The Maccabees (167-134 BC)

Mattathias, Judas the Hammer, Jonathan, Simon: the family of the Maccabees wrested Judea from the persecution of Antiochus IV and restored the Temple's purity. The story of the revolt, the martyrs and the Hasmonean dynasty, fulfilled in Christ and honored by the Church.

Ignispedia

The Maccabees are the Jewish family who, in the 2nd century before Jesus Christ, wrested Judea from the most violent religious persecution in its history and restored the Temple of Jerusalem to its purity. An aged priest, Mattathias, refused to sacrifice to the idols of the Greek king Antiochus IV Epiphanes; his sons took up arms, and the third of them, Judas, surnamed Maccabee ("the Hammer"), crushed the Seleucid armies one after another, purified the profaned Temple and instituted the feast of the Dedication, which the Jews still celebrate under the name of Hanukkah. From 167 to 134 BC, from Mattathias to Simon, this family of priests turned war leaders won the independence of Judea and founded the Hasmonean dynasty, which reigned until the arrival of the Romans.

Their story is told by the Bible itself, in the first and second books of Maccabees, received by the Catholic Church as Holy Scripture. It is there, in the blood of the martyrs, that the faith of Israel confesses with new clarity the resurrection of the bodies, creation out of nothing and prayer for the dead: three truths that Christianity would hold as central. Christ himself went up to the Temple for the feast born of their victory (Jn 10:22), the Epistle to the Hebrews echoes their martyrs (Heb 11:35), and the Church honours as saints Eleazar, the seven brothers and their mother.

This article presents the family: its name, its story, its figures, its witnesses, its theology, its Christian fulfilment and its cult. For the two books themselves, their detailed doctrines and the question of the canon that divides Catholics and Protestants, see the dedicated article The Books of Maccabees.

The Maccabees in the canon of Scripture

A war name become a family name

The word "Maccabees" initially designates neither a people nor a book, but a man: Judas, third son of Mattathias and soul of the revolt. His surname, Maqqaba in Hebrew, means according to the most widely accepted interpretation "the hammer", an image of the warrior who strikes and shatters the enemy armies[1]. From Judas, the surname passed to his brothers, then to the whole family, and finally to the two books that tell their story. The family also bears a second, more official name: the Hasmonaeans, from the name of an ancestor, Hasmon (Asamonaios in Josephus), a priest of the class of Abijah according to the genealogy which the Jewish historian traces back one generation further than the biblical book[2].

Mattathias had five sons, whom the first book names with their war surnames (1 Mac 2:2-5)[3] :

SonSurnameFate
JohnGaddisCaptured and then killed by the sons of Jambri (1 Mac 9:35-36)
SimonThassiLast leader of the revolt, prince and high priest (142-134)
JudasMaccabeeHero of the revolt, fallen at Elasa (160)
EleazarAvaranHeroic death beneath a war elephant (1 Mac 6:43-46)
JonathanApphusHigh priest and leader (160-142), assassinated by treachery

The two books that tell their story

The story of this family is known to us first through the Bible itself: the first book of Maccabees, a sober chronicle following the family from Mattathias to Simon (c. 175-134), and the second book, a theological drama centred on the persecution, the martyrs and the victories of Judas (c. 180-161)[4]. The two works are independent, by different authors, and complement one another more than they repeat one another. They belong to the deuterocanonical books: received by the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Churches as the Word of God, absent from Jewish and Protestant bibles[5]. The details of their contents, their doctrines and the debate over the canon are set out in the article The Books of Maccabees: they are not repeated here, where the family and its story take the leading role.

The story: from persecution to independence

  1. 175 B.C.
    Antiochus IV Epiphanes ascends the Seleucid throne

    The new king of Syria claims to embody the divine and wants to mould all his subjects into Greek culture, the Jews included.

  2. 167 B.C.
    The persecution and the abomination of desolation

    The Law forbidden on pain of death, books burned, a pagan altar erected on the altar of burnt offerings. Mattathias refuses to sacrifice at Modein and takes to the hills.

  3. 166 B.C.
    Death of Mattathias, Judas takes command

    The old priest dies after delivering his testament; his son Judas, the Hammer, wages guerrilla warfare against the Seleucid generals.

  4. 164 B.C.
    Purification of the Temple and the feast of the Dedication

    On the 25th of Kislev, three years after the profanation, sacrifice resumes. The annual feast of the Dedication (Hanukkah) is instituted.

  5. 161 B.C.
    Victory over Nicanor at Adasa

    Judas crushes the general Nicanor; the 13th of Adar becomes a feast day, the "day of Nicanor."

  6. 160 B.C.
    Eleasa: the death of Judas

    Abandoned by part of his troops, Judas falls weapon in hand against Bacchides. Jonathan succeeds him.

  7. 152 B.C.
    Jonathan becomes high priest

    The Seleucid pretender Alexander Balas appoints Jonathan high priest: the priestly family is restored to the leadership of the Temple.

  8. 142 B.C.
    Jonathan assassinated, Simon takes the lead

    The general Tryphon has Jonathan killed by treachery at Ptolemais. Simon, the last son of Mattathias, takes up the fight.

  9. 141 B.C.
    Capture of the citadel and de facto independence

    Simon drives the Seleucid garrison out of the Acra of Jerusalem; the people acclaim him leader and hereditary high priest.

  10. 134 B.C.
    Assassination of Simon, accession of John Hyrcanus

    Simon is assassinated with two of his sons at Dok. His son John Hyrcanus succeeds him: the Hasmonean dynasty is founded.

Antiochus IV Epiphanes and the abomination of desolation

To understand the Maccabees, one must go back to Alexander the Great. Upon his death (323 B.C.), his empire is divided among his generals, and Judea passes from the Ptolemies of Egypt to the Seleucids of Syria after 200 B.C. With them comes a flood of Hellenism: the Greek language, gymnasiums, Greek-style cities. Part of the aristocracy of Jerusalem allows itself to be seduced, to the point of selling off the high priesthood: the legitimate high priest Onias III is ousted in favour of schemers who plunder the Temple[6].

