Five days before Passover, Jesus descends from the Mount of Olives toward Jerusalem, seated on a donkey, while the crowd spreads their cloaks and cries out: "Hosanna to the Son of David!"[1]. The four Gospels recount the scene, each with its own accent, and all of them read in it the fulfilment of the oracle of Zechariah: "Behold, your king is coming" (Zech 9:9)[2]. The Catechism sees in it the manifestation of the Kingdom that the King-Messiah will accomplish through the Passover of his death and resurrection[3].
The event is unique in the public ministry: Jesus, who had always eluded popular attempts to make him king[4], here chooses the moment, prepares the details, and accepts the messianic acclamation. He enters the city of David as a King, but on a humble mount, and he weeps over Jerusalem as he sees it[5]. Kingship claimed and humility proclaimed hold together: this is the whole mystery of that day.
This article reads the four accounts as the Church receives them: testimonies rooted in history, carried by known authors, dated to the first century, meditated upon by the Fathers, sung by the liturgy, and scrutinised by modern research, whose hypotheses are examined at the end of the journey.
The file in one page: the four accounts of the entry
Before going into the detail, here is how the four Gospels distribute the material. All of them recount the same day, but none says exactly the same things: Matthew gives the prophetic fulfilment, Mark the movement, Luke the tears, John the festival crowd.
| Gospel | Form of the account | What it contributes in its own right |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew 21:1-11 | Account of fulfilment | The donkey and the colt brought together, the explicit quotation of Zechariah, the acclamation to the "Son of David", the city "in turmoil"[6][7] |
| Mark 11:1-11 | Brief and lively account | The sending of two disciples, the colt "on which no one has ever yet sat", the cloaks and the greenery cut in the fields, the evening visit to the Temple[8][9] |
| Luke 19:28-44 | Account of ascent and mourning | The descent of the Mount of Olives by "the whole multitude of the disciples", the Pharisees rebuked ("the stones will cry out"), the tears over Jerusalem and the announcement of the siege[10][11] |
| John 12:12-19 | Festival account | The day after the anointing at Bethany, the crowd that had come for the festival with palm branches, the "King of Israel", the remark about the disciples who understood only after the glorification[12][13] |
These four voices do not contradict one another; they complement one another: Matthew proves, Mark shows, Luke weeps, John contemplates. It is the same event seen from four angles, as four witnesses of the same scene each recount what struck him.
Matthew: the King announced by the prophets
Matthew, the most Jewish of the four evangelists, constructs his account as a demonstration: everything that happens that day was written. He alone quotes Zechariah in full, and he alone has two animals brought.
The donkey and the colt
Jesus sends two disciples with precise instructions: in the village opposite, they will find "a donkey tied, and a colt with her", which they are to untie and bring; if anyone questions them, they are to answer, "The Lord has need of them"[14]. The disciples obey, bring the two animals, spread their cloaks on them, and Jesus sits down[15]. Why two animals when the other three accounts show only one? Because the oracle of Zechariah names both: "a donkey, a colt, the foal of a donkey" (Zech 9:9)[16]. Matthew wants to show that the prophecy is fulfilled to the letter: the mother is brought along with her young, which is in any case the most natural thing for a young animal never yet ridden. Jesus mounts the colt, as Mark and Luke specify[17]. Saint Augustine already noted that "both were brought to the Lord", and read a spiritual meaning in it: the colt, which no one had ridden, figures the nations called to faith, and the donkey the people of Israel[18]. A detailed examination of this question belongs to the liturgical reading of Palm Sunday, treated in Palm Sunday.
"Hosanna to the Son of David"
The crowd that goes before and that follows cries out "Hosanna", acclaims the "Son of David", blesses "him who comes in the name of the Lord"[19]. The title Son of David is the royal messianic title par excellence: it designates the heir promised to David, the one whose reign will have no end (cf. 2 Sam 7:12-16)[20]. By publicly accepting it, Jesus claims the Davidic kingship at the very moment when he is about to die. Matthew adds a detail that no other gives: "all the city was in turmoil", and to the question "Who is this man?", the crowds answer, "This is the prophet Jesus, from Nazareth in Galilee"[21]. The turmoil (the Greek verb literally means "to shake as in an earthquake") says that Jerusalem senses something greater passing by than one more pilgrim.
"Hosanna to the Son of David! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Hosanna in the highest!" (Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21:9, liturgical translation AELF)[22]
Mark and Luke: the pilgrim's path and the prophet's tears
Mark and Luke recount the same ascent, but Luke, the investigator, adds pathos to it: it is in his Gospel alone that Jesus weeps over the city.
