Saint Peter, a Galilean fisherman who became the first of the Twelve Apostles, is the figure most frequently mentioned in the New Testament after Jesus himself: he is named 154 times as Peter, not counting Simon and Kephas[1]. Witness of the Transfiguration, first confessor of the divinity of Christ, pardoned renegade and then shepherd of the flock, martyr in Rome under Nero, he is also one of the authors of Scripture: two epistles bear his name, and the most ancient tradition sees behind the Gospel of Mark his own preaching set down in writing[2].
This article presents him as a figure of the Bible received by the Church: his exact place in the canon, the traditional attribution and dating of his writings, the ancient witnesses that guarantee them, their structure and theology, their use in the liturgy, and then, at the end of the journey, the objections of modern exegesis and their limits. The dogmatic dossier of his primacy is treated in Pope Saint Peter, the archaeology of his tomb in Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome, and his portrait as a saint in Saint Peter: these are not duplicated here, but referred to.
Peter's place in the New Testament
First of the lists, most named of the witnesses
In the four lists of the Twelve given by the New Testament, Simon Peter is always named first, just as Judas is always named last; Matthew even writes: “first, Simon, called Peter”[3]. Benedict XVI notes the figures: after Jesus, Peter is the most famous and most frequently cited figure of the New Testament writings, mentioned 154 times with the surname Peter, the Greek translation of the Aramaic Kephas given by Jesus himself, attested nine times, especially in the letters of Paul; to these are added 75 mentions of Simon and two of Simeon, in Acts 15:14 and 2 Peter 1:1[4]. He speaks on behalf of the Apostles, receives the most solemn words of Christ, and presides over the first community of Jerusalem[5].
The following table shows where the New Testament has Peter speak or act, and where he is silent: this distribution already outlines his role, as witness to Christ from Galilee to Rome.
| Corpus | Peter appears there | Main role |
|---|---|---|
| The four Gospels | Everywhere, from the first call to the morning of Easter | Called disciple, confessor, witness, pardoned renegade |
| The Acts of the Apostles | Chapters 1 to 12, then at the council (ch. 15) | Head of the first Church, opening to the Gentiles |
| The letters of Paul | Galatians 1-2, 1 Corinthians 1, 9 and 15 | Pillar of Jerusalem, witness of the Resurrection |
| The two epistles of Peter | Named author (1 Pet 1:1; 2 Pet 1:1) | Shepherd who exhorts the tested Churches |
| Revelation | Never named directly | The twelve foundations bear the names of the Twelve (Rev 21:14) |
This table calls for two observations. First, Paul says little about Peter, but what little he says is decisive: fifteen days spent with him in Jerusalem three years after his conversion, the hand of fellowship exchanged at Antioch, and primacy in the list of the witnesses of the Resurrection[6][7]. Second, Revelation does not name him, even though the whole New Testament converges towards him: a sign that his figure belongs to the apostolic story narrated, not to the prophetic vision.
Simon, son of Jonah, fisherman of Galilee
A Jew from Bethsaida, a fishing craftsman
Simon is the son of John, according to the wording of John 1:42, or the son of Jonah (Bar-Jona), according to Matthew 16:17: both forms have been in circulation since the early Church and refer to the same man[8]. He is from Bethsaida, a small town on the eastern shore of the Sea of Galilee, which also produced Philip and Andrew, his brother; his speech betrays a Galilean accent[9]. Like his brother, he is a fisherman: together with the family of Zebedee, father of James and John, he runs a small fishing operation on the Lake of Gennesaret, which implies a certain degree of comfort and the presence of partners, not romanticised poverty[10].
Two domestic details round out the portrait. He is married: one day Jesus heals his mother-in-law at Capernaum, in the house where Simon himself lodges, and Paul will later recall that the apostles, including Peter, travel accompanied by a believing woman[11][12]. And this house at Capernaum has gone down in history: excavations there have uncovered, beneath the mosaic pavement of a small Byzantine church, the remains of an older house-church, with inscriptions containing invocations to Peter[13]. The fisherman thus lodged at the heart of Jesus' first Galilean headquarters.
First a disciple of the Baptist, then called at the lake
Before following Jesus, Simon sought God at the school of John the Baptist: the desire to see God act in history leads him, together with Andrew, as far as Judea to hear the Baptist's preaching[14]. It is there, according to the fourth Gospel, that Andrew brings him to Jesus, who looks at him and gives him a new name[15].
"You are Simon, son of John; you shall be called Kephas, which means: Peter."[16]
This name given in advance governs all that follows: God renames those he sends, as Abram became Abraham and Jacob became Israel. The synoptic account of the call at the lake gives us the scene: Jesus gets into Simon's boat to teach the crowds, orders the impossible catch, and before the nets that break apart Simon cries out that he is a sinful man.
"And so, Peter's boat becomes Jesus' pulpit."
- Benedict XVI, general audience of 17 May 2006[17]
The Risen Lord will make this frightened fisherman a fisher of men all the way to Rome.
