A relic is, in the Catholic tradition, the body of a saint, a fragment of that body, an object that served him in life or in his martyrdom, or an object that touched his remains. The modern objection to this practice is ancient and can be stated in a single sentence: venerating bones is idolatry; honouring corpses is a cult of the dead. This accusation was raised by Vigilantius of Calagurris around 406, by Erasmus in 1526, by Luther in 1517-1520, by Calvin in his Treatise on Relics of 1543, and by Voltaire in his Dictionnaire philosophique of 1764.
The Catholic response does not consist in denying the reality of the abuses these critics point to: false relics, sacrilegious trade, popular credulity, superstition. It consists in distinguishing a legitimate use from a blameworthy abuse, and in showing that this distinction is neither late nor rhetorical. It appears as early as the Martyrdom of Polycarp, around 156, where the Christians of Smyrna affirm that they worship Christ and love the martyrs alone. It is codified by the Council of Nicaea II in 787, by that of Lateran IV in 1215, by Trent in 1563, and reformulated by the Catechism of the Catholic Church in paragraphs 1674 and 2132.
Three claims form the backbone of the Catholic case. First: to worship a relic would be idolatrous, but to venerate it as a sign of God's work in a saint is not — this is the distinction between latria and dulia, laid down by Saint John Damascene, taken up by Saint Thomas Aquinas, and confirmed at Trent. Second: matter is not foreign to divine action, and Scripture gives several examples in which God manifests His power through a body or an object linked to a just man — the bones of Joseph, those of Elisha, the cloak of Elijah, Peter's shadow, Paul's cloths. Third: honouring the body of a saint is not a cult of death, but a concrete confession of the resurrection of the flesh that the Creed has professed since the second century.
This article examines the objection point by point, its best historical versions, and the Catholic response sourced to the Fathers, the councils, the theologians, and the recent magisterium. It honestly acknowledges the abuses that the Church herself recognised at Trent, and shows why the answer to those abuses is regulation, never the rejection of the post-apostolic practice.
A question that keeps returning for twenty centuries
The objection against relics runs through Christian history like a red thread. It was not born with Luther or Calvin: it is as old as the practice itself. When the Christians of Smyrna gather the bones of their bishop Polycarp, burned around 156, the narrator of the Martyrdom must already specify: "We worship Him as the Son of God, but the martyrs, as disciples and imitators of the Lord, we love them rightly."[1] The distinction is laid down as early as the second Christian generation. It implies that the accusation was already circulating.
This objection takes on various forms in every century. Vigilantius of Calagurris writes it in 403-406, Wycliffe in the fourteenth century, Erasmus in 1526, Luther and Calvin in the sixteenth century, Voltaire in the eighteenth, and a certain contemporary religious rationalism still today. The constancy of the criticism deserves respect: no Christian practice has been attacked so regularly for so long. This suggests it touches a sensitive point — the encounter of the sacred and matter, the place of the body in faith, the question of the idol.
What exactly does the word "relic" designate?
The Latin word reliquiae, "what remains", has a technical meaning in the Catholic Church. It does not designate just any memento of a deceased person, but the bodily remains of a person whose holiness is canonically recognised, or an object associated with that person. The Instruction on Relics in the Church promulgated by the Congregation for the Causes of Saints on 8 December 2017 distinguishes, in the canonical tradition, two main classes:[2]
| Class | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| First-class relics (reliquiae insignes) | The entire body of a blessed or a saint, or a notable part (head, arm, leg, heart), or a portion that constitutes the remains in full | Body of Bernadette at Nevers · Tongue of Anthony of Padua · Heart of Carlo Acutis at Assisi |
| Second-class relics (non insignes) | Small bone fragments · Objects of contact (ex contactu): clothing, instruments, cloths that touched the body | Hair of Carlo Acutis distributed to dioceses · Bone fragments placed in altars at their consecration |
To this canonical distinction is added a threefold pedagogical division taught since the Middle Ages:
- First class: the saint's own body, his bones or his ashes.
- Second class: an object that served him in life or in martyrdom — clothing, book, instrument, chain, instrument of torture.
- Third class: an object that touched a first-class relic — a small cloth or medal applied to the tomb.
Catholic practice therefore carefully distinguishes the levels. A third-class relic contains nothing of the saint; it is only a sign of communion with him.
The distinction that defuses the objection: latria, dulia, hyperdulia
The heart of Catholic doctrine on the subject rests on four technical words that theology has forged to clarify what anti-relic criticism systematically conflates. The distinction is ancient: it is already found in Saint Augustine (Against Faustus XX, 21), in Saint John Damascene, and in Saint Thomas Aquinas. Trent confirms it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church maintains it in paragraph 2132.
| Greek Term | Meaning | Recipient | Theological Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Latria (λατρεία) | Absolute worship, due to the creator alone | God alone (Father, Son, Holy Spirit) | First commandment |
| Hyperdulia (ὑπερδουλεία) | Singular veneration of the Mother of God | The Virgin Mary alone | Term of scholastic theology (Saint Thomas); Ephesus 431 defined Mary as Theotokos |
| Dulia (δουλεία) | Veneration of the servants and friends of God | Angels and saints of Heaven | Nicaea II 787, Trent XXV |
| Relative veneration | Honour rendered to the image, the relic, or the place because of what they represent | Images, relics, shrines | Nicaea II: "the honour passes to the prototype" |
The Instruction of the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints expressly recalls that the relics of the blessed and the saints cannot be exposed for the veneration of the faithful without a proper certificate of authenticity[3]. The structure of Catholic discourse leaves no ambiguity: God is worshipped, the saints are venerated, their bodies are honoured, and objects of contact are respected. To confuse these levels is precisely what the Church has refused to do since Nicaea II.
This fourfold distinction is not a late rhetorical device. It restates in technical language what the Christians of Smyrna were saying in plain language as early as 156: we adore Christ, we love the martyrs. The entire Catholic argument flows from this.
The biblical foundations of the veneration of the body
The first objection to consider is also the most radical: the veneration of relics would be alien to Scripture, or even condemned by it. This claim, common among Luther and Calvin, does not withstand a careful examination of the texts. The Bible does not thematise the word "relic" — it predates the technical institution — but it lays down several theologically decisive precedents: God has never treated matter as foreign to his action.
The bones of Joseph carried out of Egypt
The first biblical precedent is explicit. Before dying, the patriarch Joseph makes his brothers swear: "God will surely come to your aid, and then you must carry my bones up from this place" (Genesis 50:25). Four centuries later, at the Exodus, Moses fulfils the oath: "Moses took the bones of Joseph with him because Joseph had made the sons of Israel swear an oath" (Exodus 13:19)[4]. The book of Joshua concludes the story: "And the bones of Joseph, which the Israelites had brought up from Egypt, were buried at Shechem" (Joshua 24:32).
Jewish tradition itself makes this translation an exemplary act. The Mekhilta de Rabbi Ishmael, a rabbinic commentary on Exodus, recounts that Moses searches for the bones with the help of Serah daughter of Asher, the sole survivor of the generation that had known Joseph[5]. The Babylonian Talmud comments:
"Come and see how beloved the commandments were to Moses our master: all the Israelites were busy with the plunder of Egypt, and he was busy with the bones of Joseph." — Babylonian Talmud, tractate Sotah, folio 13a[6]
This precedent is decisive. It shows that already in the Old Testament, moving and keeping the bones of a righteous man is neither an impure act nor a cult of the dead: it is an act of fidelity to a promise of God. The translation of Christian relics invents nothing; it prolongs a biblical gesture.
Elisha and the dead man raised to life by contact with the bones
The second precedent is even clearer on the question of the power associated with the bodies of the saints. The second book of Kings reports a brief but striking episode:
"As they were burying a man, suddenly they saw a marauding band; so they threw the man's body into Elisha's tomb. When the body touched Elisha's bones, the man came to life and stood up on his feet." — 2 Kings 13:20-21[7]
This text is taken up canonically in the book of Sirach, which comments around 180 BC:
"During his lifetime he performed wonders, and even in death his works were wonderful. In spite of all this, the people did not repent." — Sirach 48:13-14[8]
The Greek and Latin Fathers read this passage as a direct scriptural foundation for the Christian veneration of holy bodies. Saint Cyril of Jerusalem writes in the fourth century:
"The corpse that was thrown into the sepulchre of Elisha, upon touching the prophet's body, was restored to life: proof that, even when the soul is not present, a virtue dwells in the bodies of the saints, because of the righteous soul that dwelt in them for so many years." — Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures XVIII, 16, c. 348-350[9]
The patristic argumentation is firm: if the objection against relics were valid, 2 Kings 13:21 would be incomprehensible.
The cloths of Paul, the shadow of Peter, the fringe of Christ's garment
The New Testament confirms this line. Three apostolic passages are regularly cited by the Fathers and by the Council of Trent:
"People brought the sick into the streets and laid them on beds and mats so that at least Peter's shadow might fall on some of them as he came by. Crowds gathered also from the towns around Jerusalem, bringing their sick and those tormented by impure spirits, and all of them were healed." — Acts of the Apostles 5:15-16[10]
"God did extraordinary miracles through Paul, so that even handkerchiefs and aprons that had touched him were taken to the sick, and their illnesses were cured and the evil spirits left them." — Acts of the Apostles 19:11-12[11]
"A woman who had been subject to bleeding for twelve years came up behind him and touched the edge of his cloak. She said to herself, 'If I only touch his cloak, I will be healed.'" — Gospel according to Saint Matthew 9:20-21[12]
These three passages share a structure that patristic theology has noted. In none of the three cases does the power belong to the object, the shadow, or the garment: it is God who acts, and the text says so expressly ("God did extraordinary miracles", Acts 19:11). But God chooses to act through a material mediation, through a body, through a cloth, through a fringe. This is precisely the logic of relics.
The biblical argument can be put in one sentence: it is not contrary to Scripture for God to grant a grace through contact with an object linked to a righteous person. This argument alone does not establish the Catholic discipline of relics, but it destroys the objection in principle of the Reformers, according to which any material mediation would be idolatrous.
The Old Testament and ritual purity: a false problem
A recurring counter-objection: the Old Testament would declare impure anyone who touches a corpse (Numbers 19:11-16); New Testament Christianity should therefore, all the more reason, refuse all contact with the dead. This reading ignores three things.
First, Israel's ritual purity code does not define a moral value of bodies; it defines a cultic order tied to access to the sanctuary. Touching a corpse renders one ritually impure for approaching the Temple, as does touching a menstruating woman or consuming certain foods. This code is abolished in the New Testament. Saint Peter sees at Joppa the sheet let down from heaven and hears the voice: "Do not call anything impure that God has made clean" (Acts 10:15).
Second, the Old Testament itself, in the passage from 2 Kings 13:21 already cited, does not treat the contact between the dead man and the bones of Elisha as idolatrous. The episode is not condemned: it is reported as a wondrous work of God.
Third, Christ himself overturns the taboo. He touches the bier of the young man of Nain (Luke 7:14), takes the hand of the dead daughter of Jairus (Mark 5:41), and calls Lazarus, already decomposed (John 11:39-44). Christianity is not a religion that flees death out of a phobia of matter: it is a religion that affirms that death has been defeated in the flesh. It is within the coherence of this doctrine that the veneration of holy bodies develops.
Polycarp and the First Controversy (c. 156)
The earliest post-apostolic testimony of the veneration of relics is found in a letter that the Church of Smyrna addresses to the Church of Philomelium shortly after the death of its bishop Polycarp, burned and then pierced around 155–156 (Eusebius's Chronicle gives 167). This text, known as the Martyrdom of Polycarp, is one of the oldest surviving acts of martyrdom. It is crucial for two reasons: it is very close to the apostles (Polycarp had been a direct disciple of Saint John), and it explicitly lays down, already in the second Christian generation, the distinction between worship and veneration.
The Account of Smyrna
After Polycarp's death, the Christians want to gather his body. But someone, the account says, suggested to Nicetes, the father of Herod and brother of Alce, that he go and ask the magistrate not to hand over the body to them, “lest,” said he, “they should forsake the Crucified and begin to worship this one”[13]. This is precisely the modern accusation of idolatry leveled by Jews and pagans against Christians: if you retrieve the body, you will make your bishop into a new god.
The narrator's reply is one of the most important statements in early Christian literature on the question:
“They did not know that we could never abandon Christ, who suffered for the salvation of those who are saved throughout the entire world, the innocent for the sinners; nor could we worship another. Him, as the Son of God, we worship; the martyrs, as disciples and imitators of the Lord, we rightly love, because of their incomparable devotion toward their own king and master.” — Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter XVII, c. 155–156[14]
These words have been enshrined in the liturgy for eighteen centuries. The Greek verb used for Christ is proskyneō (to worship); the one used for the martyrs is agapaō (to love). The technical distinction is laid down. It will become latria and dulia in Greek and then Latin systematic theology, but it is already there in the popular prose of the second century.
Gathering the Bones More Precious Than Gold
The next chapter recounts the act itself:
“The centurion, seeing the strife provoked by the Jews, placed the body in the midst and burned it, according to custom. And so afterwards we gathered his bones, more precious than precious stones, and more tried than gold, and we laid them in a suitable place. There, the Lord will allow us, as far as possible, to gather in joy and gladness to celebrate the anniversary of his martyrdom, in memory of those who have already fought, and to train and prepare those who are to come.” — Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter XVIII[15]
Four decisive elements appear in this paragraph. First, the value attributed to the bones (“more precious than precious stones”) — a phrase that Greek and Latin Fathers will take up in chorus for four centuries. Next, the place: a suitable location, which will later become the martyrium basilica and then the cathedral. Then, the annual anniversary of the martyrdom, which is the historical origin of the dies natalis recorded in the martyrology. Finally, the catechetical purpose: to gather in order to prepare those who must one day confess in their turn. The veneration of relics is not an isolated act of sentimental piety; it is, from Smyrna in 156 onward, a structured ecclesial act.
The Martyrdom of Polycarp is not an isolated text. Around the same period, Saint Ignatius of Antioch, on the road to his Roman martyrdom (c. 107), writes to the Romans:
“Let me be given to the wild beasts, through whom it is possible for me to reach God. I am God's wheat, and I am ground by the teeth of the wild beasts so as to become the pure bread of Christ.” — Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Romans IV, 1, c. 107[16]
The image is striking: Ignatius wishes that his body be ground down to become bread, that is, a sacrificial offering, in imitation of the Eucharist. The martyr's body is not a corpse to be forgotten; it is, by identification with Christ, a sacramental sign.
