Adam and Eve (c. 4000 BC)

Adam and Eve, the first parents of the human race: the narrative of Genesis, its author Moses according to tradition, its theology of marriage and the fall, and its fulfilment in Christ the new Adam.

Ignispedia

Adam and Eve are, according to the Scripture received by the Church, the first parents of the whole human race: created directly by God, placed in the Garden of Eden, fallen through disobedience, then raised up by the promise of a Saviour. Their story occupies the first five chapters of the Bible, in the book of the Book of Genesis, and runs through the whole of Catholic theology: image of God, marriage, work, original sin, redemption through Christ the new Adam and Mary the new Eve. The Church holds them to be two real persons, celebrated in the liturgical calendar, and sees in their fall the event that the death of Christ came to repair.

Adam and Eve in the canon of Scripture

Genesis, the first book of the Bible

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The account of Adam and Eve is found in Genesis, the first of the five books of the Pentateuch (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy), itself the first part of the Old Testament and the opening of the whole Christian Bible[1]. Genesis bears in Hebrew the name Bereshit ("In the beginning"), its first word, and in Greek that of Genesis ("origin, birth") given by the Septuagint[2]. Its place is not accidental: everything that Revelation will later say about sin, covenant, the chosen people and the Messiah presupposes this beginning[3].

The book has fifty chapters. The story of Adam and Eve occupies the first five, what is commonly called the history of the origins (Gn 1–11), before the cycle of the patriarchs which opens with the call of Abraham in Gn 12[4]. This architecture makes Adam and Eve not an isolated episode but the foundation of all salvation history: from them descend Noah, then Abraham, then the people of Israel, then Christ himself according to his human genealogy[5].

The other mentions of Adam and Eve in the Bible

Adam and Eve are not confined to Genesis: about a dozen biblical books name or presuppose them, which rules out treating Gn 1–5 as a late piece bolted on. The table below brings together the main mentions.

Biblical bookPassageWhat the text contributes about Adam and Eve
PsalmsPs 8:5-7Man "a little lower than a god", crowned with glory, echo of Gn 1
Ben SiraSir 17:1-4God creates man from the earth and clothes him with strength according to his image
WisdomWis 2:23-24Man created for incorruptibility; death entered through the devil's jealousy
TobitTb 8:6Marriage prayer: "It is you who made Adam" and Eve his helper
Ben SiraSir 49:16Adam placed above every living being of creation
Gospel of LukeLk 3:38Genealogy of Jesus going back to "Adam, the son of God"
Gospel of MatthewMt 19:4-6Jesus quotes Gn 1:27 and Gn 2:24 as the word of the Creator
RomansRom 5:12-21Through one man sin entered; through one comes justification
1 Corinthians1 Cor 15:21-22.45The first Adam, a living being; the last Adam, life-giving spirit
1 Timothy1 Tim 2:13-14Adam formed first, then Eve; reminder of the deception
JudeJude 14Enoch "the seventh from Adam", genealogy counted as real
RevelationRev 12:9The devil identified with the "serpent of the origins", the one of Gn 3

Two of these mentions deserve particular attention. When Jesus is questioned about marriage, he does not comment on the Law of Moses: he goes back to the beginning, quoting together the two accounts of creation as a single word of the Creator[6]. And when Saint Paul builds his doctrine of salvation, he makes Adam not a literary figure but the inverted type of Christ: one real man on one side, one real man on the other[7].

"Have you not read that the Creator, from the beginning, made them male and female, and said: For this reason, a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh?"

  • Jesus Christ, Gospel according to Saint Matthew 19:4-5, AELF translation[8]

The Traditional Author and Dating: Moses

What the Jewish and Ecclesial Tradition Holds

The unanimous Jewish tradition, taken up by the Church, attributes the Pentateuch to Moses: Christ Himself speaks of what "Moses wrote" about Him and refers His listeners to the "book of Moses"[9]. The New Testament assumes this attribution without ever discussing it, and the Fathers receive it as a fact: Moses is the human author of the account of the origins, writing under divine inspiration[10].

The Pontifical Biblical Commission, when consulted on the question, confirmed on 27 June 1906 the substance of this traditional attribution: Moses is indeed the author of the Pentateuch in the sense understood by tradition, which excludes neither the use of earlier sources nor later touches or additions made under inspiration[11]. This decree was given by Saint Pius X an authority binding in conscience[12].

The Received Dating: The 2nd Millennium BC

In the received chronology, Moses leads the exodus from Egypt in the 2nd millennium BC, and the writing of the Pentateuch therefore belongs to that period: the Genesis account predates the writing prophets such as Isaiah or Jeremiah by more than a millennium[13]. This antiquity explains the style of the text, its archaic language, and its closeness to the world of the ancient Near East, without detracting anything from its inspiration.

The creation of Adam itself is placed by the received biblical chronology around 4000 BC: this is the calculation of Ussher (4004 BC, in his Annals of 1650)[14], that of the Jewish Seder Olam Rabbah (3761 BC, origin of the Hebrew calendar)[15], and that of the Fathers who counted the generations from Adam, such as Saint Bede the Venerable in his On the Reckoning of Time (725)[16]. These calculations differ from one another by a few centuries depending on the manuscripts followed, but they converge on the essential point: a short human history, on the order of six thousand years.

