The Miraculous Catch of Fish

After a night with nothing caught, Peter casts the nets at the word of Jesus: two boats filled in Luke 5, 153 large fish and the net unbroken in John 21, the call and restoration of the same apostle.

Ignispedia

The miraculous draught of fishes refers to two gospel accounts in which fishermen of Galilee, after an entire night without catching anything, fill their nets on the word of Jesus alone. The first account, in chapter 5 of the Gospel of Saint Luke, is set at the beginning of the public ministry: Simon Peter, who has toiled all night, casts the nets in broad daylight, confesses that he is a sinful man, then leaves everything to follow Jesus, who tells him that from now on he will be catching men[1]. The second account, in chapter 21 of the Gospel of Saint John, is set after the Resurrection: seven disciples have fished in vain, the Risen One stands on the shore without being recognised at first, the nets cast to the right of the boat bring in 153 large fish without tearing, and Jesus shares with his own the bread and the fish grilled over a charcoal fire[2].

The Church receives these two accounts as real events in the life of Jesus and in his Easter appearances, on a par with the miracle at Cana or the multiplication of the loaves. She also reads in them, since the Fathers, a vivid image of her own mission: the net cast upon the word of Christ gathers men from every nation, and this net, in the Easter account, does not break. This article presents first the two accounts verse by verse, then their place in the canon, their traditional authors and dating together with their early witnesses, the lake and the fishing trade that form their setting, their theology, their fulfilment in the whole of Scripture, the reading of the Fathers, their liturgical and spiritual use, and finally the objections of historical-critical exegesis with the responses that can be made to them.

The two accounts, step by step

The first draught: Luke 5, 1-11

The crowd by the lake and Simon's boat

Luke opens the account with the crowd pressing around Jesus to hear the word of God, on the shore of the lake of Gennesaret[3]. Two boats are there, the fishermen have got out of them and are washing their nets: the night's work is over, and it has brought nothing. Jesus gets into Simon's boat, asks him to put out a little from the shore, sits down and teaches the crowd from the boat[4]. The seated position is that of the master who teaches, and the boat becomes for a while the chair of the word.

This detail prepares what follows. The same boat that carried the word will carry the catch, and the same Simon who lent his boat will lend his nets, and then his whole life. Luke builds his account in three movements that the reader can follow effortlessly: the word taught, the word obeyed, the word that calls.

Put out into the deep

When the teaching is over, Jesus says to Simon: "Put out into the deep, and let down your nets for a catch"[5]. The order is given in broad daylight, after a night of fruitless work, to men who have known the lake since childhood. Net fishing on this lake was done at night, when the fish rise toward the surface and toward the lit areas, and by day the attempt was, in human terms, unpromising according to the fishermen's own knowledge.

Simon's reply is the human heart of the account: "Master, we have toiled all night without catching anything; but at your word I will let down the nets"[6]. Simon does not question Jesus' competence in matters of fishing, he does not claim to understand, he obeys a word. The whole spirituality of the miraculous draught of fishes lies in this "at your word": obedience does not come from a calculation of probabilities, it comes from trust in the one who speaks.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"Master, we have toiled all night without catching anything; but at your word I will let down the nets." (Gospel of Saint Luke, 5, 5[7])

The nets that tear and the two boats

The result exceeds the need: the fishermen catch such a great quantity of fish that their nets tear, they signal to their partners in the other boat, and the two boats fill up to the point of sinking[8]. Luke gives three concrete measures of the superabundance: the nets that break, the call for reinforcements, the boats that go down. The gift is real, material, verifiable by men of the trade, and it exceeds the ordinary capacity to contain it.

Note what Jesus does not do. He touches neither the nets nor the water, he pronounces no formula, he makes no ritual gesture. As at Cana, where he fills the jars of the Old Covenant, he acts by his word alone, in the manner of the Creator of Genesis who speaks and the thing is. The sign therefore points to its author: he who commands the fish of the lake as God commands his creation.

Depart from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man

At the sight of the catch, Simon Peter falls at Jesus' knees and says: "Depart from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man"[9]. The title changes on his lips: the one he called Master in verse 5, he now calls Lord. Astonishment seizes James and John too, the sons of Zebedee, Simon's partners, and all who are with them[10].

Peter's reaction is that of the men of the Bible before the manifestation of the holy God: Isaiah, before the vision of the Temple, cries out that he is a man of unclean lips (Is 6, 5)[11]. Peter does not ask for a share of the catch, he does not bargain, he confesses. It is precisely this confession that makes him fit for mission, for Jesus does not answer his request to depart; he answers with a call: "Do not be afraid, from now on it is men you will be catching"[12].

"Depart from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man." (Gospel of Saint Luke, 5, 8[13])

They left everything and followed him

Luke's conclusion is one of complete sobriety: bringing the boats back to shore, the fishermen leave everything and follow Jesus[14]. The "everything" includes the boats, the nets, the richest catch of their lives, and the family fishing business. The miracle is therefore not told for its own sake: it is the instrument of a vocation. The first miraculous draught of fishes is inseparable from the call of the first disciples, and this is how the Church has always read it.

The second draught: John 21, 1-14

I am going fishing, and a night without catching anything

After his Resurrection, Jesus appears again to the disciples on the shore of the Sea of Tiberias[15]. John names those present: Simon Peter, Thomas called Didymus, Nathanael of Cana in Galilee, the sons of Zebedee and two other disciples, seven in all[16]. Simon Peter says: "I am going fishing," the others answer: "We will go with you," they get into the boat, and that night they catch nothing[17].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The return to the former trade is not presented as a fault, but it forms the dark background of the account: without the Risen One recognised, the work of the disciples remains barren, like the night of Luke 5. The parallel between the two fruitless nights is intended by the Church's tradition of reading: the same lake, the same men, the same nocturnal failure, the same word that reverses the situation at daybreak.

