 1 January, within the octave of Christmas, instituted by the liturgical reform of 1969 (previously the Feast of the Circumcision).

    129
  98. Liturgy of the Hours: the Magnificat (Lk 1, 46-55) is the gospel canticle sung each evening at Vespers, as the Benedictus each morning at Lauds.

    130
  99. The Angelus: daily triple ringing originating in the Middle Ages (13th century), echoing the Ave of Gabriel (Lk 1, 28), the Blessed of Elizabeth (Lk 1, 42) and the fiat (Lk 1, 38); commended by Paul VI, Marialis Cultus, 41.

    131
  100. Saint Pius V, Consueverunt Romani, 1569: form of the Rosary, one hundred and fifty Aves in fifteen mysteries; John Paul II, Rosarium Virginis Mariae, 2002: the luminous mysteries; feast on 7 October, in memory of Lepanto (1571).

    132
  101. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 971: devotion to Mary, of hyperdulia, "utterly special", essentially distinct from adoration, expressed in the liturgical feasts and Marian prayer such as the Rosary.

    133
  102. Second Vatican Council, dogmatic constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church "affirms without hesitation the historicity" of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus actually did and taught.

    134 148
  103. John Paul II, encyclical Redemptoris Mater, 25 March 1987: Mary in the pilgrimage of faith, from the Annunciation to Calvary; Cana as a preparation for the hour.

    137
  104. Pius XII, apostolic constitution Munificentissimus Deus, 1 November 1950, 26-28: the dogma of the Assumption founded on the Woman of Rev 12, she who is full of grace, blessed among all generations, and the ark of Ps 131, 8.

    140
  105. The two-source hypothesis: Markan priority (65-70), Matthew and Luke (80-90) combining Mark and a sayings source Q, never found, John at the turn of the second century.

    141
  106. Rudolf Bultmann and demythologization: the infancy narratives read as narrative expressions of Easter faith (theologoumena), with no direct historical import.

    142
  107. Passages cut out according to stylistic criteria, dated according to a theory of religious evolution, then invoked as proof of that evolution: the reasoning goes in a circle.

    143
  108. When every precise prediction is automatically classified among the later touch-ups, the late dating is presupposed by the method, not demonstrated by the manuscripts.

    144
  109. Pontifical Biblical Commission, instruction Sancta Mater Ecclesia, 21 April 1964: the three stages — the life of Jesus, the oral preaching of the apostles, the writing of the evangelists — without dissolving history into the faith of the communities.

    149
  110. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 502: "The gaze of faith can discover, in connection with the whole of Revelation, the mysterious reasons for which God, in his saving plan, willed that his Son be born of a virgin. These reasons concern both the person and the redemptive mission of Christ and the acceptance of this mission by Mary for all men" (texte officiel, vatican.va, archive FRA0013).

    150

Can’t find your topic?