On the Friday following the Last Supper, around the third hour of the day, Jesus is led outside Jerusalem to the place called Golgotha, and crucified between two thieves. He dies around the ninth hour, after having spoken seven words that the four Gospels have preserved. At the moment of his death, the veil of the Temple is torn, the earth trembles, and the Roman centurion guarding the cross confesses: "Truly this man was the Son of God" (Mk 15:39). For the Christian faith, this death is not an accident of history: it is the sacrifice by which Christ offers his life for the multitude and fulfils the Scriptures.
This article first sets out what the Scriptures recount and what the Church has always believed, together with the ancient witnesses that attest to it, the theology that unfolds from it, and the liturgy that still celebrates it every year. The debate raised by a portion of contemporary exegesis concerning the exact date, the chronology of the hours, and the historicity of the phenomena is set out at the end of the article, along with the responses it calls for. For the overall account of the Passion, see The Passion according to the four Gospels; for what immediately precedes it, see The Trial of Jesus and The Agony of Jesus in Gethsemane.
The Crucifixion in the Scriptures: four accounts of a single event
No event in the life of Jesus is recounted with as much detail as his death. The four Gospels converge on the place, the manner of execution, the persons present, and the hour of death, while each retains its own emphasis. Saint Paul, who writes before them, already summarises the core of the faith: "For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures" (1 Cor 15:3). The Catechism recalls that "the redemptive death of Jesus fulfils in particular the prophecy of the Suffering Servant" of Isaiah 53[1].
| Witness | Traditional date | What it contributes in particular |
|---|---|---|
| Saint Matthew (Mt 27:32-56) | Apostle and eyewitness, the Gospel received first by the Church | The darkness, the earthquake, the opened tombs; "Truly this man was the Son of God" |
| Saint Mark (Mk 15:21-41) | Saint Peter's interpreter in Rome | The most sober account and the earliest in its form; the cry of abandonment from Psalm 21; the centurion's confession |
| Saint Luke (Lk 23:26-49) | Companion of Saint Paul, inquiry among the witnesses (Lk 1:1-4) | The word to the good thief, the prayer of forgiveness, "Father, into your hands I commend my spirit" |
| Saint John (Jn 19:17-37) | The beloved apostle, present at the foot of the cross | The titulus in three languages, the seamless tunic, "Woman, behold your son", the spear wound and the blood and water |
This convergence is the first fact to be explained. The four accounts were written for different communities — in Rome, Syria, Greece, and Asia Minor — and they agree on details that no inventor would have had any interest in fabricating: the forced assistance of a passer-by, Simon of Cyrene, whose sons Alexander and Rufus Mark names as persons known to his readers (Mk 15:21); the offer of wine mixed with myrrh, refused by Jesus (Mk 15:23); the division of the garments by lots; the presence of women named Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and Joses, and Salome (Mk 15:40). The tradition of the Church has always received these four accounts as the testimony of the apostles and their companions, handed down without interruption from the eyewitnesses[2].
"And they came to a place called Golgotha (which means the place of a skull). They offered him wine to drink, mixed with gall; but when he tasted it, he would not drink." — Saint Matthew, Mt 27:33-34
Attribution and traditional dating of the Gospels
The Church received the four Gospels under the names of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and this attribution is not a late convention. Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, around 180, who had known Saint Polycarp, himself a disciple of the Apostle John, already lists the four Gospels as a universally received fact: Matthew published his Gospel among the Hebrews, Mark, Peter's interpreter, set down in writing the preaching of the apostle, Luke, Paul's companion, recorded the Gospel preached by Paul, and John, the disciple of the Lord, published his own at Ephesus[3]. The Muratorian Fragment, a Roman list of received books dated to the late second century, names Luke and John in the same order[4].
