The descent into hell is the article of the Apostles' Creed by which the Church confesses that Jesus, after his death on the cross, descended in his soul to the abode of the dead to announce salvation there and to free the righteous who had gone before him. The word "hell," in the plural, does not designate here the hell of the damned: it translates the Latin inferi, the world below where all the dead, good and bad alike, dwelt before the opening of Heaven. This is why the Catechism sets out the meaning of the formula at once[1].
"The frequent phrase that Jesus 'rose from the dead' presupposes that the Crucified sojourned in the abode of the dead before his Resurrection. This was the first meaning given by the apostolic preaching to Christ's descent into hell: Jesus experienced death like all men and joined them in soul in the abode of the dead. But he descended there as Savior, proclaiming the Good News to the spirits imprisoned there."
Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 632[2]
The event takes place within the interval of Holy Saturday, between the burial of Friday evening and the dawn of Easter. No Gospel recounts it as a visible scene: it belongs to the hidden side of the paschal mystery, the one faith confesses without seeing. For the death that precedes, see The crucifixion of Jesus; for the morning that follows, The apparitions of the Risen One; for the whole account, The Passion according to the four gospels.
This article presents the descent as Sacred Scripture received by the Church: its place in the canon and in the Creed, the traditional authors and datings of the texts that ground it, the ancient witnesses, the theological unfolding of Holy Saturday, the Latin and Eastern liturgical usage, the iconography, and then, at the end of the journey, the examination of objections and modern hypotheses.
What the article of the Creed confesses
The abode of the dead is not the hell of the damned
French fosters a stubborn confusion: "descending into hell" spontaneously evokes the hell of eternal punishment. Tradition, however, distinguishes four realities that ancient vocabulary sometimes gathered under the same Latin word infernus. The table below separates them clearly: it reads as a map of Holy Saturday, before any further development.
| Reality designated | Who is concerned | Relation to Christ's descent |
|---|---|---|
| The abode of the dead in general (Sheol, Hades) | All the dead of the old Covenant | The broad setting of the descent: the dead Christ joins the dead |
| The limbo of the Fathers | The righteous who died before Christ, awaiting the Savior | Freed by Christ and led to the vision of God |
| Purgatory | The saved who died in a state of purification | Touched by the fruits of the Passion, without being the proper aim of the descent |
| The hell of the damned | Those who died in final refusal of God | Christ does not descend there to deliver the damned |
The Catechism settles the question in a single sentence, drawn from the whole medieval tradition[3] :
"Jesus did not descend into hell to deliver the damned, nor to destroy the hell of damnation, but to free the righteous who had gone before him."
Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 633[4]
This distinction protects two joined truths. On the one hand, the death of Christ is real and total: his soul, separated from his body, truly joins the common lot of the dead, without privilege. On the other, this soul remains united to the person of the Word: it descends freely, victorious and bearing grace, not captive to the abode it enters[5]. Saint Thomas Aquinas devotes eight articles of the Summa Theologiae to this single mystery, a sign of the place it holds in received theology[6].
The place of the clause in the Apostles' Creed
The formula descendit ad inferos, "he descended into hell," belongs to the so-called Apostles' Creed, the baptismal creed of the Roman Church, still recited today in the rosary and admitted by the Catechism as "the symbol kept by the Roman Church, in which Peter, first of the Apostles, held court"[7]. Its textual history is known with precision, and it deserves to be told frankly, since the objection of late invention often rests upon it: we will answer it at the end of the article.
Around 404, Rufinus of Aquileia comments on the creed of his local Church and honestly notes that the descent clause appears neither in the Roman text nor in the Eastern texts, while holding it to be equivalent, in substance, to the mention of the burial[8]. The fact is thus ancient and admitted: the explicit clause spread slowly, between the fourth and the seventh century, until it entered the received text of the Creed[9]. But the absence of a clause in a local baptismal formula does not prove the absence of the faith it expresses: the Fathers of the early centuries teach the descent long before it was inscribed everywhere in the Creed, as the section on witnesses will show.
A truth of received faith, at its own degree
As regards degrees of certainty, Christ's descent to the abode of the dead belongs to the Catholic faith confessed in the Creed and taught by the ordinary magisterium: the Fourth Lateran Council, in 1215, professes in its constitution Firmiter that Christ, after his Passion, "descended into hell, rose from the dead and ascended into Heaven"[10]. The Catechism places it in article 5 of the Creed, between death and Resurrection, and presents it as the fulfillment of the evangelical proclamation of salvation[11]. It is neither a school opinion nor a pious image: it is a link in the paschal account without which, for tradition, the lot of the righteous of the Old Testament would remain suspended.