Mark: the sobriety of Peter's witness
Mark gets straight to the point: the sending of the two disciples, the instruction ("The Lord has need of it, and will send it back here immediately"), the colt found outside near a gate, passers-by who ask questions, and the answer that quiets them[23]. Then the cloaks spread out, the greenery "cut from the fields", and the double cry: "Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Blessed is the Kingdom that comes, that of our father David!"[24]. Mark is the only one to have "the Kingdom" explicitly acclaimed: the crowd is not merely greeting a man, it is hailing the coming of the Kingdom. And Mark alone closes the day with a note of great eyewitness truth: when evening came, Jesus looked around the Temple, and then, "as it was already late", returned to Bethany with the Twelve[25]. The cleansing of the Temple will wait until the next day: that evening, the King inspects his house in silence.
Luke: the multitude, the Pharisees, and the stones
Luke arranges the scene as an ascent: Jesus walks at the head towards Jerusalem, arrives "near Bethphage and Bethany, near the mountain called the Mount of Olives", and sends two disciples to fetch the colt "on which no one has ever yet sat", with the same password: "The Lord has need of it"[26]. On the way down the mountain, "the whole multitude of the disciples", filled with joy, praises God for the miracles they have seen and proclaims: "Blessed is he who comes, the King, in the name of the Lord!"[27]. Luke alone has "the King" spoken in so many words, and he alone notes the reaction of the Pharisees mingled with the crowd: "Master, rebuke your disciples!" The answer rings out: "I tell you: if these were silent, the stones would cry out"[28]. The acclamation is not an outburst that can be silenced: creation itself would have to utter it if human beings fell silent.
The tears over Jerusalem
Then comes the pathetic high point of Luke's narrative, absent from the other three. On coming in sight of the city, Jesus wept over it[29]. He weeps as the prophets wept, and his words mingle desire and judgment: Jerusalem has not recognized "what gives peace", and days will come when her enemies will encircle her and leave "not a stone upon a stone", "because you did not recognize the time of your visitation from God"[30]. The Catechism takes up this moment: when Jerusalem comes into view, Jesus weeps over it and expresses "once more the desire of his heart"[31]. Forty years later, in 70, the legions of Titus would encircle the city and destroy the Temple: Luke's hearers, who were writing after the catastrophe or on its eve, heard in these tears a prophecy fulfilled.
"On coming in sight of the city, Jesus wept over it, saying: Ah! if you too had recognized on this day what gives peace! But now it has been hidden from your eyes." (Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19:41-42, AELF liturgical translation)[32]
John: the Palm Sunday crowd and the hour that has come
John recounts the same entry, but from the vantage point of the feast: it is no longer the procession that goes up, but Jerusalem that comes down to meet him. His account alone names the palms, and it alone admits that the disciples understood only later.
The next day: the feast comes to meet Jesus
"The next day", that is, the day after the anointing at Bethany, "the great crowd that had come for the feast learned that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem"[33]. The crowd, then, has not been following Jesus from Galilee: it comes out of the city, it is already gathered for Passover, and it comes to meet him with "branches of palm trees"[34]. This detail changes the whole picture: the entry is not merely the arrival of a group of Galilean pilgrims, it is Jesus' encounter with the Paschal gathering itself. The cry takes up Psalm 118 with a royal addition: "Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord, the King of Israel!"[35]. And John quotes Zechariah in brief form: "Do not be afraid, daughter of Zion: behold your king is coming, seated on the foal of a donkey"[36].
"We would like to see Jesus": the hour of the nations
John links the entry immediately to the episode of the Greeks: pagans who have come up to worship during the feast ask to see Jesus, and Jesus answers: "The hour has come for the Son of Man to be glorified"[37]. The entry thus opens the hour, that is, the Passion: the King acclaimed by Jerusalem will draw the nations to himself. This is the deep meaning John gives to the day: Israel's acclamation leads to the calling of the pagans, and the kingship proclaimed on the road will be brought to completion on the cross, whose inscription will proclaim in three languages, "Jesus the Nazarene, King of the Jews" (Jn 19:19-20)[38].
The disciples understood only later
John adds a confidence of disarmingly honest candor: "His disciples did not understand this at the time, but when Jesus was glorified, then they remembered that this had been written about him"[39]. The admission is precious for the historian and the believer alike: the accounts of the entry are not a staging fabricated after the fact by disciples who had understood everything in advance. They are the memory of men who lived a dazzling day without understanding it, and who grasped its meaning only in the light of the resurrection. Memory precedes understanding: this is the mark of true testimony.
