The Ascension of Jesus is the raising of the risen Christ into heaven, on the fortieth day after Easter, before the eyes of the Apostles gathered on the Mount of Olives. It brings to a close the time in which Jesus, after his death and burial, had shown himself alive to his disciples, and it opens the age of the Church: the Lord is no longer visible as before, he is seated at the right hand of the Father, he sends the Holy Spirit, and he will come again.
The account takes up only a few verses, but its weight is immense. Without the Ascension, the apparitions would remain a parenthesis: astonishing encounters, and then nothing more. With it, everything falls into place. The Risen One does not vanish as one stops seeing someone; he enters into the glory of God with his humanity, he takes his place there as King and as high priest, and he leaves his own a word, a mission, and a promise of return.
This article presents the Ascension as Sacred Scripture received by the Church: its place in the canon, the traditional authors and datings of the accounts, the ancient witnesses, the account in Acts step by step, what the other Gospels say or leave unsaid, the place, the figures of the Old Testament, the theology of the session at the right hand of the Father, the liturgical memorial, and then, at the end of the journey, the objections and the historical-critical debate with its limits. For the death that precedes it, see The crucifixion of Jesus; for the tomb, The burial of Jesus; for the encounters of the forty days, The apparitions of the Risen One; for the feast itself, Ascension of the Lord has its own article and is here only the memorial of the event.
The Ascension in the canon of the Scriptures
An event narrated twice by the same author
Only one author narrates the Ascension as a scene: Saint Luke, twice. He places it at the end of his Gospel, when Jesus leads his disciples towards Bethany, blesses them and is carried into heaven while they prostrate themselves and return to Jerusalem filled with great joy[1]. He takes it up again at the beginning of the Acts of the Apostles, his second volume, this time with the duration, the precise place, the cloud, the two men in white garments and the promise of the return[2].
This double narration is no accident. Luke writes a work in two parts: what Jesus did and taught until the day he was taken up, and then what the Holy Spirit does in the Church beginning from Jerusalem. The Ascension is the hinge of the two volumes: it closes the first, it opens the second. The first verse of Acts says so plainly, addressing the same dedicatee as the Gospel[3].
"Dear Theophilus, in my first book I have spoken of all that Jesus did and taught from the beginning until the day he was taken up into heaven, after having given his instructions to the Apostles he had chosen through the Holy Spirit."
Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 1:1-2[4]
Around this central account, the rest of the New Testament does not narrate the scene, but it confesses it, sings it, and draws out its consequences. Mark sums it up in one sentence in his ending received by the Church[5]. Matthew does not narrate it: he stops on the mountain in Galilee, with the promise of a presence that lasts until the end of the world[6]. John does not stage it either, but Jesus announces it before his Passion and Mary Magdalene hears it on the morning of Easter[7]. Paul and the apostolic letters do not describe the raising: they proclaim its result, the Lord exalted, seated at the right hand of God, interceding for his own[8].
The table of texts
The table below sets out the passages that structure the dossier. It reads like a map, before the step-by-step account: each column says what a text brings of its own, and what it does not say.
| Passage | What the text brings of its own on the Ascension |
|---|---|
| Luke 24:50-53 | Jesus leads the disciples towards Bethany, blesses them as he takes leave of them, is carried into heaven; joyful return to Jerusalem |
| Acts 1:1-14 | Forty days of apparitions, command to wait for the Spirit, question of the Kingdom, raising, cloud, two men in white, promise of the return, Mount of Olives, waiting in the Upper Room |
| Mark 16:19-20 | Summary: the Lord Jesus is taken up into heaven, is seated at the right hand of God, the disciples go out to preach with his help |
| Matthew 28:16-20 | No account of the raising: the mountain in Galilee, all authority given, universal mission, the promise "I am with you all days" |
| John 20:17; 6:62; 14 to 16 | Announcement of the ascent to the Father; "I have not yet ascended" on the morning of Easter; departure necessary for the Advocate to come |
| Eph 1:20-23; 4:8-10 | God raises Christ, seats him at his right hand, gives him as Head to the Church; the one who ascended fills all things |
| Heb 4:14; 7:25; 9:24; 10:19-22 | The high priest passing through the heavens, entered into the true sanctuary, always living to intercede |
| 1 Pet 3:22; Phil 2:9-11 | Jesus Christ ascended into heaven, at the right hand of God, exalted above every name |
No single text is sufficient on its own, and this is a strength. Luke gives the scene and the setting, Mark the brief confession, Matthew the abiding presence, John the ascent to the Father as return, Paul and the letters the kingship and priesthood of the exalted Lord. Received together, as the Church has always read them, they describe one and the same event under lights that converge without copying one another: the crucified and risen One has not sunk back into oblivion, he reigns.
The ending of Mark, received in the canon
Mark's sentence on the Ascension is found in the long ending of his Gospel (Mark 16:9-20). Its textual situation has been known and discussed since antiquity, and the article will deal with it at the end of the journey along with the objections. Here, it is enough to lay down the fact that governs the Catholic reading: this ending belongs to the text the Church receives as canonical. The Council of Trent defined that the sacred books must be received whole, with all their parts, as they are customarily read in the Catholic Church[9]. Saint Irenaeus, around 180, already quotes the verse of the raising and of the session at the right hand of God, expressly attributing it to Mark, and thus well before the great fourth-century codices that omit the ending[10]. The liturgy proclaims it as the gospel of the feast according to the year[11].
"The Lord Jesus, after he had spoken to them, was taken up into heaven and sat down at the right hand of God. As for them, they went out and proclaimed the Gospel everywhere. The Lord worked with them and confirmed the Word by the signs that accompanied it."
Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16:19-20[12]
The received authors and the ancient witnesses
Luke, physician and companion of Paul
The Church receives the Gospel and Acts as the work of Saint Luke, physician and companion of Saint Paul. The earliest witness to the whole is Saint Irenaeus, disciple of Polycarp, who had known Saint John: around 180, he lists the four Gospels and their authors, and he presents Luke as the disciple and companion of Paul, who set down in a book the Gospel preached by his master[13]. The Muratorian Fragment, towards the end of the second century, counts Luke as the third Gospel[14]. Paul himself names Luke in his letters, as a collaborator and as the beloved physician[15], and Acts shifts into the first person plural on several journeys, a sign of a companion present at the Apostle's side[16].