The Foundations in Scripture
The expectation of the Old Testament: Sheol and its promises
The Old Testament names Sheol the undifferentiated abode where all the dead descend, both righteous and wicked, in a shadow of existence cut off from God's praise[12]. Jacob refuses to be comforted and declares that he will go down into mourning to his son in Sheol[13]; the psalm asks who will praise God in the abode of the dead[14]. This very darkness gives force to the texts that pry it open: the God of Israel is already confessed there as master of death.
"I know that my Redeemer lives, and that on the last day he will rise upon the dust; and after my skin has been destroyed, in my flesh I shall see God."
Book of Job, 19, 25-26[15]
Psalm 16, read by the apostles as a prophecy of Christ, affirms that God will not abandon the soul of his faithful one to Sheol, nor let his holy one see corruption[16]. Hosea puts on God's lips a word of defiance to death, which Saint Paul will take up at the heart of his hymn to the Resurrection[17]:
"From the claws of Sheol I shall ransom them, from death I shall deliver them. Where are your plagues, O Death? Where is your pestilence, O Sheol?"
Book of Hosea, 13, 14[18]
Zechariah announces a prisoner freed from the pit without water by the blood of the covenant[19]; Isaiah, captives to whom it will be said to come out, and prisoners summoned to appear in the light[20]; Daniel, sleepers of the dust who will awake[21]. Taken one by one, these texts describe historical deliverances; received together in the Church's reading, they sketch the precise expectation to which the descent responds: someone must enter the abode of the dead in order to open its door from within.
The sign of Jonah and the word of Christ
Christ himself pointed to the event through an image, and this self-interpretation counts above all in the dossier. To the scribes and Pharisees who ask for a sign, he replies with the sign of Jonah[22]:
"For just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the sea monster, so the Son of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth."
Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 12, 40[23]
Jonas is a historical fact for the Christ who refers to him, not a convenient parable: the sign involves the reality of the two terms compared. The "heart of the earth" is not reduced to the stone tomb: tradition reads in it the whole abode of the dead, where Christ remains, dead as to the body, living and active as to the soul united to the Word[24]. The same Matthew reports, at the hour of Christ's death, the opening of the tombs and the resurrection of many saints who appeared in Jerusalem after the Resurrection[25]: an anticipatory tremor, in the gospel narrative, of the liberation that the descent accomplishes.
The received authors and the ancient witnesses of the Gospels
The Church receives the four Gospels as the work of the evangelists whom tradition has named since the beginning: Matthew the apostle, Mark the interpreter of Peter, Luke the companion of Paul, John the beloved disciple. The earliest witness to the whole is Saint Irenaeus, disciple of Polycarp, who had known John: around 180, he lists the four Gospels and their authors[26].
"John, the disciple of the Lord, he who had reclined on his breast, published the Gospel too, during his stay at Ephesus, in Asia."
The traditional dating remains defensible: Matthew in the years 40 to 60, Mark at Rome in the years 60, Luke around 60 to 63, John at Ephesus in the years 90 to 100. The Pontifical Biblical Commission confirmed on 29 May 1907 that it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of the fourth gospel[28]. Vatican II holds the same line for the four accounts[29]. This foundation matters here: the descent does not rest on a late or marginal text, but on the joint reading of the Gospels, Acts, Paul and Peter, received at the heart of the canon fixed by the Council of Trent[30].
Peter preaches to the dead: the two decisive texts
The most direct text of the New Testament is found in the first letter of Peter, written by the apostle according to received tradition, and whose Petrine attribution is defended by liturgical use and the ancient witnesses[31]. Peter there links the Passion and an approach of Christ to the imprisoned spirits:
"Christ suffered for sins, once for all, the righteous for the unrighteous, in order to lead you to God; put to death in the flesh, made alive in the spirit, in which also he went and preached to the spirits in prison, those who, long ago, had been disobedient."
