The Passion according to the four Gospels

From the Last Supper to the tomb, the four Gospels recount the death of Jesus in Jerusalem with a common thread and their own emphases. Their witness, the seven words from the Cross, the sacrifice accomplished, and the prayer of the Church.

Ignispedia

The Passion refers, in the language of the Church, to the whole of the sufferings and death of Jesus, from the last meal with his disciples to his burial. The four Gospels recount it at length: in Mark, it takes up almost a third of the book, and each of the four accounts devotes its most developed portion to it. This weight is no accident of composition. For the Christian faith, the Cross is not the failure of a preaching: together with the Resurrection, it is the centre of the Good News proclaimed by the apostles[1].

"The Paschal Mystery of the Cross and Resurrection of Christ is at the centre of the Good News that the apostles, and the Church after them, must proclaim to the world."[2]

This article reads the four accounts as the Church receives them: a Holy Scripture, inspired and handed on by witnesses, which tells of an event that took place in Jerusalem, under Pontius Pilate, at the time of Passover. It compares the four versions without flattening them, shows what each one brings, then follows the narrative, its theology, its fulfilment in the Old Testament, and its place in the prayer of the Church. Related articles already deal in detail with the Last Supper, the agony at Gethsemane, the entry into Jerusalem and the trial of Jesus: they are referred to here, not redone. The modern debate over the composition of the accounts is examined at the end of the survey, along with its limits.

Four accounts, one and the same event

In other words, there is not one Passion narrative repeated four times, but four testimonies to the same event, close in their outline and distinct in their emphasis. The simplest image is that of four witnesses of one and the same scene: they agree on the essentials, and each retains what struck him. It is precisely this convergence, combined with differences of detail, that has always struck ancient readers.

The outline common to the four Gospels

The four accounts follow the same sequence. Jesus takes a last meal with the Twelve, announces the betrayer, then goes at night to the Mount of Olives where he prays and where Judas hands him over[3][4][5][6]. He appears before the Jewish authorities, then before Pilate, who condemns him to crucifixion[7][8][9][10]. He carries his cross to Golgotha, is crucified there between two criminals, dies after hours of agony, and Joseph of Arimathea then buries his body in a new tomb, in the presence of women disciples[11][12][13].

This common framework is remarkable. The evangelists diverge far more in their choice of Jesus' words during his ministry than in the Passion, where their accounts closely overlap. Tradition has seen in this the sign of a very ancient and very stable memory, fixed from the very first preaching, since it is the death of Christ, read in the light of his Resurrection, that the apostles proclaim above all[14].

"For I handed on to you as of first importance what I had myself received: Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures."[15]

What each evangelist brings in his own right

GospelPassion chaptersDistinctive emphasis of the account
MatthewMt 26-27The fulfilment of the Scriptures, the earthquake and the opened tombs at the death of Jesus[16]
MarkMk 14-15The bareness of the narrative, the abandonment, the cry of Psalm 22 and the centurion's confession[17][18]
LukeLk 22-23Mercy: the prayer for the executioners, the good thief, the appearance before Herod[19][20][21]
JohnJn 18-19The sovereignty of Jesus, who gives himself up freely; Mary and the beloved disciple at the foot of the Cross[22][23]
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Matthew writes for readers familiar with the Scriptures of Israel: he stresses that everything happens "so that the Scriptures might be fulfilled", and he alone tells of the dream of Pilate's wife, the suicide of Judas, and the potter's field[24][25]. Mark, the briefest, goes straight to the essentials with a sobriety that is at times stark: in him, Jesus dies in an apparent abandonment, with the opening of Psalm 22 as his only word[26]. Luke, a physician and companion of Paul according to tradition, insists on the innocence of Jesus, proclaimed three times by Pilate, and on his mercy towards the repentant thief[27][28]. John, finally, presents a Jesus who is never overtaken by events: it is he who names himself before the guards, who carries his own cross, and who, from the height of the Cross, entrusts his Mother to the beloved disciple[29][30][31].

Why these differences are not contradictions

A great deal of modern reading is only too willing to set these accounts against one another, as though every difference amounted to a refutation. The ancient reading of the Church proceeds otherwise, and it is more demanding: it distinguishes disagreement about the event itself, which it does not find in the outline, from the diversity of viewpoints, which it receives as a richness. Saint Augustine devoted an entire work to showing the agreement of the evangelists, passage by passage, treating their divergences of order and wording as those of witnesses who do not relate everything in the same sequence[32].

This method retains its force. Two witnesses reciting the same testimony word for word would arouse the suspicion of a learned lesson; four accounts that converge on the event and diverge on the details retained bear the ordinary mark of testimony. The historical-critical question will be taken up below, but the principle is already established here: the diversity of the accounts is a fact of the text, and it calls for an explanation; by itself, it is not proof of fabrication.