Cast the net on the right side of the boat

At daybreak, Jesus stands on the shore, but the disciples do not know that it is he[18]. He asks them whether they have any fish, they answer that they do not, and he says: "Cast the net on the right side of the boat, and you will find some"[19]. They cast it, and they are no longer able to haul it in because of the great quantity of fish[20].

It is then that the disciple whom Jesus loved recognizes the Lord and says to Peter: "It is the Lord"[21]. Simon Peter, who had stripped himself for the work, puts on a garment and throws himself into the water to reach the shore swimming, while the other disciples return with the boat, towing the net, about a hundred metres from the shore[22]. John, who sees and who believes, points; Peter, who loves and who hastens, plunges. The two movements complement one another, and the Church has seen in them the relationship between contemplation that recognizes and action that rushes forth.

"Cast the net on the right side of the boat, and you will find some." (Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 6[23])

The charcoal fire, the bread, and the 153 large fish

On landing, the disciples see a charcoal fire with fish laid on it, and bread[24]. Jesus asks them to bring some of the fish they have just caught; Simon Peter climbs into the boat and drags the net ashore, full of 153 large fish, and despite their number the net is not torn[25]. Then Jesus invites them: "Come and have breakfast"; he takes the bread and gives it to them, and likewise the fish[26]. John specifies that this is the third time that Jesus, risen from the dead, has manifested himself to his disciples[27].

Three features distinguish this catch from the first. The fish are counted, and the number is given exactly: 153. They are large, all of them, with no sorting or discard mentioned. And the net, which was torn in Luke 5, is not torn. The Fathers have read in these three features an announcement of the Church gathered at the end of time, where the gathering will be complete and definitive. The section on the Fathers returns to this in detail.

"Simon Peter climbed back into the boat and dragged the net ashore. It was full of large fish, one hundred and fifty-three of them; and although there were so many, the net was not torn." (Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 11[28])

Two catches, one single Lord: the comparative table

The following table brings together the data of the two accounts as the evangelists give them. It is read in columns: each row compares the same element in the two catches, and the final column states what the comparison brings to light.

Element comparedLuke 5, 1-11John 21, 1-14What the comparison shows
Moment in the life of JesusBeginning of the public ministry, before the PassionAfter the Resurrection, Paschal apparitionThe same Lord calls at the beginning and sends at the end
Hour and prior workTeaching by day after a night of fishing told in the past tenseWhole night of fishing without catching anything, then daybreakIn both cases, human effort alone remains fruitless
Jesus' wordPut out into the deep, and let down your netsCast the net on the right side of the boat, and you will find someFruitfulness comes from obedience to the word, not from technique
Peter's reactionHe falls to his knees and confesses that he is a sinnerHe throws himself into the water to reach the recognized LordThe confessed sinner becomes the disciple who hastens
Quantity caughtA great quantity, no number given153 large fish, counted one by oneFrom overflowing abundance to the counted and completed gathering
State of the netThe nets are tornThe net is not torn despite the numberThe Church of the present time struggles, the accomplished Church loses nothing
BoatsTwo boats filled so far as to be sinkingOne boat, the net towed then dragged ashore by PeterThe mutual help of the Churches, then the unity of the final gathering
Outcome of the accountThey leave everything and follow JesusJesus gives the bread and the fish, the meal of the Risen OneThe vocation first, the Paschal communion afterwards
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

This table does not merge the two accounts into one: it shows why the Church reads them together without confusing them. They are two distinct events, at two distinct moments, with distinct details that the evangelists kept distinct. Their resemblance comes from the unity of the one who acts and of the mission he entrusts, not from a copy of one upon the other.

The place of the two catches of fish in the canon

In the Gospel of Luke: the call at the threshold of the ministry

Luke places the first catch of fish in chapter 5, right after the beginning of the preaching in Galilee and the healing of Simon's mother-in-law (Lk 4:38-39)[29], and right before the healing of the leper and the paralytic. In his plan, this account holds the place that Mark and Matthew give to the call of the four fishermen by the Sea of Galilee (Mk 1:16-20; Mt 4:18-22)[30], but Luke develops it into a true vocation narrative: teaching, sign, confession, call, following Christ. The reader understands from the outset who Peter is — a forgiven sinner who has been called — before following him throughout the gospel and then in the Acts of the Apostles, Luke's second volume.

Luke's vocabulary is precise. He calls the lake the "Lake of Gennesaret," the local name for the basin, where Mark and John say "Sea of Galilee" or "Sea of Tiberias"[31]. He speaks of Simon's partners, James and John, a detail of working arrangements that corresponds to a family fishing business with hired workers, such as Mark also mentions for the sons of Zebedee (Mk 1:20)[32]. These concrete touches belong to the received account, and the Church reads them as the traces of a testimony rooted in the milieu of the fishermen of Capernaum and Bethsaida.

In the Gospel of John: the Easter epilogue and the mission

John places the second catch of fish in chapter 21, after the account of the Resurrection in chapter 20 and its first conclusion: "Jesus did many other signs in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book" (Jn 20:30)[33]. Chapter 21 forms the epilogue of the gospel: an appearance by the lake, an abundant catch of fish, a meal, then Jesus' dialogue with Peter about love and the flock (Jn 21:15-19) and a word about the beloved disciple (Jn 21:20-23)[34]. The catch of fish opens this epilogue as Cana opened the book of signs: with a sign of superabundance that reveals who Jesus is.