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

In 175 B.C., Antiochus IV ascends the throne, styling himself Epiphanes ("the god manifest"), a title of such arrogance that his contemporains would mock it as Epimanes, "the madman." Returning frustrated from Egypt, he decides to break Jewish distinctiveness. In 167, he crosses the line of no return: he has the daily sacrifice ceased, forbids the Sabbath, circumcision and the Law on pain of death, and erects a pagan altar on the altar of burnt offerings, where pigs are immolated. This is the "abomination of desolation" announced by the Book of Daniel (Dn 9:27; 11:31)[7].

Mattathias at Modein: the refusal

It all begins in the village of Modein, where officers of the king come to compel the Jews to sacrifice to idols. The old priest Mattathias, son of John, son of Simeon, of the priestly class of Abijah, settled at Modein, is ordered to set the example. His answer is the manifesto of the whole revolt:

"All the nations belonging to the king's dominions may well obey him. But as for me, my sons and my brothers, we will follow the Covenant of our fathers. May Heaven preserve us from abandoning the Law and its precepts!" (1 Maccabees 2:19-21)[8]

Seeing a Jew step forward to sacrifice, Mattathias, burning with zeal for the Law as Phinehas of old (Num 25), strikes him down on the very altar, cuts down the royal officer, overturns the pagan altar, then cries through the city for all the faithful to follow him into the mountains (1 M 2:27)[9]. Armed resistance is born. Dying the following year (166), Mattathias leaves his sons a testament in which he reviews the heroes of the faith, from Abraham to Daniel, teaching them that God saves those who remain faithful to him (1 M 2:49-70)[10]. He entrusts the command to Judas for war and to Simon for counsel.

Judas the Hammer: the guerrilla of faith

Judas Maccabeus is the great hero of the epic. At the head of a handful of poorly armed men, he defeats one after another the Seleucid generals sent against him. His principal victories, narrated in chapters 3 to 7 of the first book, unfold across three campaigns[11]:

Battle (c. 166-164)Seleucid opponentOutcome
Beth-horonSera, then Gorgias at EmmausArmies put to flight by a handful of men
Beth-zurLysias, regent of the young Antiochus VVictory opening the road to Jerusalem
Adasa (161)NicanorGeneral killed, hand exposed; feast of the 13th of Adar

His strategy is that of guerrilla warfare (night attacks, knowledge of the terrain, refusal of pitched battle), but his true weapon is faith. Before each battle against overwhelming forces, he reminds his men that victory does not lie in large battalions:

"It easily happens that a multitude falls into the hands of a few. Indeed, victory in battle does not depend on the size of the army: from Heaven comes the strength." (1 Maccabees 3:18-19)[12]

This saying sums up the theology of the whole narrative: Israel does not conquer by its own might, but because God fights for it, exactly as in the days of Joshua and Gideon. Meanwhile, Antiochus IV dies in 164 in Persia while attempting to plunder a sanctuary (1 M 6:1-17), and his young successor Antiochus V, advised by Lysias, must come to terms[13].

The purification of the Temple and the feast of the Dedication

The climax of the epic is the recapture of Jerusalem and the purification of the profaned Temple. Judas has the defiled altar demolished, builds a new one with intact stones, remakes the sacred vessels, and relights the lamp of the sanctuary. On the 25th of the month of Kislev, 164 (December), three years to the day after the profanation, sacrifice is offered once more. The joy is so great that an annual feast is instituted:

"Judas Maccabeus decided, with his brothers and the whole assembly of Israel, that the anniversary of the dedication of the altar should be celebrated for eight days each year at that date, in joy and gladness." (1 Maccabees 4:59)[14]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

This feast is Hanukkah ("Dedication"), still celebrated by Jews for eight days around the lighting of the lights. It is also the only feast of Maccabean origin mentioned in the New Testament: the Gospel of John notes that Jesus was teaching in the Temple at the time of "the feast of the dedication of the Temple at Jerusalem; it was winter" (Jn 10:22)[15].

Eleasa: the death of Judas

Judas does not long enjoy his victories. After defeating Nicanor at Adasa (161) and concluding an alliance with rising Rome (1 M 8), he faces at Eleasa (160) the army of Bacchides with only eight hundred men, most of his troops having deserted him. He refuses to flee and falls weapon in hand. The book notes soberly that all Israel mourned him (1 M 9:18-21)[16]. His death does not halt the movement: his brother Jonathan takes the lead of the faithful and withdraws to the desert of the Jordan.

Jonathan: the priest-diplomat

Jonathan, surnamed Apphus, initially leads the same guerrilla life as Judas, avenging his brother John along the way, who was killed by marauders (1 M 9:35–42)[17]. But his genius is diplomatic: playing off the rivalries between Seleucid pretenders, he obtains from Alexander Balas, in 152, the title of high priest, along with the purple robe and the golden crown (1 M 10:15–21)[18]. For the first time since the crisis, a son of Mattathias ascends the pontifical throne: the priestly family is restored to the leadership of the Temple. Jonathan consolidates, fortifies Jerusalem, negotiates with Rome and Sparta, then falls into the trap of the general Trypho, who has him captured at Ptolemaïs and assassinated (142)[19].

Simon: independence recognised

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Simon, surnamed Thassi, the last surviving of the five sons, resumes the struggle with consummate prudence. He obtains from the pretender Demetrius II exemption from tribute[20], drives out in 141 the Seleucid garrison of the citadel (the Acra) that had held Jerusalem for twenty-six years, and enters the city with palm branches and canticles (1 M 13:49–52)[21]. The following year, a great assembly of the people, the priests and the elders proclaims Simon leader, ethnarch and high priest in perpetuity, by a solemn decree engraved on bronze and displayed at the Temple (1 M 14:27–49)[22]. Judaea is independent in fact, mints its own coinage, dates its deeds from the era of Simon, and knows the peace described by the fine passage of 1 M 14:4–15. In 134, Simon is assassinated along with two of his sons, Judas and Mattathias, during a feast at Dok by his son-in-law Ptolemy, son of Abubus, who coveted power (1 M 16:11–17)[23]. His third son, John Hyrcanus, escapes the plot and succeeds him: the Hasmonean dynasty begins.