Why Smyrna Defuses the Modern Objection
This second-century text plays a decisive role in the apologetic debate. It is not a late theoretical justification, fabricated in the Middle Ages to defend a dubious practice. It is a testimony of the second Christian generation, written in an age when the Church asserts itself against pagan idolatry, when the first concern of the faithful is precisely not to be confused with the worshippers of the gods. If the veneration of Polycarp's bones had been idolatrous, these very Christians, who died rather than throw the pinch of incense before the image of the emperor, would have been the first to refuse it.
The logical structure is relentless. The same Church that dies rather than worship Vespasian carefully gathers the bones of Polycarp. If one holds that this Church understood what idolatry means, one must hold that it did not regard its own gesture as such. It remains, then, to understand why: the answer lies in chapter XVII — “Christ, we worship; the martyrs, we love.”
The Fourth Century, or the Founding Translations
In the fourth century, the practice of venerating relics left the clandestine cemeteries and entered the basilicas. Three major episodes shape this transformation: the translation of Saint Babylas to Daphne by the Caesar Constantius Gallus in 351, the invention of the True Cross by Saint Helena around 326, and the invention of the relics of Gervasius and Protasius by Saint Ambrose in Milan on 17 June 386. These three cases show that the veneration of relics is not a medieval development: it is patristic.
Saint Babylas at Daphne: the First Official Translation
Babylas had been bishop of Antioch in the third century, martyred under Decius around 250. In 351, the Caesar Constantius Gallus, brother of the future emperor Julian, had a martyrium church built at Daphne, a suburb of Antioch, in front of the temple of Apollo, and solemnly transferred the bones of Babylas there. Saint John Chrysostom, in his Discourse on Babylas, explains the spiritual meaning of the gesture: the Caesar wished to bring a physician to the sick man — that is, to set the power of martyrdom against that of the pagan oracles[17].
Eleven years later, in 362, the emperor Julian the Apostate, wishing to restore the cult of Apollo, asked the oracle to respond — but it fell silent. Julian attributed this silence to the proximity of Babylas and had the relics re-exhumed. On 22 October 362, shortly after this exhumation, a mysterious fire destroyed the roof of the temple and the statue of Apollo, a copy of the Olympian Zeus of Phidias. Chrysostom saw divine thunderbolts in it; Ammianus Marcellinus, a pagan historian, reports that the Christians were accused, but acknowledges that the cause remains obscure[18]. The translation of 351 is unanimously regarded as the first official translation of a relic in the history of the Church — a decisive precedent that all medieval transfers would invoke.
Saint Helena and the Invention of the True Cross (326)
The mother of the emperor Constantine, Helena, made a pilgrimage to the Holy Land between 326 and 328, after the Council of Nicaea. According to a converging tradition — Cyril of Jerusalem around 348, Ambrose of Milan around 395, Rufinus of Aquileia around 402, Socrates, Sozomen, Theodoret — she discovered, beneath the pagan temple of Aphrodite erected by Hadrian on the site of Calvary, the wood of three crosses. The identification of Christ's Cross was made, according to tradition, by a miraculous sign.
The earliest testimony concerning the dispersal of the fragments is that of Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, around 350:
"The holy wood of the Cross bears witness in its favour, it which is visible among us to this day; and from this place, through those who have received fragments of it with faith, ever since, the whole world is almost filled with it." — Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, Catecheses IV, 10, around 350[19]
Egeria, a pilgrim from Galicia, describes in her Itinerarium (the 380s) the Good Friday liturgy in Jerusalem: the faithful approach the wood exposed by the bishop, and the deacons stand guard — "for it is said that someone once bit the holy Cross and carried off a piece of it"[20]. The detail is precious: it attests to both an intense veneration and a strict supervision, as early as the fourth century.
Saint Ambrose and the Invention of Gervasius and Protasius (386)
The most famous and best-documented episode of the fourth century takes place in Milan in June 386. The bishop Ambrose has just completed the Basilica Ambrosiana; he is looking for relics to consecrate it. According to his own account in Letter 22 to his sister Marcellina, on 17 June 386, led by a supernatural intuition, he had the ground dug near the tombs of the martyrs Nabor and Felix, outside the Porta Vercellina. Two skeletons of men of great stature were found, their heads separated from their bodies, their garments soaked in blood: Gervasius and Protasius, martyrs until then known only from oral memory.
"We found two men of wondrous stature, such as were seen in ancient times. All the bones were intact, and there was much blood. For two days we carried out the invention, and on the third day we transferred them to the ambrosian basilica." — Saint Ambrose, Letter 22 to Marcellina, June 386[21]
During the procession of translation, on 19 June 386, a blind butcher named Severus — known to the whole city — touched the cloth covering the shrine, brought it to his eyes, and recovered his sight. The miracle is attested by a first-rate eyewitness: Saint Augustine himself, then in Milan, one year away from his baptism. He would later write of it in the Confessions:
"You revealed then in a vision to Your renowned bishop the place where lay the bodies of the martyrs Gervasius and Protasius, which You had kept for so many years incorrupt in Your secret treasure... When they were revealed and exhumed, and with due honour had been transferred to the ambrosian basilica, not only were the possessed delivered, the demons themselves confessing, but also a citizen known to all, blind for many years, having learned the cause of the popular tumult and rejoicing, rose up and asked his guide to lead him to the place. Once there, he asked to touch with his handkerchief the bier of Your saints, whose death is precious in Your eyes. When he had done so and had brought the cloth to his eyes, they were opened at once." — Saint Augustine, Confessions IX, 7, 16, around 397[22]
This testimony is crucial. Augustine is not at that time a militant Catholic bishop: he is a Manichaean intellectual on the way to faith, a stranger to all popular superstition. His account of the miracle, written eleven years after the events from Hippo, retains the methodical objectivity of the Father of The City of God. And he adds, in the same book of the Confessions, that this miracle preceded his own baptism — which suggests that it played a role in his conversion.
The event of June 386 has another major consequence: the Brescia lipsanotheca, the oldest known Latin reliquary, dated to the end of the fourth century, arose within the ambrosian orbit. This is the moment when the Latin Church provided itself with an iconography and liturgical furnishings of its own for the veneration of relics.
Hippo, Saint Stephen, and the catalogue of miracles
The Milanese episode of 386 is followed, in the next generation, by a decisive event for the Latin Church: the invention of the relics of Saint Stephen, the protomartyr, at Caphargamala in Palestine, north of Jerusalem, on 3 December 415, by the priest Lucianus[23]. The Revelatio Sancti Stephani of Lucianus, translated into Latin by the Spanish priest Avitus, quickly circulated in the West, accompanied by portions of the relics. One of these portions reached Africa, where Saint Augustine had become bishop.
Augustine bears direct witness to what then took place at Hippo and in the neighbouring dioceses. Book XXII, chapter 8 of The City of God, written around 426, is one of the most valuable documents in patristic history on the question. There he records, with the meticulousness of an archivist, more than twenty miracles associated with the relics of Saint Stephen. The context of the chapter is explicit: Augustine is answering the objection of the pagans who claim that miracles ceased with the apostles.
Petronia, the ring, and the river Bagrada
« A lady of rank, of noble birth, from Carthage... told me that a Jew had persuaded her to wear under all her clothes a girdle of goat's hair, and upon this girdle a ring which, instead of a precious stone, bore a stone found in the kidneys of an ox. On the bank of the river Bagrada, as she went to wash, she saw the ring fallen at her feet, while the girdle remained intact... She could not suspect that the Twenty Martyrs, whose shrine she was about to visit, were not the authors of this prodigy. » — Saint Augustine, The City of God XXII, 8, c. 426[24]
Florentius the tailor and the fish at the silver wedding
« There was at Hippo an old man named Florentius, a poor and devout man, who lived by his trade of tailor. Having lost the garment that covered him and having no means to buy another, he ran to the tomb of the Twenty Martyrs, which is greatly renowned among us, and begged them to clothe him. »
In the belly of the fish he buys a few hours later, the cook Catose finds a gold ring. Overcome with remorse, he returns it to Florentius, saying to him: « See how the Twenty Martyrs have clothed you. »[25] The ring, once sold, would indeed enable the tailor to buy a new garment.
Martial, the pagan who converts on his deathbed
Augustine then recounts the story of an old nobleman named Martial, who had a great aversion to the Christian religion, but whose daughter was a Christian and whose son-in-law had recently been baptized. Seeing that his father-in-law was falling gravely ill, they implored him in tears; he brutally rebuffed them. The son-in-law then runs to the chapel of Saint Stephen, prays at length, and returns with flowers taken from the altar; he places them under the head of his sleeping father-in-law. At daybreak, Martial cries out that a bishop be fetched, and dies shortly afterwards repeating the very words of Stephen: « Lord Jesus, receive my spirit »[26].
Bishop Lucillus of Sinita
« Lucillus, bishop of Sinita, a town near the colony of Hippo, was carrying in procession a shrine containing relics of the same martyr. Now, a fistula from which he had long suffered and which his physician was waiting to lance was suddenly healed by the mere carrying of this sacred burden. » — Saint Augustine, The City of God XXII, 8[27]
The chapter lists twenty-three similar cases: Eucharius of Calama raised after two clinical deaths, the child Hesperius healed of demonic possession, the blind man who recovers his sight in Milan during the very episode of Gervasius and Protasius, Audure and the little dead girl brought back to life, the physician Gennadius. Augustine concludes, with a candour that has not aged:
« If I wished merely to record the healings wrought by the most glorious martyr Stephen in the colony of Calama and in our own, it would take several volumes; and even then, I could not set down all those of which we have documented knowledge through the libelli that we read to the people, but only those which have thus been put in writing. » — Saint Augustine, The City of God XXII, 8[28]
Why is the catalogue of Hippo decisive?
The attestation of The City of God XXII, 8 is one of the most solid from late antiquity. Three features make it historically almost unassailable. First, Augustine writes as a bishop, in a work intended for posterity, where his reputation for rigour is at stake. Next, he writes to answer the pagans who denied the continuity of miracles: a lie would be suicidal. Finally, he describes cases verifiable by his contemporaries — he names the people (Petronia, Florentius, Catose, Martial, Lucillus of Sinita), gives the places (Hippo, Calama, Sinita), specifies the dates.
Augustine arrives, in the same chapter, at a major theological conclusion: the miracles of the relics do not turn away from Christ. They point back to the living God, to the ecclesial communion of the saints, and above all to the resurrection of the flesh professed by the Apostles' Creed. The relics are bound to the hope of the glorified body. It is precisely this articulation that will be taken up by Thomas Aquinas and confirmed by Trent.
Vigilantius against Jerome: the forgotten controversy of 406
Before Luther, Calvin and Voltaire, the objection to relics already had its theorist in the early Church. His name is Vigilantius of Calagurris, a priest from the Pyrenees (south-western Gaul), ordained in Barcelona around 395, and author of a lost pamphlet that can be reconstructed from the refutation addressed to him by Saint Jerome in 406. The controversy is far more important than is commonly thought: everything the Reformers would say twelve centuries later is already found in Vigilantius, and everything the Catholic Church would say is already found in Jerome.
Who was Vigilantius, and what exactly did he say?
According to the passages in Jerome that quote him, Vigilantius attacked four specific practices of the Church of his time:
- The veneration of the relics themselves — fragments of bones carried in small vessels.
- The nocturnal vigils at the tombs of the martyrs, accused of encouraging moral disorder.
- The custom of lighting candles near the burial places of the saints — a practice he considered suited to daylight and therefore useless, and borrowed from paganism.
- The sending of alms to the monks of Palestine and to the loca sancta, which he judged to be detrimental to the local poor.
He also denied the practice of invoking the intercession of the saints, holding that the saints, being dead, could neither hear nor intervene.
Jerome's reply
Jerome wrote the Contra Vigilantium in the summer of 406, in response to a letter from Bishop Riparius, who had informed him of Vigilantius's positions. The tone is virulent — Jerome admits to having lost sleep — and the ad hominem attack begins in the very first sentence:
"Suddenly Vigilantius — or rather Dormitantius, the Sleeper — has arisen, animated by an unclean spirit, who fights against the Spirit of Christ and denies that the tombs of the martyrs should be honoured." — Saint Jerome, Contra Vigilantium, paragraph 1, summer 406[29]
The apostrophe is biting, but what follows deploys a precise theological argument. The central passage, which methodically defuses the accusation of idolatry, has become a locus classicus of Catholic theology:
"We, I say it plainly, we do not venerate, we do not adore the relics of the martyrs, nor the sun and the moon, nor the angels and archangels, nor the Cherubim, nor the Seraphim, nor any name that is named in this world and in the world to come, lest we should serve the creature instead of the Creator, who is blessed for ever. But we honour the relics of the martyrs, so as to adore Him of whom they are the martyrs. We honour the servants, so that this honour may redound to their Master." — Saint Jerome, Contra Vigilantium, paragraph 5, summer 406[30]
This sentence already contains, in plain terms, the whole decree of Trent. Latria: to God alone. Dulia: to the saints. Relative veneration: to the relics, so as to adore Him of whom they are the martyrs. The Catholic doctrine of the fourth–fifth century is laid down, articulated and published long before the medieval controversies.
Jerome also answers the objection with scriptural precision. Vigilantius asked: "Why venerate what God, in the Law, declares impure?" Jerome counters with 2 Kings 13:21 (Elisha), Acts 5:15 (Peter's shadow), Acts 19:12 (Paul's cloths), and the resurrection at the tomb of Lazarus. He also counters with the public gesture: if relics are impure dung, why have the Romans, the Constantinopolitans, the Antiochenes and the Alexandrians joyfully welcomed the arrival of the holy remains? Why does the bishop of Rome offer the holy sacrifice above the venerable bones of Peter and Paul[31]?
A decisive controversy for history
The Vigilantius affair is no minor incident. It is the first internal doctrinal debate in the Church over the status of relics. Three things make it decisive for modern apologetics.
First, it proves that the accusation of idolatry is prior to the Protestant Reformation by more than a thousand years. Modern criticism invented nothing; it reactivated an ancient objection.
Second, it proves that the Church treated the objection at the highest intellectual level as soon as it appeared. Jerome is no marginal theologian: he is the translator of the Vulgate, the most listened-to scriptural commentator of his time, and the Latin patristic authority that all the councils will invoke.
Third, it proves that the Catholic answer has been constant from the beginning. When Trent defined in 1563 that the relics of the saints are to be honoured and that those who assert the contrary are to be condemned, the council was not defining a novelty: it was confirming the tradition running from Smyrna 156 to Jerome 406, from Damascene 743 to Thomas 1273.