Peter in the Gospels
The call, the confession, the Transfiguration
The Gospels allow us to follow step by step the spiritual journey of Peter, a determined and impulsive character, capable alike of drawing the sword in the Garden of Olives and of the most sincere repentance[18]. Three high points structure this journey. The call by the lake, where the carpenter of Nazareth, who is no fishing expert, wins the professional's trust against all expertise: "at your word, I will lower the nets"[19]. The confession at Caesarea Philippi, where Jesus is not content with hearsay and demands a personal commitment: "But you, who do you say I am?", and Peter answers on behalf of the others: "You are the Christ"[20]. This answer, Matthew specifies, comes not from flesh and blood but from the Father in heaven, and it contains in embryo the future profession of faith of the Church[21].
Immediately following comes the promise that grounds his unique place:
"You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church; and the powers of Death shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of Heaven: whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven."[22]
The Catechism sees in it the rock of the Church's faith and the charge entrusted to Simon, first of the college of the Twelve[23]. The dogmatic foundation of this primacy, along with objections and their answers, is treated in Pope Saint Peter: the reader is referred there and it is not repeated. The Transfiguration makes Peter, together with James and John, one of the three witnesses of the glory, first asleep then dazzled; he will propose setting up three tents, not knowing what he is saying, and he will hear the Father's voice[24]. He himself will later recall this moment in his second epistle as a vision of a grown man, not an invented tale[25].
The denial and the shepherd's restoration
Peter wants a divine-man Messiah who imposes his power; Jesus presents himself as the human God, the suffering servant, and at the announcement of the Passion Peter protests and brings down upon himself the "Get behind me, Satan"[26]. At the Last Supper, Jesus warns him personally: Satan has demanded to sift the disciples like wheat, but he has prayed that Peter's faith might not fail, with a precise mission for the aftermath of the fall.
"I have prayed for you, that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers."[27]
The denial takes place as announced, three times before a servant girl, then the cock crows and the Lord turns round: Peter weeps bitterly[28]. On Easter morning, the angel's message expressly names Peter among the recipients, and Paul will open his list of apparitions with him: "he appeared to Peter, then to the Twelve"[29][30]. By the lake, the threefold question repairs the threefold denial: to each "do you love me" answers a charge, lambs then sheep, up to the invitation to follow towards an announced martyrdom[31]. The forgiven sinner becomes the shepherd: it is this forgiveness, not any natural superiority, that grounds all his subsequent ministry.
Peter in Acts and the Letters of Paul
Head of the First Church of Jerusalem
At Pentecost, it is Peter who stands up with the Eleven, explains the tongues of fire through the prophet Joel, and baptizes three thousand people in a single day: the fisherman intimidated before a servant girl now speaks before thousands of listeners[32]. He heals in the name of Jesus, answers the Sanhedrin, receives the vision of the sheet with the unclean animals, and understands that the Gospel overflows Israel[33]. Two episodes show his stature: before Ananias and Sapphira, who lie to the Holy Spirit, his word strips away the masks and protects the nascent holiness of the Church; freed from Herod's prison while the Church prays without ceasing, he finds that God opens the doors that kings shut[34].
At the Council of Jerusalem, as the debate over the circumcision of converted Gentiles grew heated, Peter stands up and decides the matter: God has shown His choice by giving the Spirit to the Gentiles through his mouth, making no distinction, purifying their hearts by faith; why impose a yoke that neither the fathers nor the apostles have been able to bear[35]? James will confirm it, and the letter to the Churches will seal the decision. Here the first of the Apostles is the door-opener: opening the door to the Gentiles, then opening the council. Between Jerusalem and Rome, one stage is attested by tradition: Peter governed the Church of Antioch, of which he is regarded as the first bishop, as Jerome recalls at the head of his notice[36].
What Paul Says About Peter, and the Incident at Antioch
Paul does not recount Peter's life, but he presumes it known and gives it decisive weight. Three years after his conversion, he goes up to Jerusalem to make the acquaintance of Cephas and stays fifteen days with him: the converted persecutor checks his Gospel with the witness[37]. Later, James, Peter and John, regarded as the pillars, extend the right hand to him and to Barnabas as a sign of communion, sharing the fields of mission: to Peter the circumcised, to Paul the nations[38].
« They recognized that the proclamation of the Gospel had been entrusted to me for the uncircumcised, just as it had been to Peter for the circumcised. Having recognized the grace that was given to me, James, Peter and John, who are regarded as the pillars of the Church, extended the right hand to us. »[39]
Then comes the incident at Antioch, where Paul resists Peter to his face because he had begun to withdraw from meals with the Gentiles for fear of the circumcised[40]. Far from cancelling Peter's office, as is sometimes objected, this confrontation presupposes it: one publicly rebukes only the man whose conduct commits the whole Church, and Paul himself relates the episode without ever disputing either Peter's mission or his rank among the pillars. The full case for the objection is dealt with in Pope Saint Peter.
The Two Epistles of Peter, Received Scripture
The Traditional Attribution: Peter, Sylvanus, and Babylon
The first epistle opens with a solemn address: « Peter, apostle of Jesus Christ, to those who sojourn as strangers in the dispersion in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia »[41]. Five provinces of Asia Minor, a vocabulary of exile: the author writes as an apostle to scattered communities. He signs off his method at the end: through Sylvanus, regarded as a trustworthy brother, he writes these few words to exhort and attest the true grace of God[42]. Sylvanus is Silas: prophet of the Church of Jerusalem, companion of Paul in mission, co-signer of the letters to the Thessalonians[43]. A secretary of this rank explains without detour the fine Greek of the epistle, which is sometimes set against the Galilean fisherman: the objection assumes that Peter wrote everything with his own hand, which the text itself denies.