The Hasmoneans after Simon: a dynasty until Rome

Prutah of John Hyrcanus I, American Numismatic Society, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 licence.

With John Hyrcanus I (134–104), religious resistance becomes a kingdom. Hyrcanus expands Judaea (Idumaea, Samaria), and his coins, bronze prutahs in the name of "Yehohanan the high priest and the council of the Jews", are the oldest material witnesses of the Hasmonean state[24]. His son Aristobulus I (104–103) is, according to Josephus, the first Hasmonean to wear the royal diadem (Antiquities, XIII, 301), even though his own coins still give him only the title of high priest, which leaves historians debating the first true royal title[25].

Hasmonean rulerReignKey event
John Hyrcanus I134–104Expansion of the territory, first Jewish coins
Aristobulus I104–103First diadem according to Josephus; one-year reign
Alexander Jannaeus103–76Territorial peak, civil war against the Pharisees
Salome Alexandra76–67Reigning queen, internal peace, support for the Pharisees
Hyrcanus II against Aristobulus II67–63Fratricidal war that invites Roman arbitration
Pompey takes Jerusalem63End of independence; Judaea becomes a tributary of Rome
Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

Under Alexander Jannaeus (103–76), the kingdom reaches its greatest extent, but at the cost of a bloody civil war with the Pharisees. His widow Salome Alexandra (76–67), the only reigning queen of the Second Temple period, restores internal peace[26]. At her death, her sons Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II tear each other apart: the two brothers appeal to Pompey, who lays siege to Jerusalem, seizes the Temple in 63 BC and takes Aristobulus captive to Rome[27]. The independence won by Simon comes to an end; Judaea, reduced and tributary, will await the Messiah under Roman rule, and then under Herod, who will marry the Hasmonean princess Mariamne before extinguishing the dynasty[28]. The people who will go up to the Temple of Jesus are those whom the Maccabees saved from forced Hellenisation. Archaeology continues to illustrate this building legacy: in October 2026, the Israel Antiquities Authority announced the uncovering, south of the kibbutz Ramat Rachel, of a section of about 300 metres of the Lower Aqueduct of Jerusalem, a work some 21 kilometres long that carried water by gravity from the Pools of Solomon to the Temple Mount and whose construction archaeologists attribute to the Hasmonean period[29].

Figures of the resistance

Eleazar the scribe: die rather than pretend

The first martyr told of in the second book is the old scribe Eleazar, ninety years old, whom they try to force to eat pork. He is offered an honourable way out: pretend to obey by eating permitted meat, to save his life. He refuses, for fear that the young, seeing him give in, might conclude that the Law does not matter:

"Such a comedy is unworthy of my age. By choosing to die with determination and nobility for our venerable and holy laws, I shall leave the young the noble example of a beautiful death." (2 Maccabees 6:24-28, condensed passage)[30]

Eleazar introduces a new idea: it is better to die than to sin, and the witness of blood is more fruitful than survival bought through betrayal. The Fathers will see in him the forerunner of the Christian martyrs[31].

Eleazar Avaran and the elephant

Another Eleazar, fourth son of Mattathias, surnamed Avaran, illustrates the family's military heroism. At the battle of Beth-Zacharia against the regent Lysias, seeing an elephant caparisoned with the royal arms that he takes for the young king's, he fights his way under the beast's belly, pierces it with his sword and dies crushed beneath its fall (1 M 6:43-46)[32]. The book, usually sparing of comment, salutes the deed: he gave his life "to save his people and win for himself an immortal name".

The seven brothers and their mother

Then comes the most famous page: the martyrdom of seven brothers and their mother, put to death one after another before the king's eyes. At each torment, one of them confesses his faith in the resurrection of the body, the most explicit affirmation of this truth in the whole Old Testament:

"You are a scoundrel, you who tear us away from this present life, but since we die in fidelity to his laws, the King of the world will raise us up to eternal life." (2 Maccabees 7:9)[33]

But it is the mother who dominates the scene. Seeing her seven sons perish in a single day, she encourages them one after another in the language of their fathers. To her youngest, the last one alive, she addresses an exhortation containing one of the deepest texts of the whole Bible, the affirmation of the creation of the world from nothing:

"I beg you, my child, look at the heaven and the earth and at all they contain: know that God made all this from nothing, and that the race of men was born in the same way." (2 Maccabees 7:28)[34]

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The mother's reasoning is of admirable strength: the God who drew the universe from nothingness can, all the more readily, give life back to torn bodies. Faith in the resurrection is founded on faith in creation. The Catechism of the Catholic Church expressly quotes these martyrs as the moment when the resurrection begins to be expressed in Israel[35].

The traditional authorship and dating

The first book: a Jew close to the events, writing in Hebrew

Jewish, patristic and ecclesial tradition receives the first book as the work of a Jew of Judea, a supporter of the Maccabees, writing soon after the events, under the reign of John Hyrcanus (134-104): the book ends with the accession of Hyrcanus (1 M 16:23-24) and admires Rome in a way that presupposes a composition prior to Pompey's conquest (63)[36]. Several internal clues support this proximity: the author knows the geography of Judea in detail, carefully dates each event according to the Seleucid era, quotes official documents (treaties with Rome and Sparta, royal letters, decree for Simon), and writes in a Hebrew whose turn of phrase the Greek translation has preserved[37].

The decisive witness is Saint Jerome: in his prologue, he states that he had the Hebrew text before his eyes, "Machabaeorum primum librum Hebraicum repperi" ("I found the first book of Maccabees in Hebrew")[38]. Origen, a century and a half earlier, already knew the Semitic title of the work (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 25)[39]. The Hebrew original was then lost, and only the Greek of the Septuagint survives: it is partly for this reason that the book, absent from the Hebrew collections, was not retained in the Rabbinic Bible, whereas the Church, which read the Greek Bible of the Apostles, received it as Scripture.

