The Apparitions of the Risen One

The apparitions of the Risen One in the Bible: Mary Magdalene, Cephas, Emmaus, Thomas, the Sea of Tiberias, five hundred brothers, James and Paul, what the texts say and why their witnesses hold fast.

Ignispedia

The appearances of the Risen Lord are the encounters by which Jesus, on Easter morning and during forty days, showed himself alive to his disciples after his death and burial. They form the verifiable heart of the Easter proclamation: before any development, the faith of the Church rests on a list of names, places, and days. Christ died, he was buried, he rose again on the third day, he appeared.

These encounters are neither inner visions recounted after the fact, nor a rumor that grows over time. The earliest texts present them as public events in their order: a named woman, a named apostle, a counted group, a persecutor turned around. A hurried reader may retain this: the empty tomb opens the case, the appearances fill it with witnesses, and the Church is born from these witnesses.

This article presents the appearances as Sacred Scripture received by the Church: their place in the canon, the traditional authors and datings of the accounts, the earliest summary handed on by Saint Paul, each encounter in its order, the chronology and geography of the forty days, the theology of the glorious body, the liturgical remembrance of Easter, and then, at the end of the journey, the objections and the historical-critical debate with its limits. For the death that precedes, see The Crucifixion of Jesus; for the burial and the tomb, The Burial of Jesus; for the sojourn among the dead, The Descent into Hell; for the fortieth day, The Ascension of Jesus is the subject of its own article and appears here only as the end of the journey.

The appearances in the canon of Scripture

The earliest summary: the list received by Paul

The oldest text that names the appearances is not a Gospel: it is a formula that Saint Paul hands on to the Corinthians around the middle of the 50s, some twenty years after the events, stating that he himself received it[1]. The formula is brief, rhythmic, made to be learned and repeated: death, burial, resurrection, appearances. It does not yet narrate the scenes; it already gives the list of witnesses, in an order that governs the whole case.

"For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures; that he was buried; that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures; that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve."

First Letter to the Corinthians, 15:3-5[2]

Paul at once extends the list beyond the circle of the Twelve: more than five hundred brethren at once, most of whom are still alive at the time he writes, then James, then all the apostles, then himself last of all[3]. This detail matters: an author inventing a legend does not point to hundreds of still-living witnesses whom his readers can go and question. The received formula presupposes a community that knows the names and can verify them.

Paul's vocabulary is technical: to transmit and to receive designate, in the Judaism of his time as in his own usage, the faithful handing on of a teaching that comes from before oneself[4]. The list of 1 Corinthians 15 is therefore not Paul's literary creation around 55: it goes back, by his own admission, to what he received, hence to the very earliest years of the Church of Jerusalem, in the company of Cephas and James, whom he says he visited shortly after his conversion[5].

Four accounts, one same morning and forty days

The four Gospels unfold what Paul's formula summarizes. The table below gives the passages that structure the case: it reads like a map, before the continuous account.

PassageWhat the account contributes of its own about the appearances
Mt 28The women at the tomb, the meeting on the way, the rendezvous in Galilee, the universal mission
Mk 16:9-20Mary Magdalene first, the two disciples on the road, the Eleven at table, the sending and the Ascension summarized
Lk 24Emmaus, the appearance in the midst of the disciples, the touchable body, the meal, the opening of the Scriptures
Jn 20-21Mary Magdalene in the garden, the evening with closed doors, Thomas eight days later, the Sea of Tiberias and Peter
Acts 1:3The setting of the forty days, the many proofs, the Kingdom proclaimed before the Ascension
1 Cor 15:3-8The earliest list: Cephas, the Twelve, five hundred brethren, James, all the apostles, Paul
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

No single account is sufficient by itself: Matthew gives Galilee and the mission, Mark the rapid succession of witnesses, Luke the pedagogy of Emmaus and the proof of the body, John the personal encounters and the restoration of Peter. Received together, as the Church has always read them, they describe one same event under four lights that intersect without copying one another, with the divergences of detail proper to distinct testimonies and the constant agreement on the core: the Crucified is alive, he shows himself, he sends.

The received authors and the ancient witnesses

The Church receives these accounts as the work of the evangelists whom tradition has named from the beginning: Matthew the apostle, Mark the interpreter of Peter, Luke the companion of Paul, John the beloved disciple. The earliest witness to the whole is Saint Irenaeus, disciple of Polycarp, who had known John: around 180, he lists the four Gospels and their authors[6].

"John, the disciple of the Lord, the one who had reclined on his breast, also published the Gospel, during his sojourn at Ephesus, in Asia."

Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1[7]

The ancient relays succeed one another without break: Papias, cited by Eusebius, reports that Mark wrote down exactly, but without order, what he held from Peter's preaching, and that Matthew collected the words of the Lord in the Hebrew language[8]; the Muratorian Fragment, around the end of the second century, counts Luke as the third Gospel and John as the fourth[9]. The Council of Trent fixed the canon by receiving these books entire with all their parts[10].

The traditional dating remains defensible without acrobatics: Matthew in the 40s to 60s, Mark in Rome in the 60s, Luke around 60 to 63, John at Ephesus in the 90s to 100. Papyrus P52, a fragment of John copied around 125, and Papyrus P75, which joins Luke and John at the beginning of the third century, show the texts already circulated far from their place of origin a generation after their composition[11]. The Pontifical Biblical Commission confirmed on 29 May 1907 that it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of the fourth Gospel, a historical account of the deeds and the real discourses of the life of the Lord[12]. Vatican II holds the same line for the four accounts[13].

"Holy Mother Church has firmly held and holds that these four Gospels, whose historicity she affirms without hesitation, faithfully hand on what Jesus, the Son of God, during his life among men, really did and taught for their eternal salvation."

Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19[14]

The ending of Mark, received in the canon

An honesty is called for here, and the article places it at the canon stage rather than discovering it as an objection: the last twelve verses of Mark, which summarise the appearances to Mary Magdalene, to the two disciples and to the Eleven, are missing in two great fourth-century codices, and some ancient witnesses stop at the women's flight before the empty tomb[15]. The fact is real, it has been known since antiquity, and neither Eusebius nor Jerome concealed it[16].

