Joseph of Arimathea is the man who gave his tomb to Jesus: a wealthy dignitary, a member of the Jerusalem Council, who had the boldness to go and ask Pilate for the body of the Crucified, wrapped it in a shroud and laid it in the new tomb he had had hewn out of the rock. The four Gospels tell of the gesture, each with its own light, and the Church sees in it the fulfilment of Isaiah's prophecy: with the rich his tomb.
His appearance is brief and decisive. He has neither discourse nor miracle, only a public act at a time when everyone is hiding: the apostles have fled, Peter has denied, and it is a member of the tribunal that condemned Jesus who steps out of the shadows to bury him in broad daylight. Alongside Nicodemus, he performs the Jewish burial with an almost royal generosity, a hundred pounds of myrrh and aloes, linen cloths and spices according to custom. Then he vanishes from Scripture as quickly as he entered it, leaving Christians an empty tomb and late legends a hero of romance.
This article presents him as a figure of the Bible received by the Church: his place in the canon of the four Gospels, the traditional authors and datings of the narratives that name him, his portrait trait by trait, the unfolding of Good Friday evening, the fulfilled prophecy, his memory in the liturgy of East and West, the later traditions weighed at their proper value, and then, at the end of the journey, the debate with modern exegesis. The dossier of the burial shared with Nicodemus can also be read in Nicodemus, the life of the evangelist in Saint John the Evangelist: they are not duplicated here, we refer to them. To be distinguished from Saint Joseph, the husband of Mary, with whom he shares only his first name.
Joseph of Arimathea in the canon of Scripture
Four narratives for a single gesture
Joseph of Arimathea belongs to the small number of figures whom the four Gospels name together: Matthew, Mark, Luke and John all tell of the request for the body to Pilate and the burial. None of the four mentions him anywhere else, no other book of the New Testament names him, and yet his presence on Good Friday evening is disputed in no Christian tradition. The table below gives the four passages that structure the whole dossier.
| Passage | What the narrative brings of its own about Joseph |
|---|---|
| Mt 27:57-60 | Wealthy man, a disciple as well, new tomb hewn out of the rock, great stone rolled |
| Mk 15:42-47 | Influential man, member of the Council, boldness to go to Pilate, Pilate's astonishment, the centurion's report, shroud purchased, Mary Magdalene as witness |
| Lk 23:50-56 | Good and righteous man, with no part in the Council's decision, Arimathea a town of Judea, a tomb where no one had yet been laid, women who look on and then prepare the spices |
| Jn 19:38-42 | A disciple in secret for fear, Pilate's permission, Nicodemus and his hundred pounds of spices, linen cloths according to Jewish custom, garden and new tomb close by |
Each evangelist illuminates one facet: Matthew the wealth that fulfils Isaiah, Mark the political boldness of the gesture, Luke Joseph's innocence in the trial, John the passage from secrecy into the open with Nicodemus. None of the four narratives works on its own: it is the whole, received as a whole, that makes Joseph the witness of the real burial of Jesus[1].
The four Gospels that tell of him: received authors and dating
The Church receives the four narratives as the work of the evangelists whom tradition has named from the beginning: Matthew the apostle, Mark the interpreter of Peter, Luke the companion of Paul, John the beloved disciple. The earliest witness of this set is Saint Irenaeus, himself a disciple of Polycarp, who had known John: around 180, he lists the four Gospels and their authors, Matthew among the Hebrews, Mark after the departure of Peter and Paul, Luke the companion of Paul, then John at Ephesus[2].
"John, the disciple of the Lord, who had reclined upon his breast, also published a Gospel, during his stay at Ephesus, in Asia."
The ancient witnesses follow one another without a break: Papias, cited by Eusebius, reports that Mark wrote down exactly, though without order, what he had received from the preaching of Peter, and that Matthew collected the oracles of the Lord in the Hebrew language[4] ; the Muratorian Fragment, around the end of the 2nd century, counts Luke as the third Gospel and John as the fourth[5] ; Clement of Alexandria, cited by Eusebius, reports that John, seeing that the outward facts had already been set forth, composed last a spiritual Gospel[6]. The papyrus P52, a fragment of John copied around 125, and the papyrus P75, which joins Luke and John at the beginning of the 3rd century, rule out any fanciful late dating: the texts were already circulating far from their place of origin a generation after their composition[7]. The Pontifical Biblical Commission confirmed on 29 May 1907 that it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of the fourth Gospel, a historical account of the real events and discourses of the Lord's life[8].