The second book: the epitome of Jason of Cyrene

The author of the second book does not hide: he himself declares that he is abridging a work in five volumes by a certain Jason of Cyrene, now lost, and confesses the toil of such an epitome:

"But for us who have undertaken this painful task of summary, the task, far from being easy, cost us sweat and sleepless nights." (2 Maccabees 2:26)[40]

This preface is precious: it is one of the few places in the Bible where a sacred author describes his own method of work. Far from weakening inspiration, this testimony illuminates it: God inspires real men, who toil over their work like any writer. The epitome, written in Greek from the outset in the style of the Hellenistic diaspora, is attached to two letters to the Jews of Egypt, the first dated to 124 BC, which places the work at the turn of the second and first centuries[41]. Jason himself, to judge by his precise knowledge of Palestine, had lived in Judea and was writing soon after the death of Nicanor (161), even before the fall of Judas, of whom he does not speak[42].

The reception: the Bible of the Apostles, then that of the Church

Both books entered the Church with the Septuagint, the Greek Bible that the Apostles read: the New Testament's quotations of the Old Testament most often follow the Greek, and it is in this Bible that the first Christian generations encountered the Maccabees[43]. The regional councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397) list them in the canon; the council of Florence (1442) and then that of Trent (8 April 1546) solemnly define them among the Scriptures[44]. Saint Augustine summed up the position of the Church: the Jews do not hold these books to be canonical, "but the Church holds them to be canonical, because of the extreme and admirable sufferings of certain martyrs" (see below).

The ancient witnesses to the account

Flavius Josephus and the Greek sources

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The first external witness is Flavius Josephus (c. 37–c. 100 AD). In his Antiquities of the Jews (books XII–XIII), he follows 1 Maccabees closely, while also having access to sources now lost: he is the one who gives the full genealogy going back to Hasmoneus (XII, 265) and who recounts the Hasmonean continuation after Simon[45]. The biblical account moreover overlaps with the Greek historian Polybius on Seleucid affairs (death of Antiochus, Syrian wars), and the official documents inserted into the two books (royal letters, decrees) are rooted, according to the work of Elias Bickerman on the Seleucid chancellery, in real diplomatic practices[46]. Far from being an isolated legend, the Maccabean epic is embedded in a network of cross-attesting testimonies.

The New Testament, the first Christian witness

The New Testament encounters the Maccabees at two decisive points. First, the Gospel of John places Jesus at the Temple for the feast of the Dedication (Jn 10:22): Christ honours with his presence the feast born of Judas's victory[47]. Second, the Epistle to the Hebrews, in its great gallery of witnesses of faith, evokes those who « were tortured and would not accept deliverance, so that they might obtain a better resurrection » (Heb 11:35)[48]. The Greek vocabulary of this verse echoes 2 Maccabees directly: the author of the New Testament reads the Old Testament with the Septuagint, Maccabees included, and holds up its martyrs as models of faith[49].

« Women received their dead back by resurrection. But others were tortured and would not accept deliverance, so that they might obtain a better resurrection. » (Hebrews 11:35)[50]

The Fathers: Chrysostom, Gregory of Nazianzus, Augustine

From the fourth century onwards, the Maccabean martyrs receive a splendid cult in the Church. Saint Gregory of Nazianzus devotes his Oration 15 to them, delivered for their feast in 379 or 381, in which he argues that they deserve the same veneration as the Christian martyrs[51]. Saint John Chrysostom preaches in Antioch, around 386, two homilies on the Maccabees before their relics, in a city that possesses a church in their name[52]. Saint Augustine likewise dedicates sermons to them and settles the question of the canon in their favour:

« These books of the Maccabees, the Jews do not hold them to be canonical, but the Church holds them to be canonical, because of the extreme and admirable sufferings of certain martyrs. » (Saint Augustine, The City of God, XVIII, 36)[53]

The theology of the Maccabees

If the Church holds so firmly to this family, it is not only for its heroism: it is because its history bears, in explicit form, four truths of faith that the rest of the Old Testament expressed only in embryo. The following table sums them up; their detailed exposition belongs to the article The books of the Maccabees.

DoctrineText of the MaccabeesConfirmation in the Church
Resurrection of the body2 M 7:9.14: the King of the world will raise the martyrsCEC § 992; common faith
Creation out of nothing2 M 7:28: God made everything "out of nothing"Lateran IV (1215); CEC § 297
Prayer for the dead2 M 12:38-46: sacrifice for the fallen soldiersFlorence, Trent; CEC §§ 1031-1032
Intercession of the saints2 M 15:12-16: Onias and Jeremiah pray from HeavenCommunion of saints; CEC § 956

Before the Maccabees, Israel's hope in the hereafter remained hazy: the dwelling of the dead, the sheol, was an indistinct shadow. It is against the backdrop of martyrdom that springs forth one of the most explicit expressions of faith in a bodily resurrection to eternal life, which the Pharisees will soon share (cf. Acts 23:6) and which Christ will fulfil: « I am the resurrection and the life » (Jn 11:25)[54]. And it is a mother at the foot of the scaffold, not a philosopher, who sets out the clearest biblical text on creation out of nothing, taken up at the Fourth Council of Lateran[55].

The theology of the Maccabees also comes down to a maxim of war: « victory does not depend on the size of the army: strength comes from Heaven » (1 M 3:19). The small faithful number against the unfaithful multitude — this is already the whole logic of Gideon and his three hundred men, and it will be that of the Cross: God saves through the small, the weak and the despised[56].

The Christian Fulfillment

Christ at the Feast of the Dedication

Original Ignispedia infographic created with AI

The most direct link between the Maccabees and Christ lies in a single verse from Saint John: "Then came the Feast of the Dedication at Jerusalem. It was winter. Jesus was walking in the Temple, in Solomon's Colonnade" (Jn 10:22-23)[57]. Jesus is present at the Temple for the feast born of Judas's victory, and it is in this setting that he proclaims: "I and the Father are ONE" (Jn 10:30). The one whose house the Maccabees had purified reveals there that he is the Son: the Dedication finds its fulfillment in him, for the true Temple, from now on, is his body (cf. Jn 2:21)[58].

