Coming out of the Jordan, where the Father's voice has just proclaimed him beloved Son, Jesus does not go up towards the crowds: the Spirit drives him into the desert[1]. There he fasts for forty days and forty nights, then faces the Tempter in three assaults: turning stones into bread, throwing himself from the top of the Temple, receiving all the kingdoms of the world in exchange for an act of adoration. Three times, Jesus replies with Scripture, and the devil withdraws "until the appointed time"[2].
The three synoptic Gospels recount this episode: Saint Matthew and Saint Luke set it out in detail in three scenes, Saint Mark summarises it in two striking verses, with the wild beasts and the angels[3]. The Catechism sees its saving meaning in it: Jesus is the new Adam, who remained faithful where the first succumbed, and his victory in the desert anticipates the victory of the Passion[4].
This article follows the three accounts step by step, shows where Jesus draws his replies from, explains why the Son willed to be tempted, gives the ancient witnesses to the Gospels and their traditional datings, describes the place of the episode in Lent, and then answers honestly the objections of modern exegesis.
The case in a single page: three accounts of one same battle
The episode belongs to all three synoptic Gospels, at the exact juncture between the baptism and the preaching in Galilee. Saint Matthew and Saint Luke develop the same face-off in three acts, with a different order for the last two. Saint Mark, according to tradition Peter's spokesman in Rome, keeps only the essentials in two verses, but adds two details the other two do not give: the wild beasts and the ministry of the angels[5].
| Account | Extent | Order of the three assaults | Distinctive features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mt 4:1-11 | Eleven detailed verses | Bread, Temple, mountain | "Away with you, Satan!", the angels who serve |
| Mk 1:12-13 | Two sober verses | No details | The Spirit who "drives", the wild beasts, the angels |
| Lk 4:1-13 | Thirteen detailed verses | Bread, mountain, Temple | "In an instant", the devil who withdraws "until the appointed time" |
Three remarks are called for straight away. First, the episode immediately follows the baptism in all three accounts: it is the first battle of public life, before any miracle and any discourse. Then, the fourth Gospel does not tell it, but Saint John keeps its echo: Christ is ceaselessly confronted there by the "prince of this world", and it is he who announces that this prince "is about to be cast out"[6]. Finally, the difference in order between Matthew and Luke does not disturb the faith: Saint Augustine already noted that it is not known with certainty which of the last two assaults came first, and that the essential point is that all three indeed took place[7].
The account according to Saint Matthew: the duel of the Scriptures
"Led into the desert by the Spirit"
"Then Jesus was led into the desert by the Spirit to be tempted by the devil"[8]. The word matters: it is not the devil who leads Jesus on, it is the Spirit who leads him. Saint John Chrysostom draws a lesson from this for every baptised person: after the grace of baptism, greater temptations may come, and one must not be troubled by them as by something unexpected, for this is the normal course of the battle[9]. The same Father adds that God does not go out to meet temptation of his own accord, but that once led by the Spirit, one must hold firm manfully[10].
"After fasting forty days and forty nights, he was hungry"[11]. The devil does not attack during the fast, but in the hunger: Chrysostom sees in this the proof that fasting is a very powerful shield against the demon, and that Christ fasts not out of need, but to instruct us[12].
"Command that these stones become loaves"
"The tempter approached and said to him: If you are the Son of God, command that these stones become loaves"[13]. The formula will come back twice, and Chrysostom pierces its trickery: the devil heard the voice at the baptism proclaim the beloved Son, he heard the testimony of John, then he sees this famished man; perplexed, he no longer knows whether he is dealing with a mere man or with the Son of God, and his ambiguous question is a net to learn what is hidden from him[14]. He flatters by speaking of dignity, and keeps silent about the hunger so as not to seem to reproach.
Jesus answers: "It is written: Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God"[15]. This is Deuteronomy, chapter 8, the word Moses addressed to Israel concerning the manna: God made his people pass through hunger "so that you may know that man does not live by bread alone, but by everything that comes from the mouth of the Lord"[16]. A first effect of meaning: where Israel grumbled against the manna, Jesus receives hunger in obedience. Saint Thomas notes that the food miracle would not have been a sin in itself, since Jesus will multiply the loaves for the crowd; the fault would have been to seek by miracle, for his sole relief, what he could obtain otherwise, whereas Israel had received the manna because there was no other means of feeding itself in the desert[17].
"Throw yourself down": when the devil quotes Scripture
"Then the devil takes him to the Holy City, places him on the pinnacle of the Temple and says to him: If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down; for it is written: He will give his angels orders concerning you, and: They will bear you up on their hands, lest your foot strike a stone"[18]. The Tempter, repelled by Scripture, comes back with Scripture: he quotes Psalm 91, the psalm of divine protection. The manoeuvre is classic and always current: isolating a verse from its whole to make it say the opposite of the faith.
