Saint Paul (Saulus, then Paulus), born in Tarsus around the year 5–10 and martyred in Rome around 64–67, is, together with Saint Peter, one of the two pillars of the early Church. A persecutor of the first Christians, seized by the risen Christ on the road to Damascus, he became the "Apostle of the nations" and carried the Gospel from Jerusalem to the heart of the Roman Empire[1][2].
He knew neither the Jesus of Galilee nor the empty tomb, and yet no one, after the Twelve, has marked the Christian faith so profoundly. His thirteen letters make up nearly a quarter of the New Testament and constitute the Church's first great theological corpus: justification by faith, the primacy of Christ, the doctrine of the Body of Christ, the hymn to charity[3][4].
This article treats Paul as Holy Scripture received by the Church: his place in the canon, the traditional attribution and dating of his letters, the ancient witnesses, the plan of each epistle, his theology, his liturgical use, and finally the historical-critical debate at the end of the article. His detailed biography, his spirituality, and his cult belong to the related article Saint Paul.
"I live, but it is no longer I, it is Christ who lives in me."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Galatians 2:20[5]
Paul's Place in the New Testament
The First Theologian of the New Testament
Paul is the first Christian author whose writings we possess. His first letter, to the Thessalonians, dates from around the year 50, some twenty years before the writing of the first Gospels. When he writes, the Church has neither a formulated creed nor a bound New Testament: she has the preaching of the apostles, the Scriptures of Israel, and the Eucharist. Paul's letters are therefore the first effort to think about faith in the risen Christ with the categories of Scripture, and the Church received them not as private essays but as the Word of God: as early as the end of the first century, the second epistle of Peter already ranks "all the letters" of Paul among "the other Scriptures"[6].
Thirteen Letters, Nearly a Quarter of the New Testament
The canon received by the Catholic Church attributes thirteen epistles to Paul, arranged not in chronological order but by decreasing length: first the nine letters addressed to seven Churches (Romans, Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, Thessalonians), then the four letters addressed to individuals (Timothy, Titus, Philemon)[7]. Together with Acts, which recounts his mission in chapters 9 to 28, Paul occupies more than a quarter of the New Testament, more than any other sacred author[8].
Saul of Tarsus, Persecuting Pharisee
A Jew of the Diaspora, a Roman Citizen
Saul is born in Tarsus, the cultured capital of Cilicia, into a Jewish family of the tribu of Benjamin, attached to the Hebrew language and to Pharisaic observance[9]. From birth he bears a rare privilege: Roman citizenship, inherited from his father, which would protect him twice, at Philippi and then at Jerusalem, and would open the road to Rome for him through his appeal to Caesar[10][11]. Having gone up to Jerusalem, he studies "at the feet of Gamaliel", the great doctor spoken of with respect by Acts itself, and is formed in a wholehearted and zealous reading of the Law[12].
"Circumcised on the eighth day, of the race of Israel, of the tribe of Benjamin, a Hebrew, son of Hebrews; as to the observance of the law of Moses, I was a Pharisee; as to zeal, I was a persecutor of the Church; as to the righteousness that the Law gives, I had become blameless."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Philippians 3:5–6[13]
The Persecutor of the First Christians
This zeal turns first against the nascent Church. Saul keeps the garments of the stoners of Stephen, ravages the Church house by house, and obtains letters to hunt down the disciples as far as Damascus[14]. Far from being a biographical detail, this past violence grounds his entire theology of grace: the one who calls himself "the foremost of sinners" and "the abortion" among the apostles received nothing by merit, everything by mercy[15][16]. His detailed life, his inward conversion, and his holiness are treated in the article Saint Paul: here it is the Apostle of the Scriptures who concerns us.
The road to Damascus and the Apostle's call
Around 33–36, on the road to Damascus where he was going to arrest the disciples, Saul is struck down by a light from heaven: "Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me?" To his question "Who are you, Lord?", the answer grounds all of Pauline ecclesiology: "I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting": to strike Christians is to strike Christ himself, for the Church is his Body[17]. Baptized by Ananias, Saul at once passes from persecutor to preacher, to the scandal of both camps[18].
Paul never presents Damascus as a mere moral conversion but as an apostolic call, placed on the same level as the appearances of the Risen One to Peter, to the Twelve, and to James: "and last of all, he appeared also to me, the one untimely born"[19]. It is on this appearance that he grounds his title of apostle, contested by some at Corinth: "Am I not an apostle? Have I not seen Jesus our Lord?"[20]. After a retreat in Arabia and then a first stay of fifteen days with Peter in Jerusalem, he evangelizes Syria and Cilicia for some ten years, almost unknown "by face" to the churches of Judea, but already reputed: "he who used to persecute us is now proclaiming the faith"[21].