The last verse of the gospel claims the origin of the testimony: "It is this disciple who testifies to these things and has written them, and we know that his testimony is true" (Jn 21:24)[35]. The miraculous catch of John 21 therefore belongs to the testimony that the gospel attributes to the disciple whom Jesus loved, and whom tradition identifies with the apostle John. The question of the appendix, raised by part of modern exegesis, is treated at the end of the article together with its answers.

The canonical reception of the two books

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In the Catholic canon, the Gospels of Luke and of John are received as inspired Scripture on the same footing as Matthew and Mark: the Council of Trent, in its session IV on 8 April 1546, fixed the list of sacred books received by the Church, the four Gospels included, and Vatican I confessed that these books, written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, have God as their author[36]. The two accounts of the catch of fish therefore belong to the Word of God read in the Church, and not to a pious tradition added afterwards. Their double attestation, in a synoptic and in John, at two different moments in the life of Jesus, forms part of the way the Church receives them: not as an embarrassing duplicate, but as two signs that the same Lord gave at the beginning and at the end of his visible presence.

The authors, traditional dating and ancient witnesses

Luke, companion of Paul, author of the third gospel and of Acts

The tradition of the Church attributes the third gospel to Luke, the physician and companion of Saint Paul. Paul himself names him "Luke, the beloved physician" (Col 4:14) and counts him among his fellow workers (Phlm 24; 2 Tim 4:11)[37]. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, around 180, presents Luke as Paul's inseparable companion, who set down in a book the gospel preached by the apostle[38]. The prologue of the gospel declares the author's method: after having carefully investigated everything from the origins among the eyewitnesses who became servants of the word, he wrote an orderly account so that the reader might recognise the soundness of the teachings received (Lk 1:1-4)[39].

Traditional dating places the writing in the wake of the apostolic preaching, in the first century, before the end of the first Christian generation. The second volume, the Acts of the Apostles, ends with Paul preaching in Rome without his trial being recounted (Acts 28:30-31)[40], a silence that traditional reading has often noted: the author stops where his account leads him, in the years of Paul's Roman captivity. Part of contemporary exegesis proposes a later dating and discusses Luke's relationship to the other synoptics. These hypotheses are presented at the end of the article. They eliminate neither the testimony of the prologue, nor the ancient and unanimous attribution to Luke, nor the reception of his book as Scripture.

John, the beloved apostle, author of the fourth gospel

Tradition attributes the fourth gospel to Saint John, son of Zebedee, one of the Twelve, present in both accounts of the catch of fish as a son of Zebedee associated with Peter in Luke 5 and as a fisherman among the group of seven in John 21[41]. Saint Irenaeus, trained by Polycarp who had known John, writes that John, the disciple of the Lord, published his gospel during his stay at Ephesus[42]. The gospel itself designates its guarantor as the disciple whom Jesus loved, witness of the cross, of the empty tomb and of the appearances (Jn 19:26-35; 20:2-8; 21:7.20-24)[43].

Traditional dating places the writing at the end of the first century, during the lifetime of the witnesses of the first generation. This early but not late dating in the sense of modern reconstructions rests on the chain of ancient witnesses recalled below. It has never meant for the Church that the gospel would be a mere transcript: John himself says that he has chosen his signs so that the reader may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God (Jn 20:31)[44]. An account chosen and ordered with a view to faith remains, in the Catholic reading, a true account of real events.

The ancient witnesses of the two gospels

The following table brings together the material and patristic witnesses that carry the two books in which the catches of fish appear. It is read from top to bottom, from the oldest fragments towards the explicit patristic attestations.

WitnessApproximate dateWhat it attests
Papyrus P52 (fragment of John 18)First half of the 2nd centuryThe fourth gospel was already circulating in Egypt a generation after its traditional composition
Papyrus P75 (Luke and John)Late 2nd or early 3rd centuryThe Gospels of Luke and of John brought together in a single ancient codex, with a carefully copied text
Papyrus P66 (John almost complete)Around 200The fourth gospel transmitted as a complete book, read and corrected by its copyists
Tatian, DiatessaronAround 170The four Gospels, including Luke and John, harmonised into a single account, and thus already received together
Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against HeresiesAround 180Explicit attribution of Luke to Paul's companion and of John to the apostle of Ephesus
Muratorian CanonLate 2nd centuryLuke the physician and John the apostle named as the authors of the third and fourth gospels

These witnesses do not by themselves prove every verse, but they establish the decisive fact for traditional reading: the books of Luke and of John did not arise anonymously in the middle of the second century to be attributed to apostles afterwards. They circulate early, together, with their attributions, in Churches that kept the memory of the witnesses. It is on this reception that the Church's confidence in the two accounts of the catch of fish rests.

The position of the magisterium

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The magisterium has never treated these attributions as free opinions without weight. The Council of Trent received the four Gospels into the canon with their traditional authors, Vatican I confessed God as the author of the sacred books, and the constitution Dei Verbum of Vatican II teaches that the Gospels faithfully transmit what Jesus did and taught, the evangelists having chosen and ordered their material while preserving the truth of the testimony[45]. The Catholic reading therefore holds together both affirmations: real human authorship, with the choices, style and arrangement proper to Luke and John, and the truth of the events recounted, including the two miraculous catches of fish.

The lake, the boats, and the fisherman's trade

The Lake of Gennesaret, Sea of Galilee, Sea of Tiberias

The lake where Simon and his partners fish bears three names in the Gospels: Lake of Gennesaret in Luke, Sea of Galilee in Matthew and Mark, Sea of Tiberias in John, after the town founded by Herod Antipas on its western shore[46]. It is a freshwater lake fed by the Jordan, about 21 kilometres long and about 13 wide, its surface lying more than 200 metres below sea level[47]. Its northern shores, around Capernaum and Bethsaida, formed the most active fishing zone, and the lake's fish, fresh or salted and dried at Magdala, supplied a trade that extended beyond Galilee.