The anointing at Bethany: a question of dates honestly raised
John places the anointing by Mary at Bethany "six days before Passover" (Jn 12:1)[40], whereas Mark and Matthew place it "two days before Passover" (Mk 14:1; Mt 26:2)[41]. Is this a contradiction? Several readings have been proposed since the Fathers: two distinct anointings (John's at the beginning of the week, Mark's at the end), or an anticipation in John, grouping the farewells at Bethany before the entry. The Church has never ruled between these harmonizations, and the article notes them without settling the question: the essential point, attested by all, is that the anointing at Bethany immediately precedes the entry and that Mary announces there, by her perfume, the burial of the Lord[42]. The fine chronology of the week is detailed further below.
"Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord, the King of Israel!" (Gospel according to Saint John, 12:13, AELF liturgical translation)[43]
The Route: from Bethany to Jerusalem
The entry follows a precise itinerary, marked by known and verifiable places: Bethany, Bethphage, the Mount of Olives, the Kidron Valley, the Temple. The topography of the accounts is exact, and each place carries a meaning.
Bethany, the village of friends
Jesus has just come from Jericho, where he healed the blind Bartimaeus (Mk 10:46–52)[44], and he goes up to Bethany, "fifteen stadia" from Jerusalem, or about three kilometres (Jn 11:18)[45]. Bethany is the village of Martha, Mary, and Lazarus, whom Jesus has just raised: it is this sign, says John, that set the crowd of the entry in motion[46]. Bethany is also the refuge of the evenings of Holy Week: each evening, Jesus returns there to sleep (Mk 11:11)[47]. The King entering his capital lodges with his friends, not in a palace.
Bethphage and the Mount of Olives
From Bethany, the road passes through Bethphage, the "house of figs" according to the commonly accepted etymology, a hamlet on the eastern slope of the Mount of Olives[48]. The Mount of Olives is a ridge about three kilometres long that overlooks Jerusalem from the east, separated from the city by the Kidron Valley. It is a place laden with hope: the prophet Zechariah announced that the feet of the Lord would rest upon the Mount of Olives on the day of deliverance (Zech 14:4)[49]. In descending from this mountain towards the Temple, Jesus sets his steps within the very geography of Israel's expectation.
The last week, day by day
The entry opens Holy Week. Here is the timeline that the four accounts allow us to reconstruct, following the order of Mark, the most precise as to the days.
- SaturdayThe anointing at Bethanysix days before Passover (Jn 12:1)
Jesus arrives at Bethany. Mary pours costly ointment on his feet. Jesus sees in it the announcement of his burial[50].
- SundayThe entry into Jerusalemfive days before Passover
Descent of the Mount of Olives, cloaks, palm branches, Hosanna. In the evening, a quiet visit to the Temple, then back to Bethany[51].
- MondayThe fig tree and the cleansing of the Templethe King cleans his house
Jesus curses the barren fig tree, drives the sellers from the Temple: "My house shall be called a house of prayer" (Mk 11:17)[52].
- TuesdayThe controversies in the Templetrick questions and parables
The tribute to Caesar, the resurrection of the dead, the great commandment, the parables of the tenants and the wedding feast (Mk 11:27–13:37)[53].
- WednesdaySilence and betrayalthe plot is hatched
Judas goes to the chief priests and agrees with them to hand Jesus over (Mk 14:10–11)[54].
- ThursdayThe Last Supperthe last Passover meal
Jesus eats the Passover with the Twelve, institutes the Eucharist, prays in Gethsemane where he is arrested. The full dossier is to come in The Last Supper.
- FridayThe trial and the Crossthe King crowned with thorns
Appearance before the Sanhedrin and then Pilate, scourging, crucifixion at Golgotha. See The trial of Jesus and The crucifixion of Jesus.
"Behold your king": Zechariah, the psalms, and royal gestures
Nothing in this day is improvised: every gesture of Jesus and of the crowd reprises a text or a royal custom of Israel. To understand the entry, one must know three references: the oracle of Zechariah, the pilgrimage psalm, and the enthronements of old.
The oracle of Zechariah 9:9
The prophet Zechariah, active after the exile to Babylon, at the time of the rebuilding of the Temple (towards the end of the sixth century before Christ, according to traditional dating), announces to Jerusalem the coming of a king of a new kind[55]. Here is his oracle, as Matthew and John quote it:
"Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion! Shout aloud, O daughter of Jerusalem! Behold, your king is coming to you: he is righteous and victorious, humble and mounted on a donkey, a colt, the foal of a donkey." (Book of Zechariah, 9:9, AELF liturgical translation)[56]
Three traits define this king: he is righteous, he is victorious (salvation is given to him), and he is humble, mounted on a donkey, the mount of times of peace, the opposite of the war horse (cf. Zech 9:10, which breaks the bow of war)[57]. The rest of the oracle announces a reign of peace "to the ends of the earth." By choosing exactly this mount, Jesus signs his entry: he is indeed the announced King, but a King who refuses violence. Saint Jerome, in his commentary on Zechariah, reads in it the figure of the gentle Christ, and the whole tradition after him[58]. Benedict XVI, in the chapter he devotes to the entry in his book on Jesus, sees in it the gesture by which Jesus claims the rights of kings while transfiguring them: a royalty of poverty that fulfils the prophecy instead of contradicting it[59].
