Zacchaeus (1st century)

Zacchaeus, the chief tax collector of Jericho who climbed a sycamore tree to see Jesus: the encounter of Luke 19, the promise to repay fourfold, salvation entering his house, and what the Church knows of him, from Caesarea to Rocamadour.

Ignispedia

Zacchaeus is the chief tax collector of Jericho who climbed a sycamore tree to see Jesus: a wealthy and despised man, small in stature, whom the crowd keeps from approaching and whom the Lord calls by name, then invites himself to his house without being invited. Ten verses, in the Gospel of Luke alone, tell the liveliest scene of the whole ascent to Jerusalem: a notable who runs, a tree climbed, an immediate joy, a scandalised murmur, a promise that costs half a fortune, and the word that seals everything, that salvation has entered this house, for the Son of man came to seek and save what was lost.

His very name sounds like an irony of history: in Aramaic, it means pure and righteous, and it designates the patron of the toll collectors of a customs town[1]. The Church holds him to be a person who lived, honoured as the first bishop of Caesarea in Palestine, commemorated on 20 April by the Eastern Churches, commented on by Clement of Alexandria, Ambrose, Cyril, Jerome, Bede and the popes, painted by Tissot, and proclaimed every year on the thirty-first Sunday in Ordinary Time.

This article presents him as a figure of the Bible received by the Church: his place in the Lucan canon, the traditional authorship and dating of the gospel that tells his story, the city, the trade and the tree that frame him, the encounter verse by verse, his theology of restitution, his memory in ancient tradition, his presence in the liturgy, and then, at the end of the journey, the debate with modern exegesis. The detailed dossier on the third gospel is found in The Gospel according to Saint Luke, the life of its author in Saint Luke the Evangelist: we do not repeat them here, we refer to them.

Zacchaeus in the canon of Scripture

A story found only in Luke

Zacchaeus appears neither in Matthew, nor in Mark, nor in John, nor in Acts, nor in the epistles: the ten verses of his encounter belong to the Gospel according to Saint Luke alone, and to it alone[2]. This is not an anomaly: Luke keeps to himself a whole treasury of stories the others did not retain, the good Samaritan, the prodigal son, the lost drachma, the Pharisee and the tax collector in the Temple, and it is in this vein, that of the lost found and the rich called, that Zacchaeus takes his place. The table below breaks the scene down into six moments, to settle the dossier before any commentary.

MomentVersetsWhat the account provides
The man and the cityLk 19:1-2Jesus passes through Jericho, Zacchaeus, chief tax collector, wealthy
The desire and the obstacleLk 19:3-4He wants to see Jesus, the crowd and his small stature prevent him, he climbs a sycamore tree
The call by nameLk 19:5-6Jesus looks up, calls him, invites himself to his house, Zacchaeus comes down quickly and receives him with joy
The murmurLk 19:7All grumble: he is lodging with a sinner
The promiseLk 19:8Half to the poor, fourfold in restitution
The sentenceLk 19:9-10Salvation in this house, son of Abraham, to seek and save what was lost

None of the six moments works on its own: the desire gives the tree, the tree gives the call, the call gives the joy, the joy gives the promise, and the promise receives the sentence. It is the whole, received as a whole, that makes Zacchaeus the convert of the final ascent, a few days from the Passion, on the road leading from Jericho to Jerusalem.

The gospel that tells his story: received authorship and dating

The Church receives the third gospel as the work of Saint Luke, the physician of Antioch, companion of Saint Paul, writing after having followed everything carefully from the beginnings, as he himself says in his prologue. The earliest witness is Saint Irenaeus, around 180: Luke, the companion of Paul, set down in a book the Gospel preached by him[3].

"Luke, the companion of Paul, set down in a book the Gospel preached by him."

Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1[4]

The ancient transmitters succeed one another without break: the Muratorian Fragment, around the end of the second century, presents Luke as the third evangelist, physician and companion of Paul, who wrote according to what he had heard without having seen the Lord himself in the flesh[5] ; Tertullian, defending this gospel against Marcion who wished to annex it, recalls that it is the work of Paul's disciple[6] ; Eusebius sums up the tradition, Luke, an Antiochian by birth, a physician by profession, a companion of Paul[7]. The Bodmer Papyrus XIV-XV, known as P75, copied around 175-225 and kept at Cologny, already contains Luke and John together: the text was circulating, carefully copied, less than a century and a half after the events[8].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The traditional dating, the years 62-63, at the end of Paul's captivity in Rome, therefore remains defensible without any acrobatics: it fits with the end of Acts, which stops on Paul preaching freely in Rome without recounting either his death or the ruin of Jerusalem, and with the life of the Apostle's companion. The real modern debate concerns this date, not the events related, and it is dealt with at the end of the article. For the complete dossier on the book, see The Gospel according to Saint Luke.