It does not, however, overturn the Church's reception, for three dated reasons. First, Saint Irenaeus, around 180, therefore well before the codices in question, already quotes the long ending as Mark's word, including the Ascension it summarises[17]. Next, the ending circulates widely in the ancient manuscript and liturgical tradition, and the Latin Church reads it for the feast of the Ascension[18]. Finally, the Council of Trent received the Gospel of Mark in its entirety with all its parts, in the form transmitted by the Vulgate and consecrated by the usage of the Church[19]. The textual question concerns the history of copying; the canonical reception, for its part, is settled, and the content of the ending merely summarises what Luke and John recount at length. The scholarly debate will find its place at the end of the article; it cannot serve as a neutral framework to open the file.

Easter morning: the women, Mary Magdalene, Peter

The empty tomb, threshold of the appearances

The appearances begin with a constated absence. On the first day of the week, at early dawn, Mary Magdalene and the women who had watched the burial return with the spices prepared before the Sabbath rest, and find the stone rolled away and the tomb empty[20]. The empty tomb is not yet an appearance: it does not say where Jesus is, it says only that he is no longer where Joseph had laid him. That is precisely why it counts: it gives the encounters that follow a verifiable place, an absent body to explain, and named witnesses who arrive before any official account.

The angelic announcement, in the four traditions, sends the women back to the disciples and to Galilee, with a word that runs through the whole file: he goes before you[21]. Peter, informed, runs to the tomb with the other disciple: he sees the cloths, the burial cloth rolled up separately, and the text soberly notes that the beloved disciple saw and believed, before any encounter[22]. Paschal faith is thus born in dated stages: an empty tomb, a word, a race, and only then the appearances. A story invented all at once would have shown the Risen One to everyone at the same instant; the Gospels preserve the laborious order of human steps.

Mary Magdalene, first messenger

The first appearance recounted at length is granted to Mary Magdalene, who had remained alone near the tomb after Peter and John left. John shows her weeping, bending over the tomb, then turning towards the one she takes for the gardener, until the moment when her name turns her whole self around[23].

"Jesus said to her: Mary! She turned and said to him in Hebrew: Rabbouni!, which means: Teacher."

Gospel according to Saint John, 20:16[24]

The Risen One stops her at a gesture and sends her on a mission: do not hold me, go find my brothers and tell them that I am going up to my Father and your Father[25]. Mary Magdalene then runs to announce to the disciples that she has seen the Lord and what he said to her[26]. Mark summarises the same priority: risen on the morning of the first day, Jesus appeared first to Mary Magdalene, from whom he had cast out seven demons, and it was she who went to announce it to those who had been with him, in mourning and in tears[27]. Matthew joins to the scene the other women, seized together on the way back, Jesus coming to meet them and charging them to warn his brothers to go to Galilee[28].

The Aedicule of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, traditional site of Jesus' tomb, in its current state. Photo: Gary Todd, 2018, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 licence.

The Catechism underlines the exact place of these women: come to complete the anointing of the body hastily buried, they are the first to meet the Risen One, and the women thus become the first messengers of the Resurrection for the apostles themselves[29]. In a culture where a woman's testimony did not found a public case, no inventor anxious to convince would have entrusted the first announcement to Mary Magdalene, a former possessed woman, weeping alone in a garden. This embarrassing feature, preserved by the four traditions, is one of the firmest indications that the accounts transmit a memory rather than fabricate a proof.

Cephas: the appearance Paul puts first

Paul does not name Mary Magdalene; he opens his list with Cephas, that is, Peter[30]. Luke preserves the living trace of this apostolic priority: on the return from Emmaus, the two disciples find the Eleven assembled who tell them that the Lord has risen and that he has appeared to Simon[31].

"It is true! The Lord has risen and he has appeared to Simon-Peter."

Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24:34[32]

No Gospel recounts the scene itself. This silence is remarkable: the head of the apostles, who has just denied three times during the night of the trial, receives an encounter that the modesty of the texts leaves in the shadow, known only by the announcement that it took place. Paul, who visited Cephas in Jerusalem shortly after his own conversion and stayed fifteen days with him[33], held this fact from a direct witness. Peter's restoration will be recounted at length only on the shore of the Sea of Tiberias; but from Easter morning, the earliest list puts the pardoned renegade at the head of the appearances to the apostles. The Church did not erase the fall to embellish the witness: she kept the fall, the forgiveness and the charge, in that order.

The same day: Emmaus and the evening in the Upper Room

On the road to Emmaus, hearts burning

That same day, two disciples leave Jerusalem for Emmaus, about eleven kilometres away, discussing everything that has happened: the powerful prophet, the condemnation, the crucifixion, the empty tomb reported by the women, and their disappointed hope[34]. A traveller joins them; they do not recognise him, and he reproaches them for their slowness to believe before opening the Scriptures to them, from Moses and the prophets, in everything that concerned him[35].

"Were not our hearts burning within us while he spoke to us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us?"

Gospel of Saint Luke, 24, 32[36]

They press him to stay at the entrance to the village, and it is at table, when he takes the bread, blesses it, breaks it and gives it to them, that their eyes are opened and they recognise him, at the very moment he vanishes from their sight[37]. They rise up that very hour, return to Jerusalem by night, and recount what happened on the road and how they recognised him in the breaking of the bread[38]. Mark summarises the same appearance in brief form: Jesus manifested himself under another appearance to two of them as they were walking into the country, and the Eleven did not believe them either[39].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Emmaus gives the Easter dossier its complete pedagogy: a shattered hope, a Scripture re-read, a heart that burns before understanding, a broken bread that brings recognition, and a night-time run that turns two fugitives into witnesses. Luke, who will open Acts with forty days of teaching about the Kingdom, sets down from the very first day this lesson: the Risen One allows himself to be recognised in the Scriptures explained and in the gesture of the meal, not in satisfied curiosity. It is also the only appearance in which the witnesses fail to recognise him for a long time before knowing him, which makes the account unusable as a mere hallucination of expectation: they were waiting for a liberator of Israel, they meet a stranger who must first reshape their reading of the Bible.

That evening, doors closed: touch, look, eat

On the evening of that same day, the disciples are gathered in Jerusalem, the doors locked for fear, when Jesus comes among them and says to them: peace be with you[40]. Luke recounts the same coming with a realism that borders on the uncomfortable: seized with fright, they think they are seeing a spirit, and the Risen One must dispel their bewilderment with his hands, his feet and a piece of grilled fish eaten before them[41].

"Look at my hands and my feet: it is I myself! Touch me and see: a spirit has not flesh and bones as you see that I have."