Hosanna and Psalm 118
The crowd's cry comes from Psalm 118 (117 in the Greek numbering), the last of the Passover Hallel, the song of the pilgrims who went up to the Temple for the feasts[60]. The psalm says: "Give, O Lord, give salvation! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!"[61]. "Hosanna" transcribes the Hebrew "save, then," a supplication that became an acclamation of joy: the crowd asks for salvation by proclaiming the one who brings it. By crying this verse as Jesus passes, the pilgrims make him the "coming one" of the psalm, the envoy of God awaited at the feast. The Church has kept this cry: every Mass takes it up in the Sanctus, just before the consecration[62].
"Give, O Lord, give salvation! Give, O Lord, give victory! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Psalm 117:25–26, AELF liturgical translation)[63]
Cloaks, palms, and branches: gestures of enthronement
To spread one's cloak under someone's feet is to acknowledge him as king: so it was done for Jehu, when they spread the garments under him at the top of the steps, crying "Jehu is king!" (2 Kings 9:13)[64]. To cut branches and strew the road is the welcome reserved for victors and liberators: so was Simon Maccabeus welcomed entering the citadel of Jerusalem "with songs of praise and palm branches" (1 Macc 13:51)[65]. John's palms also refer to the Feast of Tabernacles, where Israel waved the lulav, the festive bouquet (Lev 23:40)[66], and already announce the palms of the martyrs and of the crowd of Revelation (Rev 7:9)[67]. Each gesture of the crowd is thus a language: without pronouncing the word "king," it enthrones.
The colt never ridden: a reserved animal
Mark and Luke specify that the colt is one "on which no one has ever yet sat"[68]. The detail is not picturesque: in the Law, animals destined for sacred use must never have borne the yoke (cf. the red heifer of Num 19:2, the cow of Deut 21:3, the cows of the ark in 1 Sam 6:7)[69]. The mount of the King entering the holy city is a reserved beast, intact, as befits a divine use. Saint John Chrysostom, in his homily on this passage, marvels that Christ makes the beasts themselves contribute to the prophecy: creation obeys and carries its Lord[70].
The theology of the entry: a King who comes in tears
The Church does not read the entry as a mere picturesque anecdote: she sees in it the summary of the whole mystery of Christ, a humble King who reveals himself before giving himself over. The Catechism devotes four dense paragraphs to it (nn. 557–560), which provide the Catholic key to the day[71].
The resolute ascent and the King of glory
Jesus "resolutely took the road to Jerusalem," knowing that he was going there to die, after having announced his Passion three times[72]. Then comes the welcome: whereas he had always eluded popular attempts to make him king, Jesus chooses the time and prepares the details of his messianic entry. Acclaimed as the Son of David, he enters his city "mounted on a donkey": he does not conquer the Daughter of Zion by cunning or by violence, but by humility[73].
"How will Jerusalem welcome its Messiah? Whereas he had always eluded popular attempts to make him king, Jesus chooses the time and prepares the details of his messianic entry into the city of David, his father. He is acclaimed as the son of David, the one who brings salvation. Yet the King of Glory enters his City mounted on a donkey: he does not conquer the Daughter of Zion, figure of his Church, by cunning or by violence, but by the humility that bears witness to the Truth." (Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 559)[74]
The children and the poor, subjects of the Kingdom
On that day, the subjects of the Kingdom are neither the powerful nor the priests: they are the children and the "poor of God," who acclaim him just as the angels announced to the shepherds[75]. Matthew recounts that after the entry, children cry out in the Temple, "Hosanna to the Son of David," to the scandal of the chief priests, and that Jesus answers them with Psalm 8: "Out of the mouths of children and infants you have brought forth praise" (Mt 21:15–16; Ps 8:3)[76]. The little ones recognize the King whom the wise refuse: this is the law of the Kingdom, already proclaimed in the Beatitudes (see The Beatitudes).
The next day: the cleansing of the Temple
The King who has just entered inspects his house, then cleanses it. The day after the entry (the very same day, in Matthew's compressed account), Jesus drives the vendors from the Temple: "My house shall be called a house of prayer"[77]. The entry and the cleansing form a single royal gesture: the Messiah takes possession of the place of the divine presence and restores its use. It is this gesture, even more than the entry, that will seal his arrest: by touching the Temple, Jesus touches the heart of religious power. What follows belongs to the dossier of the Passion (see The Passion according to the four Gospels).