Traditional dating places Mark around the 60s, Matthew and Luke in the 60s to 80s, and John towards the end of the first century, at Ephesus, when the apostle, very old, completed the testimony of the first three. For the crucifixion, this chronology matters: Mark writes a generation after the events, while witnesses are still alive, and Paul, from the 50s onward, transmits a kerygma of the death of Christ that he says he himself received (1 Cor 15:3). The Rylands papyrus, a fragment of the Gospel of John dated to the first half of the second century and found in Egypt, shows that the fourth Gospel was already circulating far from its place of origin a few decades after its composition[5].
A portion of contemporary exegesis proposes later dates and anonymous authors. This debate is addressed at the end of the article. It suffices to note here that the traditional attribution rests on a chain of named witnesses from diverse geographical backgrounds, and not on an isolated decision: Papias of Hierapolis, around 120, already speaks of Mark as Peter's interpreter and of Matthew as the recorder of the words of the Lord, in fragments preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea[6].
The torture of the cross in the Roman world
Crucifixion was not invented for Jesus. The Romans had inherited it from the peoples of the Mediterranean and had made it the punishment reserved for rebellious slaves, brigands, and seditionists in the provinces: a slow, public, and shameful death, intended as a deterrent. Cicero calls it the most cruel and hideous of punishments, and holds that a Roman citizen should not even hear its name[7]. This is why a citizen such as Saint Paul was beheaded, rather than crucified.
The condemned man carried the crossbeam of his cross, the patibulum, to the place of execution, where the vertical post was already planted. He was nailed or bound by the wrists and feet, then left exposed. Death came through exhaustion, loss of blood, and gradual asphyxiation: to breathe, the crucified man had to pull himself up on his nailed feet, at the cost of extreme pain. The guards sometimes hastened the end by breaking the legs, the crurifragium, which made this raising impossible (John 19:31-32). A notice, the titulus, bore the reason for the condemnation, so that the crowd would understand the lesson.
Archaeology has confirmed the reality of this practice in Judaea itself. In 1968, in the Giv'at ha-Mivtar neighbourhood, north of Jerusalem, excavations uncovered the ossuary of a first-century crucified man named Jehohanan, whose right heel bone still preserved the iron nail that had pierced it, along with a fragment of olive wood[8]. To this day, this is the only skeletal remains of a crucified man from antiquity identified with certainty, the nails being most often removed and the bodies of the executed rarely buried in a family tomb.
The place: Golgotha, outside the walls
The four Gospels name the place Golgotha, an Aramaic word that John translates as "Place of the Skull" (John 19:17). Three explanations of this name have been proposed: a hill whose shape resembled a skull, a place of execution where bones lay, or the tradition, attested among several Fathers, that Adam was buried at that spot, so that the blood of Christ would flow over the skull of the first man. Whatever the etymology, the topographical data of the Gospels converge: the place stood outside the walls of Jerusalem, since "Jesus, in order to sanctify the people by his own blood, suffered outside the gate" (Heb 13:12); it was near the city, since the inscription on the cross "was read by many of the Jews, for the place where Jesus was crucified was near the city" (John 19:20); and it included a garden with a new tomb (John 19:41).
Christian tradition identified this place as early as the fourth century with the site of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, in the present-day Christian Quarter of the Old City. In 325, the Emperor Constantine had the temple of Venus that Hadrian had erected on the site after the Bar Kokhba revolt demolished, and the excavations brought to light a rocky hill and tombs cut into the rock, consistent with a disused quarry located outside the first-century city wall[9]. Saint Helena, Constantine's mother, presided, according to tradition, over the discovery of the True Cross during these works[10]. The Constantinian basilica, consecrated in 335, encompassed both the rock of Calvary and the tomb, and pilgrimage has never ceased since: the Bordeaux Pilgrim, in 333, already describes the route of the pilgrims from Jerusalem to the Mount of Olives passing through these places[11].
A competing hypothesis, known as the Garden Tomb, proposed in the nineteenth century north of the Old City, appeals through its peaceful setting, but the tombs it presents date from the Iron Age and the Byzantine period, not from the first century; it rests on no ancient tradition. The site of the Holy Sepulchre remains the only one attested by continuous memory and by the archaeology of the city wall.