Place in the canon, traditional authors and dating

Four Gospels received as one apostolic witness

From the second century onwards, the Church receives four Gospels, no more, no fewer, and she refuses both to merge them into a single narrative and to add others to the canon. Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, around 180, maintains that there can be neither more nor fewer than four Gospels, and he attributes them to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John[33]. The so-called Muratorian Fragment, an ancient list of received books, likewise enumerates the four Gospels among the writings of the New Testament[34]. The canon of the Council of Trent then solemnly receives the sacred books "in their entirety, with all their parts", as they are read in the Church[35].

The First Vatican Council teaches that these books, "written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, have God as their author"[36]. Vatican II takes this up: the Gospels are of apostolic origin, and the Church "unhesitatingly asserts their historicity" with regard to what they hand down of the life and teaching of Jesus[37]. It is within this received framework, and not within a neutral one that would already be a taking of sides, that this article reads the Passion.

The traditional attributions, witness by witness

Tradition attributes the first Gospel to Matthew, the tax collector called by Jesus[38]. Papias of Hierapolis, in the early second century, reports that Matthew collected the sayings of the Lord, a testimony preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea[39]. The second Gospel is attributed to Mark, Peter's interpreter: again according to Papias, Mark set down in writing, accurately but without a set order, what Peter taught, as he remembered it[40]. The third belongs to Luke, the physician companion of Paul, who states himself in the prologue that he has "carefully investigated everything from the beginning" with the eyewitnesses[41][42]. The fourth is attributed to John, the apostle, the disciple whom Jesus loved, who identifies himself at the end of the book as the witness of these things[43]. Irenaeus, who had known Polycarp, himself a disciple of John, passes on this short chain between the apostle and the second-century Church[44].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

These attributions are not late inventions without grounding: they are unanimous in the ancient titles of the manuscripts, among the Fathers, and in liturgical usage. No ancient manuscript attributes these books to other authors. Traditional dating places their composition in the second half of the first century, during the lifetime of the witnesses or their immediate associates, which is confirmed by the place already given to these texts, quoted and commented upon, from the Apostolic Fathers and the second-century apologists onwards.

What tradition requires us to hold, and what remains disputed

One must distinguish the levels. That the four Gospels are inspired and canonical belongs to the faith of the Church. That their authors are the apostles and companions of apostles named by tradition belongs to a constant, ancient and unanimous reception, which a Catholic can hold with confidence. Questions of original language, of the order of composition among the Synoptics, or of the precise date to within a few years, remain matters of study, where several Catholic hypotheses coexist without touching the event narrated. To confuse these levels, by treating a hypothesis about dating as though it refuted the witness itself, is the first slippage to avoid, and it will be examined at the end of the article.

The ancient witnesses to the event

Two mentions outside the Church: Tacite and the stone of Pilate

The event does not rest solely on Christian texts. The Roman historian Tacite, writing around 116 about the Christians persecuted under Nero, notes that the Christ, from whom they take their name, had been handed over to execution under Tiberius, by the procurator Pontius Pilate[45]. The sentence is brief, hostile to the Christianity it treats as a superstition, and this is what makes it valuable: a pagan author, with no favour to show, takes for granted the fact of the execution and its administrative setting.

"The author of this name, Christ, had been handed over to execution under the reign of Tiberius, by the procurator Pontius Pilate."[46]

Stone of Pilate, 1st century, Israel Museum. Photo: Carole Raddato, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Image unchanged.

The figure of Pilate himself is not a character of legend. In 1961, a Latin inscription discovered at Caesarea Maritima, on the coast of Judea, yielded his name and his office: Pontius Pilate, prefect of Judea, dedicates a building there to the emperor Tiberius[47]. The prefect of the Gospels is thus a Roman administrator attested by epigraphy, in office during the years in which the four narratives place the Passion. Flavius Josephus, a Jewish historian of the first century, also mentions Jesus and his condemnation by Pilate to the cross, in a passage some of whose Christian confessional phrases are held by many scholars to be scribal interpolations; the core of the notice, which reports the execution, is on the other hand widely received as authentic[48]. Caution is required as to the exact words of Josephus; it does not extend to the fact itself, already established on other grounds.

The realism of the details, from the praetorium to the tomb

The narratives teem with verifiable details that anchor the event in the Judea of the 30s: the praetorium, the prefect's residence in Jerusalem during the festivals; the cohort and its soldiers; the scourging that precedes Roman crucifixion; the written charge in three languages; Golgotha, the place called the Skull, near a garden and tombs hewn from the rock[49][50][51]. Crucifixion itself, a Roman punishment reserved for slaves and rebels, is described without embellishment and without heroic glamour. The first Christians had no interest in inventing a crucified Messiah, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Greeks, in Paul's words[52]. This criterion, known as that of embarrassment, remains one of the most sober in the case file: one does not invent, in order to found a preaching, the most shameful death in the Roman world.