Jericho, the tax collectors, and the sycamore

The city of palm trees, balsam, and customs

Jericho is called in Scripture the city of palm trees, the oasis of the Jordan where Moses gazed upon the Promised Land[9]. Flavius Josephus describes its plain planted with palm and balsam trees, the most precious fragrance of the East, and excavations at Herodian Jericho, southwest of the old tell, have uncovered the winter palaces, pools, and gardens that made it a royal residence[10][11]. The city lies on the road that climbs from the Jordan to Jerusalem, a day's walk from the Temple: every traveller going up for Passover passes through it, every trade entering Judea pays there, and it is to guard this toll that collectors are posted there.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The post was worth its weight in gold. Jericho concentrated the balsam, the dates, the caravans coming from the east by the Jordan ford, and the pilgrims going up to Jerusalem[12]. A chief collector installed there held one of the most profitable offices in Judea, on the model of the tax farmers who levied the tax for Rome while enriching themselves along the way. When Luke writes that Zacchaeus is rich, he is not doing psychology: he is describing a post.

Chief of tax collectors: a title, a name, a reputation

The Greek word is a hapax of the New Testament: architelônès, chief of tax collectors, is read nowhere else in Scripture[13]. Zacchaeus is no mere clerk behind a counter: he runs the office, farms out the taxes, employs subordinates, and his fortune comes from the margin he took on every collection. Benedict XVI summed up the case in a single sentence, during the Angelus devoted to this scene: the tax collectors collected the taxes owed to the Roman emperor, and they often took advantage of their position to extort money, which is why Zacchaeus was very rich, but despised by his fellow citizens[14].

His very name doubles the contrast: Zacchaeus renders the Aramaic zakkay, which means pure, innocent, just[15]. The pure one is called the corrupt one, the just one runs the toll, and the irony of the name prepares the reversal of the narrative, for the man will end up honouring what his name announced. His contemporaries, for their part, saw only the trade: collaborator with the occupier, extorter of the poor, public sinner, excluded from honours and trust. It is to this man that Jesus is going to ask hospitality.

Small of stature on a sycamore

Sycamore of Jericho associated with Zacchaeus by local tradition. Photo Bonio, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; this identification is not historical proof.

Luke notes the physical detail with a witness's precision: he was small of stature, literally small in stature, and the crowd prevented him from seeing[16]. A few commentators have suggested reading a young age rather than a small size, but what follows settles the matter in favour of the obvious meaning: it is because he is small that he must climb, and the whole sacred comedy of the scene — a notable who runs and climbs up a tree — depends on this body that does not fit through.

« He sought to see who Jesus was, but he could not because of the crowd, for he was small of stature. So he ran ahead and climbed up into a sycamore tree to see Jesus who was going to pass that way. »

Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19:3–4[17]

The sycamore, the sycamore fig with its low and widely spreading branches, is the tree of the poor: its fruit feeds the humble, and the prophet Amos kept the herds and trimmed the sycamores before God sent him[18]. To climb up there, for a head of office in a rich cloak, is to accept ridicule before the whole city: to run ahead, to hoist oneself into the branches, to put oneself in full view above the crowd that despises him. The desire to see has overcome the dignity of rank, and it is this bare desire, without calculation, that Jesus will reward beyond all asking.

The encounter, verse by verse

Zacchaeus, come down quickly: the invitation without an invitation

Jesus arrives at the tree, lifts up his eyes, and calls the man by name. No one has introduced them, Zacchaeus has asked for nothing, and the Lord's first word is a hurried order coupled with a necessity: come down quickly, for today I must stay at your house[19]. The Greek verb expresses haste, speusas, and the it is necessary, dei, expresses the divine mission — the same it is necessary that runs through all of Luke when God acts: it was necessary for him to be in his Father's house, it is necessary that he proclaim the Kingdom, it is necessary that the Son of man suffer[20]. This is not a passing courtesy: it is Heaven making an appointment at a tax collector's house.

« On arriving at that place, Jesus lifted up his eyes and said to him: Zacchaeus, come down quickly, for today I must stay at your house. Quickly he came down and received Jesus with joy. »

Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19:5–6[21]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Two gazes cross, and the first is that of Jesus: he lifts up his eyes to the branch, he knows the name of the man perched there, he invites himself without waiting to be invited. Saint Ambrose noted the lesson: without being invited, he invites himself into the house, for he already knew with what riches he would reward the hospitality, and although he had not yet heard the word of invitation, he had already seen the will[22]. Titus of Bostra adds that Zacchaeus asked only to see, and that He who can do beyond what is asked granted him far more than he expected[23]. Zacchaeus comes down quickly, and receives with joy: obedience is immediate, joy is the first fruit.

The joy and the murmuring

The joy of the host causes scandal. Everyone grumbled, says Luke, with the verb of the murmurs of the desert: diegongyzon, the same one that grumbled against Moses over the manna, against Jesus who ate with tax collectors, against the father who welcomes the prodigal son[24]. The crowd that barred the way to the small man now bars salvation from the sinner: he has gone to lodge at the house of a man who is a sinner, and the sentence lands like a verdict[25]. The reproach is aimed at Jesus as much as at Zacchaeus: a master who respects himself does not sit at table with dirty money.