Gospel of Saint Luke, 24, 39[42]

He shows them his hands and his feet; then, as they still cannot believe for joy, he asks to eat and takes the fish before them[43]. John adds the gift that makes this evening the birth of the confessing Church: he breathes on them, gives the Holy Spirit and entrusts the power to forgive sins[44]. Luke adds the other half of the gift: he opens their minds to the Scriptures and makes them witnesses of the death, the resurrection and the repentance proclaimed to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem[45].

This evening appearance settles the question that the whole dossier must hold: the Risen One is neither a ghost, nor a revived corpse simply resuming his old life, nor an idea that consoles. It is the same Jesus, recognisable by his wounds, able to eat, and at the same time free with regard to locked doors and distances. The disciples pass in a single evening from fear to joy, but the text takes care to note their initial bewilderment and their slowness: the first witnesses are not enthusiasts awaiting a prodigy, they are defeated men who must be convinced.

Saint Ignatius of Antioch, a generation after the apostles, already hands down this insistence on the tangible body of the Risen One against those who reduced him to an appearance: after his resurrection, Jesus ate and drank with his own like a being of flesh, although he was spiritually united to the Father[46]. The controversy is old because the temptation is old: as early as the first century, it was easier to admit a Christ-spirit than a Christ risen in his flesh. The Gospels answer in advance with a grilled fish.

Eight Days Later, by the Shore of the Lake, in Galilee

Thomas: doubt named, touched, and healed

Thomas, one of the Twelve, was not there on the evening of Easter. At the others' announcement, he sets a condition that no forger would invent for his collective hero: unless I see in his hands the mark of the nails, unless I put my finger into the mark of the nails and my hand into his side, no, I will not believe[47]. Eight days later, the disciples are gathered again, Thomas with them, the doors locked, and Jesus comes into their midst with the same word of peace[48].

"Put your finger here, and see my hands; reach out your hand, and put it in my side: cease to be unbelieving, be believing."

Gospel according to Saint John, 20:27[49]

The text does not say that Thomas touched. It gives his response, which is the highest confession of the fourth gospel: my Lord and my God[50]. Jesus receives it and at once turns the scene toward future readers: because you have seen me, you believe; blessed are those who believe without having seen[51]. Saint Gregory the Great, commenting on this page for Easter preaching, draws from it the law of the whole dossier: Thomas's doubt, by feeling the scars, heals in us the wounds of unbelief, and his late touch serves the faith of the absent more than the prompt faith of the present[52].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The episode is read every year on the Second Sunday of Easter, now the Sunday of Divine Mercy: the Church recognizes in it her own portrait. She believes without having seen, on the word of witnesses who have seen, touched, and first doubted. Thomas is not the unbeliever punished; he is the demanding witness whose condition, taken seriously by the Risen One himself, silences the objection of a credulous faith that would have believed without proof.

At the Lake of Tiberias: the work, the meal, and Peter restored

John then recounts a manifestation by the Sea of Tiberias, the third to the assembled disciples by his own count[53]. Simon Peter goes back to fishing, six others follow him, the night catches nothing; at daybreak, Jesus stands on the shore unrecognized, tells them to cast the net on the right, and the catch becomes superabundant: one hundred and fifty-three large fish, without the net tearing[54]. The beloved disciple is the first to recognize: it is the Lord, and Peter throws himself into the water[55]. On the shore, a charcoal fire is already ready, with fish and bread; Jesus invites them to eat, takes the bread and gives it to them[56].

After the meal comes the solemn restoration of Peter, in three questions that answer his three denials at the fire in the high priest's courtyard[57]. The Risen One asks him neither for excuses nor for explanations about the night of the trial; he asks him for his love, and at each answer he entrusts the flock to him: feed my lambs, be the shepherd of my sheep, feed my sheep[58].

"Simon, son of John, do you truly love me, more than these? Yes, Lord! You know it: I love you. Jesus said to him: Be the shepherd of my lambs."

Gospel according to Saint John, 21:15[59]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The scene completes what the private appearance to Cephas had begun in secret: the first witness on Paul's list becomes the shepherd publicly, not because he did not fail, but because the Risen One raised him up. A propaganda account would have erased the denial or invented an excuse; John keeps both fires, that of the denial and that of forgiveness, and lets the reader make the connection.

The mountain of Galilee: all of them, some doubts, the sending

Matthew closes his gospel where the angel and Jesus had set the rendez-vous on the morning of Easter: in Galilee, on the mountain that Jesus had designated to them[60]. The Eleven go there, see him, fall down in worship, and the evangelist notes without gloss that some doubted, in the same sentence as the adoration[61]. It is from this mountain, and not from a locked room, that the order goes out which founds the universal Church[62].

"Go! Make disciples of all nations: baptize them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, teach them to observe everything I have commanded you. And I am with you all days, even to the end of the world."

Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28:19-20[63]

Jerusalem and Galilee. Topography without modern borders: Eric Gaba and NordNordWest, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; landmarks added. The location of Emmaus remains debated.

The contrast is measured: the same book that had opened the public life with the Sermon on a mountain of Galilee closes it with the sending from a mountain of Galilee, with the Trinitarian formula of baptism and the promise of a daily presence. The apparitions are therefore not a consoling epilogue after the failure of the Cross; they are the starting point of a mission of which the eyewitnesses are the guarantors. The one who says "I am with you" is the one they saw alive after having seen him dead.

Those named only by Paul: five hundred brothers, James, Paul

More than five hundred brothers at once

Between the Twelve and James, Paul inserts an appearance that no Gospel recounts: Jesus appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still alive, though some have died[64]. The Gospels' silence about this immense scene and its lack of any picturesque detail are themselves instructive: Paul's list is not a summary of the Gospels but an independent tradition, older than them in its wording, which preserves a fact the detailed narratives did not retain.

The number is a difficulty for every fragile hypothesis. A hallucination is a private event; a subjective vision is told in the first person; a legend grows with time. Paul, around 55, instead points to a counted group, gathered at once, and still mostly alive and therefore interviewable at the time of writing. He gives neither the place nor the day, which rules out making it a narrative; but he gives the fact and the witnesses, which is precisely the form of a public argument. The reader in Corinth who doubted could write, travel, ask: the five hundred were not an image — they were addresses.

James, the brother of the Lord

Paul then names James, before moving on to all the apostles[65]. This is James, the brother of the Lord, who would become the head of the Church of Jerusalem, the one Paul visits with Cephas and whom he calls a pillar of the Church[66]. Yet the Gospels show Jesus' brothers, during his public life, in misunderstanding and at a distance from his mission[67]. The man who did not follow his brother during his lifetime presides, a few years later, over the mother Church at the cost of his life, and ancient tradition preserves the portrait of a just man respected throughout Jerusalem[68].