First letter of Saint Peter, 3, 18-20[32]
The verb used, kèrussô, means to proclaim like a herald, to announce officially, rather than to convert through lengthy preaching[33]. The second mention, in chapter 4, broadens the announcement to the dead without limiting it to the contemporaries of Noah[34]:
"For this is why the Gospel was preached to the dead also, so that, judged as men in the flesh, they might live according to God in the spirit."
First letter of Saint Peter, 4, 6[35]
The traditional Catholic reading, followed by the Catechism, holds the two passages together: Christ, dead, in his soul made alive and united to the Word, proclaims to the righteous held captive the accomplishment of salvation and brings them out of it[36]. The alternative readings, which will be the subject of the objections section, must explain why Peter places this proclamation between death and Resurrection, and why he links it to the baptism that saves[37].
Paul and Acts: the depths of the earth and Psalm 16
Saint Paul supplies the second pillar of the dossier. In the letter to the Ephesians, he quotes Psalm 68, "on ascending on high he led captivity captive," and comments on the descent that precedes the ascension[38]:
"Now "he ascended," what does it mean, except that he also descended into the lower regions of the earth? He who descended is the same who ascended above all the heavens, in order to fill all things."
Letter to the Ephesians, 4, 9-10[39]
The movement is complete: descent, then ascent with freed captives, an image that tradition associates with the righteous led into Heaven[40]. In Acts, Peter, on the day of Pentecost, applies Psalm 16 to the Resurrection while specifying the point that concerns us: Christ was not abandoned to Hades and his flesh did not see corruption[41]:
"God raised him up, having delivered him from the pains of Hades, for it was not possible for him to be held by it."
Acts of the Apostles, 2, 24[42]
The same discourse affirms that David, dead and buried, spoke prophetically of Christ by saying that his soul would not be abandoned to the abode of the dead[43]. Paul, at Antioch in Pisidia, takes up the same psalm in the same sense[44]. The Hebrew of the psalm says Sheol, the Greek of the Septuagint and of Acts says Hades: in both cases, the place of the dead where Christ, unlike David, was not left a prisoner.
The following table gathers the texts that ground the article of the Creed: it serves as a biblical map for the whole article.
| Text | What it brings to the dossier of the descent |
|---|---|
| Ps 16, 10 (Acts 2, 27-31) | The soul of God's holy one not abandoned to Sheol, read as a prophecy of Christ |
| Hos 13, 14; Zech 9, 11; Is 49, 9 | The ransom from Sheol and the freeing of the prisoners of the pit |
| Mt 12, 40 | The sign of Jonah: three days and three nights in the heart of the earth |
| Mt 27, 52-53 | The tombs opened and the saints raised, firstfruits of the liberation |
| Acts 2, 24-31 | Christ not held by Hades, according to the psalm reread by Peter |
| Eph 4, 8-10 | The descent into the lower regions, then the ascension with the captives |
| 1 Pet 3, 18-20 | The proclamation to the spirits in prison, between death and life in the spirit |
| 1 Pet 4, 6 | The Gospel preached to the dead, so that they might live according to God |
| Heb 2, 14-15; Rev 1, 18 | The power of death broken, the keys of death and Hades held by the Risen One |
Two texts close the map. The Letter to the Hebrews gives the liberating purpose of the whole Incarnation: to deliver those who were held in slavery by the fear of death.[45] The Apocalypse, received as the work of the Apostle John, puts on the lips of the Risen One the claim to the keys won:
"Fear not. I am the First and the Last, the Living One; I was dead, and behold, I am alive for ever and ever, and I hold the keys of death and hades."
Revelation, 1:17-18[46]
Holy Saturday: what the soul of Christ does among the dead
The body in the tomb, the soul among the dead, the divinity united to both
Received theology holds three joined assertions during the rest of Holy Saturday. The body of Christ rests in the tomb, incorrupt, as confessed by the application of Psalm 16.[47] His human soul, separated from the body by real death, descends to the dwelling of the dead.[48] The divinity of the Word, however, is separated from neither the body nor the soul: which is why the Church can say that God himself visited the dead, without death having dissolved the person of the Son.[49] Saint Thomas draws from this the consequence for the adoration of the body in the tomb and for the presence of the whole Christ in the dwelling visited.[50]
Freeing the just who were waiting: the limbo of the Fathers
The just of the old Covenant, Abraham, Moses, David, the prophets and the Precursor, had died in faith and expectation, but the gate of Heaven remained closed by Adam's sin as long as the Redeemer had not accomplished his work.[51] The Catechism names their expectation from the parable of poor Lazarus received into Abraham's bosom[52]:
"The souls of the just who were awaiting the Redeemer in Abraham's bosom, it is these that Christ freed when he descended into hell."
Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 633, drawing on the Roman Catechism[53]
Saint Thomas specifies the modality: by the virtue of his Passion, Christ delivers the holy Fathers from the punishment that held them back from glory, without purgatory being emptied thereby, since souls that still had purification to undergo according to divine justice were not in the same state as the Fathers already purified.[54] He likewise excludes any deliverance of the damned: the descent does not reopen a case closed by the particular judgment.[55] This firmness protects the realism of judgment, while leaving the liberation of the Fathers entire.
To announce, to judge, to lead: the three gestures of the descent
Tradition distinguishes three gestures in the one visit. Christ announces the fulfilment to the spirits held fast, according to Peter's proclamation.[56] He manifests his victory to the powers that held the dead, according to the logic of Ephesians 4 and Revelation: the keys change hands.[57] He leads the freed just toward the vision of God, which liturgy and iconography figure as Adam seized by the hand and raised up. These three gestures unfold one and the same truth: the death of Christ is not a dead time of salvation, but its retroactive application to all prior human history. Without the descent, the just of Israel would have awaited a Saviour who would never have come as far as them.
The ancient witnesses: from the Fathers to the Holy Saturday homily
The descent attested from the 2nd century
Long before the general inscription of the clause in the creeds, the teaching is present among the earliest witnesses. Saint Ignatius of Antioch, around 110, writes that the prophets themselves awaited Christ as their master and that, when he came, he raised them from the dead.[58] Saint Justin, in the middle of the 2nd century, cites an oracle of Jeremiah according to which the Lord remembered his dead of Israel sleeping in the dust of the sepulchre and descended to them to announce salvation.[59] Saint Irenaeus, around 180, teaches that the Lord descended into the lower regions to announce his coming and the remission of sins to those who would believe in him[60]:
"The Lord descended into the lower regions of the earth, seeking his lost sheep, that is, man, his handiwork."
Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, IV, 27, 2, in the development on the recapitulation[61]
The chronology of attestations, below, shows a doctrine rising from the Fathers toward the formulation of the Creed, and not a creedal clause that would have invented its doctrine after the fact.
- c. 110Saint Ignatius of Antioch
The prophets, disciples of Christ in expectation, are raised by him at his coming, according to the letter to the Magnesians.
- c. 155Saint Justin
The Dialogue with Trypho reports the word of Jeremiah: the Lord descended to announce salvation to his sleeping dead.
- c. 180Saint Irenaeus
The descent is part of the recapitulation: Christ visits the dead as he visited the living.
- c. 210Tertullian and Hippolytus
Christ in the dwelling of the dead and the freeing of the saints become a theme taught in the West as in the East.
- c. 404Rufinus of Aquileia
The commentary on the Creed notes the explicit clause at Aquileia and its absence from the Roman and Eastern formularies, with equal substance.
- 5th centurySaint Augustine
Letter 164 to Evodius discusses the scope of 1 Peter 3, refuses a deliverance of the damned, and maintains the liberation of the just.
- 1215Lateran IV
The constitution Firmiter professes the descent in the summary of the faith of the Latin Church.
- 1553Saint Thomas received and the Roman Catechism
The Summa, question 52, then the Catechism of the Council of Trent fix the scholastic distinctions still taken up in 1992.
Augustine, letter 164 and the question of limits
Saint Augustine left the most honest ancient discussion of the difficulties. In his letter 164 to Evodius, around 414, he refuses to settle what he does not see clearly, sets aside the idea that Christ would have emptied hell of the damned, and maintains that the just were delivered at the descent.[62] His caution is precious: it shows that tradition never confused the liberation of the Fathers, received from Scripture, with a general second chance after death, which it never taught. The same Augustine elsewhere affirms without hesitation the reality of the descent, received from the preaching of the Church.[63]
The ancient Holy Saturday homily: Adam raised by the hand
The most read patristic text on the descent is the ancient homily for Holy Saturday, preserved in the Greek tradition and taken up each year by the Office of Readings for Holy Saturday in the Roman liturgy.[64] Its author remains anonymous; its authority rests on its antiquity and its continuous liturgical reception. It stages the encounter of Christ and Adam:
"I command you: awake, O sleeper, I did not create you to dwell here in chains. Rise from among the dead, I am the life of the dead. Rise, work of my hands, rise, my image made in my likeness."