The Acts narrative keeps the name Saul until Cyprus, where Luke specifies "Saul, also called Paul": Paulus is his Roman name, henceforth put forward for the mission among the nations[22]. The title "From Saul to Paul" therefore designates this overturning of a life, not a change of name that occurred at Damascus.
Paul in the Acts of the Apostles
Barnabas and the entry into mission
It is Barnabas, the Cypriot Levite, who goes to fetch Saul in Tarsus and introduces him into the Church of Antioch, where the disciples receive for the first time the name of "Christians"[23]. Sent out by this Church, Barnabas and Saul carry out the first journey (around 45–48): Cyprus, then southern Asia Minor, with the founding of churches and Paul's first stoning at Lystra[24]. The later quarrel between the two men over Mark does not prevent Paul from recalling Mark with tenderness at the end of his life[25].
The Council of Jerusalem and the incident at Antioch
Faced with the Judaizers who demand the circumcision of converted Gentiles, Paul goes up to Jerusalem with Barnabas and Titus: this is the Council of Jerusalem (around 49–50), where Peter, James, and John extend to him "the right hand of fellowship", sharing the missions: to Peter the circumcised, to Paul the Gentiles[26]. The full dossier of the council is treated in the article Council of Jerusalem. There remained a zone of friction, which Paul recounts without varnish: at Antioch, he "opposed him to his face" — Peter himself, whose wavering attitude towards eating at common tables risked making people believe that the Law is added to Christ in order to be saved[27]. Far from weakening Peter's authority, the episode shows two apostles whose communion survives a public correction, in order to keep the Gospel of grace pure.
The great missionary journeys
From 49 to 57, Paul carries out two immense journeys that bring the Gospel to Europe for the first time.
| Journey | Dates | Route | Major fruits |
|---|---|---|---|
| First, with Barnabas | Around 45–48 | Antioch, Cyprus, Southern Asia Minor | Foundations, stoning at Lystra[28] |
| Second, with Silas then Timothy | Around 49–52 | Asia, Macedonia, Athens, Corinth (18 months) | Philippi, Thessalonica, the Areopagus speech, Corinth[29][30] |
| Third | Around 53–57 | Galatia, Ephesus (2 to 3 years), Macedonia, Greece | The school of Tyrannus, the farewell at Miletus, the collection for Jerusalem[31] |
At Corinth, the proconsul Gallio refuses to condemn Paul and dismisses him: the anecdote, dated with precision by the letter of the emperor Claudius to the Delphians carved in stone, which names Gallio proconsul of Achaia at the time of the twenty-sixth imperial acclamation, that is, in 51–52, constitutes the most solid chronological marker of the Apostle's life and makes it possible to date his earliest letters[32][33]. At Ephesus, his daily preaching in the school of Tyrannus pushes back magic and the silversmiths of Artemis, until the riot of Demetrius[34].
The arrest in Jerusalem and the captivity in Rome
Having gone up to Jerusalem with the collection from the Gentile churches, Paul is arrested in the Temple on a false accusation, escapes scourging by invoking his Roman citizenship, then, before the governor Festus, appeals to Caesar: as a citizen, he will be judged in Rome[35][36][37]. The account of Acts ends with two years of supervised residence in Rome (around 60–62), where Paul "preached the kingdom of God with all boldness and without hindrance"[38]. Luke stops there, recounting neither trial nor martyrdom: the most ancient tradition, carried by Clement of Rome, supposes a release, a final mission as far as Spain as Paul had planned, then a return to Rome and the crown of martyrdom under Nero[39][40].
- Around 5-10Birth in Tarsus
Saul is born into a Jewish family of the tribe of Benjamin, a Roman citizen by birth[41].
- Around 33-36The road to Damascus
- Around 45-48First journey with Barnabas
Cyprus and Southern Asia Minor: first foundations, first stoning[44].
- Around 49-50The Council of Jerusalem
Peter, James, and John recognize his mission to the Gentiles[45].
- Around 50-52Corinth and the first letters
Eighteen months in Corinth, before Gallio; 1 and 2 Thessalonians[46].
- Around 53-57Ephesus and the great epistles
Two to three years of teaching; Galatians, Corinthians, Romans[47].
- Around 60-62First Roman captivity
Supervised residence; captivity letters: Philippians, Philemon, Colossians, Ephesians[48].