Jesus answers: "It is also written: You shall not put the Lord your God to the test"[19]. This is Deuteronomy, chapter 6, the word that reminded Israel of the sin of Massah, when the people had demanded proof from God on pain of ceasing to believe[20]. Demanding a spectacular prodigy to verify that God protects is exactly putting God to the test. Saint Thomas adds a fine remark: one can draw glory even from an external humiliation, and it is indeed vainglory that is at stake here, seeking a spiritual glory by throwing oneself into the void[21].
"All this I will give you": the refused adoration
"The devil takes him again onto a very high mountain and shows him all the kingdoms of the world and their glory. He says to him: All this I will give you, if, falling at my feet, you prostrate yourself before me"[22]. Third assault, the gravest: after the flesh and vainglory, ambition and idolatry. Saint Thomas points out that the devil no longer says "If you are the Son of God": this third temptation does not address the spiritual, sons of God by adoption, but only the carnal, ready to despise God in order to reign[23]. And he highlights the mechanism: ambition carries within it another danger, for in order to reign it accepts to serve; the higher it aims, the lower it abases itself[24].
So, for the first time, Jesus rebukes: "Away with you, Satan! for it is written: 'Worship the Lord your God, and serve him alone'"[25]. This is Deuteronomy, chapter 6: "You shall fear the Lord your God, him you shall serve"[26]. Why this sudden severity, after two calm replies? Saint Thomas answers: the Christ bore without disturbance the insult directed at himself, but when the devil usurps the honour due to God, he drives him away. A lesson for us: to bear courageously the insults directed at us, and not even to listen to those directed at God[27].
"Angels came near"
"Then the devil left him. And behold, angels came near, and they served him"[28]. The sobriety of the verse is striking: no triumphalism, a service. He who refused to turn stones into bread for himself is served by angels. The victory in the desert is already a miniature Easter: the fast, the combat, then the service and the light, a first fulfilment of the paschal victory that it anticipates[29].
Mark and Luke: two complementary perspectives
Mark: the sobriety of Peter's witness
"Immediately the Spirit drives Jesus out into the desert and, in the desert, he remained forty days, tempted by Satan. He was among the wild beasts, and the angels served him"[30]. Two verses, no detail of the three assaults, but three unique touches. The verb "drives" (the Spirit casts him out, literally) speaks of the force of the divine impulse. The wild beasts place Jesus back in a regained paradise: where Adam had lost his familiarity with the animals, the new Adam lives among them in peace, like Daniel in the lions' den. The angels who serve him frame the episode: the combat takes place under the gaze of heaven, and heaven already secures its outcome.
According to received tradition, Mark writes in Rome from Peter's preaching: this brevity has the tone of a witness who goes straight to the essentials. It also confirms, by its independence, that the developed account of Matthew and Luke does not come from a single pen: three voices tell of the same combat[31].
Luke: the Spirit, the reversed order, and "the appointed time"
"Jesus, filled with the Holy Spirit, left the banks of the Jordan; in the Spirit, he was led through the desert where, for forty days, he was tempted by the devil"[32]. Luke insists on the Holy Spirit: filled with the Spirit at the start, Jesus returns from the desert "in the power of the Spirit"[33]. Between the two lies the combat. Luke specifies that Jesus "ate nothing during those days, and, when that time was over, he was hungry"[34]: the fast is total, the hunger comes afterwards, at the precise moment when the Tempter strikes.
Two differences from Matthew deserve attention. First the order: in Luke, the mountain comes second and the Temple last, at Jerusalem. Saint Augustine settles the matter with wisdom: one does not know with certainty which of the two came first, and what matters is that all three truly took place; the evangelists may have followed different orders because sometimes greed is born of vainglory, and sometimes the reverse[35]. Then the ending: "Having thus exhausted every form of temptation, the devil withdrew from Jesus until the appointed time"[36]. The word sends a shiver: the combat in the desert is only one round. The "appointed time" will be the agony at Gethsemane and then the Passion, where the same Tempter will return by other voices.
Forty days: Moses, Elijah, and Israel
The number is striking, and it is intentional: forty days without eating, like Moses on Sinai before receiving the tablets ("Moses remained on the mountain forty days and forty nights"), like Elijah walking forty days to Horeb by the strength of the mysterious bread[37]. Chrysostom notes that the Christ stops at exactly forty days, without going further: Moses and Elijah preceded him that far by the power of God, but going beyond that measure would have made the truth of his flesh doubtful in the eyes of many[38]. The fast speaks at once of continuity (the same forty days as the great fasters of Israel) and of the reality of humanity (the hunger comes, the flesh is real).