The Martyrs, Forerunners of the Christian Martyrs

The Fathers see in Eleazar, the seven brothers, and their mother the forerunners of the Christian martyrs: before the Roman arenas, they showed that it is better to die than to deny God, in the hope of the resurrection[59]. The Epistle to the Hebrews ranks them among the witnesses of faith, and the Church honors them as saints, among the rare figures of the Old Testament to receive a feast in the Martyrology (see below). The blood of the Maccabees is thus the first seed from which the harvest of the Church's martyrs will spring, according to the saying of Tertullian: the blood of the martyrs is seed of Christians[60].

Judas among the Nine Worthies

The figure of Judas so struck the Christian West that in the Middle Ages he was ranked among the Nine Worthies, those nine models of chivalry: three pagans (Hector, Alexander, Caesar), three Jews (Joshua, David, Judas Maccabeus), and three Christians (Arthur, Charlemagne, Godfrey of Bouillon)[61]. The theme, introduced by Jacques de Longuyon in Les Vœux du paon (1312), adorned for centuries town halls, tapestries, and manuscripts. Later, the figure inspired theatre and music: the Judas Macabeo of Calderón (1641), then the great oratorio by Handel, Judas Maccabaeus (1747), whose chorus celebrates the hero's victory[62]. No other judge or king of Israel has known such fortune in the Christian imagination.

Liturgical Use

The Feast of the Holy Maccabees on 1 August

The "Holy Maccabees" (Eleazar, the seven brothers, and their mother) are inscribed in the Roman Martyrology on 1 August, among the rare saints of the Old Testament to receive a proper feast there, preserved in the traditional calendar (in the current general calendar, 1 August is the memorial of Saint Alphonsus Liguori)[63]. Their cult, attested at Antioch from antiquity (a dedicated church, relics venerated in the time of Chrysostom), testifies to the importance attached to their witness from very early on: Jews who died before Christ are honored as Christian saints, because their martyrdom foreshadowed that of the witnesses of the Gospel.

Readings and Prayer for the Dead

The Roman liturgy also draws from the books of the Maccabees its texts on prayer for the dead. Judas's gesture in sending his offering to the Temple "so that the dead might be delivered from their sins" (2 M 12:46, in the wording of the Crampon Bible, which has remained famous: "It is therefore a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead") grounds the practice of Masses for the dead, the commemoration of 2 November, and indulgences for souls[64]. Whenever the Church prays for those who have left us, she prolongs the "holy and wholesome thought" of Judas Maccabeus: charity stronger than death.

The Historical-Critical Debate and Its Limits

What Part of Contemporary Exegesis Proposes

Part of contemporary exegesis approaches the books of the Maccabees with the tools of historical criticism and proposes several theses: the first book would be the work of an anonymous author writing under John Hyrcanus or shortly after, with an apologetic aim in favor of the dynasty; the second book would belong to the Hellenistic genre of "pathetic history", which resorts to dramatic scenes, recomposed speeches, and amplified figures to move the reader, which would call for caution regarding the accuracy of certain episodes, notably the martyrdom of chapter 7; the two letters placed at the head of the second book have been contested as borrowed pieces, even forgeries; the figures of armies and dead would be exaggerated according to ancient habits[65]. Some add that the absence of the Maccabees from the Hebrew Bible would prove their low authority in the Judaism of the time.

The Fragilities of These Reconstructions

These hypotheses deserve examination, but they carry their own fragilities. First, they often rest on the argument from silence: because a fact is attested by only one source, it is held to be doubtful, whereas for a period documented only in fragments, the single source is the norm, not the exception. Next, the criticism of "recomposed speeches" applies to biblical texts a suspicion it does not apply with the same severity to Greek historians: Thucydides himself admitted recomposing speeches (I, 22), without anyone denying the Peloponnesian War on that account[66]. The amplified figures belong to the conventions of ancient narrative, shared by sacred and profane authors alike, and prove neither the invention of the battles nor that of the martyrs[67].

Above all, presuppositions count as much as evidence. When the supernatural (heavenly apparitions, divine interventions) is set aside in principle as non-historical, it is no longer the examination of the sources that concludes, but a philosophy that has concluded in advance: the miracle being impossible, any account containing one is suspect. This is the anti-miracle presupposition, which is not a result of research but its unacknowledged starting point. Likewise, the idea that the martyrdom of chapter 7 would be a late edification assumes what it ought to prove: that faith in the resurrection could not have existed so early, whereas that is precisely what the text attests.

Why the Traditional Reading Remains Defensible

Faced with these reconstructions, the traditional reading rests on stubborn facts. Even the most demanding criticism holds the first book to be a first-rate source: the exegete Cornill, cited by the Catholic Encyclopedia, sees in it only one voice, that of an "absolutely trustworthy account of one of the most important periods in the history of the Jewish people"[68]. The eighteenth-century attempts to discredit the book (the Wernsdorf brothers) failed. The book cites verifiable documents, knows the geography in detail, dates according to the Seleucid era with a precision that presupposes proximity to the events, and Josephus, who had other sources, corroborates rather than contradicts it[69].

For the second book, the classical defense retains its force: the author is not responsible for the pieces he cites (letters, decrees); the apparent divergences with the first book are explicable (a distinct campaign of Lysias, a not strictly chronological order, two complementary accounts of the death of Antiochus); the book betrays an exact knowledge of a multitude of small details, often confirmed by Josephus, who did not know it; and even its detractors admit the value of its first part[70]. Above all, scholarly historiography varies with its time: in the nineteenth century a Pharisaic manifesto was read in it, in the twentieth the model of a sovereign Jewish state, after the Shoah a religious resistance. This observation, established by Daniel R. Schwartz, one of the most authoritative commentators on the dossier, illustrates the limits of any reconstruction: the "consensus" is never a neutral and final verdict, but a dated reading, caught up in the presuppositions of its time[71]. It in no way undermines the continuous reception, Jewish then Christian, patristic then liturgical, which from antiquity honored these men and these martyrs as real and venerable.

For further reading

Notes and References

  1. The surname Maccabee (Greek Makkabaios) is generally linked to the Aramaic/Hebrew maqqaba(t), "hammer." Other hypotheses see it as an acronym of the war cry taken from Exodus 15:11 (Mi kamokha ba-elim YHWH, "Who is like you among the gods, O Lord?"). Cf. Jonathan A. Goldstein, I Maccabees, Anchor Bible, Doubleday, 1976.