Luke does not present himself as an inventor. He opens his Gospel by saying that he has carefully investigated everything from the origins with those who, from the beginning, were eyewitnesses and servants of the Word, in order to write an orderly account for Theophilus[17]. This concern for named and verifiable witnesses is found throughout the Easter dossier: the list received by Paul names hundreds of witnesses still alive at the time he writes[18]. An author fabricating a legend does not speak like this.
"John, the disciple of the Lord, the one who had rested on his breast, also published the Gospel, during his stay at Ephesus, in Asia."
The traditional dating remains defensible
The traditional dating of the two volumes of Luke remains solid without acrobatics: the Gospel in the sixties, Acts shortly after, around 60 to 63. The simplest argument comes from the very end of Acts: the book stops with Paul a prisoner in Rome for two years, preaching freely, without mentioning either his death under Nero, or the persecution of 64, or the fall of Jerusalem in 70[20]. An author writing long after these events, and who had recounted in detail Paul's ordeals and the tensions of Jerusalem, would have no reason to be silent about their outcome. The final silence of Acts is better explained if the book is completed before them.
The manuscripts confirm an early circulation. Papyrus P75, from the early third century, already joins Luke and John in a single carefully made codex; papyrus P52, a fragment of John copied around 125, shows the Gospels already spread far from their place of origin a generation after their writing[21]. The Pontifical Biblical Commission confirmed on 29 May 1907 that it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of the fourth Gospel, a historical account of the deeds and the real discourses of the life of the Lord[22]. Vatican II holds the same line for the four accounts[23].
"Holy Mother Church has firmly held and holds that these four Gospels, whose historicity she affirms without hesitation, faithfully transmit what Jesus, the Son of God, during his life among men, really did and taught for their eternal salvation."
Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19[24]
The Council of Trent fixed the canon by receiving these books entire with all their parts[25]. It is in this received canon, and not in a later reconstruction, that the Ascension is first read.
The fortieth day: the account of Acts step by step
Forty days of proofs
The account of Acts begins with a frame, before any scene. After his Passion, Jesus presented himself alive to the Apostles with many proofs, appearing to them during forty days and speaking of the Kingdom of God[26]. The number is not decorative. In the Bible, forty marks a complete time of preparation: forty days of Moses on the mountain, forty years of Israel in the desert, forty days of Elijah's walk to Horeb, forty days of Jesus' fasting in the desert before the temptation[27]. Here, the forty days separate two modes of presence. During this time, the Risen One eats and drinks with his own, but his glory still remains veiled under the features of an ordinary humanity; the last appearance ends with the irreversible entry of his humanity into divine glory[28].
This is the meaning of the word spoken to Mary Magdalene on the morning of Easter, "I have not yet ascended to the Father." The Catechism reads in it a difference of manifestation between the glory of the risen Christ and that of the Christ exalted at the right of the Father, and it calls the Ascension the event, both historical and transcendent, that marks the transition from one to the other[29].
The meal, the command to wait, and the question of the Kingdom
When the day came, Jesus eats with the Apostles and orders them not to leave Jerusalem, but to wait there for what the Father had promised: to be baptized in the Holy Spirit within a few days[30]. The promise takes up what John the Baptist announced and what Jesus himself had promised in the farewell discourses: an Advocate who would come when he had gone[31].
The Apostres then ask the question that has occupied them from the beginning: is the Lord going to restore the kingdom to Israel? Jesus' answer not only corrects a date, it shifts the whole horizon. It is not for them to know the times and moments that the Father has fixed; however, they will receive a power, that of the Holy Spirit, and they will be his witnesses in Jerusalem, in Judea, in Samaria and to the ends of the earth[32]. The Kingdom is not restored like a restored political throne: it advances through witness, from near to far, and it is the whole book of Acts that will unfold this geography.
The chronology below summarizes the frame of the forty days as the accounts give it, without forcing each encounter into a date it does not have.
- First dayThe empty tomb and the first appearances
On the morning of Easter, the tomb is found empty, Mary Magdalene meets the Risen One, the disciples of Emmaus recognize him at the breaking of the bread and, in the evening, he stands in the midst of his own.
- Eighth dayThomas confesses his Lord
Eight days later, Thomas, absent the first evening, sees the wounds of the Risen One and confesses: my Lord and my God.
- During forty daysThe lake, the mountain and the widened witnesses
By the shore of the Sea of Tiberias, on the mountain of Galilee, before more than five hundred brethren at once, before James then all the apostles, Jesus shows himself alive with many proofs and speaks of the Kingdom of God.
- Fortieth dayThe Ascension on the Mount of Olives
Jesus blesses the Apostles, is lifted up before their eyes, a cloud takes him out of their sight and two men in white garments announce that he will return.
- Ten days of waitingThe Upper Room, Mary and the election of Matthias
The Apostles return to Jerusalem, persevere in prayer with Mary the mother of Jesus and choose Matthias to complete the Twelve, until Pentecost.
The elevation, the cloud and the two men in white
The scene itself takes up three verses. Jesus is lifted up before the eyes of the Apostles, a cloud comes to take him out of their sight, and as they still gaze into heaven, two men in white garments stand before them[33]. Every detail counts. The elevation is visible: it is not an inward vision, but a departure watched. The cloud is not a vehicle: throughout the Bible, it is the sign of the presence of God, the one that guided Israel in the desert and that enveloped the disciples at the Transfiguration[34]. Saint Thomas Aquinas says it plainly: the cloud did not furnish Christ with a help similar to that of a vehicle; it appeared as a sign of divinity[35].
"After these words, before their eyes, he was lifted up, and a cloud took him out of their sight. And as they were still gazing into heaven where Jesus was going, behold, two men in white garments stood before them."