The traditional dating fits in one line per Gospel, and it remains defensible without acrobatics: Matthew in the 40s to 60s, Mark the interpreter of Peter at Rome in the 60s, Luke the physician companion of Paul around 60 to 63, John at Ephesus in the 90s to 100. The Council of Trent fixed the canon by receiving these books entire with all their parts[9], and Vatican II recalls that the Church affirms without hesitation the historicity of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus really did and taught[10].
"Holy Mother Church has firmly maintained and maintains that these four Gospels, whose historicity she affirms without hesitation, faithfully transmit what Jesus, the Son of God, during his life among men, really did and taught for their eternal salvation."
Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19[11]
For the complete dossier on the fourth Gospel, see The Gospel according to Saint John ; for the Twelve and their companions, Saint Peter and Saint Paul.
The oldest summary: he was buried
Even before the detailed narratives of the Passion, the oldest Christian text speaking of the death of Jesus already mentions his burial. Around the mid-50s, that is, some twenty years after the events, Saint Paul hands on to the Corinthians what he himself received: Christ died, he was buried, he was raised on the third day[12]. The burial is part of the core, not the decoration: without a body laid somewhere, the announcement of the third day would make no sense to the first hearers.
The same Paul, preaching at Antioch in Pisidia, attributes the burial to the leaders of Jerusalem themselves: after the execution demanded of Pilate, they took Jesus down from the tree and laid him in the tomb[13].
"And when they had fulfilled all that was written of him, they took him down from the tree of the cross and laid him in a tomb."
Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 13:29[14]
This awkward plural, the inhabitants of Jerusalem and their leaders, fits exactly with the Gospel accounts: it is not a Galilean disciple who buries Jesus, but a local dignitary, a member of the court. A late Christian inventor would never have entrusted the body of his Lord to those responsible for his condemnation: he would have chosen Peter, John, or the women. The name of Joseph, preserved by four independent accounts even in the most ancient formulas, is the signature of a memory, not a construction.
Who was Joseph: a portrait in four strokes
A rich man, from Arimathea
Matthew opens his identity card with wealth: when evening had come, a rich man arrived, from Arimathea, who had himself become a disciple of Jesus[15]. The detail is not worldly, it is prophetic, as we shall see: it is because he is rich that Joseph owns a new tomb hewn from the rock, and it is this tomb that fulfils Isaiah.
Arimathea, in Greek Arimathaia, is identified by Eusebius of Caesarea with Ramathaim-Zophim, the town of Elkanah and Samuel the prophet, near Diospolis, modern Lod, in the district of Thamna: an identification taken up by Saint Jerome in his Latin version of the Onomasticon[16]. The connection rests on the form: Arimathaia transcribes the Hebrew Ramathaim, the place in the hill country of Ephraim where Samuel was born[17]. Luke specifies that Arimathea is a town of Judah[18]: in the first century, the Samuelite town did indeed belong to Judean territory, some thirty kilometres north-west of Jerusalem. Several sites in the hill country of Ephraim have been proposed by modern scholars, without secure consensus, but the ancient identification remains the best documented.
A prominent member of the Council
Mark and Luke agree on the office: Joseph is a member of the Council, the Sanhedrin of Jerusalem. Mark adds that he was a man of influence, literally of fine stature, noble in appearance, and that he too was waiting for the kingdom of God[19]. The Greek vocabulary speaks of rank: bouleutès, a councillor sitting on the supreme court of the Jews, that assembly of seventy-one members — priests, elders and scribes — which judged capital cases and had just handed Jesus over to the Roman prefect.
This is the whole force of the Gospel paradox: the condemning court supplies the gravedigger. Joseph sits on the body that handed Jesus over to Pilate, and it is he who will claim the body from that same Pilate. Far from softening the contradiction, the evangelists sharpen it: John specifies that Joseph was a disciple in secret, for fear of the Jews[20], that is, for fear of his own colleagues. His coming out into the open is all the more striking for it: he breaks publicly with his milieu, at the risk of his position, on the very day when the risk is greatest.