The continuous narrative, from the Last Supper to the tomb

To understand the sequence, picture the week as a climb over a few very dense days: the solemn entry into Jerusalem, the controversies in the Temple, the last supper, the night of the arrest, the morning hearings, then the crucifixion and burial before sunset. The evangelists do not all give the same time markers, but Mark punctuates the day of the Cross with a precision that has shaped the Church's memory: the third hour, the sixth hour, the ninth hour[53][54][55].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI
  1. Sunday
    The entry into Jerusalem
    the palms and the acclamation

    Jesus enters the city riding on a donkey, acclaimed by the crowd, then weeps over Jerusalem in Luke. The detailed account is the subject of the article on the entry of Jesus into Jerusalem[56].

  2. Thursday evening
    The Last Supper and the washing of the feet
    the institution of the Eucharist

    The last supper, the announcement of the betrayer and of the denial, the institution of the new meal in the Synoptics, the washing of the feet and the long farewell discourse in John. See the Last Supper[57][58].

  3. Thursday night
    Gethsemane and the arrest
    the prayer, then the kiss

    The agonized prayer in the Garden of Olives, the arrival of Judas with an armed band, the arrest and the scattering of the disciples. See the agony of Jesus in Gethsemane[59].

  4. Friday morning
    The hearings
    before the authorities, then before Pilate

    The nighttime interrogation, Peter's denial, the hearing before Pilate, Barabbas released and the condemnation. See the trial of Jesus[60].

  5. Friday
    The crucifixion and death
    from Golgotha to the ninth hour

    The carrying of the cross, the crucifixion between two thieves, the last words, the darkness and the death, attested by the centurion[61].

  6. Friday evening
    The burial
    Joseph of Arimathea and the women

    Joseph of Arimathea obtains the body, wraps it in a shroud and lays it in his new tomb, under the gaze of the women who are already preparing the return on Sunday morning[62][63].

The night: betrayal, arrest and denial

The Passion opens on a night of chained betrayals. Judas bargains his betrayal for thirty pieces of silver in Matthew, the price of the servant in the book of Zechariah[64][65]. Peter, who protests his fidelity, denies three times before the cock crows, then weeps bitterly at the look of the Lord[66][67]. The disciples sleep in the garden, then flee at the arrest[68]. This unvarnished tableau, in which the closest all fail, belongs to the realism of testimony: a community that invented its own golden legend would not have kept, front and center, the cowardice of its founders.

The morning: two powers, one condemnation

The accounts distinguish two scenes. First the hearing before the religious authorities of Jerusalem, where Jesus openly confesses that he is the Christ, the Son of the Blessed One[69][70]. Then the hearing before Pilate, sole holder of the power of life and death in the occupied province[71]. Pilate declares Jesus innocent several times in Luke, tries to release him, then gives way to pressure and hands him over to be crucified[72][73]. John reports the dialogue about kingship and truth, which gives the scene its own depth[74].

"What is truth?"[75]

Pilate's question, left without a spoken answer, receives its answer in what follows of the narrative: Truth itself falls silent, then allows itself to be condemned. The Fathers and the preachers have never ceased to meditate on this silence, which is neither an evasion nor a defeat, but the form the patience of the Son takes here.

The afternoon: the Cross, the darkness and the death

At Golgotha, the soldiers divide Jesus' garments and cast lots for his tunic, a detail all four accounts link to Psalm 22[76][77]. The title nailed above his head states the reason for the condemnation, Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews, in Hebrew, in Latin and in Greek[78][79]. Darkness covers the land from the sixth to the ninth hour in the Synoptics[80]. Jesus dies with a loud cry in Mark and Matthew, after commending his spirit in Luke and John[81][82][83]. The veil of the Temple is torn, and the centurion on guard confesses, in Mark, the divine sonship of the crucified one[84][85].

The Seven Last Words of Christ on the Cross

No single evangelist reports all seven words: tradition gathered them by weaving together the four accounts, and this harvest itself teaches how the Church reads the Passion, in the unity of the four witnesses. Here they are in the order in which Christian meditation has received them.