But the chief backdrop is Israel itself: forty years in the desert, between the Red Sea and the Promised Land. Deuteronomy says so: "Remember the long march you made during forty years in the desert; the Lord your God imposed it on you to make you pass through poverty; he wished to test you and to know what was in your heart: would you keep his commandments, yes or no?"[39]. Israel grumbled for bread, demanded proofs at Massah, prostrated before the golden calf: exactly the three points where Jesus, for his part, stands firm. The Catechism sums it up: unlike those who provoked God for forty years in the desert, the Christ reveals himself as the Servant totally obedient to the divine will[40].
| The forties | Place | Situation | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moses, 40 days without bread | Sinai | Before receiving the Law | The tablets of the covenant |
| Elijah, 40 days' journey | Towards Horeb | Fleeing the threat, fed with mysterious bread | The Lord's gentle voice |
| Israel, 40 years | The desert | Tested by hunger and fear | Grumblings, Massah, golden calf |
| Jesus, 40 days without eating | The desert of Judea | Driven by the Spirit, tempted by Satan | Victory through Scripture, angels who serve |
As for the precise place, the Gospels say "the desert", and no more. Tradition sees it as the desert of Judea, between the Jordan where Jesus is baptised and the heights that rise towards Jerusalem and Jericho. Since Byzantine times, Christians have venerated a particular summit above Jericho, the Mount of the Quarantine (in medieval Latin Mons Quarantana, in Arabic Jabal al-Quruntul, the mountain of the forty): a first monastery was built there in the sixth century above the cave where tradition places the fast, and the present Greek Orthodox monastery, clinging to the cliff, keeps its memory alive[41]. The Church does not define the place to the nearest metre, but she honours this memory: generations of pilgrims have climbed there to read chapter 4 of Saint Matthew facing the desert.
The Three Responses: Deuteronomy Against the Tempter
The most striking feature of the duel is Jesus' unique weapon: three times he answers "It is written," and three times he draws from the same book, Deuteronomy, the desert book par excellence, Moses' testament to the generation about to enter the Promised Land. The following table gathers the battle:
| Assault | The devil's proposition | Jesus' response | Source cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| The bread | Turn stones into bread to satisfy his hunger | Man does not live by bread alone | Deut 8:3 (the manna) |
| The Temple | Throw himself from the pinnacle; the angels will bear him up (Psalm 91 misused) | You shall not put the Lord your God to the test | Deut 6:16 (Massa) |
| The mountain | All the kingdoms, in exchange for worship | It is the Lord your God you shall worship, to him alone you shall give worship | Deut 6:13 (the first commandment) |
Three remarks shed light on this choice. First, Jesus fights as man, not as God: Pope Saint Leo the Great teaches that Christ repels the enemy by the authority of the Law rather than by deploying his power, so as to honour our human nature all the more and to inflict upon the adversary a greater defeat, since the enemy of mankind is vanquished not as by God, but as by a man[42].
« Christ repelled the enemy by the authority of the Law and not by deploying his power, so as to honour our human nature the more: the enemy of mankind was vanquished not as by God, but as by a man. » (Pope Saint Leo the Great, Sermon on Lent, Ignispedia translation)[43]
Next, the three temptations cover the whole matter of sin: Saint Ambrose, commenting on Luke, affirms that Scripture would not have said that "when every temptation was ended," the devil departed, if the matter of all sins were not contained in these three, for the springs of temptation are the springs of desire[44]. Saint John names them in his first letter:
« For all that is in the world, the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, the pride of riches, is not of the Father but of the world. » (Saint John, First Letter 2:16)[45]
The bread targets the lust of the flesh, the Temple the lust of the eyes (spectacle and glory), the mountain the pride of riches and power. Finally, the order follows a calculated progression: Saint Thomas, after Saint Gregory, shows that the devil does not tempt the spiritual man at once with grave faults, but begins with the lighter ones to lead him little by little to the greater; thus he tempted the first man (the fruit, then "your eyes will be opened," then "you will be like gods"), and thus he tempted the Christ (the support of the body, then vainglory, then the ambition that despises God)[46].
Why the Son Willed to Be Tempted: the Theology of the Desert
The question asks itself: what is the Sinless One doing in a battle against the Tempter? Saint Thomas takes it head-on: was it fitting that Christ be tempted? Yes, and for four reasons which he borrows from the Fathers[47].