Pseudo-Chrysostom, gathered by the Golden Chain, answered in advance: the innocent frequents the guilty, the fountain of justice touches cupidity, and just as the physician does not heal without dirtying his hands, the Lord endures the infection to bring the remedy[26]. Those who bite with their reproaches, he adds, cast discredit on the work instead of seeing that the tax collector was converted and led a better life. The murmuring proves one thing: no one expected anything good from this house, and it is into this condemned house that salvation is going to enter.

The promise: half to the poor, fourfold in restitution

Standing, Zacchaeus addresses the Lord. The verb conveys solemnity: he stands up, he speaks in public, before the grumblers, and his sentence consists of two commitments that empty his fortune[27].

« Behold, Lord: I give half of my goods to the poor, and if I have wronged anyone, I will restore fourfold. »

Zacchaeus to the Lord, Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19:8[28]

The tenses are present: I give, I restore. Theophylact of Ohrid sees in this the mark of the deed, not the plan: he does not say I will give, he says I give, and if one does the reckoning, after the half given to the poor, the fourfold restored to the wronged from the remainder leaves almost nothing more of his own goods[29]. Pseudo-Chrysostom admires the learning without schooling: without having been taught, he obeys, and as the sun lights a house by its work and not by its word, the Saviour has put to flight the darkness of sin by the rays of his justice[30]. Above all, Zacchaeus does not await the judgement of the Law: he makes himself his own judge, and anticipates the sentence by restitution.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

For the fourfold is not a rhetorical figure: it is the reparation prescribed by the Law. Whoever steals an ox shall restore five oxen, whoever steals a sheep shall restore four, says Exodus, and Nathan imposes upon David, for the poor man's sheep, that he restore it fourfold[31][32]. The table below shows that Zacchaeus applies the justice of Moses to the letter, then goes beyond it through almsgiving.

TextCaseReparation
Ex 22:1Theft of an ox or a sheepFive oxen for an ox, four sheep for a sheep
2 Sam 12:6Nathan judges David for the poor man's sheepRestore the sheep fourfold
Lk 19:8Zacchaeus, of his own accord, before witnessesRestore fourfold for any wrong done, and give half to the poor

Son of Abraham

Jesus answers with a verdict that turns the grumbling upside down: today, salvation has come to this house, for he too is a son of Abraham[33]. He too: the "too" is aimed at the complainers who had excluded him from the descent. Bede reads the title as an adoption by imitation: Zacchaeus is called a son of Abraham not because he was born of his race, but because he imitates his faith, and just as Abraham left his country and his father's house, he gave up all his goods by distributing them to the poor[34]. Theophylacte specifies the tense: it does not say that he was a son of Abraham, but that he is one now, for previously, a chief of tax collectors with no likeness to the righteous Abraham, he was not[35].

The word house overflows the one man: salvation enters under a roof, for servants, children, guests, as once the ark kept an entire family or Passover covered a whole household[36]. The one the crowd called the sinner receives the oldest title of Israel, and the crowd learns that descent from Abraham is not proved by despising the lost, but by the faith that gives.

To seek and to save what was lost

The last saying is the programme of the whole gospel: the Son of man came to seek and to save what was lost[37]. The verb "seek" recalls the lost sheep that Ezekiel promised to bring back: what is lost, I will seek it out, said the Lord through the prophet, and Luke fulfils the oracle in the streets of Jericho[38]. The whole third part of Luke converges here: the sheep, the coin, the son, and then the tax collector — four lost ones, four found, and the last one found pays with his fortune.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"Then Jesus said concerning him: Today, salvation has come to this house, for he too is a son of Abraham. For the Son of man came to seek and to save what was lost."

Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19:9-10[39]

Cyril of Alexandria saw in the crowd the image of the ignorant tumult that cannot see the summit of wisdom: as long as Zacchaeus remained in the press, he did not see Christ, and it was by rising above common ignorance that he was judged worthy of receiving the One he desired to behold[40]. To climb the tree was already to leave the crowd; to come down quickly was to enter into salvation.

Conversion and reparation: the theology of Zacchaeus

Restitution, condition of forgiveness

Zacchaeus is not content to regret: he makes restitution. This is the whole Catholic doctrine of reparation, and the Church has stated it in the clearest terms: in justice, the reparation of an injustice committed requires the return of the stolen good to its owner, and the Catechism recalls that the seventh commandment obliges this restitution[41]. Saint Thomas makes of it an entire treatise, and takes up the sentence of Saint Augustine to Macedonius: sin is not forgiven if the stolen good is not returned when it can be[42].

The scene at Jericho is the Gospel of this doctrine in action. Zacchaeus does not first ask for forgiveness: he begins by paying, and it is after the promise of reparation that Jesus proclaims salvation. The order matters: mercy comes first, it enters uninvited, but it does not dispense one from making restitution, it gives the strength to make restitution. Titus of Bostra noted that the seed of salvation had already germinated in the desire to see, and that no one who sees Jesus can remain in evil[43]. To see, to come down, to make restitution: three verbs for a single conversion.