Why This Attribution Remains Defensible

Three arguments support the traditional position. First, the testimony of Christ Himself: if Moses had not written these books, the words of Jesus attributing them to him would be erroneous, which faith in His inerrancy excludes[17]. Next, the unanimity of reception: no ancient Jewish or Christian tradition proposes another author, and the Samaritans themselves, separated from the Jews since the Exile, preserve the same Pentateuch attributed to Moses[18]. Finally, internal coherence: the Pentateuch presents itself as the work of the lawgiver of Israel, a witness to the events of the Exodus, and Genesis as the prehistory he gives to his people before the Law[19].

The Ancient Witnesses to the Text of Genesis

The Septuagint of Alexandria (3rd Century BC)

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The oldest translation of Genesis is the Septuagint, a Greek version produced in Alexandria from the 3rd century BC, according to tradition by seventy-two Jewish translators whose mission the Letter of Aristeas (2nd century BC) recounts[20]. It is this Greek Bible that the New Testament and the Fathers quote most often: when Saint Paul speaks of Adam, he reads Genesis in this version. Its existence proves that the Hebrew text of Genesis was already fixed, venerated, and spread throughout the Jewish world several centuries before Christ.

The Hebrew Text, the Samaritan Pentateuch, and Qumran

The Masoretic text, fixed by the Jewish scribes known as Masoretes over the course of the first Christian millennium, preserves the Hebrew of Genesis with verifiable fidelity: the manuscripts of Genesis discovered at Qumran, on the shore of the Dead Sea, some of which date back to the 2nd century BC, confirm in all essentials the millennial stability of this text[21]. The Samaritan Pentateuch, preserved by the Samaritan community separated from Judaism since the Babylonian Exile, provides a further independent witness: despite centuries of separation, the two traditions agree on the account of Adam and Eve[22].

The Vulgate of Saint Jerome (Late 4th Century)

Saint Jerome translated Genesis into Latin in Bethlehem at the end of the 4th century, directly from the Hebrew: this is the Vulgate, the official Bible of the Latin Church for more than fifteen centuries[23]. The account of Adam and Eve that the Roman liturgy still proclaims today descends in a direct line from this work: the chain of transmission of the text, from Moses to the present-day missals, is documented without interruption.

Text WitnessPeriodLanguageDecisive Contribution
Received Hebrew text2nd millennium BC (Mosaic authorship)HebrewInspired original, preserved by the scribes
Septuagint3rd century BC, AlexandriaGreekBible of the apostles and the Fathers, text already fixed
Qumran manuscripts2nd century BC to 1st century ADHebrewProof of the stability of the text over a thousand years
Samaritan PentateuchPreserved since the Exile (6th century BC)HebrewIndependent witness to the same account
Vulgate of Saint JeromeLate 4th century AD, BethlehemLatinBible of Western Christendom for 1500 years

The narrative of Genesis, step by step

The plan of the first five chapters

The story of Adam and Eve follows a simple and dramatic plan: creation (Gen 1 to 2), fall (Gen 3), consequences in the first family and the descendants (Gen 4 to 5). The table below gives the map before the detailed reading.

SectionContentCharacters introduced
Gen 1, 1-2, 3Creation of the world in six days, then man and woman in the image of GodAdam and Eve (named "man and woman")
Gen 2, 4-25Second account: the garden of Eden, the formation of womanEve formed from Adam, the garden, the two trees
Gen 3Temptation, disobedience, judgment, expulsionThe serpent, the cherubim
Gen 4Cain and Abel, the first murder, the line of Cain, the birth of SethCain, Abel, Seth
Gen 5Genealogy from Adam to Noah, with lifespansEnoch, Methuselah, Lamech, Noah

Gen 1: man and woman created in the image of God

The first chapter closes on the summit of the work: after the light, the stars, the animals, God creates the human being, male and female, in his image and likeness, and entrusts the earth to them[24]. Three features distinguish this creation: it is deliberate in divine council ("Let us make man"), it bestows a unique dignity (the image), and it comes with a blessing and a mission (to be fruitful, fill the earth, and subdue it)[25]. The Catechism sees in it the foundation of all Christian anthropology: "Man occupies a unique place in creation: he is made in the image of God"[26].

"God created man in his image, in the image of God he created him, male and female he created them."

  • Book of Genesis 1, 27, AELF translation[27]

Gen 2: the garden, the shaped earth, the woman taken from man

The second chapter revisits the creation of man with other images: God shapes Adam from the dust of the ground (adam comes from adamah, the arable earth) and breathes into his nostrils a breath of life[28]. Then he places him in a garden planted in Eden, a Hebrew word meaning "delight," to keep and cultivate it[29]. Next comes the creation of woman: God plunges the man into a mysterious sleep, takes one of his ribs and shapes it into a woman, whom the man recognizes as "bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh"[30].

The proper name of Eve (Hawwah, "the living one") is given only after the fall: "The man named his wife Eve, because she was the mother of all the living"[31]. Before that, she is ishshah, the woman taken from the man (ish): the Hebrew itself speaks of their consubstantiality. The chapter closes on the first word of marriage: the man will leave father and mother, be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh[32]. It is this verse that Jesus will quote as the word of the Creator and that the Marriage Rite still offers among its readings[33].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"Then the Lord God formed man with dust taken from the ground; he breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became a living being."