Good and righteous, a stranger to the verdict
Luke settles the question every reader asks: did Joseph vote for Jesus' death along with the others? No: he was a good and righteous man, who had not given his consent to their deliberation or to their deeds[21]. The formula is clear and covers both stages of the Jewish trial, the resolution and the execution. Joseph is neither a traitor to his side nor an accomplice making amends: he is a righteous man caught up in an iniquitous deliberation, in which he took no part.
This moral portrait has an apologetic weight that the Fathers noted: the witness of the burial is neither a fanatic nor a blind partisan, but a dignitary concerned with justice, whose word carries weight. And his righteousness does not remain interior: it goes out, it walks as far as the praetorium, it asks, it pays with his person and his purse. Joseph's goodness is not a sentiment, it is a courage.
A disciple in secret, grown bold
John gives the spiritual key to the man: a disciple, but in secret, for fear[22]. Mark gives the dramatic key: the same man took courage, literally he grew bold, dared, took it upon himself to go to Pilate[23]. Between these two verses lies a whole conversion: the death of Jesus achieves what his life had not yet obtained, it tears Joseph free from fear.
Saint John Chrysostom admires this late boldness and draws the lesson for the timid of every age: the one who hid his attachment shows himself after the death bolder than the fleeing apostles, because he has understood that the Crucified is truly the Son of God[24].
"Joseph, who until then hid that he was a disciple, showed himself of great boldness after the death of Christ. For he was not an obscure man, but a member of the Council, and a most distinguished one: which makes his courage all the more evident. He exposed himself to death, incurring the enmity of all, out of affection for Jesus: he dared to ask for the body, and did not cease until he had obtained it. And not only in taking it, nor in burying it magnificently, but in laying it in his own new tomb, he shows his love and his courage."
Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 88 on Saint Matthew (translated from English)[25]
The parallel with Nicodemus suggests itself: two dignitaries, two disciples of the shadows, two men whom the cross brings out into the open. But their trajectories differ: Nicodemus journeyed through three scenes, from the night of John 3 to the Sanhedrin of John 7 and on to the tomb; Joseph bursts forth at once, for a single definitive act. One ripens, the other decides: two paths to the same light.
Good Friday Evening, Hour by Hour
Asking Pilate for the Body
It all begins with a step the evangelists emphasize the cost of: going to the Roman prefect, in his praetorium, on the evening of a political execution, to claim the body of a man condemned to death. Mark uses the verb of boldness: Joseph dared to enter before Pilate[26]. The gesture is doubly risky: vis-à-vis the Romans, declaring solidarity with a crucified man executed for sedition; vis-à-vis his own people, openly displaying his dissent.
Pilate is surprised that Jesus is already dead: on the cross, the agony often lasted for days. He summons the centurion, checks, and then gave Joseph permission to take the body[27]. This Roman check matters: Jesus' death is attested by an officer, not only by those close to him. As a matter of law, handing the body over to a notable who requests it is anything but implausible: Flavius Josephus relates that Titus, at his request, had three of his acquaintances near Tekoa taken down from their crosses, and one of them survived[28]. If a Roman general could grant such a favor in the middle of a war, a prefect could well return a corpse to a member of the Council at festival time.
Taking Down, Wrapping, Embalming
Matthew summarizes the gesture in two stages: Joseph took the body and wrapped it in a clean linen shroud, a new and pure linen cloth[29]. Mark specifies that he bought this shroud, Luke that he himself took the body down from the cross[30][31]. John alone adds the scale of the embalming: Nicodemus brought a mixture of myrrh and aloes weighing about a hundred pounds, and the two men bound the body with cloths and the spices, according to the Jewish custom of burying the dead[32].
"Nicodemus, who had first come to Jesus at night, came too; he brought a mixture of myrrh and aloes weighing about a hundred pounds. They took the body of Jesus, therefore, and bound it with cloths, using the spices according to the Jewish custom of burying the dead."
Gospel according to Saint John, 19, 39-40[33]
A hundred Roman pounds, that is over thirty kilos of spices: an almost royal quantity, incomparable with an ordinary burial. Saint Augustine, commenting on John's precision regarding the Jewish custom, sees in it a lesson of universal scope: the evangelist meant to show that, in the duties owed to the dead, the customs of each people must be respected, and that the Church does not bury otherwise than in the received piety[34]. Joseph and Nicodemus are not improvising: they carry out the Jewish burial according to the rules, which makes the testimony of the empty tomb all the more solid.