"The entry of Jesus into Jerusalem manifests the Coming of the Kingdom that the King-Messiah will accomplish through the Passover of his Death and Resurrection. It is by its celebration, on Palm Sunday, that the liturgy of the Church opens the great Holy Week." (Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 560)[78]
The ancient witnesses: who wrote, when, and how we know it
The Church receives the four accounts from known witnesses, rooted in the first century. Here is the traditional position, carried by the ancient witnesses and the canonical reception, before the examination of modern hypotheses at the end of the article.
| Gospel | Author according to tradition | Traditional dating | Principal ancient witness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew | The apostle Matthew, first in the language of the Hebrews | The 50s to 60s | Papias, relayed by Eusebius (Ecclesiastical History, III, 39): Matthew composed the words of the Lord in the Hebrew language[79] |
| Mark | John Mark, Peter's interpreter in Rome | The 60s | Papias: Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote accurately what he remembered[80] |
| Luke | Luke, the physician companion of Paul | Around 60 to 63 | Ancient prologues and Saint Irenaeus: Luke, companion of Paul, set down the Gospel preached by him[81] |
| John | The apostle John, in Ephesus | Around 90 to 100 | Saint Irenaeus, disciple of Polycarp who was himself a disciple of John: John published his Gospel in Ephesus[82] |
Papias, Irenaeus and the canon: the chain of custody
From the beginning of the second century, Papias of Hierapolis inquires among the companions of the apostles about the origin of the Gospels: this is the first historical inquiry into the sacred authors, and it names Matthew and Mark[83]. Around 180, Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, who had known Polycarp, disciple of the apostle John, attests the four Gospels, no more and no less, comparing them to the four winds and the four faces of the cherubim[84]. The Muratorian Fragment (late second century) already lists the four Gospels as received Scripture[85]. The four accounts of the entry therefore circulate together, as Scripture, while the grandchildren of the witnesses were still alive.
The Fathers read the entry: Augustine, Chrysostom, Jerome
The Fathers are not content merely to transmit the accounts; they meditate on them. Saint Augustine, in his treatise On the Harmony of the Evangelists (around 400), defends inch by inch the coherence of the four accounts, even in the details that seem to contradict one another, such as the two animals of Matthew against the single donkey of the other three[86]. Saint John Chrysostom devotes his 66th homily on Saint Matthew to the entry: he marvels there at a King who sends for his mount as a master disposes of his creation, and at a crowd whose children will silence the doctors[87]. Saint Jerome, commenting on Zechariah, fixes the Christological reading of the oracle: the just one, the savior and the poor one, is Christ entering his Church[88]. Three voices, three centuries, one and the same reading: the entry is a fact accomplished in prophecy.
The Church celebrates the Entry: a pointer, not a duplicate
The Entry is celebrated every year on Palm Sunday, which opens Holy Week: the blessing of the palms, a procession that re-enacts the ascent to Jerusalem, then the reading of the Passion[89]. The full story of this feast, from the procession down the Mount of Olives described by the pilgrim Egeria in the fourth century to the present Missal, is told in the companion article, a complete dossier to be found here: Palm Sunday. We retain here only the essentials: the liturgy does not commemorate an idea, but the fact recounted above, and it is the liturgy that taught Christian crowds the cry of the road, repeated at every Mass in the Sanctus.
A solidly established historical event
Even historians most reserved about the supernatural retain the entry into Jerusalem as a fact: it gathers together the marks of historicity that criticism itself has forged.
Four independent attestations
All four Gospels recount the entry, with diverging details that rule out slavish copying: two animals in Matthew against only one elsewhere, greenery from the fields in Mark against palms in John, weeping in Luke alone, the crowd of pilgrims in John alone[90]. When four witnesses recount the same day while contradicting one another on secondary details yet converging on the essentials (the mount, the acclamation, the kingship), the historian recognises in them the mark of true memories, not that of a concerted legend.
The criterion of embarrassment: a Messiah on a donkey
A community that had invented a triumphant entry out of whole cloth would have had its hero enter as a conqueror, on horseback, to the acclamations of the powerful. Yet the actual entry confounds every messianic expectation of the time: a borrowed donkey's colt, the cloaks of the poor, children for an escort, and a King who weeps. The historian E. P. Sanders counts the entry and the gesture at the Temple that follows it among the best-attested episodes of the life of Jesus, precisely because they fit poorly with what a legend would have imagined[91].
The exact topography and the crowded Passover
Bethany at fifteen stadia, Bethphage on the slope of the Mount of Olives, the descent towards the Kidron and the Temple: every place named exists and follows on in the real order of the terrain[92]. And the vast crowd is explained: at Passover, Jerusalem overflowed with pilgrims come from the whole Jewish world, whom Flavius Josephus describes as countless (his precise figures are disputed, the attendance itself is not)[93]. The entry presupposes exactly this setting: a pilgrimage feast, a city full, an awaited Galilean prophet. The verifiable setting carries the narrative.