The place of sending completes the anchoring: « The community that is at Babylon greets you, as does Mark, my son »[44]. From the early Church onward, Babylon designates Rome figuratively, as Eusebius attests: Peter is said to have written his first epistle in Rome itself, calling the city Babylon in the sense of the Apocalypse, and there he mentions Mark, his spiritual son[45]. Tradition thus places the writing in Rome, in the years preceding the martyrdom, around 62–64, when Nero's persecution begins to strike after the fire of 64 attested by Tacitus[46].
The second epistle presents itself as a testament: Symeon Peter writes to those who share the same faith, knowing that his departure is near, as the Lord has made known to him, and he declares that he is already writing his second letter to awaken the memory of the readers[47]. Tradition dates it to the apostle's final months, around 64–67.
Ancient Witnesses and Reception into the Canon
No writing of the New Testament enters the canon without being read, copied, and cited as Scripture by the Churches. For the letters of Peter, the chain of witnesses is early and continuous. Eusebius, at the beginning of the fourth century, ranks the first epistle among the writings unanimously recognized, freely cited by the ancients as an undisputed work, while he honestly notes that the second did not then figure among the universally received writings[48]. This very honesty is authoritative: the Church did not canonize blindly; she weighed.
Jerome, around 392–393, summarizes the state of the case:
« He wrote two epistles called catholic, the second of which is held by many not to be his, because of the difference of style with the first. »
- Saint Jerome, De viris illustribus, ch. I[49]
He himself attributes this difference to the change of secretary, and the Church eventually received both. From the mid-fourth century, Cyril of Jerusalem asks his catechumens to receive, besides the four Gospels and the Acts, the seven catholic epistles of James, Peter, John, and Jude, with the fourteen of Paul as a seal[50].
The following table gathers the great canonical lists that expressly name the two epistles of Peter: from Rome to the ecumenical council, the reception never wavers.
| Canonical list | Date | Formulation concerning Peter |
|---|---|---|
| Roman Canon, called of Damasus | 382 | Two epistles of the apostle Peter, among the seven canonical[51] |
| Innocent I, letter to Exuperius of Toulouse | 20 February 405 | Two epistles of Peter, Jude in parentheses in certain manuscripts[52] |
| Eugene IV, bull of union with the Copts | 4 February 1442 | Two of Peter, three of John, one of James, one of Jude[53] |
| Council of Trent, decree on the sacred books | 8 April 1546 | Two of the apostle Peter, received under pain of anathema[54] |
Trent gives the dogmatic definition that closes the Catholic debate:
« The holy council receives and venerates with the same sentiment of piety and the same respect all the books both of the Old Testament and of the New Testament, since God is the single author of both. If anyone does not receive these books as sacred and canonical in their entirety: let him be anathema. »[55]
The Catechism confirms the rule of reading: the Church receives as sacred and canonical the 46 books of the Old and the 27 of the New Testament, with their full lists[56]. And the oldest surviving manuscript of the two letters points the same way: the Bodmer VIII papyrus, shelfmark P72, copies in Greek the entirety of the first and second epistles with Jude, a physical witness of the third or fourth century proving that the two letters already circulated together as Scripture[57].
The First Epistle: Structure and Theology
The Structure of the Letter
The first epistle is an apostolic exhortation to tried Christians, built in five movements that the following table summarises with their divisions.
| Movement | Passage | Content |
|---|---|---|
| Address and thanksgiving | 1, 1 - 2, 10 | Election, rebirth to a living hope, holy people |
| Living as strangers | 2, 11 - 3, 12 | Conduct among the pagans, duties of state, marriage |
| Suffering with Christ | 3, 13 - 4, 19 | Apology of hope, the example of Christ, the fiery furnace |
| The shepherds of the flock | 5, 1-11 | Elders, humility, vigilance against the lion |
| Sent by Silvanus | 5, 12-14 | Secretary, greetings from Babylon and from Mark |
The opening sets the tone: "Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ: in his great mercy, he has given us a new birth to a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead" [58]. This living hope is the watchword of the whole letter: it is still read aloud every year on the second Sunday of Easter[59].
A Theology of Tried Hope
Three emphases give the letter its unity. The holy people: drawing on Exodus, Peter calls the baptised "a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation", charged with proclaiming the marvels of him who called them out of darkness into his marvellous light[60]. No writing of the New Testament states the common priesthood of the faithful with such force, a priesthood that the Second Vatican Council would later take up. And Peter, whom Christ surnamed the Rock, reserves the finest title for another: "draw near to him: he is the living stone" [61]. The bearer of the name steps back before the one he designates. Christ, model of sufferers: "Christ suffered for you, leaving you an example so that you might follow in his steps, he who committed no sin" [62]. Unjust suffering, endured without threat like the Lamb, becomes witness and mission. The defence of hope: "always be ready to make a defence to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you" [63]. This verse gave its name to the whole of Christian apologetics.