The rich man saved

Zacchaeus arrives in the narrative right after two scenes that closed every door to the rich: the notable who goes away sad because he had great possessions, and the saying about the camel passing more easily through the eye of a needle than a rich man entering the Kingdom[44]. Then comes the blind man of Jericho who receives his sight by the roadside, and at once Zacchaeus climbing the tree[45]. The sequence is deliberate: after the impossible, the possible; after the rich man who refuses, the rich man who gives; after the blind man healed, the seeing man converted.

Bede applies the very image of the camel here: behold the camel, unburdened of its hump, passing through the eye of a needle — the rich man and tax collector who abandons the love of wealth and takes his dishonest gains in disgust, and receives the blessing of the Lord's company[46]. Saint Ambrose drew from it the golden rule: let the rich learn that fault does not attach to goods themselves, but to those who do not know how to use them, for riches, which are obstacles to virtue in the unworthy, become means of advancing in it among the good[47]. Saint Jerome, quoted by Benedict XVI, settles it in a word: he gave his wealth, and at once replaced it with the wealth of the Kingdom of heaven[48].

"For fools, wealth feeds dishonesty; for the wise, on the contrary, it aids virtue: to the latter it offers an occasion of salvation, to the former an obstacle that destroys them."

Saint Maximus of Turin, Sermons, 95, quoted by Benedict XVI[49]

Today: Luke's word for salvation

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Three times in the gospel, Luke rings the same "today": today a Saviour is born to you, today this Scripture is fulfilled, today salvation has entered this house, and on the cross, today you will be with me in paradise[50]. The word says that salvation is not deferred: it arrives, it enters, it abides, on the very day one receives it. Zacchaeus receives Jesus today, makes restitution today, is saved today, and the good thief, another Lucan convert of the eleventh hour, will hear the same word at the same point of the narrative, when there will be no longer a tree to climb, but a cross to die upon. The two dossiers answer each other and do not repeat one another.

The Christian memory: Caesarea, the Fathers, and the images

First bishop of Caesarea in Palestine

The earliest tradition makes Zacchaeus something other than a convert of a day: a shepherd. The Apostolic Constitutions, a fourth-century collection of ecclesiastical discipline, list the first bishops ordained by the apostles, and for Caesarea in Palestine, the first name is his[51].

"Of Caesarea in Palestine, the first was Zacchaeus, who had been a publican; after him came Cornelius, and third Theophilus."

Apostolic Constitutions, VII, 46[52]

Two clarifications are called for. First, this collection is not by the apostles: a fourth-century compilation, it stands as a witness to the memory of the Churches, not as a record of an ordination[53]. Second, it does not by itself prove that the publican of Jericho governed Caesarea: it proves that the fourth-century Churches believed it, and that they united in one and the same man the convert of Luke and the shepherd of the coast. That is much: so early a memory is not invented about a stranger, and the man who shared his fortune with the poor had the profile of the first shepherds.

Clement of Alexandria: Zacchaeus or Matthew

An even older witness, Clement of Alexandria, around 200, reports a tradition that brings Zacchaeus close to another famous publican: Matthew, the apostle and evangelist, who also passed through the tax office[54].

"It is said that Zacchaeus, or according to some Matthew, the chief of the publicans, hearing that the Lord had deigned to come to his house, said: Lord, if I have taken anything by false accusation, I restore it fourfold."

Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, IV, 6[55]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Clement writes architelōnēs, chief of the publicans, the same rare title that Luke gives to Zacchaeus, and he applies it in the same sentence to both names[56]. Should this be read as some identifying the two men, the collector of Capernaum who became an apostle and the one of Jericho who became a bishop, or merely as the same tradition of restitution circulating about both? The text tilts in favour of the identification: as early as the end of the second century, Zacchaeus belongs to living memory, cited as the example of the rich man saved by choice, not by gifts, since Christ, says Clement, judges a rich man not by his presents but by his decision.

April 20 and August 23

The Eastern Churches celebrate Zacchaeus on April 20, as one of the seventy apostles and bishop of Caesarea, the one whom Jesus made come down from the sycamore[57]. The Copts keep the same date, and the Franciscan survey of the Christians of the Holy Land notes that the Roman Martyrology commemorates him on August 23[58]. The Latin West has not given him a proper Mass in the general calendar: his memory is carried by the Martyrology, read at the office, and by the Eastern Churches, which have never ceased to sing of him. A convert of a day does not obtain two dates in the calendars: for that, an entire Church must have looked upon him as a father.

Amadour of Rocamadour: the legend of the Quercy

A local tradition of the Quercy carries Zacchaeus as far as Gaul: driven from Palestine by persecution with his wife Veronica, she who wiped the face of Christ, he is said to have landed in Aquitaine, evangelized the South-West, and finally lived as a hermit on the rock that became Rocamadour, under the name of Amator, Amadour[59]. In 1166, an intact body was discovered before the chapel of the Virgin, presented as his, and the shrine became one of the great pilgrimages of France.