Between the family's unbelief and James' primacy, the texts place an appearance that only Paul lists. No convenient explanation accounts for the reversal: one does not become the head of a persecuted community over a crucified brother one kept away from, because others supposedly had visions. James saw, and his entire life, down to his violent death in Jerusalem, is the signature of what he saw[69]. His person will be treated elsewhere; here, his name in Paul's list is enough: he is a witness snatched from the camp of the indifferent.

All the apostles, then Paul, the last

The list closes with two groups: all the apostles, beyond the Twelve, then Paul himself, last, like one untimely born[70]. Paul does not slip into the series of appearances in Jerusalem and Galilee; he claims a distinct encounter, on the road to Damascus, while he was persecuting the Church, and he tells it three times in Acts with the same structure: a light, a voice, a name, a sending[71]. In his own defense, he poses the question that sums up his case: am I not an apostle, have I not seen Jesus our Lord[72]?

The case of Paul is the counterpart of the case of James. James did not believe and becomes a leader; Paul fought and becomes apostle to the nations. Between the two, Paul's list lines up witnesses whom everything sets apart: a woman in the garden, a renegade restored, two fleeing disciples brought back, an unbeliever convinced by the very terms of his demand, five hundred brothers together, an indifferent brother, a persecutor. A communal invention would have produced homogeneous and immediately credible witnesses; the tradition has preserved embarrassing, slow, divided witnesses, who were unanimous only on one point: they saw him alive.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The table below brings together the complete list, in the order the sources give it, to serve as a reference for the whole dossier.

Witness or groupMain sourceWhat the appearance establishes
Mary Magdalene and the womenJn 20, 11-18; Mt 28, 9-10; Mk 16, 9The first recounted encounter, the announcement to the apostles
Cephas (Peter)1 Cor 15, 5; Lk 24, 34The first apostolic witness, the renegade restored
The two disciples of EmmausLk 24, 13-35; Mk 16, 12-13Scripture opened, the breaking of the bread
The Eleven, on Easter eveningLk 24, 36-43; Jn 20, 19-23The body that can be touched, the gift of the Spirit, the mission of forgiveness
The Eleven with ThomasJn 20, 24-29Doubt examined, the confession of faith
Seven disciples at the Sea of TiberiasJn 21, 1-23Peter restored and entrusted with the flock
The Eleven in GalileeMt 28, 16-20The universal sending and the promise of presence
More than five hundred brothers1 Cor 15, 6The counted group, still alive around 55
James, the brother of the Lord1 Cor 15, 7The indifferent one who became head of Jerusalem
All the apostles1 Cor 15, 7The widened college of witnesses
Paul, last1 Cor 15, 8; Acts 9The persecutor who became an apostle

Forty days: chronology and geography

A framework given by Luke: forty days

Luke alone gives the dossier its complete framework. At the beginning of Acts, he summarizes the interval between the Resurrection and the Ascension: Jesus, after his Passion, presented himself alive to the apostles with many proofs, appearing to them during forty days and speaking of the Kingdom of God[73].

« It was to them that, after his Passion, he presented himself alive, with many proofs, appearing to them during forty days and speaking of the Kingdom of God. »

Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 1, 3[74]

This framework orders what the Gospels narrate without dating each event. The first day brings together the empty tomb, Mary Magdalene, Emmaus and the evening in the Cenacle. The eighth day gives Thomas. Between Jerusalem and Galilee lie the Sea of Tiberias, the mountain of the commissioning and, without precise date, the appearances to the five hundred and to James. The fortieth day concludes with the Ascension, which is the subject of The Ascension of Jesus and enters here only as a final boundary. Paul, years later, places himself outside this framework, last of all, without confusing it with the forty days.

  1. First day, Easter Sunday
    The empty tomb and the first encounters

    Early in the morning, the women find the empty tomb; Mary Magdalene meets the Risen One in the garden; Cephas sees him; in the evening, the disciples of Emmaus recognize him in the breaking of the bread and the Eleven receive him behind closed doors (Jn 20; Lk 24).

  2. Eight days after Easter
    Thomas with the Eleven

    The disciples are gathered again, Thomas being present, and the Risen One invites him to move his finger to his wounds; Thomas replies: my Lord and my God (Jn 20, 26-28).

  3. During the forty days
    Galilee, the Sea of Tiberias and the commissioning

    By the lake, the catch of the one hundred and fifty-three fish and the restoration of Peter (Jn 21); on the mountain of Galilee, the mission to all nations (Mt 28, 16-20); the appearances to the five hundred brethren and to James, with no place or day specified (1 Co 15, 6-7).

  4. Fortieth day
    The end of the Jerusalem appearances

    After forty days of appearances and teaching about the Kingdom, the Risen One is lifted up to heaven before the eyes of the apostles: this is the Ascension, dealt with in its own article (Ac 1, 3-11).

  5. A few years later
    Paul, the last witness

    On the road to Damascus, the persecutor meets the Risen One and places himself last in the list, like an untimely birth (1 Co 15, 8; Ac 9).

Two poles: Jerusalem and Galilee

The geography of the appearances comes down to two poles that the narratives never confuse. Jerusalem gives the tomb, the garden, the upper room, Emmaus eleven kilometres away and the recent scandal of the Cross: it is the place of danger, where the disciples lock themselves in. Galilee gives the lake of the first call, the mountain of the teaching and the rendezvous announced from the morning of Easter: it is the place of the mission regained, where the fishermen become apostles again.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

This double anchoring rules out a floating account. The witnesses do not see the Risen One just anywhere, in the exaltation of a new cult; they meet him first where he died and was buried, before the identifiable tomb, then where he had called them, in the land of their ordinary work. Between the two, an eleven-kilometre road travelled twice in the same day, by day while fleeing and at night while running. The precision of places, like that of names, belongs to the very form of apostolic testimony: Peter, in his preaching reported by Luke, sums up that God raised Jesus and that the apostles, who ate and drank with him after his resurrection, are the witnesses chosen in advance[75].

One same body, transfigured: the theology of the appearances

The same, recognisable, and yet new

The whole dossier rests in a tension that the narratives never relax. On the one hand, identity is hammered home: it is really me, see my hands and my feet, touch and see, the wounds of the Cross are the identity card of the Risen One[76]. On the other, the newness is just as constant: he enters through closed doors, he disappears at the moment of the breaking of the bread, he is not recognised at first in the garden nor on the road nor on the shore, Mary Magdalene must hear her name, the disciples of Emmaus must receive the Scripture and the bread, Peter must hear the net filling to understand.