The New Tomb in the Rock
Matthew gives the decisive detail: Joseph laid the body in the new tomb he had hewn out in the rock, then rolled a great stone to the entrance[35].
"Taking the body, Joseph wrapped it in a clean linen shroud, and laid it in the new tomb he had hewn out in the rock. Then he rolled a great stone to the entrance of the tomb and went away."
Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 27, 59-60[36]
Three details carry all the historical weight of the passage. The tomb is new, and Luke adds that no one had yet been laid in it[37]: no possible confusion with another deceased person, no naturalistic explanation by a neighboring body. The tomb belongs to Joseph, hewn out for him: Jesus rests in the burial place of another, as Isaiah foretold. The tomb is nearby: John notes that a garden was near the place of the crucifixion, with this new tomb in it, and that the proximity determined the choice, because of the Preparation[38]. The women, Mary Magdalene at their head, observe the place where he is laid: they will be the first witnesses of the emptiness, because they were the last witnesses of the fullness[39].
Tombs with rolling stones, burial chambers cut into the rock and closed by a stone slab, are well attested by the archaeology of Judea in the time of the Second Temple: the account describes a layout confirmed by excavations, not a theatrical set[40].
The Haste Before the Sabbath
Everything is played out against the clock: it was the day of Preparation, and the Sabbath lights were already shining[41]. The Law ordered that a corpse not be left overnight on the wood, but be buried the same day[42]. The Mishnah specifies that those condemned to death were buried the same day, in tombs prepared by the tribunal[43]. Joseph therefore acts in legal urgency: take down, wrap, lay before nightfall, even if it meant leaving the full embalming until after the Sabbath, which the women would indeed prepare[44].
This haste explains the silences of the account: no prolonged mourning, no procession, no public lamentations. It also explains why the tomb is Joseph's own: a burial place was needed immediately, and his, right near Calvary, was ready. Necessity brings about fulfilment: it is the constraint of the Sabbath that places Jesus in the tomb of the rich man.
With the rich his tomb: prophecy fulfilled
Seven centuries before Joseph, Isaiah had described the suffering Servant, put to death with the wicked, and yet laid with the rich: they made his grave with the wicked, his tomb with the rich, though he had committed no violence nor deceit[45].
"They made his grave with the wicked, and his tomb with the rich, although he had done no violence, and there was no deceit in his mouth."
Book of Isaiah, 53:9[46]
The contrast of the verse matches Good Friday exactly: crucified with the wicked, between two brigands, one of whom is elsewhere named the good thief, and buried with the rich, in the new tomb of a prominent man. Matthew, who alone notes Joseph's wealth, writes for readers able to hear the resonance: the rich man of Arimathea is the instrument of prophecy, unknowingly and without forcing the point.
Saint John Chrysostom adds that the new tomb is not a luxury of circumstance but a provision of Providence: by laying Jesus in a sepulchre where no one had yet rested, God rules out in advance any suspicion of confusion with another body, and prepares the proof of Easter morning[47]. The borrowed tomb thus becomes a piece of the Paschal dossier: because it belongs to a known man, situated near the city, seen by the women, and afterwards guarded at the priests' request, no one will be able to say that the wrong sepulchre was chosen.
The theology of the gesture goes further: the King is buried as a poor man dependent on others' alms. He who had nowhere to lay his head receives as his first dwelling the stone of another. This poverty, extending even into death, completes the kenosis, and the Church sings of it every Holy Saturday before the tomb.
The memory of the Church: liturgy, place, images
In the Latin calendar
The old Roman calendar honoured Joseph of Arimathea on 17 March; the Roman Martyrology now lists him on 31 August, with Saint Nicodemus, his companion in the burial[48]. The move, out of Lent where 17 March often fell, allows the two witnesses of the burial to be celebrated together, as they acted together. Each year, the liturgy of the Triduum renews their gesture: on Good Friday, the Church proclaims the Passion according to Saint John with the scene of Joseph and Nicodemus, and the faithful kneel before the cross that has been laid down[49].