The degree of authority is here at its lowest: a late legend, without early witness, mixing two figures that Scripture never marries, Zacchaeus the tax collector and Veronica the woman of the Gospel[60]. The article reports it because it exists and because it has moved crowds to prayer, not because it proves anything: Rocamadour illuminates devotion, only the early sources ground history. The reader who climbs to the shrine will know what he venerates there, a pious memory, not a dossier.

The Fathers: Ambrose, Cyril, Bede

No Father doubts the historicity of the man: all comment on the scene as a lived fact, rich in teaching. Saint Ambrose, in his Exposition of Luke, opens the case with hope: the chief of the publicans is introduced with good reason, for who will henceforth despair of himself, when he who lived by fraud attains to grace, and he is rich besides, so that it may be known that not all rich men are miserly[61]. The same Ambrose is astonished at the detail of his stature: what does the evangelist mean in describing his height, and no one else's, unless that he was young in evil, or still weak in faith, since he who could climb was not yet prostrate in sin[62].

James Tissot, Zacchaeus in the Sycamore Tree Awaiting the Passing of Jesus, 1886-1894. Brooklyn Museum, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Saint Cyril notes the promptness: Zacchaeus put off acting not a moment, and was judged worthy of the favour of God, who gives sight to the blind and calls those who are far off[63]. Bede unfolds the mystical sense: Zacchaeus, which is interpreted justified, denotes the believers come from the nations, brought low by the occupations of the world, sanctified by God, eager to see the Saviour enter Jericho to share the faith he brought to the world[64]. Three readings, four centuries, one and the same certainty: Zacchaeus existed, he climbed, he heard, he restored.

In art: Tissot and the sycamore of Jericho

The painters have retained the suspended moment: the man in the tree, his gaze raised. James Tissot, for his Life of Our Lord Jesus Christ, fixed the scene in watercolour, Zacchaeus in the sycamore awaiting the passing of Jesus, a work now in the Brooklyn Museum[65]. Stained glass, altarpieces and illuminations vary the motif throughout Europe, the same contrast every time: the rich man above, the Saint below who raises his eyes. And in Jericho itself, the piety of the place shows a sycamore: facing the Franciscan estate, on the road to the tell, a Greek Orthodox church keeps the tree of tradition, felled since 1967 but replanted from its shoots[66]. The tree passes, the account remains.

Zacchaeus in the prayer of the Church

The Thirty-First Sunday in Ordinary Time

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Every year, on the thirty-first Sunday in Ordinary Time of Year C, the Church proclaims the gospel of Zacchaeus at Mass[67]. It was on this occasion that Benedict XVI commented on the scene in Saint Peter's Square, recalling that Luke shows particular attention to mercy, with episodes that highlight the love of Christ, who came to call not the righteous but sinners[68].

"God excludes no one, neither the poor nor the rich. God does not allow himself to be conditioned by our human prejudices, but sees in each person a soul to be saved, and he is especially drawn to those who are considered lost and who consider themselves as such."

Benedict XVI, Angelus of 31 October 2010[69]

The same pope went on to add the essential point: mercy takes nothing away from the gravity of sin, but always aims to save the sinner and to offer him the chance to start afresh, to convert[70]. Thus the tax collector of Jericho frames the year: heard in the autumn of Ordinary Time, he tells the rich and the despised once again that the gaze of God always falls upon us before our repentance, and that the joy of welcome is worth more than all the grumbling.

The Sunday of Zacchaeus in the Eastern Churches

In the East, Zacchaeus opens Lent: the Sunday that ushers in the Triodion, the liturgical book of the preparatory weeks, is called the Sunday of Zacchaeus, and Luke 19:1-10 is read on it[71]. The meaning is crystal clear: before fasting, one must desire to see, and the little man who runs ahead of the crowd is the image of the sinner who gets ahead of his habits in order to place himself in the Lord's sight. Desire, haste, joy, reparation: all of Lent is contained in ten verses, and the hymns of the day sing the host of Jericho as the patron of beginnings.

What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

The late dating of Luke

A portion of contemporary exegesis proposes dating the third Gospel and the Acts of the Apostles to the years 80-90, that is, a generation after the events, and to see in them the work of a second-generation Christian rather than Paul's companion[72]. Along the same lines, the two-source hypothesis, today the most widespread, makes Luke a compiler who combines the Gospel of Mark and a lost collection of sayings known as Q, together with his own material: the account of Zacchaeus would belong to this special material, shaped by the evangelist[73].

The presentation is fair-minded, and it hits the mark on one point: Luke writes as a historian, he orders, investigates, composes, and his own prologue says as much[74]. But to order is not to invent, and the late dating rests less on evidence than on presuppositions: Luke is dated after 70 because one assumes that a detailed prophecy of the destruction of Jerusalem cannot precede the event, and then the whole edifice is pushed back, Acts included — even though Acts ends before Paul's death. This is the classic circular reasoning: the text is dated by the theory, and then the theory is proved by the date. The early dating, around 62-63, explains the text just as well, without supposing the impossibility of prophecy, and it has on its side the unanimity of the ancient witnesses.