John of Damascus and Thomas Aquinas: the theological synthesis
Between Jerome and the Reformation, two major theologians crystallize the Catholic doctrine on relics. Saint John of Damascus, in Constantinople in the 8th century, amid the iconoclast crisis. Saint Thomas Aquinas, in Paris in the 13th century, within a scholastic framework that anticipates the Protestant objections. Between them, they write the theological grammar of the veneration of relics.
Byzantine iconoclasm (730–787): the context of the definition
The Catholic doctrine on relics does not develop in the comfort of a peaceful Church. It is forged in a major crisis. On 17 January 730, the Byzantine emperor Leo III the Isaurian promulgates an edict ordering the destruction of all icons and sacred images throughout the Empire; relics are included in the suspicion. The Patriarch of Constantinople, Germanus, refuses, resigns on 22 January 730, and goes to live as a monk on his estate at Platonion. His successor, Anastasius, is placed on the patriarchal throne to carry out imperial policy. This is the beginning of the first iconoclast crisis, which lasts until the Council of Nicaea II in 787.
Under Constantine V Copronymus (741–775), the persecution turns violent: monks, the chief defenders of images and relics, are tortured; the conciliabulum of Hieria (754), convened without any patriarch, declares iconoclasm a doctrine of the state. Byzantine chroniclers report that Constantine V had the relics of Saint Euphemia of Chalcedon thrown into the sea to keep them from popular veneration — a gesture explicitly condemned by Nicaea II[32]. It is in this police-state context that John of Damascus, beyond reach because he lives in Muslim territory, writes his Three Treatises against Those Who Slander the Holy Images (c. 726–730) and then incorporates the material into An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith (c. 743–749).
« If you complain that the Law forbids the representation of God, I will answer that you have not understood the Scriptures. The letter kills, the spirit gives life. Find the hidden meaning beneath the letter. Tell me: how can the invisible be represented in an image? How can the uncircumscribed be depicted? But when you see the incorporeal become man for you, then you make an image of his visible form. » — Saint John of Damascus, First Treatise on the Images, c. 726[33]
The argument transfers exactly to relics. Once God became flesh (John 1:14), matter itself entered the sphere of the sacred. To refuse images and to refuse relics are, for Damascene, two symptoms of the same cryptodocetic heresy that refuses to take the Incarnation seriously. The writing of An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith is generally dated to around 743, in Damascene's final years. It is this text, written out of reach of the Emperor of Constantinople, that will furnish the theological arsenal of the Council of 787.
Saint John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa IV, 15
Chapter 15 of Book IV is entitled “On the veneration of the saints and of their relics” and constitutes the first systematic treatise on the subject:
“The saints are to be honored, for they are the friends of Christ, the children and heirs of God… they are not gods by nature, but gods by grace, as servants of God — not because they reign as such by their own essence, but in union with him who reigns and of whom they partake.” — Saint John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa IV, 15, c. 743[34]
On the relics themselves, Damascene is explicit. He advances a striking thesis, which will be decisive for Thomas: relics are not corpses in the usual sense, because Christ has transfigured death.
“The Master Christ has made the remains of the saints sources of salvation for us, causing to spring from them manifold blessings and an oil of sweet fragrance. Under the Law, whoever touched a corpse was considered unclean, but these are not dead. Since he who is himself Life and the author of Life was numbered among the dead, we no longer call dead those who have fallen asleep in the hope of the resurrection and with faith in him.” — Saint John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa IV, 15[35]
This statement is theologically revolutionary. It shifts the status of the holy body: it is no longer a corpse (a body given over to decomposition alone), it is a body asleep in Christ — a temple of the Spirit, destined for glory. The ritual purity of the Old Testament is surpassed because Christ has conquered death. To touch a holy body is therefore not to draw near to impurity; it is to draw near to the resurrection.
Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae III, q. 25, a. 6
Thomas Aquinas, in Paris around 1273, takes up the question in article 6 of question 25 of the Tertia Pars: Utrum reliquiae sanctorum sint adorandae — “Whether the relics of the saints should be venerated”. He raises three objections, gives a sed contra citing Saint Augustine (via the Decretum of Gennadius of Marseilles), and answers with an analogy that has become classic:
“The garment of a father, his ring, and anything of this sort, is all the dearer to his children the greater the affection they have for their parents. All the more, then, should the bodies themselves not be despised, which are something more united and more intimate to us than clothes.” — Saint Augustine, De civitate Dei I, 13, cited by Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae IIIa q. 25 a. 6, sed contra[36]
The analogy of the father's ring is central. Thomas broadens it: if we keep the ring of a deceased parent without confusing it with his person, all the more do we keep the body of a saint without confusing it with God. Veneration is mediated: it aims at the saint through his body, and at the God who sanctified the saint through the saint.
Thomas pushes precision to the point of answering each objection in turn:
- Objection 1: Is there not a risk of idolatry? Answer: Christian veneration differs from the cult of the pagan dead — one honors God through his servants, never as distinct gods.
- Objection 2: Venerating a senseless body is absurd. Answer: one venerates the senseless body not for its own sake, “but on account of the soul that was united to it and that now enjoys God”, and on account of God “who used it as an instrument”.
- Objection 3: The dead body is not the living body. Answer: it is “by reason of the identity of the matter which is to be reunited with its form” — the argument rests entirely on the final resurrection.
This last answer is theologically explosive. For Thomas, to venerate a relic is to profess the resurrection of the flesh. If one ceases to believe that the body will rise again, then veneration does indeed become irrational. But if the Creed is true, veneration is coherent: this body which rests here will be glorified there.
Why the body matters: Incarnation and resurrection
The Damascene–Thomas synthesis alone sets forth the deepest reason for the Catholic veneration of relics. It does not lie in a pious nostalgia, nor in an archaic fascination with matter, nor in a compromise with popular paganism. It lies in two dogmas: the Incarnation and the resurrection of the flesh.
Incarnation: God became flesh (John 1:14). The body is not despicable, since the Son assumed it. "What the Word has not assumed is not saved," writes Gregory of Nazianzus to Cledonius around 382. Therefore the body is saved. Therefore it has a supernatural value.
Resurrection of the flesh: this body that dies will rise again. The Apostles' Creed has professed this since the 2nd century. The resurrection is not the mere survival of a disembodied soul — it is the glorious transformation of the body itself. The body resting in Bernadette's reliquary at Nevers is promised the same glory as the risen body of Christ.
To honour a relic, then, is to profess twice over: that God came in the flesh, and that the flesh is destined for glory. And it is, as Augustine says and Trent confirms, to reject the dualism that despises the body in favour of an abstract spirituality. On this point, the opposition between Catholicism and certain currents of Protestantism is not merely liturgical: it is dogmatic.
From Nicaea II to Trent: the magisterial definition
The Fathers and theologians found the doctrine; the councils define it. Four stages structure the magisterial definition of the veneration of relics. The Second Council of Nicaea (787) responds to the first great crisis — Byzantine iconoclasm. The Fourth Council of the Lateran (1215) inaugurates the canonical regulation of relics. The Council of Constance (1415) condemns Wyclif. The Council of Trent (1563) formulates the normative definition that still holds authority today.
Nicaea II (13 October 787): honour passes to the archetype
Convened by the Empress Irene and the Patriarch Tarasius, the council closes the first iconoclast crisis that had torn the Greek Church apart since 730. Its final definition, promulgated on 13 October 787 during the VIIth session, sets forth the great rule of Christian veneration: "The honour paid to the image passes to the one it represents" (a formula taken from Saint Basil, On the Holy Spirit XVIII, 45). Canon 7 condemns those who reject relics:
"If anyone rejects the relics of the holy martyrs, let him be anathema." — Council of Nicaea II, session VII, canon 7, 13 October 787[37]
The definition establishes the decisive distinction between adoration (reserved to God) and veneration (given to images and relics) — a distinction the Latin theologians (Damascene, Thomas) had already elaborated. The canon does not invent the practice; it defends a received practice against an iconoclast innovation. This is a major step: the veneration of relics becomes a point of the ecumenical faith, and the rejection of this veneration becomes a rupture with ecclesial communion.
Lateran IV (30 November 1215), canon 62: the first universal regulation
The Fourth Council of the Lateran, convened by Innocent III, is one of the great legislative moments of the Christian Middle Ages. Among its 71 canons, canon 62 deals specifically with the regulation of relics:
"Because the Christian religion has often been degraded by the fact that some expose the relics of saints for sale and display them indiscriminately, we decree by the present that henceforth no ancient relics shall in any way be displayed outside a reliquary, nor offered for sale. As for relics discovered recently, no one shall offer them for public veneration unless they have first been approved by the authority of the Roman Pontiff." — Council of Lateran IV, canon 62, 30 November 1215[38]
Three major prohibitions are laid down. First prohibition: the sale of relics. Second prohibition: their display outside a sealed reliquary. Third prohibition: the public veneration of a new relic without papal approval. This regulation, contemporary with the great age of translations and the furta sacra studied by Patrick Geary[39], implicitly acknowledges that abuses exist and that they dishonour the practice. The regulation itself is old: Lateran IV does not correct a recently arisen practice; it systematises a framework already sketched out.
Constance (4 May 1415): the condemnation of Wyclif's theses
The Council of Constance, at its VIIIth session on 4 May 1415, condemns 45 propositions drawn from the writings of the English theologian John Wyclif (d. 1384), several of which touch on the cult of the saints and of relics. Wyclif denied, among other things, the legitimacy of the veneration of images, of shrines, and of the invocation of the saints. The council reaffirms the constant doctrine, anticipating the controversies that would break out a century later with Luther[40].
Trent (3 December 1563), session XXV: the founding text
Convened in response to the Protestant Reformation, the Council of Trent closes its XXVth and final session, on 3 December 1563, with a decree entitled De invocatione, veneratione et reliquiis sanctorum, et de sacris imaginibus — "On the invocation, veneration and relics of the saints, and on sacred images.". This is the normative text on the question for the four centuries that follow. The central passage states:
"The sacred bodies of the holy martyrs and of the others who live with Christ, who were living members of Christ and the temple of the Holy Spirit, who are to be raised by him to eternal life and glorified, are also to be venerated by the faithful; and through them God grants many benefits to mankind. Therefore those who assert that no honour and veneration is due to the relics of the saints, or that these, and the other sacred memorials, are uselessly honoured by the faithful, and that the frequenting of the places dedicated to the saints in order to obtain their help is superfluous, are to be wholly condemned, as the Church has already long since condemned them and condemns them also today." — Council of Trent, session XXV, decree on relics, 3 December 1563 (DS 1822)[41]
Three assertions are linked in this paragraph. Positive assertion: the bodies of the saints must be venerated. Theological justification: because they were members of Christ, temples of the Holy Spirit, and because they will rise to be glorified — this is the Incarnation/resurrection coherence that Thomas had established. Sanction: those who deny this veneration are condemned, "as the Church has already long since condemned them," a formula pointing to Wyclif and, implicitly, Calvin.
The same decree acknowledges, in its second part, the existence of abuses and imposes their correction. No new relic is to be admitted to veneration without the approval of the diocesan bishop; no image bearing false doctrine is to be displayed; all superstition and all pursuit of shameful gain in the worship of the saints are to be suppressed. Trent does not defend abuses: it defends the practice by prohibiting the abuses.
Magisterial synthesis in eight stages
| Date | Document | Central assertion |
|---|---|---|
| 13 October 787 | Council of Nicaea II, canon 7 | Anathema against those who reject the relics of the martyrs |
| 30 November 1215 | Lateran IV, canon 62 | Prohibits sale; every new relic requires papal approval |
| 4 May 1415 | Constance, session VIII | Condemnation of Wyclif's anti-relic theses |
| 3 December 1563 | Trent, session XXV (DS 1821-1825) | Normative definition; condemns those who deny the honour due to relics |
| 25 January 1983 | Code of Canon Law, can. 1187-1190 | Current canonical regulation |
| 11 October 1992 | Catechism of the Catholic Church §1674, §2132 | Pedagogical synthesis for the universal Church |
| 17 May 2007 | Instruction Sanctorum Mater | Procedure for the causes of beatification |
| 8 December 2017 | Instruction Les reliques dans l'Église | Authentication and preservation: current disciplinary rules |
- 155-156SmyrnaThe Christians gather the bones of Polycarp and distinguish the adoration of Christ from the love of the martyrs.
- 386MilanAmbrose transfers Gervasius and Protasius; Augustine attests to the miracle of Severus.
- 406Jerome against VigilantiusThe first internal controversy already formulates the modern objection.
- 787Nicaea IIThe council condemns the rejection of the relics of the holy martyrs.
- 1215Lateran IVCanon 62 forbids the sale of relics and requires approval of new ones.
- 1563TrentSession XXV gives the normative Catholic definition.
- 1983-1992Code and CatechismCanonical discipline and universal catechesis take up the distinction.
- 2017Instruction on relicsAuthentication, seals, conservation, and the prohibition of commerce.
This twelve-century continuity, running from Nicaea II to the Instruction of 2017, has no equivalent in Christian controversies. No Catholic practice has been so regularly attacked, and none has received so continuous and precise a magisterial definition.
The relics of the Passion: a case apart
Not all relics hold the same rank in the Catholic conscience. Above the relics of all the saints stand the Christ relics — those said to have touched the body of Christ directly between the Last Supper and the Resurrection. They are not honoured with a veneration superior to that of the saints' relics — latria remains due to God alone, never to the object — but the theological relationship to them is unique: these objects are tied to the Incarnation and the Redemption themselves, and no longer merely to a historical saint.
The traditional inventory distinguishes six great categories: the True Cross (wood of the patibulum), the Crown of Thorns (Sainte-Chapelle, Paris), the Holy Shroud (Turin), the Sudarium of Oviedo (face cloth), the Holy Tunic of Argenteuil and the Holy Robe of Trier (garments of Christ), and finally the Holy Nails and the Holy Lance (instruments of the Passion). None of these relics grounds the Catholic faith. But their scientific convergence — particularly the AB blood group identified on three distinct supports — constitutes a body of evidence that skeptical criticism struggles to explain by chance.