Catholic theology reads these two series together, sacrificing neither. The body of the Risen One is the true body born of the Virgin, crucified and buried, but passed into glory: it is no longer subject to death, to hunger by necessity, to locks or to distances, without ceasing to be flesh and bones, able to eat a fish before witnesses[77]. The Catechism puts it this way: the Resurrection of Christ was not a return to earthly life, as with the resurrections worked before Easter, but the passage from one state to another, beyond time and space, in a body both authentic and endowed with new properties[78].

Saint Thomas Aquinas devotes an entire question of the Summa to this point: after the resurrection of Christ, he examines the quality of his risen body, then the way in which this resurrection was manifested to the disciples[79]. From this he draws out the properties that the scholastic tradition will class under the four gifts of the glorious body, promised to all the risen of whom Christ is the first: impassibility, which can no longer suffer or die; clarity, which shines with the glory of the soul; agility, free with regard to distances; subtlety, free with regard to obstacles, as in the entrance through closed doors[80]. The appearances furnish the illustrations one by one: the wounds kept without pain, the veiled then luminous recognition, Emmaus and Jerusalem in the same evening, the locked room passed through without being forced.

Why not a manifestation to all

An objection has returned since antiquity: if Jesus has risen, why did he not show himself to Pilate, to the Sanhedrin, to all Jerusalem? Thomas raises the question from the first article of his question on the manifestation: should the resurrection of Christ be manifested to all[81]? His answer follows the very order of the narratives: the resurrection, which already belongs to the glorious life and no longer to the common order of this world, was not to be proved by a permanent public display, but manifested to chosen witnesses, whose testimony would ground the faith of all the others[82].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Saint Augustine had already classified the matter in his harmony of the evangelists, comparing the notices of the four Gospels with Paul and Acts to establish the order of the manifestations, from the first to the last[83]. The choice of witnesses is not a defect in the dossier; it is its legal form: God, who had chosen witnesses for the hidden Incarnation of Bethlehem, chooses witnesses for the Resurrection, and sends them. The faith of the whole Church thus rests, in a manner both assumed and verifiable in the texts, on a short chain: men and women named have seen, then have spoken, then have died saying it.

Cause of our resurrection, firstfruits of those who sleep

Paul never separates the appearances from their fruit. The same chapter that lines up the witnesses continues: Christ has been raised from the dead, firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep, and as all die in Adam, so all will receive life in Christ[84]. Without resurrection, he adds with a frankness that ruins symbolic readings, the preaching is empty, the faith is in vain, the apostles are false witnesses and the dead in Christ are lost[85].

« If Christ has not been raised, our proclamation is without content, your faith too is without content. »

First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 14[86]

The Catechism takes up this architecture: a historical event attested by the empty tomb and the encounters, the Resurrection is at the same time, at the heart of the mystery of faith, a transcendence that surpasses history without ceasing to be inscribed in it through witnesses[87]. It is finally the common work of the Trinity and the promise of our own: the baptized, buried with Christ through baptism, is called to walk in new life already here below, awaiting the moment of rising with him[88]. The apparitions are therefore not merely proofs lined up to convince a skeptic; they are the first form of the life of the world to come, shown for forty days to those who would have to proclaim it.

What the Church celebrates: the apparitions in the liturgy

The octave and the Sundays of the Easter season

The Church does not file these accounts away in a chapter of ancient history: she rereads them each year, in the very order of the encounters. During the Octave of Easter, the Latin liturgy lets us hear in succession the women at the tomb, Mary Magdalene in the garden, the disciples of Emmaus, the appearance in the midst of the disciples, the Sea of Tiberias, and Mark's summary: the week following Easter retraces, day after day, the path of the first witnesses[89]. The second Sunday of Easter gives us Thomas and the beatitude of those who believe without having seen, and the Church celebrates Divine Mercy there, the Risen One with open wounds standing in the midst of his own[90].

The Easter season prolongs this reading for fifty days, until Pentecost: the Acts of the Apostles hold the place of the first reading there, as the continuous account of what the witnesses did with what they had seen, and the Sunday Gospels return to the apparitions, the Good Shepherd, and the farewell discourse of the Cenacle[91]. The structure is a catechesis: before recounting the Church, the liturgy makes us hear again, every spring, the forty days that founded it.

Regina Caeli and Via Lucis: praying with the witnesses

Two forms of popular prayer carry the memory of the apparitions. Throughout the Easter season, the antiphon Regina Caeli replaces the Angelus: the Church there addresses the Queen of heaven, congratulating her on the Resurrection of her Son, and tradition has sung it since the heart of the Middle Ages in the evening prayer of religious communities before its universal spread[92]. Its cry is simple: the one you were deemed worthy to bear has risen, as he said.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

More recent, the Via Lucis, or way of light, transposes onto the Easter season the form of the Stations of the Cross: fourteen stations meditate on the apparitions of the Risen One, from the empty tomb to Pentecost, following the accounts of the Gospels and the Acts[93]. The Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy, published by the Congregation for Divine Worship in December 2001, explicitly recommends it: by meditating on the apparitions of the risen Christ, the faithful are led to bear witness in their turn to the resurrection[94]. The devotion states exactly the doctrine of this article: the apparitions are not contemplated like a closed album; they send out those who meditate on them.

Objections, historical-critical debate and limits

First objection: the stolen body

The oldest objection is already in the Gospel. Matthew reports that the guards, having come to announce the empty tomb to the chief priests, receive money to say that the disciples came by night to steal the body while they slept, and he notes that this account has spread to this day[95]. The polemic is thus contemporary with the claimed events: from the 1st century onward, the empty tomb is a disputed fact, not a late invention that no one would have contested.

The answer lies with the witnesses themselves. Body-snatchers do not die for a lie they have fabricated; a Peter who has just denied out of fear does not become, within a few weeks, the public preacher of Jerusalem, at the very place of the guarded tomb, without anyone opposing the body to him. Above all, the theft explains at best an empty tomb; it explains neither the repeated encounters, nor James, nor Paul, nor the lasting transformation of a scattered group into organized witnesses around a list of names that Paul can still cite twenty years later.