  • Book of Genesis 2, 7, AELF translation[34]

Gen 3: temptation, the fall, judgment and promise

The third chapter is the drama: the serpent, described as the craftiest of the animals, makes the woman doubt the word of God, then his goodness, then leads her, along with the man, to eat the fruit of the forbidden tree[35]. Their eyes are opened at once, but upon their nakedness: shame enters the world. Questioned by God as he walks in the garden in the cool of the day, the man blames the woman, the woman blames the serpent: original harmony is broken along with obedience.

Judgment follows, in three sentences: the serpent will be cursed and crawl; the woman will bring forth children in pain and desire her husband, who will rule over her; the man will toil on cursed ground, by the sweat of his face, until he returns to dust[36]. But in the very heart of the serpent's condemnation, God slips in the first announcement of salvation, the protoevangelium: the offspring of the woman will crush the serpent's head[37]. Before the expulsion, God himself clothes Adam and Eve in tunics of skin, a last gesture of fatherly solicitude[38], then stations the cherubim and the flaming sword at the entrance to the garden[39].

"I will put enmity between you and the woman, between your offspring and her offspring: he will crush your head, and you will bruise his heel."

  • Book of Genesis 3, 15, AELF translation: the protoevangelium[40]

"By the sweat of your face shall you eat your bread, until you return to the ground from which you came: for you are dust, and to dust you shall return."

  • Book of Genesis 3, 19, AELF translation[41]

Gen 4: Cain, Abel and Seth

The fourth chapter shows sin spreading already within the first family: Cain, a tiller of the ground, kills out of jealousy his brother Abel, a shepherd whose offering had pleased God[42]. Questioned, Cain answers with the most famous question of evasion: "Am I my brother's keeper?" God marks him with a protective sign and exiles him to the land of Nod, where his descendants found the first trades: herdsmen, musicians, metalworkers[43]. After this dark line, Eve bears Seth, given "in place of Abel," and it was in his time, the text specifies, "that people began to invoke the name of the Lord"[44]: public worship is born in the line that will lead to Noah.

Gen 5: the genealogy from Adam to Noah

The fifth chapter sets out ten generations from Adam to Noah, each with the patriarch's age at the birth of his son and the total length of his life: Adam begets Seth at 130 years and dies at 930 years[45]. The genealogical table, with its astonishing lifespans, culminates with Methuselah (969 years) and is interrupted with Enoch, who "walked with God" and was taken without dying at 365 years[46].

PatriarchAge at the birth of the named sonTotal lifespan
Adam130 years (Seth)930 years
Seth105 years (Enosh)912 years
Enosh90 years (Kenan)905 years
Kenan70 years (Mahalalel)910 years
Mahalalel65 years (Jared)895 years
Jared162 years (Enoch)962 years
Enoch65 years (Methuselah)365 years, taken by God
Methuselah187 years (Lamech)969 years
Lamech182 years (Noah)777 years
Noah500 years (Shem, Ham, Japheth)950 years

These figures vary slightly among the witnesses of the text: between the creation and the Flood, the Hebrew text counts 1656 years, the Septuagint 2262 years, the Samaritan Pentateuch 1307 years, because the three traditions do not agree on the age of the patriarchs at the birth of their sons[47]. Far from embarrassing the traditional reading, these discrepancies confirm that careful scribes copied received numbers without harmonizing them: one does not invent crookedly.

The theology of Adam and Eve: what the Church holds

Created in the image of God, body and soul

Man is the only visible being capable of knowing and loving his Creator: such is the scope of the divine image, which designates not a physical likeness but a spiritual kinship[48]. The Church teaches that every human soul is immediately created by God, not produced by parents, and that it is immortal: this is the foundation of the inviolable dignity of every person, from the first instant of existence[49]. Saint Thomas Aquinas clarifies the articulation: Adam's soul is created directly by God, while his body is formed from the matter of the world, and Eve's drawn from Adam himself, to mark the unity of the couple and of the human race[50].

A single couple at the origin of all: monogenism

Adam and Eve are the first parents of all humankind, without exception: this is monogenism, which Pius XII declares incompatible with any thesis that would posit true men not descended from Adam by natural generation, or that would reduce Adam to a collection of first parents[51]. Saint Paul gives its missionary version to the Athenians: God "has made from one every nation of mankind to live on all the face of the earth"[52]. Saint Augustine draws universal brotherhood from it: God willed that all men come from one, so that human society might be held together by the bond of blood as much as by that of concord[53].

The complete philosophical and scientific demonstration of this unity, as well as the refutation of polygenism, is treated in the dedicated article: Did Adam and Eve really exist? They do not belong to this page, which presents the characters and their story.

Marriage instituted from the beginning

Before any commandment, God notes a lack: "It is not good that the man should be alone"[54]. Woman is therefore not a late addition but the completion of the design: drawn from man, recognized by him, united to him in one flesh[55]. The Catechism sees in it the divine institution of marriage: Scripture opens with the creation of man and woman in the image of God[56]. When Tobiah prays on the night of his wedding, he takes up this very foundation: "It was you who created Adam, and for him you made his wife Eve as a help and support"[57].