The letter names persecution without disguise: "do not be surprised at the fiery trial that has broken out among you", and "if it is as a Christian, let him glorify God for that name" [64]. The word "Christian", still rare at this date, appears there as a title of which one can boast before the courts: a sign of a Church already faced with public hostility, well before the great general persecutions.
The Second Epistle: Testament and Vigilance
The Structure of the Testament
The second epistle is brief, three chapters, and solemn like a farewell discourse. Moses before entering Canaan, Paul at Miletus before the elders of Ephesus, Jesus at the Last Supper: Scripture knows the genre of the testament, and Peter places himself within it by announcing his imminent departure[65].
| Movement | Passage | Content |
|---|---|---|
| The confirmed call | 1, 1-11 | Faith received as a share, virtues in a chain, a sure vocation |
| The eyewitness | 1, 12-21 | The Transfiguration seen, the prophetic word confirmed |
| Against the false teachers | 2, 1-22 | Denunciation of heretics, the examples of the Flood and Sodom |
| The day of the Lord | 3, 1-18 | Mockers, God's patience, new heavens, a call to vigilance |
Witness of the Transfiguration, Reader of Paul
The heart of the letter is a personal testimony. Against the sophisticated tales already being spread by the false teachers, Peter sets what he saw with his own eyes on the holy mountain: the glory received from the Father and the voice heard. The liturgy of the Transfiguration, each 6 August, offers this passage as an alternative first reading[66].
"It was not by following cleverly devised myths that we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but because we were eyewitnesses of his majesty. This voice coming from heaven we ourselves heard when we were with him on the holy mountain." [67]
Peter adds to it a principle of interpretation that governs the whole Catholic reading of Scripture: no prophecy explains itself, for men spoke from God, moved by the Holy Spirit[68]. Then, in a feature unique in the whole New Testament, he ranks the letters of Paul among the Scriptures: Paul, "our beloved brother", has written with the wisdom received, and the ignorant twist his difficult passages "as they do the rest of the Scriptures" [69]. From the apostolic generation itself, one apostle thus acknowledges the scriptural authority of another apostle: the consciousness of the canon is born from within, not from a late decision. The opening itself bears a discreet mark of authenticity: the author names himself "Symeon Peter", with the Hebrew form of the name that the New Testament uses elsewhere only once, on the lips of James at the Council of Jerusalem[70]. A forger of the second century would have written in everyday Greek; the witness writes as a Galilean speaks.
The final eschatology answers the mockers who laugh at the promise: the Lord does not delay, he exercises patience, and the day will come like a thief, with new heavens and a new earth where righteousness will dwell[71]. Vigilance, not the calculation of dates, is Peter's answer, as it will be that of the whole Church.
Peter behind the Gospel of Mark
Papias and Peter's interpreter
The second Gospel does not name its author, but the earliest tradition of the Church links it to Peter through Mark. Papias, bishop of Hierapolis in the first half of the second century, reports what an elder used to say: Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately, though without order, everything he remembered of the words and deeds of the Lord, for he had neither heard nor followed Christ himself, but had followed Peter, who adapted his teaching to the needs of his listeners[72].
« Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately, though without order, everything he remembered of what the Lord had said or done. »[73]
This testimony, transmitted by Eusebius, is the oldest we possess on the origin of a Gospel, generally dated to the years 110–140. It explains two features of the text of Mark: its lively, eyewitness reporting, with observed details and proper names, and its apparent lack of order — that of an oral preaching adapted to successive audiences.
The Roman catechesis set down in writing
A century later, Irenaeus of Lyon, who had known Polycarp, a disciple of John, confirms and refines:
« After their departure, Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, handed down in writing what Peter had preached. »
Matthew had therefore published his Gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul preached in Rome and founded the Church there. Eusebius adds the Roman setting: Peter's hearers in Rome, not content with oral teaching, would have begged Mark to leave them a written monument of the doctrine, and Peter, learning of it by revelation, would have rejoiced and given the work the authority of his approval for the use of the Churches[75].
The convergence is remarkable: Papias in Asia, Irenaeus in Gaul, Clement in Alexandria, and Eusebius in Caesarea — four witnesses from four regions — say the same thing without having concerted. The second Gospel is the voice of Peter set down by Mark. The literary dossier of the Markan text, with its own characteristics, is presented in The Gospel according to Saint Mark and in the article devoted to Saint Mark.
Rome and the apostle's martyrdom
The closest witnesses
Peter left no account of his death, but the witnesses who follow closely upon him are unanimous: he died a martyr in Rome under Nero. Clement of Rome, writing to the Corinthians around 96, while witnesses were possibly still alive, evokes Peter and Paul as the pillars persecuted by jealousy, Peter having endured many hardships before suffering martyrdom and departing for the place of glory due to him[76]. Ignatius of Antioch, being led to execution around 107, writes to the Romans: « it is not as Peter and Paul that I give you orders; they were apostles », taking for granted their presence and authority in the capital[77].