Second objection: an apparent death

The theory of a Jesus who merely fainted, revived by the coolness of the tomb, has circulated in learned or novelistic forms. It clashes with the entire chain of gestures recounted: flagellation, attested crucifixion, the lance thrust in John, the centurion's verification in Mark, a body bound in cloths and laden with spices, a rolled stone[96]. A disfigured survivor, crawling out of a guarded tomb, would have inspired pity and care, not the proclamation of a glorious Lord entering through closed doors and eating out of condescension. The apparitions describe a transfigured living one, not a convalescent survivor; one would therefore have to add to the improbable awakening a metamorphosis of the perception of all the witnesses, which displaces the hypothesis without making it any simpler.

Third objection: visions, hallucinations and disappointed hope

The explanation by subjective vision has a long history: the disciples, deeply shaken, were said to have projected their hope or their guilt into apparitions, and then the community transformed these inner experiences into accounts of encounters. David Friedrich Strauss, in the nineteenth century, gave this reading its classic mythic form, and part of modern exegesis has taken it up under varied psychological or sociological vocabularies[97].

It founders on the very diversity of the witnesses lined up by the sources. A hallucination is individual and contagious only under narrow conditions; it does not occur at once in a lone woman in the garden, two disappointed walkers who do not recognize their companion, eleven locked-in men who believe they see a spirit, an absent one who sets his conditions, five hundred gathered brothers, an indifferent brother, and a persecutor on mission. It explains neither the empty tomb, which the adversaries themselves dispute already in Matthew, nor why first-century Jews would have invented an individual resurrection before the end of time, a category their religious framework did not provide for in this way. It assumes finally that grief naturally produces faith in a glorious, touchable, eating body, whereas the accounts show everywhere the opposite movement: unbelief first, recognition afterward, and often against the expectation of the witnesses.

Fourth objection: contradictory accounts, therefore legendary

The divergences between the four accounts are real: the number and names of the women vary, the comings and goings to the tomb do not overlap step for step, the order of the apparitions between Jerusalem and Galilee demands a work of harmonization that Saint Augustine already undertook with care[98]. A hasty reading concludes that witnesses who diverge on the circumstances cannot agree on the fact.

The conclusion overshoots its premise. Independent accounts telling of a concerted invention would converge on the verifiable details; distinct testimonies converge on the core and diverge on the order, the messengers, and the routes, as do the depositions about one and the same event seen from different vantage points. Augustine does not hide these discrepancies: he compares them notice by notice, including with Paul and the Acts, and maintains the harmony on the succession of the principal manifestations[99]. Honest criticism may discuss any particular harmonization; it cannot turn the presence of variants, which is the ordinary condition of ancient testimony, into proof of the absence of an event.

What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

A part of contemporary exegesis proposes to read the apparitions as the narrative shaping, a generation after the events, of visionary experiences of the first disciples, in Gospels written late by anonymous communities rather than by the witnesses named by tradition. Rudolf Bultmann gave this program its most influential twentieth-century form: the Easter kerygma would count as the word of faith, while the apparition accounts would amount to a secondary objectification to be demythologized[100]. Presented fairly, this reading has the merit of taking seriously the literary form of the accounts and the distance between the event and its final writing.

Its limits must be stated with equal fairness. It often rests on hypothetical reconstructions of oral traditions that no one has preserved, on circular datings in which texts are dated by the theology attributed to them and then that theology is proved by those dates, and on a presupposition that rules out in advance precise prophecy and miracle as historical possibilities[101]. It makes massive use of the argument from silence: Mark would stop at the empty tomb, so the apparitions would be an addition; Paul would be unaware of the empty tomb, so he would genuinely have been unaware of it. It extrapolates from incomplete clues—the ending of Mark or a variant involving the women—to reconstruct a complete history of Christian origins. It finally treats the Tradition that names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John as suspect in principle, while granting considerable credit to anonymous communities whose place or leader it cannot cite.

Benedict XVI warned, in his exhortation on the Word of God, against an exegesis that would dissolve the text into scholarly strata without ever encountering the persons or the event they attest[102]. The traditional position remains defensible today for positive reasons, and not out of a refusal of criticism: a received formula, dated to the earliest years, already names the witnesses; independent accounts converge on the core while diverging on the details; the witnesses are embarrassing, slow, and transformed against their expectations; two of the greatest, James and Paul, come from indifference and persecution; and the Church born of these encounters rereads them every year, in order, without ever having needed to conceal the doubts of Thomas or the denials of Peter. It is this body of converging evidence, and not a single account, that the reader is invited to weigh.

For further reading

Notes and References

  1. First letter to the Corinthians, 15, 3-5, AELF translation: Paul hands on what he has received, Christ died for our sins, buried, raised on the third day, appeared to Cephas and then to the Twelve. Formula received from the first witnesses, cited around the middle of the 50s.

    1 2 30
  2. First letter to the Corinthians, 15, 6-8, AELF translation: more than five hundred brethren at once, most of them still alive, then James, then all the apostles, then Paul last of all.

    3
  3. First letter to the Corinthians, 11, 23 and 15, 3: the verbs to hand on and to receive designate in Paul the faithful passing on of a teaching received, according to the Jewish usage of tradition.

    4
  4. Letter to the Galatians, 1, 18-19, AELF translation: three years after his conversion, Paul goes up to Jerusalem to make the acquaintance of Cephas and stays fifteen days with him; he sees no other apostle, except James, the brother of the Lord.

    5 33
  5. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, c. 180: Matthew published among the Hebrews, Mark transmitted after the departure of Peter and Paul, Luke, Paul's companion, set down the Gospel preached, John published his own at Ephesus. Direct witness of Polycarp, himself a disciple of John.

    6 7
  6. Papias, reported by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down exactly, without order, what he retained from the preaching; Matthew collected the words of the Lord in the Hebrew language.

    8
  7. Muranatorian Fragment, late second century, Roman canon: Luke as the third Gospel, John as the fourth, composed at the request of his fellow disciples and bishops.

    9
  8. Council of Trent, session IV, 8 April 1546: the canon receives the holy books in their entirety with all their parts.

    10 19
  9. Papyrus P52, a fragment of John 18 copied c. 125, kept in Manchester; papyrus P75, Bodmer codex of the early third century containing Luke and John: their circulation far from the place of origin implies the antiquity of the composition.

    11
  10. Pontifical Biblical Commission, decree of 29 May 1907 on the fourth gospel: it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of a historical account of the facts and the real discourses of the life of the Lord.

    12
  11. Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church affirms without hesitation the historicity of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus really did and taught.

    13 14
  12. Long ending of Mark (Mk 16:9-20) absent from the codices Sinaiticus and Vaticanus (fourth century) and from a few early witnesses that stop at Mk 16:8; a well-known textual question discussed since antiquity.