"It was you who created Adam, and for him you made his wife Eve as a help and support."

  • Book of Tobit 8:6, marriage prayer, AELF translation[58]

Work and the tending of the garden

Placed in Eden "to till it and keep it," Adam receives work before the fall: it is therefore not a curse but a vocation, a participation in the Creator's work[59]. The sweat and toil come after: the cursed ground will produce thorns and thistles[60]. This distinction illuminates the entire social doctrine of the Church on work: it is good by nature, burdensome by accident, ever since Adam disobeyed.

Original justice: what Adam and Eve lost

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Before the fall, our first parents enjoyed original justice: friendship with God, inner harmony without disordered desire, harmony of the couple, harmony with creation, exemption from death[61]. The Council of Trent dogmatically defined what was lost: Adam, by transgressing the commandment, at once lost the holiness and justice in which he had been established[62]. The Roman Catechism of 1566 already transmitted this doctrine to the parish priests charged with instructing the faithful[63].

Original sin: an event, not a symbol

The Catechism affirms it with a precision that summaries always half omit: "The account of the fall (Gen 3) uses figurative language, but it affirms a primordial event, a fact that took place at the beginning of the history of man"[64]. Adam's sin is therefore a personal act, unique in origin, transmitted to all his descendants by propagation and not by imitation, and erasable only by the merit of Christ: these are the three anathemas of the Tridentine decree on original sin[65]. Its consequences reach every man: deprivation of original justice, wounding of nature, inclination to evil, ignorance, suffering, death[66].

"The account of the fall (Gen 3) uses figurative language, but it affirms a primordial event, a fact that took place at the beginning of the history of man."

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, §390[67]

Christian Fulfillment: The New Adam and the New Eve

Saint Paul: Adam as the Inverted Figure of Christ

All of Pauline soteriology rests on the parallel between two unique men: "Just as through the disobedience of one man the many were made sinners, so through the obedience of one the many will be made righteous"[68]. And: "Since death came through a man, the resurrection of the dead has also come through a man. For as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive"[69]. The first Adam became a living being; the last Adam, a life-giving spirit[70]. Without the first term, real and historical, the second loses its meaning: one does not redeem a metaphor.

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

"Just as through the disobedience of one man the many were made sinners, so through the obedience of one the many will be made righteous."

  • Saint Paul, Letter to the Romans 5:19, AELF translation[71]

Saint Irenaeus: Recapitulation and the Untied Knot

Around 180, Saint Irenaeus of Lyon gave this parallel its theological name: recapitulation (recapitulatio). Christ retraces in reverse, and successfully, what Adam had done in disobedience, gathering into himself the long succession of men in order to give back what they had lost[72]. And he extends the parallel to Eve: what the virgin Eve had bound by her unbelief, the Virgin Mary loosed by her faith[73]. This is the first Marian theology in history, and it presupposes Eve as a real person: an imaginary knot has no need of being untied.

"What the virgin Eve had bound by her unbelief, the Virgin Mary loosed by her faith."

  • Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies, Book III, ch. 22, §4, around 180 (Latin text: Quod enim alligavit virgo Eva per incredulitatem, hoc virgo Maria solvit per fidem)[74]

"Just as through the disobedience of a virgin man was struck down and fell into death, so through the Virgin obedient to the word of God, the risen man received life."

  • Saint Irenaeus of Lyon, Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching, §33, around 180[75]

Wisdom, the Jealous Devil, and the Serpent of Origins

Two late books of the Old Testament identify the instigator: the Book of Wisdom teaches that God created man for incorruptibility, in the image of his own nature, and that "through the devil's envy death entered the world"[76]. Revelation completes the identification: the dragon fought by Michael is "the serpent of origins, the one called the Devil and Satan"[77]. The serpent of Genesis 3 is therefore not merely a cunning animal: it is the visible instrument of the invisible Adversary, as Jesus confirms by calling the devil "a murderer from the beginning"[78].

Liturgical Use: Adam and Eve Prayed To and Celebrated

Saints on the Calendar: December 24

The Church does not merely recount Adam and Eve: she venerates them as saints. The Roman Martyrology records on December 24, Christmas Eve, the memorial of the holy first parents Adam and Eve[79]. The choice of date is theology in action: on the eve of the day on which the new Adam is born, the Church commemorates the old one, whose fault made the coming of the Saviour necessary.

The Easter Vigil: "O Happy Fault"

The liturgical high point of the year, the Easter Vigil, opens with the reading of creation (Gn 1:1–2:2) as the first reading[80], and then has the Easter candle sing the Exsultet (Præconium), which dares the most famous paradox of the Latin liturgy.

"O felix culpa, quae talem ac tantum meruit habere Redemptorem! O happy fault, which earned for us so great a Redeemer!"

  • Easter Proclamation (Exsultet), sung at the Easter Vigil[81]

Lent and Marriage

The account of the fall is proclaimed on the First Sunday of Lent (Year A): by entering the desert with the tempted Christ, the Church rereads the failed temptation of the origins in the light of the victorious temptation of the new Adam[82]. And the Marriage Rite offers the accounts of creation (Gn 1:26–28; Gn 2:18–24) among the readings of the celebration: every Christian couple marries under the patronage of the first couple[83].