The date and time: a Friday of Passover
The Synoptics place the crucifixion on the day of Passover, after the paschal meal celebrated the previous evening, while John places it on the day of the Preparation of Passover, when the lambs were slaughtered in the Temple (Jn 19:14). In both readings, the event takes place on a Friday of the month of Nisan, in spring, around the year 30 or 33, the two years when the 14th of Nisan fell on a Friday according to astronomical calculations: 7 April 30 or 3 April 33[12]. Liturgical tradition has always celebrated the death of Christ on the Friday of Easter week, and the debate concerns the alignment of the calendars, not the day of the week, which is attested by the four accounts.
The hour is given with rare precision. Mark writes that Jesus was crucified at the third hour, around nine in the morning, and that he breathed his last at the ninth hour, around three in the afternoon, after darkness covered the land from the sixth to the ninth hour (Mk 15:25.33–34). John mentions the sixth hour for the final condemnation before Pilate (Jn 19:14). Ancient commentators already noted that the methods of computing the hours could vary, or that an early copy of Mark carried a different reading; the essential point, received by the whole tradition, is a crucifixion in the morning and a death in the middle of the afternoon, at the very hour when the Passover lambs were slaughtered in the Temple.
| Hour (Jewish reckoning) | Approximate hour | Event |
|---|---|---|
| Third hour | Around 9 a.m. | Jesus is crucified (Mk 15:25) |
| Sixth hour | Around noon | Darkness covers the whole land (Mk 15:33) |
| Ninth hour | Around 3 p.m. | Jesus cries out with a loud voice and breathes his last (Mk 15:34–37) |
| Evening came | Before sunset | Joseph of Arimathea asks for the body; burial before the Sabbath (Mk 15:42–46) |
From the praetorium to Golgotha: the road and Simon of Cyrene
After the flogging and the soldiers' mockery, Jesus is led to the place of execution carrying his cross (Jn 19:17). The Synoptics recount that on the way, the soldiers requisition a passer-by, Simon of Cyrene, who was coming in from the fields, and lay the cross on him behind Jesus (Lk 23:26). Cyrene is located in present-day Libya; Simon was in all likelihood a Jew of the diaspora who had come to Jerusalem for Passover. Mark adds that he was the father of Alexander and Rufus (Mk 15:21), a detail that only makes sense if his Roman readers knew these two men: a Rufus is greeted by Paul in his letter to the Romans, along with his mother, "who is also mine" (Rom 16:13). The detail, with no immediate theological import, bears the mark of a memory passed down within the community.
Luke alone reports the encounter with the women of Jerusalem who are mourning along the road. Jesus turns to them and addresses a prophetic word to them about the coming misfortune of the city: "Daughters of Jerusalem, do not weep for me; weep for yourselves and for your children" (Lk 23:28). The tradition of the Church has meditated on this journey, later called the Way of the Cross, and has made it a Lenten prayer, without confusing devotion with the narrative itself.
A large crowd follows the procession, Luke notes (Lk 23:27). Roman crucifixion was a public spectacle by design: the execution was carried out along a busy road, so as to be seen by as many people as possible. This is confirmed by the inscription placed above Jesus' head, readable by passers-by.
On the cross: the inscription, the garments, and the mockery
Pilate has the notice of the condemnation written: "Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews," in Hebrew, in Latin, and in Greek (Jn 19:19–20). The three languages proclaim the public nature of the act: Hebrew for the country, Latin for the Roman administration, Greek for the Mediterranean world. The chief priests ask for a correction, "Do not write the King of the Jews, but this man said: I am the King of the Jews," and Pilate refuses: "What I have written, I have written" (Jn 19:21–22). The Church has always read in this titulus, beyond the governor's irony, a proclamation: the reason for the condemnation states the truth about the condemned man.
The soldiers divide Jesus' garments and cast lots for his tunic, "seamless, woven in one piece from the top" (Jn 19:23). John sees in it the fulfilment of Scripture: "They divided my garments among them, and for my clothing they cast lots" (Ps 22:18, cited in Jn 19:24). The same psalm opens Jesus' prayer on the cross and describes with striking precision details of the torment: hands and feet pierced, bones that can be counted, the mockery of the onlookers (Ps 22:8.17–18). The evangelists do not fabricate these parallels after the fact: they read the event in the prayer of Israel, which Jesus himself made his own.