True Cross, Crown of Thorns, Holy Nails
The inventory of Rohault de Fleury, already cited above, is the reference instrument for the True Cross. Of the estimated 178,000 cm³ of the original cross (a pine beam 3 to 4 metres long), the fragments known worldwide amount to about 5,000 cm³, or less than 3% of the original volume. Far from Calvin's "ship", we are below the contents of a small chest. The True Cross is attested as early as Saint Cyril of Jerusalem in 348; it spreads through the West from the 5th century; the largest relic visible today is probably that of Santa Croce in Gerusalemme in Rome (the Constantinian basilica).
The Crown of Thorns enters the history of the Latin Church in August 1239, when Saint Louis buys it from the Latin emperor Baldwin II of Courtenay for about 135,000 livres tournois — roughly half the annual budget of the Kingdom of France. Saint Louis receives it barefoot on 10 August 1239 at Villeneuve-l'Archevêque, then solemnly in Paris on 19 August 1239, and has the Sainte-Chapelle built to house it, consecrated on 26 April 1248. The Crown has been kept at Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral since the Concordat (without the thorns already detached before 1239), and was saved from the flames by the chaplain of the Paris fire brigade, Father Jean-Marc Fournier, on 15 April 2019, during the Notre-Dame fire.
The Holy Nails present a particular case. Tradition holds that there were three original nails, but Eusebius of Caesarea relates that Helena had one mounted in Constantine's helmet and another in his horse's bridle (Vita Constantini III, 30); Theodoret of Cyrus confirms this (Historia ecclesiastica I, 17). Around thirty clavi sancti are today catalogued across Europe. Calvin made them one of his major arguments; Rohault de Fleury in 1870 honestly admits that only two or three fragments can be authenticated as possibly original, the rest being contact relics (secondary nails touched to the original, then venerated as such according to a logic of canonical transmission from the Middle Ages)[42].
The triple AB blood: Shroud, Sudarium, Tunic
The most striking body of evidence among the relics of the Passion concerns the three textile supports said to have been in direct contact with the body of Christ: the Holy Shroud of Turin (funerary shroud), the Sudarium of Oviedo (face cloth wrapped around the head just after death), and the Holy Tunic of Argenteuil (Christ's principal garment). Three objects, three independent historical traditions, three distinct itineraries handed down by tradition. And yet, according to specialised 20th-century studies, all three would converge on the same AB blood group — a typing that is claimed, and whose scope remains debated (see below), particularly rare in the ancient Middle East but well attested in Galilee.
| Relic | Itinerary according to tradition | Blood analysis | Date of analyses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Holy Shroud (Turin) | Edessa → Constantinople (hypothesis) → Lirey → Chambéry → Turin (1578) | Claimed AB blood | Pierluigi Baima Bollone, 1981 |
| Sudarium (Oviedo) | Jerusalem → Alexandria → Toledo → Oviedo, venerated since 812 (tradition) | Claimed AB blood | José Villalaín and Carlo Goldoni, 1995 |
| Holy Tunic (Argenteuil) | Jerusalem → Constantinople → Charlemagne, c. 800 → Argenteuil (tradition) | Claimed AB blood | Gérard Lucotte, 2005 |
The Sudarium of Oviedo deserves particular attention. Mentioned by the deacon Pelagius in his Libellus of 1059, kept in the cathedral of Oviedo in the Cámara Santa fitted out by Alfonso II around 812, it has been subjected since 1989 to a programme of systematic analyses by the Equipo de Investigación del Centro Español de Sindonología (EDICES). Dr Alan Whanger, professor of pathology at Duke University and inventor of the Polarised Image Overlay Technique, compared the Sudarium with the Holy Shroud in the 1990s. His conclusion became famous:
"We have identified seventy points of correspondence between the marks on the Sudarium and the face of the man of the Holy Shroud of Turin. For a medicolegal identification in an American court of law, fourteen are required. Seventy points constitute a material identity beyond reasonable doubt." — Prof. Alan Whanger, paper presented at the international congress on the Sudarium, Oviedo, 1990s[43]
To this convergence of anatomical marks (a nose of 7.62 cm exactly in the same position, the structure of the frontal impacts, identical right-to-left blood flows) is added the convergence of pollens. The palynologist Max Frei had identified 58 pollen species on the Holy Shroud in 1976 and 1978, the majority of Palestinian origin (holm oaks, Pistacia palaestina, Capparis ovata). On the Sudarium, 13 varieties identified by the Spanish analyses, 6 of them specifically Palestinian, shared with the Shroud[44].
The Holy Tunic of Argenteuil
The Tunica inconsutis — "the seamless tunic" — mentioned in John 19:23-24 ("Now the tunic was seamless, woven in one piece from top to bottom") is, according to centuries-old tradition, kept at the Basilica of Saint-Denys in Argenteuil, west of Paris. The relic is said to have been given by the Empress Irene to Charlemagne around 800, then passed on to his daughter Theodrade, a nun at Argenteuil. First written mention: a deed of Archbishop Hugh of Rouen around 1156. First solemn ostension: 1156; ostensions in 1933, 1934, 1984, 2016 — the 2016 ostension drew more than 200,000 pilgrims over sixteen days[45].
The most recent work on the Tunic is that of Prof. Gérard Lucotte, a geneticist (Lucotte Centre for Molecular Genetics), based on samples taken in 2004-2005 with diocesan permission. Working with a scanning electron microscope, Lucotte established three converging findings:
- Massive presence of human blood, invisible to the naked eye, distributed according to a bodily map consistent with a flagellation and a carrying of the cross prior to the crucifixion[46].
- Blood group AB identified through residual antigenic markers, in keeping with the Holy Shroud and the Sudarium[47].
- Eastern pollens (Phoenix dactylifera, Prosopis farcata, Chenopodium album, Cedrus libani, Pistacia palaestina) characteristic of first-century Palestinian flora, attesting to textile contact with the Holy Land.
Lucotte's conclusions are disputed by some pathologists, who consider the antigenic resolution insufficient on fabric more than a millennium old. The scientific debate remains open. But the mere fact that three relics of radically distinct historical provenances converge on the same blood group AB — borne by only about 5% of the world population and 3% in the Middle East — constitutes a body of evidence that prudence cannot dismiss out of hand.
"Chance is not enough to explain the convergence. Three supports, three traditions, three itineraries: if the blood were the same by coincidence, one would have to invent a new word for such a coincidence." — Pierluigi Baima Bollone, Sindone — Cento domande e risposte, San Paolo, 2010, p. 142-145[48]
This sanguine convergence does not prove authenticity in a dogmatic sense — the Catholic faith does not depend on a sequencing —, but it invalidates the Calvin argument of the "ship of fragments" for the Christic case: contemporary science lays back on the table a dossier that the Reformers believed closed.
Why this dossier matters theologically
The relics of the Passion are not an archaeological treasure. They are, theologically, a catechesis in stone on the reality of Christ's flesh. Tertullian, in the third century, had drawn up the teaching against the Docetists: "Caro cardo salutis" — "the flesh is the pivot of salvation" (De resurrectione carnis, 8). If the flesh of Jesus did not truly suffer, did not truly shed blood, was not truly touched, then Christianity is a spiritualist myth. If it truly was, then the cloths that touched it bear — not as magic, but as testimony — the historical signature of Redemption.
For this reason, the Catholic liturgy honours the instruments of the Passion every Good Friday, especially in the liturgy of Jerusalem, from which the procession of the True Cross directly derives. To venerate these relics is to confess once again that the Word became flesh and that he shed this blood AB to open eternal Life to mankind.
The altar and the stone: relics in the liturgy
One dimension is regularly forgotten in debates about relics: tradition holds that the consecrated Catholic altar receive the relics of saints. This is not a marginal custom or an optional medieval survival: it is a venerable custom that the law maintains as a recommendation — the Code (can. 1237 §2) orders it kept "in accordance with the norms given in the liturgical books", and the Missal (IGMR 302) invites this practice to be "usefully kept". It is theologically rooted in the Apocalypse of Saint John. To understand this is to grasp that the veneration of relics is not an appendage to the Catholic faith — it is inscribed in the liturgical furniture of the Eucharistic sacrifice itself.
The Apocalypse, scriptural foundation of the altar-tomb
The decisive image is found in the fifth vision of Saint John:
"When he opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of those who had been slain because of the Word of God and the testimony they had borne." — Apocalypse of Saint John 6:9[49]
Patristic theology immediately read this verse as a scriptural foundation for the Christian practice: celebrating Mass on the tomb of a martyr, or placing a portion of a relic beneath the altar. Saint Ambrose writes explicitly on 19 June 386 during the translation of Gervasius and Protasius to Milan: "Let the triumphant victims take the place where Christ is victim! But he, who suffered for all, on the altar; they, who were redeemed by his Passion, beneath the altar"[50].
The catacombs and Mass on the tomb
During the first three centuries, the persecuted Christians celebrated the Eucharist in the catacombs, on the mensae arranged above the tombs of the martyrs. Modern excavations — especially those of the catacomb of Saint-Calixtus beneath the Lateran, led by Antonio Bosio and then Giovanni Battista de Rossi in the 19th century — brought to light these mensae martyrum from which all later Christian altars originate. When in the 4th century the Church emerged from the catacombs, she did not for all that leave her dead behind: she transferred the relics into the new basilicas, placing them beneath the main altar, as Ambrose did for Gervasius and Protasius beneath the Basilica Ambrosiana.
Canon 17 of the Council of Carthage (September 401)
Explicit regulation appears at the beginning of the 5th century. The Council of Carthage of September 401 (canon 17, under the presidency of Aurelius of Carthage) decrees:
"The altars erected here and there in the fields and along the roads as memorials of martyrs must absolutely be abolished, if it is not certain that a body or relics of a martyr are placed there." — Council of Carthage, canon 17, September 401[51]
This canon is extraordinary: it forbids altars without relics. Thirteen centuries before Trent, the Latin Church considers the relic beneath the altar to be constitutive of the altar as such.
The Code of Canon Law and the IGMR today
This discipline is entirely taken up in contemporary Catholic law. Canon 1237 §2 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law provides:
"The ancient tradition of placing relics of martyrs or other saints in fixed altars or beneath them shall be maintained, in accordance with the norms given in the liturgical books." — Code of Canon Law, canon 1237 §2, 25 January 1983[52]
And the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (IGMR / GIRM), promulgated by Paul VI on 3 April 1969 and revised in 2002, states in its no. 302:
"The practice of placing beneath the altar to be dedicated relics of saints, even of non-martyrs, shall usefully be maintained. Care should be taken, however, as to the authenticity of these relics." — Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, no. 302, typical edition 2002[53]
Concretely, when a bishop consecrates a new altar — a few dozen each year in France — he seals within the sepulchrum (the cavity of the altar) a coffer containing bone fragments or ex contactu relics of one or more saints, together with the canonical record of the ceremony and an authentication parchment.
Why this practice links the Eucharist and the Resurrection
The theology behind this discipline is crystal clear. On the altar, Christ becomes present — body, blood, soul and divinity — through the eucharistic consecration. Beneath the altar rest the relics of a saint, that is, a member of Christ already glorified in soul and awaiting the bodily resurrection. The altar thus becomes an eschatological microcosm: the living Head above, the glorified members below, and the faithful assembly around. Every Catholic Mass celebrated in the world thereby visibly manifests the communion of saints. To refuse relics — as Vigilantius, Calvin and the iconoclasts wished to do — is, in strict logic, to refuse what Revelation 6:9 teaches about the souls of the martyrs "under the altar". The Catholic position, here again, invents nothing: it extends what Saint John saw.
Erasmus, Luther, Calvin: the great Reformed critique
From the fifteenth century onward, the objection to relics emerged from the circle of marginal heresies (Vigilantius, the Cathars, Wycliffe) to become a central argument of the Protestant break. Three figures brought this critique to its height: Erasmus, the reformist Catholic humanist; Luther, who made it a lever for his challenge to indulgences; and Calvin, who wrote the only systematic anti-relic treatise in history.
Erasmus at Walsingham (1526): the humanist satire
The Peregrinatio religionis ergo ("Pilgrimage for Religion's Sake"), published in Erasmus's Colloquia familiaria in 1526, is a satirical dialogue inspired by the Rotterdammer's visits to the shrines of Walsingham around 1513 and to Canterbury. The character Ogygius, a pious but gullible pilgrim, recounts his travels to the sceptical Menedemus. At Walsingham, he is shown a phial said to contain the Virgin's milk; Ogygius is enraptured; Menedemus is sarcastic. The target is not veneration as such, but credulity and economic exploitation.
Erasmus remains Catholic. He denies neither the Incarnation, nor the communion of saints, nor the resurrection. But he denounces what he regards as a popular distortion: money destined for the poor diverted to reliquaries, the absence of authentication, the absurd proliferation of objects. His critique would furnish the Reformers with their rhetorical arsenal. When Luther posted his 95 theses in 1517, European public opinion had already been prepared by Erasmus.
Luther (1517–1520): the trade in indulgences
Martin Luther's attack on relics is not frontal. Luther is less systematic than Calvin on this particular question. His critique chiefly targets the economic system of which the relics are one of the cogs: indulgences sold to finance the basilica of Saint Peter, paid-for pilgrimages, shrines that enrich the cathedral chapters and impoverish the parishes.
It was at Wittenberg, on the eve of All Saints' Day 1517, that Luther posted the 95 theses of the Disputatio pro declaratione virtutis indulgentiarum. The timing was not incidental: the crowd of pilgrims was expected in Wittenberg to venerate Frederick the Wise's collection of relics, which then numbered more than 19,000 — one of the largest in Europe. Luther does not directly attack his prince's relics, but he squarely targets the indulgences attached to their veneration.
In 1520, in the Address to the Christian Nobility of the German Nation, he generalises the critique: the pilgrimage–indulgence–relic–alms system has, in his view, become a device for enriching Rome and impoverishing the faithful. The Lutheran position would be codified in 1530 in the Augsburg Confession, Article 21, which rejects the invocation of saints as intercessors (and thus, indirectly, the veneration of their relics as mediations), while maintaining the legitimacy of their edifying memory.
Calvin (1543): the Treatise on Relics
The most systematic and most virulent pamphlet in history against relics is that of John Calvin, published in Geneva in 1543 under an interminable title: Advertissement très utile du grand proufit qui reviendroit à la chrestienté, s'il se faisoit inventoire de tous les corps sainctz, et reliques, qui sont tant en Italie, qu'en France, Allemaigne, Espaigne, et autres royaumes et pays. The text, of rare verve, was translated into Latin, German and English, and reached ten editions in fifty years.