Reception: The Fathers, Chronologists, and Artists

The Fathers read Adam and Eve as true history

From the second century onwards, the Fathers treat Adam and Eve as historical persons. Theophilus of Antioch, in his Ad Autolycum, counts the years from Adam and comments on the days of creation[84]. Saint John Chrysostom preaches 67 homilies on Genesis in Antioch, explaining verse by verse the formation of Adam, the mysterious sleep, and the fall[85]. Saint Ephrem the Syrian sings of paradise lost in his Hymns on Paradise[86]. And Saint Augustine devotes to the question his longest exegetical undertaking: The Literal Meaning of Genesis, in twelve books written between 401 and 415, in which he defends the historical sense of the text while acknowledging its allegorical depths[87]. In The City of God (books XII to XIV, 413–426), he grounds his entire doctrine of peace and fraternity on the single origin of the human race[88].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In the Middle Ages, Saint Thomas Aquinas brings system to the subject: the formation of Adam's body, the production of Eve, the nature of the divine image, the state of innocence, the dwelling of paradise (Summa Theologiae, First Part, questions 90 to 102), and then the transmission of original sin (First Part of the Second Part, questions 81 to 83)[89].

  1. c. 280–250 BC
    The Septuagint in Alexandria

    Greek translation of Genesis: the text is already fixed and revered throughout Judaism.

  2. c. AD 93–94
    Flavius Josephus tells of Adam

    The Jewish Antiquities (book I) take up the story of Adam and Eve as the opening of the history of the Jewish people[90].

  3. c. 180
    Irenaeus and Theophilus

    In Lyons and Antioch, the Fathers build upon a real Adam the theology of recapitulation and the chronology of the world.

  4. 401–415
    Augustine, The Literal Meaning of Genesis

    Twelve books defending the historical sense of Gn 1–3 against pagan and Manichaean mockery.

  5. 725
    Bede counts the years

    De temporum ratione perpetuates the short chronology from Adam in the monastic West.

  6. 1650
    Ussher dates creation

    The Annals of the Old Testament fix creation at 23 October 4004 BC, a date printed in the margins of Bibles for two centuries.

  7. 30 June 1909
    The Biblical Commission decides

    The decree on the historical character of the first three chapters of Genesis: a negative answer to those who would call it into question.

  8. 12 August 1950
    Humani Generis

    Pius XII reaffirms the unity of the human race and the incompatibility of polygenism with original sin.

The artists tell of the origins

The Creation of Adam, by Michelangelo (vault of the Sistine Chapel, c. 1511). God reaches out to Adam the spark of life: the most reproduced fresco in all of Scripture. Wikimedia Commons, Public domain (PD-Art).

Christian art has made Adam and Eve one of its most painted and sculpted subjects: the fall can be read on the walls of the catacombs from the earliest centuries, then on Romanesque capitals and Gothic stained glass[91]. Three masterpieces stand out: Masaccio, in the Brancacci Chapel in Florence (c. 1424–1427), paints the Temptation and above all the Expulsion, of an unprecedented pathetic violence[92] ; Michelangelo, on the vault of the Sistine Chapel (1508–1512), gives the Creation of Adam, become the most reproduced image of the Bible[93] ; Albrecht Dürer engraves his Adam and Eve in 1504, a summation of ideal beauty according to the canons of the Renaissance[94]. The Ghent Altarpiece of the Mystic Lamb by the Van Eyck brothers in Ghent (1432) places Adam and Eve life-size on the outer panels, facing the open heaven[95].

What modern exegesis proposes, and its limits

Common hypotheses

Since the eighteenth century, part of exegesis has proposed reading Genesis differently from tradition. Jean Astruc published his Conjectures in 1753 on the "memoirs" used by Moses, distinguishing the passages where God is called Elohim from those where he is called Yahweh[96]. Julius Wellhausen systematized the documentary hypothesis in 1878: the Pentateuch would be a late compilation of four sources (Yahwist, Elohist, Deuteronomist, Priestly), assembled after the Exile[97]. In this framework, Gen 1 (attributed to the Priestly source, 6th–5th century BC) and Gen 2 (attributed to the Yahwist, 10th century) would become two contradictory creation accounts stitched together, and Adam a symbolic figure of humanity rather than a real ancestor.

Five weaknesses in these reconstructions

Set out honestly, these hypotheses display five major weaknesses.

1. The anti-supernatural presupposition. Late dating rests for the most part on a philosophical premise rather than on a discovery: since precise prophecy or miracle is judged impossible in advance, any text containing one is declared later than the events. This is not a conclusion of research, but its starting point: the verdict is contained in the method.

2. Circular datings. Sources are dated by one another: a given psalm is late because it resembles a text judged late, which is judged late because it resembles the first. No manuscript of the Pentateuch older than Qumran allows these divisions to be verified; they remain armchair reconstructions.

3. The argument from silence. The absence of any mention of Adam in a given prophetic book is brandished as proof of his nonexistence, whereas the argument from silence never proves anything: the prophets no more cite Abraham on every page, and no one concludes from this that he did not exist.