First-century boat discovered near Ginosar in 1986, preserved at the Yigal Allon Museum. Photograph by Yong Woo Park, Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

This setting is no vague backdrop. The evangelists name the fishing villages, the partners, the boats in the plural, the nets that are washed, the hired men of the sons of Zebedee. In 1986, archaeologists uncovered in the mud of the north-west shore near Magdala a first-century Galilean fishing boat, about 8 metres long, now preserved at Kibbutz Ginosar[48]. It does not prove the catch of Luke 5, but it shows concretely the kind of vessel that could carry a dozen men and be in danger of sinking under an exceptional load.

Fishing at night, washing the nets at morning

Net fishing on the lake was practised mostly at night: the fish, notably the lake's schools of sardines and tilapias, can be approached in the darkness, and the fishermen worked with the net cast from the boat or dragged between two boats[49]. In the morning, the nets were washed and mended, the very gesture with which Luke opens his account: the night is over, the work is put away, the failure is complete. It is at precisely this moment, and not in the enthusiasm of a promising night, that Jesus asks them to put out into deep water.

The precision of the account in John 21 is of the same kind: net cast on the right, a distance of about two hundred cubits, or some hundred metres from shore, the net towed behind the boat and then hauled ashore by Peter alone[50]. These measurements are not symbolic ornaments added afterwards: they are the gestures and distances of the trade, recounted by men who had practised it or by those who had the account from them.

Why the sign speaks first to fishermen

The Sea of Galilee on a survey by Anderson and Kitchener published around 1882. Magdala and Tiberias are named on this map; the plain of Gennesaret and Tell Hum, the site of Capernaum, also appear on it. This nineteenth-century document does not settle the debated location of Bethsaida. National Library of Israel, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain. Image reduced without displacing locations.

Jesus chooses fishermen, and he confirms them in their trade before transfiguring it. He despises neither the nets nor the night's work: he gets into the boat, he teaches from the boat, he fills the boats. The mission he announces takes up the very word of the trade: to catch. "From now on it is men you will catch" says the Greek with a word that evokes the capturing of living beings in order to keep them alive, a nuance commentators have noted since antiquity[51]. The net of the gospel word does not kill its catch: it draws it from the water of death into life.

What the Two Catches Reveal: The Theology of the Sign

The Word That Makes Sterile Labour Fruitful

The first teaching of the two accounts is the relationship between human effort and the word of Christ. The fishermen are neither lazy nor incompetent: they have toiled all night, and they know the depths, the hours and the shoals. Their fruitless night is not a fault; it is the ordinary condition of human work left to itself. Fruitfulness comes when the same technique, the same nets and the same arms obey a word that comes from elsewhere. The Church has always refused to turn this into a recipe for temporal success: the same Peter who fills two boats will know prison, the scattering of the faithful and martyrdom. Fishing teaches apostolic fruitfulness, which is measured by the men gathered for the Kingdom, not by immediate visible success.

Peter the Sinner, Peter the Called, Peter the Sent

Peter runs through both accounts as their common thread. In Luke 5, he confesses his sin and receives the promise of a catch of men. Between the two accounts, he has followed Jesus, confessed that he is the Christ, denied him three times by a charcoal fire (Jn 18, 18.25-27)[52], and run to the empty tomb. In John 21, he finds again a charcoal fire, a full net, and the Lord who, just after the meal, will ask him three times whether he loves him and entrust his sheep to him (Jn 21, 15-17)[53]. The Paschal catch is therefore not a nostalgic repetition of the first call: it is the rehabilitation of the sinner who has become a pastor. He who had said "depart from me" will hear "be the shepherd of my sheep". Mercy does not abolish the mission; it grounds it.

"Do not be afraid; from now on you will be catching men." (Gospel according to Saint Luke, 5, 10[54])

The 153 Large Fish and the Net That Does Not Tear

John counts: 153 large fish. Two ancient readings have dominated, and the Church has kept both of them without making them dogmas. Saint Jerome reports that ancient naturalists counted 153 known species of fish: the net that gathers them all would figure the gathering of all nations into the Church[55]. Saint Augustine observes that 153 is the sum of the numbers from 1 to 17, and that 17 unites the ten commandments and the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit: the number would figure the totality of the elect gathered by the Law fulfilled in grace[56]. These symbolic readings presuppose the real fact they comment upon: a net actually hauled ashore, fish actually counted by fishermen for whom counting the catch was the gesture of their trade and the basis of sharing and selling.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The net that does not tear, unlike in Luke 5, struck all the ancient commentators. Augustine sets the two accounts side by side: before the Resurrection, the nets break because the Church of the present time receives good and bad and knows tears; after the Resurrection, the Paschal net does not break because the final gathering will lose none of those the Father has given to the Son[57]. The meal that follows, bread and fish given by the Risen Christ with his own hands, completes the sign in communion: the disciples do not possess their catch as plunder, they receive it at the table of the Lord.

The Fulfilment in the Whole of Scripture

The two catches fulfil and turn around several figures of the Old Testament. God had announced through Jeremiah: "I am sending for many fishers, says the Lord, and they shall catch them" (Jer 16, 16), a word of gathering after judgement[58]. Ezekiel, in his vision of the waters flowing from the Temple and healing the sea, sees fishermen spreading their nets from En-gedi to En-eglaim and catching fish of every kind, like those of the Great Sea (Ez 47, 9-10)[59]. Jesus, who calls fishermen to catch men and who fills the net with every counted species, brings these figures about beyond their first meaning: the net of the Gospel goes from the Sea of Galilee to all the nations.