Book of the Acts of the Apostles, 1, 9-10[36]
The two men in white recall those who, on Easter morning, stood before the women in dazzling attire. Their word interprets the scene and forbids the Apostles from standing there gazing upward: this Jesus, taken up into heaven, will return in the same way they saw him go[37]. The Ascension is therefore not a final farewell. It opens a directed expectation, without a date: the same Jesus, in the same glorified humanity, will return. Saint Leo the Great puts it this way: Christ remains at the right hand of the Father until the times appointed for multiplying the children of the Church are completed, and he will come to judge the living and the dead in the very flesh in which he ascended[38].
The return to Jerusalem and the expectation
The Apostles do not remain on the hill. They return to Jerusalem, go up to the upper room, and persevere with one accord in prayer, with the women and with Mary the mother of Jesus and his brothers[39]. Peter then stands up among them and has Matthias chosen to take the place left vacant by Judas, from among men who had accompanied the Lord from the baptism of John until the day of the taking up[40]. The college of the Twelve is reconstituted before Pentecost: the Church about to be born first receives its witnesses.
This reversal is decisive for reading the scene. The Ascension does not leave disciples orphaned and at a loss; it leaves a community that prays, that awaits a promise dated within a few days, and that prepares to bear witness. Luke insists on joy in the conclusion of his Gospel: the disciples return to Jerusalem with great joy and are continually in the Temple blessing God[41]. A late invention, born of an unprocessed grief, does not produce this tone.
What the other Gospels say, and what they leave unsaid
Matthew: no departure narrated, a presence promised
Matthew is the only evangelist to give neither elevation, nor cloud, nor farewell. His Easter account focuses on Galilee: the Eleven go to the mountain Jesus had designated to them, see him, bow down, and receive the universal mission[42]. The book's final word is not a departure, but exactly the opposite.
"And behold, I am with you all days, until the end of the world."
Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 20[43]
This silence of Matthew about the scene is not a denial. His concern lies elsewhere: to show that the Lord's visible absence is not a real absence. Where Luke recounts how Jesus goes away, Matthew tells how he remains. The two conclusions answer each other like the two faces of a single mystery, which the theology of the Ascension will hold together: Christ has gone, and Christ is present. The ancient tradition never set these conclusions against each other; Saint Augustine compares them notice by notice in his harmony of the evangelists and maintains their succession without concealing the differences of detail[44].
John: the ascent announced even before the Passion
John does not stage the Ascension, but no evangelist announces it as much as he does. In the discourse on the bread of life, Jesus asks what will happen when the disciples see the Son of Man ascending to where he was before[45]. At the Last Supper, he repeats that he is going to the one who sent him and that this departure is better for his own, for the Advocate will not come if he does not go[46]. On Easter morning, he tells Mary Magdalene not to hold him back, for he has not yet ascended to the Father, and he sends her to announce this ascent to the brethren[47].
"Do not hold me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go to my brethren and tell them that I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God."
Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 17[48]
In John, then, the Ascension is not an episode added after Easter: it is the goal of the movement that runs through the whole Gospel, the descent of the Word come from the Father and his return to the Father. The Cross itself is already read there as an elevation: once lifted up from the earth, the Son will draw all men to himself, a word the Catechism links directly to the Ascension, of which the elevation of the Cross is the beginning and the announcement[49].
Mark: the confession in a single sentence
Mark, in his received conclusion, holds in two movements what Luke unfolds in two volumes: the Lord is taken up and seated at the right hand of God, the disciples go out and the Lord works with them[50]. Brevity is not poverty. It shows that, very early on, the elevation and the session form part of the paschal confession itself, on the same footing as the death and the resurrection summed up by Paul. The formula of 1 Corinthians 15 already transmitted, in the 50s, the one who died, who was buried, who was raised, and who appeared[51]; Mark adds, in the language of the psalms, the sitting at the right hand.
The Place: Towards Bethany, on the Mount of Olives
Two indications that converge
Luke gives two pieces of location information that have sometimes been set against each other. The end of the Gospel says that Jesus led the disciples as far as Bethany, raised his hands, blessed them, and parted from them as he was carried up to heaven[52]. Acts says that the Apostles returned to Jerusalem from the Mount of Olives, which is near Jerusalem, a sabbath day's journey away[53]. There is no geographical contradiction here: Bethany lies on the eastern slope of the Mount of Olives, a short distance from Jerusalem. To say "towards Bethany" and to say "the Mount of Olives" is to designate the same area — once by the village aimed at, once by the hill left behind.
The sabbath day's journey gives the scale: a short distance, covered on foot on the day of rest, of the order of a kilometre. The Apostles see the scene, then return to the city the same day. The account calls for neither distant travel nor an inaccessible place: it anchors the event in a topography that any reader familiar with Jerusalem can verify, between the city, the hill of Olives, Gethsemane at the foot of the slope and Bethany beyond the summit.
A hill laden with memory
The Mount of Olives is not a neutral backdrop in the life of Jesus. It is there that he weeps over Jerusalem, there that he foretells the ruin of the Temple, at the foot of this hill that he agonises in Gethsemane on the night of his arrest, and it was from Bethany, on the slope of this same hill, that he entered the city on Palm Sunday. The Ascension in the same place closes the geography of the Passion: the place of agony becomes the place of exaltation. Christian tradition very early on kept the memory of the summit as the place of the Ascension, and the feast attached its celebration to it; the liturgical and historical development of this memory belongs to the article on the feast[54].
The prophet Zechariah had foretold that, on the day of the Lord, his feet would stand on the Mount of Olives, facing Jerusalem to the east[55]. The Apostles, who have just heard that Jesus will return in the same way, hear this place as something more than a mere hill: the point of departure is also, in the Jewish expectation they carry, the point of return. The account does not force the fulfilment, but it leaves the resonance open, and it is that resonance which gives the words of the two men in white their depth.
The Figures of the Old Testament
Elijah taken up, Enoch taken by God
The Old Testament knows of two takings-up that prepare the vocabulary of the Ascension, without being confused with it. Enoch walked with God and was no more, for God took him[56]. Elijah goes up to heaven in a whirlwind, before the eyes of Elisha, who receives his cloak and a double portion of his spirit[57]. The parallel with Elijah is the strongest: a visible departure, a witness who watches, a gift left to the one who remains. But the difference governs everything. Elijah is a prophet taken up; Jesus is the risen Son who ascends by his own power, sits at the right hand of the Father and sends the Holy Spirit ten days later. The figure illuminates the form of the account; it does not exhaust its content.