To Strengthen Us Against Our Temptations
First reason, the most cited: Christ willed to be tempted in order to strengthen us. Saint Gregory the Great, in his homily for the first Sunday of Lent, says it with force:
« It was not unworthy of our Redeemer to will to be tempted, he who had come also to be put to death: in order to conquer our temptations by his temptations, as he conquered our death by his death. » (Saint Gregory the Great, Homily 16 on the Gospels, Ignispedia translation)[48]
The Letter to the Hebrews draws the consequence for our prayer: because he himself suffered the trial, Christ "is able to come to the aid of those who are tested"[49]. The tempted Christian does not pray to a distant God who would know nothing of temptation: he prays to a Brother who has gone through it without breaking.
To Warn Us: No One Is Safe
Second reason: to warn us, so that no one, however holy, should think himself secure or beyond the reach of temptation. And it is after his baptism that Christ wills to be tempted: Saint Hilary teaches that the devil's temptations fall chiefly upon those who are sanctified, for he desires above all to conquer the saints[50]. The newly baptised who has just received grace, the convert full of fervour, the religious in his cloister: all are warned. The demon attacked Adam because he saw him in great dignity, and Job because he saw him crowned and proclaimed by God himself[51]. Spiritual honour invites the assault; it does not avert it.
To Give Us the Example of Battle
Third reason: to set the example. Saint Ambrose, commenting on Luke, sees Christ enter the desert "as onto a battlefield," and he adds two motives: Christ there unveils the mystery of Adam's deliverance, driven from paradise into the desert, and he shows that the devil envies those who strive toward higher goods[52]. The desert is therefore not only a place, but a condition: every child of God whom the Spirit impels toward some great work finds himself, from the devil's point of view, "in the desert," for there is no injustice there for the devil to delight in[53].
To Conquer for Us, as the New Adam
Fourth reason, the deepest: to conquer in our stead and reopen the way. The Catechism teaches: "Jesus is the new Adam, who remained faithful where the first had succumbed to temptation. Jesus perfectly fulfils Israel's vocation. In this, Jesus is the victor over the devil: he has bound the strong man to plunder his goods. Jesus' victory over the tempter in the desert anticipates the victory of the Passion, the supreme obedience of his filial love for the Father"[54].
« The Evangelists indicate the salvific meaning of this mysterious event. Jesus is the new Adam, who remained faithful where the first had succumbed to temptation. » (Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 539)[55]
And the Catechism adds the criterion of the true Messiah: "Jesus' temptation reveals the way that the Son of God is Messiah, in contrast to the way Satan proposes to him"[56]. The Messiah of bread multiplied at will, the Messiah of the prodigy in the Temple, the Messiah of kingdoms gained by compromise: three false messianisms refused in a word. The true Messiah will reign, but through the Cross. This is why Christ conquered the Tempter for us:
« For we have not a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin. » (Letter to the Hebrews 4:15)[57]
The ancient witnesses: who wrote, when, and how we know it
As with any Gospel account, the question of authors and dates is settled first by the ancient witnesses, those who knew the apostles or their immediate successors, long before modern reconstructions[58].
The table of witnesses
| Witness | Date | What he attests |
|---|---|---|
| Saint Papias of Hierapolis | Early 2nd century | Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down exactly what he remembered; Matthew composed the words of the Lord in the Hebrew language |
| Saint Irenaeus of Lyons | c. 180 | The four Gospels: Matthew among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul are in Rome, Mark from Peter, Luke from Paul, John at Ephesus |
| Saint Clement of Alexandria | Late 2nd century | The Gospels with genealogies (Matthew, Luke) were written first; Mark wrote in Rome at the request of Peter's hearers |
| Muratorian Fragment | Late 2nd century | Oldest Latin list of the Scriptures: it receives the four Gospels, Luke named third, John fourth |
| Councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397) | Late 4th century | Fixing of the canon for the Latin Church, four Gospels included; confirmed at Trent (1546) |
The formulations of Papias, Irenaeus and Clement are those that tradition has handed down to us through Eusebius of Caesarea in his Ecclesiastical History: Papias attests that "Mark, having become Peter's interpreter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, all that he remembered of the words and deeds of Christ," and Irenaeus reports that "Matthew published his Gospel among the Hebrews in their own dialect, while Peter and Paul were preaching at Rome," then Mark, Luke and John[59].