The historicity of the account called into question

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Some go further and read the scene as an edifying story composed by Luke: a chief tax collector who repays fourfold — is that plausible? And did the Jericho of Jesus' day still have a tax office, when the old tell seemed abandoned? The objection from restitution presupposes what it asserts: that a rich man never gives back, and therefore that the rich man who gives back is a fiction. As for Jericho, it confuses two cities: the Old Testament tell, deserted, and the Herodian Jericho, alive, with its palace, its balsam groves, its customs post, a few hundred meters away, which excavations have restored to history[75]. Luke, who places his scene in the town crossed on the road to Jerusalem, is speaking of the second, not the first.

First line of resistance: a vocabulary too precise for a fable

An invented story does not encumber itself with technical terms. Yet Luke uses architelônès, a word found nowhere else, gives the hero an exact Semitic name with its meaning, zakkay the pure, locates the office in the city where an office would have to be, and has him promise a fourfold restitution that is the letter of the Law[76][77]. Edifying fables stay vague; this account teems with verifiable anchors — trade, place, law, botany. One does not dress up a parable in a civil status that the tax collectors of Jericho could have denied, especially when writing a generation after the events.

Second line of resistance: the embarrassment of the hero

If Luke had wanted to illustrate the conversion of the rich with an example, he would have chosen a presentable hero: a generous Pharisee, a repentant shepherd, a moved soldier. He chooses the worst possible candidate, a chief tax collector, a collaborator of Rome, a notorious thief, a ridiculous little man perched in a tree before his whole town. The criterion of embarrassment, which historians apply to accounts that are awkward for their authors, operates here at full strength: one does not invent a boss who brings shame; one endures him because he existed. The lavish promise completes the proof: an edifying fiction would have had him promise alms, not empty his fortune fourfold.

Third line of resistance: the internal coherence of Luke

The scene is no erratic block: it is bound to the whole Lukan fabric by dozens of threads — the "must" of the divine mission, the "today" of salvation, the grumbling of the righteous, the son of Abraham found again, the lost sheep sought. These echoes are not visible seams, but the weave of an author who recounts what he has received in the language of his theology, like any ancient historian who orders without betraying. To remove Zacchaeus from Luke is to tear out a stone that holds up the wall.

Fourth line of resistance: the ancient witnesses never doubted

From Clement to Ambrose to Cyril to Bede, from the banks of the Nile to those of the Bosphorus and from Milan to Northumbria, no ancient witness treats Zacchaeus as a symbol[78]. These readers, who wielded allegory better than anyone and who knew how to tell when a text was a parable, read a man, commented on a conversion, preached a reparation. The fiction hypothesis therefore supposes that the whole early Church was mistaken about a text written in its own language, and that the truth had to wait for the modern universities. That is possible in principle; in practice, it is a heavy presumption to raise without proof.

Why the traditional reading remains defensible

The question of the compiler remains: did Luke arrange things? Yes — and the Church has never denied it, since his prologue claims investigation and order. But to arrange is not to forge, and the third Gospel remains, in the words of unanimous tradition, the work of Paul's companion, received into the canon as early as the second century, copied in the century that followed, and commented on as history by all the Fathers. Benedict XVI recalled, against an exegesis that would dissolve the text into strata, that one never encounters the Jesus of reconstructions, only that of the received Gospels, and that faith is directed to him[79]. Zacchaeus, who climbed his tree and came down in joy, belongs to this received Jesus: to deny him as a man is to impoverish the gospel; to keep him as a witness is to keep the whole gospel.

Going further

Zacchaeus teaches the rich detachment, the despised hope, and everyone that the desire to see is enough to make God look up: one can begin perched in a tree, stammer a ruinous promise, and end up the first bishop of a Church. Whoever believes their house is too dirty for a visit will remember that Jesus invites himself without waiting for an invitation; whoever believes their wrongs are too old to be made right will remember the fourfold paid that very day. The little man of Jericho has become the discreet patron of all beginnings: to want to see is already to be seen.

For further reading: the book's file in The Gospel according to Saint Luke, the life of its author in Saint Luke the Evangelist, the other tax collector called by the Lord in Saint Matthew the Evangelist, the rich disciple who buried the Lord in Joseph of Arimathea, and the other convert of the eleventh hour in the good thief.

Notes and References

  1. Zacchaeus renders the Aramaic zakkay, pure, innocent, just: the name announces what the conversion will accomplish.

    1 15
  2. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 1-10: the passage through Jericho, Zacchaeus, the sycamore, the call, the promise, the sentence. Liturgical translation of the AELF, on aelf.org.

    2 16 17
  3. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, c. 180: Luke, Paul's companion, set down in a book the Gospel preached by him. Sources Chrétiennes 211.