The table below compares the three ascents without conflating them: it shows what is similar in form, and what absolutely sets Christ apart from the two righteous men of the old covenant.
| Ascent | Witness and form of departure | What is left to men | Proper scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enoch (Gen 5:24) | No named witness; God takes him, with no scene described | A memory of righteousness in the genealogies | God can deliver a righteous man from the common death |
| Elijah (2 Kings 2:1–18) | Elisha watches; chariot and horses of fire, whirlwind | Elijah's cloak and a double portion of his spirit | The prophet departs, his spirit passes to his successor |
| Jesus (Acts 1:9–11) | The Eleven watch; ascent, cloud, two men in white | The promised Holy Spirit, the mission to the ends of the earth, the promise of return | The risen Son enters the Father's glory with his humanity and reigns there |
The psalms of ascent and of session
Two psalms carry the oldest interpretation of the event. Psalm 46 sings of God ascending amid acclamation, to the sound of the horn, and the nations summoned under his reign[58]. The liturgy of the feast proclaims it each year between the readings, because it gives the ascent its music: it is not a flight, but an acclam enthronement.
Psalm 109, the most quoted of all the Old Testament in the New, gives the very formula of the session: an oracle of the Lord to my lord, sit at my right hand[59]. Jesus himself applies it to the Messiah in his controversy with the scribes, Peter applies it to the Risen One at Pentecost itself, and the Letter to the Hebrews makes it the key of his priesthood[60]. When Mark, Paul and the letters say that Christ is seated at the right hand of God, they are not describing a piece of heavenly furniture: they are quoting this psalm and confessing a reign.
"An oracle of the Lord to my lord: Sit at my right hand, and I will make your enemies a footstool for your throne."
Psalm, 109, 1[61]
Daniel's Son of Man
The prophet Daniel, in a night vision, sees one coming with the clouds of heaven, like a Son of Man, who is given dominion, glory and kingship, for a reign that will have no end[62]. Jesus takes this title for himself before the high priest, joining the coming on the clouds to the session at the right hand of the Power[63]. The Catechism reads the session of the Ascension as the inauguration of this reign of the Messiah, the fulfilment of Daniel's vision, from which the Apostles become the witnesses of the Reign that will have no end[64]. The cloud of Acts is therefore not only the sign of the divine presence: it is also, for a reader of Daniel, the cloud of the Son of Man who receives the Kingdom.
The theology of the Ascension
Seated at the right hand of the Father: a reign, not a place
"To sit at the right hand" does not designate a place in space. The Catechism takes up the definition of Saint John Damascene: by the right hand of the Father is to be understood the glory and honour of the divinity, where he who existed as the Son of God before all ages sat down bodily after his incarnation and the glorification of his flesh[65]. Saint Thomas Aquinas distinguishes two senses of the word "to sit": the repose of him who remains eternally incorruptible in the beatitude of the Father, and the power of him who reigns with him and holds from him his power of judging, as one who sits at the right hand of the king assists him in reigning and judging with him[66].
Paul unfolds the same reign in the language of resurrection. God displayed his power in Christ by raising him from the dead and seating him at his right hand in the heavens, above every principality and every name, and he gave him as Head to the Church, which is his body[67]. The Ascension therefore does not take Christ away from his own: it constitutes him Head of a body that remains on earth. This is why Matthew can end without a departure and Luke end with a departure, without contradicting each other: the Lord who is raised up is the Lord present to his body.
Our humanity entered into glory
The most consoling heart of the feast is anthropological: what ascends is not merely the Son of God returning home, but our humanity, taken from the womb of Mary, crucified, buried and risen, which enters into the glory of God. Saint Leo the Great makes it the song of the feast.
"Since the ascension of Christ is our own elevation, and whither the glory of the Head has gone before us, the hope of the body is called in its turn, let us exult, my beloved, with a worthy joy, and let us rejoice in a devout thanksgiving. For today we have not only been confirmed in the possession of paradise, but we have even penetrated, in Christ, the heights of the heavens."
Saint Leo the Great, Sermon 73, first sermon on the Ascension, 4[68]
Saint Gregory the Great, preaching the feast in the basilica of Saint Peter on the Gospel of Mark, comments on the white garments of the angels: at the birth, the divinity seemed humbled; at the Ascension, the humanity is exalted, and he who in his birth had appeared as a humble God showed himself, in his Ascension, as an exalted man[69]. He sees in it the effacement of Adam's condemnation: that nature to which it had been said, "you are dust and to dust you shall return", has today ascended to heaven[70].
"Do you wish, dearly beloved brethren, to know these leaps? From heaven he came into the womb of his mother, from the womb into the manger, from the manger onto the cross, from the cross into the tomb, from the tomb he returned to heaven."
Saint Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels, II, 29, 10[71]
Tertullian already said it to those who denied the resurrection of the flesh: Christ has carried into heaven the pledge of our flesh, and flesh and blood may take heart, for they have conquered in Christ heaven and the Kingdom of God[72]. Saint Thomas sets out the logic of this hope: the Passion opened heaven by taking away sin, but the Ascension of Christ is the direct cause of ours, because it began it in our Head, to whom his members must be united[73].
The high priest entered into the true sanctuary
The letter to the Hebrews reads the Ascension through the gestures of Israel's worship. Once a year, the high priest passed through the veil of the Holy of Holies with the blood of the sacrifices. Christ, for his part, did not enter a sanctuary made by human hands, a copy of the true one; he entered heaven itself, in order to stand now for us before the face of God, and he is always living to intercede on behalf of those who draw near to God through him[74].
"Christ did not enter a sanctuary made by human hands, a copy of the true one; he entered heaven itself, in order to stand now for us before the face of God."
Letter to the Hebrews, 9, 24[75]
The Catechism concludes that in heaven Christ exercises his priesthood perpetually and that he is the centre and chief actor of the liturgy that honours the Father in the heavens[76]. For Saint Thomas, the very presence of Christ before the Father is a prayer: God, who has thus exalted the human nature of Christ, will also have mercy on those for whom the Son of God assumed that nature[77]. The Ascension is therefore not the retirement of a king who abandons his kingdom: it is the installation of an intercessor who never ceases to act.