- Around 64-67Martyrdom under Nero
The Pauline corpus, Received Scripture
Thirteen epistles in a deliberate order
The New Testament arranges Paul's letters by decreasing length, from the great letters to the Churches down to the personal note to Philemon. The traditional dating, anchored to the chronology of Acts and the Gallio inscription, is as follows:
| Epistle | Traditional place and date | Occasion and heart of the message |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Thessalonians | Corinth, c. 50-51 | The earliest preserved Christian letter: standing firm in tribulation, watching in the expectation of the Lord[51] |
| 2 Thessalonians | Corinth, c. 51 | Correcting apocalyptic fever: the Day is not yet here; keep working while you wait[52] |
| Galatians | Antioch or Ephesus, c. 48-55 | Manifesto of freedom: circumcision adds nothing to Christ[53] |
| 1 Corinthians | Ephesus, c. 55-56 | Restoring a divided Church: unity, Eucharist, resurrection, the hymn to charity[54] |
| 2 Corinthians | Macedonia, c. 56-57 | Defence of the apostolic ministry in weakness: treasure in earthen vessels[55] |
| Romans | Corinth, c. 57 | The charter of the Gospel: justification by faith, Adam and Christ, Israel and the nations[56] |
| Philippians | Rome, c. 60-62 | Joy in chains: the hymn of Christ humbled then exalted[57] |
| Philemon | Rome, c. 60-62 | A runaway slave returned as a "beloved brother": the Gospel unchains social bonds[58] |
| Colossians | Rome, c. 60-62 | The absolute primacy of Christ against all syncretism[59] |
| Ephesians | Rome, c. 60-62 | The Church as the Body of Christ and the plan to gather all things into him[60] |
| 1 Timothy | Macedonia, c. 62-65 | Ordering the Church of Ephesus: bishops, deacons, sound doctrine[61] |
| Titus | Nicopolis, c. 62-65 | Organising the Churches of Crete: presbyters in every city[62] |
| 2 Timothy | Rome, c. 66-67 | The martyr's testament: "I have waged the good fight", handing on the deposit[63] |
Why the Epistle to the Hebrews is not included
The Epistle to the Hebrews, anonymous, follows immediately after Paul's letters in our Bibles, which fostered the idea of a fourteenth Pauline letter, upheld in the East by Clement of Alexandria and Origen. But the Latin tradition, through Tertullian and then Jerome, consistently distinguished it from the corpus. Jerome, in his notice on the Apostle, enumerates precisely: "nine letters to seven Churches", then "to his disciples: two to Timothy, one to Titus, one to Philemon", making thirteen epistles of Paul, and he treats Hebrews separately[64]. The Church, by receiving Hebrews into the canon without crediting it to Paul, shows her discernment: she does not baptise as Pauline every apostolic writing, which all the more strengthens the credibility of the thirteen letters she does attribute to him.
The traditional attribution and the ancient witnesses
What Paul says about himself
The letters carry their own marks of authenticity, which the tradition has never ceased to note. Paul names his co-senders (Silvanus and Timothy from 1 Thessalonians onwards), his secretary (Tertius, who greets the Romans himself in chapter 16), and his own hand for the final greeting, an explicit anti-forgery device: "The greeting is in my own hand, Paul. This is the mark in all my letters"[65][66][67]. The material details match Acts: Phoebe of Cenchreae carries the letter to the Romans, Gaius hosts Paul in Corinth, the collections, the companions and the trials dovetail seamlessly[68].
The earliest witnesses
No writing of the New Testament is cited as early or as widely as the letters of Paul. The earliest witness, Clement of Rome, writes to the Corinthians around 96, some thirty years after the martyrdom, and sums up the Apostle's race in a famous sentence:
"After instructing the whole world in righteousness and reaching the farthest limits of the West, he bore witness before the prefects, and so departed this world for the holy place."
- Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians, 5, 7[69]
The Spain Paul aimed for in Rom 15 here becomes "the farthest limits of the West": thirty years after the events, Rome remembers that the plan announced in the epistle was fulfilled, and that the Apostle sealed his preaching with martyrdom:
| Witness | Date and place | What he attests |
|---|---|---|
| Clement of Rome | c. 96, Rome | Cites Paul, tells of his race "to the farthest limits of the West" and his martyrdom under the prefects[70] |
| Ignatius of Antioch | c. 107, on the way to Rome | "I do not command you as Peter and Paul": the two apostles already hold authority together[71] |
| Polycarp of Smyrna | c. 110-140 | Recalls that "the blessed Paul" taught the Philippians and wrote them letters[72] |
| Marcion | c. 140, Rome | His truncated canon retains ten letters of Paul: even the heretic bears witness to the collection already formed[73] |
| Muratorian Fragment | c. 170-200, Rome | Lists the letters to the seven Churches and then the personal ones: the corpus of thirteen is in place[74] |
| Irenaeus of Lyons | c. 180 | Cites Romans, Corinthians and Galatians abundantly as apostolic Scriptures[75] |
| Tertullian | c. 200, Carthage | The apostolic Churches "read" the letters of Paul alongside the Gospels[76] |
| Eusebius of Caesarea | c. 325 | Places the fourteen (with Hebrews) among the recognised writings and recounts the martyrdom under Nero[77] |
From the end of the first century, then, the letters circulate, are cited as authority and read in the assemblies. The second epistle of Peter, itself Scripture, already presupposes a collection "of all the letters" of Paul which the ignorant "twist" as they do "the other Scriptures": by 60-65 at the latest according to the traditional dating, the Pauline corpus is treated on a par with the Bible[78]. The Muratorian Fragment confirms this in its own way: it notes that the letters of Paul "declare themselves whence and for what cause they were sent", proof that in Rome, around 170, they were already being read as an ordered collection, the seven Churches first, then the personal ones[79].