WordGospelWhat it reveals
Father, forgive them: they know not what they doLk 23:34Mercy toward the executioners, from the very first hour[86]
Today, with me, you will be in ParadiseLk 23:43Salvation offered to the repentant thief, without delay[87]
Woman, behold your son; behold your motherJn 19:26-27Mary given as mother to the disciple, and to the Church in him[88][89]
My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?Mt 27:46; Mk 15:34The cry of Psalm 22, prayer of the suffering Just One[90]
I thirstJn 19:28The thirst of the Crucified, read as the fulfillment of Scripture[91]
It is accomplishedJn 19:30The work completed, spoken in the perfect tense[92]
Father, into your hands I commend my spiritLk 23:46The trusting abandonment of Psalm 31, the last prayer of the Son[93][94]
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"[95]

This cry is not a cry of despair: it is the first verse of Psalm 22, which Jesus makes his own in prayer. Now this psalm, after the lament of the just one abandoned and pierced, ends in thanksgiving and the announcement of salvation for all the nations[96]. To pray the psalm by its first verse, in the Jewish culture of the time, is to invoke it in its entirety, lament and hope together. Christian interpretation has always seen in it both the truth of the felt abandonment and the trust that passes through it.

"Father, into your hands I commend my spirit."[97]

The last word in Luke answers the cry of Mark through Psalm 31, the evening prayer of the just one who falls asleep in God. Between these two psalms stands the whole Passion as read by the Church: the Son truly enters into the night of human suffering, and he enters it as Son, without ceasing to commend his spirit to the Father. Saint Thomas Aquinas, in his commentary on the Passion, holds these two sides together: Christ truly suffered, in body and in soul, and his suffering, freely offered, has the value of a sacrifice for the salvation of mankind[98].

The theology of the Passion: why Christ suffered

A freely accepted sacrifice, not one merely undergone

The four accounts insist on a point that all of theology will take up: Jesus does not undergo his death as an accident that catches him by surprise. He announces it three times during his ascent to Jerusalem, in increasingly precise terms[99][100][101]. In the garden, he refuses defense by the sword and declares that he could call upon the Father's help, which he does not request[102][103]. In John, he says it in a full formula: no one takes his life from him; he lays it down of his own accord[104].

"No one takes it from me; I lay it down of my own accord."[105]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The Catechism receives this freedom at the heart of its presentation: the death of Christ is at once the Passover sacrifice that accomplishes redemption and the free offering of the Son to his Father for the sins of mankind[106][107]. Saint Thomas orders the fitting reasons for the Passion by showing how it manifests together the justice and the mercy of God, without one crushing the other[108]. This insistence safeguards two truths at once: against the image of a cruel Father demanding a price, the accounts show the Son giving himself; against the image of a merely exemplary death, they show a death that effects salvation.

The fulfillment of the Scriptures, from Psalm 22 to the Suffering Servant

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The evangelists read the Passion in the Scriptures of Israel, and they say so. The division of the garments refers to Psalm 22[109]. The price of the betrayal and the potter's field refer to Zechariah and Jeremiah in Matthew[110]. The vinegar held out to the Crucified refers to Psalm 69[111][112]. Above all, the fourth song of the Servant, in Isaiah 52 and 53, describes a disfigured just one, pierced for the sins of others, silent before those who shear him, laid in a tomb with the rich man[113][114][115]. Luke has Philip read this text with the Ethiopian eunuch, who asks of whom the prophet speaks thus, and Philip, "starting with this passage of Scripture, proclaimed to him the Good News of Jesus"[116][117].

"He was pierced for our transgressions, crushed for our iniquities."[118]

This is not a patch applied after the fact. Jesus himself, on the evening of Easter in Luke, reproaches the disciples for their slowness to believe "all that the prophets have spoken" and explains to them, "beginning with Moses and all the prophets," what the Scriptures say concerning him[119][120]. The figural reading of the Passion, which recognizes in it the Paschal lamb of Exodus, the Servant of Isaiah and the just one of the Psalms, thus goes back to the risen Christ as Luke presents him, and then to the apostles, before becoming the work of commentators.

Mary, the women and the disciple at the foot of the Cross

Fra Angelico, Crucifixion with the Virgin, Saint John and Mary Magdalene, c. 1419-1420. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

John alone places Mary, the mother of Jesus, standing near the Cross, with the beloved disciple, and reports the word that entrusts them to one another[121][122]. The Synoptics show the women disciples watching from afar, then following Joseph of Arimathea to the tomb to see where the body is laid[123][124][125]. This female presence, constant from the crucifixion to the burial, and then to the morning of Easter, is a feature the accounts had no motive to invent in a world where the testimony of women counted for little in the courts. The Church has read in it the fidelity of those who did not flee, and the place of Mary, associated to the very end with the offering of her Son.

The question of dates: the Passover meal and the day of death

The Synoptics present the Last Supper as the Passover meal, after which Jesus is arrested in the night and crucified the next day[126][127]. John indicates that the authorities, on the morning of the hearing, avoid entering the praetorium so that they could eat the Passover, and he places the crucifixion on the day of Preparation of the Passover[128][129]. This difference in presentation has fuelled a long debate: did Jesus die on the very day of Passover, or the day before, at the moment when the lambs were immolated in the Temple?