The departure that sends the Spirit and that promises the return
Jesus had linked his departure to the coming of the Advocate: it is better for the disciples that he go away, for without this departure the Spirit will not come to them[78]. Acts shows the fulfilment ten days later, at Pentecost, when the promised Spirit fills the Apostles and launches the witness from Jerusalem[79]. The Ascension is thus the threshold between two presences: the visible presence of the Risen One for forty days, and the presence of the Spirit in the Church until the return.
For the return is part of the event. The last word of the account is not the elevation, but the promise of the two men in white: this Jesus will return in the same way[80]. The Catechism places Christ entered into the realm of God, whence he will return, but which meanwhile hides him from the eyes of men[81]. Jesus' refusal to reveal the times and the seasons fixed by the Father forbids any calculation of dates[82]: the Ascension gives no calendar, it gives a direction, a mission between the departure and the return, and a way of living this time, with eyes lifted up without remaining motionless.
"We must follow him with the heart to where we believe he has ascended with his body. And if we are still held back here by the weakness of the body, let us follow him at least with the steps of love."
Saint Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels, II, 29, 11[83]
What the Church Professes
The article of the Creed
The two Symbols sung by the Church confess the Ascension in the same phrase as the session. The Apostles' Creed says that Christ ascended into heaven, is seated at the right hand of God the Father almighty, from where he will come to judge the living and the dead. The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, sung at Sunday Mass, says that he ascended into heaven, that he is seated at the right hand of the Father, that he will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and that his kingdom will have no end[84]. Three assertions hold together in one article: the elevation, the present reign, the future return. Remove the Ascension, and the other two lose their foothold.
The Catechism: historical and transcendent
The Catechism opens its presentation of the Ascension with the saying from Mark and with the framework of the forty days, during which the glory of the Risen One remains veiled under an ordinary humanity, before the irreversible entry of his humanity into divine glory symbolized by the cloud and by heaven, where he now sits at the right hand of God[85]. From this it draws the formula that sums up the whole article: the Ascension is an event at once historical and transcendent, marking the transition between the glory of the Risen One and that of the exalted Christ[86]. Historical, because it takes place at a moment, in a place, before witnesses who recount it. Transcendent, because it passes the humanity of Jesus into the realm of God, which the eyes cannot follow.
The same teaching links the Ascension to the present life of the faithful. The exalted Christ intercedes ceaselessly for us as the mediator who permanently ensures for us the outpouring of the Holy Spirit[87]. He has opened for his own access to the Father's house, so that his members may have the hope of joining him where he, their Head and their Principle, has gone before them[88]. The Ascension is therefore not a memory of the past: it describes the present regime of salvation, a Lord who reigns, a Spirit who is given, a Church that bears witness, and a humanity whose destiny has already entered heaven in its head.
The liturgical memorial, in brief
The Church celebrates the event at the solemnity of the Ascension of the Lord, fixed on the fortieth day after Easter, always a Thursday, or transferred to the seventh Sunday of Easter where it is not a holy day of obligation. Each year, the liturgy proclaims the account from Acts, then one of the three Gospels according to the lectionary cycle, Psalm 46, and an apostolic letter that gives the meaning of the session[89]. First celebrated in the joy of the fifty days from Easter to Pentecost, the memorial of the Ascension received its own feast on the fortieth day at the end of the fourth century; around 400, Saint Augustine counts it among the solemnities observed by the whole earth[90].
Everything else, the rank of the feast and the precept, the Rogations that precede it, the novena that follows it up to Pentecost, ancient and modern customs, falls under the article devoted to the feast. Here it suffices to retain the gesture the liturgy has the faithful perform each year: to listen to the account of the departure, to sing the psalm of ascent, and to set out again like the Apostles, not with eyes lost in heaven, but as witnesses. On this celebration, see Ascension of the Lord.
Objections and the historical-critical debate
Part of contemporary exegesis proposes to read the Ascension as something other than an event that happened to the Apostles. These readings deserve to be set out in their strongest form, then examined. None should have the last word without a reply.
Objection 1: Luke contradicts himself between his Gospel and Acts
Objection. In Luke 24, everything seems to happen on Easter day itself: the empty tomb, Emmaus, the evening appearance, then the setting out towards Bethany and the elevation. In Acts 1, the same author speaks of forty days. The same writer would thus be telling the same scene twice, in two incompatible ways, the sign of a literary construction rather than a memory.
Reply. Luke 24 gives no date for the elevation. It links the scenes of the first day and those that follow without any mark of duration, like an account that condenses so as to close a volume. Nothing in his text says "the same day": it is the reader who fills the silence with a date. Acts, the second volume that picks up exactly where the first left off, specifies what the ending condensed: forty days. Saint Augustine already compared the notices of the four Gospels, of Paul, and of Acts concerning the appearances of the Risen One and established their order without concealing the discrepancies[91]. A narrative compression followed by a precision is not a contradiction: it is the ordinary gesture of an author who sums up at the end of a book what he unfolds at the opening of the next. The objection presupposes that an account without a date asserts a date, which is a presupposition of reading, not a fact of the text.
Objection 2: the ending of Mark is an addition, so Mark's Ascension falls
Objection. The long ending of Mark (Mk 16:9–20) is missing from Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, the two great fourth-century manuscripts, and a few ancient witnesses stop at Mk 16:8. Part of the criticism concludes that these verses are not by Mark and that their testimony on the Ascension must be set aside.
Reply. The textual difficulty is real, and it has been known since antiquity: Eusebius of Caesarea and Saint Jerome know the diversity of the copies concerning this ending and discuss it openly[92]. But its absence in two fourth-century codices does not settle the matter by itself. Saint Irenaeus quotes Mk 16:19 as a saying of Mark around 180, thus more than a century before these codices, and the ending is thereafter received in the immense majority of manuscripts, versions, and the liturgy[93]. The Council of Trent receives the books entire with all their parts such as they are customarily read in the Church[94]. The question of whether Mark himself wrote these verses with his own hand and the question of whether the Church receives them as Scripture are two distinct questions. For the Catholic faith, the second is settled by the received canon and by constant liturgical usage, without there being any need to deny the manuscript data. Setting the verse aside solely on the grounds that it is textually disputed confuses a question of manuscript criticism with a verdict on the event.