Ancient Homily for Holy Saturday, Office of Readings[65]
"The Lord advances, holding the victorious weapon of the cross. As soon as he sees him, Adam, our first father, beating his breast with joy, cries out to all: My Lord be with us all! And Christ answers Adam: And with thy spirit."
Ancient Homily for Holy Saturday, Office of Readings[66]
The gesture of the hand seized, at the heart of these lines, will become the visual motif of all the Byzantine iconography of the Resurrection itself. The Cite Catechism cites this homily at the end of its exposition, as the voice of liturgy on the mystery.[67]
The Gospel of Nicodemus: a beloved tale, outside the canon
In the fourth or fifth century, an apocryphal text, the Gospel of Nicodemus, also known as the Acts of Pilate, relates the descent in detail: the bronze gates shattered, Satan bound, Adam, Isaiah and John the Baptist welcoming Christ, the righteous led into paradise[68]. This narrative nourished piety, medieval theatre, and the imagination of the West, down to Dante. Its status must be stated clearly: it does not belong to the canon established by the Church, it is not a source of faith, and none of its narrative details may be cited as fact. Its value is that of a witness to reception: it proves that the descent occupied the ancient Christian imagination to such a degree that it demanded a narrative, and it handed down to art the motif of the shattered gates that iconography retained[69].
Theology: a victory that spans the whole history of salvation
Christ recapitulates the living and the dead
Saint Irenaeus calls recapitulation the act by which Christ takes up all humanity into himself, from Adam to the last of men[70]. The descent is the underground counterpart of this taking up: the Saviour does not save only the generations who encounter him in the flesh; he reaches the buried generations who could only wait for him. The psalm quoted by Paul, "he led captivity captive," finds here its most literal fulfilment[71]. This is why the Eastern icon of Easter does not depict the empty tomb, but precisely this liberation: the Resurrection shown through its effects upon the dead.
Adam raised: the first and the last man meet
The ancient homily and iconography converge on Adam, and this choice is theology in miniature. He through whom death entered the world is the first to be seized by the hand of the new Adam[72]. The Fall is not merely forgiven from afar: it is visited, raised, carried away. The spiritual tradition draws from this a consequence for every Christian death: no one henceforth descends alone to where Christ has already passed, and baptism unites the believer to this descent as to the ascent, according to Paul's teaching on baptism into Christ's death[73].
What the descent is not: neither a second chance nor an emptied hell
The clarification is worth setting out before the objections, for two symmetrical misunderstandings threaten the subject. The descent is not a second chance offered after death to those who refused God during their lives: the letter to the Hebrews establishes that men die once, and after that comes judgment[74], and both Augustine and Thomas exclude the deliverance of the damned[75]. Nor is it the destruction of hell: the Catechism says so expressly[76]. It is the application of the Paschal victory to the righteous who, having died before its accomplishment, could receive its fruits only through this visit. The particular judgment of each soul at death stands; the descent does not replay it — it opens Heaven to those whom death had preceded before the hour of the Cross.
Liturgical use: Holy Saturday, the day of the descent
The great silence of the Latin Church
Holy Saturday is, in the Roman liturgy, a day without Mass until the Vigil: the altar is bare, the tabernacle empty, the Church keeps watch in silence beside the Lord in the tomb[77]. The Office of Readings offers the ancient homily as the second reading: the descent is therefore not only taught, it is prayed each year by the whole Church[78]. The Catechism opens its presentation on this very silence, quoting the homily[79]:
"Today a great silence reigns on earth, a great silence and a great stillness. A great silence, because the King is asleep. The earth trembled and is still, because God has fallen asleep in the flesh and has raised those who have been asleep for centuries."
Ancient homily for Holy Saturday, quoted in the Catechism, no. 635[80]
The Easter Vigil, when evening comes, unfolds what the descent has prepared: the Exsultet sings of the night when Christ, breaking the bonds of death, rose victorious from the underworld[81]. The liturgical sequence is itself an exegesis: silence of the day, hidden liberation, explosion of light at night.