4. Confusing literary possibility with historical proof. That a text can be divided into sources (any text can, including a newspaper article) does not prove that it was so composed. Moreover, the criteria of division (divine names, doublets, style) yield divergent results depending on the school — a sign that they measure the method more than the text.

5. Contempt in principle for Tradition. The reconstructions treat the unanimous testimony of ancient Jews and Christians as suspect by principle, while granting modern hypotheses a confidence that their incessant revisions belie: the classical documentary hypothesis itself is today abandoned or profoundly reshaped by a large part of its heirs.

Why the traditional reading remains defensible

Faced with these weaknesses, the traditional position lines up solid pieces: the testimony of Christ attributing these books to Moses[98], the proven antiquity of the text through the Septuagint and Qumran[99], the unanimity of Jewish and Christian reception[100], the magisterial confirmation of 1909 requiring that the historical-literal sense be maintained of the creation of all things, the special creation of man, the formation of the first woman from the first man, and the unity of the human race[101], and Pius XII's reaffirmation that the first eleven chapters "belong to history in a true sense"[102]. Saint Paul VI, in 1966, judged incompatible with the faith those explanations which deny that the sin from which so many evils came was first the disobedience of Adam, the "first man"[103]. One therefore does not write "research has shown" when it is a matter of revisable hypotheses: one writes that part of contemporary exegesis proposes, and then one responds.

The same message of 1996 also recalls the distinction established by Pius XII, which every Catholic may hold without fear: "If the human body takes its origin from pre-existing living matter, the spiritual soul is immediately created by God"[104]. And it sets aside unambiguously materialist readings: theories that make the spirit emerge from the sole forces of living matter "are incompatible with the truth of man"[105]. As for the formula of Vatican II on inerrancy, it states why God had the truth recorded, "for the sake of our salvation", and not what inerrancy pertains to: a council does not contradict Providentissimus Deus[106].

"In man we therefore find ourselves before a difference of an ontological order, before an ontological leap, one might say."

Conclusion: the first couple and the last Adam

Adam and Eve open the Bible because they open history: created out of love in the image of God, married by God himself, workers in his garden, fallen through pride, mourned by God who clothes them before exiling them, promised a victorious offspring from the very sentence pronounced upon them. The whole rest of Scripture is nothing but the unfolding of Gen 3:15: the hostility between the serpent and the woman, between her offspring and his, until the Cross where the new Adam, obedient even unto death, crushes the head the old one had followed. The Church celebrates them on the eve of Christmas because they are the reason for Christmas: without their fall, no Redeemer; without their reality, no redemption. "O happy fault," she sings each year in the Easter night, "which gained for us so great a Redeemer"[108].

Go deeper with Via Divina - The fall and the promise of the Saviour are at the heart of the free Via Divina foundational course, which unfolds salvation history from Genesis to the Resurrection. To discover the full course, open /home/formation.

Further reading

  • Did Adam and Eve really exist? - the full article on historicity, monogenism and direct creation around 4000 BC.
  • Did the Flood really happen? - the continuation of the story of the origins, from Adam to Noah.
  • Moses - the author of the Pentateuch according to tradition.
  • Noah - the tenth from Adam, father of humanity after the Flood.
  • Abraham - the call that opens the patriarchal cycle in Gen 12.
  • The Bible - the canon, inspiration and inerrancy of Scripture.

Notes and references

Notes and References

  1. Council of Trent, session IV, Decree on the Sacred Books and Traditions, 8 April 1546: the council fixes the canon and receives the books entire with all their parts.

    1
  2. Greek translation of Alexandria from the 3rd century BC; the Letter of Aristeas to Philocrates (2nd century BC) recounts the legend of its seventy-two translators.

    2 20 99
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §1602: Scripture opens with the creation of man and woman in the image of God (Gen 1:26-27).

    3 56
  4. Usual structure of the book: story of the origins (Gen 1 to 11), then the cycle of Abraham (Gen 12 to 25), of Isaac and Jacob (Gen 26 to 36), of Joseph (Gen 37 to 50).

    4 19
  5. Gospel according to Saint Luke 3:38, AELF translation: the genealogy of Jesus traces back through Seth and Adam to God, "Adam, the son of God".

    5
  6. Gospel according to Saint Matthew 19:4-6, AELF translation: Jesus cites Gen 1:27 and Gen 2:24 as the word of the Creator; cf. Mk 10:6-8.

    6 8 33 83
  7. Saint Paul, Epistle to the Romans 5:19, AELF translation: by the disobedience of one the many made sinners, by the obedience of one the many made righteous.

    7 68 71
  8. Gospel according to Saint John 5:46, AELF translation: "If you believed Moses, you would believe me also, for it is of me that he wrote"; cf. Mk 12:26, the "book of Moses".

    9 17 98
  9. First Vatican Council, constitution Dei Filius, ch. 2, 24 April 1870 (DS 3006): the sacred books, written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, have God for their author; cf. Leo XIII, Providentissimus Deus, 18 November 1893 (DS 3291), and Vatican II, Dei Verbum 11.