Around the cross, the accounts describe three circles of mockery: the passers-by who shake their heads, the chief priests and scribes who trade the provocation back and forth, and the two thieves crucified with him (Mt 27:39–44). The challenge hurled is always the same: "If you are the Son of God, come down from the cross" (Mt 27:40). Jesus' response is silence and prayer. The Catechism emphasizes that it is precisely by not coming down from the cross that Jesus reveals himself as the Servant who "will justify the multitudes" by bearing their iniquity[13].
The Two Thieves and the Word of Paradise
Jesus is crucified between two criminals, whom Luke calls thieves and whom tradition has often identified as brigands or insurgents. Mark and Matthew report that, at first, both insult him along with the crowd. Luke alone tells of the conversion of one of them: rebuking his companion who reviles Jesus, he acknowledges the justice of their own condemnation, confesses Jesus' innocence, then addresses to him the prayer the Church has never ceased to repeat: "Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom" (Lk 23:42). The reply is immediate and solemn, introduced by Jesus' amen: "Amen, I say to you: today, with me, you will be in Paradise" (Lk 23:43).
"Amen, I say to you: today, with me, you will be in Paradise." — Jesus to the good thief, Lk 23:43
Tradition has given this thief the name Dismas, and the Church venerates him as a saint — the only saint canonized, as the often-quoted saying goes, by Christ himself while still living. His conversion at the last moment, with no other work than the confession of his fault and trust in the condemned man beside him, became for preachers the proof that mercy knows no late hour. It also shows, from the cross itself, the universal scope of the sacrifice: the first man saved by Christ's death is a criminal undergoing the same sentence.
The Seven Words of Christ on the Cross
Tradition has gathered into seven words the phrases spoken by Jesus on the cross, drawn from the four Gospels. No evangelist gives them all; their collection is the work of the Church's reading, which saw in them a complete testament. The Hours of the Passion, meditated upon notably by Saint Alphonsus Liguori and by the tradition of the Hours of the Passion passed on by Luisa Piccarreta, have made these words the centre of Good Friday contemplation, without these private meditations replacing the gospel text itself.
Forgiveness and the Promise
The first word reported by Luke is a prayer for the executioners: "Father, forgive them: they know not what they do" (Lk 23:34). It fulfils the word of the Servant of Isaiah who "interceded for transgressors" (Is 53:12), and it inaugurates, from the cross, the teaching on forgiveness of enemies that Jesus had given in the Sermon on the Mount. The second word is the promise to the good thief, already quoted: Paradise opened that very day, even before the resurrection.
Mary and John at the Foot of the Cross
John, present at the foot of the cross with Mary, reports the third word, in two stages: "Woman, behold your son," then to the disciple: "Behold your mother" (Jn 19:26-27). The Church has always read in this more than a family arrangement: Mary, who had consented at the Annunciation, is given as mother to the beloved disciple, a figure of every disciple, and the disciple takes her "into his home." The Catechism links this scene to Mary's motherhood toward the Church[14]. Mary's presence at the foot of the cross, standing, in John's words, lies at the heart of the meditation of the Stabat Mater, sung in the liturgy of Our Lady of Sorrows.
"Woman, behold your son." Then he said to the disciple: "Behold your mother." — Jesus on the cross, Jn 19:26-27
Abandonment, Thirst, and Fulfilment
The fourth word is the cry reported by Mark and Matthew in Jesus' own language: "Eloï, Eloï, lema sabactani," "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me" (Mk 15:34; Ps 22:2). It is not a cry of despair: it is the first verse of Psalm 22, the prayer of the suffering righteous man that ends in praise and the announcement of the conversion of the nations. In praying it, Jesus takes upon himself the experience of distance from God that is that of sin, while remaining within the prayer of Israel. Some passers-by misunderstand and think he is calling Elijah, a new mockery born of a misunderstanding of the Aramaic.