Dionysius of Corinth, around 170, writes to the Romans that Peter and Paul planted together the Church of Corinth and then that of Italy, taught there together, and suffered martyrdom at the same time[78]. And Gaius, a member of the Roman Church under Zephyrinus, at the turn of the third century, hurls at his opponent: « I can show you the trophies of the apostles: go to the Vatican or on the Ostian Way, you will find the trophies of those who founded this Church »[79]. Half a century after the events, pilgrims were already being shown the tombs, at the Vatican for Peter, on the Ostian Way for Paul.
The inverted cross and the twenty-five years
Tertullian, around 200, sums up the Roman pride:
« Happy Church, where the apostles poured out all their doctrine with their blood, where Peter endures a passion like that of his Lord, where Paul wins his crown! »
- Tertullian, On the Prescription against Heretics, ch. 36[80]
Jerome, around 392–393, fixes the transmitted chronology: Simon Peter, son of John, of Bethsaida, after being bishop of Antioch and preaching to the Dispersion of Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, came to Rome in the second year of Claudius to combat Simon Magus, held the sacerdotal seat there for twenty-five years until the fourteenth and last year of Nero, and there received martyrdom, nailed to the cross head downwards and feet upwards, declaring himself unworthy to be crucified as his Lord[81]. He adds that he is buried in the Vatican, near the triumphal way, and venerated by the whole world.
The chronology of the twenty-five years, which supposes an arrival as early as 42, remains disputed even among Catholics; the central fact, however, is not: Peter came to Rome, taught there, and died a martyr there under Nero, around 64–67. The archaeology of the Vatican necropolis and the history of the tomb are developed in the Basilica of Saint Peter in Rome, and the detailed account of his Roman life in Saint Peter.
- Around 27–28The call by the lakeside
Simon the fisherman follows Jesus with Andrew; he becomes Peter, the Rock.
- Around 29The confession at Caesarea
First to confess Christ; promise of the keys and of the Church.
- Around 30Easter and Pentecost
Denial then forgiveness; first witness cited by Paul; three thousand baptisms.
- Around 40The opening to the Gentiles
Baptism of the centurion Cornelius at Caesarea Maritima.
- Around 49–50The Council of Jerusalem
Peter settles the debate on the circumcision of Gentile converts.
- Around 62–64The first epistle
Written in Rome, through Silvanus, to the Churches of Asia Minor.
- Around 64–67The martyrdom in Rome
Crucified under Nero; buried in the Vatican.
The liturgical use of the Petrine heritage
The Church does not merely read Peter: she prays to him and celebrates him. The second epistle feeds the Transfiguration on 6 August, where the eyewitness testimony is offered as the alternative first reading[82]. The first epistle feeds the Easter season, with the living hope of the Second Sunday of Easter and the readings of the Good Shepherd[83].
Two feasts mark the year: 29 June, the shared solemnity of Peter and Paul, the two columns whose blood founded Rome, and 22 February, the Chair of Saint Peter, which celebrates the apostle's teaching authority in his successor.
The keys, promised in Matthew 16, became his universal attribute, appearing even in the papal coat of arms. The details of the cults and iconography are presented in Saint Peter and in the article on the shared feast, Saints Peter and Paul.
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
The article has first set out the traditional position: both epistles are by Peter, written from Rome around 62-67, and Mark transmits his preaching. A part of contemporary exegesis offers another reading: the first epistle by a disciple after Peter's death, the second epistle a pseudonymous work of the second century, Mark attributed late, Rome invented. These hypotheses deserve a fair hearing, and then a reply, for they determine the confidence a reader may place in the text.
Objection 1: The fine Greek of the first epistle, impossible for a Galilean fisherman
The objection has force: the first epistle is written in polished Greek, steeped in the Septuagint, with balanced periods. A fisherman of Bethsaida, whose mother tongue is Aramaic, could not have composed it alone. The reply comes down to one name: Silvanus. The epistle itself declares that it is written through him, and Silvanus is no unknown figure: a prophet of Jerusalem, a companion on Paul's missionary journeys, co-signer of epistles[84][85]. Antiquity routinely worked with secretaries who gave shape to a text, and Jerome had already explained the difference in style between the two epistles by the change of interpreter[86]. The objection assumes what the text denies: solitary composition, without assistance.
Objection 2: The persecution described presupposes Domitian or Trajan, not Nero
The letter speaks of a fiery ordeal and of appearing as a Christian, which some place under Domitian (the 90s) or Trajan (after 110), when Pliny describes, in his letter to Trajan, Christians prosecuted for the name alone[87]. But Nero had opened the way as early as 64: Tacite recounts the fire of Rome blamed on the Christians, handed over to the torches and the beasts, and Suetonius confirms the tortures under that reign[88].
Above all, the argument suffers from a circle: one dates the letter by the persecution one assumes to be general, then one proves from that date that the persecution was general. Local and intermittent pressures, attested from Claudius to Trajan, are enough to explain the tone of the letter, without requiring an Empire-wide persecution.