In the East: the Myrrh-bearers and the troparion
The East honours Joseph with the myrrh-bearing women, those bearers of spices who went to the tomb: the second Sunday after Pascha is dedicated to them, and Joseph holds first place there with Nicodemus[50]. The Orthodox Churches and several Lutheran Churches also celebrate him on 31 July[51]. The troparion of Great and Holy Friday, in Tone 2, sings his gesture in a few words that the faithful repeat in procession around the Epitaphios, the icon of Christ in the tomb.
"The noble Joseph, taking down from the wood thy most pure body, wrapped it in a clean shroud, covered it with spices, and laid it in a new tomb."
Troparion of Great Friday, Tone 2 (translated from the English)[52]
The place: the garden and the Holy Sepulchre
John places the tomb in a garden, near the place of crucifixion[53]. As early as the 4th century, the Christian tradition of Jerusalem showed pilgrims the rock of Calvary and the nearby tomb: under Constantine, Bishop Macarius had the site cleared, and Eusebius recounts in his Life of Constantine the construction of the basilica that would become the Holy Sepulchre[54]. Although the identification of the exact location is debated among specialists, the setting — garden and quarry at the gates of the city — matches what archaeology would expect of a well-to-do 1st-century Jewish burial. The pilgrim who kneels today beneath the rotunda prays at the place where the memory of the Church, for seventeen centuries, has located Joseph's tomb.
In art: the Descent from the Cross
Joseph is everywhere in the iconography of the Deposition: at the top of the ladder, supporting the body with Nicodemus, offering the shroud, overseeing the entombment. Rubens's triptych in Antwerp, Rogier van der Weyden's Descent, and the Byzantine icons of the Entombment show him as a compassionate notable, often in a rich mantle, between the grieving Virgin and Saint Mary Magdalene kneeling[55]. Art has retained of him what Scripture says: neither apostle nor prophet, but the necessary righteous man, the man of the shroud and the stone.
Late Traditions: What Can Be Kept
The Acts of Pilate
From the earliest centuries, apocryphal accounts develop Joseph's role: the Acts of Pilate, also called the Gospel of Nicodemus, tell of his arrest by the Jewish leaders, his imprisonment and miraculous release, and then his testimony before the Sanhedrin[56]. These texts, whose core goes back to the early Christian centuries, have no canonical authority and mix memory with amplification: the Church does not receive them as history, but as ancient piety. They attest at least to one thing: the figure of Joseph already fascinated the early Christians, who were not content with the half-chapter of the Gospels.
The Grail and Glastonbury
In the High Middle Ages, Joseph becomes a romance hero: Robert de Boron, around 1200, makes him the first guardian of the Grail, the vessel of the Last Supper said to have caught the blood of the Crucified[57]. The monks of Glastonbury, in England, asserted from the twelfth century onwards that Joseph had brought Christianity to Britain and that his tomb lay within their abbey[58]. Honesty requires it to be said plainly: no ancient source links Joseph to Britain or to a chalice, and the old Catholic Encyclopedia already described these accounts as fabulous[59]. The Grail belongs to literature, not to history. But the legend says something true about devotion: Christians loved Joseph enough to invent a second life for him, because his first, one evening in Jerusalem, seemed to them too short.
Historicity: Objections and Replies
Five Pillars of the Account
The Joseph dossier is one of the strongest in the New Testament, and even critical exegetes acknowledge this. Five facts converge.
First, quadruple independent attestation: four accounts, four angles, one same core — the request to Pilate, the linen shroud, the new tomb, the stone. The differences in detail, Matthew alone on the wealth, Mark alone on the centurion, Luke alone on the innocence at the trial, John alone on Nicodemus, rule out slavish copying and attest to traditions that intersect without repeating one another[60].
Second, the most unlikely witness: a member of the Sanhedrin who does good. The great exegete Raymond Brown, hardly a suspect apologist, considered the burial of Jesus by Joseph very probable, precisely because it is almost inexplicable that Christians hostile to the Jewish authorities would have invented out of nothing a member of the Sanhedrin who treats Jesus well[61]. One does not invent a friend in the camp of the executioners.
Third, the women witnesses: it is they who watch where the body is laid, and it is they who will find the empty tomb. In a culture where female testimony carried little weight in law, an invented account would have chosen notables to discover the resurrection. The choice of women smells of memory, not strategy[62].