Traditional datings
| Gospel | Traditional dating | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Saint Matthew | 50s-60s, before the destruction of Jerusalem (70) | The first written work, in a Jewish-Christian milieu, according to Irenaeus and Papias |
| Saint Mark | 60s, in Rome | From Peter's preaching, before his martyrdom (c. 64-67), according to Papias, Irenaeus and Clement |
| Saint Luke | Early 60s | Acts ends with Paul's Roman imprisonment without mentioning his death, which places the Gospel, which precedes them, at the beginning of the decade |
| Saint John | Late 1st century, at Ephesus | Irenaeus, trained by Polycarp who had known John, attests the Ephesian publication |
These datings place the three accounts of the temptation within one or two generations of the events, in communities that still counted direct witnesses to the public life. They remain defensible, as the final part will show: the late datings proposed by part of contemporary exegesis rest on hypothetical reconstructions, not on discoveries.
The Church celebrates the desert: Lent and the first Sunday
Each year, the Church enters the desert with Christ: "Through the forty solemn days of Lent, the Church unites herself each year to the mystery of Jesus in the desert"[60]. Lent is not first and foremost an exercise of the will; it is a following: forty days to accompany the Lord's forty days, with His weapons — fasting, prayer and almsgiving.
The first Sunday of Lent places the temptation in the foreground, with the Gospel of the combat according to the liturgical cycle: Year A, the account of Saint Matthew (Mt 4:1-11); Year B, the sobriety of Saint Mark; Year C, the account of Saint Luke[61]. In Year A, the first reading and the epistle answer the Gospel: the fall of Adam (Gn 2-3) and the new Adam (Rm 5), the exact diptych of the theology of the desert. Thus, from the very entry into Lent, the Church tells her faithful where they are going: to battle, with a Victor.
The catechumens preparing for Easter baptism scrutinize this Gospel closely: they too, like Christ emerging from the Jordan, will receive grace and then face the adversary. And throughout Lent, the sixth petition of the Our Father, "lead us not into temptation," resounds differently once one has contemplated the tempted Christ: it is His own victory that we ask Him to share[62].
For us: fighting with the weapons of Christ
The episode is not a museum piece: it is a combat manual. Saint John Chrysostom draws five fruits from it for the baptized person under temptation: temptation proves that one has become stronger, it keeps one humble amid the gifts received, it testifies before the demon that one has truly left him behind, it makes one stronger than steel, and it reveals the treasure entrusted[63]. In other words: being tempted after a grace is not a failure; it is the sign that one now counts for the adversary.
Neither seeking temptation nor fleeing it when the Spirit leads
Should one go into the desert to seek the fight? Saint Thomas distinguishes two kinds of occasions: those that come from the person, when one draws near to sin oneself by not avoiding the occasion, and these must be avoided; and those that come from the devil, who envies those who strive for higher goods, and these must not be avoided, for the help of the Spirit is mightier than the assault[64]. The Christian flees voluntary occasions (places, screens, company that ruin him) and stands firm in the trials that faithfulness brings upon him.
Scripture learned by heart
Jesus does not argue, does not reason, does not negotiate: he counters with the exact verse, three times "It is written"[65]. This assumes a well-stocked memory: Deuteronomy learned by heart, ready for the hour of hunger. The Christian who wants to stand firm on the evil day learns his verses too: the sixth petition of the Our Father each morning, a psalm in the night, a word of Christ against each lie. The devil quotes Scripture crooked; one can only answer him well by knowing it straight.
Fasting, shield of body and soul
Chrysostom insists: it is in hunger, not during the fast, that the devil attacks, which proves that fasting is a very powerful shield[66]. Lent keeps this lesson: depriving the body in order to starve the passions as well. Temptation is not yet sin: it becomes sin when one consents to it, as explained in the article on the difference between temptation and sin, and God permits temptation only for a greater good, as explained in the article on why God permits temptations.
An event that really happened
Should this account be read as a parable invented after Easter to say that Jesus was "faithful," or as a fact? The Church holds to the fact, and she has good reasons.
First, the multiple and independent attestation: Matthew and Luke develop three scenes in a partly different order, Mark summarizes in two verses with his own details (the beasts, the angels)[67]. Three voices, three angles, one and the same fight: this is the shape of a reported event, not a fable copied out. Next, the coherence of the framework: the baptism just before (the baptism of Jesus), Galilee just after, the forty days linking Moses, Elijah, and Israel. Next, the psychology of the Tempter: Chrysostom shows a perplexed devil, who does not know whom he is speaking to and sets snares in order to learn[68]. An inventor would have made the devil an accomplice playing his part; the account shows a real adversary, in ignorance and cunning.
Above all, faith stakes its God on it: "we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, one who has been tested in every way, similar to us, with the exception of sin"[69]. If the temptation had not taken place, this word would be empty. Benedict XVI, in the first volume of Jesus of Nazareth (2007), devotes an entire chapter to the temptations and reads in them the decisive discernment between true and false messianism[70].