Objection 3: The silence of Muratori and the doubts about the second epistle prove fraud
The Muratorian Fragment, around 170-200, receives Jude and two letters of John among the canonical books, even welcomes the Apocalypse of Peter, but passes over the two epistles of Peter in silence[89]. Added to the hesitations of Origen, who knows the second as disputed, the record seems damning[90]. Three replies are in order. First, the fragment is mutilated at the beginning: its silence carries no more weight than that of a maimed witness, and it also passes over James and Hebrews, without anyone concluding that these are fraudulent. Second, the ancient doubts concern literary authenticity, never orthodoxy: Eusebius and Jerome record them instead of hiding them, proof of a Church that weighs matters rather than invents them[91][92]. Finally, the papyrus P72 shows the two letters copied together as Scripture from the third or fourth century, and the unanimous reception of the fourth-century lists, from Cyril to Damasus, settles the ancient debate in favour of authenticity[93][94].
Objection 4: Mark, an anonymous Gospel attributed late to an obscure figure
No manuscript of Mark bears a signature, and the attribution to Peter's interpreter would come only from Papias, around 130. But no competing attribution exists anywhere in antiquity: neither Matthew, nor Luke, nor John, nor any other name has ever been proposed for the second Gospel, and all the witnesses, from Asia, Gaul, Alexandria and Caesarea, converge on Mark and Peter[95][96]. An attribution invented late would have left traces of debate; early unanimity speaks for memory, not for construction. And Papias's remark about the lack of order precisely explains the chronological tensions with the other Gospels, instead of aggravating them.
Objection 5: Peter in Rome, a legend to found the papacy
In the nineteenth century, the Tübingen school read early history as a conflict between Petrine and Pauline factions, making Peter's Rome a late projection of Roman claims[97]. The texts resist: Clement writes around 96, Ignatius around 107, Dionysius around 170, Gaius shows the trophies around 198, and one does not display tombs fifty years after the events without a continuous local memory[98][99][100]. Above all, the tables have turned: Oscar Cullmann, a Protestant exegete, established in his 1952 monograph that Peter's coming and martyrdom in Rome rest on solid historical foundations, against the theses of his own camp[101]. When a Protestant sides with Rome on Peter in Rome, the legend hypothesis is finished.
Methodological limits to keep in mind
Beyond the point-by-point replies, four weaknesses afflict the late reconstructions. The argument from silence: passing over a writing in silence is not refuting it, especially with a mutilated fragment like Muratori. Circular dating: dating by the supposed persecution, then proving the persecution by the date. The anti-supernatural presupposition: when a precise prophecy is held in advance to be impossible, any text that predicts correctly is declared late, and the conclusion is contained in the postulate. The confusion between literary possibility and historical proof: showing that a disciple could have written in Peter's name does not establish that he did so, in the face of an early and unanimous tradition that says otherwise. The Catholic reading, for its part, rests on named witnesses, dated manuscripts and conciliar lists: that is why the traditional datings and attributions remain defensible, and indeed the best founded.
To go further
- Saint Peter: a portrait of the saint of the origins, his spirituality and his cult
- Pope Saint Peter: the primacy, the objections and their answers
- Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome: the Vatican necropolis and the tomb
- Saint Paul the Apostle: the other pillar of the early Church
- Saint Andrew the Apostle: the brother who brought Peter to Jesus
- The Gospel according to Saint Mark: the text of Peter's interpreter
- Saint Mark the Evangelist: the disciple and secretary
- Saints Peter and Paul: the common feast of June 29
- The Virgin Mary in the New Testament
- Saint John the Baptist in the New Testament
- Saint Joseph in the New Testament
Notes and References
Benedict XVI, general audience of May 17, 2006, Peter, the Fisherman: after Jesus, Peter is the most famous and most frequently cited figure in the writings of the New Testament, mentioned 154 times with the surname Peter, the Greek translation of the Aramaic Kephas given by Jesus, attested nine times especially in Paul, plus 75 mentions of Simon and two of Simeon (Acts 15:14; 2 Pet 1:1). Text at https://www.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/fr/audiences/2006/documents/hf_ben-xvi_aud_20060517.html.
1 4 8Papias of Hierapolis, Exposition of the Sayings of the Lord, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History III, 39, 15: Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, everything he remembered. Eng. text NPNF Series II, vol. I: https://ccel.org/ccel/schaff/npnf201/npnf201.iii.viii.xxxix.html. Original text: "Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he remembered of the things said or done by Christ."
2 72 73 95Mt 10:2, trans. AELF: « Voici les noms des douze Apôtres : le premier, Simon, nommé Pierre. »
3Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 552: Simon Peter holds first place in the college of the Twelve; at his confession, Christ promises to build his Church upon him and gives him the keys. Official text: https://www.vatican.va/archive/FRA0013/__P1I.HTM.
5 23Gal 1:18-19, trans. AELF: fifteen days with Cephas.
6 371 Cor 15:3-8, trans. AELF: the appearance to Peter first.
7 30Benedict XVI, same audience: Simon of Bethsaida, a fisherman associated with the family of Zebedee, a disciple of John the Baptist along with Andrew, a believing and practising Jew. Same URL.
9 10 14Mt 8:14-15; Mk 1:29-31; Lk 4:38-39, trans. AELF: the healing of the mother-in-law.
111 Cor 9:5, trans. AELF: the apostles, including Peter, accompanied by a believing woman.
12Benedict XVI, same audience: the excavations at Capernaum have brought to light, beneath the octagonal mosaic of a small Byzantine church, the remains of an older house-church, with inscriptions containing invocations to Peter. Same URL.