    1
  2. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XII, 265: Mattathias, son of John, son of Simeon, son of Asamonaios, priest of the division of Joarib, citizen of Jerusalem (text cross-referenced via the online edition, Sefaria). The division of Abijah (Joarib) is one of the twenty-four priestly divisions (1 Chr 24:7). Cf. Jewish Encyclopedia (1901), article "Hasmoneans."

    2
  3. 1 Maccabees 2:2-5, liturgical translation (AELF): John surnamed Gaddis, Simon called Thassi, Judas called Maccabeus, Eleazar surnamed Avaran, Jonathan surnamed Apphus.

    3
  4. 1 Maccabees covers roughly 175-134 BC; 2 Maccabees roughly 180-161. The two works are independent, by different authors. Cf. F. Bechtel, "Books of Machabees," Catholic Encyclopedia (1913).

    4
  5. The deuterocanonical books of the Old Testament are: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, 1-2 Maccabees, and sections of Esther and Daniel. The term was coined by Sixtus of Siena, Bibliotheca Sancta, 1566. Fully inspired and canonical for the Catholic Church; "Apocryphal" for Protestants.

    5
  6. On the Hellenization of Jerusalem, Jason, Menelaus, and the gymnasium at the foot of the citadel, see 2 M 4 and Emil Schürer, The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ, ed. Vermes-Millar-Black, T&T Clark, 1973-1987, vol. I.

    6
  7. The "abomination of desolation" refers to the pagan altar erected on the Temple altar in December 167 BC (1 M 1:54). The expression comes from Daniel (Dn 9:27; 11:31; 12:11) and will be taken up by Christ (Mt 24:15).

    7
  8. 1 Maccabees 2:19-21, liturgical translation (AELF). Manifesto of the revolt: Mattathias sets Israel's fidelity to the Covenant of the fathers against the servile obedience of the nations.

    8
  9. 1 Maccabees 2:23-28: Mattathias kills the apostate and the royal officer, overturns the altar, then calls the zealous for the Law to follow him into the mountains. Modin (Modein), the family's homeland, lay in western Judaea, on the foothills overlooking the coastal plain.

    9
  10. 1 Maccabees 2:49-70: as he is dying, Mattathias reviews the heroes of faith (Abraham, Joseph, Phinehas, Joshua, Caleb, David, Daniel and his companions) and entrusts Judas with the conduct of the war and Simon with the role of counsellor.

    10
  11. 1 Maccabees 3-7, liturgical translation (AELF): Judas's victories over Apollonius, Seron, Gorgias at Emmaus and Lysias at Beth-zur, the purification of the Temple (ch. 4), expeditions into Gilead and Galilee (ch. 5), the death of Antiochus IV (ch. 6), the victory over Nicanor at Adasa (ch. 7).

    11
  12. 1 Maccabees 3:18-19, liturgical translation (AELF). Before the battle against Seron. Central theme: victory comes from God and not from the strength of arms (cf. 1 Sam 14:6; Jdg 7, Gideon's small number).

    12
  13. 1 Maccabees 6:1-17: Antiochus IV dies in 164 in Persia while attempting to plunder the sanctuary of Elymais. The biblical account is corroborated by Polybius (Histories, XXXI) regarding the king's end.

    13
  14. 1 Maccabees 4:59, liturgical translation (AELF). Institution of the feast of Dedication, celebrated for eight days beginning on 25 Kislev (cf. 1 M 4:52-54). Purification of the Temple in 164 BC, three years after the desecration of 167.

    14
  15. John 10:22-23, liturgical translation (AELF): "Then came the feast of the Dedication of the Temple in Jerusalem. It was winter. Jesus was walking about in the Temple, under the portico of Solomon." The only explicit mention of the Maccabean feast in the New Testament.

    15 47 57
  16. 1 Maccabees 9:5-21: at Elasa (160), Judas faces Bacchides with eight hundred men, refuses to flee, and falls. His brother Jonathan takes over the leadership of the movement (1 M 9:23-31).

    16
  17. 1 Maccabees 9:35-42: John, the eldest son of Mattathias, is captured and then killed by the sons of Jambri near Madaba; Jonathan avenges him at the wedding of one of their chiefs.

    17
  18. 1 Maccabees 10:15-21: Alexander Balas, a Seleucid claimant, appoints Jonathan high priest in 152, with the purple robe and the golden crown. The family's first entry into the supreme pontificate.

    18
  19. 1 Maccabees 12:39-13:30: the general Tryphon lures Jonathan to Ptolemais with a small escort, takes him prisoner and then has him murdered (142). Simon has his bones brought back to Modin and raises a family mausoleum for him (1 M 13:25-30).

    19
  20. 1 Maccabees 13:34-42: Demetrius II exempts Judea from tribute and recognizes Simon as high priest and ally; official documents are now dated by the years of Simon, a mark of recovered independence.

    20
  21. 1 Maccabees 13:49-52: in 141, Simon drives the Seleucid garrison out of the Acra, the citadel that had dominated Jerusalem for twenty-six years, and brings the people in with palm branches, harps, and hymns.

    21
  22. 1 Maccabees 14:27-49: a great assembly proclaims Simon high priest, leader (ethnarch) and hereditary strategist; the decree is engraved on bronze tablets displayed in the Temple. Judaea mints coinage and dates its documents from the era of Simon.

    22
  23. 1 Maccabees 16:11-17: Ptolemy, son of Abubus, Simon's son-in-law, murders Simon and two of his sons during a banquet at the fortress of Dok (134). John Hyrcanus, warned in time, escapes the plot and succeeds him.

    23
  24. The bronze prutahs bearing the name of "Yehohanan the high priest and the council of the Jews" are attributed to John Hyrcanus I and are the oldest autonomous Jewish coins. Cf. Y. Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins, Amphora, 2001.

    24
  25. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XIII, 301: Aristobulus I is the first Hasmonean to wear the diadem, the first Jew in nearly five centuries to wear the crown. The geographer Strabo, followed by some numismatists (the coins of Aristobulus bear only the title of high priest), attributes the first royal title to Alexander Jannaeus: the point remains debated, which takes nothing away from the dynasty's de facto kingship.