The comparison with the miracle of Cana also illuminates the superabundance. At Cana, the wine kept for the end surpasses the wine of the beginning; at the lake, the catch given on the word surpasses a whole night of labour. In both cases, the Johannine sign and the Lucan sign speak of the same superabundance of God's gift, which is not measured by strict need. And the parable of the net, proper to Matthew, gives the ecclesial reading that the Fathers will apply to the two catches: the Kingdom is like a net that gathers fish of every kind, good and bad together until the sorting at the end (Mt 13, 47-50)[60].

The Church Fathers Read the Two Catches of Fish

Saint Augustine: the torn nets and the intact net

Augustine comments on the two accounts in his Harmony of the Gospels and in his Tractates on the Gospel of John, and he refuses to blend them together: Luke tells of the catch at the beginning, John of the one after the Resurrection, and the difference in the nets forms part of the teaching[61]. Before the Passion, the nets tear under the multitude, because the present Church mingles good and bad and suffers divisions. After the Resurrection, the net cast on the right side — the side Scripture associates with salvation — brings in only large fish and does not tear, a figure of the final gathering in which nothing will be lost[62]. His reading of the number 153, through the sum of 1 to 17, unites Law and grace in the totality of the saved[63].

Augustine thus sets in direct opposition the nets that broke in Luke 5 and the net that, despite the number, was not broken in John 21: the comparison is his own, and his entire ecclesial reading of the two catches flows from it[64].

Saint John Chrysostom and Saint Cyril: recognizing the Lord

John Chrysostom, in his homilies on the Gospel of John, notes the delicacy of the Risen One who stands on the shore, questions without imposing himself, feeds before questioning Peter, and lets himself be recognized only by the sign of the full net, just as he had made himself known to the disciples of Emmaus at the breaking of the bread[65]. Cyril of Alexandria, in his Commentary on John, reads the paschal catch as the figure of the mission entrusted to the apostles after the Resurrection: the net of apostolic teaching, cast into the sea of the world at Christ's command, gathers the nations without tearing, because the one who orders the catch guarantees its completion[66]. In both Fathers, symbolism never replaces the event: it unfolds it, because the event took place and carries a meaning intended by its author.

Saint Jerome and the net of all nations

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Jerome, commenting on Ezekiel and his vision of the fishers of the Temple river, reports the ancient tally of fish species and applies it to the net of John 21: every known species enters the net, just as every nation enters the preaching of the apostles[67]. The reading has come down through the centuries because it states the universality of the mission in the words of the trade: a net that does not select in advance, a catch whose sorting does not belong to the fishers. It joins the parable of the net in Matthew 13 and the words of Peter himself in the Acts, when he understands that God welcomes, in every nation, whoever fears him and does what is right (Acts 10:34–35)[68].

The Two Catches of Fish in Prayer and the Life of the Church

The Lectionary: Luke 5 in Year C, John 21 within the Octave of Easter

The Church solemnly rereads these two accounts each year. Luke 5:1–11 is the gospel of the fifth Sunday of Ordinary Time in Year C, paired in the lectionary with the vocation of Isaiah (Is 6) and Paul's hymn to the transmitted Resurrection (1 Cor 15): three vocations, three men seized by the holiness of God who sends them[69]. John 21:1–14 is read on the Friday within the octave of Easter, during the week in which the Church rereads an appearance of the Risen One each day[70]. The liturgy thus places the first catch on the path of vocations and the second in the paschal light, exactly at the two places the accounts occupy in the gospels.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI
  1. Around 28
    The first catch and the call (Lk 5:1–11)

    Jesus teaches from Simon's boat, orders him to put out into the deep, fills both boats, receives Peter's confession and calls him to catch men. James and John leave everything and follow him.

  2. Around 28–30
    Fishers become apostles

    The former fishermen of Galilee preach, heal, and gather the crowds in Israel, then, after Pentecost, carry the Gospel beyond the lake and the land, according to Luke's second volume, the Acts of the Apostles.

  3. Around 30
    The paschal catch and the meal (Jn 21:1–14)

    Seven disciples fish in vain through the night; the Risen One has the net filled with 153 large fish without its tearing, and then gives them bread and fish on the shore of Tiberias.

  4. 6 January 2001
    Duc in altum, the call of John Paul II

    At the threshold of the third millennium, Saint John Paul II opens his apostolic letter Novo millennio ineunte with the word of Jesus to Simon, Put out into the deep, and makes it the programme of the Church for the millennium beginning.

Duc in altum: put out into the deep

On 6 January 2001, at the close of the Great Jubilee of the year 2000, Saint John Paul II signed the apostolic letter Novo millennio ineunte, At the Beginning of the New Millennium. He opens it with the very account of Luke 5: hearts, he writes, resonate with the word of Jesus inviting the apostle to put out into the deep for a catch, Duc in altum (Lk 5:4), and Peter and his companions, trusting in the word of Christ, cast the nets[71]. The Pope sees in this the gesture of the whole Church after the Jubilee: not settling into a tally of labours, but setting out again from Christ and casting the nets.

« Duc in altum! This word rings out for us today, and it invites us to remember the past with gratitude, to live the present with passion and to look forward to the future with confidence. » (Saint John Paul II, apostolic letter Novo millennio ineunte, 6 January 2001, no. 1[72])

A school of prayer and mission for the faithful

The spirituality of the miraculous catch rests on four gestures that the faithful of every age can make their own. To listen to the word from the borrowed boat — that is, to give Christ the concrete place in one's life and work. To obey his word when the night has been fruitless, without demanding to understand the result in advance. To confess one's sin like Peter, instead of bargaining with the sign. And to leave what must be left in order to follow, or, after the fall, to throw oneself into the water like the Peter of John 21 to reach the Lord who waits on the shore. The holy fishers of God, from the apostles to the missionaries, have lived by these four gestures, and the fishing continues whenever a Christian casts the net of the word into waters where he would not have dared to fish alone.