The Byzantine East: the Anastasis as the icon of Easter
In the Byzantine tradition, the descent is the visual centre of Easter. The icon of the Anastasis, a Greek word meaning Resurrection and Rising, shows Christ in glory, standing upon the shattered gates of the abode of the dead, seizing Adam, and often Eve, by the wrist to draw them from the opened tombs, surrounded by David, Solomon, John the Baptist and the righteous[82]. The frescoes of the Church of the Holy Saviour in Chora, in Constantinople, from the 14th century, give its most famous monumental version[83]. The hymnography of Byzantine Holy Saturday sings of the same mystery: the guarded tomb contains him whom hades cannot hold[84]. Where the West readily paints Christ emerging from the tomb, the East shows who benefits first from the Resurrection: the dead. Both traditions confess the same article under two complementary images.
The recited Creed and baptism
The clause finally lives in daily prayer: the Apostles' Creed opens the rosary and serves as the baptismal profession in the Roman Rite, where the catechumen confesses the descent before confessing the Resurrection[85]. Peter explicitly links his proclamation to the dead to the baptism that saves[86]: to descend into the water with Christ is already to share in the movement by which he descended among the dead in order to rise again. The descent is therefore not a decorative article between two major articles: it names the lowest point of the Paschal trajectory, without which the ascent would have neither a starting point nor captives to carry away.
Objections and Historical-Critical Debate
This final section sets out the objections in their strongest form and then answers them. The historical-critical method has been of real service to the reading of the texts; it becomes fragile when a working hypothesis is presented as a verdict, or when a presupposition rules out in advance what the texts assert.
Objection 1: "The clause is a late invention, absent from the primitive Creed"
Reply: the textual fact is accurate and has been known since Rufinus himself: the explicit clause is missing from the ancient Roman formulary and from the Eastern formularies, and it spread gradually[87]. But the inference "therefore the doctrine is late" does not follow. Ignatius, Justin and Irenaeus teach the descent in the first and second centuries, before any general creedal inscription[88][89]. The history runs from preaching to clause, as with other Creed formulations that make an ancient faith explicit at a late date. Confusing the history of a formula with the history of the faith it formulates is the central error of the objection.
Objection 2: "1 Peter 3 does not speak of a descent, but of Christ preaching through Noah or to the fallen angels"
Reply: these readings exist and must be set out fairly. Some contemporary exegesis proposes that Christ, in spirit, once preached through Noah to the men of his generation, or that he proclaims his victory to the fallen angels held captive[90]. They stumble, however, on the sequence of the text: Peter places the action between being put to death in the flesh and being made alive in the spirit, links it to the fate of the dead and to baptism, and then states without ambiguity, in the following chapter, that the Gospel was preached to the dead[91][92]. The traditional reading, which sees in it the visit of the dead Christ to the dead, respects the narrative sequence of the letter better than reconstructions that move the scene outside the paschal interval. The real philological ambiguity of one verse is not enough to dissolve the convergence of Peter, Paul, Acts and the Fathers.
Objection 3: "The descent would give a second chance after death"
Reply: this is the misreading the tradition has most consistently rejected. Augustine rejects it, Thomas rejects it, the Catechism rejects it[93][94][95]. Those set free are the righteous who died in waiting, not damned souls fished out nor the indifferent converted after their judgment. Scripture holds both edges together: men die once, and after that comes judgment[96], and the Gospel was preached to the dead so that they might live according to God[97]. The descent applies the Redemption to those who had preceded it in time; it does not reopen the time of decision for those who have closed it.
Objection 4: "A hell that one may hope is empty renders the descent useless, or contradicts it"
Reply: in the twentieth century, Hans Urs von Balthasar argued that it is permitted to hope that all men are saved, drawing in particular on the solidarity of the Christ who descended into hell[98]. Hope for each person, sustained by the prayer of the Church, is legitimate and even commanded by charity. But turning this hope into a certainty that hell is empty would go beyond what the Church teaches: she holds together God's universal saving will and the real possibility of definitive refusal, without ever declaring that any particular person is damned[99]. The descent, far from being contradicted, grounds the hope without hardening it into a system: Christ went to the lowest depths, and no one can say that a place of death remained foreign to him.