Several Catholic readings hold both together without forcing the texts. Some put forward the different calendars then in use in Jerusalem, which shifted the celebration by a day depending on the groups. Others point out that John, without contradicting the storyline, charges his calendar with theological meaning: Christ dies at the hour when the lambs are immolated, because he is the true Lamb announced by John the Baptist[130][131]. Benedict XVI examined these hypotheses in his book on Jesus of Nazareth, holding the Last Supper to be an anticipated Passover meal celebrated by Jesus with his own, without thereby dissolving the historicity of the account[132]. The firm point, common to all four, remains: the Passion takes place at the time of Passover, and it is to this feast of the liberation from Egypt that the evangelists, after Christ himself, attach his death[133].

"Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed."[134]

The faces around the Cross

James Tissot, Simon of Cyrene Compelled to Carry the Cross with Jesus, c. 1886-1894, Brooklyn Museum. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Simon of Cyrene, father of Alexander and Rufus in Mark, is compelled to carry the cross behind Jesus; the precision of his sons' names suggests people known to the first readers of the Gospel[135][136]. Barabbas, released in place of Jesus, is presented as a rioter guilty of murder in Mark and Luke, which makes the exchange all the more striking: the guilty man is released, the Innocent condemned[137][138]. The daughters of Jerusalem, in Luke alone, receive on the way to Golgotha a word from Jesus turned towards the coming judgement rather than towards his own suffering[139]. Joseph of Arimathea, a member of the council who had not approved the condemnation in Luke, faces his fear and asks Pilate for the body[140][141]. Nicodemus, who had come to Jesus at night at the beginning of the Gospel of John, returns in broad daylight with a mixture of myrrh and aloes for the burial[142][143].

These faces matter for credibility as much as for meditation. For credibility, because they are named, placed, and sometimes linked to families that the early communities may have known. For meditation, because they sketch the possible responses before the Crucified: constraint turned into service in Simon, grace received without merit in Barabbas, tears in the women of Jerusalem, late courage in Joseph and Nicodemus. In the four accounts, the Passion is never a two-character scene: a whole people, with its leaders, its soldiers, its onlookers and its hidden faithful, is revealed around the Cross.

The Passion in the prayer and liturgy of the Church

Holy Week and the reading of the four accounts

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The Church does not read the Passion only in books: she celebrates it. On Palm Sunday, the liturgy has the whole account of the Passion read according to the evangelist of the year — Matthew, Mark or Luke in turn. On Good Friday, it is always John's account that is sung, in the celebration of the Passion of the Lord, with the great universal prayer and the veneration of the Cross[144]. This rhythm draws each believer, year after year, into the four accents of the same event, never reducing them to a single one.

The Easter Triduum holds together what this article distinguishes in order to explain it: Holy Thursday celebrates the Supper and the washing of the feet, Good Friday the death, Holy Saturday the silence of the tomb, and the Easter Vigil the Resurrection. The Catechism presents this paschal mystery as the summit of the liturgical year as much as the centre of faith[145].

The Way of the Cross, the Rosary and the meditation of the Hours

Popular devotion has extended the liturgy through the Way of the Cross, which follows in fourteen stations the route from the praetorium to the tomb, and through the five sorrowful mysteries of the Rosary, which meditate in turn on the agony, the scourging, the crowning with thorns, the carrying of the cross and the crucifixion[146]. In the tradition of the Divine Will, Luisa Piccarreta composed the Twenty-Four Hours of the Passion, an hour-by-hour meditation from the Supper to the burial, which the Church leaves to the piety of the faithful as a received private revelation[147]. These varied forms express the same conviction: the Passion is not skimmed over; it is contemplated slowly, scene by scene.

Melito of Sardes, a second-century bishop, was already preaching the Christian Passover by rereading the Exodus: in his homily On Pascha, preserved by an ancient papyrus and edited in the twentieth century, he presents Christ as the true lamb of which the lamb of Egypt was the figure[148]. Eighteen centuries of preaching, singing and prayer separate Melito from the believer who today follows the Way of the Cross, but the reading is the same: the Passion reread in the Exodus, the Psalms and the prophets, and received as the Passover of God who sets free.

What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

Some contemporary exegesis proposes reading the Passion narratives as late communal compositions, built from the Old Testament rather than from memories, and dating their writing after the year 70 by looking for allusions to the destruction of the Temple. In its most sceptical form, this reading treats Jesus' words as creations of the community, the convergent details as literary borrowings between evangelists, and the empty tomb as a legendary development. These hypotheses must be presented honestly, and then examined, for none of them establishes itself as a measured fact.