This spiritual reading does not turn the account into a free allegory. It starts from the event told by Luke and John, it follows the reading of the Fathers and of the liturgy, and it arrives at imitation. This is the very order of the lectio divina that the Church practices on these pages: the event, its meaning, and the life that flows from it.

Objections and the Historico-Critical Debate

Part of contemporary exegesis proposes reading the two catches of fish other than as the Church has received them. These readings deserve to be set out fairly, then examined, for no objection should be left unanswered.

Objection 1: John 21 would be an added appendix, and therefore the second catch would be a late construction

Chapter 20 of John ends with a sentence that looks like the end of a book (Jn 20:30–31), and part of exegesis infers from this that chapter 21 was added afterwards by a redactor, which would make the Paschal catch suspect. Three answers hold. First, no ancient manuscript of John stops at chapter 20: the papyri and the great codices transmit the Gospel with its chapter 21, and no witness knows a John without the epilogue[73]. Next, an epilogue added by the evangelist himself or by his immediate circle, while the witnesses were still alive, is not a late invention: the final verse attributes the testimony to the beloved disciple and has it guaranteed by the community that receives it (Jn 21:24), which presupposes controlled transmission, not a free legend[74]. Finally, the patristic tradition receives the whole chapter without hesitation, and Irenaeus knows the Gospel of John as a whole. The appendix hypothesis describes at most a stage of composition; it proves neither the falsity of the account nor its fabrication.

Objection 2: the two catches would be a single event told twice

The first catch in Luke 5, distinct from the Paschal catch of John 21. Cartoon by Raphael for a tapestry, c. 1515. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The resemblances between Luke 5 and John 21 (a fruitless night, a word, a full net, Peter at the centre) lead some exegetes to propose that a single event was placed by Luke at the beginning of the ministry and by John after the Resurrection. But the differences are at least as strong as the resemblances: nets that tear apart against an intact net, two boats against one, no number against 153 counted fish, a call to follow against a Paschal meal, Peter asking the Lord to depart against Peter throwing himself into the water to reach him. An account duplicated by copying tends to preserve the striking details; here, the striking details are precisely the ones that differ. Augustine, who knew both texts by heart, ruled in favour of two distinct events whose resemblance is willed by the Lord himself, who repeats on the shore of the same lake, with the same men, the sign of their vocation in order to confirm it after the Resurrection[75]. The traditional reading holds to this position: it explains both the resemblance and the difference, whereas the duplicate hypothesis must explain why the copyist would have changed all the verifiable details.

Objection 3: an abundance of fish would be explained by a natural phenomenon of the lake

A natural explanation is sometimes proposed: a shoal of fish passing by chance, or, in recent limnological studies on the Sea of Galilee, fish surfacing linked to oxygen-poor zones that drive them towards the surface and the shore[76]. These phenomena exist on this lake, and no one needs to deny them. Yet they do not explain the account as it is written: the exact coincidence between the word given, the side of the boat indicated, the net cast once after a sleepless night by local professionals, and the catch that follows immediately. Above all, the natural explanation shifts the question without removing it: for the disciples, the sign is not the presence of fish in a fish-filled lake, but the word that finds them there at the hour, the place and the gesture it designates. John's account adds that this catch leads to the recognition of the Risen One and to his meal, which no shoal of fish explains. Presenting the natural phenomenon as if it refuted the account already presupposes that the word of Christ cannot command his creation: that is a presupposition, not a conclusion.

Objection 4: the number 153 would be an invented symbol, therefore the account would be an allegory

The exact number has given rise to many constructions, from the soundest to the most fanciful. From this it is sometimes concluded that the whole account would be an allegory composed around a symbolic number. The reverse reasoning is more correct. Counting the fish is the ordinary gesture of fishermen who share and sell their catch; it is even the only number of fish given in the Gospels, and its precision struck ancient readers precisely because it smells of a real count, made on the shore by men of the trade. The symbolic readings of Augustine and Jerome come after the fact and presuppose it: one seeks the meaning of a number only because a witness has transmitted it as the count of a real catch. That a real fact also carries a spiritual meaning is the ordinary way of Scripture, which tells of the Exodus, the manna or the bronze serpent as facts before unfolding their figure. The symbol does not abolish the event; it crowns it.

Objection 5: Luke would have composed his vocation account from separate traditions

For Luke 5, part of exegesis proposes that Luke combined a summary call of the first disciples, parallel to Mark 1, with an account of a miraculous catch of fish that came from elsewhere, close to John 21. This reconstruction rests on the comparison of the texts with one another, not on any document that can be shown: no manuscript, no earlier written source presents the separate pieces that the hypothesis assembles. Luke declares in his prologue that he has followed everything carefully from the beginnings with the witnesses (Lk 1:1–4): the hypothesis asks us to believe that he did the opposite and fabricated the scene in which Peter receives his vocation, a scene that the rest of his work, Acts, presupposes as accomplished everywhere in the person of Peter, first preacher at Pentecost and fisher of men before the Sanhedrin as before the house of Cornelius (Acts 2; 10)[77]. The late dating of Luke, where it is proposed, rests largely on this kind of circular reconstruction: the text is dated by the theory one has built up while reading it, and then the date is invoked to validate the theory. The traditional position, attribution to Luke the companion of Paul and an ordered account drawn from the witnesses, remains defensible point by point, and it is this that the Church has received.