    10 106
  10. Pontifical Biblical Commission, 27 June 1906: substantial confirmation of the Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch, without excluding earlier sources or inspired revisions.

    11
  11. Saint Pius X, motu proprio Praestantia Scripturae, 18 November 1907 (Acta Sanctae Sedis 40, pp. 723-726): the decisions of the Biblical Commission bind in conscience.

    12
  12. Traditional dating: Moses and the Exodus belong to the 2nd millennium BC; Genesis is therefore more than a thousand years earlier than the writing prophets (8th–6th centuries).

    13
  13. James Ussher, Annales Veteris Testamenti, London, 1650, p. 1: creation at the beginning of the night preceding 23 October 4004 BC (Julian calendar), based on the genealogies and Assyrian synchronisms; modern trans. Larry and Marion Pierce, The Annals of the World, Master Books, 2003.

    14
  14. Seder Olam Rabbah, attributed to Rabbi Yossi ben Halafta (2nd century): creation is placed in the year 3761 BC, the origin of the Hebrew calendar.

    15
  15. Saint Bede the Venerable, De temporum ratione (On the Reckoning of Time), 725: perpetuates in the West the short chronology counted from Adam.

    16
  16. Pentateuch preserved by the Samaritan community, separated from Judaism since the Exile (6th century BC): an independent witness to the same text attributed to Moses.

    18 22 100
  17. Dead Sea Scrolls (2nd century BC to 1st century AD): the copies of Genesis confirm the stability of the Hebrew text over nearly a thousand years.

    21
  18. Saint Jerome, Latin translation from Hebrew in Bethlehem, late 4th century: the Vulgate, official Bible of the West for over fifteen centuries.

    23
  19. Genesis 1:27, AELF translation: man created in the image of God, male and female.

    24 27
  20. Genesis 1:28, AELF translation: blessing and mission, to be fruitful, fill the earth, and subdue it.

    25
  21. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §355: man holds a unique place in creation; he is in the image of God.

    26 48
  22. Genesis 2:7, AELF translation: Adam formed from dust, the breath of life breathed into him.

    28 34
  23. Genesis 2:15, AELF translation: the man placed in the garden of Eden to keep and cultivate it.

    29 59
  24. Genesis 2:21-24, AELF translation: the sleep, the rib, the woman recognized, and the union in one flesh.

    30 55
  25. Genesis 3:20, AELF translation: Eve (Hawwah, the living one), mother of all the living.

    31
  26. Genesis 2:24, AELF translation: to leave father and mother, to cling, to become one flesh; cited by Jesus in Mt 19:5.

    32
  27. Genesis 3:1-6, AELF translation: the serpent's dialogue, doubt, the fruit eaten.

    35
  28. Genesis 3:16-19, AELF translation: the three sentences, pain, toil, return to dust.

    36 41 60
  29. Genesis 3:15, AELF translation: the protoevangelium, the first announcement of the Saviour born of the woman.

    37 40
  30. Genesis 3:21, AELF translation: God clothes Adam and Eve in garments of skin.

    38
  31. Genesis 3:24, AELF translation: the cherubim and the flaming sword east of the garden.

    39
  32. Genesis 4:1-8, AELF translation: Cain and Abel, the offerings, the first murder.

    42
  33. Genesis 4:17-22, AELF translation: the line of Cain, first herdsmen, musicians and metalworkers.

    43
  34. Genesis 4:25-26, AELF translation: the birth of Seth, the public invocation of the name of the Lord.

    44
  35. Genesis 5:3, AELF translation: Adam begets Seth at 130 years old; cf. Gen 5:5 for his 930 years.

    45
  36. Genesis 5:21-24, AELF translation: Enoch walks with God and is taken up at 365 years old.

    46
  37. Creation to the Flood: 1656 years (Hebrew text), 2262 years (Septuagint), 1307 years (Samaritan Pentateuch), according to the ages of the patriarchs at the birth of their son in each tradition.

    47
  38. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §366: every spiritual soul is immediately created by God, it is not produced by the parents, it is immortal (cf. Pius XII, Humani Generis, DS 3896; Lateran V, DS 1440).

    49
  39. Saint Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, First Part, qq. 90-102 (the production of man and woman, the divine image, the state of innocence, paradise) and First–Second Part, qq. 81-83 (the transmission of original sin); cf. De Malo, q. 4, a. 1, cited by the CCC 404.

    50 89
  40. Pius XII, encyclical Humani Generis, §37, 12 August 1950 (AAS 42, pp. 561-578): the faithful cannot admit polygenism, which is irreconcilable with original sin proceeding from a single Adam.

    51
  41. Acts of the Apostles 17:26, AELF translation: the speech at the Areopagus, all mankind descended from one.

    52
  42. Saint Augustine, The City of God, books XII-XIV, 413-426: the unique creation of man (XII, 22), the fall and the transmission of sin (XIV); trans. Louis Moreau revised by Jean-Claude Eslin, Éditions du Seuil, 2004.

    53 88
  43. Genesis 2:18, AELF translation: "It is not good that the man should be alone".

    54
  44. Book of Tobit 8:6, AELF translation: the prayer of Tobit, Adam created by God, Eve given as a helper.

    57 58
  45. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§374-379: original justice, divine friendship, inner, marital and cosmic harmony, exemption from death.