The weaknesses of the sceptical reading

Several weaknesses recur, and they are well known. First, the presupposition: to treat from the outset as impossible that Jesus announced his death or that the narratives preserve a memory close to the events is to decide before the inquiry what the inquiry will be able to find. Next, the circular dating: to date a text by a theory of the community that would have produced it, and then to prove the theory by the date thus obtained. Added to this is the argument from silence, which infers from the absence of a detail in one evangelist its invention by another, whereas every testimony selects. Finally, the extrapolation: to pass from a real literary dependence between the synoptics, which nobody denies, to the idea that the material narrated would have no anchor in the memory of the witnesses, which literary dependence, by itself, does not demonstrate[149].

Conversely, major scholarly works have defended the great antiquity of the core of the Passion. The profession of faith that Paul hands on in 1 Corinthians 15, received by him in the very first years after the Cross, already presupposes the death of Christ "for our sins, in accordance with the Scriptures", his burial and his Resurrection preached as a received block, not elaborated at a later date[150]. The sobriety of Mark, the embarrassment of the apostolic betrayals preserved without varnish, and the external attestation of Tacitus converge in the same direction: the fact of the Passion belongs to the oldest and least contestable core of Christian preaching.

What a Catholic reader can hold

The conclusion is not that one should choose between faith and study. The Church encourages the study of literary genres and historical contexts, provided it serves the understanding of the text instead of dissolving it[151]. A Catholic reader can therefore hold together three things: the substantial historicity of the four narratives, received with the Church[152]; the freedom to examine, as a scholar, the open questions of composition and precise dating; and the rejection of reconstructions that rest solely on the presupposition that the supernatural and prophecy would be impossible. It is this rejection, argued and not merely confessed, that makes the traditional position defensible before a demanding reader, theologian included.

To go further

The scenes that this article skims over in order to keep the unity of the narrative are treated in detail in their own articles:

Notes and References

  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 571: the paschal mystery of the Cross and the Resurrection at the heart of the Good News (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1992; text on vatican.va).

    1 2 145
  2. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, the last meal, Gethsemane and the arrest (AELF liturgical translation).

    3
  3. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, the Last Supper, Gethsemane and the arrest (AELF).

    4
  4. Gospel according to Saint Luke 22, the Last Supper, the Mount of Olives and the arrest (AELF).

    5
  5. Gospel according to Saint John 18, the arrest and the hearings (AELF).

    6
  6. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, the trial before Pilate and the crucifixion (AELF).

    7
  7. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, the condemnation, the crucifixion and the burial (AELF).

    8
  8. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, Pilate, Herod, the Cross and the tomb (AELF).

    9
  9. Gospel according to Saint John 19, the crucifixion, death and burial (AELF).

    10
  10. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 57-61, Joseph of Arimathea and the new tomb (AELF).

    11
  11. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 50-56, Joseph of Arimathea and the women at the tomb (AELF).

    12 62
  12. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 38-42, Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus (AELF).

    13
  13. First Letter to the Corinthians 15, 1-8, the profession of faith received and handed on (AELF).

    14
  14. First Letter to the Corinthians 15, 3: Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures (AELF).

    15 150
  15. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 51-54, the torn veil, the earthquake and the opened tombs (AELF).

    16
  16. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 34, the cry of Psalm 22 at the ninth hour (AELF).

    17 26 55
  17. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 39, the centurion's confession (AELF).

    18 61 85
  18. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 34, the prayer for those who crucify him (AELF).

    19 86
  19. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 40-43, the good thief (AELF).

    20
  20. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 8-12, the hearing before Herod (AELF).

    21
  21. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 4-8, Jesus identifies himself before those who come to arrest him (AELF).

    22
  22. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 26-27, Mary and the disciple at the foot of the Cross (AELF).

    23 31 88 122
  23. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 19, Pilate's wife's dream (AELF).

    24
  24. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 5-10, the death of Judas and the potter's field (AELF).

    25
  25. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 22, Pilate's third declaration of innocence (AELF).

    27 72
  26. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 41-43, the confession of the repentant thief (AELF).

    28
  27. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 5-6, "It is I, I am he", and the guards drawing back (AELF).

    29
  28. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 17, Jesus carrying his own cross (AELF).

    30 50
  29. Saint Augustine, De consensu evangelistarum (On the Harmony of the Evangelists), a work in four books devoted to the harmony of the four narratives (around 400).

    32
  30. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies III, 11, 8: neither more nor fewer than four Gospels (around 180; Sources chrétiennes edition).

    33
  31. Muratorian Fragment, an ancient list of the received books of the New Testament, enumerating the four Gospels (text preserved at the Ambrosian Library, Milan).

    34
  32. Council of Trent, session IV, 8 April 1546, decree on the sacred books received in full with all their parts (DS 1501-1505).

    35
  33. First Vatican Council, constitution Dei Filius, ch. 2, 24 April 1870: the books written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit have God as their author (DS 3006).

    36
  34. Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, n. 19, 18 November 1965: apostolic origin of the Gospels and historicity affirmed without hesitation (vatican.va).