The Chester Beatty papyrus and the great codices
Papyrology confirms this antiquity. The Chester Beatty Papyrus II (P46), copied around the year 200, preserves on eighty-six leaves a collection that already laid out Romans, Hebrews, Corinthians, Ephesians, Galatians, Philippians, Colossians and 1 Thessalonians: the Pauline collection was circulating in codex form a century and a half after the Apostle's death, in an order very close to that of our Bibles[80]. In the fourth century, the great codices Vaticanus and Sinaiticus give the corpus its definitive form, with the lists of Rome (382) and Carthage (397) fixing the canon received by the Catholic Church[81]. No apocryphal letter attributed to Paul (Third Corinthians, the Epistle to the Laodiceans, the correspondence with Seneca, the Acts of Paul) ever passed this discernment: the Church knew how to say no to the false Pauline writings, which makes her yes to the thirteen all the more carefully weighed[82].
The Great Letters: Plan and Theology
Thessalonians: Keeping Watch in Expectation
The earliest preserved Christian writings, the two letters to the Thessalonians address a young, persecuted Church, anxious about the fate of the dead before the Lord's return. Paul unfolds in three movements: thanksgiving for a faith that has become a model throughout Macedonia, defense of his selfless ministry, then instruction on the parousia: the dead will rise first, the living will be caught up with them, so "Comfort one another, therefore" rather than setting dates[83]. The second corrects those who declared the Day already come, sometimes under cover of a forged letter from Paul: work with your hands while waiting, and recognize his authentic signature[84].
"At the signal given by the voice of the archangel, and by the divine trumpet, the Lord himself will descend from heaven, and those who have died in Christ will rise first."
- Saint Paul, First Letter to the Thessalonians 4, 16[85]
Galatians: Freedom Against the Judaizers
The most vehement tone in the corpus: Judaizing missionaries want to impose circumcision on the pagan converts of Galatia, and Paul sees in this the ruin of the Gospel. Three movements: defense of his apostleship received directly from Christ (neither from Peter nor from Jerusalem), scriptural demonstration (Abraham justified by faith before the Law, the Law a mere pedagogue leading to Christ), then life in the Spirit: freedom, charity, fruit of the Spirit against works of the flesh[86][87].
"It is so that we may be free that Christ has set us free. So stand firm, and do not put yourselves again under the yoke of slavery."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Galatians 5, 1[88]
Corinthians: The Church Torn Apart and Lifted Up
Corinth, a cosmopolitan and pagan port, gives Paul his most concrete correspondence. The first letter deals in order with the factions ("I, I belong to Paul; I to Apollos"), a case of tolerated incest, lawsuits between brothers, marriage and celibacy, meat sacrificed to idols, the conduct of assemblies, charisms, then the summit: the hymn to charity and the great demonstration of the resurrection of the dead, without which "our faith is in vain"[89][90]. Along the way, Paul passes on what he himself "received" concerning the Supper, with the words of institution: the oldest eucharistic account in the New Testament, prior to the written Gospels[91]. The second letter, written in hardship, defends his attacked ministry: outcries, false accusations, a "thorn in the flesh" given him lest he become proud, and the final paradox in which the strength of Christ breaks forth in the weakness of the apostle[92].
"Love is patient; love serves; love is not jealous; it does not boast, it is not puffed up with pride."
- Saint Paul, First Letter to the Corinthians 13, 4[93]
"And if Christ has not been raised, our proclamation is without content, your faith also is without content."