    15
  13. Eusebius of Caesarea, Questions to Marinus; Saint Jerome, letters on the text of Mark: the ancients are aware of the diversity of the copies concerning the ending of Mark and discuss it openly.

    16
  14. Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 10, 5, c. 180: quotation of Mk 16:19, the Lord Jesus taken up to heaven and seated at the right hand of God, expressly attributed to Mark, before the great codices that omit the ending.

    17
  15. Latin Lectionary: the ending of Mark (Mk 16:15-20) is the traditional gospel for the Feast of the Ascension, and its Easter summary is read on the Saturday of the Octave of Easter.

    18
  16. Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16, 1-6; Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 1-10; Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 1, AELF translation: on the first day of the week, at daybreak, the women come to the tomb with the spices and find it empty.

    20
  17. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 5-7; Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16, 6-7, AELF translation: he is risen, he goes before you into Galilee, tell his disciples and Peter that he awaits them there.

    21
  18. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 3-8, AELF translation: Peter and the other disciple run to the tomb, see the linen cloths and the burial cloth rolled up separately; the beloved disciple saw and believed.

    22
  19. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 11-16, AELF translation: Mary Magdalene weeps by the tomb, turns around, takes the Risen One for the gardener, then recognizes him at her name, Mary, and answers Rabbouni.

    23 24
  20. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 17, AELF translation: do not hold me, go to my brothers and tell them that I am going up to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.

    25
  21. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 18, AELF translation: Mary Magdalene comes to announce to the disciples that she has seen the Lord and what he said to her.

    26
  22. Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16, 9-11, AELF translation: risen on the morning of the first day of the week, Jesus appeared first to Mary Magdalene, from whom he had cast out seven demons; she went to announce it to those who were in mourning and tears.

    27
  23. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 8-10, AELF translation: the women leave the tomb, Jesus comes to meet them, they grasp his feet and bow down; he charges them to tell his brothers to go to Galilee.

    28
  24. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 641: Mary Magdalene and the holy women, come to complete the anointing of Jesus' body, are the first to meet the Risen One; the women are the first messengers of the Resurrection for the apostles themselves.

    29
  25. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 33-34, AELF translation: on their return from Emmaus, the two disciples find the Eleven gathered, who declare that the Lord is risen and that he has appeared to Simon.

    31 32
  26. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 13-24, AELF translation: two disciples towards Emmaus, sixty stadia from Jerusalem, tell the unknown traveler of the powerful prophet, the condemnation, the crucifixion and the empty tomb reported by the women.

    34
  27. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 25-27, AELF translation: foolish ones, slow to believe; it was necessary that the Christ should suffer this to enter into his glory; from Moses and the prophets, he interpreted to them what concerned him in all of Scripture.

    35
  28. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 32, AELF translation: were not our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us.

    36
  29. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 30-31, AELF translation: at table, he takes the bread, says the blessing, breaks it and gives it to them; then their eyes are opened and they recognize him, but he vanishes from their sight.

    37
  30. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 33-35, AELF translation: at that very moment, they get up and return to Jerusalem; they recount what happened on the road and how they recognized him in the breaking of the bread.

    38
  31. Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16, 12-13, AELF translation: Jesus manifested himself in another form to two of them as they were walking into the country; they came back to announce it, and they were not believed any more than the others.

    39
  32. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 19-20, AELF translation: on the evening of the first day, the doors locked for fear of the Jews, Jesus comes into the midst of the disciples: peace be with you; he shows them his hands and his side.

    40
  33. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 36-40, AELF translation: seized with fright, they think they see a spirit; see my hands and my feet, it is I myself, touch me, a spirit has not flesh and bones.

    41 42 76
  34. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 41-43, AELF translation: in their joy, they still cannot quite believe; he asks to eat and takes before them a piece of grilled fish.

    43
  35. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 21-23, AELF translation: as the Father has sent me, so I send you; he breathes on them: receive the Holy Spirit; whose sins you forgive, they are forgiven.

    44
  36. Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 44-48, AELF translation: he opens their minds to the Scriptures; repentance will be proclaimed in his name to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem; you are witnesses of this.

    45
  37. Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans, 3, 1-3, c. 110: after his resurrection, Christ ate and drank with his own as a being of flesh, although he was spiritually united to the Father; an ancient polemic against reducing the Risen One to a mere appearance.

    46
  38. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 24-25, AELF translation: Thomas, absent on the evening of Easter, demands to see the mark of the nails and to place his hand in the side of the Risen One in order to believe.

    47
  39. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 26, AELF translation: eight days later, the disciples are again in the house, Thomas with them, the doors being closed, and Jesus comes into their midst.

    48
  40. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 27, AELF translation: put your finger here, see my hands, stretch out your hand and put it into my side, cease to be unbelieving, believe.

    49
  41. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 28, AELF translation: Thomas answers, my Lord and my God.

    50
  42. Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 29, AELF translation: because you have seen me, you believe; blessed are those who believe without having seen.

    51
  43. Saint Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels, homily 26, on John 20: the unbelief of Thomas, by touching the scars of the Risen One, heals the wounds of our unbelief; his doubt serves the faith of those who were absent.

    52
  44. Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 14, AELF translation: this is the third time that Jesus, risen from the dead, was revealed to his disciples, by the Sea of Tiberias.

    53
  45. Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 4-11, AELF translation: a night with no catch, the net cast to the right, one hundred and fifty-three large fish, and the net is not torn.

    54
  46. Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 7, AELF translation: the beloved disciple said to Peter, it is the Lord; Simon-Peter threw himself into the water.

    55
  47. Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 9-13, AELF translation: on the shore, a charcoal fire with fish and bread; Jesus took the bread and gave it to them, and likewise the fish.

    56
  48. Gospel according to Saint John, 18, 17-27 and 21, 15-17: three denials by the fire in the courtyard of the high priest, three questions of love by the charcoal fire of the shore.

    57
  49. Gospel according to Saint John, 21, 15-17, AELF translation: Simon, son of John, do you love me; feed my lambs, tend my sheep, feed my sheep.

    58 59
  50. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 16, AELF translation: the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain to which Jesus had ordered them to go.

    60
  51. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 17, AELF translation: when they saw him, they worshipped him, but some doubted.

    61
  52. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 18-20, AELF translation: all power has been given to me in heaven and on earth; go, make disciples of all nations, baptize them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit; I am with you all days until the end of the world.

    62 63
  53. First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 6, AELF translation: then he appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time, most of them are still alive, some have fallen asleep.