Fourth, the earliest summary: Paul passes on the burial as early as the 50s, in the formula received from the first witnesses[63]. The historian J. A. T. Robinson held the laying in the tomb to be one of the best-attested facts of the Passion[64]. Between the events and Paul, there is no room for a legend that would have had time to arise.
Fifth, the verified customs: burial on the same day according to the Law and the Mishnah[65][66], the handing over of the body on request attested in Josephus[67], rolling-stone tombs confirmed by excavations[68]. Every legal and material detail of the account finds its point of support in first-century Judaism.
- Around 30The evening of Good FridayJerusalem, before the Sabbath
Joseph asks Pilate for the body, wraps it in a linen shroud and lays it in his new tomb, with Nicodemus and his spices, before the eyes of the women[69].
- Around 50-55Paul's summaryCorinth and Antioch of Pisidia
- Around 60-100The four received accountsFrom Rome to Ephesus
- Around 125The proven diffusionFrom Egypt to Rome
- 4th centuryThe site rediscoveredJerusalem, under Constantine
The clearing of the tomb near Calvary and the construction of the Holy Sepulchre, told by Eusebius: the memory of the place meets the remembrance of the text[76].
Three Objections, Fairly Stated
First objection: Jesus would have ended up in a common grave, or been left to the beasts, according to the harshest Roman usage for the crucified. This is the thesis defended notably by J. D. Crossan, who makes of it a minority but argued position[77]. Reply: Roman usage varied according to place, governor, and feast, and Judea lived under a regime of religious exception in which the prefect accommodated local sensitivities; above all, this thesis must explain why four accounts, Paul, and the women witnesses unanimously say the contrary, and why no ancient text, even a hostile one, speaks of a common grave. A hypothesis that contradicts all the sources without producing any of its own remains a logical possibility, not a historical proof.
Second objection: Joseph would be an apologetic invention, created to provide an identifiable tomb and ground the proclamation of the empty tomb. Reply: invention would have chosen a favourable witness, an apostle or a close follower, not a member of the hostile court; it would have smoothed away the awkwardness of the secret disciple and the benefactor of the Sanhedrin, not put these details in the foreground; and it would not have let Paul attribute the burial to the leaders of Jerusalem. The fiction hypothesis makes the account stranger than it explains it[78].
Third objection: the divergences between accounts would betray legend, tomb belonging to Joseph or a mere burial vault, spices of Nicodemus or women at dawn, stone rolled away by Joseph or already in place. Reply: the divergences concern the circumstances, never the core — the request to Pilate, the linen shroud, the new tomb, the stone, the women witnesses. This is precisely the shape of several independent testimonies of the same event seen from different angles, and not that of a coordinated composition[79].
What Modern Exegesis Proposes, and Its Limits
A part of contemporary exegesis proposes dating the Gospels later than tradition, Mark around 70, Matthew and Luke around 80-90, and seeing in them communal compositions rather than direct memories[80]. Presented this way, the thesis remains a working hypothesis, and it must face its own fragilities: the datings often rest on circular reconstructions, one dates a text by a theory of sources one has built by dating the texts; the anti-miraculous presupposition rules out in advance any reading in which prophecy would truly announce the event; the argument from silence turns the absence of a detail in one evangelist into proof of ignorance; and Tradition is treated as suspect as a matter of principle, whereas it is itself a historical source, the closest to the events[81].
Above all, even the lowest datings leave Paul and his formula of burial intact, twenty years after the events, and even critical exegetes generally admit the burial itself: the debate concerns the details of the account, not its core. As Benedict XVI reminded us, an exegesis that reduced the text to strata without ever encountering the persons would miss its object[82]. The reader thus understands why the traditional reading remains defensible: not through pious stubbornness, but because the sources, the witnesses, the customs, and the places converge on the same evening, the same garden, the same new tomb.