Calvin's argument has four parts. First part: the absurd multiplication of relics proves their falsity. Several cities claim to possess the Holy Prepuce of Christ — Charroux in Poitou, Rome at Saint John Lateran, Hildesheim in Germany, and several other places — that is, at least three relics for one and the same organ, which is manifestly impossible. The Virgin nourishes the whole Church with her milk:
"There is no little town, no wretched convent, whether of monks or of nuns, where they do not show some of the milk of the Blessed Virgin, some more, some less. So much so that had the Blessed Virgin been a cow, or had she been a wet-nurse all her life, she could scarcely have yielded such a great quantity." — John Calvin, Treatise on Relics, Geneva, 1543[54]
And as for the wood of the Cross, the procedure is the same:
"If one were to gather together all that has been found of it, there would be the cargo of a good large boat. What audacity it is to fill the earth with pieces of wood in such quantity that three hundred men could not carry them!" — John Calvin, Treatise on Relics, 1543[55]
Second part: the veneration of material objects constitutes idolatry because it turns away from Christ toward things. "Instead of seeking Christ in his Word, in his sacraments and in his spiritual graces, the world has, as is its custom, amused itself with his robes, shirts and banners," writes Calvin. Third part: the practice has no scriptural basis — an assertion that ignores the biblical passages listed above. Fourth part: the confusion between true and false relics renders the whole practice indefensible. "Everything there is so confused that one cannot worship the bones of a martyr without being in danger of worshipping the bones of some brigand."
The Treatise was a massive success. It was placed on the Index librorum prohibitorum by the Faculty of Theology in Paris as early as 1543 — the same year as its publication. The speed of the sanction proves both the impact of the text and the difficulty of answering it point by point in the polemical context of the sixteenth century.
The Reformed steelman: what Calvin is right to denounce
An honest Catholic apologetics must acknowledge that Calvin's criticisms are not all false. Three findings are historically verifiable.
First finding: the multiplication of relics of the same origin was massive and indefensible in the sixteenth century. Several cities claim to possess the Holy Prepuce, several dozen churches possess a skull of John the Baptist, several dozen possess an arm of Saint Stephen, and the list goes on. Calvin is entirely right to point out this inconsistency.
Second finding: the trade in relics was a massive economic reality of the Middle Ages. The furta sacra studied by Patrick Geary in his seminal 1978 work show that monks and merchants stole, bargained and exchanged remains on a large scale, sometimes violently[56].
Third finding: canonical authentication was patchy before Trent. Lateran IV (1215) had laid down the principle, but its application remained uneven. That is precisely why Trent, two decades after Calvin, strengthened episcopal oversight.
Serious Catholic apologetics denies none of these three findings. It denies an inference: that these abuses ruin the practice itself. A false relic does not prove that all relics are false, any more than a counterfeit bill proves that all currency is worthless. The Catholic response consists in distinguishing, regulating, and authenticating — which the Church did at Trent, and continues to do in the 2017 Instruction.
Responses to the six main objections
The case against relics comes down, in practice, to six objections. Here they are in their strongest form, followed by the sourced Catholic response.
Objection 1 — Venerating bones is idolatry
This is the mother objection, formulated by Vigilantius and taken up by Calvin. Response: confusing adoration with veneration is precisely what Catholic doctrine has refused since Smyrna in 156. The Martyrdom of Polycarp chapter XVII, Jerome's Contra Vigilantium paragraph 5, Damascene's On the Orthodox Faith IV, 15, Thomas's Summa Theologica IIIa q. 25 a. 6, the decree of Trent DS 1822, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church §2132 all say the same thing: God alone is adored; the saints are loved; their bodies are honored in reference to the God who sanctified them.
The objection has force only if Catholic practice actually conflated the two levels. Yet no catechism, no council, no theologian makes this confusion. Popular practice may drift into it — but that is precisely what magisterial regulation corrects.
Objection 2 — Relics encourage superstition
This is Erasmus's objection, and it is partly true. Response: a practice can be distorted without being destroyed. Holy water can be distorted into a magic charm; pilgrimages can degenerate into religious tourism; images can become fetishes. The Church abolishes neither holy water, nor pilgrimages, nor images: she teaches and regulates.
The decree of Trent itself, at the end of the decree on relics, demands the suppression of "superstitions, dishonourable gains, drunkenness and licence". The 2017 Instruction goes further: no relic is venerated publicly without a certificate of authenticity, without diocesan approval, and the trade in relics is absolutely prohibited. Superstition is not an argument against the practice: it is an argument for regulation — which the Church has been doing since Lateran IV.
Objection 3 — The saints are dead, why address them?
A modern objection, often taken up by certain evangelical Protestants. Response: the saints are not dead in the sense of being non-existent. Jesus says that "God is not the God of the dead, but of the living; for all live to him" (Luke 20:38). Saint Paul writes that nothing, "neither death, nor life", can separate us from the love of God (Romans 8:38-39). Revelation shows the souls of the martyrs alive under the heavenly altar, crying out to God (Revelation 6:9-10).
The communion of saints, confessed in the Creed since the fourth century, holds that the Church militant on earth, the Church suffering in purgatory, and the Church triumphant in heaven form one Body. To honor a relic is not to address a corpse — it is to honor a living member of Christ whose earthly body awaits the resurrection. Here theology is inseparable from eschatology.
Objection 4 — The Old Testament forbids contact with the dead
A scriptural objection from Vigilantius. Response, already detailed above: Israel's ritual purity code is not a moral condemnation of the body, but a liturgical discipline abolished in the New Testament. The precedent of 2 Kings 13:21 — the resurrection at the touch of Elisha's bones — shows that in Scripture itself, contact with a holy body can be a vehicle of life. Christ touches the dead (Mark 5:41; Luke 7:14; John 11:39-44). Saint Peter passes his shadow over the sick (Acts 5:15-16). Saint Paul sends cloths that heal (Acts 19:11-12). The objection asks us to forget half of Scripture.
Objection 5 — There are so many false relics that the practice is ruined
This is Calvin's objection, and it is partly true for the Middle Ages. Response: the existence of false relics does not prove that all of them are. The argument rests on an undue generalization. More concretely, two facts must be taken into account.
First fact: the massive proliferation is largely medieval and tied to the sack of Constantinople in 1204, the furta sacra, and the absence of systematic authentication before Trent. Since 1563, and even more so since 2017, canonical control has been strict. A relic publicly displayed today must have a certificate of authenticity signed by the bishop or the postulator, sealed in a closed reliquary, and accompanied by an archivable dossier.
Second fact: historical abuses do not affect the best-established cases. The tomb of Saint Peter beneath the Vatican (excavations 1939-1968, Guarducci's identification, Paul VI's announcement on 26 June 1968) is not a false relic. The tomb of Saint Paul beneath Saint Paul Outside the Walls (analyses 2002-2009, carbon-14 dating confirming the first-second century, Benedict XVI's announcement on 29 June 2009) is not a false relic. The body of Bernadette at Nevers (exhumations in 1909, 1919, 1925, canonical sealings) is not a false relic. Catholic practice is not ruined by medieval forgeries — it is made more sober and more rigorous.
Objection 6 — With all the fragments of the Cross, you could load a ship
Calvin's most famous pamphleteering objection. Response: it was empirically tested in the nineteenth century by a French archaeologist, Charles Rohault de Fleury, in his Mémoire sur les instruments de la Passion de Notre-Seigneur Jésus-Christ published in 1870. Rohault de Fleury takes a worldwide inventory, millimetre by millimetre, of the known fragments of the True Cross, and compares this volume to the estimated volume of a pine-wood cross three to four metres high:
| Measurement | Result |
|---|---|
| Estimated volume of the original Cross (pine, 3-4 m × 2 m) | about 178,000 cm³ |
| Volume of known fragments in the worldwide inventory | about 5,000 cm³ |
| Ratio | about 2.8 per cent of the original volume |
Rohault de Fleury's conclusion: the known fragments amount to less than 3 per cent of the estimated volume. Far from a ship, we are below the contents of a chest[57]. Calvin's rhetoric, brilliant in controversy, does not withstand serious quantitative examination. Pius IX congratulated Rohault de Fleury for having "annihilated the sophistical arguments" of the detractors.
This response does not settle every case (the Holy Prepuce remains problematic, and the Church has discreetly withdrawn certain doubtful relics from the calendar). But it shows that the Calvinist critique, presented as a stroke of common sense, actually rests on an unverified estimate. When one checks, the picture is reversed.
The abuses acknowledged by the Church itself
An honest Catholic apologetics cannot content itself with refutation. It must also acknowledge what Trent itself acknowledged: there were abuses, they dishonoured the practice, and the Church had to correct them.
Medieval commerce and the furta sacra
Patrick Geary's major work, Furta Sacra: Thefts of Relics in the Central Middle Ages (Princeton University Press, 1978), documents this phenomenon methodically[58]. Between 800 and 1100, monks, merchants and sailors stole, traded and exchanged relics on a considerable scale. The most famous example is the theft of the body of Saint Mark by the Venetian merchants Buono di Malamocco and Rustico di Torcello in Alexandria in November 827, and its arrival in Venice on 31 January 828. The hagiographic account, written some two centuries later, tells how the Venetians hid the bones in a crate of pork and cabbages to escape the Muslim customs officers.
Another example: the theft of the relics of Saint Nicholas of Myra by 62 Bariot sailors on 9 May 1087, at the height of Turkish rule in Lycia. The Basilica of Saint Nicholas in Bari, consecrated in 1089 by Urban II, still houses the bones. Venetians and Bariots long disputed the primacy of the translation. The controversy is settled canonically in favour of Bari, but the mechanism of the theologically justified theft (translatio per furtum) remains an awkward historical fact.
The sack of Constantinople (12 April 1204)
The most massive episode of relic dispersal is the sack of Constantinople by the Fourth Crusade on 12 April 1204. Three days of systematic pillaging transferred to the West the priceless collection of the imperial chapel of the Pharos and of the great basilicas: the Crown of Thorns, fragments of the True Cross, the Holy Nail, the Holy Blood, the Lance, the Sponge, the Reed, the Shroud. Geoffrey of Villehardouin and Robert of Clari, participating chroniclers, provide partial inventories. The Sainte-Chapelle in Paris, consecrated on 26 April 1248 to house the relics bought back by Saint Louis from Baldwin II of Courtenay, concentrates 22 of them.
Saint Louis's own purchase illustrates the mixture of sincere piety and political logic. Baldwin II, a bankrupt Latin emperor, pledges the Crown to Venice in 1238; Louis IX buys it back for about 135,000 livres tournois (half the annual royal budget), receives it at Villeneuve-l'Archevêque on 10 August 1239, and welcomes it to Paris on 19 August 1239, barefoot in a tunic, carrying the reliquary with his brother Robert of Artois. An act of faith and an act of power: France becomes the "eldest daughter of the Church" through the relics of the Passion.
The French Revolution and the desecration of the royal tombs
Another major trial for relics is the French Revolution. Between 10 and 25 August 1793, by decree of the Convention, the royal tombs of the Basilica of Saint-Denis were desecrated and the bones thrown into a common grave. In every parish of France, reliquaries, shrines and treasures were seized, melted down and dispersed. A large part of the Latin relic heritage disappeared at that moment.
This is not a historical detail: it is a rupture. Once the Concordat was concluded in 1801, the Church had to rebuild its relic heritage, a task that occupied the whole of the nineteenth century. Present-day reliquaries mostly date from the post-revolutionary reconstruction — a little-known fact that sheds light on the relative sobriety of contemporary relic iconography.
Recent thefts
Illicit trade has not died out. In June 2022, a reliquary of the Precious Blood stolen from a French church was returned after the intervention of an art investigator[59]; more recently, the church of Saint-Vincent-de-Paul in Paris was itself the target of a relic theft. The black market in relics on the Internet exists — diocesan authorities fight it, and the 2017 Instruction recalls that any sale is canonically forbidden. The cause of Carlo Acutis even prompted a formal warning from the postulation against the illegal trade in the blessed's hair.
The Catholic Church denies none of these abuses. It acknowledged them as early as Trent, has regulated them since Lateran IV, and continues to tighten the canonical framework. It is precisely this ongoing magisterial self-criticism that distinguishes the Catholic position from a naive apology: it acknowledges the problem, names it, and corrects it.
Catholic discipline today
The Catholic Church's current practice regarding relics is governed by a precise canonical framework. Four texts structure it: the 1983 Code of Canon Law, the 1992 Catechism of the Catholic Church, the 2007 instruction Sanctorum Mater, and the 2017 Instruction on Relics in the Church.
Code of Canon Law (1983), can. 1187–1190
Title IV of Book IV of the Code of Canon Law, entitled “The Veneration of Saints, Sacred Images, and Relics”, contains three operative canons:
“Canon 1190 — §1. The sale of sacred relics is absolutely forbidden. §2. Relics of great significance as well as those which have been venerated by the faithful in great numbers cannot be alienated in any way or transferred permanently without the permission of the Apostolic See.” — Code of Canon Law, 1983, can. 1190[60]
The double prohibition (sale, and the alienation of significant relics without permission from the Holy See) forms the strict legal framework. Canon 1187 adds that only those servants of God inscribed in the catalogue of saints or blessed by the authority of the Church may be publicly venerated: no spontaneous devotion without canonical approval.
Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992), §1674 and §2132
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, promulgated by Saint John Paul II on 11 October 1992, places the veneration of relics in the chapter on sacramentals and popular piety:
“Outside the liturgy of the sacraments and sacramentals, catechesis must take into account the forms of piety of the faithful and popular religious practices. The religious sense of the Christian people has always found expression in various forms of piety surrounding the Church's sacramental life, such as the veneration of relics, visits to sanctuaries, pilgrimages, processions, the Stations of the Cross, religious dances, the rosary, medals, etc.” — Catechism of the Catholic Church, §1674[61]
And more systematically, in the section on the first commandment:
“The Christian veneration of images is not contrary to the first commandment which proscribes idols. Indeed, ‘the honor rendered to an image passes to its original’ (St. Basil, Spir. 18, 45), and ‘whoever venerates an image venerates the person depicted in it’ (Council of Nicaea II: DS 601; cf. Council of Trent: DS 1821–1825). The honor paid to sacred images is a ‘respectful veneration’, not the adoration due to God alone.” — Catechism of the Catholic Church, §2132[62]
The Catechism thus refers directly to Nicaea II (DS 601), to Trent (DS 1821–1825), and to Saint Basil. The dogmatic consistency spanning twelve centuries is fully embraced.