- Saint Paul, First Letter to the Corinthians 15, 14[94]
Romans: The Charter of the Gospel
Written in Corinth around the year 57 to a Church he did not found and wishes to visit on his way to Spain, the Epistle to the Romans is the systematic presentation of the Gospel: Paul shows himself in full, with no local controversy to put out[95]. A plan in four movements: all are guilty, Jews and pagans alike, no one is justified by the Law; free justification through faith in Christ, like Abraham before circumcision; the baptized person's new life, freed from sin and led by the Spirit; then the mystery of Israel: partial hardening until the entrance of the nations, for "all Israel will be saved" and the gifts of God are without repentance[96][97]. The letter closes with concrete exhortation and greetings in which an entire network of domestic Churches files past.
"All men have sinned, they are deprived of the glory of God, and he, freely, makes them righteous by his grace, by virtue of the redemption accomplished in Christ Jesus."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Romans 3, 23-24[98]
"I have the certainty: neither death nor life, nor angels nor heavenly Principalities, nor the present nor the future, nor the Powers, nor heights nor depths, nor any other creature, nothing will be able to separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Romans 8, 38-39[99]
The Captivity Letters: Christ at the Center
From his first Roman captivity (around 60-62), Paul writes four letters in which Christ occupies all the light. To the Philippians, his most beloved community, he confides his joy even in chains and quotes the hymn of Christ who "emptied himself" even to death on a cross, before God exalted him: the christological summit of the corpus[100]. To Philemon, he sends back the runaway slave Onesimus no longer as a slave but as a "beloved brother," without abolishing the law by decree, by converting hearts: the Gospel method of social transformation[101]. To the Colossians, he proclaims the cosmic primacy of Christ, "image of the invisible God, firstborn of all creation," against the syncretisms that drag the Lord down to the level of the powers[102]. To the Ephesians, he unfolds the plan to gather "all things under one head, the Christ," and the Church his Body, built on the foundation of the apostles[103].
"Christ Jesus, having the condition of God, did not jealously hold the rank that made him equal to God. But he emptied himself, taking the condition of a servant, becoming like men."
- Saint Paul, Epistle to the Philippians 2, 6-7[104]
The Pastorals: Handing On to Timothy and Titus
Last in the corpus, the letters to Timothy and Titus organize the handing on: Paul, who knows his departure is near, entrusts to his spiritual sons the "deposit" intact. First to Timothy and the letter to Titus: choose bishops and deacons, establish presbyters "from city to city," keep sound doctrine against myths, pray for all men[105][106]. The second to Timothy is his testament: abandoned by nearly all in his Roman prison, he rereads his life as a libation already poured out and bequeaths the crown promised "to all those who have longed with love for his glorious appearing"[107].
"I am already being offered in sacrifice; the moment of my departure has come. I have waged the good fight, I have finished my race, I have kept the faith."
- Saint Paul, Second Letter to Timothy 4, 6-7[108]
Paul's theology in summary
Five pillars support the entire edifice, and each one runs through all the letters:
| Pillar | Content | Major passages |
|---|---|---|
| The primacy of Christ | Dead and risen, image of the invisible God, Lord before whom every knee bows | Ph 2, Col 1, 1 Cor 15[109][110] |
| Free justification | The sinner declared righteous by faith, without the works of the Law, following the example of Abraham | Gal 2-3, Rom 3-5[111][112] |
| The Body of Christ | Baptized members incorporated, diverse charisms, charity as the bond: the Church is Christ in his fullness | 1 Cor 12-13, Rom 12, Eph 4[113][114] |
| Israel and the nations | Israel's partial hardening for the salvation of the Gentiles, then "all Israel will be saved" | Rom 9-11[115] |
| Watchful waiting | Certain Parousia, unknown date: stay awake, work, console, pray without ceasing | 1-2 Thess, 1 Cor 7 and 15[116][117] |
Augustine drew from it his doctrine of grace against Pelagius, Chrysostom his finest panegyrics, Thomas Aquinas his Pauline commentaries, Luther himself his starting point before the break: no sacred author has been commented on as much, and the Council of Trent drew up its decree on justification from Paul, rejecting both salvation without grace and faith without works[118][119][120].
Chrysostom alone preached the entire Pauline corpus from the pulpit, homily by homily, and his commentaries on Romans remain the model of patristic reading: Paul explained by the man whom the Church surnamed "Golden-Mouthed," in the very language in which the Apostle had written.