To go further
- Nicodemus: the companion in the burial, from the night of John 3 to the myrrh of John 19
- The Gospel according to Saint John: the full dossier on the fourth Gospel
- Saint John the Evangelist: the apostle who tells the story of Joseph and Nicodemus
- Saint Mary Magdalene: the first witness of the tomb, present at the burial
- Saint Peter and Saint Paul: the Twelve and the apostle of the Paschal summary
- The Virgin Mary in the New Testament: the Mother at the foot of the cross
- The Holy Shroud of Turin: the linen cloth and the investigation of the burial sheet
- Saint Joseph in the New Testament: the namesake, husband of Mary
- Lazarus of Bethany, Martha of Bethany, Mary of Bethany: the friendly house of Bethany, not far from the garden
Notes and References
The four pericopes: Mt 27:57-60; Mk 15:42-47; Lk 23:50-56; Jn 19:38-42 (AELF translation, Association Épiscopale Liturgique pour les pays Francophones).
1Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, around 180: Matthew published among the Hebrews, Mark transmitted the Gospel after the departure of Peter and Paul, Luke, the companion of Paul, set down in writing the Gospel preached, John published his own at Ephesus. Direct witness of Polycarp, himself a disciple of John.
2 3 73Papias, reported by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down exactly, though without order, what he retained of the preaching; Matthew collected the sayings of the Lord in the Hebrew language.
4 72Muranatorian Fragment, end of the 2nd century, Roman canon: Luke as the third Gospel, John as the fourth, composed at the request of his fellow disciples and bishops.
5 75Clement of Alexandria, reported by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14: John, seeing that the outward facts had been set forth, composed last of all a spiritual Gospel.
6Papyrus P52, a fragment of John 18 copied around 125, kept in Manchester; papyrus P75, the Bodmer codex of the early 3rd century containing Luke and John: their circulation far from the place of origin implies the earliness of the writing.
7 74Pontifical Biblical Commission, decree of 29 May 1907 on the fourth Gospel: it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of a historical account of the deeds and the real discourses of the life of the Lord.
8Council of Trent, session IV, 8 April 1546: the canon receives the holy books in their entirety with all their parts.
9Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church affirms without hesitation the historicity of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus truly did and taught.
10 11First Letter to the Corinthians, 15:3-4: Paul hands on what he has received, Christ died for our sins, buried, raised on the third day. A formula received from the first witnesses, around the mid-50s.
12 63 70Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 13, 29, AELF translation: after the execution demanded from Pilate, they took Jesus down from the wood and laid him in the tomb. Paul's discourse at Antioch of Pisidia.
13 14 71Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 27, 57-60, AELF translation: the rich man of Arimathea, the spotless linen cloth, the new tomb in the rock, the great stone.
15 29 35 36Eusebius of Caesarea, Onomasticon, 225, 12: Armatham Seipha, city of Elkanah and Samuel, near Diospolis, in the district of Thamna. An identification taken up by Saint Jerome in his Latin version, Book of Places.
16First Book of Samuel, 1:1 and 1:19: Ramathaim-Zophim, in the hill country of Ephraim, the homeland of Elkanah and Samuel.
17Gospel according to Saint Luke, 23, 50-56, AELF translation: the good and just man who had no part in the decision, Arimathea, a town of Judea, the tomb where no one had yet been laid, the lights of the Sabbath, the women and the spices.
18 21 31 37 41 44Gospel according to Saint Mark, 15, 42-47, AELF translation: the influential man, a member of the Council, the boldness before Pilate, Pilate's astonishment, the centurion's report, the linen cloth bought, the tomb in the rock, Mary Magdalene as witness.
19 23 26 27 30 69Gospel according to Saint John, 19, 38-42, AELF translation: the disciple in secret for fear of the Jews, Pilate's permission, Nicodemus and the hundred pounds of myrrh and aloes, the linen cloths according to Jewish custom, the garden and the new tomb close by.
20 22 32 33 38 53Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 88 on Saint Matthew, on Mt 27 (translated from the English, text consulted on newadvent.org): Joseph, who had hidden his attachment, became very bold after the death, exposed to the enmity of all, obtaining the body and laying it in his new tomb out of love and courage.
24 25Flavius Josephus, Life, 75: near Tekoa, Josephus recognizes three of his acquaintances among the crucified and obtains from Titus that they be taken down; one of them survives. The handing over of a crucified man upon request is attested under Roman authority.
28 67Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 120, on Jn 19 (translated from the English, text consulted on newadvent.org): the evangelist, by noting that the burial followed Jewish custom, warns that the customs of each people must be respected in the duties rendered to the dead.
34Mk 15:47; Lk 23:55; Jn 19:25: Mary Magdalene and the women observe the burial; they will be the first witnesses of Easter morning.