    3 4
  4. Muratorian Fragment, c. 170-200: the third gospel is by Luke, physician and companion of Paul, who wrote according to what he had heard.

    5
  5. Tertullian, Against Marcion, IV, 2, c. 207: defense of the gospel of Luke, the work of Paul's disciple, against the Marcionite annexation.

    6
  6. Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 4: Luke, an Antiochian by birth, a physician by profession, companion of Paul.

    7
  7. Bodmer Papyrus XIV-XV, known as P75, copied c. 175-225, kept at the Bodmer Foundation in Cologny: contains the gospels of Luke and John.

    8
  8. Dt 34, 3: Jericho, the city of palm trees, shown to Moses from Mount Nebo. 2 Chr 28, 15: the same title for the city.

    9
  9. Flavius Josephus, The Jewish War, IV, 8: the plain of Jericho, its palms, its balsam trees, a fragrance found nowhere else.

    10 12
  10. Ehud Netzer, Hasmonean and Herodian Palaces at Jericho, Israel Exploration Society, Jerusalem, 2001: the winter palaces, pools, and gardens of Herodian Jericho, southwest of the ancient tell.

    11 75
  11. Lk 19, 2: architelonēs, chief of the collectors, the only use of the word in the whole New Testament.

    13 76
  12. Benedict XVI, Angelus, Saint Peter's Square, 31 October 2010, 31st Sunday in Ordinary Time Year C: the tax collectors who collected the dues owed to Rome, Zacchaeus very rich but despised, the scandal of the visit, the fourfold promised. Full text on vatican.va.

    14 48 49 68 69 70
  13. Am 7, 14: Amos kept the flocks and tended the sycamores before his sending. The sycamore fig, with its low branches, is the tree of the humble.

    18
  14. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 5-6: Jesus looks up, calls Zacchaeus by name, invites himself for today, Zacchaeus comes down quickly and receives him with joy. Liturgical translation of the AELF, on aelf.org.

    19 21
  15. Lk 2, 49: I must be in my Father's house. Lk 4, 43: I must proclaim the Kingdom. Lk 9, 22: the Son of man must suffer. Lk 24, 26: was it not necessary that the Christ should suffer. The Lucan dei speaks of divine necessity.

    20
  16. Saint Ambrose, Exposition of the Gospel according to Luke, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19. English text: Uninvited he invites Himself to his house, for He knew how richly He would reward his hospitality. And though He had not yet heard the word of invitation, He had already seen the will.

    22
  17. Titus of Bostra, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: Zacchaeus asked only to see, and He who is able to do more than we ask granted him far more than he had hoped. English text: He who is able to do more than we ask for, granted to him far above what he expected.

    23 43
  18. Lk 5, 30: the Pharisees grumble against the disciples who eat with tax collectors and sinners. Lk 15, 2: they grumble because Jesus welcomes sinners. Ex 16: the grumblings of Israel in the desert against Moses.

    24
  19. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 7: all complained, he has gone to stay at the house of a man who is a sinner. Liturgical translation of the AELF, on aelf.org.

    25
  20. Pseudo-Chrysostom, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: the physician endures the infection to bring the remedy, the tax collector was converted; Zacchaeus does not await the judgment of the law, he makes himself his own judge. English texts: As a physician sometimes cannot save his patients without the defilement of blood ; Zacchaeus waits not for the judgment of the law, but makes himself his own judge.

    26 30
  21. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 8: half to the poor, the fourfold in reparation. Liturgical translation of the AELF, on aelf.org.

    27 28
  22. Theophylact of Ohrid, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: he does not say I will give, he says I give, and after the half given, the fourfold returned leaves him almost nothing of his goods; he was not a son of Abraham before, he is now. English texts: He says not, I will give, but, I give ; He said not that he was a son of Abraham, but that he now is.

    29 35
  23. Ex 22, 1: whoever steals an ox shall restore five oxen, whoever steals a sheep shall restore four sheep.

    31 77
  24. 2 Sam 12, 6: Nathan to David, for the poor man's sheep, he shall restore it fourfold.

    32
  25. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 9-10: today salvation for this house, he too a son of Abraham, to seek and save what was lost. Liturgical translation of the AELF, on aelf.org.

    33 36 37 39
  26. Bede the Venerable, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: son of Abraham by imitation of the faith, as Abraham left his country, he abandoned all his goods. English text: Zacchaeus is called the son of Abraham, not because he was born of Abraham's seed, but because he imitates his faith.

    34
  27. Ezek 34, 16: what is lost, I will seek, the promise of the Lord the shepherd that Luke 19, 10 fulfills.

    38
  28. Saint Cyril of Alexandria, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: the crowd is the tumult of an ignorant multitude that cannot see the summit of wisdom. English text: The crowd is the tumultuous state of an ignorant multitude, which cannot see the lofty top of wisdom.

    40
  29. Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 2412: by virtue of commutative justice, reparation for an injustice committed requires the restitution of the stolen good.