What the debate leaves standing

At the end of the examination, the objections reach the reconstructions proposed around the texts, not the texts themselves in their attestation: two distinct accounts, transmitted early, received by the Fathers as two events, carried by two Gospels whose ancient attribution has not been seriously replaced. The reader may therefore hold, with the Church, that Peter cast his nets into the deep at the beginning of the ministry and that the net of the 153 fish was hauled ashore on the morning of Easter. Upon this twofold catch, the Lord founded a vocation, restored a fallen apostle, and traced in advance the gathering of his Church. It remains for the fishers of today to go forward, on his word, into the deep.

To go further

Notes and References

  1. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 5:1–11: account of the first miraculous catch of fish and the calling of Simon, James and John.

    1
  2. Gospel according to Saint John, 21:1–14: appearance of the Risen One on the shore of the Sea of Tiberias, the catch of 153 large fish and the meal of bread and fish.

    2
  3. Lk 5:1: the crowd presses around Jesus to hear the word of God, on the shore of the Lake of Gennesaret.

    3
  4. Lk 5:2-3: two boats by the shore, the fishermen are washing their nets, Jesus teaches the crowd seated in Simon's boat.

    4
  5. Lk 5:4: "Put out into the deep, and let down your nets for a catch," in liturgical Latin Duc in altum.

    5
  6. Lk 5:5: Simon's reply, a night of toil without catching anything and obedience at the word of Jesus.

    6 7
  7. Lk 5:6-7: a great number of fish, nets tearing, a sign to the partners, two boats filled to the point of sinking.

    8
  8. Lk 5:8: Simon Peter falls at the knees of Jesus and confesses that he is a sinful man.

    9 13
  9. Lk 5:9: amazement seizes Simon, James and John the sons of Zebedee, and all their companions.

    10
  10. Is 6:5: Isaiah, before the vision of the Lord in the Temple, cries out that he is a man of unclean lips.

    11
  11. Lk 5:10: "Do not be afraid; from now on you will be catching men."

    12 54
  12. Lk 5:11: the fishermen bring the boats back to shore, leave everything and follow Jesus.

    14
  13. Jn 21:1: Jesus reveals himself again to the disciples on the shore of the Sea of Tiberias.

    15
  14. Jn 21:2: Simon Peter, Thomas called the Twin, Nathanael of Cana, the sons of Zebedee and two other of his disciples, seven in all.

    16
  15. Jn 21:3: "I am going fishing," they got into the boat and a night without catching anything.

    17
  16. Jn 21:4: at daybreak, Jesus stood on the shore, though the disciples did not recognize him.

    18
  17. Jn 21:5-6: a question about fish, a negative answer, an order to cast the net on the right side of the boat.

    19
  18. Jn 21:6: "Cast the net on the right side of the boat, and you will find," the net impossible to haul in because of the number of fish.

    20 23
  19. Jn 21:7: the disciple whom Jesus loved said to Peter, "It is the Lord," Peter threw himself into the water.

    21
  20. Jn 21:7-8: Peter reaches the shore by swimming, the other disciples come back towing the net, about a hundred metres from the shore.

    22
  21. Jn 21:9: on landing, the disciples see a charcoal fire with fish on it, and bread.

    24
  22. Jn 21:10-11: Peter hauls ashore the net full of 153 large fish, without the net tearing.

    25
  23. Jn 21:12-13: "Come and have breakfast," Jesus took the bread and gave it to them, and so with the fish.

    26
  24. Jn 21:14: third manifestation of the risen Jesus to his disciples, according to John's count.

    27
  25. Jn 21:11: the count of the 153 large fish and the intact net.

    28
  26. Lk 4:38-39: the healing of Simon's mother-in-law, just before the account of the catch in Luke's arrangement.

    29
  27. Mk 1:16-20 and Mt 4:18-22: the calling of the four fishermen by the Sea of Galilee in Mark and Matthew.

    30
  28. The lake is called the Lake of Gennesaret in Lk 5:1, the Sea of Galilee in Mk 1:16, the Sea of Tiberias in Jn 21:1.

    31
  29. Mk 1:20: James and John in the boat with Zebedee their father and the hired servants, a sign of an organized fishing business.

    32
  30. Jn 20:30: many other signs not written in this book, a first conclusion before the epilogue of chapter 21.

    33
  31. Jn 21:15-23: dialogue with Peter about love and the flock, then a word about the beloved disciple, which follows immediately after the meal of the catch.

    34
  32. Jn 21:24: the disciple who testifies to these things and has written them, testimony received as true.

    35
  33. Council of Trent, session IV, decree on the canonical Scriptures, 8 April 1546; Vatican I, dogmatic constitution Dei Filius, chapter 2, 24 April 1870 (DS 3006): the holy books written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit have God as their author.

    36
  34. Col 4:14: "Luke, the beloved physician"; Phlm 24 and 2 Tim 4:11: Luke counted among Paul's fellow workers.

    37
  35. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, book III, chapter 1: Luke, a companion of Paul, set down in a book the gospel preached by Paul.

    38
  36. Lk 1:1-4: Luke's prologue, careful inquiry among the eyewitnesses and an orderly account for the certainty of the teaching received.

    39
  37. Acts 28:30-31: Paul stayed two years in Rome and proclaimed the Kingdom without the account giving the outcome of his trial.

    40
  38. James and John, sons of Zebedee, are named among the fishermen in Lk 5:10 and Jn 21:2.

    41
  39. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, book III, chapter 1: John, the disciple of the Lord, published his gospel during his stay in Ephesus; Irenaeus held the tradition of Polycarp, a disciple of John.