The fifth word, in John, is brief: "I thirst" (Jn 19:28). John specifies that Jesus speaks it "so that the Scripture might be fulfilled," echoing Psalm 69: "To quench my thirst, they gave me vinegar" (Ps 69:22). A sponge soaked in vinegar is held up to him on a stalk of hyssop. The sixth word follows immediately: "It is finished" (Jn 19:30), in Greek tetelestai, a word signifying the completion of a task and the payment of a debt. The seventh, in Luke, places everything back into the Father's hands, in the words of Psalm 31: "Father, into your hands I commend my spirit" (Lk 23:46; Ps 31:6). Then, says John, "he bowed his head and gave up his spirit" (Jn 19:30).
Death: darkness, the torn veil, and the centurion's confession
From the sixth to the ninth hour, "darkness covered the whole land" (Mk 15:33). The three Synoptics report this as an event accompanying the crucifixion. Tradition has seen in it the mourning of creation, echoing the prophecy of Amos about the sun setting at noon (Am 8:9). At the moment of death, two signs are reported. First, "the veil of the Temple was torn in two, from top to bottom" (Mk 15:38): the curtain that closed the Holy of Holies, which only the high priest crossed once a year, on the Day of Atonement, is opened from top to bottom — that is, by an initiative coming from God. The Letter to the Hebrews reads in it the opening of access to the true sanctuary through the flesh of Christ, "a new and living way" (Heb 10:19-20).
Next, Matthew alone adds that the earth shook, the rocks were split, and tombs were opened (Mt 27:51-53). Finally, the centurion commanding the execution detail, a Roman and pagan witness to the whole scene, pronounces the confession that closes Mark's narrative: "Truly, this man was the Son of God" (Mk 15:39). Luke gives the same scene his own inflection: the centurion "glorified God and said, 'This man was truly righteous'" (Lk 23:47), and the crowds return home "beating their breasts" (Lk 23:48). The first confession of Christ's divinity after his death thus comes from a soldier of the execution, just as the first to enter Paradise is a thief: the narratives underscore that the cross overturns ranks.
John adds one final fact, unique to his eyewitness testimony. The Jewish authorities having asked that the bodies not remain on the cross during the Sabbath of Passover, the soldiers break the legs of the two thieves; coming to Jesus, they find him already dead and do not break his legs. A soldier opens his side with a lance thrust, "and at once blood and water flowed out" (Jn 19:34). John insists on his standing as a witness: "He who saw it has borne witness — his testimony is true" (Jn 19:35). He sees in it the fulfilment of two Scriptures: "Not one of his bones shall be broken," the prescription of the paschal lamb (Ex 12:46, cited in Jn 19:36), and "They shall look upon him whom they have pierced" (Zech 12:10, cited in Jn 19:37). The theology of the Church has read in the blood and the water the sacraments of Baptism and the Eucharist, born from the side of Christ, the new Adam asleep, from whose side the Bride is formed as Eve from the side of Adam.
For what immediately follows — Joseph of Arimathea's request for the body, the burial, and the guarding of the tomb — see The Burial of Jesus.
Theology of the cross: why this death saves
The crucifixion is not merely a reported event: it is the heart of the apostolic preaching. Paul, who like every Jew had been scandalized by the idea of a crucified Messiah, since "cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree" (Deut 21:23), made it the core of his proclamation: "We proclaim a crucified Messiah, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, but to those who are called, he is Christ, the power of God and the wisdom of God" (1 Cor 1:23-24). He takes up the curse of the Law and turns it around: "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the Law by becoming a curse for us" (Gal 3:13).