13Jn 1:42, trans. AELF.
15 16Benedict XVI, same audience: Peter's boat becomes the Chair of Jesus; Peter could not yet imagine that he would one day arrive in Rome to be a fisher of men there. Same URL.
17Benedict XVI, same audience: a determined and impulsive character, capable of drawing the sword in the Garden of Olives, naive and fearful at times, but honest to the point of the most sincere repentance. Same URL.
18Lk 5:4-10, trans. AELF: the miraculous catch of fish and the call.
19Mk 8:27-33, trans. AELF: the confession and « Passe derrière moi, Satan » ("Get behind me, Satan").
20Benedict XVI, same audience: at Caesarea Philippi, Jesus demands a personal stance, Peter answers on behalf of the others, and his answer contains in embryo the future profession of faith of the Church. Same URL.
21Mt 16:18-19, trans. AELF.
22Mk 9:2-8; Mt 17:1-8; Lk 9:28-36, trans. AELF: Peter, James, and John as witnesses.
242 Pet 1:16-19, trans. AELF.
25 67Benedict XVI, same audience: Peter wants a divine man-Messiah who imposes his power, Jesus presents himself as the human God, the suffering servant; hence the "Get behind me, Satan." Same URL.
26Lk 22:31-32, trans. AELF.
27Mt 26:69-75; Mk 14:66-72; Lk 22:54-62, trans. AELF.
28Mk 16:7, trans. AELF: « Allez dire à ses disciples et à Pierre. » ("Go tell his disciples and Peter.")
29Jn 21:15-17, trans. AELF: the threefold question and the charges of lambs and then of sheep.
31Acts 2:14-41, trans. AELF: Peter's discourse and three thousand baptisms.
32Acts 10:1 - 11:18, trans. AELF: the vision of the sheet and the baptism of Cornelius.
33Acts 5:1-11 and Acts 12:1-17, trans. AELF: Ananias and Sapphira, Herod's prison.
34Acts 15:7-11, trans. AELF: Peter's intervention at the council.
35Saint Jerome, On Illustrious Men, ch. I: Simon Peter, son of John, of Bethsaida, bishop of Antioch, came to Rome in the second year of Claudius, held the see there twenty-five years until the fourteenth year of Nero, and was crucified head downwards; he wrote two epistles called Catholic, the second of which is held by many not to be his because of its style; the Gospel of Mark is attributed to him; buried at the Vatican. Eng. trans. NPNF Series II, vol. III. Original text: "He wrote two epistles which are called Catholic, the second of which, on account of its difference from the first in style, is considered by many not to be by him."
36 49 81 86 92Gal 2:7-9, trans. AELF: the pillars and the division of missions.
38 39Gal 2:11-14, trans. AELF: Paul resists Peter to his face at Antioch.
401 Pet 1:1, trans. AELF.
411 Pet 5:12-13, trans. AELF: Silvanus as secretary, greetings from Babylon and from Mark.
42 44 84Acts 15:22-32; 1 Thess 1:1, trans. AELF: Silas, prophet of Jerusalem and companion of Paul.
43 85Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History II, 15, 1-2: the Roman listeners beg Mark to set the teaching down in writing; Peter, on learning of it, rejoices and gives his approval; he writes his first epistle from Rome itself, calling the city Babylon by figure (1 Pet 5:13). Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/250102.htm. Original text: "And Peter makes mention of Mark in his first epistle which they say that he wrote in Rome itself, as is indicated by him, when he calls the city, by a figure, Babylon."
45 75Tacitus, Annals, XV, 44: after the fire of Rome in 64, Nero handed the Christians over to the torches, the beasts, and the cross; Suetonius, Life of Nero, 16: Christians struck down with torments under this reign.
46 882 Pet 1:13-15 and 2 Pet 3:1, trans. AELF: the near departure and the second letter.
47 65Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History III, 3, 1: the first epistle of Peter is recognized as authentic and freely quoted by the ancients as an uncontested work; the second did not then appear among the universally received writings. Text: https://ccel.org/ccel/schaff/npnf201/npnf201.iii.viii.iii.html. Original text: "One epistle of Peter, that called the first, is acknowledged as genuine. And this the ancient elders used freely in their own writings as an undisputed work."
48 91Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures, IV, 33-36, c. 350: receive the four Gospels, the Acts, the seven Catholic epistles of James, Peter, John and Jude, and the fourteen of Paul; read nothing of the apocrypha. Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/310104.htm. Original text: "the seven Catholic Epistles of James, Peter, John, and Jude."
50 94Roman Canon attributed to Damasus, Rome, 382: seven canonical epistles, two of them from the apostle Peter. Denzinger, Symboles et définitions de la foi catholique, French ed., no. 179.
51Innocent I, letter Consulenti tibi to Exuperius of Toulouse, 20 February 405: two epistles of Peter in the list of books received into the canon. Denzinger, French ed., no. 213.
52Eugene IV, bull Cantate Domino for the union with the Copts, Florence, 4 February 1442: two of Peter, three of John, one of James, one of Jude. Denzinger, French ed., no. 1334-1335.