What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits
Set out honestly, the current hypotheses of part of contemporary exegesis are as follows: Matthew and Luke are said to have drawn on a lost common source (known as "source Q") for their three scenes; the account is said to be a midrash, that is, a narrative meditation woven from verses of Deuteronomy, composed after Easter to present Jesus as the new Israel; the difference in order between the two evangelists is said to betray a literary construction rather than a memory; and the whole, dated to the years 80–90, would reflect the debates of later communities rather than the days of the Jordan[71].
These proposals must be discussed, for they carry methodological weaknesses.
First limit: the common source remains a hypothesis. No manuscript of this source has ever been found, and the reconstruction already assumes what it wants to prove: that two evangelists could neither meet nor draw from the common apostolic preaching. Confusing a literary possibility with historical proof is building on sand.
Second limit: the anti-miraculous presupposition. When one posits in advance that a forty-day fast, a duel with the devil, and angels who serve cannot have taken place, one necessarily concludes invention. But this starting point is not a result of scholarship; it is a philosophy. The Catholic reader is entitled to refuse it: the supernatural is not an embarrassment, it is the subject.
Third limit: the argument from silence and circular dating. Dating Matthew and Luke to the years 80–90 because their accounts would be late compositions, then proving that they are late because one has dated them to the years 80–90, is going in circles. The ancient witnesses (Papias, Irenaeus, Clement) place the Gospels much earlier, within a generation or two of the events, and no parchment discovered since has contradicted them.
Fourth limit: the difference in order is not a contradiction. Saint Augustine settled it sixteen centuries ago: we do not know which of the last two assaults came first, the evangelists may have followed different orders, and what matters is that all three took place[72]. To demand of ancient witnesses the word-for-word agreement of a modern court record is to hold them to a standard that no historical narrative meets.
Conclusion: the traditional datings and attributions remain defensible, indeed the most solid. The reader who has followed the case understands why: witnesses close to the apostles, three converging accounts, a theology that presupposes the fact, a liturgy that has celebrated it since the earliest centuries. Part of contemporary exegesis proposes something else; it proposes, it does not demonstrate.
To go further
The episode of the desert is illuminated by the pages that surround it in the life of Christ:
- The Baptism of Jesus: the previous episode, at the Jordan, where the Spirit descends and the Father proclaims.
- The Hidden Life of Jesus: the thirty years of Nazareth that precede the desert.
- The Nativity of Jesus and The Flight into Egypt: the beginnings, already under the sign of the struggle.
- Jesus Found in the Temple: at twelve years old, already entirely at the Father's work.
- The Lord's Prayer: the sixth petition, "lead us not into temptation", learned at the school of the desert.
- The Sermon on the Mount and The Beatitudes: the teaching that follows the victory.
- The Synoptic Gospels: the file on the relationships between Matthew, Mark and Luke.
- The Agony of Jesus in Gethsemane: the "appointed time" when the Tempter returns.
- The Wedding at Cana: the first sign in Galilee, after the desert.
Notes
Notes and References
Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 1, trans. AELF (aelf.org): “Then Jesus was led into the desert by the Spirit to be tempted by the devil.”
1 8Gospel according to Saint Luke 4, 13, trans. AELF: “Having thus exhausted every form of temptation, the devil departed from Jesus until the appointed time.”
2 36Gospel according to Saint Mark 1, 12-13, trans. AELF: “At once the Spirit drove Jesus into the desert and, in the desert, he remained forty days, tempted by Satan. He lived among the wild beasts, and the angels ministered to him.”
3 5 30 67Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 539, official French text (vatican.va): “The Evangelists indicate the salvific meaning of this mysterious event. Jesus is the new Adam, who remained faithful where the first had succumbed to temptation. Jesus perfectly fulfils the vocation of Israel: contrary to those who once provoked God for forty years in the desert (cf. Ps 95:10), Christ reveals himself as the Servant of God wholly obedient to the divine will. In this, Jesus is the victor over the devil: he has bound the strong man to take back his spoil (Mk 3:27). Jesus' victory over the tempter in the desert anticipates the victory of the Passion, the supreme obedience of his filial love for the Father.”
4 29 40 54 55Gospel according to Saint John 12, 31: Christ announces that the prince of this world “is going to be cast out”, a Johannine echo of the struggle in the desert.
6Saint Augustine, On the Harmony of the Evangelists, II, cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4 (Ignispedia translation from the English): it is not certain which came first, the kingdoms shown or the pinnacle of the Temple; it matters little, provided it be clear that all this did indeed take place; the evangelists may have followed different orders, for sometimes covetousness is born of vainglory, sometimes the reverse.