    37 152
  35. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 9, 9, the calling of Matthew the tax collector (AELF).

    38
  36. Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History III, 39, quoting Papias of Hierapolis on Matthew and on Mark, Peter's interpreter (Sources chrétiennes edition).

    39 40
  37. Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 1-4, the prologue and the enquiry among the witnesses (AELF).

    41
  38. Gospel according to Saint Luke 1, 3: to have investigated everything carefully from the beginnings (AELF).

    42
  39. Gospel according to Saint John 21, 24, the witness disciple who wrote these things (AELF).

    43
  40. Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies III, 3, and the Polycarp chain, disciple of John (Sources chrétiennes ed.); cf. Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History V, 8 and VI, 14.

    44
  41. Tacitus, Annals XV, 44: Christ handed over to execution under Tiberius by the procurator Pontius Pilate (c. 116; established Latin text, literal French translation).

    45 46
  42. Pontius Pilate inscription, Caesarea Maritima, limestone discovered in 1961 (excavations of Antonio Frova), naming Pontius Pilate, prefect of Judaea, dedicating a building to Tiberius (Israel Museum, Jerusalem).

    47
  43. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities XVIII, 63-64 (Testimonium Flavianum): notice on Jesus condemned by Pilate to the cross, whose confessional formulas are disputed and whose core is widely accepted.

    48
  44. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 13, the praetorium and the Lithostrotos (AELF).

    49
  45. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 41, the garden and the new tomb near the place of the crucifixion (AELF).

    51
  46. First Letter to the Corinthians 1, 23: a crucified Christ, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Greeks (AELF).

    52
  47. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 25, the third hour (AELF).

    53
  48. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 33, the darkness from the sixth to the ninth hour (AELF).

    54 80
  49. Gospel according to Saint Luke 19, 41-44, Jesus weeps over Jerusalem (AELF).

    56
  50. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, 26-29, the institution of the meal (AELF).

    57
  51. Gospel according to Saint John 13, 4-15, the washing of the feet (AELF).

    58
  52. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, 43-50, the arrest (AELF).

    59
  53. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 28-38, Jesus led to the praetorium (AELF).

    60
  54. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 55-56, the women at the tomb and the preparation of spices (AELF).

    63 125
  55. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, 15, the thirty pieces of silver (AELF).

    64
  56. Book of Zechariah 11, 12-13, the thirty pieces and the potter (AELF).

    65
  57. Gospel according to Saint Luke 22, 61, the Lord's look toward Peter (AELF).

    66
  58. Gospel according to Saint Luke 22, 62, Peter weeps bitterly (AELF).

    67
  59. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, 50, all abandon him and flee (AELF).

    68
  60. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, 61-62, Jesus' confession before the high priest (AELF).

    69
  61. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, 62, "I am," and the Son of Man seated at the right hand of the Power (AELF).

    70
  62. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 31, the right of capital punishment reserved to the Roman authority (AELF).

    71
  63. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 25, Pilate hands Jesus over to their will (AELF).

    73
  64. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 37, the kingship of Jesus and the testimony to the truth (AELF).

    74
  65. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 38, Pilate's question about the truth (AELF).

    75
  66. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 24, the division of the garments and the tunic lots (AELF).

    76
  67. Psalm 22, 19: they divide my garments among them (AELF).

    77 109
  68. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 19-20, the title written by Pilate in three languages (AELF).

    78
  69. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 20, the title read by many, near the city (AELF).

    79
  70. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 37, the loud cry and the last breath (AELF).

    81
  71. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 46, the handing over of the spirit into the Father's hands (AELF).

    82 93 97
  72. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 30, "It is accomplished," and the handing over of the spirit (AELF).

    83 92
  73. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 38, the veil of the Temple torn (AELF).

    84
  74. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 43, today in Paradise (AELF).

    87
  75. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 27, the disciple takes Mary into his home (AELF).

    89
  76. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 46, the cry of Psalm 22 at the ninth hour (AELF).

    90 95
  77. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 28, the thirst of the Crucified (AELF).

    91
  78. Psalm 31, 6: into your hands I commend my spirit (AELF).

    94
  79. Psalm 22, 28-31, the proclamation of salvation to all nations that closes the psalm (AELF).

    96
  80. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae III, q. 46-49: the Passion of Christ, its fittingness, its effects and its value as sacrifice (Cerf ed.).

    98 108
  81. Gospel according to Saint Mark 8, 31, the first announcement of the Passion (AELF).

    99
  82. Gospel according to Saint Mark 9, 31, the second announcement of the Passion (AELF).

    100
  83. Gospel according to Saint Mark 10, 33-34, the third announcement, the most detailed (AELF).

    101
  84. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, 52-53, the sword put back in its sheath and the legions of angels not requested (AELF).