    61
  46. Council of Trent, Session V, Decree on Original Sin, canon 1, 17 June 1546 (DS 1511): Adam lost the holiness and justice in which he had been established.

    62
  47. Roman Catechism (of St Pius V), Rome, 1566: hands on to parish priests the doctrine of creation and the Fall.

    63
  48. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §390: figurative language of Genesis 3 and a primordial event that really occurred.

    64 67
  49. Council of Trent, Session V, canons 2 and 3, 17 June 1546 (DS 1512-1513): one sin in its origin, transmitted by propagation and not by imitation, effaced by the sole merit of Christ.

    65
  50. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§396-404: consequences of Adam's sin for humanity.

    66
  51. Saint Paul, First Letter to the Corinthians 15:21-22, AELF translation: all die in Adam, all will come to life in Christ.

    69
  52. Saint Paul, First Letter to the Corinthians 15:45, AELF translation: the first Adam a living being, the last Adam a life-giving spirit.

    70
  53. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, Book III, ch. 18, §1, c. 180: Christ recapitulates in himself the long line of men; critical edition Sources Chrétiennes no. 211, Éditions du Cerf, 1974.

    72
  54. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies, Book III, ch. 22, §4, c. 180: what the virgin Eve bound by disbelief, the Virgin Mary loosed by her faith; Sources Chrétiennes no. 211, pp. 439-441.

    73 74
  55. Saint Irenaeus of Lyons, Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching, §33, c. 180; Sources Chrétiennes no. 406, Éditions du Cerf.

    75
  56. Book of Wisdom 2:23-24, AELF translation: man created for incorruptibility, death entered through the devil's jealousy.

    76
  57. Revelation 12:9, AELF translation: the serpent of old named Devil and Satan.

    77
  58. Gospel according to Saint John 8:44, AELF translation: the devil a murderer from the beginning.

    78
  59. Martyrologium Romanum, typical edition, Vatican City, 2004, at 24 December: commemoration of the holy first parents Adam and Eve.

    79
  60. Roman Missal, Easter Vigil: Gen 1:1 to 2:2 as the first reading of the Easter night.

    80
  61. Easter Proclamation (Exsultet) of the Easter Vigil: “O felix culpa quae talem ac tantum meruit habere Redemptorem”.

    81 108
  62. Sunday Lectionary, First Sunday of Lent, Year A: Gen 2:7-9 and 3:1-7, the Fall reread in the light of Christ's victorious temptation (Mt 4:1-11).

    82
  63. Saint Theophilus of Antioch, To Autolycus, Books II-III, c. 180: commentary on the days of creation and reckoning of the years since Adam.

    84
  64. Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on Genesis (67 homilies preached at Antioch): verse-by-verse exposition; Sources Chrétiennes collection, Éditions du Cerf.

    85
  65. Saint Ephrem the Syrian, Hymns on Paradise, 4th century: song of the lost garden and the tree of life.

    86
  66. Saint Augustine, The Literal Meaning of Genesis (De Genesi ad litteram), twelve books, 401-415: defence of the historical sense of Gen 1 to 3.

    87
  67. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, book I, c. 93-94 AD: the story of Adam and Eve told at the opening of the history of the Jewish people.

    90
  68. Adam and Eve are among the most constant subjects of Christian art, from early Christian sarcophagi to Gothic stained glass.

    91
  69. Masaccio, The Temptation and The Expulsion from Paradise, Brancacci Chapel, Florence, c. 1424-1427.

    92
  70. Michelangelo, ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, Vatican, 1508-1512: Creation of Adam, Temptation and Fall.

    93
  71. Albrecht Dürer, Adam and Eve, copper engraving, 1504.

    94
  72. Jan and Hubert van Eyck, Ghent Altarpiece, Ghent, 1432: Adam and Eve on the exterior panels.

    95
  73. Jean Astruc, Conjectures sur les mémoires originaux dont il paraît que Moïse s'est servi pour composer le livre de la Genèse, Brussels, 1753: distinction of the divine names Elohim and Yahweh.

    96
  74. Julius Wellhausen, Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, Berlin, 1878: systematisation of the documentary hypothesis (Yahwist, Elohist, Deuteronomist and Priestly sources).

    97
  75. Pontifical Biblical Commission, decree De charactere historico trium priorum capitum Geneseos, 30 June 1909 (AAS 1, pp. 567-569): the literal historical sense cannot be called into question regarding the creation, the special creation of man, the formation of woman, and the unity of the human race.

    101
  76. Pius XII, Humani Generis, §38, 12 August 1950: the first eleven chapters belong to history in a true sense.

    102
  77. Saint Paul VI, address on original sin, 11 July 1966 (AAS 58, p. 654): irreconcilable with the faith to deny that sin was first the disobedience of Adam, the “first man”.

    103
  78. Saint John Paul II, Message to the Members of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on the Occasion of Their Plenary Assembly, 22 October 1996 (written text, filed among the messages of the Holy See, not delivered as an address): §5 on the soul immediately created by God (citing Pius XII) and on the incompatibility of materialist readings, §6 on the ontological leap; official French text on vatican.va.

    104 105 107

Can’t find your topic?