    42
  40. The disciple whom Jesus loved at the foot of the cross and witness of the pierced side (Jn 19:26-35), at the empty tomb (Jn 20:2-8), at the recognition of the Risen One at the lake (Jn 21:7).

    43
  41. Jn 20:31: these signs have been written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name.

    44
  42. Vatican II, dogmatic constitution Dei Verbum, no. 19, 18 November 1965: the four gospels faithfully transmit what Jesus did and taught, the evangelists having selected and arranged their material.

    45
  43. Tiberias, a town founded by Herod Antipas on the western shore of the lake, gives its Johannine name to the Sea of Galilee (Jn 6:1; 21:1).

    46
  44. The Sea of Galilee, fed by the Jordan, is about 21 kilometres long and 13 wide, with a surface more than 200 metres below the level of the Mediterranean Sea.

    47
  45. A first-century Galilean fishing boat discovered in 1986 near Magdala, about 8 metres long, kept at Kibbutz Ginosar (Yigal Allon Museum).

    48
  46. Net fishing on the Sea of Galilee was done at night, with cast or dragged nets, especially for the shoals of sardines and lake tilapias; in the morning the nets were washed and mended (Lk 5:2).

    49
  47. Jn 21:8: the disciples were only about two hundred cubits from the shore, some hundred metres; Jn 21:11: Peter hauls the net ashore alone.

    50
  48. Lk 5:10: the Greek verb translated as "take" evokes the catching of living beings in order to keep them alive, a nuance noted by ancient and modern commentators on the passage.

    51
  49. Jn 18:18.25-27: Peter warms himself by a charcoal fire in the high priest's courtyard and denies the Lord three times, an echo noted by the Fathers with the charcoal fire of Jn 21:9.

    52
  50. Jn 21:15-17: after the meal of the catch, Jesus asks Peter three times if he loves him and entrusts lambs and sheep to him.

    53
  51. Saint Jerome, Commentary on Ezekiel, on Ez 47: ancient naturalists counted 153 species of fish, a reading applied by tradition to the net of Jn 21 as a figure of the gathering of all nations.

    55
  52. Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 122, on Jn 21: 153 as the sum of the numbers from 1 to 17, the ten commandments and the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit.

    56
  53. Saint Augustine, Harmony of the Gospels and Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 122: bringing together Lk 5 (torn nets) and Jn 21 (intact net) as figures of the present Church and the fulfilled Church.

    57
  54. Jer 16, 16: "I am sending for many fishermen, says the Lord, and they shall catch them," a word of gathering following the announcement of judgement.

    58
  55. Ez 47, 9-10: the waters flowing from the Temple heal the sea, the fishermen spread their nets and take fish of every kind.

    59
  56. Mt 13, 47-50: parable of the net that gathers fish of every kind, good and bad alike, until the sorting at the end of time.

    60
  57. Saint Augustine, On the Agreement of the Evangelists (Harmony of the Gospels), bringing together the accounts of Lk 5 and Jn 21 held to be two distinct events.

    61
  58. Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 122, on Jn 21: the net cast on the right and not torn, a figure of the definitive gathering of the elect.

    62
  59. The same reading in Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 122, on Jn 21:11.

    63
  60. Saint Augustine, comparison of Lk 5, 6 and Jn 21, 11 in his Harmony of the Gospels and Treatise 122 on John: wording summarising his comparison of the torn nets and the intact net.

    64
  61. Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Gospel of John, homilies on Jn 21: the delicacy of the Risen Christ on the shore, the sign of the full net and the meal given to the disciples.

    65
  62. Saint Cyril of Alexandria, Commentary on the Gospel of John, Book XII, on Jn 21: the net of apostolic teaching cast into the sea of the world gathers the nations without being torn.

    66
  63. Saint Jerome, Commentary on Ezekiel, on Ez 47, 9-10: the fishermen of the river of the Temple and the ancient count of the species of fish.

    67
  64. Acts 10, 34-35: Peter, at Cornelius's house, understands that God welcomes, in every nation, the one who fears him and does what is right.

    68
  65. Roman Lectionary: Lk 5, 1-11, gospel of the fifth Sunday in Ordinary Time (Year C), with Is 6, 1-8 and 1 Cor 15, 1-11.

    69
  66. Roman Lectionary: Jn 21, 1-14, gospel of Friday within the Octave of Easter.

    70
  67. Saint John Paul II, apostolic letter Novo millennio ineunte, 6 January 2001, no. 1: opening on Lk 5, 4, Duc in altum, Peter and his companions casting their nets at the word of Christ. Text on vatican.va.

    71
  68. Saint John Paul II, Novo millennio ineunte, no. 1, 6 January 2001: "Duc in altum!", memory of the past, passion for the present and trust in the future. Text on vatican.va.

    72
  69. No ancient manuscript of the fourth gospel ends at Jn 20: the papyri P66 and P75 and the great codices transmit the gospel with chapter 21.

    73
  70. Jn 21, 24: the testimony of the beloved disciple guaranteed by the community that receives it, "we know that his testimony is true."

    74
  71. Saint Augustine, Harmony of the Gospels: Lk 5 and Jn 21 held to be two distinct catches of fish, at the beginning of the ministry and after the Resurrection.

    75
  72. Limnological studies of the Sea of Galilee (Lake Kinnéret) describe oxygen-poor zones driving fish to the surface; they concern the present-day lake and do not account for the word, the unique gesture and the recognition recounted in Jn 21.

    76
  73. Acts 2: Peter as preacher at Pentecost; Acts 10: Peter sent to Cornelius and witness to the opening to the nations, fulfilment of the catch of men announced in Lk 5, 10.

    77

Can’t find your topic?