    25
  26. On the reigns of Alexander Jannaeus (103-76) and Salome Alexandra (76-67), and then the fratricidal war of their sons, see Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, books XIII-XIV, and Lee I. Levine, "The Age of Hellenism", Center for Online Judaic Studies.

    26
  27. Fratricidal war between Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II (67-63); both brothers appeal to Pompey, who besieges Jerusalem, takes the Temple after three months, and leads Aristobulus away captive to Rome. Cf. Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, XIV, 48-76; Jewish War, I, 131-158.

    27
  28. Herod the Great (37-4 BC), of Idumaean origin, marries the Hasmonean princess Mariamne, granddaughter of Hyrcanus II, then has the last Hasmoneans executed. The last Hasmonean prince, Antigonus II, is put to death in 37.

    28
  29. Israel Antiquities Authority, announcement of 11 October 2026: a section of about 300 metres of the lower aqueduct uncovered south of Kibbutz Ramat Rachel during a salvage excavation carried out ahead of the construction of a new neighbourhood, the excavation directed by Benyamin Storchan and Gil Freid; the structure, some 21 kilometres long from Solomon's Pools to the Temple Mount, is attributed by the excavators to the Hasmonean kings and is said to have remained in intermittent use until about a century ago; results presented at the 19th colloquium on the archaeology of Jerusalem and its surroundings (14-16 October 2026). Cf. The Jewish Edition, 11 October 2026; Hayadan, report on the same announcement.

    29
  30. 2 Maccabees 6:24-28, liturgical translation (AELF), abridged passage. The old scribe Eleazar, ninety years old (2 M 6:24), refuses even to pretend to eat forbidden meat, out of concern not to scandalise the young.

    30
  31. The Fathers see in the Maccabean martyrs (Eleazar, the seven brothers, their mother) the forerunners of the Christian martyrs. Saint Gregory of Nazianzus (Oration 15) and Saint John Chrysostom (two homilies) composed panegyrics in their honour. They are among the few figures of the Old Testament honoured with a feast in the Roman Martyrology (1 August, traditional calendar).

    31 59
  32. 1 Maccabees 6:43-46: at Beth-Zachariah, Eleazar Avaran slips beneath the royal elephant, pierces it and is crushed to death. The book salutes him who gave his life “to save his people and win for himself an immortal name” (1 M 6:44).

    32
  33. 2 Maccabees 7:9, liturgical translation (AELF), text verified. Spoken by the second of the seven brothers. One of the clearest statements in the Old Testament of the bodily resurrection to eternal life (cf. Dn 12:2). Quoted in the CCC § 992.

    33
  34. 2 Maccabees 7:28, liturgical translation (AELF), text verified. Spoken by the mother to her youngest son: the clearest biblical text on creation from nothing, the scriptural foundation taken up at the Fourth Lateran Council (1215).

    34
  35. Catechism of the Catholic Church, § 992: “God progressively revealed to his People the mystery of the Resurrection. [...] In their trials, the Maccabean martyrs confess: ‘The King of the world will raise us up to live again forever, we who die for his laws’ (2 M 7:9).”

    35
  36. The commonly accepted dating places 1 Maccabees in the reign of John Hyrcanus (134–104), since the book ends with his accession (1 M 16:23–24) and presupposes a date of composition before Pompey’s conquest (63). Cf. Jonathan A. Goldstein, I Maccabees, Anchor Bible, Doubleday, 1976; overview F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913).

    36
  37. The sentence structure of the Greek of 1 Maccabees betrays a Semitic original, and the obscurities of the text are explained by an imperfect translation or a misreading of the Hebrew. Cf. F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913): turns of phrase modelled on the Hebrew, knowledge of Palestinian geography, use of the equivalents “Heaven” and “He” out of reverence for the Name.

    37
  38. Saint Jerome, Prologus Galeatus (preface to the books of Samuel and Kings, Vulgate): “Machabaeorum primum librum Hebraicum repperi” (“I found the first book of the Maccabees in Hebrew”). The original text has since disappeared; only the Greek survives.

    38
  39. Origen (quoted by Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, VI, 25) gives the Semitic title of the first book (Sarbeth Sarbaneel according to the corrected reading), proof that the work circulated under a Hebrew or Aramaic title in the third century.

    39
  40. 2 Maccabees 2:26, liturgical translation (AELF). The author declares that he is abridging the five-volume work of Jason of Cyrene (2 M 2:23), now lost. A rare biblical passage in which a sacred writer explicitly describes his working method.

    40
  41. The first of the two letters appended to the book is dated to the year 188 of the Seleucid era, that is 124 BC. The abridgement can hardly be much later, the request for a summary presupposing that Jason’s work was still close at hand. Cf. F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913); Daniel R. Schwartz, 2 Maccabees, de Gruyter, 2008, who argues for an early date.

    41
  42. Jason of Cyrene, to judge by his precise knowledge of Palestine, had lived in Judaea. His work ended with the death of Nicanor (161) and affirmed that Jerusalem remained in the hands of the Jews (2 M 15:37–38), which presupposes a date of composition before the fall of Judas at Elasa (160). Cf. F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913).

    42
  43. The Septuagint (LXX), the Greek translation of the Bible made at Alexandria from the third century BC, contains the deuterocanonical books absent from the rabbinic Hebrew Bible. The early Church, Greek-speaking, received it as its Old Testament. Cf. Marguerite Harl, Gilles Dorival, Olivier Munnich, La Bible grecque des Septante, Cerf, 1988.

    43
  44. Council of Trent, Session IV, Decree De Canonicis Scripturis (8 April 1546): lists the complete canon, including “the two books of Maccabees, the first and the second.” Denzinger-Schönmetzer 1501-1504. Confirms the canon of the Council of Florence (Cantate Domino, 1442) and of the councils of Hippo (393) and Carthage (397).

    44
  45. Flavius Josephus (c. 37–c. 100 AD) closely follows 1 Maccabees in his Jewish Antiquities (books XII–XIII), while also drawing on sources now lost. The agreement with the Seleucid Greek sources (Polybius) is generally held to be sound. Cf. Bezalel Bar-Kochva, Judas Maccabaeus, Cambridge UP, 1989.