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
Honesty requires setting out the current hypotheses of historical-critical exegesis on these accounts, and then honestly showing their limits. This section accords no hypothesis the status of a final verdict.
Current hypotheses on the entry
Part of contemporary exegesis proposes reading the accounts as follows: Mark, written first around 65–70, would supply the framework that Matthew and Luke, around 80–90, would each have enriched in their own way (the two-source hypothesis); Matthew would have split the donkey's colt into two beasts through an overly literal reading of the Hebrew parallelism in Zechariah; John, written around 90–110, would have theologised the scene (palms, King of Israel, the disciples' incomprehension) at a distance from the events[94]. Some add that the Passover crowd would have been amplified by the Palm Sunday liturgy, which would have fed back into the accounts.
Four limits of method
First, the late dating of the Gospels rests in part on circular reasoning: texts are dated after 70 because they foretell the destruction of the Temple with precision, which assumes in advance that a precise prophecy is impossible[95]. Next, the two-source hypothesis explains the resemblances among the Synoptics, but it proves nothing about the truth of the facts: a common source, even a supposed one, can transmit an accurate memory. Thirdly, the thesis of Matthew's "blunder" underestimates the evangelist: bringing the mother along with her young is natural, and Matthew quotes Zechariah knowingly, not through a misreading. Finally, the argument from silence (Josephus does not recount the entry) proves nothing: Josephus does not chronicle the pilgrims of every Passover, and his brief passage on Jesus only sketches a career in broad strokes[96].
Why the traditional position remains defensible
Four accounts rooted in the first century, carried by authors named by the earliest witnesses, received together in the canon from the second century, topographically exact, embarrassing for their own authors, and confirmed in their setting by history (the crowded Passover, the ruin of 70 foretold in tears): such is the dossier. Part of contemporary exegesis proposes seeing in it a late construction, but its reconstructions remain hypothetical and its datings, revisable. The reader who has followed the whole journey understands why the Church continues to read the entry as its first hearers did: the memory of a real day, when the promised King came to his city on a donkey, and his city did not recognise him.
To go further
- Palm Sunday: the liturgical feast, its history since Egeria, its palms, its procession, its readings.
- The Last Supper: the last Passover meal, four days after the entry.
- The Passion according to the four Gospels: the complete account of the week following the entry.
- The trial of Jesus: before the Sanhedrin and then Pilate, the King judged.
- The crucifixion of Jesus: at Golgotha, the inscription proclaims the King of the Jews.
- The baptism of Jesus: at the Jordan, the beginning of the public life that the entry completes in manifesting.
- The Transfiguration: the King of glory glimpsed before the ascent to Jerusalem.
- Jesus found in the Temple: at twelve years old, the first ascent to the house of the Father.
- The Nativity of Jesus: in Bethlehem, the city of David where the Son of David is born.
- The Beatitudes: the poor and the meek, subjects of the Kingdom acclaimed along the road.
- The Sermon on the Mount: the charter of the Kingdom whose entry is the manifestation.
- The wedding at Cana: the first sign, where water becomes wine.
- The temptations of Jesus in the desert: the refusal of easy royalty, before the acceptance of humble royalty.
- The hidden life of Jesus: the thirty years of Nazareth that precede the manifestation.
Notes
Notes and References
Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 9, AELF: "Those who went ahead and those who followed cried out: Hosanna to the son of David! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Hosanna in the highest heavens!"
1 7 19 22Book of Zechariah, 9, 9, AELF liturgical translation (aelf.org): "Exult with all your might, daughter of Zion! Shout for joy, daughter of Jerusalem! Behold your king comes to you: he is just and victorious, humble and riding on a donkey, a colt, the foal of a donkey."
2 16 56Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 560 (vatican.va): "Jesus' entry into Jerusalem manifests the coming of the Kingdom that the King-Messiah is going to accomplish by his Passover, through his Death and Resurrection. It is with the celebration of this entry on Palm Sunday that the Church's liturgy opens Holy Week."
3 78 89Gospel according to Saint John, 6, 15, AELF: after the multiplication of the loaves, Jesus realizes that they are going to come "and carry him off to make him their king" and withdraws alone into the mountain.
4Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 41-42, AELF: "On coming within sight of the city, Jesus wept over it, saying: Ah! if you too had recognized this day what brings peace! But now it has remained hidden from your eyes."
5 11 29 32Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 1, AELF liturgical translation (aelf.org): "As they drew near Jerusalem, at Bethphage on the Mount of Olives, Jesus sent two disciples."