"We proclaim a crucified Messiah, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, but to those who are called, he is Christ, the power of God and the wisdom of God." — Saint Paul, 1 Cor 1:23-24
The Church has held together, without setting them against one another, several languages for expressing the one mystery. The language of sacrifice: Christ is the Lamb of God announced by John the Baptist (Jn 1:29), immolated at the hour of the Passover lambs, whose blood redeems the multitude (Mk 10:45). The language of fulfilment: the Servant of Isaiah 53, "pierced for our transgressions," whose text Philip explains to the Ethiopian eunuch in the earliest days of the Church (Acts 8:32-35). The language of victory: the cross, an instrument of shame, becomes the trophy where Christ "disarmed the principalities and powers and made a public example of them" (Col 2:15), which the liturgy sings in the hymn Vexilla Regis. The Catechism summarizes: "Love to the end confers on Christ's sacrifice its value of redemption and reparation, of expiation and satisfaction"[15].
This theology has never made suffering itself the price demanded by a cruel God: it affirms that the Son, freely, "gave himself up" (Gal 2:20), and that the Father "did not spare his own Son, but gave him up for us all" (Rom 8:32). The cry of abandonment and the trusting surrender of the spirit hold together the two faces of the mystery: the full reality of human suffering embraced, and the full filial trust that passes through death. See The Last Supper for the words of institution that give this death its sacramental meaning, and The Agony of Jesus in Gethsemane for the consent that precedes it.
The Cross in the Life of the Church: Liturgy and Devotion
The death of Christ is celebrated each year at the heart of the Easter Triduum, on Good Friday, in the Liturgy of the Passion: the reading of the Passion according to Saint John, the great universal prayer, the adoration of the cross, and Communion with the hosts consecrated the day before, since Good Friday is the only day of the year when Mass is not celebrated. The Feast of the Exaltation of the Holy Cross, on 14 September, commemorates the dedication of the Constantinian basilicas of Jerusalem and the veneration of the relic of the cross. Every Mass, moreover, calls to mind the death of the Lord in the anamnesis that follows the consecration: "We proclaim your death, O Lord Jesus, we profess your resurrection, we await your coming in glory"[16].
The sign of the cross, traced first on the forehead and then over the whole body, has become the Christian's most familiar gesture, and the crucifix, the representation of Christ nailed to the cross, the central image of Western Christian art. The Stations of the Cross, popularised by the Franciscan guardians of the holy places and then by Saint Alphonsus Liguori, lead meditation on the journey from the praetorium to the tomb in fourteen stations. The stigmata received by Saint Francis of Assisi on La Verna in 1224, and later by many mystics, have been received by the Church as a singular participation in the wounds of the Crucified, always discerned and never confused with the Gospel event itself.
Devotion to the five wounds, the Precious Blood, and the Sacred Heart prolongs this contemplation. In the wake of the Divine Will, the Hours of the Passion, meditated on the basis of the writings of Luisa Piccarreta, guide the faithful hour by hour through the day from Thursday evening to Friday evening; these meditations belong to private revelation so received and are to be read at that level, without taking the place of the Gospel accounts, which alone are authoritative. See The Temptations of Jesus in the Desert for the remote preparation for this battle, and The Entry of Jesus into Jerusalem for the opening of Holy Week.
Ancient Witnesses Outside the Gospels
The crucifixion under Pontius Pilate is one of the events in the life of Jesus attested also outside Christian texts. Tacite, a Roman historian with no sympathy for Christians, whom he describes as given to an abominable superstition, wrote around 116 that "the Christ, from whom the name had its origin, had undergone the sentence of death during the reign of Tiberius, at the hands of the procurator Pontius Pilate"[17]. Flavius Josephus, a Jewish historian of the first century, mentions the condemnation of Jesus by Pilate to the cross in a passage whose present form has been touched up by Christian copyists, but whose core — the crucifixion by Pilate at the instigation of the notables — is held to be authentic by the majority of historians who work on the text, including in the Arabic version, which preserves a less interpolated form[18].
The Babylonian Talmud preserves, in a passage of the tractate Sanhedrin, the distorted but real memory of an execution of Jesus on the eve of Passover, "hanged" after a herald had sought in vain for a defender[19]. The Acts of the Apostles, finally, shows that the earliest preaching, from Pentecost onwards, places the crucifixion at its centre and names it before the inhabitants of Jerusalem: "This Jesus whom you crucified, God has made both Lord and Christ" (Acts 2:36). The fact of death on the cross was never denied by the ancient opponents of Christianity: the pagan philosopher Celsus, in the second century, mocked it, which presupposes that he took it for granted[20]. The ancient debate concerned the meaning of this death, never its reality.