Objection 3: a body cannot rise; heaven is an outdated cosmology
Objection. The Ascension would describe a vertical journey in a tiered universe, earth below, heaven above, which modern astronomy has abolished. A human body does not rise in this way; the account would therefore be a mythical image clothing an inner experience of the disciples.
Reply. The Church has never taught that the heaven where Christ sits is a region of the physical universe, situated above the atmosphere. The Catechism speaks of the irreversible entry of Christ's humanity into divine glory symbolized by the cloud and by heaven[95]: the word heaven here designates the realm of God, and the cloud is its sign, as at Sinai or at the Transfiguration. Saint Thomas already specified that the cloud served Christ neither as vehicle nor as aid in his ascension, but appeared as a sign of divinity[96]. The account thus says two things at once, which the Catechism holds together by calling the event at once historical and transcendent[97]: the risen body of Jesus really rises before the eyes of the disciples, and what the eyes can no longer follow is his entry into the glory of the Father. Objecting with the physics of a space journey is answering an assertion that the text, read in its own biblical symbolic language, does not make. The real difficulty, that of the miracle itself, is dealt with by the following objection.
Objection 4: ancient ascensions show a borrowed mythic motif
Objection. The ancient world tells of abductions and apotheoses: Elijah and Enoch in the Bible, Romulus or Heracles in the Greco-Roman world. The Ascension would have taken up this available motif in order to glorify a departed master after the fact, as if the disciples had projected their faith into a narrative of elevation.
Reply. The formal parallel does exist, and the article itself showed it with Elijah and Enoch: it is not an embarrassing discovery, it is part of biblical language. But a resemblance of form does not prove an invention of content. Between the cases, the differences are precisely what makes this dossier distinctive: a crucified man publicly executed, an empty tomb, appearances to named witnesses over forty days, then an elevation before the Eleven, followed ten days later by public preaching in the very place of the execution. Ancient apotheoses glorify heroes or emperors, at a distance, with no hostile witnesses to convince and no community born in the city of the martyrdom. Above all, the argument from the motif proves at most that a form was available: it does not prove that it was filled by an invention. Moving from literary possibility to the historical fact of fabrication is exactly the leap that the method must justify, and that it presupposes here instead of demonstrating. The Christian tradition, for its part, receives Elijah as a real figure who prepares, not as a mask that disguises.
Objection 5: subjective visions would have been enough to produce the narrative
Objection. Since the mythic readings of the nineteenth century, one hypothesis keeps returning: the disciples would have experienced inner visions born of grief or hope, then these experiences would have been objectified into appearance narratives, crowned by a scene of elevation that gives the group its birth certificate.
Reply. The hypothesis must explain more than one experience: it must explain the ancient list of witnesses, including more than five hundred brothers at once, most of them still alive when Paul passes it on[98]; the conversion of James, the Lord's brother, who did not believe during the public ministry and who becomes a pillar of the Church of Jerusalem[99]; the reversal of Paul, a persecutor, who places himself last in the same list[100]; and the tone of the final narrative, of the disciples returning to Jerusalem with great joy to wait ten days in prayer[101]. A subjective vision shared by five hundred people, converting a skeptical brother and a persecutor, then producing a calm and organized expectancy, demands as much faith in collective psychology as the narrative demands faith in the event. The vision hypotheses describe a general possibility; they have never produced the concrete mechanism that would have linked these precise facts together, with these names, in this order, in so few years.
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
These objections share a method that must be named, for it governs their conclusions even before the texts are examined. Part of contemporary exegesis proposes to date the narratives late, to cut them into successive editorial layers, and to treat the Tradition that transmits them as suspect by principle. Its weaknesses are recurring: hypothetical reconstructions presented as results, circular datings in which a text is dated by a theory built by dating texts, a presupposition that rules out precise prophecy and miracle in advance, arguments from silence drawn from incomplete documents, extrapolation from partial clues, and confusion between literary possibility and historical proof[102].
On the Ascension, these limits can be seen concretely. Dating Luke late because his narrative seems constructed, then concluding from that date that the narrative is constructed, is a circle. Setting aside the ending of Mark because two codices omit it, without weighing the testimony of Irenaeus who quotes it a century earlier, is a choice of witnesses, not a demonstration. Reading Luke 24 as if it dated the elevation to the first day, when it does not date it, makes the text say what it leaves unsaid. None of these approaches is illegitimate as a question; all of them become weak when presented as a verdict.
Benedict XVI warned against an exegesis that would reduce the sacred text to strata and reconstructions without encountering the event or the persons who attest to it[103]. The traditional position, for its part, remains defensible point by point: an author named from the second century and linked to Paul, a second volume that stops before the death of Paul and before the fall of Jerusalem, ancient manuscripts widely circulated, an ending of Mark quoted by Irenaeus and received by the canon and the liturgy, named witnesses still alive when the list circulates. The reader does not have to choose between faith and history: he may hold that these texts are what they claim to be, received testimonies, and that the event they recount took place.
To go further
- The apparitions of the Risen Lord: the encounters of the forty days preceding the elevation
- Ascension of the Lord: the feast, its rank, its readings and its customs
- The crucifixion of Jesus: the death and the elevation of the Cross, which foreshadows that of heaven
- The burial of Jesus: the burial and the empty tomb
- The descent into hell: the sojourn among the dead between the Cross and Easter
- The Transfiguration: the veiled glory shown in advance on the mountain
- The Last Supper: the farewell discourses and the promise of the Advocate
- The Sermon on the Mount: the teaching of the Kingdom proclaimed during the forty days
Notes and References
Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 50-53, AELF liturgical translation: Jesus leads the disciples towards Bethany, lifts his hands, blesses them, parts from them and is carried up to heaven.
1Acts of the Apostles, 1, 9-11, AELF translation: before their eyes he was lifted up, a cloud took him out of their sight, two men in white garments announce that he will return in the same way.