The fulfilment of the Scriptures according to Paul
Paul, a Pharisee turned apostle, reads the Scriptures of Israel as a promise of which Christ is the fulfilment, and he lays out the proof of it to Jews and Gentiles alike. Four demonstrations recur constantly: Abraham, justified by faith before circumcision and before the Law, becomes the father of all believers, the uncircumcised included[121] ; Adam, through whom sin entered, finds his counterpart in Christ, the "last Adam" and "life-giving Spirit," through whom grace abounds[122] ; the Passover, with the immolated lamb, is fulfilled in the immolated Christ, whose Christians eat the unleavened bread of purity[123] ; the Law, holy and good, remains a provisional guardian that confined all under sin in order to lead to Christ, not a definitive régime of salvation[124]. This is the whole Christian reading of the Old Testament, received by the Church and confirmed by the Second Vatican Council, which sees in the New the hidden light of the Old[125].
The liturgical use of the Pauline heritage
The Church does not merely comment on Paul: she prays him. Every Sunday, the second reading at Mass is almost always taken from his letters, and the weekday lectionary draws on them abundantly: no author feeds the table of the Word as much after the Gospels[126]. Two feasts mark the year: 25 January, the Conversion of Saint Paul, which celebrates Damascus as the model of every turning of grace; 29 June, Peter and Paul together, the two pillars of Rome, with an octave and a first-class solemnity[127]. Paul is the patron of theologians, missionaries, and the Catholic press, and his name opens the great jubilee year that Benedict XVI dedicated to him in 2008-2009 for the bimillennium of his birth[128]. His tomb, beneath the high altar of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, remains one of the major Roman pilgrimages, together with the commemoration of his martyrdom under Nero, dealt with in the article on the persecutions of Nero.
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
Part of contemporary exegesis proposes retaining as certainly authentic only seven letters (Romans, 1 and 2 Corinthians, Galatians, Philippians, 1 Thessalonians, Philemon) and attributing the other six to disciples: Ephesians, Colossians, 2 Thessalonians and above all the Pastoral Letters. This hypothesis, born with the Tübingen school in the nineteenth century, deserves a fair examination, then a reply.
Objection 1: The vocabulary of the Pastorals, too different to be Paul's
The Pastorals, it is said, employ partly unprecedented vocabulary (handbooks count around 175 words absent from the rest of the corpus) and a calmer, more ecclesial, less impetuous style. Reply: a man writes differently at sixty, in prison, to spiritual sons entrusted with Churches, than at thirty-five to communities in crisis; above all, Paul dictated through secretaries (Tertius named in Rm 16:22) and co-signed with Silvanus or Timothy, which explains the variations of hand without a change of author[129][130]. Stylometry measures divergences; it does not prove a different hand.
Objection 2: The Church of the Pastorals presupposes the second century
Organised overseers, presbyters and deacons, "sound doctrine" against myths: one reads there the second-century Church, not Paul's. Reply: Acts already shows Paul establishing presbyters "in every Church" from the first journey, and the Letter to the Philippians greets "overseers and deacons" around 60: the structure exists in his lifetime[131][132]. The objection dates the institutions by assumption, then declares Paul too early: circular reasoning.
Objection 3: 2 Thessalonians contradicts itself
It announces the Day as imminent and then distant, and denounces a false letter: proof, it is claimed, of a forger giving himself away. Reply: the text distinguishes the Day of the Lord, not yet come and preceded by signs, from a local false alarm declaring that it would be "already here": no contradiction, but a pastoral clarification, sealed by the autograph greeting claimed[133].
Objection 4: Ephesians and Colossians, too contemplative for the Paul of urgency
Their cosmic Christology and their serene ecclesiology would smack of the school, not the Apostle. Reply: a Roman prisoner meditates differently from a harassed missionary, and Colossians answers a specific local syncretism, not a second-century gnosticism of which it shows no characteristic feature[134]. Above all, Philemon, admitted as authentic by all, travels with Colossians and names the same companions: separating the two requires artificially cutting a single mailing[135].
Objection 5: Acts would idealise Paul, contradicted by his letters
The Paul of Acts, a conciliatory good citizen, is set against the Paul of the letters, a trenchant polemicist. Reply: the two sources converge on the essentials (Damascus, Barnabas, Jerusalem, journeys, arrest, Rome) and on the details (companions, collections, citizenship), with normal divergences of perspective between a historian and a correspondent[136][137]. Above all, Acts also reports the harsh sides (stonings, quarrels, prisons): the supposed idealisation is not to be read in the text.
Methodological limits to keep in mind
Beyond the point-by-point replies, five weaknesses recur in these reconstructions: they treat the Tradition (Clement, Muratorian Canon, Irenaeus) as suspect in principle while accepting without proof the hypothesis of a posthumous school; they date ecclesiastical institutions by models, then exclude Paul from what they have aged; they confuse literary possibility (a disciple could have written in the master's name) with historical proof; they use the argument from silence (Acts silent on Paul's death, therefore the martyrdom is legend) against converging positive testimonies (Clement, Eusebius, Tacitus, the tomb on the Ostian Way)[138][139][140]; they sometimes presuppose that dated prophecy and narrated miracle are impossible, which is no longer history but philosophy. The Church, for her part, leaves exegetes to debate freely on unsettled questions, but her liturgical and canonical reading continues to receive the thirteen letters as the Apostle's inheritance: the reasonable presumption remains authenticity, and it is for the contrary hypothesis to prove itself, not the other way round[141].