The Instruction Sanctorum Mater (17 May 2007)
Promulgated by the Congregation for the Causes of Saints under Benedict XVI, Sanctorum Mater sets out the procedures for the diocesan or eparchial investigation of causes of beatification and canonization. Title VIII deals specifically with the preservation and translation of relics during the process: the taking of bone fragments, anatomo-pathological examinations, canonical sealing.
The Instruction on Relics in the Church (8 December 2017)
This is the current reference text. Promulgated on 8 December 2017 by Cardinal Angelo Amato, Prefect of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints, the Instruction replaces the appendix of Sanctorum Mater and systematizes the canonical framework[63]. It lays down several strict rules.
- Obligatory authentication: no relic may be venerated publicly without a certificate of authenticity (authentica) issued by the competent ecclesiastical authority.
- Canonical recognition: any recognition, exhumation, removal, or dismemberment of a holy body requires the prior nihil obstat of the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints.
- Absolute prohibition of trade: the sale of relics (even non-significant ones), their display in profane places, and their commercial photography are forbidden.
- Significant / non-significant distinction: the procedure varies according to status, and is stricter for the whole body or notable parts.
- Preservation: reliquaries must be inviolable, clearly marked, and worthily appointed.
- Public veneration: forbidden for those who have not been beatified (a strict limit to private bona fama sanctitatis).
The Instruction is unprecedented in its legal precision. It brings to completion a long maturation: Polycarp 156, Nicaea II 787, Lateran IV 1215, Trent 1563, Sanctorum Mater 2007, Instruction 2017. The framework today is tighter than at any point in history.
When Science Meets Relics
The nineteenth and twentieth centuries put relics to the test of science. Three cases illustrate this encounter: Rohault de Fleury's inventory (1870), Secondo Pia's photograph (1898), and the Vatican excavations (1939-1968 and then 2002-2009). To these three cases is added the blood dossier of the Passion relics, treated in a specialized Ignispedia article.
Charles Rohault de Fleury and the True Cross (1870)
The French Catholic archaeologist Charles Rohault de Fleury published in 1870, with the publisher L. Lesort in Paris, a folio volume entitled Mémoire sur les instruments de la Passion de Notre-Seigneur Jésus-Christ, accompanied by 23 plates. The work is the fruit of half a century: Rohault traveled the treasuries of Europe, measured every fragment, weighed every splinter, drew every piece. The summary table inventories the total volume of fragments of the True Cross known throughout the world: about 5,000 cm³ — against an estimated volume of the original Cross of 178,000 cm³[64].
This numerical refutation of the Calvinist "ship" marks the entry of relics into the scientific age. Pius IX, who received Rohault de Fleury in audience, encouraged the publication and publicly congratulated him. The Mémoire remains consultable on archive.org and is authoritative.
Secondo Pia and the Holy Shroud (28 May 1898)
On 28 May 1898, at 9:30 p.m., the Turin lawyer Secondo Pia, an amateur photographer, climbed a 3.35-metre scaffold in the cathedral of Turin to photograph the exposed Holy Shroud. The plate, with a 14-minute exposure, revealed upon development a striking image: the photographic negative of the cloth yields a clear positive image of the face and body of a crucified man. In other words, the image visible on the cloth is itself a photographic negative predating any photography.
Secondo Pia describes the scene in a letter to Arthur Loth dated 29 June 1907:
"Alone, locked in my darkroom, completely absorbed in my work, I felt a very intense sensation when I saw for the first time, as my plates were developing, the Holy Face." — Secondo Pia, letter to Arthur Loth, 29 June 1907[65]
The Holy Shroud thus entered scientific history. Pia's photograph would trigger, seventy years later, the STURP mission (1978), then the contested C14 dating of 1988, then the contemporary controversy over the AB blood (treated in the specialized Ignispedia article on the blood improbability of the Passion relics).
The Excavations of the Tomb of Saint Peter (1939-1968)
The most important archaeological investigation of the twentieth century concerning an apostolic relic is that of the tomb of Saint Peter, beneath the papal altar of the Vatican Basilica. Pius XII ordered it in 1939, following the testament of Pius XI. The excavations, conducted by Msgr Ludwig Kaas and then by the archaeologists Antonio Ferrua, Engelbert Kirschbaum, Bruno Apollonj Ghetti and Enrico Josi, lasted ten years.
In 1942, in a niche of the "red wall", human bones were discovered. Beside them, a Greek graffito: ΠΕΤΡ[ΟΣ] ΕΝΙ — "Peter is here". Pius XII announced in his Christmas radio message of 1950: "The final conclusion of the work and studies answers with a very clear yes: the tomb of the prince of the apostles has been found." But the pope remained cautious about the identification of the bones themselves.
The epigrapher Margherita Guarducci resumed the investigation after 1953. Her expertise, cross-referenced with the anthropological examination of Professor Venerando Correnti, identified the remains as those of a robust man of 60-70 years, who died in the first century. She published her conclusions in 1965 under the title Le reliquie di Pietro sotto la confessione della basilica vaticana. On 26 June 1968, at the general audience, Paul VI announced:
"The relics of Saint Peter have also been identified in a manner that can be considered convincing. This news, which we must announce to the Church, fills our hearts with joy." — Blessed Paul VI, general audience, 26 June 1968[66]
On 29 June 2019, Pope Francis solemnly offered the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew a reliquary containing nine bone fragments from the tomb of Saint Peter. It was the first time that a part of the remains of the Prince of the Apostles returned symbolically to the Eastern Church.
The Excavations of the Tomb of Saint Paul (2002-2009)
At Saint Paul Outside the Walls, the sarcophagus of the apostle, long inaccessible, was examined between 2002 and 2006. The analyses focused on purple and gold linen fabrics, incense residues, and bone fragments. A blind carbon-14 dating yielded the first-second century. On 29 June 2009, at the close of the Pauline Year, during first vespers at the Basilica of Saint Paul, Benedict XVI announced:
"The bone fragments, subjected without their identity being known to carbon-14 examination by experts, were revealed to belong to a man who lived between the first and the second century. This seems to confirm the unanimous and unchallenged tradition that this is the remains of the apostle Paul." — Benedict XVI, homily at first vespers, Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, 29 June 2009[67]
None of these results is dogmatically required: the Catholic faith does not depend on a radiocarbon test. But the accumulation of archaeological, epigraphic and palaeopathological evidence converges with the oral and written tradition of nineteen centuries. It is the paradigmatic example of the encounter between science and relics in the twenty-first century.
Three Contemporary Relics, Three Lessons
To conclude the factual dossier, three modern cases illustrate how the Catholic practice of relics unfolds today: Bernadette Soubirous (incorrupt body, reliquary at Nevers), Charbel Makhlouf (Maronite saint, monastery of Annaya), and Carlo Acutis (contemporary blessed canonised in 2025).
Saint Bernadette Soubirous: Three Exhumations, a Wax Mask
Bernadette died at Nevers on 16 April 1879. Thirty years later, on 22 September 1909, with her beatification cause under way, Bishop Mgr Gauthey carried out the first canonical exhumation. The medical report, signed by Doctors Jourdan and Talon, records that the body is intact, the skeleton complete, the musculature atrophied but preserved, the skin still adhering to the muscles in places, the face whitish, the eyes appearing as cavities, and the nose already showing the beginnings of decomposition.
Two further exhumations followed, on 3 April 1919 and in 1925, for the canonical sampling. Dr Comte's report then noted continuous deterioration: a practically mummified body, mould patches, calcium salts, the skin gone in places. The preservation is therefore not miraculous in the sense of complete incorruption — it is a remarkable but explicable preservation. To allow public exposition for the beatification (14 June 1925 by Pius XI) and the canonisation (8 December 1933), a wax mask was placed over the face and hands. The body now rests in a crystal reliquary at the Saint-Gildard convent in Nevers.
The lesson is valuable for apologetics: the Catholic Church does not lie about the state of bodies. Bernadette's wax mask is public, Dr Comte's report is available for consultation, and the preservation is described not as a miracle stricto sensu but as a sign.
Saint Charbel Makhlouf: The Luminous Exudation of Annaya
The Maronite monk Charbel Makhlouf died at the Saint-Maron monastery in Annaya, Lebanon, on 24 December 1898, the eve of Christmas. He was buried on 25 December 1898 without a coffin, in accordance with Lebanese monastic custom. For four months, the monks observed a supernatural light above his tomb; on 15 April 1899, the superior ordered the canonical exhumation. The body was found intact, supple, and exuding a pinkish liquid that witnesses compared to bloody sweat. The phenomenon recurred during later medical examinations (1927, 1950, 1965).
The cause was opened on 4 April 1929. Paul VI beatified Charbel on 5 December 1965 and canonised him on 9 October 1977. The Maronite Postulatio documents more than twenty-nine thousand graces attributed to his intercession. The lesson here is one of convergence between Eastern popular piety, rigorous medical examinations, and the Roman canonical process: three cultures, one same recognition.
Carlo Acutis: The Sobriety of a Contemporary Saint
Saint Carlo Acutis (1991–2006), a young Italian who died of acute leukaemia at the age of 15, was beatified on 10 October 2020 at Assisi by Cardinal Vallini, and canonised on 7 September 2025 by Pope Leo XIV — the first canonised saint born in the 1990s. His body has been on display since 1 October 2020 at the Santuario della Spogliazione in Assisi.
The Church does not claim that the body is incorrupt: the postulation clearly announced that the face and hands are in wax, modelled to give a recognisable appearance. The actual body is dressed in jeans, a jacket and trainers — the young man's ordinary clothes, a sign that holiness is not reserved to a clerical state. Acutis's heart has been placed in a reliquary at the Cathedral of San Rufino in Assisi (altar inaugurated on 16 October 2022); locks of hair have been distributed as third-class relics to dioceses around the world (Rome, London, Seoul, Tokyo).
The transparency about the use of wax is a perfect example of contemporary Catholic sobriety. The Church does not play on appearances. It displays, it regulates, it authenticates. Carlo Acutis, through his youth and modernity (a computer programmer, a video game enthusiast, nicknamed "the Apostle of the Internet"), embodies what devotion to relics can be in the 21st century: sourced, authenticated, sober, and directed towards the imitation of holiness rather than fascination with remains.
The voice of the saints on their own bodies
One dimension is rarely heard in the debate over relics: what the saints themselves thought and said about their own bodies. Far from any morbid fascination, their unanimous voice bears witness to a precise understanding — their body is not them, yet it has been a temple; it is not an idol, but it will be glorified. This spiritual voice is the best answer to the modern objection, because it comes from those very people who are claimed to have been ashamed of this practice.
Saint Thérèse of the Child Jesus: "after my death, I will let fall a shower of roses"
Saint Thérèse of Lisieux, on her deathbed, understands that her body will become a relic. She is not alarmed by this — she makes use of it to announce her posthumous mission:
"I want to spend my Heaven doing good on earth. After my death, I will let fall a shower of roses." — Saint Thérèse of the Child Jesus, words of 9 June 1897 and 17 July 1897, reported by Mother Agnes, Last Conversations[68]
To her sister Céline, who worried about the destruction of her remains, she replied serenely:
"Whether my little body is mouldy or not, I shall always be happy, as long as I am with the good God." — Saint Thérèse of the Child Jesus, conversation reported by Sister Céline (Mother Geneviève), summer 1897, Last Conversations[69]
Her reliquary, opened a first time on 6 August 1910 and then on 9–10 September 1917, is today in the basilica of Lisieux. Her relics have travelled to 80 countries since 1994 — one of the longest reliquary pilgrimages in history. Thérèsian holiness embraces this journey of the bones: it is the mission she had promised herself in Heaven.
Saint Bernadette: "I am a broom" and explainable incorruptibility
Bernadette Soubirous (1844–1879), before her death at Nevers, would say to Sister Pasturaud:
"I am a broom that the Virgin has used. When the broom is no longer needed, it is put back behind the door." — Saint Bernadette Soubirous, saying reported by Sister Marthe Pasturaud, February 1879, in Procès apostolique de Nevers, 1923[70]
This radical humility contrasts with the remarkable preservation of her body — three exhumations (1909, 1919, 1925) attested to greatly slowed decomposition, without anything strictly miraculous, accompanied by the wax mask that now makes the reliquary visible. Bernadette knew that her body had been the instrument of the Virgin. She did not claim it for herself; she left it to the Church, which made of it what relics always are: a sign, never an idol.
Saint Padre Pio: the interior struggle with his own stigmata
Padre Pio (1887–1968) bore in his flesh the five wounds of Christ since 20 September 1918. His reaction was not one of pride but of spiritual shame:
"I beg you to ask Jesus to take this cross away from me. I do not want men to see me; I want to go unnoticed." — Saint Padre Pio, letter to Fr. Benedetto Nardella, 22 October 1918, Epistolario I, no. 117[71]
His gloves, soaked with the blood of the stigmata, are today displayed at San Giovanni Rotondo and in Rome. The popular piety that venerates them does not contradict Padre Pio's humility: it prolongs it. What he refused for himself — being put in the spotlight — the Church embraces for the good of the souls of the faithful, because the stigmata were themselves a call to conversion.
Saint John-Marie Vianney: "for me, purgatory!"
The Curé of Ars (1786–1859), canonized in 1925, used to say:
"When one does not love one's God, one loves no one. And when one loves only oneself, one's body after death is but a little dust to be thrown into the vault. But when one loves God with all one's heart, that body becomes a tabernacle." — Saint John-Marie Vianney, unpublished sermons, collected by Abbé Toccanier, Esprit du Curé d'Ars, Dumoulin, 1894, p. 211[72]
His incorrupt heart has been preserved in the reliquary of Ars since the canonical exhumation of 1904. His whole body, for its part, has been exposed beneath the altar of the basilica of Ars since 1925. The theology of the Curé of Ars's heart is at once Christological (the Heart of Christ adored in the tabernacle) and eschatological (the organ that loved so much awaits the resurrection together with the other members). To venerate this heart is to profess both of these dogmas at the same time.
Saint John Damascene concludes
The clearest theological synthesis remains that of the monk of Saint Sabas, concerning the remains of the saints — a text that must be reread after hearing Thérèse, Bernadette, Pio and Vianney:
"The Master Christ has given us, in the holy relics, sources of salvation, from which spring forth on every side manifold blessings: oil, perfumes, blood. Let no one be astonished. If, by the will of God, water gushed forth from the rock in the desert, and from the jawbone of an ass for Samson, is it incredible that a fragrant perfume should flow from the relics of the martyrs? By no means, for those who believe in the power of God and in the honour due to the saints." — Saint John Damascene, De fide orthodoxa IV, 15, c. 743[73]
This patristic word of the 8th century says, almost word for word, the same thing as Thérèse in the 19th. The voice of the saints is one single voice across twelve centuries. They consent to become relics because they believe in the resurrection of the flesh. They refuse to be idols because they have never ceased to adore God alone. What skeptical criticism presents as ecclesiastical pride is, in the saints' own words, an act of humility and hope.