    64
  54. First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 7, AELF translation: then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles.

    65
  55. Letter to the Galatians, 1, 19 and 2, 9, AELF translation: James, the brother of the Lord, visited by Paul with Cephas; James, Cephas and John regarded as the pillars of the Church.

    66
  56. Gospel according to Saint Mark, 3, 21 and 6, 3-4; Gospel according to Saint John, 7, 5, AELF translation: during his public life, Jesus' relatives are astonished or seek to seize him, and his brothers did not believe in him.

    67
  57. Hegesippus, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, II, 23: James, the brother of the Lord, surnamed the Just, head of the Church of Jerusalem, respected for his piety even by the Jews.

    68
  58. Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, II, 23; Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XX, 200: the violent death of James, the brother of Jesus, in Jerusalem, in the 1st century.

    69
  59. First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 8-9, AELF translation: last of all, he appeared even to me, who am like an abortion, the least of the apostles, unworthy of the name for having persecuted the Church of God.

    70
  60. Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 9, 3-6; 22, 6-10; 26, 13-18: the three accounts of the meeting at Damascus, light, voice, the name of Jesus and the sending forth to the nations.

    71
  61. First Letter to the Corinthians, 9, 1, AELF translation: am I not free, am I not an apostle, have I not seen Jesus our Lord.

    72
  62. Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 1, 3, AELF translation: after his Passion, he presented himself alive to the apostles with many proofs, appearing to them during forty days and speaking of the Kingdom of God.

    73 74
  63. Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 10, 39-41, AELF translation: God raised Jesus on the third day and gave him to be manifested, not to all the people, but to witnesses chosen in advance, who ate and drank with him after his resurrection.

    75
  64. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 645-646: the risen body of Christ is the true crucified body bearing the traces of the Passion, sharing in divine life with the properties of a glorious body, free in the Spirit.

    77
  65. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 646: the Resurrection of Christ was not a return to earthly life, such as those of Lazarus, the daughter of Jairus and the young man of Nain, but a passing to a life beyond time and space.

    78
  66. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, questions 53 to 56: the resurrection of Christ, the quality of his risen body, the manifestation of his resurrection and its causality with regard to ours.

    79
  67. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, Supplement, questions 82 to 85, scholastic tradition of the four gifts of the glorious body: impassibility, subtlety, agility and clarity, of which the risen body of Christ is the model.

    80
  68. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 55, article 1: should the resurrection of Christ have been manifested to all; an examination of the appearances to the witnesses.

    81
  69. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 55, articles 1 to 6: why the manifestation is made to chosen witnesses, and under what proofs, bodily and scriptural, the Risen One made himself known.

    82
  70. Saint Augustine, De consensu evangelistarum, book III, chapter 25: comparison of the accounts of the four Gospels, of Paul and of Acts concerning the manifestations of the Risen One, and the establishing of their order.

    83 98
  71. First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 20-23, AELF translation: Christ has been raised from the dead, the first fruits of those who have fallen asleep; as all die in Adam, all will receive life in Christ.

    84
  72. First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 14-19, AELF translation: if Christ has not been raised, the proclamation is empty, faith is in vain, the apostles are false witnesses and those who have fallen asleep in Christ are lost.

    85 86
  73. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 647-648: the Resurrection, a historical event attested by the disciples who truly experienced the Risen One, is at the same time a transcendent event that goes beyond and surpasses history.

    87
  74. Letter to the Romans, 6, 3-4, AELF translation: by baptism into the death of Christ, we were buried with him, so as to walk in new life as Christ has been raised from the dead.

    88
  75. Roman Missal lectionary, Octave of Easter: Monday, the women at the tomb (Mt 28); Tuesday, Mary Magdalene (Jn 20); Wednesday, Emmaus (Lk 24); Thursday, the appearance to the disciples (Lk 24); Friday, the Sea of Tiberias (Jn 21); Saturday, Mark's summary (Mk 16).

    89
  76. Second Sunday of Easter, gospel of Thomas (Jn 20:19-31); Saint John Paul II, Divine Mercy Sunday instituted at the canonization of Saint Faustina on 30 April 2000.

    90
  77. Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year, Easter season of fifty days until Pentecost: readings from the Acts of the Apostles as the first reading, and gospels of the appearances and the farewells on the Sundays.

    91
  78. Marian antiphon Regina Caeli, sung throughout the Easter season in place of the Angelus: rejoice, Queen of heaven, the one you were worthy to bear has risen as he said.

    92
  79. Via Lucis, a way of light in fourteen stations, from the empty tomb to Pentecost, meditating on the appearances of the Risen One according to the Gospels and Acts, an Easter counterpart to the Way of the Cross.

    93
  80. Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy, December 2001, 153: the Via Lucis, a recent exercise of piety, meditates on the apparitions of Jesus from his Resurrection to his Ascension and disposes the faithful to witness.

    94
  81. Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28:11-15, AELF translation: the guards announce the empty tomb to the chief priests, receive money to say that the disciples stole the body while they slept; a story spread, Matthew notes, to this day.

    95
  82. Gospel according to Saint Mark, 15:42-47; Gospel according to Saint John, 19:31-42, AELF translation: death ascertained by the centurion and by the lance blow, body wrapped in linen cloths with spices according to Jewish custom and laid in the new tomb.

    96
  83. David Friedrich Strauss, The Life of Jesus Critically Examined, 1835-1836: a mythical reading of the gospel narratives, in which the apparitions are reread as subjective visions of the disciples; the classical form of the vision hypothesis, later taken up under varied vocabularies.

    97
  84. Saint Augustine, De consensu evangelistarum, book III, chapter 25: the differences of order and detail between the evangelists are examined account by account, without concealing the discrepancies, and agreement is maintained on the succession of the principal appearances.

    99
  85. Rudolf Bultmann, program of demythologization, 1941 lecture and works on the New Testament: distinction between the kerygma of faith and the apparition accounts held to be secondary objectifications; major influence on a part of twentieth-century exegesis.

    100
  86. Recurring frailties of critical reconstructions: hypotheses of unattested oral traditions, circular datings, a presupposition ruling out precise prophecy and miracle in advance, the argument from silence, extrapolation from incomplete clues, the Tradition treated as suspect by principle.

    101
  87. Benedict XVI, apostolic exhortation Verbum Domini, 30 September 2010: a warning against an exegesis that would reduce the sacred text to strata and reconstructions without ever meeting the event or the persons who attest to it.

    102

Can’t find your topic?