7 35 72Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 13 on Saint Matthew, on Mt 4, 1 (newadvent.org/fathers/200113.htm, Ignispedia translation from the English): Christ endures being led into the desert so that every baptized person, if after his baptism he endures greater temptations, may not be troubled by them as by something unexpected; God does not prevent temptations, first to teach the baptized that he has become stronger, then to keep him humble, and further to assure the demon of his abandonment, to make him stronger than steel and to display the treasure entrusted; the devil would not have assailed Adam without his great dignity, nor Job without his crown.
9 10 51 63Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 2, trans. AELF: “After fasting forty days and forty nights, he was hungry.”
11Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 13 on Saint Matthew, on Mt 4, 2 (ibid.): the devil draws near not during the fast but in the hunger, which shows how great a good fasting is and how powerful a shield; Christ fasts forty days, going no further, as Moses and Elijah before him by the power of God, lest the excess of the miracle discredit the truth of his humanity.
12 38 66Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 3, trans. AELF: “The tempter approached and said to him: If you are the Son of God, command that these stones become bread.”
13Saint John Chrysostom, Homily 13 on Saint Matthew, on Mt 4, 3 (ibid.): having heard the voice from above and the testimony of John, then seeing this famished man, the devil is perplexed, able to believe neither in a mere man nor in the Son of God; as before Adam, he feigns what is not in order to learn what is, and weaves his nets with an ambiguous question.
14 68Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 4, trans. AELF: “But Jesus answered: It is written: Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God.”
15 65Book of Deuteronomy 8, 3, trans. AELF: “He made you pass through poverty, he made you feel hunger, and he gave you manna to eat so that you might know that man does not live by bread alone, but by everything that comes from the mouth of the Lord.”
16Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4, reply to objection 1: to change stones into bread for his own relief alone would have been disordered, whereas Israel received the manna for want of any other means and Christ fed the crowds in the desert in the same necessity.
17Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 5-6, trans. AELF: “Then the devil took him to the Holy City, placed him on the pinnacle of the Temple and said to him: If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down; for it is written: He will give his angels orders concerning you, and: They will carry you on their hands, so that your foot will not strike a stone.”
18Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 7, trans. AELF: “Jesus declared to him: It is also written: You shall not put the Lord your God to the test.”
19Book of Deuteronomy 6, 16, trans. AELF: “You shall not put the Lord your God to the test, as you did at Massah.”
20Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4, reply to objection 2: one may seek glory even in outward humiliation, whence the vainglory of the fall from the pinnacle, citing Saint Augustine, On the Sermon on the Mount, II, 12.
21Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 8-9, trans. AELF: “The devil took him again to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their glory. He said to him: All this I will give you, if, falling at my feet, you bow down before me.”
22Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4: the devil tempts gradually, from lighter faults towards graver ones, as he tempted the first man; the first two temptations say “If you are the Son of God”, not the third, which is addressed only to the carnal.
23 46Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4, reply to objection 3: ambition carries another danger within it, for the sake of reigning it accepts servitude, citing Saint Ambrose on Saint Luke 4, 5.
24Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 10, trans. AELF: “Then Jesus said to him: Away with you, Satan! For it is written: It is the Lord your God you shall worship, to him alone you shall render service.”
25Book of Deuteronomy 6, 13, trans. AELF: “You shall fear the Lord your God, you shall serve him, it is by his name that you shall swear.”
26Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4, reply to objection 6: Christ bears injury against himself without being disturbed, but drives out the devil when he usurps the honour due to God, to teach us to suffer personal injuries and not even to listen to those aimed at God.
27Gospel according to Saint Matthew 4, 11, trans. AELF: “Then the devil left him. And behold, angels drew near, and they ministered to him.”
28Traditional dating: the years 60, at Rome, from Peter's preaching, before Peter's martyrdom (c. 64-67); testimonies of Papias, Irenaeus and Clement.
31Gospel according to Saint Luke 4, 1-2, trans. AELF: “Jesus, filled with the Holy Spirit, left the banks of the Jordan; in the Spirit he was led through the desert where, for forty days, he was tempted by the devil. He ate nothing during those days and, when that time was over, he was hungry.”
32Gospel according to Saint Luke 4, 14, trans. AELF: Jesus returns to Galilee “in the power of the Spirit”.
33Gospel according to Saint Luke 4, 2, trans. AELF: “He ate nothing during those days and, when that time was over, he was hungry.”
34Moses: Book of Exodus 24, 18 (forty days and forty nights on the mountain); Elijah: First Book of Kings 19, 8 (forty days and forty nights as far as Horeb, strengthened by the mysterious bread).