6 48Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 1-6, AELF: the sending of the two disciples to the village opposite, the tethered colt by a gate, outside, and the password: "The Lord has need of it and will send it back here immediately."
8 23Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 11, AELF: Jesus entered the Temple, "looked around at everything and, as it was already evening, went out to Bethany with the Twelve".
9 25 47 51Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 37-38, AELF: on the descent of the Mount of Olives, "the whole multitude of the disciples" praises God and proclaims: "Blessed is he who comes, the King, in the name of the Lord. Peace in heaven and glory in the highest heavens!"
10 27Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 12, AELF: "The next day, the great crowd that had come for the feast learned that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem."
12 33Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 16, AELF: "His disciples did not understand this at the time, but when Jesus was glorified, then they remembered that this had been written about him and done for him."
13 39Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 2, AELF: "You will find a she-donkey tethered and its foal with her. Untie them and bring them to me."
14Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 7, AELF: the disciples "brought the donkey and its foal, spread their cloaks on them, and Jesus sat on them".
15Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 7, AELF: "They bring the young donkey to Jesus, cover it with their cloaks, and Jesus sits on it."
17Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 51, on Jn 12: the donkey and the colt brought together to the Lord, read as figures of Israel and the nations called to faith; see the full development in Palm Sunday.
18Second Book of Samuel, 7, 12-16: Nathan's promise to David, a house and a kingdom established forever.
20Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 10-11, AELF: "As Jesus entered Jerusalem, the whole city was stirred and said: Who is this man? And the crowds said: It is the prophet Jesus, from Nazareth in Galilee."
21Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 9-10, AELF: "Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Blessed is the kingdom that comes, that of David our father. Hosanna in the highest heavens!"
24Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 28-30, AELF: Jesus walks at the head towards Jerusalem; near Bethphage and Bethany, he sends two disciples to fetch the colt "on which no one has ever yet sat".
26Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 39-40, AELF: "Master, rebuke your disciples!" Jesus replies: "I tell you: if these keep silent, the stones will cry out."
28Gospel according to Saint Luke, 19, 43-44, AELF: announcement of the siege, the encirclement and the ruin, "because you did not recognize the time when God visited you".
30Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 558 (vatican.va): Jesus continues to call Jerusalem to gather around him; "when Jerusalem comes into view he weeps over her and expresses once more his heart's desire: 'Would that even today you knew the things that make for peace!'"
31Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 13, AELF: "The people took palm branches and went out to meet him."
34Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 13, AELF: "Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord, the king of Israel!"
35 43Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 15, AELF: "Do not be afraid, daughter of Zion: behold your king comes, seated on the foal of a donkey."
36Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 23, AELF: "The hour has come for the Son of Man to be glorified."
37Gospel according to Saint John, 19, 19-20, AELF: the inscription "Jesus the Nazarene, king of the Jews", written in Hebrew, Latin and Greek.
38Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 1, AELF: "Six days before Passover, Jesus came to Bethany where Lazarus lived, whom he had raised from the dead."
40 50Gospel according to Saint Mark, 14, 1, AELF: "The feast of Passover and of Unleavened Bread was to take place in two days"; follows the account of the anointing at Bethany (Mk 14, 3-9).
41Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 7, AELF: "Leave her alone; let her keep this for the day of my burial!"
42Gospel according to Saint Mark, 10, 46-52, AELF: the healing of Bartimaeus on leaving Jericho, just before the ascent to Jerusalem.
44Gospel according to Saint John, 11, 18, AELF: "Bethany was near Jerusalem, at a distance of fifteen stadia," that is, about three kilometers.
45 92Gospel according to Saint John, 12, 18, AELF: it is because the crowd had learned of the sign of Lazarus that it came out to meet Jesus.
46Book of Zechariah, 14, 4: on the day of the Lord, "his feet will stand on the Mount of Olives".
49Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 17, AELF: "My house shall be called a house of prayer for all nations. But you, you have made it a den of robbers."
52 77Gospel according to Saint Mark, 12, 17, AELF: "Give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and to God what belongs to God"; chapters 12-13 bring together Tuesday's controversies in the Temple.
53Gospel according to Saint Mark, 14, 10-11: Judas Iscariot goes to the chief priests to hand Jesus over to them.
54The book of Zechariah presents itself as the word addressed to the prophet under Darius, at the time of the rebuilding of the Temple (Za 1, 1: the second year of Darius, that is, 520 BC); tradition reads in it the announcement of the humble King of chapters 9 to 14.
55Book of Zechariah, 9, 10: the king will make chariots, horses and bows of war disappear and "will announce peace to the nations".
57Saint Jerome, Commentary on Zechariah (in his commentaries on the twelve minor prophets): on Zec 9, 9, the just one, the saviour and the poor one read as figures of the meek Christ entering his Church.