    102
  85. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, 53-54, the fulfilment of the Scriptures preferred to the requested help (AELF).

    103
  86. Gospel according to Saint John 10, 18: no one takes the life of the Good Shepherd, he lays it down of his own accord (AELF).

    104 105
  87. Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 606-618: the free offering of the Son and the sacrifice of the New Covenant (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1992).

    106
  88. Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 613: the death of Christ as paschal sacrifice and sacrifice of the New Covenant (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1992).

    107
  89. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 27, 9-10, the fulfilment of the prophetic word concerning the potter's field (AELF).

    110
  90. Psalm 69, 22: vinegar for my thirst (AELF).

    111
  91. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 29, the sponge of vinegar offered to the Crucified (AELF).

    112
  92. Book of Isaiah 53, 5, pierced for our transgressions (AELF).

    113 118
  93. Book of Isaiah 53, 7, silent like a lamb led to the slaughter (AELF).

    114
  94. Book of Isaiah 53, 9, his tomb with the rich man (AELF).

    115
  95. Acts of the Apostles 8, 32-33, the eunuch reading Isaiah 53 (AELF).

    116
  96. Acts of the Apostles 8, 35, Philip proclaims Jesus from this passage (AELF).

    117
  97. Gospel according to Saint Luke 24, 25, the reproach to the disciples slow to believe the prophets (AELF).

    119
  98. Gospel according to Saint Luke 24, 27, the explanation of the Scriptures beginning with Moses and the prophets (AELF).

    120
  99. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 25, Mary standing near the Cross (AELF).

    121
  100. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 40-41, the women watching from a distance (AELF).

    123
  101. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 47, the women observe where the body is laid (AELF).

    124
  102. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 26, 17-19, the preparation of the Passover meal (AELF).

    126
  103. Gospel according to Saint Mark 14, 16, the disciples prepare the Passover (AELF).

    127
  104. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 28, not entering the praetorium in order to eat the Passover (AELF).

    128
  105. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 14, the day of Preparation of the Passover, about the sixth hour (AELF).

    129
  106. Gospel according to Saint John 1, 29, behold the Lamb of God (AELF).

    130
  107. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 36, not one of his bones shall be broken, a word likened to the paschal lamb (AELF).

    131
  108. Benedict XVI, Jesus of Nazareth, vol. 2, From the Entrance into Jerusalem to the Resurrection, Paris, Éditions du Rocher, 2011: discussion of the chronologies of the Supper and the Cross, and reading of the meal as an anticipated Passover meal.

    132
  109. First Letter to the Corinthians 5, 7: Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed (AELF).

    133 134
  110. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 21, Simon of Cyrene, father of Alexander and Rufus (AELF).

    135
  111. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 26, Simon of Cyrene laden with the cross behind Jesus (AELF).

    136
  112. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 7, Barabbas imprisoned for insurrection and murder (AELF).

    137
  113. Gospel according to Saint John 18, 40, Barabbas was a bandit (AELF).

    138
  114. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 28-31, the daughters of Jerusalem on the road to Golgotha (AELF).

    139
  115. Gospel according to Saint Luke 23, 51, Joseph, a member of the council, who had not approved the decision (AELF).

    140
  116. Gospel according to Saint Mark 15, 43, Joseph of Arimathea asks Pilate for the body (AELF).

    141
  117. Gospel according to Saint John 3, 1-2, Nicodemus comes to Jesus by night (AELF).

    142
  118. Gospel according to Saint John 19, 39, Nicodemus brings myrrh and aloes for the burial (AELF).

    143
  119. Roman Missal, celebration of the Passion of the Lord on Good Friday: reading of the Passion according to Saint John, universal prayer and veneration of the Cross (typical edition).

    144
  120. Saint John Paul II, apostolic letter Rosarium Virginis Mariae, 16 October 2002, n. 22: the five sorrowful mysteries (vatican.va).

    146
  121. Luisa Piccarreta, The Twenty-Four Hours of the Passion: meditation from the Last Supper to the burial, hour by hour. Private revelation received by the Church (nulla osta from the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, June 2024): cited as meditation, not as dogma.

    147
  122. Melito of Sardis, On Pascha (Peri Pascha), 2nd-century homily (c. 160-170), ed. O. Perler, Sources chrétiennes 123, Paris, Cerf, 1966; text preserved notably by Papyrus Bodmer XIII.

    148
  123. Discussion of the methodological weaknesses of sceptical reconstructions: the presupposition of impossibility, circular dating, the argument from silence and extrapolation, examined in the New Testament introduction literature, e.g. R. E. Brown, An Introduction to the New Testament, 1997, French trans., Que sait-on du Nouveau Testament ?, Paris, Bayard, 2000.

    149
  124. Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, n. 12: the study of literary genres in the service of the understanding of Scripture (vatican.va).

    151

Can’t find your topic?