To go further
- The life, spirituality and cult: Saint Paul.
- The companion from the very first hour: Barnabas ; the spiritual sons: Timothy, Titus ; the first martyr: Stephen.
- The twin figure: Saint Peter the Apostle ; the council: Council of Jerusalem.
- The tomb and the martyrdom: Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, Nero's persecutions.
- The other figures of the New Testament: the Virgin Mary, Saint John the Baptist, Saint Joseph.
Notes and References
Acts 9:1-19, trans. AELF: the road to Damascus, Ananias, the baptism, "chosen instrument" (9:15).
1 17 18 42Phil 3:4-8, trans. AELF: Benjamin, Pharisee, citizen; Acts 22:28 for citizenship by birth.
2 9 13 41Rom 3:21-28, trans. AELF: justification by faith.
3 56 96 98 1121 Cor 12:31 - 13:13, trans. AELF: the hymn to charity.
4 54 89 93 113Gal 2:20, trans. AELF.
52 Pet 3:15-16, trans. AELF: "all the letters" of Paul and "the other Scriptures".
6 78Saint Jerome, On Illustrious Men (De viris illustribus), ch. V, 392: "nine letters to seven Churches", plus two to Timothy, one to Titus, one to Philemon, making thirteen epistles of Paul; Hebrews treated separately.
7 64Acts 28:16-31, trans. AELF: two years in Rome, preaching "unhindered".
8 38 48Acts 16:1-3 and 16:37-38, trans. AELF: Timothy circumcised, citizenship invoked at Philippi.
10Acts 25:10-12, trans. AELF: "I appeal to Caesar."
11 37Acts 22:3 and 22:25-29, trans. AELF: brought up at the feet of Gamaliel, a Roman citizen by birth.
12Acts 7:58 - 8:3, trans. AELF: Stephen stoned, Saul keeping the garments, the Church ravaged.
141 Tim 1:15, trans. AELF: "Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am, I, the foremost."
151 Cor 15:3-11 and 15:14, trans. AELF: the kerygma received, the apparitions of the Risen One, Paul "the untimely born".
16 19 90 941 Cor 9:1-5, trans. AELF: "Have I not seen Jesus our Lord?" and the rights of the apostles.
20Gal 1:11-24, trans. AELF: the Gospel received by revelation, Arabia, the fifteen days with Peter.
21 43 86Acts 13:1 - 14:28, trans. AELF: first journey, presbyters appointed in every Church (14:23).
22 24 28 44 131Acts 11:25-26, trans. AELF: Barnabas seeks Saul at Tarsus, a year at Antioch, the name of Christians.
232 Tim 4:6-8 and 4:11, trans. AELF: the libation poured out, the good fight, Mark to be brought along.
25 49 63 107 108Gal 2:1-10, trans. AELF: the journey up to Jerusalem, the right hand of fellowship, the sharing of missions.
26 45 136Gal 2:11-14, trans. AELF: the resistance to Peter to his face, at Antioch.
27Acts 17:1-34, trans. AELF: Thessalonica, Berea, the Areopagus discourse.
29Acts 18:1-18, trans. AELF: Corinth eighteen months, Gallio the proconsul, Aquila and Priscilla.
30 33 46Acts 19:1 - 20:38, trans. AELF: Ephesus two years, the school of Tyrannus, Demetrius' riot, the farewell at Miletus.
31 34 47Letter of the Emperor Claudius to the Delphians, inscribed at Delphi: Gallio, "my friend and proconsul of Achaia", at the time of the 26th imperial acclamation, that is 51-52; cf. Acts 18:12-17.
32Acts 21:27-36, trans. AELF: the arrest in the Temple.
35Acts 22:25-29, trans. AELF: Roman citizenship spares him the flogging.
36Rom 15:19-28, trans. AELF: from Jerusalem to Illyricum, the plan for Spain.
39 95Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians, 5, 4-7, c. 96, trans. Sources Chrétiennes no. 167: Paul herald in the East and in the West, "reached the farthest point of the West", martyred under the prefects.
40 69 70 138Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, II, 22 and II, 25, c. 325, trans. Sources Chrétiennes: the Roman sojourn, Nero's persecution, Peter and Paul crowned with martyrdom.