37Book of Deuteronomy 8, 2, trans. AELF: “Remember the long march you made during forty years in the desert; the Lord your God imposed it on you to make you pass through poverty; he wished to test you and to know what was in your heart: whether you would keep his commandments, yes or no?”
39Mount of the Quarantine (medieval Mons Quarantana, Arabic Jabal al-Quruntul, the mountain of the forty), 3 km north-west of Jericho: first Byzantine monastery in the 6th century above the cave of the fast, present Greek Orthodox monastery of the 19th century clinging to the cliff.
41Pope Saint Leo the Great, Sermon 1 on Lent, ch. 3, cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4 (Ignispedia translation from the English): Christ repelled the enemy by the authority of the Law and not by deploying his power, so as to honour our human nature the more, since the enemy of mankind was conquered not as by God, but as by a man.
42 43Saint Ambrose, Commentary on Saint Luke 4, 13, cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 4 (Ignispedia translation from the English): Scripture would not have said that every temptation being finished, the devil departed, if the matter of all sins were not contained in these three temptations, for the springs of temptations are the springs of desires, lust of the flesh, hope of glory, greed for power.
44First letter of Saint John 2, 16, trans. AELF: “All that is in the world, the desire of the flesh, the desire of the eyes, the pride of wealth, all this does not come from the Father, but from the world.”
45Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 1 (newadvent.org/summa/4041.htm): it was fitting that Christ be tempted, first to strengthen us, second to warn us, third to give us an example, fourth to fill us with confidence in his mercy.
47Saint Gregory the Great, Homily 16 on the Gospels (First Sunday of Lent), cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 1 (newadvent.org, Ignispedia translation from the English): original English " It was not unworthy of our Redeemer to wish to be tempted, who came also to be slain ; in order that by His temptations He might conquer our temptations, just as by His death He overcame our death. "
48Letter to the Hebrews 2, 18, trans. AELF: “And because he suffered to the very end the trial of his Passion, he is able to come to the aid of those who undergo a trial.”
49Saint Hilary of Poitiers, Commentary on Saint Matthew, ch. 3, cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 1: the devil's temptations chiefly assail those who are sanctified, for above all he desires to conquer the saints.
50Saint Ambrose, Commentary on Saint Luke 4, 1, cited by Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 2 (Ignispedia translation from the English): Christ was led into the desert to provoke the devil, for without combat there is no victory; there he reveals the mystery of Adam's deliverance and shows that the devil envies those who strive toward higher goods.
52Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, IIIa, q. 41, a. 2: Christ entered the desert as into a field of battle; occasions of temptation that come from man must be avoided, those that come from the devil who envies higher goods must not be, for the aid of the Spirit is more powerful.
53 64Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 540, official French text (vatican.va): “The temptation of Jesus reveals the way the Son of God is Messiah, in contrast to the way Satan proposes and that men (cf. Mt 16:21-23) desire to attribute to him. This is why Christ vanquished the Tempter for us: For we do not have a high priest incapable of sympathizing with our weaknesses, one who has been tested in every way, similarly, yet without sin (Heb 4:15). Each year the Church unites herself, through the forty days of Great Lent, to the mystery of Jesus in the desert.”
56 60Letter to the Hebrews 4, 15, trans. AELF (cited by the Catechism, no. 540): “For we do not have a high priest incapable of sympathizing with our weaknesses, one who has been tested in every way, similarly, yet without sin.”
57 69Saint Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III, 1, 1, Ante-Nicene Fathers I edition, English text on newadvent.org: Matthew published his Gospel among the Hebrews while Peter and Paul were preaching at Rome, then Mark from Peter, Luke from Paul, and John at Ephesus. Papias, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, III, 39: Mark, Peter's interpreter, wrote down exactly everything he remembered. Saint Clement of Alexandria, cited by Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 14: the Gospels with genealogies were written first.
58 59First Sunday of Lent, year A: Gn 2-3 (the fall), Rm 5, 12-19 (the new Adam), Mt 4, 1-11; year B: the brief account of Saint Mark; year C: the account of Saint Luke (Roman lectionary, Ordo).
61Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 2846-2849: commentary on the sixth petition of the Lord's Prayer, “lead us not into temptation”, which refers back to the struggle of Christ (cf. no. 2849).
62Benedict XVI, Jesus of Nazareth, vol. I, 2007 (French ed. Flammarion, 2007): chapter devoted to the temptations, where the discernment between true and false messianism is at the centre.
70Hypotheses proposed by part of contemporary exegesis: lost common source known as "Q" (Matthew-Luke double tradition), haggadic midrash on Deuteronomy, late post-Paschal composition; proposed datings: Mark c. 70, Matthew and Luke c. 80-90.
71