Objections and the Historical-Critical Debate
Part of contemporary exegesis acknowledges the crucifixion as the best-established fact in the life of Jesus, precisely because a crucified Messiah was a scandal that no community would have invented: this is the so-called criterion of embarrassment, applied here with particular force. The discussions concern rather the circumstances and the reading of the accounts. These should be set out with their limits.
The Date: 30 or 33, and the Relationship Between John and the Synoptics
The most discussed divergence concerns the exact day: the Synoptics make the Last Supper a Passover meal and place the crucifixion on 15 Nisan, whereas John places the crucifixion on 14 Nisan, the day of Preparation, at the hour when the lambs were slaughtered. Part of contemporary exegesis proposes seeing this as the reflection of different calendars in use in Jerusalem, or as a theological presentation by John identifying Jesus with the Paschal Lamb. Others maintain a strict harmony by reading John's Preparation as the Friday of the Passover week. The point to retain is that the disagreement concerns the reckoning of the day within the month, whereas the four accounts agree on Friday, on the proximity of Passover, and on the sequence: Supper, night-time arrest, morning trial, and crucifixion. A reconstruction that proceeds from a divergence of calendars to conclude that the whole is unreal takes a step that the data do not demand.
The Hours and the Darkness
The discrepancy between the third hour in Mark for the crucifixion and the sixth hour in John for the condemnation has given rise to many hypotheses of copying or of a different reckoning of the hours. Likewise, the darkness at noon is sometimes linked to an eclipse, a link that astronomers dismiss, since a solar eclipse is impossible at the time of the full moon of Passover and does not last three hours. The Gospel accounts, moreover, do not speak of an eclipse: they report darkness, in the language of the prophets, without giving its physical cause. To demand that the text be a weather record, and then declare it false because it is not one, amounts to imposing on it a literary genre that is not its own. The ancient historian Thallus, cited by Julius Africanus, already attempted to explain the darkness by an eclipse, which at least attests that the memory of unusual darkness circulated early[21].
The Phenomena and the Words
The earthquakes and the opened tombs, reported by Matthew alone, are often classified as symbolic additions. It is true that in Matthew they belong to a writing laden with references to the prophets; it does not follow that they have no anchoring whatsoever, and the argument from the silence of the other three evangelists does not prove the non-existence of a fact that they were not all meant to report in the same way. As for the seven words, their distribution across four independent accounts is precisely what one expects of complementary testimonies; the hypothesis that makes each one a creation of the community must explain why no community created the saying that best suited its own theology of the moment, and why Luke preserves both the forgiveness of the executioners and the prayer of abandonment replaced by trusting surrender.
The general limit of these reconstructions lies in their presuppositions: when the dating of an account is pushed back beyond the lifetime of the witnesses on the grounds that it contains a prophecy too precise, such as the ruin of Jerusalem announced before the crucifixion, the conclusion is already in the premise. The traditional attribution of the Gospels, upheld by Irenaeus, Papias, and the reception of the Churches, remains defensible, and it is by that standard that the accounts of the crucifixion must first be read: as the received testimony of those who were there, among them John, who declares that he saw the blood and water flow from the pierced side.
To go further
- The Passion according to the four Gospels for the overall account, from Gethsemane to the tomb.
- The trial of Jesus for the hearings before the Sanhedrin, Pilate and Herod that precede the condemnation.
- The Last Supper for the Passover meal of the previous evening and the words of institution of the Eucharist.
- The agony of Jesus in Gethsemane for the night of prayer and the arrest.
- The burial of Jesus for the taking down from the cross and the burial by Joseph of Arimathea.
- The descent into hell for Holy Saturday and the proclamation to the dead.
- The appearances of the Risen One for Easter morning and the encounters with the risen Christ.