Objection 5: "The abode of the dead is ancient mythology that modern faith must abandon"
Reply: the vocabulary of Sheol and Hades does indeed belong to the ancient world, and the Church has never canonised a tiered cosmography. But the reality confessed is not reducible to its image: that Christ truly died, that his work reaches those who died before him, and that death is henceforth traversed by his victory — this is the content that the ancient images carry and that the Creed retains[100]. To abandon the article on account of its vocabulary would be to abandon with the same gesture half of biblical language. The Catholic reading distinguishes the truth affirmed from the representation that carries it, without dissolving the former into the latter.
Objection 6: "The Gospels recount no descent, therefore it is legendary"
Reply: the argument rests on the silence of a literary genre that does not claim to tell everything: the Gospels recount the public life, the Passion and the appearances, and leave in shadow the interval of Holy Saturday, with the exception of the sign of Jonah and the opened tombs[101][102]. The testimony comes from the apostolic letters, that is, from the same first century and the same circle of witnesses[103][104]. To treat as late legend a teaching present in Peter, Paul, Ignatius and Irenaeus is to date the texts as late as possible and to reject their received attribution: it is this accumulation of hypotheses, not the tradition, that must then be proved.
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
Some contemporary exegesis proposes to date the letters of Peter late and hold them to be pseudepigraphic, to read the descent as a victory myth borrowed from neighbouring religions, or to reduce it to a metaphor for the depth of Christ's death[105]. These hypotheses must be known; they do not impose themselves as demonstrations. Their recurring fragilities are identifiable: hypothetical reconstructions presented as established, circular datings where the text is dated by the theory it is then used to prove, presuppositions that rule out prophecy and miracle in advance, arguments from silence drawn from texts that made no claim to completeness, and extrapolation from incomplete clues[106]. Benedict XVI warned against an exegesis that would dissect the text without ever encountering the living Christ it announces[107]. The traditional position, for its part, rests on named witnesses, an uninterrupted liturgical reception and a convergence of independent texts: it remains defensible, and this article has presented it as such, without concealing the questions it leaves open.
To go further
- The Crucifixion of Jesus : the death of Good Friday, from which the soul of Christ descends
- The Burial of Jesus : the body in the tomb during the rest of Holy Saturday
- The Passion according to the four Gospels : the whole set of Passion narratives
- The appearances of the Risen Lord : Easter morning and the encounters with the Risen One
- The Ascension of Jesus : the return of the Christ who descended, forty days after Easter
- The Last Supper : the institution of the Eucharist, on the eve of the Passion
- The Agony of Jesus in Gethsemane : the night that precedes the Cross
Notes and References
Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 630 to 637, article "He descended into hell", Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1992: the abode of the dead, distinct from the hell of damnation.
1Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 632: first meaning of the descent, the dead Christ joins the dead as Saviour.
2 36 40 48 100Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 633: liberation of the just from the bosom of Abraham, following the Roman Catechism of the Council of Trent.
3 4 53 76 95Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 52, a. 1: the fittingness of the descent, the soul of Christ, united to the Word, joins the abode of the dead.
5 24 49Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa pars, question 52, eight articles on the descent of Christ into hell.
6 50Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 194: the Apostles' Creed, the symbol of the Roman Church where Peter presided.
7 85Rufinus of Aquileia, Commentary on the Apostles' Creed, around 404: the clause of the descent present in Aquileia, absent from the Roman and Eastern forms.
8 87History of the ancient creeds: gradual spread of the clause descendit ad inferos between the 4th and 7th centuries in Western forms.
9Fourth Council of the Lateran, constitution Firmiter, 1215: profession of the descent into hell between the Passion and the Resurrection.
10(source introuvable : cec-631)
11Sheol in the Old Testament: the common abode of the dead, Gn 37:35; Ps 115:17; Eccl 9:10.
12Book of Genesis, 37:35: Jacob declares that he will go down in mourning to his son in Sheol.
13Book of Psalms, 115:17: it is not the dead who praise the Lord.
14Book of Job, 19:25-27: the living Redeemer and the vision of God in the flesh.
15Book of Psalms, 16:10: the soul of the faithful one not abandoned to Sheol, reread in Acts 2 and Acts 13.
16Book of Hosea, 13:14: ransom from the claws of Sheol, taken up again in 1 Cor 15:55.
17 18Book of Zechariah, 9:11: the prisoners drawn from the waterless pit by the blood of the covenant.
19Book of Isaiah, 49:9: to say to the captives, "Come out," to those in prison, "Appear in the light."
20Book of Daniel, 12:2: those who sleep in the dust will awake.
21Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 12:40: the sign of Jonah, three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
22 23 101Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 27:52-53: tombs opened and saints raised at the death of Christ.
25 102Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1: the four Gospels and their authors, John at Ephesus.
26 27Pontifical Biblical Commission, response of 29 May 1907: Johannine authenticity of the fourth Gospel.
28Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, n. 19: the historicity of the four Gospels affirmed without hesitation.
29Council of Trent, session IV, 8 April 1546: the canon of Scripture received in its entirety with all its parts.
30Traditional attribution of the first letter to the apostle Peter, 1 Pet 1:1; 5:1, and its ancient liturgical reception.
31First Letter of Saint Peter, 3:18-21: put to death in the flesh, made alive in the spirit, proclamation to the spirits in prison, baptism which saves.
32 37 56 86 91 103The Greek verb kēryssō: to proclaim as a herald, to announce officially a victory or a decree.
33First Letter of Saint Peter, 4:6: the Gospel preached to the dead.
34 35 92 97Letter to the Ephesians, 4:8-10, quoting Ps 68:19: descended into the lower regions, ascended above the heavens.
38 39 71 104Acts of the Apostles, 2:24-31: Christ not held by Hades, Psalm 16 reread by Peter at Pentecost.
41 42 43 47Acts of the Apostles, 13:35-37: Paul takes up Psalm 16 at Antioch in Pisidia.
44Letter to the Hebrews, 2:14-15: to deliver those who were held in slavery by the fear of death.
45Revelation, 1:17-18: the Living One holds the keys of death and Hades.
46 57Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 637: the just were awaiting the Redeemer, the gate of Heaven closed since Adam.
51Gospel according to Saint Luke, 16:22: poor Lazarus carried into the bosom of Abraham.
52Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 52, a. 8: manner of the deliverance and the question of the souls in purgatory.
54Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 52, a. 6: Christ delivers no damned person during the descent.
55 94Saint Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Magnesians, 9, 2, around 110: the prophets were awaiting Christ and he has raised them up.
58 88Saint Justin, Dialogue with Trypho, 72: the word of Jeremiah concerning the Lord who has gone down to his sleeping dead.
59Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, IV, 27, 2; V, 31, 1: the descent and the recapitulation of the dead.
60 61 70 89Saint Augustine, Letter 164 to Evodius, around 414: the scope of 1 Peter 3, the refusal of a deliverance of the damned.
62 63 75 93Ancient homily for Holy Saturday, anonymous author, Patrologia Graeca 43: second reading of the Office of Readings of Holy Saturday.
64 65 66 72 78Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 635: quotation from the ancient homily of Holy Saturday and the liberation of Adam.
67 79 80Gospel of Nicodemus (Acts of Pilate), second part, 4th or 5th century: apocryphal account of the descent, outside the canon.
68 69Letter to the Romans, 6:3-4: buried with Christ by baptism into his death.
73Letter to the Hebrews, 9:27: men die once only, and after that comes judgment.
74 96Roman liturgy of Holy Saturday: a day without Mass, the stripped altar, the vigil at the tomb until the Easter Vigil.
77Exsultet, Easter proclamation of the Vigil: Christ breaking the bonds of death, risen victorious from hell.
81Byzantine iconography of the Anastasis: Christ in glory upon the broken gates, raising Adam and Eve.
82Frescoes of the Anastasis, Church of the Holy Saviour in Chora, Constantinople, 14th century.
83Byzantine hymnography of Holy Saturday: Hades unable to hold him who is in the tomb.
84Alternative readings of 1 Pet 3:19: preaching by Noah or proclamation to the fallen angels, held by part of contemporary exegesis.
90Hans Urs von Balthasar, Dare We Hope "That All Men Be Saved"?, 1986: hope for the salvation of all, to be distinguished from a certainty about an empty hell.
98Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 1033 to 1037: hell as definitive refusal, without any declaration by the Church on the damnation of a particular person.
99Part of contemporary exegesis proposes late datings and pseudepigraphy for the letters of Peter: working hypotheses, not established verdicts.
105Recurring weaknesses: hypothetical reconstructions, circular datings, the anti-miraculous presupposition, the argument from silence, extrapolations from incomplete evidence.
106Benedict XVI, exhortation Verbum Domini, 30 September 2010: against an exegesis that would never encounter the persons announced by the text.
107