    41
  30. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, II-II, q. 62, on restitution, after Saint Augustine, Letter 153 to Macedonius: sin is not forgiven if the stolen good is not restored when one is able.

    42
  31. Lk 18, 18-27: the rich official goes away sad, the camel and the eye of a needle, what is impossible for men is possible for God.

    44
  32. Lk 18, 35-43: the blind man by the roadside at the entrance to Jericho, healed just before the meeting with Zacchaeus.

    45
  33. Bede the Venerable, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: the camel unburdened of its hump passes through the eye of a needle, the rich man abandons the love of riches. English text: The camel disencumbered of his hunch passes through the eye of a needle.

    46
  34. Saint Ambrose, Exposition of the Gospel according to Luke, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: who will despair of himself when the one who lived by fraud attains grace, and not all rich men are avaricious. English text: For who will hereafter despair of himself, now that he attains to grace who gained his living by fraud. And he too moreover a rich man, that we may know that not all rich men are covetous.

    47 61
  35. Lk 2, 11: today a Savior is born to you. Lk 4, 21: today the Scripture is fulfilled. Lk 23, 43: today you will be with me in paradise.

    50
  36. Apostolic Constitutions, a collection of ecclesiastical discipline compiled in the 4th century, in eight books: witness to the memory of the Churches, not written by the apostles.

    51 53
  37. Apostolic Constitutions, VII, 46, list of the early bishops: Of Caesarea of Palestine, the first was Zacchaeus, who had been a publican. English text: Of Caesarea of Palestine, the first was Zacchaeus, who was once a publican; after whom was Cornelius, and the third Theophilus.

    52
  38. Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, c. 200: a collection of traditions and exegetical notes, a witness to the Alexandrian memory.

    54
  39. Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, IV, 6: it is said that Zacchaeus, or according to some Matthew, the chief of the publicans, promised to restore fourfold. English text: It is said, therefore, that Zaccheus, or, according to some, Matthew, the chief of the publicans, on hearing that the Lord had deigned to come to him, said, Lord, and if I have taken anything by false accusation, I restore him fourfold.

    55 56
  40. The Churches of the East celebrate the apostle Zacchaeus, bishop of Caesarea, the one whom Jesus made come down from the sycamore, on 20 April.

    57
  41. A. Mertens, Who was a Christian in the Holy Land, Franciscan Printing Press, Jerusalem, 1980: the Copts celebrate Zacchaeus on 20 April; the Roman Martyrology commemorates him on 23 August.

    58
  42. Sanctuary of Rocamadour: body discovered in 1166 before the chapel of Our Lady, the legend of Amadour, the Zacchaeus who came to Gaul with Veronica, a hermit of the rock. A late local tradition, with no ancient witness.

    59 60
  43. Saint Ambrose, Exposition of the Gospel of Luke, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: why describe his stature, unless it was because he was young in evil or weak in faith. English text: What means the Evangelist by describing his stature, and that of none other? It is perhaps because he was young in wickedness, or as yet weak in the faith.

    62
  44. Saint Cyril of Alexandria, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: Zacchaeus showed no delay, and was judged worthy of the favor of God. English text: Zacchaeus made no delay in what he did, and so was accounted worthy of the favor of God.

    63
  45. Bede the Venerable, cited in Saint Thomas Aquinas, Golden Chain on Lk 19: Zacchaeus, which is interpreted justified, signifies the believers who came from the nations. English text: Zacchaeus, which is by interpretation justified, signifies the Gentile believers.

    64
  46. James Tissot, Zacchaeus in the Sycamore Tree Awaiting the Passage of Jesus, illustration from The Life of Our Lord Jesus Christ, 1886-1896, watercolor on graphite, Brooklyn Museum, public domain.

    65
  47. A. Mertens, Who was a Christian in the Holy Land, Franciscan Printing Press, Jerusalem, 1980: in Jericho, facing the Franciscan estate, a Greek Orthodox church keeps the sycamore of tradition.

    66
  48. Thirty-first Sunday in Ordinary Time, Year C: the Gospel proclaimed is Lk 19:1-10, as attested by the Angelus of Benedict XVI on 31 October 2010.

    67
  49. Zacchaeus Sunday opens the Triodion, the liturgical season of preparation for the Byzantine Great Lent: Lk 19:1-10 is read on it.

    71
  50. Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke, Anchor Bible, Doubleday, 1981: dates the writing of Luke-Acts to the 80s, a hypothesis now very widespread.

    72 74
  51. The two-source hypothesis: Luke would combine the Gospel of Mark, a lost collection of sayings known as Q, and his own material, including the account of Zacchaeus.

    73
  52. The unanimous reading of the Greek and Latin Fathers: none treats Zacchaeus as an allegory; all comment on a man, a conversion, a reparation.

    78
  53. Benedict XVI, apostolic exhortation Verbum Domini, 30 September 2010: against an exegesis that would reduce the text to layers without encountering the persons.

    79

Can’t find your topic?