2 33 36Acts of the Apostles, 1, 1-2, AELF translation: first book to Theophilus, all that Jesus did and taught until the day when he was taken up to heaven.
3 4Gospel according to Saint Mark, 16, 19-20, AELF translation: the Lord Jesus, after speaking to them, was taken up to heaven and seated at the right hand of God; the disciples preach everywhere, the Lord working with them.
5 12 50Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 20, AELF translation: I am with you all days until the end of the world.
6 43Gospel according to Saint John, 20, 17, AELF translation: do not hold on to me, I have not yet ascended to the Father; I am going to my Father and your Father.
7 47 48Letter to the Ephesians, 1, 20-23; Letter to the Hebrews, 7, 25 and 9, 24; First Letter of Peter, 3, 22, AELF translation: the risen Christ seated at the right hand of God, interceding, ascended into heaven.
8Council of Trent, session IV, 8 April 1546: the canon receives the holy books in their entirety with all their parts.
9 25 94Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 10, 5, c. 180: quotation of Mk 16, 19, the Lord Jesus taken up to heaven and seated at the right hand of God, expressly attributed to Mark, prior to the great codices that omit the ending.
10 93Latin Lectionary: the ending of Mark (Mk 16, 15-20) is the traditional Gospel for the feast of the Ascension according to the year.
11Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, c. 180: Matthew published among the Hebrews, Mark transmitted Peter's preaching, Luke, Paul's companion, set down the Gospel preached, John published his own at Ephesus. A witness who was a disciple of Polycarp, himself a disciple of John.
13 19Muratorian Fragment, late 2nd century, Roman canon: Luke as the third Gospel, John as the fourth.
14Letter to the Colossians, 4, 14; Second Letter to Timothy, 4, 11; Letter to Philemon, 24, AELF translation: Luke, the beloved physician, Paul's collaborator.
15Acts of the Apostles, 16, 10-17; 20, 5 to 28, 16: passages in the first person plural, known as the "we" passages, a sign of a companion who was present.
16Gospel according to Saint Luke, 1, 1-4, AELF translation: to have carefully informed himself of everything from the beginnings with the eyewitnesses and servants of the Word, so as to write an ordered account to Theophilus.
17First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 6, AELF translation: appeared to more than five hundred brethren at once, most of them still alive, some have fallen asleep.
18 98Acts of the Apostles, 28, 30-31: Paul remains two years in Rome and preaches the Kingdom without hindrance; the book stops before his death and before the fall of Jerusalem in 70.
20Papyrus P52, fragment of John 18 copied c. 125, kept in Manchester; papyrus P75, Bodmer codex from the early 3rd century containing Luke and John: circulation far from the place of origin, presupposing an early date of composition.
21Pontifical Biblical Commission, decree of 29 May 1907 on the fourth Gospel: it is historically certain that the apostle John is the author of a historical account of the events and the real discourses of the life of the Lord.
22Second Vatican Council, constitution Dei Verbum, 19, 18 November 1965: the Church affirms without hesitation the historicity of the four Gospels, which faithfully transmit what Jesus truly did and taught.
23 24Acts of the Apostles, 1, 3, AELF translation: after his Passion, he presented himself alive with many proofs, appearing during forty days and speaking of the Kingdom of God.
26Book of Exodus, 24, 18; First Book of Kings, 19, 8; Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 4, 2, AELF translation: forty days of Moses on the mountain, of Elijah's journey towards Horeb and of Jesus' fasting in the desert.
27Catechism of the Catholic Church, 659: during the forty days, the glory of the Risen Lord remains veiled under the appearance of an ordinary humanity; the last apparition ends with the irreversible entry of his humanity into divine glory, symbolized by the cloud and by heaven, where he sits at the right hand of God.
28 34 85 95Catechism of the Catholic Church, 660: the event of the Ascension, at once historical and transcendent, marks the transition between the glory of the risen Christ and that of the Christ exalted at the right hand of the Father.
29 86 97Acts of the Apostles, 1, 4-5, AELF translation: during a meal, an order not to leave Jerusalem and to wait for what the Father had promised, the baptism in the Holy Spirit within a few days.
30Gospel according to Saint John, 16, 7, AELF translation: it is better for you that I go away, for if I do not go away, the Advocate will not come to you.
31 46 78Acts of the Apostles, 1, 6-8, AELF translation: it is not for you to know times and seasons; you will receive a power, that of the Holy Spirit, and you will be my witnesses to the ends of the earth.
32Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 57, article 4, reply to the third objection: the cloud did not provide Christ with assistance like that of a vehicle; it appeared as a sign of divinity.
35 96Acts of the Apostles, 1, 11, AELF translation: this Jesus who has been taken up to heaven from among you will come in the same way as you saw him go into heaven.
37 80Saint Leo the Great, Sermon 74, second sermon on the Ascension, 2: Christ remains at the right hand of the Father until the completion of the times appointed for multiplying the sons of the Church, and he will come to judge in the very flesh with which he ascended.
38Acts of the Apostles, 1, 12-14, AELF translation: return from the Mount of Olives to Jerusalem, the upper room, persevering prayer with the women, Mary the mother of Jesus and his brothers.
39Acts of the Apostles, 1, 21-26, AELF translation: to choose a witness among the men who have accompanied the Lord from the baptism of John until the day of the taking up; the lot designates Matthias.
40Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 52-53, AELF translation: the disciples prostrate themselves, return to Jerusalem with great joy and are constantly in the Temple blessing God.
41 101Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 28, 16-18, AELF translation: the Eleven in Galilee, on the mountain designated; all power has been given to me in heaven and on earth.
42Saint Augustine, De consensu evangelistarum, book III, chapter 25: comparison of the accounts of the four Gospels, of Paul and of Acts concerning the manifestations of the Risen Lord, and the establishment of their order.
44 91Gospel according to Saint John, 6, 62, AELF translation: and if you were to see the Son of man ascend to where he was before.
45Catechism of the Catholic Church, 662: in heaven Christ permanently exercises his priesthood, centre and principal agent of the liturgy that honours the Father; the elevation on the Cross signifies and announces the elevation of the Ascension, it is its beginning, according to Jn 12, 32.