Notes and References
Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 601: "This redemptive death of Jesus accomplishes in particular the prophecy of the Suffering Servant", with reference to Is 53:7-8 and Acts 8:32-35. Definitive edition, Mame/Plon, Paris, 1998.
1 13Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1: listing of the four Gospels and their authors, c. 180. Edition by A. Rousseau and L. Doutreleau, Sources chrétiennes 211, Cerf, Paris, 1974.
2 3Muratorian Fragment, list of the books received at Rome, late 2nd century, lines on Luke and John. Edition in E. Preuschen, Analecta, 2nd ed., Tübingen, 1910.
4Rylands Papyrus Gk. 457 (P52), fragment of Jn 18:31-33.37-38, dated to the first half of the 2nd century, John Rylands Library, Manchester. C. H. Roberts, An Unpublished Fragment of the Fourth Gospel, Manchester, 1935.
5Papias of Hierapolis, Fragments, c. 120, preserved in Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39, 15-16, on Mark as Peter's interpreter and on Matthew. Sources chrétiennes 31, Cerf, Paris, 1952.
6Cicero, Against Verres, II, 5, 165: the crucifixion torture described as most cruel and most hideous, and unworthy of a Roman citizen. Les Belles Lettres edition, Paris, 1929.
7Y. Yadin and N. Haas, work on the ossuary of Jehohanan, Giv'at ha-Mivtar, Jerusalem, 1968; N. Haas, "Anthropological Observations on the Skeletal Remains from Giv'at ha-Mivtar", Israel Exploration Journal, vol. 20, 1970, p. 38-59.
8Eusebius of Caesarea, Life of Constantine, III, 25-40: demolition of the temple of Venus, discovery of the tomb and construction of the basilicas, c. 337. Sources chrétiennes 559, Cerf, Paris, 2013.
9Sulpicius Severus, Chronicle, II, 33, on the discovery of the cross by Saint Helena; to be supplemented by Ambrose of Milan, De obitu Theodosii, 43-47. Sources chrétiennes 441, Cerf, Paris, 1999.
10Itinerarium Burdigalense, the Pilgrim of Bordeaux, 333, description of Jerusalem and the places of the Passion. Sources chrétiennes 320 (P. Maraval, Lieux saints et pèlerinages d'Orient), Cerf, Paris, 1985.
11C. J. Humphreys and W. G. Waddington, "Dating the Crucifixion", Nature, vol. 306, 1983, p. 743-746: astronomical calculations favouring 3 April 33, to be discussed alongside 7 April 30.
12Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 964: Mary's role "toward the Church and all humanity" extends to the cross, where she is given as mother to the disciple, Mame/Plon, Paris, 1998.
14Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 616: "It is love to the end (Jn 13:1) that confers on Christ's sacrifice its value of redemption and reparation, of expiation and satisfaction", Mame/Plon, Paris, 1998.
15Roman Missal, Eucharistic prayer, anamnesis of the people: "We proclaim your death, O Lord Jesus, we proclaim your resurrection, we await your coming in glory." Desclée-Mame, Paris, typical edition.
16Tacitus, Annals, XV, 44, 3: "the Christ had undergone the penalty under the reign of Tiberius, by the hands of the procurator Pontius Pilate", c. 116. Les Belles Lettres edition, Paris, 1990.
17Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 63-64 (Testimonium Flavianum); on the authentic core and the Arabic version of Agapius, S. Pines, An Arabic Version of the Testimonium Flavianum, Jerusalem, 1971.
18Babylonian Talmud, tractate Sanhedrin 43a: memory of an execution on the eve of Passover. Soncino edition, London, 1935.
19Celsus, True Discourse, c. 177, fragments preserved in Origen, Against Celsus, I-II: mockery of the crucifixion, which presupposes the fact as taken for granted. Sources chrétiennes 132, Cerf, Paris, 1967.
20Thallus, History, fragment cited by Africanus and preserved by George the Syncellus, Chronography: attempt to explain the darkness by an eclipse. Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker 256.
21