39 62Jewish Second Temple burial chambers cut into the rock and closed by a rolling stone, of the golel type, attested by excavations in Judea: the Gospel account describes an ordinary arrangement for a wealthy burial.
40 68Book of Deuteronomy, 21:22-23: the body of an executed man shall not remain overnight on the wood; he shall be buried the same day.
42 65Mishnah, Sanhedrin 6, 5-6: those condemned to death are buried the same day, not in the tombs of their fathers but in burial places prepared by the court.
43 66Book of Isaiah, 53:9, AELF translation: the tomb assigned with the wicked, the grave with the rich, for the Servant without violence or deceit.
45 46Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 88 on Saint Matthew (translated from the English): the laying in Joseph's own and new tomb shows his love and courage, and this arrangement dispels any suspicion that another would be raised in place of Christ.
47Old Roman calendar on 17 March; Roman Martyrology in force: Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus inscribed together on 31 August, outside Lent.
48On Good Friday, the Latin liturgy proclaims the Passion according to Saint John, chapters 18 and 19, with Joseph's gesture at verses 38 to 42.
49In the East, the second Sunday after Easter, called the Sunday of the Myrrh-bearing Women, honors the women who carried the spices together with Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus.
50The Orthodox Churches and several Lutheran Churches celebrate Joseph of Arimathea on 31 July.
51Troparion of Great and Holy Friday, Tone 2 (translated from the English): the noble Joseph, taking down from the wood the most pure body, wrapping it in linen, anointing it with spices, laying it in a new tomb. Sung in procession around the epitaphios.
52Eusebius of Caesarea, Life of Constantine, book III: under Emperor Constantine, Bishop Macarius has the site of Calvary and the nearby tomb cleared, and the basilica of the Holy Sepulchre is erected.
54 76The Deposition by Peter Paul Rubens, triptych, 1611-1614, Cathedral of Our Lady of Antwerp: Joseph at the top of the ladder with Nicodemus; the Descent from the Cross by Rogier van der Weyden, around 1435, Prado Museum: Joseph in a rich mantle supporting the body.
55Acts of Pilate, also called the Gospel of Nicodemus, whose core goes back to the early centuries: the arrest, imprisonment and testimony of Joseph before the leaders. An apocryphal text, with no canonical authority.
56Robert de Boron, Joseph d'Arimathie in verse, around 1200: the vessel of the Supper, said to have collected the blood of the Crucified, entrusted to Joseph, the romantic origin of the Grail.
57The monks of Glastonbury Abbey, in England, asserted from the 12th century onward that Joseph had evangelized Britain: a late tradition with no support whatever in the ancient sources.
58Catholic Encyclopedia, 1913, article Joseph of Arimathea: feast on 17 March in the West and 31 July among the Greeks, details of the Acts of Pilate unworthy of belief, fabulous legend of Gaul.
59Mt alone on the wealth and the stone rolled by Joseph, Mc alone on the centurion, Lc alone on the innocence at the trial, Jn alone on Nicodemus and the garden: divergences of circumstances, agreement on the core.
60 79Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, Doubleday, 1994, vol. 2: the burial of Jesus by Joseph is judged highly probable, since it is almost inexplicable that Christians would have invented from nothing a Sanhedrist who treats Jesus well, given the hostility of early Christian writings toward the authorities responsible for his death (conclusion reported notably in the transcript of the Craig-Ehrman debate on the resurrection).
61 78J. A. T. Robinson, Cambridge exegete: the burial of Jesus ranks among the best-attested facts of the Passion.
64J. D. Crossan, The Historical Jesus, HarperSanFrancisco, 1991: minority thesis of an anonymous burial, or even of a body abandoned according to the harshest Roman practice, against the unanimous testimony of the ancient sources.
77A portion of contemporary exegesis proposes Mark around 70, Matthew and Luke around 80-90, by communities rather than by direct witnesses: a working hypothesis, not an established verdict.
80Recurring weaknesses: hypothetical reconstructions, circular datings, a presupposition that rules out miracle and precise prophecy in advance, argument from silence, extrapolation from incomplete clues, Tradition treated as suspect by principle.
81Benedict XVI, apostolic exhortation Verbum Domini, 30 September 2010: against an exegesis that would reduce the text to layers without ever encountering the persons.
82