50 77 1391 Thess 4:13-18 and 4:16, trans. AELF: the instruction on the parousia.
51 83 85 1162 Thess 2:1-12; 3:6-12 and 3:17, trans. AELF: the Day not yet come, work, the greeting in his own hand.
52 67 84 117 133Gal 3:6-29; 5:1-25, trans. AELF: Abraham, the Law as pedagogue, freedom, the fruit of the Spirit.
53 87 88 111 121 1242 Cor 4:7-12; 12:7-10, trans. AELF: the treasure in earthen vessels, the thorn in the flesh.
55 92Phil 2:5-11, trans. AELF: the hymn of Christ humbled and exalted.
57 100 104 109Phlm 10-17, trans. AELF: Onesimus, "beloved brother".
58 101 135Col 1:15-20, trans. AELF: the hymn of Christ's primacy.
59 102 110 134Eph 1:3-14; 2:8-10; 2:19-22, trans. AELF: blessing, grace, the foundation of the apostles.
60 103 1141 Tim 1:12-16; 3:1-13, trans. AELF: Paul "chief of sinners", bishops and deacons.
61 105Titus 1:5-9; 3:12, trans. AELF: presbyters from town to town, the meeting at Nicopolis.
62 1061 Thess 1:1, trans. AELF: Paul, Silvanus and Timothy as co-senders.
65 130Rom 16:1-2 and 16:22-23, trans. AELF: Phoebe the bearer, Tertius the secretary, Gaius the host.
66 68 129Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Romans, 4, 3, c. 107, trans. Sources Chrétiennes no. 10: "I do not command you as Peter and Paul".
71Saint Polycarp of Smyrna, Letter to the Philippians, 3, 2 and 9, 1, c. 110-140, trans. Sources Chrétiennes no. 10: "the blessed Paul" taught and wrote.
72Marcion, canon c. 140: ten Pauline letters and an expurgated Luke; witness to the collection already formed, even among the heretic.
73Muratorian Fragment, Roman list c. 170-200 (8th-century Latin manuscript, Ambrosian Library): Paul's letters to the seven Churches and then to individuals, which "declare themselves whence and for what cause they were sent".
74 79Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, III, c. 180, trans. Sources Chrétiennes: quotations from Romans, Corinthians, Galatians as Scriptures.
75Tertullian, On the Prescription of Heretics, 36, c. 200: the apostolic sees where "one reads" the letters of the apostles.
76Chester Beatty Papyrus II (P46), copied c. 200: eighty-six surviving leaves of a codex containing Romans, Hebrews, Corinthians, Ephesians, Galatians, Philippians, Colossians and 1 Thessalonians.
80Lists of Rome (382, under Damasus) and of Carthage (397): the Catholic canon of the New Testament, 27 books.
81Acts of Paul, 3 Corinthians, Laodiceans, Paul-Seneca correspondence: none was retained by the lists of Rome (382) or Carthage (397).
821 Cor 11:23-25, trans. AELF: "I myself received what comes from the Lord": the words of the eucharistic institution.
91Rom 9:1 - 11:36, trans. AELF: Israel, the jealousy of the nations, "all Israel will be saved" (11:26).
97 115Rom 8:31-39, trans. AELF: the hymn of inseparable love.
99Saint Augustine, On the Spirit and the Letter (De spiritu et littera), 412: commentary on Romans 7, 8 on grace against Pelagius.
118Saint John Chrysostom, 7 Panegyrics on Saint Paul (De laudibus sancti Pauli), late 4th century.
119Council of Trent, decree on justification (De iustificatione), session VI, 13 January 1547.
120Rom 5:12-21, trans. AELF: Adam and Christ.
1221 Cor 5:7-8, trans. AELF: "Our paschal lamb has been sacrificed: it is Christ."
123Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 18 November 1965: no. 11 on inerrancy, no. 14-16 on the Old Testament fulfilled in the New.
125 141Roman Lectionary: the Sunday second reading in Ordinary Time follows the Pauline letters in semi-continuous reading.
126General Roman Calendar: the Conversion of Saint Paul on 25 January, Saints Peter and Paul on 29 June, solemnity.
127Benedict XVI, Pauline Year, 29 June 2008 to 29 June 2009, for the bimillennium of the Apostle's birth: cycle of Wednesday catecheses on Paul in 2008-2009.
128Phil 1:1, trans. AELF: the greeting "to the bishops and deacons".
132Acts 15:1-35, trans. AELF: the assembly of Jerusalem.
137Tacitus, Annals, XV, 44: the fire of Rome (64) and the punishment of the Christians under Nero.
140