53Council of Trent, session IV, decree De libris sacris, 8 April 1546: God as sole author of the two Testaments; list including two from the apostle Peter; anathema against those who do not receive them. Denzinger, French ed., no. 1501-1504.
54 55Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 120: the Church receives as sacred and canonical 46 books of the Old Testament and 27 of the New, whose lists are given in full. Mame/Plon edition, Paris, 1992.
56Bodmer Papyrus VIII (Gregory-Aland P72), third or fourth century: complete Greek copy of the first and second epistles of Peter together with Jude, the oldest surviving manuscript of the two letters. Ed. M. Testuz, Papyrus Bodmer VII-IX, Bibliotheca Bodmeriana, Cologny-Geneva, 1959; catalogued by the INTF.
57 931 Pet 1:3-9, trans. AELF.
58Roman Lectionary, Second Sunday of Easter: in the second reading, 1 Pet 1:3-9, the living hope. Verified at https://www.aelf.org/2026-04-12/romain/messe.
59 831 Pet 2:9-10, trans. AELF.
601 Pet 2:4-8, trans. AELF: « Approchez-vous de lui : il est la pierre vivante rejetée par les hommes, mais choisie et précieuse devant Dieu. » ("Come to him: he is the living stone rejected by men, but chosen and precious in the sight of God.")
611 Pet 2:21-25, trans. AELF.
621 Pet 3:15-16, trans. AELF.
631 Pet 4:12-16, trans. AELF.
64Roman Lectionary, Transfiguration of the Lord, 6 August: in the alternative first reading (or), 2 Pet 1:16-19, the testimony of the eyewitness. Verified at https://www.aelf.org/2025-08-06/romain/messe.
66 822 Pet 1:20-21, trans. AELF: no prophecy explains itself.
682 Pet 3:15-16, trans. AELF: Paul, beloved brother, and the rest of the Scriptures.
692 Pet 1:1 and Acts 15:14, trans. AELF: « Syméon Pierre » ("Simeon Peter") at the opening of the letter; « Syméon » ("Simeon") in James's discourse at the council.
702 Pet 3:8-13, trans. AELF: the patience of the Lord and the new heavens.
71Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies III, 1, 1: Matthew publishes his Gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul preach in Rome; after their departure, Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, hands down in writing what Peter had preached. Trans. Roberts-Donaldson: https://www.earlychristianwritings.com/text/irenaeus-book3.html. Original text: "After their departure, Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, did also hand down to us in writing what had been preached by Peter."
74 96Clement of Rome, Epistle to the Corinthians, ch. 5: Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured many labours before suffering martyrdom and departing for the place of glory that was his due. Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1010.htm. Original text: "Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labours; and when he had at length suffered martyrdom, departed to the place of glory due to him."
76 98Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Romans, ch. 4: "I do not, as Peter and Paul, issue commandments unto you; they were apostles, I am but a condemned man." Eng. text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0107.htm. Original text: "I do not, as Peter and Paul, issue commandments unto you. They were apostles; I am but a condemned man."
77 99Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History II, 25, 5-8: Paul beheaded and Peter crucified under Nero; Gaius shows the trophies on the Vatican and on the Ostian Way; Dionysius of Corinth attests their common planting of the Church and their simultaneous martyrdom. Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/250102.htm. Original text: "It is recorded that Paul was beheaded in Rome itself, and that Peter likewise was crucified under Nero"; Gaius: "I can show the trophies of the apostles. For if you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian way, you will find the trophies of those who laid the foundations of this church."
78 79 100Tertullian, On the Prescription of Heretics, ch. 36: happy the Church where the apostles poured out all their teaching with their blood, where Peter endures a passion like that of his Lord. Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0311.htm. Original text: "Where Peter endures a passion like his Lord's! Where Paul wins his crown in a death like John's."
80Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History III, 33: Pliny the Younger consults Trajan about Christians prosecuted for the name, and the emperor orders that they not be sought out but that those denounced be punished. Text: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/250103.htm. Original text of the rescript: "the race of Christians should not be sought after, but when found should be punished."
87Muratorian Fragment, c. 170–200 (Latin text mutilated at the beginning, trans. Roberts-Donaldson): the Epistle of Jude and two of John counted among the catholic epistles; the Apocalypse of Peter received by some; silence on the two Epistles of Peter. Text: https://www.earlychristianwritings.com/text/muratorian.html. Original text: « The Epistle of Jude, indeed, and two belonging to the above-named John, are reckoned among the Catholic epistles. »
89Origen, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History VI, 25: Peter left one acknowledged epistle, and perhaps a second, for it is disputed; first clear attestation of the debate with Firmilian of Caesarea (letter to Cyprian 74, 6). From the note in the Schaff ed., NPNF Series II, vol. I.
90Ferdinand Christian Baur, Paulus, der Apostel Jesu Christi, Stuttgart, 1845: the overall thesis of the Tübingen school, which reads the apostolic age as a conflict between Petrine and Pauline factions.
97Oscar Cullmann, Saint Pierre, disciple, apôtre, martyr, Delachaux et Niestlé, Neuchâtel-Paris, 1952: the work's overall thesis, which establishes Peter's coming to Rome and his martyrdom against radical criticism.
101