Relics and Incarnation: the Catholic coherence
At the end of this journey, we must return to the doctrinal foundation. The veneration of relics is not a concession to popular piety, nor a compromise with ancient paganism, nor a medieval distortion. It is the consistent expression of three dogmas that the Catholic faith has held since the beginning.
Christianity is not Platonism
Platonism holds that the body is a prison of the soul, and that liberation consists in escaping it. A Platonic religion would despise the mortal body, regarding it as waste to be forgotten. Christianity says the opposite. God created the body and saw that it was « very good » (Genesis 1:31). The Word became flesh (John 1:14). The sacraments work through material signs (water, oil, bread, wine, the laying on of hands). The body of every Christian is a « temple of the Holy Spirit » (1 Corinthians 6:19). And the body of every saint, which was a temple, retains a dignity that death does not dissipate.
The sacramentality of matter
Relics are not sacraments in the strict sense: they do not give grace ex opere operato as baptism or the Eucharist does. But they belong to the same spiritual grammar — a grammar in which God acts through sensible signs. The water of baptism, the oil of confirmation, the bread of the Eucharist, the stone of the altars, the cross of blessings, the pious medal, the saint's relic: all belong to one and the same world in which matter is not opposed to the spirit, but serves as its vehicle.
This is why the Protestant rejection of relics was often accompanied by a broader rejection: the altar becomes a table, the oil becomes symbolic, the image disappears, the Eucharistic presence becomes a memorial. The veneration of relics is not a liturgical detail; it is a test of the sacramentality of Christianity as a whole. Where one ceases to honour holy bodies, one ends up ceasing to believe that matter can be a vehicle of grace.
The resurrection as horizon
The decisive argument, the one Thomas puts forward in his Summa, is that of the resurrection. To honour a relic is not an act of nostalgia turned towards the past; it is an act of hope turned towards the future. This body resting here will be glorified there. The bones of Polycarp burned at Smyrna, the perforated skull of the Maronite bishop Charbel, the wax face of Bernadette, the skeleton of Saint Peter identified beneath the Vatican: all await the same resurrection as the glorious body of the risen Christ.
This eschatological dimension is rarely perceived by critics. Vigilantius, Calvin, and Voltaire saw corpses; Christians see bodies asleep in hope, in the words of Damascene. When Christian eschatology is removed, the practice becomes incomprehensible. When it is restored, the practice is illuminated.
Conclusion: neither idolatry nor worship of the dead
The initial question was: « Are relics a form of idolatry of the dead? » The Catholic answer, grounded in twenty centuries of tradition, is no, and this answer rests on four pillars.
First pillar: the theological distinction between adoration and veneration, laid down as early as Smyrna in 156, systematised by Damascene and Thomas, confirmed by Nicaea II, by Trent, and by the Catechism of the Catholic Church §2132. God alone is adored. The saints are venerated. Their bodies are honoured in reference to the God who sanctified them.
Second pillar: the continuity of the practice since the early Church. The Martyrdom of Polycarp chapter XVIII, the translation of Babylas in 351, the discovery of the relics of Gervasius and Protasius in 386, the catalogue of miracles of Hippo around 426, the Vatican excavations of 1939–1968: the veneration of holy bodies is neither medieval, nor popular, nor superstitious in its principle. It is apostolic.
Third pillar: the continuous magisterial regulation, which recognises abuses and corrects them. Lateran IV in 1215 against the sale of relics, Trent in 1563 against superstitions, the 1983 Code of Canon Law against commerce, the 2017 Instruction on authentication and preservation. The Church has never denied the abuses that Calvin denounced; she has refused the inference that these abuses would invalidate the practice itself.
Fourth pillar: the dogmatic coherence with the Incarnation and the resurrection of the flesh. A religion that professes that the Word became flesh and that the body will rise again cannot despise the bodies of the saints. Contempt for relics is not merely a liturgical rejection: it is, in essence, a concession to the Platonic dualism that Christianity has always refused.
The real question, then, is not « bones or no bones? ». The real question is: does God truly sanctify the whole man, body included? If so, then the body that was a temple of the Holy Spirit here below is not biological waste to be forgotten. It is a member of Christ awaiting the resurrection, and it is right to honour it as such. This answer, the Martyrdom of Polycarp already gave it in 156, and the decree of Trent confirms it again in 1563. The Church does not change. She simply makes more precise what she has always said.
To go further
- Incorruptible bodies — phenomenon attested since the 2nd century, doctrine and emblematic cases.
- The blood improbability of the Passion relics — AB convergence of the Holy Shroud, the Sudarium of Oviedo and the Tunic of Argenteuil.
- The Holy Shroud of Turin — scientific and apologetic dossier.
- The communion of saints — theological foundation of the veneration of the saints and their relics.
- Purgatory — prayer for the dead and ecclesial communion among the three states of the Church.
- The Resurrection of Jesus — foundation of the resurrection of the flesh and the veneration of holy bodies.
- Eucharistic real presence — God acts through material signs.
- The Council of Trent (1545-1563) — magisterial response to the Protestant Reformation.
- The Christian catacombs of Rome — the first places of veneration of the martyrs.
- The great Protestant objections — overview of the apologetic dossier.
- Martin Luther (1483-1546) and John Calvin (1509-1564) — the leading critics of the Reformation.
Notes and References
Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter XVII, c. 155-156. Critical edition: Pierre-Thomas Camelot, Ignace d'Antioche, Polycarpe de Smyrne, Sources Chrétiennes no. 10, Cerf, 1958, p. 244-245. Greek text on newadvent.org/fathers/0102.htm. Original Greek of the key passage: « Τοῦτον μὲν γὰρ Υἱὸν ὄντα τοῦ Θεοῦ προσκυνοῦμεν, τοὺς δὲ μάρτυρας ὡς μαθητὰς καὶ μιμητὰς τοῦ Κυρίου ἀγαπῶμεν ἀξίως ».
1 13 14Congregation for the Causes of Saints, Instruction Relics in the Church: Authenticity and Conservation, signed by Cardinal Angelo Amato and Archbishop Marcello Bartolucci on 8 December 2017, published on 16 December 2017. Official text at vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/csaints/documents/rc_con_csaints_doc_20171208_istruzione-reliquie_en.html. The Instruction replaces the appendix of Sanctorum Mater (2007) and codifies all current procedures.
2 3 63Exodus 13:19: "Moses took the bones of Joseph with him, for Joseph had made the sons of Israel swear solemnly, saying: God will surely intervene in your favour, and then you must carry my bones away from here with you." Jerusalem Bible, Cerf, 1998, p. 116.
4Mekhilta de Rabbi Ishmael, tractate Beshalah, on Exodus 13:19. Critical edition: H. S. Horovitz and I. A. Rabin, Frankfurt, 1928, p. 78-80. Sefaria: sefaria.org/Mekhilta_d'Rabbi_Yishmael.13.19. The commentary recounts that Moses, not knowing where Joseph's tomb was (the Egyptians had allegedly sunk the coffin in the Nile to prevent Israel's departure), was helped by Serah daughter of Asher.
5Babylonian Talmud, tractate Sotah, folio 13a. Steinsaltz and Soncino editions.
6Second Book of Kings 13:20-21. Jerusalem Bible, p. 530.
7Sirach 48:13-14. Jerusalem Bible, Cerf, 1998, p. 1322. Greek text: « καὶ ἐν κοιμήσει ἐπροφήτευσεν τὸ σῶμα αὐτοῦ » — "and in his sleep of death, his body prophesied."
8Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, Catecheses XVIII, 16, c. 348-350. Patrologia Graeca 33, col. 1037. Critical edition: W. K. Reischl and J. Rupp, Munich, 1860, vol. II, p. 320. Eng. trans. on newadvent.org/fathers/310118.htm. Cyril comments there precisely on 2 Kings 13:21 as proof that even when the soul is not present, a power resides in the bodies of the saints because of the just soul that dwelt in them for so many years.
9Acts of the Apostles 5:14-16. Jerusalem Bible, p. 1797.
10Acts of the Apostles 19:11-12. Jerusalem Bible, p. 1846. Greek text: « δυνάμεις τε οὐ τὰς τυχούσας ὁ Θεὸς ἐποίει διὰ τῶν χειρῶν Παύλου, ὥστε καὶ ἐπὶ τοὺς ἀσθενοῦντας ἀποφέρεσθαι ἀπὸ τοῦ χρωτὸς αὐτοῦ σουδάρια ἢ σιμικίνθια ».
11Gospel according to Saint Matthew 9:20-21. Jerusalem Bible, p. 1670. Parallels: Mark 5:25-34; Luke 8:43-48.
12Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter XVIII, c. 155-156. Sources Chrétiennes no. 10, p. 246-247. Original Greek: « ὀστᾶ αὐτοῦ, τιμιώτερα λίθων πολυτελῶν καὶ δοκιμώτερα ὑπὲρ χρυσίον » — "his bones, more precious than costly stones and more proven than gold."
15Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Romans IV, 1, c. 107. Sources Chrétiennes no. 10, Cerf, 1958, p. 130. Greek text: « σῖτός εἰμι Θεοῦ καὶ δι' ὀδόντων θηρίων ἀλήθομαι, ἵνα καθαρὸς ἄρτος εὑρεθῶ τοῦ Χριστοῦ ».
16Saint John Chrysostom, Discourse on Babylas (Λόγος εἰς τὸν μακάριον Βαβύλαν), c. 378-379. Critical edition: Margaret A. Schatkin, Jean Chrysostome — Discours sur Babylas, Sources Chrétiennes no. 362, Cerf, 1990. On Constantius Gallus and the translation to Daphne: SC 362, p. 134-139.
17Ammianus Marcellinus, Res Gestae XXII, 13. Latin text and French trans. in Édouard Galletier, Collection des Universités de France (Budé), Belles Lettres, 1968, vol. III. The pagan historian reports the fire of the temple of Apollo on 22 October 362, but remains cautious about the exact cause; he explicitly rejects the accusation levelled against the Christians.
18Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, Catecheses IV, 10, c. 348-350. Patrologia Graeca 33, col. 469. First explicit attestation of the trade in fragments of the True Cross.
19Egeria, Itinerarium Egeriae 37, 1-2, c. 381-384. Critical edition: Pierre Maraval, Égérie, Journal de voyage, Sources Chrétiennes no. 296, Cerf, 1982, p. 286-289. The passage about the pilgrim biting off a fragment of the Cross is one of the most famous in early pilgrimage literature.
20Saint Ambrose, Letter 22 to Marcellina (= Epistula 77 in the CSEL edition), June 386. Critical edition: Otto Faller and Michaela Zelzer, Sancti Ambrosii Opera, Pars X, CSEL 82/3, Vienna, 1982, p. 126-140. Eng. trans. on newadvent.org/fathers/340922.htm. Full account of the invention of Gervasius and Protasius with testimony of healing miracles.
21Saint Augustine, Confessions IX, 7, 16, c. 397-401. Critical edition: Pierre de Labriolle, Collection Budé, Belles Lettres, 1925, vol. II, p. 217-218. French trans. on fr.wikisource.org. Augustine wrote this testimony eleven years after the event, from Hippo, as a Catholic bishop.
22Lucianus of Caphargamala, Revelatio Sancti Stephani, translated into Latin by the priest Avitus, c. 415-416. Critical edition: S. Vanderlinden, Revelatio Sancti Stephani, Revue des études byzantines 4 (1946), p. 178-217. The Revelatio recounts the triple apparition of the rabbi Gamaliel to Lucianus, identifying the burial place of Stephen, Nicodemus and Abibas.
23Saint Augustine, The City of God, book XXII, chapter 8, c. 426. Critical edition: Bernhard Dombart and Alphons Kalb, Sancti Aurelii Augustini De civitate Dei, CCSL 47-48, Brepols, 1955. Classic French trans.: Louis Moreau and Jean-Claude Eslin, La Cité de Dieu, Seuil, Points-Sagesses, 1994, vol. III. Chapter 8 is one of the longest in the work and constitutes the most important patristic catalogue of miracles attributed to relics. Online edition: fr.wikisource.org/wiki/La_Cit%C3%A9_de_Dieu_(Augustin)/Livre_XXII.
24 25 26 27 28Saint Jerome, Contra Vigilantium, paragraph 1, summer 406. Patrologia Latina 23, col. 339-340. French trans.: Charles Matougues, Œuvres complètes de Saint Jérôme, Paris, Vivès, 1864, vol. III. Original Latin: « orta est subito Vigilantia, seu, ut rectius dicam, Dormitantia, immundo spiritu pugnans ». French translation available on remacle.org/bloodwolf/eglise/jerome/vigilantius.htm.
29Saint Jerome, Contra Vigilantium, paragraph 5-6 depending on the edition, summer 406. Patrologia Latina 23, col. 343-344. Original Latin: « Nos autem non dico martyrum reliquias, sed ne solem quidem et lunam, non angelos, non archangelos, non cherubin, non seraphim, et omne nomen quod nominatur, et in praesenti saeculo et in futuro, colimus et adoramus, ne serviamus creaturae potius quam Creatori, qui est benedictus in saecula. Honoramus autem reliquias martyrum, ut eum cujus sunt martyres adoremus. » This passage is cited by all later Latin theologians as the normative expression of the Catholic position.
30Saint Jerome, Contra Vigilantium, paragraphs 7-8, summer 406. Patrologia Latina 23, col. 345-348. Jerome develops the ab ecclesia argument there: the apostolic sees of Rome, Constantinople, Antioch and Alexandria all practise the veneration of relics.
31Theophanes the Confessor, Chronographia, years 6259-6260 from the creation (corresponding to 766-767 AD). Critical edition: Carl de Boor, Theophanis Chronographia, Teubner, 1883-1885, vol. I, p. 439-440. English translation: Cyril Mango and Roger Scott, The Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor: Byzantine and Near Eastern History AD 284-813, Clarendon Press, 1997, p. 606-608. The account of the fate of the relics of Saint Euphemia under Constantine V is explicitly taken up in the Vita Stephani Iunioris, written around 809 by Stephen the Deacon, who makes it one of the charges against iconoclasm.