49 76First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 3-5, AELF translation: I handed on what I had received, the Christ who died for our sins, was buried, rose on the third day, appeared to Cephas and then to the Twelve.
51Gospel according to Saint Luke, 24, 50, AELF translation: Jesus leads the disciples as far as to the vicinity of Bethany, raises his hands and blesses them.
52Acts of the Apostles, 1, 12, AELF translation: they returned to Jerusalem from the Mount of Olives, near Jerusalem, a sabbath day's journey away.
53Article Ascension of the Lord: history of the feast on the fortieth day, rank, readings, Rogation days and the Pentecost novena.
54Book of Zechariah, 14, 4, AELF translation: on that day his feet will stand on the Mount of Olives, which faces Jerusalem to the east.
55Book of Genesis, 5, 24, AELF translation: Enoch walked with God, then he was no more, for God had taken him.
56Second Book of Kings, 2, 1-18, AELF translation: Elijah goes up to heaven in a whirlwind, Elisha receives his cloak and asks for a double share of his spirit.
57Psalm, 46, AELF translation: God ascends amid acclamations, the Lord, to the sound of the horn; a song proclaimed by the liturgy of the feast.
58Psalm, 110, 1, AELF translation: an oracle of the Lord to my lord: sit at my right hand.
59 61Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 22, 41-46; Acts of the Apostles, 2, 34-35; Letter to the Hebrews, 1, 13, AELF translation: Psalm 110 applied to the Messiah by Jesus, by Peter at Pentecost and by the letter to the Hebrews.
60Book of Daniel, 7, 13-14, AELF translation: with the clouds of heaven there comes one like a Son of man; dominion, glory and kingship are given to him, his reign will have no end.
62Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 26, 64, AELF translation: you will see the Son of man seated at the right hand of Power and coming on the clouds of heaven.
63Catechism of the Catholic Church, 664: the session at the Father's right hand means the inauguration of the Messiah's reign, the fulfilment of Daniel's vision concerning the Son of man; the apostles become the witnesses of the Reign that will have no end.
64Catechism of the Catholic Church, 663, citing Saint John Damascene, On the Orthodox Faith, IV, 2 (PG 94, 1104C): by the Father's right hand is meant the glory and honour of the divinity, where the Son has taken his seat bodily after the incarnation and the glorification of his flesh.
65Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 58, article 1: two senses of Christ's sitting, rest in the blessedness of the Father and the power to reign and judge with him.
66Letter to the Ephesians, 1, 20-23, AELF translation: God raises Christ, seats him at his right hand in the heavens above all things, and gives him as Head to the Church, his body.
67Saint Leo the Great, Sermon 73, 4 (PL 54). Ignispedia translation checked against the Latin text: Christi ascensio nostra provectio est, et quo praecessit gloria capitis, eo spes vocatur et corporis.
68Saint Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels, II, 29 (PL 76), preached to the people in the basilica of Saint Peter for the Ascension; critical edition and translation by R. Étaix, G. Blanc and B. Judic, Sources chrétiennes 522, Paris, Cerf, 2008: birth and humbled divinity, Ascension and exalted humanity; the leaps from heaven to heaven; follow with the heart and with the steps of love.
69 70 71 83Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh, 51: Christ has carried into heaven the pledge of our flesh; flesh and blood, take heart, in Christ you have conquered heaven and the Kingdom of God.
72Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 57, article 6, reply to the second objection: Christ's Ascension is the direct cause of ours, begun in our Head to which his members must be united.
73Letter to the Hebrews, 9, 24 and 7, 25, AELF translation: entered into heaven itself to stand before the face of God; ever living to intercede for those who draw near to God through him.
74 75Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, question 57, article 6: the very presence of Christ, by his human nature introduced into heaven, is an intercession for us.
77Acts of the Apostles, 2, 1-41: ten days after the Ascension, the promised Holy Spirit fills the Apostles at Pentecost and launches the testimony from Jerusalem. Article Pentecost.
79Catechism of the Catholic Church, 665: Christ has entered into God's domain, from which he will return, but which meanwhile hides him from the eyes of men.
81Acts of the Apostles, 1, 7, AELF translation: it is not for you to know the times and seasons that the Father has established by his own authority.
82Catechism of the Catholic Church, synoptic presentation of the Apostles' Creed and the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, official French text (vatican.va).
84Catechism of the Catholic Church, 667: Christ intercedes ceaselessly for us as the mediator who permanently secures for us the outpouring of the Holy Spirit.
87Catechism of the Catholic Church, 661, citing the preface of the Ascension: Christ has opened the way to the Father's house, so that his members may have the hope of joining him there where he, Head and Principle, has preceded them.
88Lectionary of the Roman Missal, solemnity of the Ascension: Acts 1, 1-11 as the first reading every year, Psalm 46, apostolic letter and gospel according to the year (Matthew 28, Mark 16 or Luke 24).
89Saint Augustine, Letter 54, to Januarius: the Ascension counted, around 400, among the solemnities celebrated by the whole earth.
90Eusebius of Caesarea, Questions to Marin; Saint Jerome, letters on the text of Mark: the ancients know the diversity of manuscripts regarding the ending of Mark and discuss it openly.
92Letter to the Galatians, 1, 19 and 2, 9; Gospel according to Saint John, 7, 5, AELF translation: James, the brother of the Lord, at first without faith during the public ministry, then a pillar of the Church of Jerusalem with Cephas and John.
99Acts of the Apostles, 9, 3-6; 22, 6-10; 26, 13-18; First Letter to the Corinthians, 15, 8-9, AELF translation: the Risen Lord appeared last to Paul, persecutor turned apostle.
100Recurring weaknesses of critical reconstructions: hypotheses of unattested traditions, circular datings, a presupposition ruling out precise prophecy and miracle in advance, the argument from silence, extrapolation from incomplete clues, Tradition treated as suspect by principle.
102Benedict XVI, apostolic exhortation Verbum Domini, 30 September 2010: a warning against an exegesis that would reduce sacred scripture to layers and reconstructions without encountering the event or the persons who bear witness to it.
103