    45 69
  46. On the chancery origin of the official documents inserted in 1–2 Maccabees, see Elias Bickerman, “La charte séleucide de Jérusalem,” Revue des Études Juives, vol. 100, 1935, pp. 4-35, and Der Gott der Makkabäer, 1937 (trans. The God of the Maccabees, Brill, 1979).

    46
  47. Hebrews 11:35, liturgical translation (AELF), text re-checked on aelf.org on 8 October 2026. The verse echoes the martyrs of 2 M 6–7: tortured people who refuse release “so as to rise to a better life.”

    48 50
  48. The link between Heb 11:35 and 2 M 6–7 is acknowledged by commentators of every stripe, from the Cambridge Greek Testament (the verb “were tortured” would refer especially to 2 M) to contemporary study notes. The Greek of the epistle (“a better resurrection”) answers the Greek of the second book.

    49
  49. Saint Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 15, On the Maccabees, delivered for their feast in 379 or 381: the Jewish martyrs before Christ deserve the same veneration as the Christian martyrs. Cf. Raphaëlle Ziadé, Les martyrs Maccabées, Brill, 2006.

    51
  50. Saint John Chrysostom, two homilies On the Maccabees (CPG 4354), preached at Antioch around 386 before the relics of the martyrs, in a city that has a church dedicated to them. Both sermons address doubts about the legitimacy of the Christian cult of these Jewish martyrs.

    52
  51. Saint Augustine, The City of God, book XVIII, ch. 36 (Latin cross-checked against the augustinus.it edition): “Macchabaeorum libri, quos non Iudaei, sed Ecclesia pro canonicis habet propter quorumdam martyrum passiones vehementes atque mirabiles” (“the books of the Maccabees, which the Jews do not have, but which the Church counts as canonical because of the intense and wonderful sufferings of certain martyrs”). Augustine defends their canonicity, grounded in the reception of the Church.

    53
  52. The Catechism places the witness of the Maccabean martyrs among the stages of the “progressive revelation of the Resurrection” (CCC §§ 992-993), soon shared by the Pharisees (Acts 23:6) and brought to fulfilment by Christ: “I am the resurrection and the life” (Jn 11:25).

    54
  53. Fourth Lateran Council (1215), constitution Firmiter credimus: God “by his almighty power created from nothing both alike, together from the beginning of time.” Denzinger-Schönmetzer 800. The formula is rooted in 2 M 7:28. Cf. also CCC § 297.

    55
  54. The theme of the victorious few runs through Scripture: Gideon and his three hundred men (Jdg 7), Jonathan son of Saul (1 Sam 14:6), and Judas Maccabeus (1 M 3:18–19). Saint Paul takes it up: “what is weak in the world, that is what God chose” (1 Cor 1:27).

    56
  55. It is at the feast of the Dedication that Jesus proclaims his unity with the Father (Jn 10:30) and that the Jews attempt to stone him (Jn 10:31–39). The true Temple, from now on, is his body (Jn 2:19–21).

    58
  56. Tertullian, Apologeticum, 50: “semen est sanguis christianorum” (“the blood of Christians is a seed”). The Maccabean martyrs are its first Old Testament illustration.

    60
  57. Judas Maccabeus is counted among the Nine Worthies: three pagans (Hector, Alexander, Caesar), three Jews (Joshua, David, Judas Maccabeus), three Christians (Arthur, Charlemagne, Godfrey of Bouillon). A theme introduced by Jacques de Longuyon, Les Vœux du paon (1312), immensely widespread in medieval art.

    61
  58. George Frideric Handel, Judas Maccabaeus, an oratorio to a libretto by Thomas Morell (1747), composed after the Battle of Culloden: the Jewish hero becomes the figure of the national liberator. Preceded by the Judas Macabeo of Calderón de la Barca (1641).

    62
  59. The "Maccabee saints" are listed in the Roman Martyrology on August 1, among the few Old Testament saints to receive their own feast there, preserved in the traditional calendar (in the current general calendar, August 1 is the memorial of Saint Alphonsus Liguori). Their cult, attested in Antioch from antiquity, bears witness to the importance attached to their witness from very early on.

    63
  60. 2 Maccabees 12:44-46, liturgical translation (AELF). The well-known Crampon variant (1923), still famous in the liturgy, reads: "It is therefore a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead, that they may be loosed from their sins." Scriptural foundation of purgatory and prayer for the departed (CCC § 1032: Florence, DS 1304; Trent, DS 1820).

    64
  61. "Pathetic history" is a genre of Hellenistic historiography that favors dramatic effect (vivid scenes, reconstructed speeches, inflated figures). Cf. F. W. Walbank, "History and Tragedy", Historia 9 (1960), pp. 216-234, a seminal study applied to Hellenistic historians.

    65
  62. Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, I, 22: the historian admits to reconstructing speeches "as it seemed to me that each would have been most likely to speak appropriately to the situation at hand", without anyone thereby denying the reality of the war he recounts.

    66
  63. Ancient authors, both sacred and profane, commonly give estimated or popular figures rather than exact numbers, especially for enemy forces and casualties. One cannot demand of an account of a popular uprising the precision of a modern general staff.

    67
  64. Carl Heinrich Cornill, Einleitung in das Alte Testament, cited by F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913): on the historical value of 1 M, "there is but one voice: we possess a source of the very first order, a narrative absolutely worthy of faith".

    68
  65. Classic answers to objections against 2 M, summarized from F. Bechtel, Catholic Encyclopedia (1913): Lysias's campaign distinct from that of 1 M 4; the first book's ordering is not strictly chronological; two complementary accounts of the death of Antiochus; accurate knowledge of a multitude of small details confirmed by Josephus, who did not know the second book.

    70
  66. Daniel R. Schwartz, "Modern Scholarship on 1-2 Maccabees in Its Historical Context: Three Episodes", The Bible and Interpretation, August 2024: Geiger (Pharisaic manifesto), Israeli historians (sovereign-state model), post-Shoah religious rereading (Hengel). Scholarly readings vary according to each generation's concerns.

    71

Can’t find your topic?