32Saint John of Damascus, First Treatise on the Defence of the Holy Images, paragraphs 4-8, written c. 726-730. Patrologia Graeca 94, col. 1232-1244. Critical edition: Bonifatius Kotter, Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos, vol. III, Contra imaginum calumniatores orationes tres, De Gruyter, 1975, p. 75-90. English translation: Andrew Louth, Three Treatises on the Divine Images, St Vladimir's Seminary Press, 2003, p. 19-46.
33Saint John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa, Book IV, chapter 15, c. 743. Patrologia Graeca 94, col. 1163-1170. Critical edition: Bonifatius Kotter, Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos, vol. II, Expositio fidei, De Gruyter, 1973, p. 207-213. English translation at newadvent.org/fathers/33044.htm.
34Saint John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa IV, 15, c. 743. Patrologia Graeca 94, col. 1167-1168.
35Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa pars, question 25, article 6, "Utrum reliquiae sanctorum sint adorandae", c. 1273. Leonine edition: Summa Theologiae, Editio Leonina, vol. XI, Rome, 1903, p. 282-283. French translation: Somme Théologique, Cerf, 1985, t. 4, p. 232-234. The sed contra cites Gennadius of Marseilles, De ecclesiasticis dogmatibus ch. 73 (a text long attributed to Saint Augustine), which itself draws on Augustine's De cura pro mortuis gerenda. The analogy of the ring ("anulus parentis") comes from Augustine, De civitate Dei I, 13.
36Council of Nicaea II, session VII, Horos and canon 7, 13 October 787. Reference: Denzinger-Hünermann no. 600-603. Critical edition: Erich Lamberz, Concilium universale Nicaenum secundum, Acta Conciliorum Oecumenicorum, series secunda, vol. III, De Gruyter, 2008-2016, 3 volumes.
37Fourth Council of the Lateran, canon 62 "De reliquiis sanctorum", 30 November 1215. Reference: Denzinger-Hünermann no. 812. Original Latin: "Cum ex eo quod quidam sanctorum reliquias exponunt venales et eas passim ostendunt, christianae religioni detractum sit saepius, ne in posterum detrahatur, praesenti decreto statuimus, ut antiquae reliquiae amodo extra capsam nullatenus ostendantur nec exponantur venales. Inventas autem de novo nemo publice venerari praesumat, nisi prius auctoritate Romani Pontificis fuerint approbatae."
38Patrick J. Geary, Furta Sacra: Thefts of Relics in the Central Middle Ages, Princeton University Press, 1978; revised edition 1990. ISBN 978-0691008622. A classic study of relic thefts between 800 and 1100, whose chapter III is devoted to the paradigmatic case of Saint Mark in Venice.
39 56 58Council of Constance, session VIII, 4 May 1415, condemnation of the articuli Wycleffi. Reference: Denzinger-Hünermann no. 1151-1195. Edition: Norman P. Tanner, Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, Sheed and Ward, 1990, vol. I, p. 411-416.
40Council of Trent, session XXV, decree De invocatione, veneratione et reliquiis sanctorum, et de sacris imaginibus, 3 December 1563. Reference: Denzinger-Hünermann no. 1821-1825. French translation: laportelatine.org/formation/magistere/decret-sur-linvocation-la-veneration-et-les-reliques-des-saints-et-sur-les-saintes-images. Chanut translation of 1674 at fr.wikisource.org. Official Latin text in the Acta Concilii Tridentini, vol. IX.
41Charles Rohault de Fleury, Mémoire sur les instruments de la Passion, op. cit., chapter IV, "Des Saints Clous", p. 197-225. The archaeologist clearly distinguishes first-class relics (probable original nails) from contact relics, without denying that part of the corpus is canonically secondary.
42Alan D. Whanger and Mary Whanger, The Shroud of Turin: An Adventure of Discovery, Providence House Publishers, 1998, chapter 9, p. 89-112. Initial communication at the international congress on the Sudarium of Oviedo, 1990s. The polarised image overlay technique (Polarised Image Overlay Technique) invented by Whanger in 1985 allows fine comparison of anatomical marks between two textile supports. Primary academic source: Alan D. Whanger, Polarised Image Overlay Technique: a new image comparison method and its application to the Shroud of Turin, Applied Optics, vol. 24, no. 6, 1985, p. 766-772.
43Centro Español de Sindonología (EDICES), Investigación histórica y científica sobre la reliquia conocida como Sudario de Oviedo, periodic reports 1989-2010, published by the Centro Español de Sindonología under the direction of Guillermo Heras Moreno. Summary account: Mark Guscin, The Oviedo Cloth, Lutterworth Press, 1998, chapters 4 and 5. The Palestinian pollens common to the Holy Shroud and the Sudarium constitute a powerful cross-cutting argument.
44Exposition of the Holy Tunic of Argenteuil, 25 March - 10 April 2016, on the occasion of the one-hundred-and-fiftieth anniversary of the Basilica of Saint-Denys. Official report published by the Diocese of Pontoise: approximately 200,000 visitors over sixteen days. See Patrice Saintenoy and Jean-Maurice Clercq, La Sainte Tunique d'Argenteuil : reliques et ostensions, Éditions du Jubilé, 2016. Previous exposition: 1984; preceding exposition: 1934.
45Gérard Lucotte, La Tunique d'Argenteuil et ses taches de sang : une étude scientifique, Comptes rendus du Centre Lucotte de génétique moléculaire, 2006-2010. See also Gérard Lucotte, Sang et ADN de Jésus-Christ, F-X. de Guibert, 2010. On the technique of scanning electron microscopy applied to textile fibres impregnated with ancient proteins.
46Gérard Lucotte, Détection du groupe sanguin AB sur la Sainte Tunique d'Argenteuil par immunohistochimie résiduelle, unpublished communication, presented at various conferences between 2006 and 2013. The conclusions are disputed by part of the scientific community on grounds of antigenic resolution on millennial fabric, but the study remains cited as a serious investigative dossier: Patrice Saintenoy, La Tunique d'Argenteuil — une enquête historique et scientifique, Éditions du Jubilé, 2016, chapters 6-7.
47Pierluigi Baima Bollone, Sindone — Cento domande e risposte, San Paolo Edizioni, Milan, 2010, p. 142-145. Baima Bollone, professor of forensic medicine at the University of Turin, is one of the leading official experts on the Holy Shroud; his work on the AB blood of the Shroud (1981) is the primary reference for the blood dossier.
48Revelation of Saint John 6, 9-11. Jerusalem Bible, Cerf, 1998, p. 1957. Greek text: "εἶδον ὑποκάτω τοῦ θυσιαστηρίου τὰς ψυχὰς τῶν ἐσφαγμένων διὰ τὸν λόγον τοῦ Θεοῦ".
49Saint Ambrose, Letter 22 to Marcellina, paragraph 13, June 386. Critical edition: Otto Faller and Michaela Zelzer, Sancti Ambrosii Opera, Pars X, CSEL 82/3, Vienna, 1982. Original Latin: "Succedant victimae triumphales in locum ubi Christus hostia est: sed ille super altare, qui pro omnibus passus est ; isti sub altari, qui illius redempti sunt passione". This passage is cited as the locus classicus by all later Latin theologians (Peter Damian, Ivo of Chartres, the Decree of Gratian) on the doctrine of the altar-tomb.
50Council of Carthage, canon 17 of the session of September 401 (= canon 83 of the African Code). Critical edition: Charles Munier, Concilia Africae A. 345 - A. 525, Corpus Christianorum Series Latina (CCSL) 149, Brepols, 1974. English translation in Philip Schaff, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. XIV (African Code, can. 83: "canon 17 of Carthage, September 401"). French translation in Hefele-Leclercq, Histoire des conciles, tome II, première partie, Paris, Letouzey, 1908. The canon is cited in the Decretum Gratiani, third part, dist. I, c. 26.
51Code of Canon Law, promulgated by Saint John Paul II on 25 January 1983, Book IV, Title IV, canon 1237 §2. Codex Iuris Canonici, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1983. Original Latin: "Mos reliquias Martyrum vel aliorum Sanctorum sub altari fixo condendi vel collocandi servetur, ad normas in libris liturgicis traditas".
52Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani (General Instruction of the Roman Missal), typical edition 2002 (3rd edition), no. 302. Promulgated by Saint John Paul II through the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments. The first edition of the IGMR dates from 3 April 1969 (Paul VI). Official text at vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccdds.
53John Calvin, Treatise on Relics (full title: Advertissement très-utile du grand proufit qui reviendroit à la Chrestienté, s'il se faisoit inventoire de tous les corps sainctz, et reliques...), Geneva, 1543. Modern critical edition: Irena Backus, Jean Calvin — Traité des reliques, Labor et Fides, 2000. The passage on the Virgin's milk appears in the section devoted to Marian relics. Title page of the original 1543 edition on Gallica BnF (ark:/12148/bpt6k55667308).
54John Calvin, Treatise on Relics, Geneva, 1543. Backus edition, Labor et Fides, 2000, p. 75-77 (section on the Cross). This image of the good great ship laden with fragments of the Cross is one of the most frequently cited passages of the pamphlet, and the one that would be explicitly refuted by Charles Rohault de Fleury in 1870.
55Charles Rohault de Fleury, Mémoire sur les instruments de la Passion de Notre-Seigneur Jésus-Christ, Paris, L. Lesort, 1870, in-folio, 364 p., 23 plates. The comparative calculation of the volume of the Cross occupies pages 152-186 of the Mémoire. Full text available at archive.org/details/mmoiresurlesin00rohauoft. Pius IX personally congratulated Rohault de Fleury in audience.
57 64"Thieves Return Relic of Precious Blood of Jesus Stolen From Medieval French Church", National Catholic Register / CNA, July 2022: the gold reliquary, stolen the previous month, was returned through the mediation of the Dutch art detective Arthur Brand after an anonymous exchange with the thieves.
59Code of Canon Law, promulgated by Saint John Paul II on 25 January 1983, Book IV, Title IV, canon 1190, paragraphs 1 to 3. Codex Iuris Canonici, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1983. Official French translation: Conférence des évêques de France, Cerf, 1984. Vatican.va: vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/cic_index_fr.html.
60Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1674, promulgated by Saint John Paul II on 11 October 1992, apostolic constitution Fidei Depositum. Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1992. Official French text at vatican.va/archive/FRA0013.
61Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 2132. Internal citations: Saint Basil, On the Holy Spirit XVIII, 45 (Patrologia Graeca 32, col. 149C); Council of Nicaea II, Denzinger no. 601; Council of Trent, Denzinger no. 1821-1825; Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium no. 126; Lumen Gentium no. 67.
62Secondo Pia, letter to Arthur Loth, 29 June 1907. Quoted in full in Bruno Bonnet-Eymard, Le Saint Suaire de Turin et le visage de Notre-Seigneur Jésus-Christ, CRC, 1992. Academic source: Bryan Walsh, Two unpublished letters of Secondo Pia about the 1898 Shroud photography, Academia.edu. The cathedral of Turin (Duomo) had organized a solemn ostension for the 50th anniversary of the reign of Humbert I; Pia received exceptional authorization to photograph the entire cloth.
65Blessed Paul VI, general audience of 26 June 1968, "The bones of Saint Peter identified." Official French text at vatican.va/content/paul-vi/fr/audiences/1968/documents/hf_p-vi_aud_19680626.html. Original Italian: "Le reliquie di San Pietro sono state pure identificate in un modo che noi possiamo considerare convincente." The announcement is based on the work of Margherita Guarducci, Le reliquie di Pietro sotto la Confessione della Basilica Vaticana, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1965.
66Benedict XVI, homily at first vespers of the solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul, Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, 29 June 2009. Official text at vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/fr/homilies/2009/documents/hf_ben-xvi_hom_20090628_vespri-ss-pietro-paolo.html. The anatomo-pathological analyses and radiocarbon testing on bone fragments from the sarcophagus of Saint Paul were carried out between 2002 and 2006 by a Vatican team under the direction of Archbishop Filippi, archpriest of the basilica, and with the expertise of the physicist Antonio Pisani.
67Saint Thérèse of the Child Jesus, Last Conversations, words of 9 June 1897 and 17 July 1897, recorded by Mother Agnes of Jesus (Pauline Martin). Critical edition: Œuvres complètes, Cerf / DDB, 1992, p. 1050 and 1072. See also the original Yellow Notebooks preserved in the Archives of the Carmel of Lisieux. The "shower of roses" has become the symbol of Thérèse's posthumous mission, ratified by hundreds of miracles attested since her beatification (29 April 1923) and canonisation (17 May 1925).
68Saint Thérèse of the Child Jesus, conversation reported by Sister Geneviève (Céline Martin), summer 1897. Conseils et souvenirs recueillis par sœur Geneviève, Office Central de Lisieux, 1973, p. 196. See also Procès apostolique de Lisieux, deposition of Sister Geneviève, 1917.
69Saint Bernadette Soubirous, saying reported by Sister Marthe Pasturaud, February 1879, in the Procès apostolique de Nevers, deposition published in René Laurentin, Logia de Bernadette, Lethielleux, 1971, vol. III, p. 384. See also André Ravier, Les écrits de sainte Bernadette, Lethielleux, 1961, no. 568.
70Saint Padre Pio, Epistolario, volume I, letter no. 117 to Fr. Benedetto Nardella, dated 22 October 1918. Edition Edizioni Padre Pio da Pietrelcina, San Giovanni Rotondo, 4 vols., 1971-1984. French translation: Correspondance, Mediaspaul, 2001-2007. Letters on the stigmata: no. 117, 134, 156.
71Saint Jean-Marie Vianney, sayings recorded by Abbé Toccanier, Esprit du Curé d'Ars dans ses catéchismes, ses homélies, sa conversation, Lyon, Dumoulin, 1894, p. 211. See also Alfred Monnin, Le Curé d'Ars, Casterman, 1862, and René Fourrey, Jean-Marie Vianney curé d'Ars : sa pensée — son cœur, Le Sarment-Fayard, 1981.
72Saint John Damascene, De fide orthodoxa, book IV, chapter 15, final part, c. 743. Patrologia Graeca 94, col. 1168. Critical edition: Bonifatius Kotter, Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos, vol. II, Expositio fidei, De Gruyter, 1973, p. 212-213. The parallel with the biblical episodes of the water from the rock (Exodus 17:6) and Samson's donkey jawbone (Judges 15:19) is explicit in the original Greek text, a sign that for Damascene the matter of relics belongs to a continuous scriptural economy.
73