58 88Joseph Ratzinger, Benedict XVI, Jesus of Nazareth, vol. 2: From the Entrance into Jerusalem to the Resurrection, Éditions du Rocher, Monaco, 2011: the chapter devoted to the entry reads the gesture by which Jesus claims the royalty announced while defining it by poverty, grounded in Zec 9, 9.
59Psalm 118 (117 in the Greek numbering) concludes the Hallel (Ps 113–118), sung at the great feasts, especially at Passover.
60Psalm 117, 25–26, AELF liturgical translation: "LORD, grant salvation! LORD, grant prosperity! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the LORD."
61 63Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 559 (vatican.va): the messianic entry prepared in detail, the acclamation to the Son of David, "Hosanna" meaning "save, give salvation", the King of Glory mounted on a donkey's colt, the children and the poor of God, and the acclamation taken up by the Church in the Sanctus.
62 73 74 75Second Book of Kings, 9, 13: for the enthronement of Jehu, each takes his garment, spreads it out for him at the top of the steps and sounds the trumpet, crying out: "Jehu is king!"
64First Book of Maccabees, 13, 51: Simon enters the citadel "with songs of praise and palm branches, to the sound of harps, cymbals and lyres".
65Book of Leviticus, 23, 40: for the Feast of Tabernacles, Israel takes "choice fruit from fine trees, fronds of palm trees, boughs of leafy trees".
66Book of Revelation, 7, 9: the great multitude "wearing white robes, with palm branches in their hands".
67Gospel according to Saint Mark, 11, 2, AELF: "You will find a young donkey tethered, on which no one has yet sat."
68Book of Numbers, 19, 2: the red heifer "without blemish or defect and that has never been under a yoke"; the same requirement in Dt 21, 3 and 1 S 6, 7.
69Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 66 on Saint Matthew (on Mt 21, 1–11): Christ sends for his mount as Lord of creation, the prophecy is fulfilled before the eyes of the leaders, and it is the children who will confess in the Temple what the doctors refuse.
70 87Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 557 (vatican.va): "When the hour came for him to be taken up to heaven, Jesus resolutely took the road for Jerusalem. By this decision he showed that he was going up to Jerusalem to die."
71 72Gospel according to Saint Matthew, 21, 15-16, AELF: the children cry out "Hosanna to the Son of David!" in the Temple; Jesus replies: "Have you never read: Out of the mouths of children and infants you have brought forth praise?" (Ps 8, 3).
76Papias of Hierapolis, Explanations of the Sayings of the Lord, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: "Matthew composed the sayings [of the Lord] in the Hebrew language."
79 83Papias of Hierapolis, cited by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: "Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately, though without order, everything he remembered."
80Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1 (newadvent.org): Matthew published his Gospel among the Hebrews during the preaching of Peter and Paul in Rome; Mark handed down Peter's preaching in writing; Luc set down the Gospel preached by Paul; John published his at Ephesus.
81 82Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 11, 8: there can be no more or fewer than four Gospels, just as there are four regions of the world and four faces of the cherubim.
84Muratorian Fragment, late 2nd century: the oldest Latin catalogue of the received Scriptures, listing the four Gospels, namely Matthew, Mark, Luke and John.
85Saint Augustine, On the Harmony of the Evangelists (De consensu evangelistarum), c. 400: a methodical defence of the coherence of the four Gospel accounts, including in the details of Holy Week where the accounts seem to diverge.
86Mt 21, 1–11; Mk 11, 1–11; Lk 19, 28–44; Jn 12, 12–19: four direct accounts of the same event, a rare occurrence before the Passion narratives.
90E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism, Fortress Press, Philadelphia, 1985: the entry into Jerusalem and the demonstration in the Temple rank among the most solid facts of the end of the ministry, since they explain the arrest better than any reconstruction without them.
91Flavius Josephus, Jewish War, VI, 9, 3: description of the immense Passover crowds in Jerusalem (the precise figures he gives are debated by historians, but the massive influx is not).
93Two-source hypothesis: Mark first (c. 65–70), taken up by Matthew and Luke (c. 80–90) with a sayings source known as Q; John last (c. 90–110), in successive layers. Part of contemporary exegesis takes it for granted, others debate it (Griesbach hypothesis, Matthean priority, the Louvain school).
94The circular reasoning here consists in dating a text after 70 because it foretells the destruction of the Temple with precision, then concluding from that dating that the prophecy was written after the event: the conclusion is already contained in the premise.
95Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XVIII, 63–64 (Testimonium Flavianum) and XX, 200 (mention of James, "brother of Jesus who was called Christ"): Josephus attests to Jesus, his condemnation under Pilate and the persistence of his disciples, without detailing every episode of the ministry.
96